Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Is drinking milk bibek?

Is drinking milk bibek?

Singh · 05 Sep 2005

wahegurujikakhalsawahegurujikifateh Everytime bibek of milk is discussed on Tapoban Phorum a proper answer isn't given. Answers like "milk is pure" are given. I would like to ask Kulbir Singh.. What are his full views on drinking milk from cartons bought from super markets? I believe milk should be taken staright out of the cow by a Singh/ni and then should be drank. Milk gets jootha when handled by non-amritdharis. Please Tapoban lot give a good answer not short answers like "milk is pure therefor cannot get jootha." [%sig%]

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

amarjeet singh · 05 Sep 2005

vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh i agree with you 100% singh, milk from supermarket is not bibek and should be taken stright from thew cow by an amritdharee. however this is not always possible (especially in wetsern countries) so as close to the cow as possible should be tried) ie str8 from the farm, were only one person has touched it, make sure this person is a non somker tho) however sometimes even this is not possible so people do get their milk from supermarkets, whilst i wouldnt call the milk bibek, if they have no other choice, wat else can they dp. the best thing is just to do as much naam simran and bani over anything you eat or drink vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Singh too · 05 Sep 2005

The issue is pretty clear. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh didn't use milk unless it was milked by an amritdhari or by himself. At the same time, Bhai Jodh Singh in his book on Bhai Sahib writes that once he asked Bhai Sahib about this problem and told him that when he is travelling he sometimes uses open milk. Bhai Sahib said that he keeps as much rehit as possible and others have to see what they can do. Bhai Sahib didn't condemn him or tell him his bibek is broken or something like that. Clearly milk in cartons is not bibeki. But at the same time, asking some Chardi Kala Singhs, they have said it seems acceptable if in this situation (where no bibeki milk is available) if the milk is boiled in sarbloh and then used. I don't think that milk is bibek from supermarkets. At the same time I think that it's not the same thing as an Indian Singh using it. Here we have no choice in the matter and for the most part the milking is done by machines. Yes, the milk bags are handled and stocked by manmukhs so it's not perfect. If there was bibeki milk available and someone chose to not use it or not take the hassle, it's a dhill, but when there is no other option I think you just have to go as far as you can.

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Amrik Singh "boongawala" · 05 Sep 2005

Does that mean milk products are ok? such as butter and cheese?

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

little I · 05 Sep 2005

gotta boil the milk before you drink it and make your own cheese from this milk. all depends how far your able to take it. take it as far as you can, if your more worried during your nitnem/life about what your going to make instead of concentrating on Guru Ji (like i do) then it's no good. try your personal best.

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

singhni · 05 Sep 2005

no amrik singh butter and cheese are not alrite. milk i suppose is essential, if u dont have milk for a long period of time u can feel the difference-i.e u'll feel weak. so some people boil milk and do gurbani over it, as they have no other choice. bibeki's do not have butter or cheese, these are not bibek. u can use olive oil insted of butter, and u dont really need cheese.

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

charanjeev singh · 05 Sep 2005

I feel everyone here has lost the point. What about dya? compassion. The first principle of sikhi is dya, compassion. The practices of society are very different than earlier days; for example as little as 80 years ago. Today we have factory farms, and drugged animals. If you are truly bibeki, you would not have any milk bought from the market today because these cows are locked up unhumanely and are drugged. Also the milk is changed by adding additional vitamins etc. Do you know where the vitamins come from? hmmmm. So you should re-consider having milk at all in this society, unless you milk your own cow. Everything is impure if you are impure. Bunch of ritualists. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

ssingh · 05 Sep 2005

so animals are pure? Drinking the milk of any animal milked by an amritdhari is pure? Or does this apply to cows only? If I touch the mammary glands of a cow, are my hands still suchay? Can I do langar seva? Obviously not, so how can the milk, that has at the very least "touched" these impure biological structures, be served in a langar of bibek? Yet if it is boiled (vapor pressure of milk liquid has been brought to atmospheric pressure) then it becomes pure? Is there a certain time frame after which all the impurities have been exorcised from the milk?

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Singh · 05 Sep 2005

Guru Sahib used milk. Kheer is mentioned as being served by Mata Khivi jee in Ramkali ki Vaar. If someone thinks they can be smarter and keep better bibek than Guru Sahib, I think they've lost the plot. Boiling makes anything more hygenic so why not boil milk? Are you suggesting it doesn't help purify? In respect to dya, I think it is more ethical to use organic milk as many (if not most bibekis) already do. Finally in regards to cheese: no. Butter: yes, but again, you heat it up first to make it ghee. Ghee is acknowledged by all Singhs as "pure substance" . The reason butter can be used is because the only ingredient is cream and that is the same as milk essentially.

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 06 Sep 2005

imho..the only truly bibek milk..was the one we received from our mothers. ALL other is "jutha" as Bhagat namdev Ji says..the calf has already made it jutha ???. In his Jail chitthean..BSB Randhir Singh Ji was adamant until the Jail authorities allowed him his own cow to personally milk..imho today we are not so adamant ?? maybe. I drink Processed milk. ( cartons) and Tinned Powder milk....maybe its time to give it up..

