Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Has 1984 taken over sikhism

Has 1984 taken over sikhism

Mr J S S · 05 Sep 2005

I have just started to get in to sikhism but everywhere i go all i hear about is 1984. If I start questioning about 1984 i get threatened with physical violence. when i start asking about the gurus it always goes back to guru gobind singh ji and then 1984. Wasnt 1984 all about a political game that spilled over in to the real world that caused untold damage between sikhs and hindus. say whenever i ask anyone a question they come out with single line quotes and cross refer them to the situation at present and 1984. Single line quotes about why khalisthan should exist, yet when the whole Shabad is said there is a total difference in meaning..... I am not sure yet I am so confused at what most preach about 1984 and the sikh religion as a whole. When i speak about 1984 i get told about revenge and hatred... yet when I speak of Shri Guru Granth Shaib jee there is a total contradiction of what I get told. I mean to cause no offence but there seems to be a great leaning over to what happened in 1984 and constant linkage of Bani to 1984. I was told sikhism was about being humble, a man of god, being on a level playing field with everyone else. That there is no creed, no difference, no barriers yet monay get to do no sewa, if u not amritdhari u cant do no sewa.... So seems to me the religion is being led down different paths... What is the right way? Bhul chuk marf karoo

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

Lionking · 05 Sep 2005

Where have you read about Revenge and hatred? Yes Sikhs are seeking justice putting the guilty on trail - but no bitterness. Want to learn about Sikhs and SIKHI and SIkh History go allaboutsikhs.com

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

star · 05 Sep 2005

to say 1984 was a politiocal game is like saying the jewish holocaust was just a game. Any holocaust whatever the number remains that. the threatening and violence you face shows the people you are mixing with are not capable of holding a talk and hence you should mix with sangat who are more open minded. the indian media and mainstream khalistani medias in usa and canada heavily relieing on self made khalistani leaders have created a monster out of a molehill. Sikhs and punjabi hindus do not have problems, in the 1980s the gov agencies went round gunning hindus. The problem sikhs have is with the centre of delhis handling of sikh issues. forget about people singh concentrate on bani yourself. if you are confused singh then you need to understand the exact reasons of your confusion. Stick to bani nitnem and you will not go wrong. if somebody hates and becomes vengeful let that be their issue, heal yourself and the environment with meditation. monai get to do seva in most gurdwaras as far as i see. forget about the ways. Your way is your own jopurney to God. forget about people. There is no family, no community, no person who will go with you when you depart from this khand beera.

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

Jagjit singh · 05 Sep 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I think it depends on your sangat. For some 1984 is a part of their sikhi, and building a Jeevan and Seva is the bigger part. For other political Singhs, 1984 is all their sikhi. Essentially 1984 it not something we can ignore. Genocide is Sikh is a real issue. However there is much more to Gurmat. Gurmat does not believe or accept revenge, it believes in truth and justice. If you seek souls who are more Gurbani, abyass focussed, you will appreciate deeper aspects of sikhi. Everyone is on their own path, and as such they all have their own groups of like minded people. You probably just need to spend time with other groups aswell, and then you stick to the one you are most comfortable with. I am not concerned about anyone focussing on 1984, because it just shows their have a Sikhi Spirit, and Kaum da Dard. I would be more worried by those who choose to think nothing has happened since 1978. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

AS · 05 Sep 2005

Excellent response Jagjit Singh ;-)

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

ekta · 05 Sep 2005

1984 is a gullughara and will remain part of sikhi 4ever.

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

Mr J S S · 05 Sep 2005

I support you in what you say Jagjit bhai. I do see 1984 as a major event that should be remembered but it is an event which will never be bigger than Sikhi, I feel that this is what is happening. You see I am a beleiver in that we are all men of god, and I do not like distinguishing between one man or the other by what path they follow.... but by the pyaar they inhibit for the almighty. Ik Onkar.. What I do not like is the constant hindu bashing which has been the result of 1984..... Whenever I ask many about what has happened that is what i begin to here.. and many of the youth in Sikhi portray such views.. Believe it or not they are not the bigger evil that sikhi faces..... moreso sikhi faces the same sorts of evils it faced when Sikhi was being created.... Hindus and Sikhi share many philosophies.... which is why i get confused when people bash them constantly bhul chuk marf karoo

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

D.T.A Minister · 05 Sep 2005

Mr J.s.s i totally agree with what YOU are saying its true how sikhism is just based on 1984 ---------- not all people like this, but majority of them are!! many people Turn to 1984 in an argument... which is totally dyabolical from my view. what happened then was a tragedy but we must not forget where sikhism has came from... i dont mean to offend anyone but sikhism is about being humble, a man of god, being on a level playing field with everyone else. in addition to this i would like to ask.... Who thinks that 1984 - in the centre point of sikhism and why? D.T.A Minister.com

