'Gurmat Bibek' & Khalsa bana
Harpartap Singh · 06 Sep 2005
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
Does Bhai Randhir Singh ji mean in this book that a Khalsa, should also wear Khalsa bana all the time after having taken Amrit? If so, should Singhs not wear pajama's over kachheray?
Could someone from the AKJ who has read the Bhai Sahib's book please elaborate?
Thanks
Re: 'Gurmat Bibek' & Khalsa bana
GURBAR AKAAAAL!!! · 06 Sep 2005
Ask an elder Jatha member. They would have lived during the time of Bhai Sahib and can give you a realistic, truthful answer.
Re: 'Gurmat Bibek' & Khalsa bana
Harpartap Singh · 07 Sep 2005
Thanks for the text in Engliish veer/bhenji .
However, my question is still this: does an Amritdhari have to have wear Khalsa bana (apart from the Panj Kakkars) all the time once he/she hhas taken Amrit?
What is the Canadian Tapoban view on this? The UK Singhs are not sure...
Re: 'Gurmat Bibek' & Khalsa bana
Kulbir Singh · 07 Sep 2005
Our stand on Baana is well known. Gursikhs in Toronto, fully promote Baana and believe that baana is part of Gurmat Rehit. To wear pants and other Western attire is against Gurmat modesty. If one has a problem and cannot wear baana at work e.g. Singhs working for military or police, then it may be okay but otherwise, it is our duty to wear bana at all times.
Many children and youth here wear baana to school, colleges and universities. Many Singhs and Singhnees wear baana at work. The weakness in is always inside us. If we become strong inside, then no one (goray, kaalay, cheenay) can say anything. The feeling that one gets wearing Guru ka Baana is not describable. One feels the presence of Siri Dasmesh jee all the time. And Siri Dasmesh jee too has to keep laaj of his Gursikh who is in baana and otherwise is a good Gursikh.
Kulbir Singh
Re: 'Gurmat Bibek' & Khalsa bana
search for tat · 07 Sep 2005
what is your view harpratap?
Are the tight jeans and T-shirt that you wore at the Never Forget 1984 march in London part of khalsa bana or Taksali Bana?
Re: 'Gurmat Bibek' & Khalsa bana
Harpartap Singh · 07 Sep 2005
lol
search for tat you are a real joker - full of krodh/hatred
May Guru ji bless you with shanti
I wasn't even at the 1984 March! You must have confused me with someone else :o)
Those who know me know what I wear when I am not at work in the office - ask the 'Tapoban' Singhs from East London
Re: 'Gurmat Bibek' & Khalsa bana
search for tat · 07 Sep 2005
no krodh or hatred here! just asking the same question you did?
so in 2004, you was not at the 1984 march?
Re: 'Gurmat Bibek' & Khalsa bana
me me me me me me !! · 07 Sep 2005
Harpartap Singh looks smart in a bana! I have seen him in bana. Keep it up Singh!!
Re: 'Gurmat Bibek' & Khalsa bana
search for tat · 07 Sep 2005
geezzz all I did was his opinion on his own question..........
Re: 'Gurmat Bibek' & Khalsa bana
Harpartap Singh · 08 Sep 2005
'search for tat'
your intention was to launch a personal attack
my intention was obvious - find out what real followers of Bhai Saahib Randhir Singh ji believe on this point
I have not formed an opinion either way - my actions speak for themselves (Kulbir Singh's post is close to the mark)
Last year, I did attend the march and wore an Amnesty International t-shirt which I thought was appropriate and I do not have any tight jeans :o)
Re: 'Gurmat Bibek' & Khalsa bana
Kulbir Singh · 08 Sep 2005
Excellent point N. Singh jeeo. Bhai Amrik Singh the elder son of Sant Kartar Singh proudly used to wear baana to Khalsa College Amritsar. In those days, all the youth was inclined towards Naxlites and Communists. It was great courage on part of Bhai Sahib to wear full baana in college.
We all know that the reward for this hardwork was immense. Within days, AISSF overshadowed all other student bodies and Bhai Amrik Singh who was the president of this organization, rose to high political levels. With Guru Sahib's kirpa he attained shaheedi in 1984. Great life!
We should learn from Bhai Amrik Singh jee and adopt baana in our life. Gurmat Baana is part of Khalsa Rehit. At least let us start with the resolution to wear only baana to Gurdwara Sahib and when meeting Singhs. It is highly inappropriate to wear pants and shirts when meeting up Gursikhs or going in the hazoori of Guru Sahib.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: 'Gurmat Bibek' & Khalsa bana
Kulbir Singh · 08 Sep 2005
Naxalites were militant communists who wanted to bring Inqlaab (revolution) to India by force. The Naxalite movement in Punjab was crushed in the late seventies and many of the remaining Naxalites joined the Sikh movement.
Kulbir Singh