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Gandalf · 07 Sep 2005

An article on milk _________________________________ "MILK" Just the word itself sounds comforting! "How about a nice cup of hot milk?" The last time you heard that question it was from someone who cared for you--and you appreciated their effort. The entire matter of food and especially that of milk is surrounded with emotional and cultural importance. Milk was our very first food. If we were fortunate it was our mother's milk. A loving link, given and taken. It was the only path to survival. If not mother's milk it was cow's milk or soy milk "formula"--rarely it was goat, camel or water buffalo milk. Now, we are a nation of milk drinkers. Nearly all of us. Infants, the young, adolescents, adults and even the aged. We drink dozens or even several hundred gallons a year and add to that many pounds of "dairy products" such as cheese, butter, and yogurt. Can there be anything wrong with this? We see reassuring images of healthy, beautiful people on our television screens and hear messages that assure us that, "Milk is good for your body." Our dieticians insist that: "You've got to have milk, or where will you get your calcium?" School lunches always include milk and nearly every hospital meal will have milk added. And if that isn't enough, our nutritionists told us for years that dairy products make up an "essential food group." Industry spokesmen made sure that colourful charts proclaiming the necessity of milk and other essential nutrients were made available at no cost for schools. Cow's milk became "normal." You may be surprised to learn that most of the human beings that live on planet Earth today do not drink or use cow's milk. Further, most of them can't drink milk because it makes them ill. There are students of human nutrition who are not supportive of milk use for adults. Here is a quotation from the March/April 1991 Utne Reader: If you really want to play it safe, you may decide to join the growing number of Americans who are eliminating dairy products from their diets altogether. Although this sounds radical to those of us weaned on milk and the five basic food groups, it is eminently viable. Indeed, of all the mammals, only humans--and then only a minority, principally Caucasians--continue to drink milk beyond babyhood. Who is right? Why the confusion? Where best to get our answers? Can we trust milk industry spokesmen? Can you trust any industry spokesmen? Are nutritionists up to date or are they simply repeating what their professors learned years ago? What about the new voices urging caution? I believe that there are three reliable sources of information. The first, and probably the best, is a study of nature. The second is to study the history of our own species. Finally we need to look at the world's scientific literature on the subject of milk. Let's look at the scientific literature first. From 1988 to 1993 there were over 2,700 articles dealing with milk recorded in the 'Medicine' archives. Fifteen hundred of theses had milk as the main focus of the article. There is no lack of scientific information on this subject. I reviewed over 500 of the 1,500 articles, discarding articles that dealt exclusively with animals, esoteric research and inconclusive studies. How would I summarize the articles? They were only slightly less than horrifying. First of all, none of the authors spoke of cow's milk as an excellent food, free of side effects and the 'perfect food' as we have been led to believe by the industry. The main focus of the published reports seems to be on intestinal colic, intestinal irritation, intestinal bleeding, anemia, allergic reactions in infants and children as well as infections such as salmonella. More ominous is the fear of viral infection with bovine leukemia virus or an AIDS-like virus as well as concern for childhood diabetes. Contamination of milk by blood and white (pus) cells as well as a variety of chemicals and insecticides was also discussed. Among children the problems were allergy, ear and tonsillar infections, bedwetting, asthma, intestinal bleeding, colic and childhood diabetes. In adults the problems seemed centered more around heart disease and arthritis, allergy, sinusitis, and the more serious questions of leukemia, lymphoma and cancer. I think that an answer can also be found in a consideration of what occurs in nature & what happens with free living mammals and what happens with human groups living in close to a natural state as 'hunter-gatherers'. Our paleolithic ancestors are another crucial and interesting group to study. Here we are limited to speculation and indirect evidences, but the bony remains available for our study are remarkable. There is no doubt whatever that these skeletal remains reflect great strength, muscularity (the size of the muscular insertions show this), and total absence of advanced osteoporosis. And if you feel that these people are not important for us to study, consider that today our genes are programming our bodies in almost exactly the same way as our ancestors of 50,000 to 100,000 years ago. WHAT IS MILK? Milk is a maternal lactating secretion, a short term nutrient for new-borns. Nothing more, nothing less. Invariably, the mother of any mammal will provide her milk for a short period of time immediately after birth. When the time comes for 'weaning', the young offspring is introduced to the proper food for that species of mammal. A familiar example is that of a puppy. The mother nurses the pup for just a few weeks and then rejects the young animal and teaches it to eat solid food. Nursing is provided by nature only for the very youngest of mammals. Of course, it is not possible for animals living in a natural state to continue with the drinking of milk after weaning. IS ALL MILK THE SAME? Then there is the matter of where we get our milk. We have settled on the cow because of its docile nature, its size, and its abundant milk supply. Somehow this choice seems 'normal' and blessed by nature, our culture, and our customs. But is it natural? Is it wise to drink the milk of another species of mammal? Consider for a moment, if it was possible, to drink the milk of a mammal other than a cow, let's say a rat. Or perhaps the milk of a dog would be more to your liking. Possibly some horse milk or cat milk. Do you get the idea? Well, I'm not serious about this, except to suggest that human milk is for human infants, dogs' milk is for pups, cows' milk is for calves, cats' milk is for kittens, and so forth. Clearly, this is the way nature intends it. Just use your own good judgement on this one. Milk is not just milk. The milk of every species of mammal is unique and specifically tailored to the requirements of that animal. For example, cows' milk is very much richer in protein than human milk. Three to four times as much. It has five to seven times the mineral content. However, it is markedly deficient in essential fatty acids when compared to human mothers' milk. Mothers' milk has six to ten times as much of the essential fatty acids, especially linoleic acid. (Incidentally, skimmed cow's milk has no linoleic acid). It simply is not designed for humans. Food is not just food, and milk is not just milk. It is not only the proper amount of food but the proper qualitative composition that is critical for the very best in health and growth. Biochemists and physiologists -and rarely medical doctors - are gradually learning that foods contain the crucial elements that allow a particular species to develop its unique specializations. Clearly, our specialization is for advanced neurological development and delicate neuromuscular control. We do not have much need of massive skeletal growth or huge muscle groups as does a calf. Think of the difference between the demands make on the human hand and the demands on a cow's hoof. Human new-borns specifically need critical material for their brains, spinal cord and nerves. Can mother's milk increase intelligence? It seems that it can. In a remarkable study published in Lancet during 1992 (Vol. 339, p. 261-4), a group of British workers randomly placed premature infants into two groups. One group received a proper formula, the other group received human breast milk. Both fluids were given by stomach tube. These children were followed up for over 10 years. In intelligence testing, the human milk children averaged 10 IQ points higher! Well, why not? Why wouldn't the correct building blocks for the rapidly maturing and growing brain have a positive effect? In the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition (1982) Ralph Holman described an infant who developed profound neurological disease while being nourished by intravenous fluids only. The fluids used contained only linoleic acid - just one of the essential fatty acids. When the other, alpha linoleic acid, was added to the intravenous fluids the neurological disorders cleared. In the same journal five years later Bjerve, Mostad and Thoresen, working in Norway found exactly the same problem in adult patients on long term gastric tube feeding. In 1930 Dr. G.O. Burr in Minnesota working with rats found that linoleic acid deficiencies created a deficiency syndrome. Why is this mentioned? In the early 1960s pediatricians found skin lesions in children fed formulas without the same linoleic acid. Remembering the research, the addition of the acid to the formula cured the problem. Essential fatty acids are just that and cows' milk is markedly deficient in these when compared to human milk. WELL, AT LEAST COW'S MILK IS PURE Or is it? Fifty years ago an average cow produced 2,000 pounds of milk per year. Today the top producers give 50,000 pounds! How was this accomplished? Drugs, antibiotics, hormones, forced feeding plans and specialized breeding; that's how. The latest high-tech onslaught on the poor cow is bovine growth hormone or BGH. This genetically engineered drug is supposed to stimulate milk production but, according to Monsanto, the hormone's manufacturer, does not affect the milk or meat. There are three other manufacturers: Upjohn, Eli Lilly, and American Cyanamid Company. Obviously, there have been no long-term studies on the hormone's effect on the humans drinking the milk. Other countries have banned BGH because of safety concerns. One of the problems with adding molecules to a milk cows' body is that the molecules usually come out in the milk. I don't know how you feel, but I don't want to experiment with the ingestion of a growth hormone. A related problem is that it causes a marked increase (50 to 70 per cent) in mastitis. This, then, requires antibiotic therapy, and the residues of the antibiotics appear in the milk. It seems that the public is uneasy about this product and in one survey 43 per cent felt that growth hormone treated milk represented a health risk. A vice president for public policy at Monsanto was opposed to labelling for that reason, and because the labelling would create an 'artificial distinction'. The country is awash with milk as it is, we produce more milk than we can consume. Let's not create storage costs and further taxpayer burdens, because the law requires the USDA to buy any surplus of butter, cheese, or non-fat dry milk at a support price set by Congress! In fiscal 1991, the USDA spent $757 million on surplus butter, and one billion dollars a year on average for price supports during the 1980s (Consumer Reports, May 1992: 330-32). Any lactating mammal excretes toxins through her milk. This includes antibiotics, pesticides, chemicals and hormones. Also, all cows' milk contains blood! The inspectors are simply asked to keep it under certain limits. You may be horrified to learn that the USDA allows milk to contain from one to one and a half million white blood cells per millilitre. (That's only 1/30 of an ounce). If you don't already know this, I'm sorry to tell you that another way to describe white cells where they don't belong would be to call them pus cells. To get to the point, is milk pure or is it a chemical, biological, and bacterial cocktail? Finally, will the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) protect you? The United States General Accounting Office (GAO) tells us that the FDA and the individual States are failing to protect the public from drug residues in milk. Authorities test for only 4 of the 82 drugs in dairy cows. As you can imagine, the Milk Industry Foundation's spokesman claims it's perfectly safe. Jerome Kozak says, "I still think that milk is the safest product we have." Other, perhaps less biased observers, have found the following: 38% of milk samples in 10 cities were contaminated with sulfa drugs or other antibiotics. (This from the Centre for Science in the Public Interest and The Wall Street Journal, Dec. 29, 1989).. A similar study in Washington, DC found a 20 percent contamination rate (Nutrition Action Healthletter, April 1990). What's