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

a · 05 Sep 2005

I do not think we are saying its the centre point, but these ppl are still alive today, for some it is still fresh in their minds, its not that we cant forgive or forget but forgiving was never the issue, forgetting is not possible if it is in ur face even today. Sikhs are still suffering, sikhs have not got justice. If sikhs are so concerned about other sikhs in India who still suffer then that does not mean that it makes it a centre point in sikhi. Sikhism can be known from reading Guru Granth Sahib Ji not the events of 1984. But if u dont like ppl talking abt it then its like asking ppl not to talk abt sept 11, it is still fresh in ppls minds an dppl still suffer. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

karm · 05 Sep 2005

jss and dta minister are you the same person???????????????????? sounds like it [%sig%]

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

RoopKaur · 05 Sep 2005

>I mean to cause no offence but there seems to be a great leaning over to what happened in 1984 and constant linkage of Bani to 1984. I was told sikhism was about being humble, a man of god, being on a level playing field with everyone else. That there is no creed, no difference, no barriers yet monay get to do no sewa, if u not amritdhari u cant do no sewa.... So seems to me the religion is being led down different paths...< Once you are a Sikh of Guru ji and follow his rehit, than no their is no other creed, caste, difference accept for Sikhi. There are certain sevas in Sikhi which only rehitvaan Sikhs can do, it has nothing to do with hate or egotism, but Guru ji has set it up so that these sevas must only be done by Sikhs of guru ji. Our religion IS being led down a different path these days, when people start becoming "moderate" and "modern", where they want to change the rehit maryada of Sikhi to fit the western ideas of political correctness and acceptance. It is most important in this time of kalyug for Sikhs to realise that we must not lose our nyaarapan, our uniqueness. As for 1984, it was a big event, which led to the Kharku movement of the 80's and 90's. Although it is not all that Sikhi is, this event shows us a lot about what kind of waters the Panth is treading in these times. The wounds from these events are deep and bloody, and it will take some time for them to heal. It is only from our history that we can learn and see where the panth is going wrong, but sadly, it seems today that instead of trying to figure out why and how this happened to the Sikhs, we are more interested in going to parties, having the latest fashions and hairstyles or drinking and drugs. I think it is time we analyse this event in more detail and stop history from repeating itself.

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 06 Sep 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh har har naam salaaheeai sach kaar kamaavai || Praise the Name of the Lord, Har, Har, and practice truthful deeds. dhoojee kaarai lagiaa fir jonee paavai || Attached to other deeds, one is consigned to wander in reincarnation. naam rathiaa naam paaeeai naamae gun gaavai || Attuned to the Name, one obtains the Name, and through the Name, sings the Lord's Praises. gur kai sabadh salaaheeai har naam samaavai || Praising the Word of the Guru's Shabad, he merges in the Lord's Name. sathigur saevaa safal hai saeviai fal paavai ||19|| Service to the True Guru is fruitful and rewarding; serving Him, the fruits are obtained. ||19|| Bhai Sahib Mr J S S Jee, The 1984 event is what grew Sikhi’s strength; it triggered a bolt through every Sikh in the world. If the Gursikhs in both years 1978 and 1984 didn’t make a stand for our Sikhi then the Hindus would have forcefully took Sikhi away from every Sikh living in India. Sikhi would have died then and there but just as Raavan caused injustice by kidnapping Rama’s wife and said “no warrior is equal to me”, he suffered at the end for his arrogance and died forgetting Vaheguru Jee, events similar to this proceeded throughout the other Yugs and then in Kaljug along comes another evil doer named Gurbachan Singh whom used disrespectful language against Satguru Jee and made fun of Gursikhi. “Khalsa shall not hear anyone denouncing the Guru, but put them to the sword” (Rehatnama) Then when Gursikhs had heard of this some of which were Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale Jee, Bhai Fauja Singh Jee and others. So Bhai Fauja Singh Jee and other Singhs went to this fake Nirankari guru (Gurbachan Singh) to peacefully discuss this matter but just as they arrived to that place they approached a police officer and told him that they want to meet with Gurbachan Singh. The police officer then told them to wait there as he went inside to ask Gurbachan Singh on there behalf but instead after half an hour he and other Hindus ran out with rifles and fired and throw stones at these innocent Gursikhs. Thirteen of these Gursikhs were killed and seventy injured. There was no justice from the Indian authorities just the Gursikhs were blamed as a verdict. So, as a result, Vaheguru Jee sent a saintly person named Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale Jee to the war in 1984 as he and the other warriors destroyed the Hindus arrogance just as Vaheguru Jee sent other saintly persons in the other Yugs to destroy evil doers. Gurbachan Singh was killed by Bhai Ranjit Singh Jee. India, Punjab still has to be punished for shooting a bullet into Guru Granth Sahib Jee but Vaheguru Jee may do this through a natural disaster. mai oulhageeaa oulhagee ham shhoroo thhaarae || I am the lowest slave of Your slaves; I am Your most humble servant. Sikhi is all about being Humble, as soon as the age of Kalyug arrived the world fell into differencing every human being with each other since it dwelled in caste but the only distinct beings on this world are Guru Jee’s Sikhs. Guru Jee says that the Khalsa is in his own image. Khalsa shall not steal. Khalsa shall not speak evil of others. Khalsa shall be the devotee of One (Guru Granth Sahib Jee). Khalsa shall always speak the truth, never tell lies. Khalsa shall have one caste only; the high and low shall become equal. Khalsa shall have one Langar. Khalsa shall not go near another’s woman. Khalsa shall not take bribery. The soul of the Khalsa shall be so pure, that he will regard gold and diamonds as dirt. Khalsa doesn’t have enemies but thinks of them as his/hers friend. If whoever goes to war with hatred and dies he/she has lost the battle but if that person goes to war with love and dies he/she is fortunate as he/she is victorious. This is what Khalsa Raj will be like, the world where in now is corrupt the five mighty warriors lust, anger, worldly attachments, ego and greed rule the earth. However Khalsa Raj appears it will come with peace; humans willingly will convert to a Sikh as they will know it’s the True religion. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

