Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Save Sikh from Indian Gallows -Prof Davinderpal Singh

Save Sikh from Indian Gallows -Prof Davinderpal Singh

DS · 02 Sep 2005

Prof Devinderpal Singh Bhullar’s fate uncertain Sikh Panth need to take up his case once again Where the judicial process ends, President of any country’s jurisdiction begins. In one’s march to justice, President is the last resort in terms of the provisions of the Constitution of that country, as we also see in India and Pakistan. Generally, presidents are constitutionally empowered to mitigate the errors that sometimes creep into judicial pronouncements due to certain legalistic compulsions and political prejudices. In view of this, we in Prof Devinderpal Singh Bhullar Defence Committee, representing the Sikh Panth, took up the case of Prof Bhullar with President of India in March 2003. The professor is facing gallows and has become victim of the fractured judicial judgement of the Supreme Court of India. The apex court, more than even the lower courts, took a starkly legalistic view on the death sentence given to Prof Devinderpal Singh Bhullar, in Delhi Bomb Blast Case, based on erroneous and fabricated confessional statement under TADA, as now has been alleged by India and others in the case of Sarbjit Singh alias Manjit Singh who is facing gallows in Pakistan almost in similar circumstances. The only difference between them seems to be that Prof Bhullar is Indian citizen while Sarbjit Singh is accused of being RAW agent who worked in enemy country (Pak) under the guise of Manjit Singh. Devinderpal Singh was convicted of conspiracy based solely on a confession extracted under torture and repudiated by him. However, his alleged co-conspirator, Daya Singh Lahoria, was found not guilty. In criminal law, a conspiracy by definition requires at least two people. A conspiracy of one- as is the case here where Devinderpal Singh's co-conspirator was found not guilty- is a legal fiction. Moreover, the confessional statement was signed by a thumbprint. For a man who is highly educated, the sign of a thumbprint implies duress. Furthermore, none of the 133 witnesses produced by the prosecution identified Professor Bhullar, while the case was in lower court. That Amnesty International's opposition to death penalty is unconditional and is based on the facts that every execution violates the fundamental human right to life and the right not to be subjected to torture or any other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment as laid down in Articles 6 and 14 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), the UN Covenant to which India is a party. The Amnesty International, in its report, while recommending the Government of India to consider certain corrective measures, too, had urged the Government to "take immediate steps to abolish the death penalty totally, in furtherance of UN objective of ultimate abolition of capital punishment." Pending total abolition, AI had further asked the Indian Government to "ensure that the outstanding death sentences should be commuted, including that of Prof Devinderpal Singh Bhullar." In addition, on April 28, 1999, the UN Commission on Human Rights (UNHRC) overwhelmingly voted for a resolution that had called for a global moratorium on the death penalty. India is a signatory to both the UDHR and the ICCPR. Besides, the Constitution of India has enshrined the Right to Life as a Fundamental Right (Article 21). And importantly, the Evidence Act does not consider confessions made before the police officer as valid as has been in the case of Prof Bhullar. That we also know that death penalty is used by some States to silence political resistance or to eliminate their opponents. And for this purpose, laws such as TADA are used where fair trial is not at all possible. If justice is secured only by an act of killing, how legitimate is the law that sanctions that sort of justice. We all know that God alone can take away life because He alone gives it. Why then, we arrogate to ourselves to finish it off, even though firmly believing that Ultimate Justice lies with God. And to supplement this spirit, Article 51A of the Indian Constitution urges compassion and humanism as fundamental duties. The Constitutional power under Article 72 of granting amnesty is an executive act and not a judicial one. It is also an act of grace, “when it is full, it releases the punishment and blots out the existence of the guilt, so that in the eye of law, the offender is as innocent as if he had never committed the offence” (Ex parte Garland, (1873) 18 Law Edition 366. The reason why the Executive is given such power, says Mr Taft, CJ, in American case (Ex parte Grossman, 27 US 87: 69 Law Edition 527), “(It) affords relief from undue harshness or evident mistake in the operation or enforcement of the criminal law.” Thus, you sir, being the Head of the State, should kindly correct, in the national interest, the blunder committed by the Judiciary in the enforcement of criminal law,” (such as TADA). We had earnest­ly hoped that President would uphold the dignity, independence and prerogative of his office and give a judicious and compassionate consideration to the representation, which was filed on behalf of the entire Sikh Panth, including Sikhs living abroad and that he would not allow his steps to falter in exercising compassionately and humanely the sacred and super power given to him by the Indian Constitution to grant amnesty to Prof Devinderpal Singh Bhullar. And that too, when the entire Sikh community has been watching the Government of India's tactics of sending persons like Satwant Singh and Kehar Singh to the gallows and giving ministe­rial berths and offices to conspirators and murderers of thousands of Sikhs. Pascal has rightly stated, "Power without justice is soon questioned." Sikhs and other minorities have been and continue to be subjected to repression and injustices of many kinds. Your Excellency's wiser and enlightened timely step of amnesty to Prof Bhullar may not only give them a healing touch but may even persuade the governments to change their policies of re­pression and keeping innocent people indefinitely in prison for a long time or killing mere suspects in faked encounters, we had urged the President in the petition. Justice M. B. Shah had acquitted Professor Bhullar, stating that the conspiracy theory falls flat as the "rest of the accused who are named in the confessional statement are not convicted or tried." In view of these facts, we respectfully appealed to the President, A P J Abdul Kalam, to take a politically and constitutionally correct decision of not only commuting the death sentence but also of freeing Prof Bhullar and earn the warm gratitude of the crores of the Sikhs. But the then Central government led by BJP did not think it proper to recommend the case to the President. The deputy PM, L K Advani was only interested in the unity of Badal- Tohra leaders. After getting united, the Akali leaders also did not put pressure on the government. The RSS and the Indian security agencies too neutralised the impact, created by the Panthic groups here in India, by manoeuvring the leadership of the South Asian Human Rights Group then active at Vancouver end. Interestingly, the Central government, the Congress, the BJP, including Akali Dal Badal, are proactive for saving the life of an alleged Indian RAW agent facing death in Pakistan, while they have totally forgotten the case of Prof Bhullar, the Indian citizen whose whole family has been victim of state repression. So, the Sikh Nation should once again take up the case of Prof Bhullar as his fate hangs in the balance. D S Gill Chair IHRO