going on here? When the FDA tested milk, they found few problems. However, they used very lax standards. When they used the same criteria, the FDA data showed 51 percent of the milk samples showed drug traces. Let's focus in on this because it’s critical to our understanding of the apparent discrepancies. The FDA uses a disk-assay method that can detect only 2 of the 30 or so drugs found in milk. Also, the test detects only at the relatively high level. A more powerful test called the 'Charm II test' can detect drugs down to 5 parts per billion. One nasty subject must be discussed. It seems that cows are forever getting infections around the udder that require ointments and antibiotics. An article from France tells us that when a cow receives penicillin, that penicillin appears in the milk for from 4 to 7 milkings. Another study from the University of Nevada, Reno tells of cells in 'mastic milk', milk from cows with infected udders. An elaborate analysis of the cell fragments, employing cell cultures, flow cytometric analysis , and a great deal of high tech stuff. Do you know what the conclusion was? If the cow has mastitis, there is pus in the milk. Sorry, it’s in the study, all concealed with language such as "macrophages containing many vacuoles and phagocytosed particles," etc. IT GETS WORSE Well, at least human mothers' milk is pure! Sorry. A huge study showed that human breast milk in over 14,000 women had contamination by pesticides! Further, it seems that the sources of the pesticides are meat and--you guessed it-- dairy products. Well, why not? These pesticides are concentrated in fat and that's what's in these products. (Of interest, a subgroup of lactating vegetarian mothers had only half the levels of contamination). A recent report showed an increased concentration of pesticides in the breast tissue of women with breast cancer when compared to the tissue of women with fibrocystic disease. Other articles in the standard medical literature describe problems. Just scan these titles: 1.Cow's Milk as a Cause of Infantile Colic Breast-Fed Infants. Lancet 2 (1978): 437 2.Dietary Protein-Induced Colitis in Breast- Fed Infants, J. Pediatr. I01 (1982): 906 3.The Question of the Elimination of Foreign Protein in Women's Milk, J. Immunology 19 (1930): 15 There are many others. There are dozens of studies describing the prompt appearance of cows' milk allergy in children being exclusively breast-fed! The cows' milk allergens simply appear in the mother's milk and are transmitted to the infant. A committee on nutrition of the American Academy of Pediatrics reported on the use of whole cows' milk in infancy (Pediatrics 1983: 72-253). They were unable to provide any cogent reason why bovine milk should be used before the first birthday yet continued to recommend its use! Doctor Frank Oski from the Upstate Medical Centre Department of Pediatrics, commenting on the recommendation, cited the problems of acute gastrointestinal blood loss in infants, the lack of iron, recurrent abdominal pain, milk- borne infections and contaminants, and said: Why give it at all - then or ever? In the face of uncertainty about many of the potential dangers of whole bovine milk, it would seem prudent to recommend that whole milk not be started until the answers are available. Isn't it time for these uncontrolled experiments on human nutrition to come to an end? In the same issue of Pediatrics he further commented: It is my thesis that whole milk should not be fed to the infant in the first year of life because of its association with iron deficiency anemia (milk is so deficient in iron that an infant would have to drink an impossible 31 quarts a day to get the RDA of 15 mg), acute gastrointiestinal bleeding, and various manifestations of food allergy. I suggest that unmodified whole bovine milk should not be consumed after infancy because of the problems of lactose intolerance, its contribution to the genesis of atherosclerosis, and its possible link to other diseases. In late 1992 Dr. Benjamin Spock, possibly the best known pediatrician in history, shocked the country when he articulated the same thoughts and specified avoidance for the first two years of life. Here is his quotation: I want to pass on the word to parents that cows' milk from the carton has definite faults for some babies. Human milk is the right one for babies. A study comparing the incidence of allergy and colic in the breast-fed infants of omnivorous and vegan mothers would be important. I haven't found such a study; it would be both important and inexpensive. And it will probably never be done. There is simply no academic or economic profit involved. OTHER PROBLEMS Let's just mention the problems of bacterial contamination. Salmonella, E. coli, and staphylococcal infections can be traced to milk. In the old days tuberculosis was a major problem and some folks want to go back to those times by insisting on raw milk on the basis that it's "natural." This is insanity! A study from UCLA showed that over a third of all cases of salmonella infection in California, 1980-1983 were traced to raw milk. That'll be a way to revive good old brucellosis again and I would fear leukemia, too. (More about that later). In England, and Wales where raw milk is still consumed there have been outbreaks of milk-borne diseases. The Journal of the American Medical Association (251: 483, 1984) reported a multi-state series of infections caused by Yersinia enterocolitica in pasteurised whole milk. This is despite safety precautions. All parents dread juvenile diabetes for their children. A Canadian study reported in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, Mar. 1990, describes a "...significant positive correlation between consumption of unfermented milk protein and incidence of insulin dependent diabetes mellitus in data from various countries. Conversely a possible negative relationship is observed between breast-feeding at age 3 months and diabetes risk.". Another study from Finland found that diabetic children had higher levels of serum antibodies to cows’ milk (Diabetes Research 7(3): 137-140 March 1988). Here is a quotation from this study: We infer that either the pattern of cows' milk consumption is altered in children who will have insulin dependent diabetes mellitus or, their immunological reactivity to proteins in cows' milk is enhanced, or the permeability of their intestines to cows' milk protein is higher than normal. The April 18, 1992 British Medical Journal has a fascinating study contrasting the difference in incidence of juvenile insulin dependent diabetes in Pakistani children who have migrated to England. The incidence is roughly 10 times greater in the English group compared to children remaining in Pakistan! What caused this highly significant increase? The authors said that "the diet was unchanged in Great Britain." Do you believe that? Do you think that the availability of milk, sugar and fat is the same in Pakistan as it is in England? That a grocery store in England has the same products as food sources in Pakistan? I don't believe that for a minute. Remember, we're not talking here about adult onset, type II diabetes which all workers agree is strongly linked to diet as well as to a genetic predisposition. This study is a major blow to the "it's all in your genes" crowd. Type I diabetes was always considered to be genetic or possibly viral, but now this? So resistant are we to consider diet as causation that the authors of the last article concluded that the cooler climate in England altered viruses and caused the very real increase in diabetes! The first two authors had the same reluctance top admit the obvious. The milk just may have had something to do with the disease. The latest in this remarkable list of reports, a New England Journal of Medicine article (July 30, 1992), also reported in the Los Angeles Times. This study comes from the Hospital for Sick Children in Toronto and from Finnish researchers. In Finland there is "...the world's highest rate of dairy product consumption and the world's highest rate of insulin dependent diabetes. The disease strikes about 40 children out of every 1,000 there contrasted with six to eight per 1,000 in the United States.... Antibodies produced against the milk protein during the first year of life, the researchers speculate, also attack and destroy the pancreas in a so-called auto-immune reaction, producing diabetes in people whose genetic makeup leaves them vulnerable." "...142 Finnish children with newly diagnosed diabetes. They found that every one had at least eight times as many antibodies against the milk protein as did healthy children, clear evidence that the children had a raging auto immune disorder." The team has now expanded the study to 400 children and is starting a trial where 3,000 children will receive no dairy products during the first nine months of life. "The study may take 10 years, but we'll get a definitive answer one way or the other," according to one of the researchers. I would caution them to be certain that the breast feeding mothers use on cows' milk in their diets or the results will be confounded by the transmission of the cows' milk protein in the mother's breast milk.... Now what was the reaction from the diabetes association? This is very interesting! Dr. F. Xavier Pi-Sunyer, the president of the association says: "It does not mean that children should stop drinking milk or that parents of diabetics should withdraw dairy products. These are rich sources of good protein." (Emphasis added) My God, it's the "good protein" that causes the problem! Do you suspect that the dairy industry may have helped the American Diabetes Association in the past? LEUKEMIA? LYMPHOMA? THIS MAY BE THE WORST--BRACE YOURSELF! I hate to tell you this, but the bovine leukemia virus is found in more than three of five dairy cows in the United States! This involves about 80% of dairy herds. Unfortunately, when the milk is pooled, a very large percentage of all milk produced is contaminated (90 to 95 per cent). Of course the virus is killed in pasteurisation-- if the pasteurisation was done correctly. What if the milk is raw? In a study of randomly collected raw milk samples the bovine leukemia virus was recovered from two-thirds. I sincerely hope that the raw milk dairy herds are carefully monitored when compared to the regular herds. (Science 1981; 213:1014). This is a world-wide problem. One lengthy study from Germany deplored the problem and admitted the impossibility of keeping the virus from infected cows' milk from the rest of the milk. Several European countries, including Germany and Switzerland, have attempted to "cull" the infected cows from their herds. Certainly the United States must be the leader in the fight against leukemic dairy cows, right? Wrong! We are the worst in the world with the former exception of Venezuela according to Virgil Hulse MD, a milk specialist who also has a B.S. in Dairy Manufacturing as well as a Master's degree in Public Health. As mentioned, the leukemia virus is rendered inactive by pasteurisation. Of course. However, there can be Chernobyl like accidents. One of these occurred in the Chicago area in April, 1985. At a modern, large, milk processing plant an accidental "cross connection" between raw and pasteurized milk occurred. A violent salmonella outbreak followed, killing 4 and making an estimated 150,000 ill. Now the question I would pose to the dairy industry people is this: "How can you assure the people who drank this milk that they were not exposed to the ingestion of raw, unkilled, bully active bovine leukemia viruses?" Further, it would be fascinating to know if a "cluster" of leukemia cases blossoms in that area in 1 to 3 decades. There are reports of "leukemia clusters" elsewhere, one of them mentioned in the June 10, 1990 San Francisco Chronicle involving Northern California. What happens to other species of mammals when they are exposed to the bovine leukemia virus? It's a fair question and the answer is not reassuring. Virtually all animals exposed to the virus develop leukemia. This includes sheep, goats, and even primates such as rhesus monkeys and chimpanzees. The route of transmission includes ingestion (both intravenous and intramuscular) and cells present in milk. There are obviously no instances of transfer attempts to human beings, but we know that the virus can infect human cells in vitro. There is evidence of human antibody formation to the bovine leukemia virus; this is disturbing. How did the bovine leukemia virus particles gain access to humans and become antigens? Was it as small, denatured particles? If the bovine leukemia viruses causes human leukemia, we could expect the dairy states with known leukemic herds to have a higher incidence of human leukemia. Is this so? Unfortunately, it seems to be the case! Iowa, Nebraska, South Dakota, Minnesota and Wisconsin have statistically higher