Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Punjab panel on violence unlikely

Punjab panel on violence unlikely

JS · 26 Aug 2005

Punjab panel on violence unlikely Prabhjot Singh Tribune News Service Chandigarh, August 25 Now when the main Opposition party, the Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD), has agreed to a debate in the Vidhan Sabha on the turbulence witnessed by the state in the 80s and 90s, the move of the Punjab government on setting up a commission on the issue may not take off. While the state government wanted to appoint a retired judge of the Punjab and Haryana High Court to head the commission, the Opposition, including the SAD and the BJP, insisted on a sitting judge of the Supreme Court to head it. The Congress high command, sources reveal, was not impressed much by the idea of a commission under the Commission of Inquiry Act as it was felt that it would not only revive sad memories of the turmoil the state had undergone but could also vitiate the peaceful atmosphere. A debate on the floor of the state legislature was enough. The SAD, which had been initially insisting that the Nanavati Commission report should also be made a part of the agenda of the Vidhan Sabha debate, appears to have accepted the challenge of the Chief Minister to a debate on any aspect of the secessionist violence that claimed more than 20,000 lives in the state. A number of senior Congress leaders also felt that entrusting a probe to a commission was like reopening wounds which time had healed. Further, they felt that there was no provocation to go back to the tragic chapter in the history of the state in which many might not come out clean. They felt that after the apology by the Prime Minister in Parliament and his promise to take action against those “found guilty” by the Nanavati Commission had sent a positive signal to the Sikh community worldwide. Further, the UPA government also wants the speedy rehabilitation of and compensation for the 1984 riot victims. Any further debate on the commission report on which time-bound action had been ordered would serve no useful purpose other than reviving painful memories. The decision of the Akalis to participate in a debate on the floor of the Punjab Vidhan Sabha may have provided a reprieve to the ruling Congress as it was not easy for it either to find a suitable or acceptable judge, serving or retired, to head the commission on a sensitive issue like the secessionist or militant violence in the state. Sources in the Punjab government reveal that the initial enthusiasm of handing over the probe to a commission is now waning and instead the focus is on the next Vidhan Sabha session for which both the ruling party and the SAD may have to do a lot of research and homework to avoid blame for the trauma that the state underwent.

Re: Punjab panel on violence unlikely

singh · 27 Aug 2005

There should be an international investigation into the viloence against Sikhs in the last 50 years. An Indian judge will produce a meaningless report like the one on the 84 massacres.

Re: Punjab panel on violence unlikely

KS · 28 Aug 2005

Parliament should pass resolution on ’84 riots, says Tarlochan Tribune News Service Patiala, August 27 Mr Tarlochan Singh, Chairman, National Commission for Minorities, while urging Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to make arrangements to bring out the truth behind the massacre of Sikhs in 1984 and to make those, who engineered the same, to seek apology from the Sikh community demanded that both Houses of Parliament should pass a joint resolution for condemning the riots. Mr Tarlochan Singh, who was here today said that though a number of commissions had been set up by successive Central governments to probe the 1984 anti-Sikh riots, these had failed to bring any relief to the kin of the victims of the community. When asked how the guilty could seek forgiveness from the Sikh community, he said the Prime Minister should call a meeting of representatives of the SGPC, Sikh political parties, jathedars of all Takhts and other dignitaries and in that meeting, all guilty should seek apology. This would bring relief to the victims and the community and would also settle forever the issue connected with the massacre of Sikhs in 1984. The Chairman said he was surprised why successive governments at the Centre had failed to pass a joint resolution in Parliament to codemn the massacre of Sikhs in 1984 when resolutions could be passed in connection with the Bhopal gas tragedy, assassination of Indira Gandhi, terrorist attack on the World Trade Centre (WTC) and bomb blasts in London. To a question regarding the proposal of the Haryana Government for setting up a separate gurdwara parbhandhak committee for the Sikh living in that state, Mr Tarlochan Singh said no government should interfere in the religious affairs of any community.

Re: Punjab panel on violence unlikely

DS · 29 Aug 2005

I was tortured in jail, Mann writes to Lahoti K S Chawla Ludhiana, August 29 Simranjit Singh Mann, president, Akali Dal (Amritsar) has complained to the Chief Justice of India that he was tortured mentally and physically. In a letter to the Chief Justice of India, Mr RC Lahoti, written from the Central Jail, Ludhiana, on August 26, Mr Mann stated: “Doctors from the Civil Hospital have examined me and recommended to the government that my cell in prison have an air-conditioner and a proper air-conditioned vehicle should be provided to me when I am taken to courts to attend the hearing of my cases. The Punjab Government has ignored this advice and the Chief Minister has stated that he has sent me to prison and watch my behaviour. Has the state a moral police here as prevails in Islamic countries. Secondly, the Chief Minister has stated that on getting bail, if I misbehave he will send me back to jail and forget where he has thrown the keys of the jail lock. Is this the sort of constitutional and legal society, we live in”. In a seven-page hand-written letter, Mr Mann had touched upon other issues, including the case against BSP supremo Mayawati in connection with the Taj corridor, review petition by Mr KPS Gill, former Punjab DGP, death sentence of Devinder Singh Bhullar, corruption cases against Mr Parkash Singh Badal and Mrs Rajinder Kaur Bhattal and the case against SGPC chief Bibi Jagir Kaur in connection with the mysterious death of her daughter.