Re: Save Sikh from Indian Gallows -Prof Davinderpal Singh

JS · 03 Sep 2005

Please contact your MP and Amnesty international to raise worldwide awarness. The Amnesty International statement in Prof Davinderpal defence in 2003 helped save him then.

Re: Save Sikh from Indian Gallows -Prof Davinderpal Singh

JS · 03 Sep 2005

http://web.amnesty.org/library/Index/ENGASA200112003?open&of=ENG-IND URGENT ACTION India: Further information on Fear for Imminent Execution/Unfair trial - Davinder Pal Singh Bhuller PUBLIC AI Index: ASA 20/011/2003 14 March 2003 Further Information on UA 21/03 (ASA 20/004/2003, 22 JANUARY 2003) IMMINENT EXECUTION/UNFAIR TRIAL INDIA Davinder Pal Singh Bhuller, (m) The Supreme Court of India has rejected a further petition challenging the appeal decision in the case of Davinder Pal Singh Bhuller. Amnesty International is extremely concerned that Davinder Pal Singh Bhuller may face imminent execution. The petition, filed by Davinder Pal Singh Bhuller’s lawyers, was rejected by the Supreme Court on 12th March. It questioned the validity of the decisions made by the Supreme Court in rejecting his appeals against the death penalty in which a senior judge expressed dissent at the Court's conclusions. The only hope of clemency for Davinder Pal Singh Bhuller remains in a mercy petition filed with the Indian President, A J P Abdul Kalam, who has the power to commute the sentence. BACKGROUND INFORMATION Davinder Pal Singh Bhuller was sentenced to death on 29 August 2001 after being found guilty of involvement in the 1993 bombing of the Youth Congress Office in the capital, New Delhi. Twelve people were killed and 29 injured in the blast. Davinder Pal Singh Bhuller sought political asylum in Germany, but was forcibly returned to India, where he was arrested on arrival at New Delhi airport in January 1995. There are serious concerns that he may not have been given a fair trial. Davinder Pal Singh Bhuller appealed against the death sentence in December 2001, but the appeal was rejected by a three-member bench of the Supreme Court. This was not a unanimous decision: the most senior of the three judges found the accused not guilty and directed that he should be released. It is usually custom, whenever there is a split decision, for the death penalty not to be handed down. However, while the Supreme Court was considering Davinder Pal Singh Bhuller 's appeal, armed militants attacked the Lokh Sabha (the lower house of the Indian parliament) on 13th December 2001.Observers believe that heightened rhetoric about the threat of "terrorism" in India following that attack, and a hardening of government policies may have influenced the judges' decision. Amnesty International opposes the death penalty in all cases, regardless of issues of guilt or innocence, or the seriousness of the crime. The death penalty is a symptom of a culture of violence, not a solution to it. It has not been shown to have any special deterrent effect and carries the risk of irrevocable error. It denies the possibility of rehabilitation and reconciliation and extends the suffering endured by the families of murder victims to the families of condemned individuals. AI Index: ASA 20/011/2003 14 March 2003