incidence of leukemia than the national average. In Russia and in Sweden, areas with uncontrolled bovine leukemia virus have been linked with increases in human leukemia. I am also told that veterinarians have higher rates of leukemia than the general public. Dairy farmers have significantly elevated leukemia rates. Recent research shows lymphocytes from milk fed to neonatal mammals gains access to bodily tissues by passing directly through the intestinal wall. An optimistic note from the University of Illinois, Ubana from the Department of Animal Sciences shows the importance of one's perspective. Since they are concerned with the economics of milk and not primarily the health aspects, they noted that the production of milk was greater in the cows with the bovine leukemia virus. However when the leukemia produced a persistent and significant lymphocytosis (increased white blood cell count), the production fell off. They suggested "a need to re-evaluate the economic impact of bovine leukemia virus infection on the dairy industry". Does this mean that leukemia is good for profits only if we can keep it under control? You can get the details on this business concern from Proc. Nat. Acad. Sciences, U.S. Feb. 1989. I added emphasis and am insulted that a university department feels that this is an economic and not a human health issue. Do not expect help from the Department of Agriculture or the universities. The money stakes and the political pressures are too great. You're on you own. What does this all mean? We know that virus is capable of producing leukemia in other animals. Is it proven that it can contribute to human leukemia (or lymphoma, a related cancer)? Several articles tackle this one: 1.Epidemiologic Relationships of the Bovine Population and Human Leukemia in Iowa. Am Journal of Epidemiology 112 (1980):80 2.Milk of Dairy Cows Frequently Contains a Leukemogenic Virus. Science 213 (1981): 1014 3.Beware of the Cow. (Editorial) Lancet 2 (1974):30 4.Is Bovine Milk A Health Hazard?. Pediatrics; Suppl. Feeding the Normal Infant. 75:182-186; 1985 In Norway, 1422 individuals were followed for 11 and a half years. Those drinking 2 or more glasses of milk per day had 3.5 times the incidence of cancer of the lymphatic organs. British Med. Journal 61:456-9, March 1990. One of the more thoughtful articles on this subject is from Allan S. Cunningham of Cooperstown, New York. Writing in the Lancet, November 27, 1976 (page 1184), his article is entitled, "Lymphomas and Animal-Protein Consumption". Many people think of milk as “liquid meat” and Dr. Cunningham agrees with this. He tracked the beef and dairy consumption in terms of grams per day for a one year period, 1955-1956., in 15 countries . New Zealand, United States and Canada were highest in that order. The lowest was Japan followed by Yugoslavia and France. The difference between the highest and lowest was quite pronounced: 43.8 grams/day for New Zealanders versus 1.5 for Japan. Nearly a 30-fold difference! (Parenthetically, the last 36 years have seen a startling increase in the amount of beef and milk used in Japan and their disease patterns are reflecting this, confirming the lack of 'genetic protection' seen in migration studies. Formerly the increase in frequency of lymphomas in Japanese people was only in those who moved to the USA)! An interesting bit of trivia is to note the memorial built at the Gyokusenji Temple in Shimoda, Japan. This marked the spot where the first cow was killed in Japan for human consumption! The chains around this memorial were a gift from the US Navy. Where do you suppose the Japanese got the idea to eat beef? The year? 1930. Cunningham found a highly significant positive correlation between deaths from lymphomas and beef and dairy ingestion in the 15 countries analysed. A few quotations from his article follow: The average intake of protein in many countries is far in excess of the recommended requirements. Excessive consumption of animal protein may be one co-factor in the causation of lymphomas by acting in the following manner. Ingestion of certain proteins results in the adsorption of antigenic fragments through the gastrointestinal mucous membrane. This results in chronic stimulation of lymphoid tissue to which these fragments gain access "Chronic immunological stimulation causes lymphomas in laboratory animals and is believed to cause lymphoid cancers in men." The gastrointestinal mucous membrane is only a partial barrier to the absorption of food antigens, and circulating antibodies to food protein is commonplace especially potent lymphoid stimulants. Ingestion of cows' milk can produce generalized lymphadenopathy, hepatosplenomegaly, and profound adenoid hypertrophy. It has been conservatively estimated that more than 100 distinct antigens are released by the normal digestion of cows' milk which evoke production of all antibody classes [This may explain why pasteurized, killed viruses are still antigenic and can still cause disease. Here's more. A large prospective study from Norway was reported in the British Journal of Cancer 61 (3):456-9, March 1990. (Almost 16,000 individuals were followed for 11 and a half years). For most cancers there was no association between the tumour and milk ingestion. However, in lymphoma, there was a strong positive association. If one drank two glasses or more daily (or the equivalent in dairy products), the odds were 3.4 times greater than in persons drinking less than one glass of developing a lymphoma. There are two other cow-related diseases that you should be aware of. At this time they are not known to be spread by the use of dairy products and are not known to involve man. The first is bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE), and the second is the bovine immunodeficiency virus (BIV). The first of these diseases, we hope, is confined to England and causes cavities in the animal's brain. Sheep have long been known to suffer from a disease called scrapie. It seems to have been started by the feeding of contaminated sheep parts, especially brains, to the British cows. Now, use your good sense. Do cows seem like carnivores? Should they eat meat? This profit-motivated practice backfired and bovine spongiform encephalopathy, or Mad Cow Disease, swept Britain. The disease literally causes dementia in the unfortunate animal and is 100 per cent incurable. To date, over 100,000 cows have been incinerated in England in keeping with British law. Four hundred to 500 cows are reported as infected each month. The British public is concerned and has dropped its beef consumption by 25 per cent, while some 2,000 schools have stopped serving beef to children. Several farmers have developed a fatal disease syndrome that resembles both BSE and CJD (Creutzfeldt-Jakob- Disease). But the British Veterinary Association says that transmission of BSE to humans is "remote." The USDA agrees that the British epidemic was due to the feeding of cattle with bonemeal or animal protein produced at rendering plants from the carcasses of scrapie-infected sheep. The have prohibited the importation of live cattle and zoo ruminants from Great Britain and claim that the disease does not exist in the United States. However, there may be a problem. "Downer cows" are animals who arrive at auction yards or slaughter houses dead, trampled, lacerated, dehydrated, or too ill from viral or bacterial diseases to walk. Thus they are "down." If they cannot respond to electrical shocks by walking, they are dragged by chains to dumpsters and transported to rendering plants where, if they are not already dead, they are killed. Even a "humane" death is usually denied them. They are then turned into protein food for animals as well as other preparations. Minks that have been fed this protein have developed a fatal encephalopathy that has some resemblance to BSE. Entire colonies of minks have been lost in this manner, particularly in Wisconsin. It is feared that the infective agent is a prion or slow virus possible obtained from the ill "downer cows." The British Medical Journal in an editorial whimsically entitled "How Now Mad Cow?" (BMJ vol. 304, 11 Apr. 1992:929- 30) describes cases of BSE in species not previously known to be affected, such as cats. They admit that produce contaminated with bovine spongiform encephalopathy entered the human food chain in England between 1986 and 1989. They say. "The result of this experiment is awaited." As the incubation period can be up to three decades, wait we must. The immunodeficency virus is seen in cattle in the United States and is more worrisome. Its structure is closely related to that of the human AIDS virus. At this time we do not know if exposure to the raw BIV proteins can cause the sera of humans to become positive for HIV. The extent of the virus among American herds is said to be "widespread". (The USDA refuses to inspect the meat and milk to see if antibodies to this retrovirus is present). It also has no plans to quarantine the infected animals. As in the case of humans with AIDS, there is no cure for BIV in cows. Each day we consume beef and diary products from cows infected with these viruses and no scientific assurance exists that the products are safe. Eating raw beef (as in steak Tartare) strikes me as being very risky, especially after the Seattle E. coli deaths of 1993. A report in the Canadian Journal of Veterinary Research, October 1992, Vol. 56 pp.353-359 and another from the Russian literature, tell of a horrifying development. They report the first detection in human serum of the antibody to a bovine immunodeficiency virus protein. In addition to this disturbing report, is another from Russia telling us of the presence of virus proteins related to the bovine leukemia virus in 5 of 89 women with breast disease (Acta Virologica Feb. 1990 34(1): 19-26). The implications of these developments are unknown at present. However, it is safe to assume that these animal viruses are unlikely to "stay" in the animal kingdom. OTHER CANCERS--DOES IT GET WORSE? Unfortunately it does. Ovarian cancer--a particularly nasty tumour--was associated with milk consumption by workers at Roswell Park Memorial Institute in Buffalo, New York. Drinking more than one glass of whole milk or equivalent daily gave a woman a 3.1 times risk over non-milk users. They felt that the reduced fat milk products helped reduce the risk. This association has been made repeatedly by numerous investigators. Another important study, this from the Harvard Medical School, analyzed data from 27 countries mainly from the 1970s. Again a significant positive correlation is revealed between ovarian cancer and per capita milk consumption. These investigators feel that the lactose component of milk is the responsible fraction, and the digestion of this is facilitated by the persistence of the ability to digest the lactose (lactose persistence) - a little different emphasis, but the same conclusion. This study was reported in the American Journal of Epidemiology 130 (5): 904-10 Nov. 1989. These articles come from two of the country's leading institutions, not the Rodale Press or Prevention Magazine. Even lung cancer has been associated with milk ingestion? The beverage habits of 569 lung cancer patients and 569 controls again at Roswell Park were studied in the International Journal of Cancer, April 15, 1989. Persons drinking whole milk 3 or more times daily had a 2-fold increase in lung cancer risk when compared to those never drinking whole milk. For many years we have been watching the lung cancer rates for Japanese men who smoke far more than American or European men but who develop fewer lung cancers. Workers in this research area feel that the total fat intake is the difference. There are not many reports studying an association between milk ingestion and prostate cancer. One such report though was of great interest. This is from the Roswell Park Memorial Institute and is found in Cancer 64 (3): 605-12, 1989. They analyzed the diets of 371 prostate cancer patients and comparable control subjects: Men who reported drinking three or more glasses of whole milk daily had a relative risk of 2.49 compared with men who reported never drinking whole milk the weight of the evidence appears to favour the hypothesis that animal fat is related to increased risk of prostate cancer. Prostate cancer is now the most common cancer diagnosed in US men and is the second leading cause of cancer mortality. WELL, WHAT ARE THE BENEFITS? Is there any health reason at all for an adult human to drink cows' milk? It's hard for me to come up with even one good reason other than simple preference. But if you try hard, in my opinion, these would be the best two: milk is a source of calcium and it's a source of amino acids (proteins). Let's look at the calcium first. Why are we concerned at all about calcium? Obviously, we intend it to build strong bones and protect us against osteoporosis. And