Forum
Ganesh drinking milk?
Ganesh drinking milk?
Kaur · 07 Sep 2005
There is a question which is haunting me from last 10 years when in Tronto
area, ganesh moorte was drinking a lot of milk.
My fellow sikh questioned me, why Sikhs are are saying
ganesh can not drink milk where as Bhagat Dhan jatt used to make thakar drink a lot of milk?
only serious reponses please.
[%sig%]
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Sep 2005
GURU ARJUN JI in his Shabad in GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB States that Bhagta Dhanan ji achieved WAHEGURU....through NAAM SIMRAN and BHGATEE just as Bhagat Ravidass Ji, Bhagat kabir J, Bhagat namdev Ji, Bhagat Sain Ji, and all other Bhagats.
This SAME story is also written about Bhagat NAMDEV JI..and It si FALSE. Read the thread on bahagt namdev and Idol Worship on this Forum.
BOTH stories about Bhagat dhana ji and Bhagat namdev Ji are FALSE. They BOTH PROVE through their GURBANI thta they are NOT IDOL WORSHIPPERS but worship WAHEGURU ONLY.
Whcih would YOU beleive..Kaur Bhen JI..GURU ARJUN Ji, GURU RAMDASS JI, Bhgat Dhanna Ji and Bhagta Namdev Ji...oR whoever told that False TALE ?? is entirely up to you.
Guur Granth ji is available everywhere for you to check.
Jarnail Singh.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Kaur · 07 Sep 2005
I know the ganesh moorte can not drink milk, in Toronto, the moorte was piped to drain milk. Is not there is shabad which says that the thakar-stone
drank the milk, only some Bhagat has to offer. Not an ordinary person.
Ajit kaur
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Harjas Kaur · 07 Sep 2005
I don't think the story is false. Miracles have occurred as well as fake things in many religions for centuries.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Mehtab Singh · 07 Sep 2005
The story about Ganesh ji drinking milk is true. There was a lot of debate about it back in September 1995 also when this happened all over the world. There were highly educated people supporting as well as opposing it as a divine miracle and/or a scientific phenomenon. At the Dubai Mandir, the idol of Ganesh accepted milk even from Arab Muslims. Other places where similar reports came from were Spain, obviously India and some other Asian countries. Didn't know it happened in Toronto as well.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Unscientific. · 08 Sep 2005
These idols are made of porous stone. On very hot periods - and the time these incidents happened it was a very hot summer - the stone gets very very dry. There is a process called capilleryaction - this is how liquids climb up very narrow tubes - and this is all that has happened here.
On a hot summers day someone has touched the idols mouth with some liquid in this case milk, and it has been 'sucked' up by the porous stone due to this capilleraction and low and behold the idol has drank milk, and the whole world goes crazy.
[%sig%]
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
aho aho · 08 Sep 2005
unscientific that explains my water dissapearing in the cup this summer and theres me thinkign it was some ghost sipping away bale bale
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
khalsa_force · 08 Sep 2005
Agreed, some years bak they hv shown all this on TV itself, tht it was all cause of STONE it was made of, capillary action is the reason.
************************************************************
Author: Unscientific.
Date: 09-08-05 04:45
These idols are made of porous stone. On very hot periods - and the time these incidents happened it was a very hot summer - the stone gets very very dry. There is a process called capilleryaction - this is how liquids climb up very narrow tubes - and this is all that has happened here.
On a hot summers day someone has touched the idols mouth with some liquid in this case milk, and it has been 'sucked' up by the porous stone due to this capilleraction and low and behold the idol has drank milk, and the whole world goes crazy.
***********************************************************
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Jagjit Singh · 08 Sep 2005
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, I remember when this happened at southall mandhir. Suddenly it got very busy. A few days later BBC, i think it was on newsnight, got some scientists to look at it. They went into great detail to prove it was a scam.
When BBC asked the hindu community leaders to comment on their findings, no one was available for comment.
In India, there is a specific scientific society which exposes conmen disguised as holy men. They have a documentary out called "santbusters".
In this they expose many fake holy men, mailnly concentrating on Sai baba, and black magic babas. There was no baba in a sikhi bana so far.
waheguru ji kekhalsa waheguruji ke fateh
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
lal killa · 08 Sep 2005
miracles can and do occur but in the case of the ganesh milk its just the stone drinking in hot weather nothing special just matter and logic bit of stone gets hot and drinks water, same will happen to porous stone in heatwave anywhere.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Sitara · 08 Sep 2005
This phenomenon of milk drinking deities is absolutely true. I along with many non-Hindus have witnessed this personally. The dismissive attitude displayed by Sikhs here is typical and their ‘scientific’ reasons are laughable to say the least.
Sikhs are so unwilling to accept this because they are so convinced that muti-pooja is futile ritual and that Hindus worship a ‘dead stone’ that when something like this happens they become bewildered.
Interestingly if a similar ‘miracle’ where to occur involving the SGGS, I wonder if Sikhs would display such a cynical outlook?
[%sig%]
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
manjh payara guru ko · 08 Sep 2005
i heard ganesh ride on mouse(chooha)shivji on bull and mata on sher(lion)and balak nath on pecock......... is it true?and how
[%sig%]
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
charanjeev singh · 08 Sep 2005
Lets say, just lets say, the statue did drink milk. So? How is that in any way going to make your a saint?