Re: Save Sikh from Indian Gallows -Prof Davinderpal Singh

LS · 22 Oct 2005

DSGMC seeks clemency for Bitta's attacker Oct. 21, 2005 With President A P J Abdul Kalam's letter to the Home Ministry on mercy petitions of death-row convicts stirring a debate, Delhi's top Sikh religious administration on Thursday sought clemency for a former university teacher facing execution for a 1993 bomb attack on the then Congress chief M S Bitta. Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee (DSGMC) president Paramjit Singh Sarna told a news conference here that Kalam's letter over the matter was "praiseworthy." "Punishing somebody twice -- first by allowing him to languish in jail for 14 long years and then executing him over the same charges -- is not justified," he said. The DSGMC chief requested the government to commute the death sentence of Davinderpal Singh Bhullar, who is convicted of killing nine people and wounding several others, including Bitta, in 1993, into life imprisonment. Sarna, a fierce critic of former Punjab Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal, however, accused the Akali chief of "having used Bhullar's death sentence only for political reasons ahead of state elections." "Badal should rather quit his party post after having failed to project the Shiromani Akali Dal's glorious record in good light during the recent debate in the Punjab Assembly." The DSGMC chief, seen as close to Punjab Chief Minister Amarinder Singh, said he "regretted seeing the Congress winning over the Akalis" in the Assembly debate. Sarna, whose committee has sent six trucks of quake relief to Pakistan, also announced to transport another consignment there shortly.

Re: Save Sikh from Indian Gallows -Prof Davinderpal Singh

JEEVAN SINGH · 22 Oct 2005

THANK YOU VERY MUCH MR D S GILL FOR THIS INFORMATION, I HAVE HEARD ALOT ABOUT YOU AND THE WORK THAT YOU HAVE DONE FOR HUMAN RIGHTS IN PANJAB