no doubt about it, milk is loaded with calcium. But is it a good calcium source for humans? I think not. These are the reasons. Excessive amounts of dairy products actually interfere with calcium absorption. Secondly, the excess of protein that the milk provides is a major cause of the osteoporosis problem. Dr. H egsted in England has been writing for years about the geographical distribution of osteoporosis. It seems that the countries with the highest intake of dairy products are invariably the countries with the most osteoporosis. He feels that milk is a cause of osteoporosis. Reasons to be given below. Numerous studies have shown that the level of calcium ingestion and especially calcium supplementation has no effect whatever on the development of osteoporosis. The most important such article appeared recently in the British Journal of Medicine where the long arm of our dairy industry can't reach. Another study in the United States actually showed a worsening in calcium balance in post-menopausal women given three 8-ounce glasses of cows' milk per day. (Am. Journal of Clin. Nutrition, 1985). The effects of hormone, gender, weight bearing on the axial bones, and in particular protein intake, are critically important. Another observation that may be helpful to our analysis is to note the absence of any recorded dietary deficiencies of calcium among people living on a natural diet without milk. For the key to the osteoporosis riddle, don’t look at calcium, look at protein. Consider these two contrasting groups. Eskimos have an exceptionally high protein intake estimated at 25 percent of total calories. They also have a high calcium intake at 2,500 mg/day. Their osteoporosis is among the worst in the world. The other instructive group are the Bantus of South Africa. They have a 12 percent protein diet, mostly p lant protein, and only 200 to 350 mg/day of calcium, about half our women's intake. The women have virtually no osteoporosis despite bearing six or more children and nursing them for prolonged periods! When African women immigrate to the United States, do they develop osteoporosis? The answer is yes, but not quite are much as Caucasian or Asian women. Thus, there is a genetic difference that is modified by diet. To answer the obvious question, "Well, where do you get your calcium?" The answer is: "From exactly the same place the cow gets the calcium, from green things that grow in the ground," mainly from leafy vegetables. After all, elephants and rhinos develop their huge bones (after being weaned) by eating green leafy plants, so do horses. Carnivorous animals also do quite nicely without leafy plants. It seems that all of earth's mammals do well if they live in harmony with their genetic programming and natural food. Only humans living an affluent life style have rampant osteoporosis. If animal references do not convince you, think of the several billion humans on this earth who have never seen cows' milk. Wouldn't you think osteoporosis would be prevalent in this huge group? The dairy people would suggest this but the truth is exactly the opposite. They have far less than that seen in the countries where dairy products are commonly consumed. It is the subject of another paper, but the truly significant determinants of osteoporosis are grossly excessive protein intakes and lack of weight bearing on long bones, both taking place over decades. Hormones play a secondary, but not trivial role in women. Milk is a deterrent to good bone health. THE PROTEIN MYTH Remember when you were a kid and the adults all told you to "make sure you get plenty of good protein". Protein was the nutritional "good guy”" when I was young. And of course milk is fitted right in. As regards protein, milk is indeed a rich source of protein- -"liquid meat," remember? However that isn't necessarily what we need. In actual fact it is a source of difficulty. Nearly all Americans eat too much protein. For this information we rely on the most authoritative source that I am aware of. This is the latest edition (1oth, 1989: 4th printing, Jan. 1992) of the Recommended Dietary Allowances produced by the National Research Council. Of interest, the current editor of this important work is Dr. Richard Havel of the University of California in San Francisco. First to be noted is that the recommended protein has been steadily revised downward in successive editions. The current recommendation is 0.75 g/kilo/day for adults 19 through 51 years. This, of course, is only 45 grams per day for the mythical 60 kilogram adult. You should also know that the WHO estimated the need for protein in adults to by .6g/kilo per day. (All RDA's are calculated with large safety allowances in case you're the type that wants to add some more to "be sure.") You can "get by" on 28 to 30 grams a day if necessary! Now 45 grams a day is a tiny amount of protein. That's an ounce and a half! Consider too, that the protein does not have to be animal protein. Vegetable protein is identical for all practical purposes and has no cholesterol and vastly less saturated fat. (Do not be misled by the antiquated belief that plant proteins must be carefully balanced to avoid deficiencies. This is not a realistic concern.) Therefore virtually all Americans, Canadians, British and European people are in a protein overloaded state. This has serious consequences when maintained over decades. The problems are the already mentioned osteoporosis, atherosclerosis and kidney damage. There is good evidence that certain malignancies, chiefly colon and rectal, are related to excessive meat intake. Barry Brenner, an eminent renal physiologist was the first to fully point out the dangers of excess protein for the kidney tubule. The dangers of the fat and cholesterol are known to all. Finally, you should know that the protein content of human milk is amount the lowest (0.9%) in mammals. IS THAT ALL OF THE TROUBLE? Sorry, there's more. Remember lactose? This is the principal carbohydrate of milk. It seems that nature provides new- borns with the enzymatic equipment to metabolize lactose, but this ability often extinguishes by age 4 or 5 years. What is the problem with lactose or milk sugar? It seems that it is a disaccharide which is too large to be absorbed into the blood stream without first being broken down into monosaccharides, namely galactose and glucose. This requires the presence of an enzyme, lactase plus additional enzymes to break down the galactose into glucose. Let's think about his for a moment. Nature gives us the ability to metabolize lactose for a few years and then shuts off the mechanism. Is Mother Nature trying to tell us something? Clearly all infants must drink milk. The fact that so many adults cannot seems to be related to the tendency for nature to abandon mechanisms that are not needed. At least half of the adult humans on this earth are lactose intolerant. It was not until the relatively recent introduction of dairy herding and the ability to "borrow" milk from another group of mammals that the survival advantage of preserving lactase (the enzyme that allows us to digest lactose) became evident. But why would it be advantageous to drink cows' milk? After all, most of the human beings in the history of the world did. And further, why was it just the white or light skinned humans who retained this knack while the pigmented people tended to lose it? Some students of evolution feel that white skin is a fairly recent innovation, perhaps not more than 20,000 or 30,000 years old. It clearly has to do with the Northward migration of early man to cold and relatively sunless areas when skins and clothing became available. Fair skin allows the production of Vitamin D from sunlight more readily than does dark skin. However, when only the face was exposed to sunlight that area of fair skin was insufficient to provide the vitamin D from sunlight. If dietary and sunlight sources were poorly available, the ability to use the abundant calcium in cows' milk would give a survival advantage to humans who could digest that milk. This seems to be the only logical explanation for fair skinned humans having a high degree of lactose tolerance when compared to dark skinned people. How does this break down? Certain racial groups, namely blacks are up to 90% lactose intolerant as adults. Caucasians are 20 to 40% lactose intolerant. Orientals are midway between the above two groups. Diarrhea, gas and abdominal cramps are the results of substantial milk intake in such persons. Most American Indians cannot tolerate milk. The milk industry admits that lactose intolerance plays intestinal havoc with as many as 50 million Americans. A lactose-intolerance industry has sprung up and had sales of $117 million in 1992 (Time May 17, 1993.) What if you are lactose-intolerant and lust after dairy products? Is all lost? Not at all. It seems that lactose is largely digested by bacteria and you will be able to enjoy your cheese despite lactose intolerance. Yogurt is similar in this respect. Finally, and I could never have dreamed this up, geneticists want to splice genes to alter the composition of milk (Am J Clin Nutr 1993 Suppl 302s). One could quibble and say that milk is totally devoid of fiber content and that its habitual use will predispose to constipation and bowel disorders. The association with anemia and occult intestinal bleeding in infants is known to all physicians. This is chiefly from its lack of iron and its irritating qualities for the intestinal mucosa. The pediatric literature abounds with articles describing irritated intestinal lining, bleeding, increased permeability as well as colic, diarrhea and vomiting in cows'milk-sensitive babies. The anemia gets a double push by loss of blood and iron as well as deficiency of iron in the cows' milk. Milk is also the leading cause of childhood allergy. LOW FAT One additional topic: the matter of "low fat" milk. A common and sincere question is: "Well, low fat milk is OK, isn't it?" The answer to this question is that low fat milk isn't low fat. The term "low fat" is a marketing term used to gull the public. Low fat milk contains from 24 to 33% fat as calories! The 2% figure is also misleading. This refers to weight. They don't tell you that, by weight, the milk is 87% water! "Well, then, kill-joy surely you must approve of non-fat milk!" I hear this quite a bit. (Another constant concern is: "What do you put on your cereal?") True, there is little or no fat, but now you have a relative overburden of protein and lactose. It there is something that we do not need more of it is another simple sugar-lactose, composed of galactose and glucose. Millions of Americans are lactose intolerant to boot, as noted. As for protein, as stated earlier, we live in a society that routinely ingests far more protein than we need. It is a burden for our bodies, especially the kidneys, and a prominent cause of osteoporosis. Concerning the dry cereal issue, I would suggest soy milk, rice milk or almond milk as a healthy substitute. If you're still concerned about calcium, "Westsoy" is formulated to have the same calcium concentration as milk. SUMMARY To my thinking, there is only one valid reason to drink milk or use milk products. That is just because we simply want to. Because we like it and because it has become a part of our culture. Because we have become accustomed to its taste and texture. Because we like the way it slides down our throat. Because our parents did the very best they could for us and provided milk in our earliest training and conditioning. They taught us to like it. And then probably the very best reason is ice cream! I've heard it described "to die for". I had one patient who did exactly that. He had no obvious vices. He didn't smoke or drink, he didn’t eat meat, his diet and lifestyle was nearly a perfectly health promoting one; but he had a passion. You guessed it, he loved rich ice cream. A pint of the richest would be a lean day's ration for him. On many occasions he would eat an entire quart - and yes there were some cookies and other pastries. Good ice cream deserves this after all. He seemed to be in good health despite some expected "middle age spread" when he had a devastating stroke which left him paralyzed, miserable and helpless, and he had additional strokes and d ied several years later never having left a hospital or rehabilitation unit. Was he old? I don't think so. He was in his 50s. So don't drink milk for health. I am convinced on the weight of the scientific evidence that it does not "do a body good." Inclusion of milk will only reduce your diet's nutritional value and safety. Most of the people on this planet live very healthfully without cows' milk. You can too. It will be difficult to change; we've been conditioned since childhood to think of milk as "nature's most perfect food." I'll guarantee you that it will be safe, improve your health and it won't cost anything. What can you lose?

