Listening to a tape while doing your Nitnem
..... · 28 Aug 2005
I get more anand doing Nitnem with Sadhsangat but thats not always practical so i like putting a Nitnem tape on while i do my Nitnem. is this acceptable?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
..... · 28 Aug 2005
I get more anand doing Nitnem with Sadhsangat but thats not always practical so i like putting a Nitnem tape on while i do my Nitnem. is this acceptable?amarjeet singh · 29 Aug 2005
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh yes vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifatehKulbir Singh · 29 Aug 2005
Nitnem should be done yourself and it is best if you do so without the aid of recorded nitnem. It is okay to use recorded nitnem for reference but when doing nitnem, your own tongue, lips, mouth and ears should be involved. Listening from nitnem makes us lazy. Kulbir Singhamarjeet singh · 30 Aug 2005
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh if you concentrate more by listening to nitnem then you should listen to it, if you concentrate more by doing it yourself then do it yourself vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifatehsingh · 30 Aug 2005
I feel gurbani more when i listen to it.why is that? I can understand each and every word when i listen to it and repeat in my head when listening to it. Is it wrong ? Also I can carry doing simran while listening to nitnem. Some times when I try doing nitnem I feel like doing simran. so I start doing simran . But when I listen to nitnem I can do simran alongwith and it makes it so enjoyable. So is it wrong to just listen to nitnem?.... · 30 Aug 2005
Kulbir Singh Ji i meant i do my Nitnem out very loud but put the tape on in the background, it makes me feel like im in sangat.Manjot Singh Khalsa · 30 Aug 2005
singh, While I was in punjab, I went to a gurudwara run by jolla wale sant. While I dont know that much about them, one of my thaias follows them. They have a strict maryada that nobody is to sing along with the keertani. While their maryada is different than most, they are very strict in it, just as strict as, if not stricter than, the tapobaners. (they have only amritdhari langar etc) Anyway, my mother started singing along with the keertan and one of the sevadars walked up and told her to be quiet. I talked to my thaia about this later and he said that basically one should listen to bani, you will get more anand. They get this from bani lines that say to talk little as well as sunai paurees in japjee sahib. Sunana te manana, bolna thora. Perhaps theres something to it, thats why you get more anand listening to a tape. Personally, I get more anand when I do patt out loud, meaning when I can also listen to it. Just listening to it though doesnt do much for me. Perhaps it just depends on a persons learning styles. Some people need visual cues, others need audio cues etc.Harjas Kaur · 30 Aug 2005
I agree with Kulbir Singh, its okay to learn from tapes but you have to do Nitnam with your own heart and mind, lips and tongue. It is after all, your prayer and not a mere learning experience. [%sig%]question · 30 Aug 2005
that maryada seems VERRRRRRRRY weird to me guru sahib says har keertan SUNAI har keertan GAAVAI this jan dookh nikatt nahee aavai or what about SAADHSANG KAL KEERTAN GAAEAA in the kaljug those who sing keertan in saadhsangat nanak thaethae bohur na aaeaa they do not have to come back into reincarnationsGurpreet Singh · 30 Aug 2005
gaveeai, sunia, man rakheeai, bhaou now some people may say im interpreting this tuk wrong because of grammar rules in gurbani.......but i disagree, and i believe one of the many interpretations of this is that one should sing bani/simran (do it loud), and than also listen to it with the ears, and than keep this bani/naam in the mind. Bhao literally means love, but what shows love to guru sahib more than bani/simran?amarjeet singh · 31 Aug 2005
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh i dont see why one should have to say his/her nitnem out loud. this may well be involiving the effort of the voice the lips and the toungue, but the main effort is that of controlling the mind to stay focused on the bani. sometimes i have found that i have concentrated more whilst listening to nitnem and other time more whilst reciting it myself. so idont think it matters whether you recite it yourself or listen to as long as you aare concentrating as much possible vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifatehsingh · 31 Aug 2005
these johllan a vale sant wear black kacherey and they also have separate mattress for sant ji to sit on it when sant ji leaves the divan they do a shatar on sant ji (canopy for all ABCDs BBCDs and CBCDs) just my 2 bits