Re: Save Sikh from Indian Gallows -Prof Davinderpal Singh

LS · 10 Dec 2005

An Open Letter Read by IHRO chairperson on the eve of World Human Rights Day at a Seminar ‘Death Penalty: A Crime Against Humanity’ organised by PRF at English Dept Auditorium, Punjab University, Chandigarh 09 December 2005 Mr Shivraj Patil Minister of Home Affairs NEW DELHI Re: Granting Amnesty to Prof Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar Who is facing Death Penalty Dear Mr Patil: To begin with, let me make it known that I am writing this letter on behalf of the Punjab Rights Forum (PRF), a league of like minded human rights, socio-economic and religio-political groups, including political parties, representing aspirations of the people of Punjab and Sikh Diaspora; for seeking amnesty to Prof Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar, who is facing Death Penalty and agonising in Tihar Jail. As you are aware, Mr Patil, that where the judicial process ends, President (Head of State)’s jurisdiction begins. In one’s march to justice, President is the last resort in terms of the provisions of the Constitution of that country, as we also see in India and Pakistan. Generally, Heads of States are constitutionally empowered to mitigate the errors that sometimes creep into judicial pronouncements due to certain legalistic compulsions and political prejudices. In view of this, we in ‘Prof Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar Defence Committee,’ representing the Sikh Panth, took up the case of Prof Bhullar with President of India in March 2003. The professor is facing gallows and has become victim of the fractured judicial judgement of the Supreme Court of India. The apex court, more than even the lower courts, took a starkly legalistic view on the death sentence given to Prof Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar, in Delhi Bomb Blast Case, based on erroneous and fabricated confessional statement under TADA. Davinder Pal Singh has been convicted of conspiracy based solely on a confession extracted under torture and repudiated by him. However, his alleged co-conspirator, Daya Singh Lahoria, was found not guilty. In criminal law, a conspiracy by definition requires at least two people. A conspiracy of one- as is the case here where Davinder Pal Singh's co-conspirator was found not guilty- is a legal fiction. Moreover, the confessional statement was signed by a thumbprint. For a man who is highly educated, the sign of a thumbprint implies duress. Furthermore, none of the 133 witnesses produced by the prosecution identified Professor Bhullar, while the case was in lower court. Amnesty International, in its report, while recommending the Government of India to consider certain corrective measures, too, had urged the Government to "take immediate steps to abolish the death penalty totally, in furtherance of UN objective of ultimate abolition of capital punishment." Pending total abolition, AI had further asked the Indian Government to "ensure that the outstanding death sentences should be commuted, including that of Prof Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar." In addition, on April 28, 1999, the UN Commission on Human Rights (UNHRC) overwhelmingly voted for a resolution that had called for a global moratorium on the death penalty. India is a signatory to both the UDHR and the ICCPR. Besides, the Constitution of India has enshrined the Right to Life as a Fundamental Right (Article 21). And importantly, the Evidence Act does not consider confessions made before the police officer as valid as has been in the case of Prof Bhullar. We too appreciate the stand taken by the President and the Chief Justice of India against death penalty, as the policy of ‘tit for tat’ or ‘bullet for bullet’ is counter productive and a total negation of human rights and rule of law. You know the Preamble to the UN Declaration of Human Rights, 1948, too says, ‘Whereas it is essential, if a man is not to be compelled to have recourse, as a last resort, to rebellion against tyranny and oppression, that human rights should be protected by rule of law.’ That we all know that death penalty is used by some States to silence political resistance or to eliminate their opponents. And for this purpose, laws such as TADA are used where fair trial is not at all possible. If justice is secured only by an act of killing, how legitimate is the law (now repealed) that sanctions that sort of justice. We believe that God alone can take away life because He alone gives it. Why then, we arrogate to ourselves to finish it off, even though firmly believing that Ultimate Justice lies with God. And to supplement this spirit, Article 51A of the Indian Constitution urges compassion and humanism as fundamental duties. The Constitutional power under Article 72 of granting amnesty is an executive act and not a judicial one. The reason why the Executive is given such power, says Mr Taft, Chief Justice, in American case (Ex parte Grossman, 27 US 87: 69 Law Edition 527), “(It) affords relief from undue harshness or evident mistake in the operation or enforcement of the criminal law.” Thus, you, sir, being Home Minister of India, should kindly correct, in the national interest, the blunder committed by the Judiciary in the enforcement of criminal law, (such as TADA) and recommend this case to the President of India for amnesty for Prof Bhullar. We had earnest­ly hoped that President would uphold the dignity, independence and prerogative of his office and give a judicious and compassionate consideration to our representation, which was filed on behalf of the entire Sikh Panth, including Sikhs living abroad and that he would not allow his steps to falter in exercising compassionately and humanely the sacred and super power given to him by the Indian Constitution to grant amnesty to Prof Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar. And that too when the entire Sikh community has been watching the Government of India's tactics of sending persons like Satwant Singh and Kehar Singh to the gallows and giving ministe­rial berths and offices to conspirators and murderers of thousands of Sikhs. Do you know, Mr Patil that SSP Sumed Singh Saini and his associates allegedly picked up Prof Bhullar’s father Balwant Singh and his mother’s brother-in-law Manjit Singh and clandestinely liquidated them while three others picked up along with his father were subjected to brutal torture? Out of them, Joginder Singh had become insane, Mohinder Singh’s hips fractured (now cannot properly walk) and Mukhtiar Singh’ legs broken. Indian justice system made mockery of their agony. Thus, justice to them (including thousands of others) remained elusive since then, while their perpetrators such as Sumed Saini and KPS Gill are being magnified day in, day out by the State. That not only the State had awarded Gold Medals to the killers in uniform of Sikh activists and but also reprieved their sentences. Therefore, sir, we must realise that India owes justice to them, including Prof Bhullar. Pascal has rightly stated, "Power without justice is soon questioned." Sikhs and other minorities have been subjected to repression and injustices of many kinds. Your government’s wiser and enlightened timely step of amnesty to Prof Bhullar may not only give them a healing touch but may even persuade the governments to change their policies of re­pression and keeping innocent people indefinitely in prison for a long time or killing mere suspects in faked encounters. Yes, Justice M. B. Shah tried to deliver justice by acquitting Professor Bhullar, stating that the conspiracy theory falls flat as the "rest of the accused who are named in the confessional statement are not convicted or tried," but all in vain, ’cause majority judgement prevailed. Two other judged united against the presiding minority judge, Mr Justice Shah. In view of these facts, we petitioned to the President, APJ Abdul Kalam, to take a politically and constitutionally correct decision of not only commuting the death sentence but also of freeing Prof Bhullar and earn the warm gratitude of the crores of the Sikhs. His Excellency has wisely referred back to the Central Cabinet Prof Bhullar’s case, along with some other cases, for reconsideration, expressing his desire against death penalty in such cases. Now the ball is in your court, sir; hit it to keep up with the Sikhs, a brave and worldwide community with fervour because eighteen million Sikhs in India and abroad and millions of emi­nent persons in other civilised communities and countries firmly believe that Prof Bhullar is a victim of fractured judicial judgement of the Supreme Court of India due to political prejudices. Moreover, the Indian leaders, including Mrs. Indira Gandhi, have time and again raised their voice against death sentence given to similar political offenders in other countries and have done their utmost to save them from the gallows. Many examples can be given from the time of appeal to Fascist leader Franco of Spain not to execute the Basque nationalists and Marxists to the example of Mrs. Indira Gandhi's appeal to save Prime Minister Bhutto of Pakistan from the gallows. In our own country, CPI (ML) guerrilla leader Naghbushan Patnaik who refused to defend him or appeal for mercy was saved from the gallows because his act of murder was a political offence. It is a well-known fact in history that even the Russian Czar saved the eminent novelist Dostoevsky by issuing a reprieve a few minutes before he was to go to the gallows. We hope you will take a similar humane and compassionate view of the issue in question and act on the principles that our government has been preaching to other nations and Countries, including Pakistan as in the recent case of Sarbjit Singh alias Manjit Singh. It is in view of these facts we respectfully appeal to you to take a politically correct decision, have compassionate attitude towards Prof Bhullar and not only to commute his death sentence but also set him free forthwith. Thanking you, Truly yours D S Gill Advocate Punjab Rights Forum