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

ns · 07 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Beautiful article by Gandalf , many Thanks for submitting it. Couple of weeks back there was a program on TV Dispatches which covered how the cow is made to suffer to produce milk and relates heavily to the article above, surely our Guru Sahiban taught us not to pain anyone, but in today's world this is not the case. I would prefer soya or rice milk anyday in comparison to normal milk cooked in sarbloh if possible of course

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Gandalf · 07 Sep 2005

for a list of articles showing how bad milk really is, go to: www.notmilk.com or http://www.milksucks.com/index2.html You will see how bad milk, and the process of making milk really is. For example, did you know that dairy farmers feed dead dairy cows back to living dairy cows (that is how Mad Cow disease spread - the disease is in the brain, but if the cow eats the brain it enters their body). Cows are also fed ground up fish, pork, Did you know that cows are tortured into producing more milk than they are naturally capable of (they produce 5 to 10 times more than they are naturally capable of) - their udders are disgustingly over capacity. Did you know that their living conditions are very very disgusting (that is a form of torture). Many cows are crammed into a very small, dirty dingy space. Who would want to live like that? Did you know cows are pumped full of hormones to produce more milk - where do you think these hormones go (thats right - in your belly) - tip: stop drinking milk, you will not have acne or other health problems. Synthetic hormones such as recombinant bovine growth hormone (rBGH) are commonly used in dairy cows to increase the production of milk. Because the cows are producing quantities of milk nature never intended, the end result is mastitis, or inflammation of the mammary glands. The treatment requires the use of antibiotics, and traces of these and hormones have been found in samples of milk and other dairy products. Pesticides and other drugs are also frequent contaminants of dairy products. I must confess, my wife has quit dairy altogether, I have just to quit cheese now (which I eat once a week). If you want to eat pure food which doesn't harm animals, stay away from milk. The only time we should have milk is when we are infants. After that we don't need it. [%sig%]

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Jasmin · 07 Sep 2005

Even as a child I always found milk repulsive. I am white, and lactose tolerant, even so, I often refused to drink it. Fortunately, my parents did not push it. I was willing to eat some cheese, and I loved yogurt, and sour cream, but not milk. However, I did use it in cereal, because I did not know what else to use. I was delighted to discover soy milk. It is so much better! I buy Silk, or Natures Promise. Some people are allergic to soy, if so, then use rice milk : ).

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Princess · 07 Sep 2005

If Gurbani supports milk and calls it Amrit then why listen to other worldly researchers? Our Guru Sahiban never stopped us from using milk but there are many examples of using it in daily life even in langar at Guru Sahiban's time.

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

charanjeev singh · 07 Sep 2005

i would say and agree that Guru Sahib indeed did use milk. but it is my opinion that Guru sahib also gave us Bibek. For example: Guru Sahib used milk. The milk were brought by sangat and milked by cows directly. No additives were added. i) now lets say someone brought milk that they stole. Nonetheless it is still milk. I am sure Janee Jaan Guru Sahib would have taught the sikh that stealing is wrong, and not accepted the milk, and would have called it poison (my speculation, or belief) what i am trying to say is that Guru Sahib gave us Bibek buddhi. We know that what we use today is definately not what was used in Guru Sahibs time (many things anyway). Everything has something or another mixed into it; even though from the appearance it seems the same. Milk is definately accepted in Guru Sahibs langar, Mata Keevi Jee served Kheer as tasty as Amrit. However we must also realize with Bibek Buddhi, that the milk that Guru Sahib used at that time, is not the same milk that is available in in most supermarkets today. They might be some places where 'good' milk is available, but in general, there is a lot of unacceptable practices accepted as mainstream and adopted today. I am in the opinion that in the times of Guru Sahibaans from Guru Nanak Dev Jee to Guru Gobind Singh Jee, the cows that provided the milk were not drugged nor kept unhumanely as they are in many facilities today. Also, i do not think that other additives were added to the milk. We should try our best to be humane Gursikhs. I try my best to abstain from milk products at home, however in langar, i love kheer (how can i say no to what the Guru has accepted) bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Scientific · 07 Sep 2005

This is brahmin talk. There can be nothing wrong with drinking milk. Sikhs are not vegetarians and certainly not vegans. There is absolutely no evidence in history to support such proposterous theories. We can deny it til the 'cows come come' but history clearly states that Sikhs are a martial race proud of its hunting and military tradition. What kind of a military force would be squirming about drinking a milkshake! Get real!

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

charanjeev singh · 07 Sep 2005

Scientific, as i have suggested to you on another thread; stick to bunsen burners.

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Jaspal Kaur · 07 Sep 2005

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji yeh when Gurbani supports milk it reasonable. However in those days cows were not tortured to the extreme mention in the above posts hana. So thats why i hear that some people use organic, soya or rice milk. I'm hope this types of milk would be suitable to drink because they are produced in the right natural manner. vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

2 sense · 07 Sep 2005

Waheguru ji ka Kahlsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh I wonder What Guru Nanak Did when traveling... How He ate... Who He took food from... and what He'd think if he saw how sikhs His supposed followers think and behave over such matters. Didn't He give the answer in Asa di vaar when he wrote about purity.