Bhopinder Singh · 06 Sep 2005

J SS Sarkari touts will want us to forget about 1984 and they will give us gurbani reasons ,we are humble people.Yes it is the biggest point in Sikh history as it bought me and many like me to sikhism , it was like a revolution. To me it seems like it is still happening and is not a event of history.It reminded us of ourselves and the mistake we made in1947.The downfall of sikhism or rehit and whatnot are the sideaffects of the mistake of 1947. I will quote a very humble sikh who spent 20 years in jail for the cause of freedom kutch hakim sehar da jalim se kutch menoo maran da shounk be see How can we forget thousands of singhs who laid down their lives for the cause of 1984. How can we since their has been no accountability for the genocide of 1984 JUST HOW CAN WE? Yet touts have the courage to come on our forums and say this . When are they going to be humble since gurbani teaches that and also all humanity is equal and all should get justice and punishment accordingly and same goes for freedom.

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

Sitara · 06 Sep 2005

----- What I do not like is the constant hindu bashing which has been the result of 1984..... ----- Hear hear! You are probably the very first Sikh on this board I have seen say this. Just when I was about to loose faith in the Sikh community. Thank you. Sitara (the andha pathar Poojak)

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

Harjas Kaur · 06 Sep 2005

[quote]What I do not like is the constant hindu bashing which has been the result of 1984..... [/quote] This is a joke. No one here is bashing Hindu's. This is not like where one hears constant sardarji jokes or shows popular bollywood movies portraying all Sikhs as terrorists. -To hold radical Hindu parties responsible which committed atrocities against Sikh people including a governmental policy of genocide and torture is not "bashing" the Hindu faith. -To distinguish Sikh practices from Hindu practices does not "bash" the Hindu faith. -To expose government sponsored groups which have insulted Sikh faith by intermingling Hinduism with Sikhi, or have murdered Singhs is not "Hindu bashing." Where is the Hindu "bashing" since 1984? Awareness of reality is not Hindu "bashing." It may have become world knowledge in 1984 that oppression of Sikhism was occuring but it was happening in 1970's and did not subside until late 1990's. Seems to me like a whole lot of Sikh bashing is what is going on here. Not only does the sangat have to deal with genocide without justice, but also blame and callous calls for "sensitivity to Hindu's" over these decades of political outrage. What about sensitivity to Sikh victims? What about simple acknowledgement that genocide and hatred and murder and torture and rapes and false imprisonment of Sikhs have occured over the last 20 years? This would go a long way to appeasing hard feelings people have. Before there can be any reconciliation, there must first be JUSTICE! Without this, there will always be tension. Can you at least see why? [%sig%]

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

Parminder Singh · 06 Sep 2005

never heard of anybody complain about talking about mughal atrocities. indians love to talk about how cruel the mughals were but if you bring up 1984 people get offended like someone insulted their mom (indira gandhi maybe?) dhadhi waaran are a part of sikhi. we remember our martyrs. More sikhs were martyred for khalistan than for india's independence and we never hear the end of bhagat singh and uddham singh, so if we remember current shaheeds why are you so worried? you should be mad that sikh in india always talk about the mughals and bhagat singh too then. if you feel that 1984 is central to sikhi right now then go fight 1947 being cetral to sikhi in india also. 1984 is central to sikhi because it is not resolved and the wounds are still open. sikh will always remember their martyrs and i'm sure sikh who lived through the mughal period always talked about mughal atrocities just as we talk about atrocities which are happening during our lifetimes. get over it. fateh! [%sig%]