Re: Save Sikh from Indian Gallows -Prof Davinderpal Singh

KS · 18 Dec 2005

WORLDWIDE DAY OF PROTEST 17 JANUARY 2006 SIKHS TO CALL FOR THE ABOLITION OF THE DEATH PENALTY AND THE RELEASE OF ALL POLITICAL PRISONERS IN INDIA A Worldwide Day of Protest is being organised for 17 January 2006. Sikhs in cities around the world from London, to Paris, to Toronto and to New York are aiming on 17 January to show their opposition to the death penalty and call for the release of all Sikh political prisoners held in jails in India. Candles will be lit in prominent places in cities throughout the world, including in India itself. Sikhs in more than 100 cities are expected to take part in the protest and will be joined by prominent non-Sikhs, such as politicians, human rights and trade union activists. In the UK the candle light protests will be taking place simultaneously in around twenty towns and cities and are being organised by the Sikh Federation (UK), Khalsa Human Rights, Sikh Secretariat, Young Sikhs (UK), Sikh student groups, Gurdwaras and the Sadh Sangat. The protests are being supported by Amnesty International and other members of the World Coalition Against the Death Penalty. The protest in London will be taking place outside the Houses of Parliament in Westminster between 5-7pm. MPs, Lords and members of the public will join Sikhs to light candles celebrating life, freedom and opposition to the death penalty. The worldwide protests are taking place on 17 January to coincide with the 11th anniversary of one of the most controversial and highest profile death penalty cases in recent Indian history. 11 years earlier on 17 January 1995 Professor Davinderpal Singh Bhullar, a Sikh political activist, was illegally deported from Germany. Davinderpal Singh was handed over to the Indian authorities on the basis that he had nothing to fear on his return to India. For 11 years Davinderpal Singh has been forced to live with the mistake by the German authorities. He was arrested and put in prison as soon as he landed in Delhi, tortured to obtain a false confession, charged and sentenced to death by hanging for a crime he did not commit. When Germany deported Davinderpal Singh to a death-penalty prone country it violated the European Convention on Human Rights. After his deportation, the court of appeal in Frankfurt allowed his appeal and said that he should not have been deported as he would face torture, harassment and death in India and were he to re-enter Germany he would be given asylum. The verdict of the court of appeal in Germany came too late for Davinderpal Singh. However, it has left Germany and the EU with a moral obligation to ensure the threat of the death penalty by India is removed and Davinderpal Singh and other political prisoners that are unnecessarily being held, either without trial or under false charges and without evidence, are released immediately. Protests in different towns and cities are in the process of being organised. Our aim is to organise candle light vigils in at least 20 towns/cities. We are already aware of vigils being organised in prominent locations in Birmingham, Bradford, Bristol, Coventry, Derby, Gravesend, Huddersfield, Leeds, Leicester, Manchester, Nottingham, Slough, Southampton, Walsall and Wolverhampton. We are also hopeful that Sikhs in the UK will also organise candle light vigils in other locations such as Cardiff, Edinburgh, Glasgow, Liverpool and Newcastle. There is no reason why the candle light vigils should not extend further to other towns and cities, especially where there are Gurdwaras or Sikh students at University. Gurjeet Singh National Press Secretary SIKH FEDERATION (UK) The first and only Sikh political party in the UK Tanglewood House, Pine Walk, Chilworth, SO16 7HQ www.sikhfederation.com [address removed]