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

. · 07 Sep 2005

Dear 2 sense, If you wonder how Guru Sahib ate and from whom he accepted food and from whom he rejected it, get yourself a primary level kaydha reader or a book of sakhees for children. Look for the story on Bhai Lalo and Malik Bhago and you'll find your answer. And Jaspal Kaur Bhain Jee, The varieties of rice milk and soy milk I've seen around here often contain lots of unnecessary ingredients. It's best to opt for regular organic milk. Most bibekis use it.

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Jasmin · 07 Sep 2005

Dear Scientific- Brahmin? Scientific, I have studied Hinduism, and some / or all Brahmins will not eat soy, as beans are grown in the ground, in dirt, and are therefore considered unclean. Prehaps they would drink rice milk, but because cows are sacred, milk and yogurt is considered ritually clean, and may be brought to temple. I would think Brahmins, traditionally, would tend to like cow's milk, which is mention in the Vedas as a suitable food. In today's world, prehaps some Hindus would avoid milk, fearing to endorse the possible slaughter of retired dairy cows. In any case I was merely stating a personal preference. What is so great, objectivily, about raw animal secretions? Unnecessary ingredients, well choose carefully, read labels. I use lots of soy now, and honestly, my cholesterol has plummeted. Last time I checked it was around 134. If anyone wants great dietitary advice, I would recommend the naturopathic blood group based diet. I would refer you to the writings of Dr. Peter J.D'Adamo. Real dairy enthusiast's are generally type B's. With me, I just get phlegm and excema. If you a milk lover, you should try the Organic Cow, a local brand, in Conn., I don't know if it's in Ontario.

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

2 sense · 07 Sep 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh So what is the point exactly - It's not the food itself but the hands which prepare it? Milk comes from the body of Cows which are not Amritdhari. The living cultures of bacteria which jell boiled milk into dahee or not Amritdhari. Boiling milk is redundant. It's already been pasturized - heated more efficiantly to kill bacteria than could be reproduced in the home. It only needs to be heated in the Karahee to the level desired for making dahee or drinking. BTW I mostly use soymilk. And no i don't make it myself (but my mother used to- before there was a market for it when it was not produced commerically). I use dairy very sparingly. For years and Years I was completely vegan, not even using leather shoes etc. There is a dairy I visited a couple times not far from my home. Cows are fed cotton seed one of the most heavily sprayed with pestiside crops. (Pestisides are retained in the butter fat of milk.) Each cow has a magnet surgically placed in the first of it's 4 stomach to attract the peices of baling wire and other metallic debris and keep it from moving through the other stomachs. Cows are fed pink peptobismol tablets bigger than a roll of quarters to treat stomach aches. That's just the tip of the iceberg. It's rumoured milk is treated with bleach to whiten it because of the blood in it from diseased milk cows. Oh yuck now i've grossed my self out- I won't be able to touch milk for awhile.

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Singh · 08 Sep 2005

This thread has got me thinking............. What do I do?

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Scientific · 08 Sep 2005

Drinking milk is fine.Go for it Scientific

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Kulbir Singh · 08 Sep 2005

No matter what anyone else says but our Guru Sahibaan have accepted the use of milk and have called it one of the amrits. It is a known fact that is also stated in Gurbani that in the langar of Siri Guru Angad Dev jee, Mata Kheevi jee, Guru Sahib's Mahal, used to serve kheer that is made from milk. This kheer used to be full of ghee too. Researchers can say whatever they want to say about milk but for Gursikhs it is established that milk, ghee, sugar and aata are acceptable things and very good things to eat since these have been specially accepted by Guru Sahib (these are ingredients of degh). Doctors can say whatever they want to say about ghee i.e. it increases cholesterol etc but Gursikhs who japp Naam know that without ghee, Naam abhyaas is harder to do. Consuming ghee (gheo) helps in japping Naam and otherwise too keeps our body strong. Memoirs of a Bengali Freedom Fighter Drink as much milk as you can. A well-known Bengali freedom fighter wrote his memoirs after serving many years in the notorious prison of Kala Paani. Kala Paani was the prison in Andaman Nicobar Islands and this prison had majority of Sikh and Bengali freedom fighters during the early 1900s. Singhs of that time and before were known for their good eating habits and this is one reason why they were strong. Singhs used to drink buckets of milk everyday. The Gora officer heard that Singhs of Punjab can drinks bowls of ghee (gheo) at one time and bucket of buffalo milk in one shot. He could not believe it and when he expressed doubt over this, Singhs in the Kala Paani jail challenged him to test them. The Bengali freedom fighter writes that the Firangi (Gora) officer ordered a bucket of milk and one of the singhs moved forward and drank the whole bucket within moments, without stopping to take a breath. After drinking one bucket, he offered to drink another one. The Firangi officer was very surprised. All this talk about not drinking milk is non-sense and definitely a Western influence. Singhs must drink milk as it makes our body strong. Singhs must consume gheo since this too makes our body strong and keeps disease away. Don't listen to Goray. Guru Sahib has promised that if a Singh gets up at amritvela, does ishnaan and then does simran, his mind and body would remain diseaseless. So who else do we need to listen to? To hell with doctors. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Gandalf · 08 Sep 2005

Kulbir Singh...The problem with milk is how it is produced today (i.e. in factory farms that treat cows like machinery and not as a living being). 500 years ago milk may have been pure because the method of producing that milk did not pollute the milk, and animals were treated with respect. Certainly someone like yourself, who promotes a bibeki lifestyle who wants to eat food that you consider is pure, can see that the production of milk today results in 2 things that go against sikhi: 1.) Impure milk contaminated with hormones, pesticides, disease and bacteria. 2.) Torture of animals, which in some cases is worse than death (since the animals are in a constant state of pain/suffering). How can you promote milk drinking after hearing that? How is that in line with your definition of Sikhi? If you want to drink milk that like you say is "one of the amrits", buy a cow, raise it, feed it and milk it yourself. If you continue to drink milk that treats animals so poorly and is so contaminated, you might as well eat meat and drop the bibeki lifestyle as well. If you have seen "The Simpsons" episode where Fat Tony has a milk farm operation that uses rats to produce milk, you will understand when I say that that is what reminds me of today's milk. Also Kulbir Singh...your statement that milk is one of the amrits...where is that in gurbani...because if that is the case, then why do people protest the picture of the cow being milked into a Bata. Someone asked if organic milk is fine - the definition of organic milk means that you don't inject the cows with anything. The cows still get treated poorly. (Why drink milk if that is the case?) [%sig%]

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

reply · 08 Sep 2005

>So who else do we need to listen to? To hell with doctors. Bole so nihal! Guru ji says the mind to remain nissal (relaxed); the Lord himself and no other determines who shall die. [%sig%]

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Common Sense · 08 Sep 2005

Kulbir Singh, Degh suppose to be served as parshaad, not as a full meal. I hope you don't live strictly on Degh and Cow Milk. Did Guru Sahib use bleached atta and refined sugar? Would you call the milk and ghee that's available now to be same as the milk and ghee that Guru Sahib consumed? I just hope that you don't go on to drink contaminated water thinking that if Guru Sahib can drink "water" so can I. LOOK AT THE FULL PICTURE BEFORE MAKING RASH STATEMENT. Vaheguru works through these Researchers to help you! Listen to them sometimes. We have been given this brain to process information and decide for ourselves based on the facts of the time.

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Kulbir Singh · 08 Sep 2005

Gandalf / Common Sense, Perhaps, as you have explained, in the changed circumstances, it is better to consume milk from your own cow. I personally want to do this but I don’t know when Guru Sahib will do kirpa in terms of enabling us to get a cow. In the meantime, I will try to shift to organic milk after consultation with sangat here. Having said that, I don’t think it is wise to totally give up milk. The option is to either give up milk and then eat supplements to get Vitamin B12 or drink milk and don’t get supplements. I go for the second option. Thanks for the information. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Singh · 08 Sep 2005

where can we obtain the natural source for b12 if milk is not ok to consume? [%sig%]

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

good idea · 08 Sep 2005

If someone finds a source to obtain organic milk in toronto please do inform the sangat on this forum. That would be great.