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

singh khalistani · 07 Sep 2005

generally speaking sometimes some sikhs start off good to learn but can get carry away from 1984 towards a strange kind of hate that starts from frustration anger that nothing was done by indian authorities instead having instigated genocides. Then while we hear of lakhs of sikhs ritualistically slaughtered while the rest of the world looked on then there is a rosy cosy picture of india ram raj and hindus flexing around with money power and claiming punjab is in peace when it has been destroyed. This hate needs to be understood and can only be changed with gurbani. No one councils any human out there to handle it when they see pictures of bodies that have iron marks, stomaches ripped out, scalps torn off, bodies lieingon the ground stretching out an extra metre from rolled out bones. Nothing in the world trains a humans reactions to what we thought was a civilised world is actually callous and barbarically looking on. In my early days i hated sometimes the hate smoked out towards hindus when it was really aimed at the police and army attack. It was only when i realised that gurbani is the only thing that can help control that anger the feeling of helplessness that we could do nothing the whole world just wanted to turn a blind eye. the feeleings are strong for most sikhs but they should not lead to hating anyone. I think you feel way to defensive about hindus and this sikh hindu bhai bhai thing. Sikhs are bhais of every religion and race.

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

Jagjit singh · 07 Sep 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, fundamental to Sikhi is recognising the human race as one. I personally think sikhs are far more open to views and opinions of non-sikhs that most other religions. Yes some sikhs may develop a hatred for Hindus because of the 1894 thing, but clearly Baba Jarnail Singh ji, Bhai Sukhdev Singh babbar and many other leaders of the movement did not. I do have to say, I have never seen Hindu-bashing? This is a completely unjustified comment. Instead I can say, popular words during the 80`s and 90`s such as "Sikh extremist", "Sikh terrorist", or the bollywood protrayal of the "sikh comedian or joker" is evidence of Sikh bashing that has happened. Anyone who is a Naam abyassi does not hate anyone or anything, the emotions is completely against the emotions of Naam. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji kefateh

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 07 Sep 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh Sikhs do not have hate for anyone but if they do this hate is only dispelled when an immense amount of Naam Bhagti is done. vavaa vair n kareeai kaahoo || WAWWA: Do not harbor hatred against anyone. Furthermore, Gursikhs don’t have hatred and are not meant to have it as it is stated in Gurbani, Gursikhs follow whatever Guru Jee has told them. If a Sikh was asked what he/she had thought of other religions, one in particular Christianity the Sikh would reply with “If whatever religion you are in this case Christianity than be a good Christian or if a Muslim be a good Muslim, be great at whatever you are and love God to the utmost level”. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

Amo d · 08 Sep 2005

The thing i dont undrstabd is why do some sikhs still hate hindus?? i know couple of people are like that but i have never questioned them. its true that you cant forget what happened that year but hatred does not come under sikhism

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

shining path warrior · 10 Sep 2005

i think it might be to do with sikhi declining in punjab after 1984 and hindu radicals gainin ground in india and ocupied punjab. I might get cussed down for this but i think punjabis in general have this trip over other indians like their better kind of thing just like th way gore have over punjabis in western countries. This better feeling could be because punjabis were fiercely independant in nature, strong minded with warrior attributes before and when sikh arrived. then other things like punjabis being tall, broad featured and light skinned with an invincbl lik attitude. Then most people not just sikhs woul consider hinduism to be mythical, the irony is here we have a mythical religion somehow making inroads into sikhism by the lapse of sikh youth towards athiesm. On the other hand gujratis maratis and delhi hindus seem to have issue with punjabi sikhs. Trieing to find out why i can only think they must fel insecure about punjabis, but they also tend to look down on us.

Re: Has 1984 taken over sikhism

nimma · 11 Sep 2005

it is weird if hindus are getting beaten somewhere i have found chardi kala singhs to say stuff like perhaps its because of 1984 and hindus attacking other groups that they are now getting it back. But when the london train bombings happened then somehow our own chardi kala singhs seem to feel the english christian gentlemen are innocently massacred by muslims with no trace to iraq palestine conflicts. The same kind of backgrounds are not compared im like why be picky? perhaps we should stop looking upto chardi kala singhs and decide things on gurmat only. either be one way or the other way. but personally as far as i am concerned no one should be hated its wrong.