Re: Punjab panel on violence unlikely

JS · 01 Sep 2005

Unhealed wounds of 1984 JS Rajput Every evening I would walk back home from my office by the side of the huge playfield of the institution in Bhopal where I was working. Young children of the families staying on the campus would be playing there in good numbers. Often, some of them would come to me, wish me and indicate their requirements, which were mostly to do with sporting equipment. It was so refreshing to see them playing together. I enjoyed being of some help in their activities and particularly the fact that they confided in me without any hesitation. One evening in the second week of November 1984 I asked my 12-year-old son why his friend Gurmeet was not to be seen for the past couple of days. "He does not play with us any more," was his hasty response. It was clear to me that he was unwilling to talk about it. I probed further and my son said, "We call him ugravadi. He gets teased easily. A couple of days back, he cried on the playfield and that day onwards, has stopped coming.He stays home!" Within minutes, I spoke to the headmaster of the higher secondary school which was a part of the institution with nearly 800 students on its rolls, including a dozen from Sikh families. I had been informed earlier that everything was smooth and there was no unfortunate impact of the ant-Sikh progrom either on the school or the college. The headmaster and the teachers were alert and were, on their own, managing well. That evening, however, I was informed that the teasing of Sikh children had grown gradually and was becoming a real concern. We discussed various implications and alternatives. Special arrangements were made to ensure guidance and counselling in the school and also on the playfield. Next evening, Gurmeet's friends visited his home, apologised sincerely, and brought him back to the playfield. My son's response made me think beyond the routine impact of tragic incidents like the one that shook the country on October 31, 1984, and all that followed subsequently. Clearly, I had failed initially in assessing the larger impact of the carnage that the country witnessed immediately after the shocking assassination of Indira Gandhi. As the head of a regional institution, which had university level students from several States of the country, I thought I was fully alert and conscious of the implications. These were discussed in adequate detail with my colleagues. Together, we had evolved a strategy to ensure that the tragic incident would not allowed to be exploited by any one in any manner. I had personally talked to them the Sikh students. They were unperturbed as regards their own safety and security as they had "full faith in their friends". In fact, their friends had assured me that they would ensure no external elements were allowed to create any disturbance on the campus. I was deeply impressed by their keenness to join the efforts to restore peace and mutual confidence. But that evening, talking to my son, I realised the multi-dimensionality of the 1984 carnage. Several dimensions are often ignored in the aftermath of organised killings. The multi-dimensionality engulfs generations and the impact is lasting. Suffering grows instead of declining with time though it gradually gets erased from the public memory. Therein also lies the bitter fact that those who do not learn from history are bound to suffer again. Governments, irrespective of ideologies and political affiliations, do develop continuity of approach once they are in power. Routinisation takes over and promises made earlier are lost in power games. It must be accepted that the national response to the massacre of innocent Sikhs never reached the level that could have assuaged the sufferings of the victims, to whatever little extent it was humanly possible in such a situation. Justice Nanavati's report is not the end. It just can't be. Twenty-one years later, on August 10, 2005, as I watched the debate in Parliament on the Nanavati Commission's report - the ninth as such report - and saw the images of demonstrations near Jantar Mantar, by people whom media describes as "Sikh victims of the 1984 riots". I had read in the morning papers the statement of a young man who as a child was made to believe that his father was working in Dubai. Most of the men in the locality where he lived as a child in 1984 were murdered for no fault of theirs. Every one in Parliament was showering high praise on the Sikh community. There was praise, praise and more praise. Yet, for 21 years, the powers-that-be could not trace the culprits and the guilty. Accountability, transparency and responsibility mean nothing to our politicians. There continues to anger and anguish over 1984 all around. There are those who are vocal and there are those who prefer to remain quiet. If one Minister leaves the Cabinet, does it make a difference to all those who were in schools and colleges in 1984 and had suffered humiliation and alienation without ever understanding as to what was their crime? Who is supposed to look after these social and emotional aspects of the crime? Can a couple of speeches, assurances and preparations for a 10th report make any difference? The glaring record of failures in imparting justice was highlighted in media. In a couple of days, it was relegated to the background. A nation that neglects its brave and industrious scores only self-goals and invites ridicule and demoralisation. Listening to the speeches in Parliament and going by the reports in media, I just can't resist recalling how unfair the system of education has been to the Sikh community. For decades together, in independent India we were teaching future generations of Indians that according to Sikh tradition, family intrigues led to the execution of Guru Tegh Bahadur! Not only this, sample another gem of history in the context of the Guru: His execution was ordered by the Mughal administration! Every effort was made to wipe out the historical facts of the beheading of the great Guru under specific orders of Aurangzeb who had offered him an alternative - convert or face execution. I have no quarrels if Aurangzeb is described as a "zinda peer" but my sensitivities do get hurt when I notice repeated effort to cut-off future generations of Indians from their roots; and that, too, through sustained distortion of history and historical facts. Efforts to remove these distortions were viewed politically and those who had, for a short while, lost control of academia, resisted these with full-throated protests and the support of the lib-Left media. They are now back in the saddle and are projecting themselves as great messiahs of the Sikh community! The under currents of alienation and distrust must not only be curbed but not allowed to grow in any form, any where. Those who have the power and authority must ponder as to why suddenly the distorted versions of history have been brought back on flimsy excuses and are being dished out to young Indians throughout the country? The wounds inflicted on the Sikh community must be healed, and healed early. That would require a multi-pronged initiative in imparting speedy justice and undistorted education. For any comments, queries or feedback, kindly mail us at [address removed] or [address removed]