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

charanjeev singh · 08 Sep 2005

waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh These cows are going under unhumane practices through various methods. I am of the opinion that if Gurmukh Pyareh (truly Gurmukh Pyareh) were to drink the milk from these cows, even the udhaar (emancipation, parupkaar) of that cow occurs. On this note; i would like to say that maybe a Gursikhs who is always a parupkaar towards all, is perhaps doing a sewa for these animals by drinking their milk. I do not know what is right and what is wrong. The rang of the Guru is magnificent. Surely the cows whom provided the milk for the langar are greatly fortunate with this sewa written on their mastak. Truly, it might be wrong to take this sewa away from them. Afterall, the Guru and the Gurus' sikhs are protecter of the meek and oppressed. The biggest sewa is surely a parupkaar. Perhaps their milk is their sewa. The Gurus Darbaar is not an ordainary darbaar jeeos. Emancipacation occurs in such abundance, we have no clue. bhul chuk mauf karna waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Gandalf · 08 Sep 2005

Charanjeev Singh...using your logic I could say that a Gursikh who is always a parupkaar towards all would do seva for an animal by eating its flesh. ....a few notes to all you milk drinkers... 1.) I got the following from a web site.. "Oh yes...organic milk. The healthiest milk from the healthiest cow is naturally loaded with lactoferrins, immunoglobulins, and growth hormones. Horizon's organic milk contains animal fat and cholesterol, dioxins, and bacteria. The amount of somatic cells (pus) in organic milk is lower than milk from non-organic cows, but it's still dead white blood cells and dead bacteria. Ask yourself this question. Does organic human breast milk sound like a delicious drink for an adult human? Instinctively, most people know that there are substances in breast milk that are not intended for their adult bodies. Same goes for pig's milk and dog's milk. Same for cow's milk. "Some people may not be able to tolerate lactose, a milk sugar. One hundred percent of humans are allergic to casein, a milk protein. Eighty percent of the protein in Horizon's organic dairy products is casein, the same glue used to adhere a label to a bottle of beer. Eat casein and your body produces histamines, then mucous." 2.) Cows that produce Organic milk are still housed in milk farms where the conditions are deplorable. As per Canadian Health standards, Organic milk needs to meet certain standards regarding what is in the milk (i.e. hormones etc). There is no conditions on animal treatment/abuse. The end product is all that matters. In the case, the end is still not justified by the means. 3.) Kulbir SIngh you say that "The option is to either give up milk and then eat supplements to get Vitamin B12 or drink milk and don’t get supplements. I go for the second option. " This is somewhat selfish (i.e. I get my nutrition, but at an animal's expense, and nutrition).There are other options for obtaining vitamin B12 (e.g. nutritional yeast, soya milk, uncooked fruits and vegetables). I know ppl who have been vegan for many years and do not take supplements. 4.) I was also reading earlier that the incidence of cancer is closely related to the rate that milk is consumed (based on a study of different societies). 5.) We all agree that we are all equal with all of god's creation. No other animal in nature drinks the milk of another animal (except humans - because Milk boards say so). You don't see a lion going up to a zebra and drinking it's milk do you? 6.) If you must drink milk and you use the health reason, the human body digests goat's milk (because it is the closest to human milk). If you do your research on this you will find that milk is actually detrimental to your long term health (because humans are not meant to drink another animal's milk and because milk is full of impurities). 7.) If you give up all dairy, you lose 5 to 7 lbs within the first 2 weeks because your body releases excess mucus/pus built up by drinking milk. Just to name a few, milk is linked with causing/enhancing/contributing to the following: Arthritis, acne, allergies, colic, asthma, cancer Again, you are what you eat!!

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Princess · 08 Sep 2005

You can get organic milk from Longo's and also other store I can't remember name right now but that opens 24 hours. I used to get from both these stores. I also heard there is a store in Orangeville where they sell organic milk bag only for $4:00 on every Tuesday. I will find soon and post it for sangat.

Re: Is drinking milk bibek?

Sukhdev Singh · 11 Sep 2005

VaheGuruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheGuruJeeKeeFateh I didn't really want talk on this issue but I felt I had to say something, as some of the stuff said previously is way misleading. There is alot of youth that visit this forum who would like to keep bibek and I would like them to have a well-balanced view on this subject before they commit to something. I am not going say whether supermarket milk is bibeki or not but will state the facts as known to me. The topic did go a bit offcourse as posters like Gandalf were promoting the idea of no milk drinking at all even if bibeki or not. This is not according to Gurmat. Milk has been integral part of the Sikh diet ever since the Guru's time. Gurbanee mentions milk, Kheer & Ghee made from milk is a vital ingredient for Degh. As for the thoughts put forward by Gandalf, I think they are from someone who is against cruelty to animals. This is not a bad thought but I think this overclouds his/her assumptions on milk. Any main stream scientist would be able to counter most of his/her arguments on milk. If you use organic milk then most of the arguments do not apply as only organic feed is given (unlike other cows, which led to BSE), no use of antibiotics/steroids unless for illness, no use of single pens, etc. Allergies caused by milk occur in other foods too like wheat so do we tell everyone to stop eating Atta? Bacteria in Milk are not all bad. Friendly bacteria in the stomach are required for a healthy digestive system. Yoghurt has plenty of this and is considered one of the best health foods it is often called natures antibiotic. Guru Jee & GurSikhs have used yoghurt to wash their hair with. The argument that most of the people on this planet do not drink milk does not hold weight for a Sikh perspective, as most of the people on this planet are not vegetarian and have other scources. However the most astonishing statement made by Gandalf has to be the one regarding Vitamin B12, he wrote "There are other options for obtaining vitamin B12 (e.g. nutritional yeast, Soya milk, uncooked fruits and vegetables)." I don't really think he/she knows what they are talking about here any half decent doctor will tell you that you can not get B12 from uncooked fruits and vegetables. As for the nutritional yeast or Soya milk B12 would have been added & therefore these are not natural scources. Before I go any further to prove that I am not one sided in this argument. I would like to tell you a bit about my background. I stopped taking dairy products about 5 years ago this was initially because of health reasons but then carried on without them because I felt it was not necessary. Then about a year ago I had a blood test which showed that I was deficient in Vitamin B12. I was told that some of the problems that I was getting could be linked to B12. I can't say for certain that my problems were because of the lack B12 but it opened my eyes. I didn't even know what B12 was before the blood test what concerned me more was the fact that this lack could cause permanent damage to nerves. This got me thinking that there had to be natural scource for B12 for a Sikh and I could only find milk as this scource. This reinforced the idea in my mind that milk had to be a raw material. Now moving on to the subject of bibeki Milk. We first need to look at the concept of bibek. Nothing is 100% bibek except for Akal Purak but this does not give us the excuse to not exercise bibek. As a Gursikh we should be trying our best to achieve as much bibek as possible. To not to try at all is not a quality of a Gursikh. In terms of food bibek we know that we should strive to eat Amrit everyday so we prepare our food reciting Naam/Gurbanee from raw materials. Now there are 2 categories of raw materials. First are the items that can be washed & cleaned with water i.e. Vegetables, Fruit, Daals, various beans etc Second are items that can not washed with water i.e. milk, ghee, oil, grinded wheat, semolina, Besan, Sugar etc. This second category needs more attention as this is where joot or other additions can be made if not handled by an amritdhari. This is the category were milk falls under. Even when speaking to GurSikhs in India some agree milk is a raw ingredient but for them the issue is the handling of the milk. Even the Tapoban GurSikhs think it is not right to consume Khula Dudh in India as we've heard many stories of how they get milk in india, i.e. people not cleaning hands, using dirty containers, spitting, adding items etc. Every time I've been to India I've always got my milk from Amritdharies with their own herd because even in India injections are extensively used on Cows/Buffaloes. Having said this there is only so much you can do even in India. Only a handful of Gursikhs I know that make there own Ghee, Atta, Oil, Gurr(sugar) but they still think its OK for other GurSikhs to use these items as they still consider them as raw materials. These are standards they have set for themselves in that environment. Here in the U.K the milk is extracted hygienically through machines so some make think it is OK to use. This is however an Individual choice as there is no limit to bibek. Everyone has to look at their circumstances & make a choice we have to take steps that increase our bhagtee. This also means we have to look after our bodies and avoid anything that may cause harm and affect your bhagtee. Having said all that I don't want to say that this is wrong or this is right. For those who do not wish to consume milk then I would strongly recommend you take B12 supplements (to some this too might not be proper bibek). However if you are thinking of immigrating to India in the next few years then it might not be necessary. I would like to also mention that deficiency in B12 does not occur overnight but over years. For some it might be 5 years others 15 years everyone is different but as you get older the need is greater for all types of vitamins. Lastly I would like ask for forgiveness in anything that has gone against Gurmat. I don't really have any real gyan these are only thoughts conjured up in my little brain but my intention was to give a balanced picture. Bhull Chuck Maaf VaheGuruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheGuruJeeKeeFateh [%sig%]