Riot victims storm DC’s office
JS · 03 Sep 2005
Riot victims storm DC’s office Tribune News Service Ludhiana, September 3 A high-level team constituted by the Union Government to analyse the quantum of relief provided to the victims of the ’84 riots came face-to-face with the ground realities here today when hordes of victims claimed that the real sufferers had not received much compensation. Unruly scenes were witnessed at the meeting in the mini-secretariat hall when a group of riot victims stormed their way to meet the committee members. Petty politics between their leaders also came to the fore as victims accused them of not doing much for the “real” sufferers. Many women wept when one victim after another victim narrated horrid tales of their torture during the riots and the apathetic attitude of the successive governments. Many of them claimed that while tall promises were made by various political parties in power in the state, nothing concrete had been done. The group informed the committee that they were living amid “hell like conditions” after the riots rendered them homeless. Led by the Chairman of the committee, Mr G.K. Marwaha, Divisional Commissioner, NCT, New Delhi, the three -member committee comprising Mr P.K. Pathak, Director, Ministry of Home Affairs, and Mr I.V. Karan, Director, Ministry of Home, listened to the grievances of victims and assured them that they would report to the Union Government about the problems being faced by them. The team visited the colony of riot victims in Dugri. Many families, who lived in big houses in Delhi before the riots, showed the team how they were putting up in one-room houses. Politics among various outfits of riot victims came to the fore when activists of the Danga Peerat Welfare Society, did not vacate the venue and told the committee members that there was no need to talk to the other party. The activists and members of the Danga Peerat Welfare Council waited to be heard for more than three hours in the open ground in the sweltering heat. They kept raising slogans while staging a demonstration and finally stormed the office of the Deputy Commissioner to force the committee members to listen to them also. The victims came up with the problems of non-allotment of flats, commercial booths and delay and non-issuance of red cards. The welfare associations demanded that the victims should be given a compensation of Rs 5 lakh each to widows and victims of the riots, red cards should be issued and their children should be given free education. Other demands included government job to one member of each family, resumption of 2 per cent reservation quota in medical and engineering colleges and free education to children up to graduation. Both organisations submitted a memorandum to the Union Government, demanding action against those named in the Nanavati Report. Central team visits ’84 riot victims Tribune News Service Patiala, September 3 A high-powered team of the Union Home Ministry yesterday visited 1984 Delhi riot victims settled here and appraised themselves of the difficulties being faced by them. The team was led by Divisional Commissioner, Delhi, Mr G.K. Marwaha, and other members, including the Directors (Home Affairs) Mr P.K. Pathak and Mr U.B. Karan. A senior Punjab government functionary, Mrs Rupan Deol Bajaj, Financial Commissioner, accompanied the team. The team visited Urban Estate (Phase 1 and 2) which has the highest concentration of such families. The members gave a patient hearing to the victims and assured them that all their grievances would be sympathetically looked into by the Home Ministry. Speaking on the occasion at the community hall of Urban Estate (Phase-2), Mrs Rupan Deol Bajaj said all riot victims were issued red cards by the Punjab Government for availing benefits accruing to them. She added that riot victims were entitled to 2 per cent reservation in plots being allotted by PUDA and local Improvements Trusts across the state. Mrs Bajaj added that the state government had also allowed 2 per cent reservation in various professional colleges to children of riot affected. Mr Tejveer Singh, Deputy Commissioner, while releasing figures said that there were 1640 riot-affected families in Patiala and a majority of them lived in phase 1 and 2 of the Urban Estate in LIG flats allotted by the government. The riot victims were represented by Mr Surinder Singh, Mr Harvinder Singh and Mr Avtar Singh. Prominent among others present were Mr Anjali Bhawra, Commissioner (Patiala Division), SSP A.S. Rai, ADC Shiv Dular Singh Dhillon and the ACA, PUDA, Mr Manvesh Sidhu. Nanavati panel report incomplete: SC lawyer Rubinder Gill Tribune News Service Patiala, September 3 Mr Harvinder Singh Phulka of the Sikh Forum does not mince words while talking about riots and their aftermath. “Be it the 1984 riots or the Gujarat riots, these should not be treated as religion-specific. It seems there are two set of laws in the country, one for the majority and the other for the minorities,” Mr Phulka says. He is a Supreme Court lawyer, who has spent 21 years trying to get justice for the 1984 anti-Sikh riot victims. Talking about the Nanavati Commission report and the role of the leadership at that time, he says Rajiv Gandhi may not have been directly involved. “There was a delay in calling the Army. The people suffered while no action was taken. There was passive concurrence by the then Home Minister P.V. Narashima Rao. A few days later in Parliament, the Home Minister said that 600 deaths had taken place. Mr Atal Bihari Vajpayee of the BJP did a survey and put the figure at 3870.” The official figure stands at 2,733. Mr Phulka says he is disillusioned with the Nanavati Commission report, which he terms as “incomplete”. It was supposed to cover the anti-Sikh riots all over the country, but it ended up concentrating only on Delhi. Such commissions are “time-buying tactics of the government”. Other departments and agencies should have acted against the accused and not waited for the commission’s report, he adds. “Various sub-committees were constituted. One of them found 72 policemen guilty. Most of them have retired but one such ‘protecter of law’, Sewa Dass, is a high-ranking official today.” He was then posted in East Delhi, where a majority of killings took place. “The Jain-Aggarwal Committee recommended registration of 316 cases. Out of these 160 were closed summarily or forgotten. Only three convictions took place, and that too were of minor nature.” On remarks by Minorities Commission Chairman Tirlochan Singh, Mr Phulka said, “Ask the people who went through the tragedy. Common people who became victims, who underwent the trauma. If they are satisfied with an apology, then it is fine.” Mr Tirlochan Singh had said the only recourse left now was a resolution in both Houses of Parliament regarding the tragedy. During the passage of years, evidence had either been lost or wiped out, he had added.