Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Granthi Qualifications

Granthi Qualifications

Hari Singh · 31 Aug 2005

I was thinking... Many preists, pastors etc. have a masters degree in theology and hold a position of respect within the community. Muslim clergy are very well versed in the fundamentals of their religion and are very well versed in the Quran and hadiths. Granthi Singhs at local gurdwara ... not all that educated ... many lack a thorough understanding of gurbani and Bhai Gurdas jee's vaars and within the community the position of a granthi is looked down upon. I think we need to establish standards in terms of appointing Granthi Singhs. So much parchar can be done if you have a rehitvaan gursikh doing this sewa. In Sikhi it is not so importnat to hold degrees and such things to do sewa but it would be useful if the Granthi Singh is well versed in a couple of languages and has strong communication skills. What do you all think? I think Tapoban is quite lucky in having Bhai Jasbir Singh doing this sewa.

Re: Granthi Qualifications

Kulbir Singh · 31 Aug 2005

I agree that Granthis should go through rigorous training on theology before qualifying for this position but along with this, the Gurdwara committees will have to loosen their wallets and start paying more to the Gursikhs who choose to become Granthis. The pay is so pathetic that no intelligent and smart person wants to pursue the career of becoming a Granthi. Granthis have to rely on anti-Gurmat activities to raise money e.g. charging for ardaas etc. Kulbir Singh

Re: Granthi Qualifications

Sakhi · 31 Aug 2005

How would we go about implementing these excellent ideas? We all come up with wonderful ideas but don't ever see them getting implemented.

Re: Granthi Qualifications

charanjeev singh · 31 Aug 2005

The best way to implement ideas is to follolw the principles that seem most ideal to you. If we practice what we preach then there will be results. If we become Panch, then we will be part of Panth. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: Granthi Qualifications

.... · 31 Aug 2005

wouldn't having lareedar saroops of Maharaj help as in the granthi's will need extensive santhiya of Gurbani inorder to recite Gurbani So no average Joe can become a granthi

Re: Granthi Qualifications

Harjas Kaur · 31 Aug 2005

[quote]So no average Joe can become a granthi[/quote] Lol, thats the best idea yet. I have seen Singhs struggling while learning to read the joined text during Akhand Paaths, and it wouldn't fly in any Gurudwara that someone is a granthi when their obviously just a beginner. [%sig%]

Re: Granthi Qualifications

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 31 Aug 2005

ITS LIKE THE CHICKEN AND EGG SITUATION... which comes first.. respect", "good pay"... from the sangat...or "adequate qualifications", Ucha Sucha jeewan" "dedication" etc from the Granthi... IN MALAYSIA....about 25 years ago when a Great Gyani..Bhai Sohan Singh Ji Melaka passed away...the sangats of malaysia Singapore etc were so stirred by hsi passing that an INSTITUTION called the Sant Sohan Singh VIDYALA Melaka was set up. This was to TRAIN LOCAL GRANTHIS. The SGPC was approached to give places to THREE Malaysians places at its Missionary College to be trained as TEACHERS who will come back later to head this Vidyala....The Three ( a husband and wife team and a third young man) went to Amritsar..got waytracked from the Sikh missionary College to a SANT DERA..and came back soon after ...just as they had left a few years earlier...the Vidyala began classes with a few drop-outs as "wanna be granthis"..Needless to say NOT a single GRANTHI was produced...GIGO of computer geeks !! IF the Vidyala management wanted to set a HIGH Entrance such as O Levels/A Levels etc..NIL Applicants..as a Granthi Job is not at all attractive. IF the Entrance" was set very low ( that is attract those who cant get any type of decent job )... then its anyones guess what types of granthis they will make !!! Well in the end it was the second type of applicants...even they failed to make the grade....and today the Vidyala stands empty...just a building used to have akhand paaths !!..and EVERY GURDWARA is staffed by DESI Granthis.. Its anybody's guess again what are the qualifications of these DESIS ?? Most of them are just marking time until they get a chance to escape to USA/canada/Australia etc...and the Number of Gurdawra Visas Forfeited by the Immigration dept runs into the thousands ( Each gurdwara is required to deposit a sum with the Immigration to ensure the granthi will leave the country legally...when they disappear..the Gurdawra loses the deposit to confiscation. It is thus amply clear the desi use this avenue to come out of India...qualifications etc are nobody's concern. The Taat Khalsa and Sentul Schools produced MORE Pathis combined than any other...since these schools have declined in population..NO MORE PATHEES are coming out of any school..so we have a shortage of even akhand pathees. The Sant Attar Singh Vidyala Niketan Foundation is successfully carrying on a Gurbani/Punjabi Classes...MY Fervent Hope of any future LOCAL Pathees/Akhand Pathees lies in these classes....even if not a single granthi is produced at least a few dozen pathees will come out..and KL at least wont have shortage of pathees. Jarnail Singh