Thats all. And no offence to anybody. Seriously.
bhul chuk mauf
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Mehtab Singh · 08 Sep 2005
[i]Author: manjh payara guru ko
Date: 09-08-05 16:22
i heard ganesh ride on mouse(chooha)shivji on bull and mata on sher(lion)and balak nath on pecock......... is it true?and how[/i]
Yes its true. How? I dunno, you gotta ask them.
[i]Author: Sitara
Date: 09-08-05 10:53
This phenomenon of milk drinking deities is absolutely true. I along with many non-Hindus have witnessed this personally.[/i]
Yes, like I said above, even Arab Muslims were surprised when the idol in the Mandir accepted milk from them. I think there were even cases where small idols at home also accepted milk, and this was brushed aside that an invisible film of milk falls down and the person thinks that the idol is accepting milk. I have still not understood the entire scientific perspective behind all this.
[i]Sikhs are so unwilling to accept this because they are so convinced that muti-pooja is futile ritual and that Hindus worship a ‘dead stone’ that when something like this happens they become bewildered.[/i]
Not bewildered, I think some of us are just disagreeing.
[i]Interestingly if a similar ‘miracle’ where to occur involving the SGGS, I wonder if Sikhs would display such a cynical outlook?[/i]
You say 'miracle', so do you also think the story about Ganesh ji's idol acepting milk is not true? And as for Dhann Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, there are loads of miracles already. There exist scientific explainations regarding Ganesh ji's milk-accepting news, but no scientific explainations about the miracles associated with Dhann Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. The latest one is about the recent Katrina hurricane where Dhann Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee was untouched by water. Besides, you cannot compare Dhann Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee to an idol. Dhann Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee is the word of God, and we Sikhs bow to Shabad Guru, not to an idol.
[u]This Shabad is by Guru Nanak Dev Ji in Raag Bihaagraa on Pannaa 556[/u]
mÚ 1 ]
ma 1 ||
First Mehl:
ihMdU mUly BUly AKutI jWhI ]
hi(n)dhoo moolae bhoolae akhuttee jaa(n)hee ||
The Hindus have forgotten the Primal Lord; they are going the wrong way.
nwrid kihAw is pUj krWhI ] AMDy guMgy AMD AMDwru ]
naaradh kehiaa s pooj karaa(n)hee || a(n)dhhae gu(n)gae a(n)dhh a(n)dhhaar ||
As Naarad instructed them, they are worshipping idols. They are blind and mute, the blindest of the blind.
pwQru ly pUjih mugD gvwr ]
paathhar lae poojehi mugadhh gavaar ||
The ignorant fools pick up stones and worship them.
Eih jw Awip fuby qum khw qrxhwru ]2]
ouhi jaa aap ddubae thum kehaa tharanehaar ||2||
But when those stones themselves sink, who will carry you across? ||2||
[u]This Shabad is by Guru Raam Daas Ji in Raag Malaar on Pannaa 1263[/u]
mlwr mhlw 4 ]
malaar mehalaa 4 ||
Malaar, Fourth Mehl:
ijqny jIA jMq pRiB kIny iqqny isir kwr ilKwvY ]
jithanae jeea ja(n)th prabh keenae thithanae sir kaar likhaavai ||
All the beings and creatures which God has created - on their foreheds, He has written their destiny.
hir jn kau hir dIn@ vfweI hir jnu hir kwrY lwvY ]1]
har jan ko har dheenh vaddaaee har jan har kaarai laavai ||1||
The Lord blesses His humble servant with glorious greatness. The Lord enjoins him to his tasks. ||1||
siqguru hir hir nwmu idRVwvY ]
sathigur har har naam dhrirraavai ||
The True Guru implants the Naam, the Name of the Lord, Har, Har, within.
hir bolhu gur ky isK myry BweI hir Baujlu jgqu qrwvY ]1] rhwau ]
har bolahu gur kae sikh maerae bhaaee har bhoujal jagath tharaavai ||1|| rehaao ||
Chant the Name of the Lord, O Sikhs of the Guru, O my Siblings of Destiny. Only the Lord will carry you across the terrifying world-ocean. ||1||Pause||
jo gur kau jnu pUjy syvy so jnu myry hir pRB BwvY ]
jo gur ko jan poojae saevae so jan maerae har prabh bhaavai ||
That humble being who worships, adores and serves the Guru is pleasing to my Lord God.
hir kI syvw siqguru pUjhu kir ikrpw Awip qrwvY ]2]
har kee saevaa sathigur poojahu kar kirapaa aap tharaavai ||2||
To worship and adore the True Guru is to serve the Lord. In His Mercy, He saves us and carries us across. ||2||
Brim BUly AigAwnI AMDuly BRim BRim PUl qorwvY ]
bharam bhoolae agiaanee a(n)dhhulae bhram bhram fool thoraavai ||
The ignorant and the blind wander deluded by doubt; deluded and confused, they pick flowers to offer to their idols.
inrjIau pUjih mVw sryvih sB ibrQI Gwl gvwvY ]3]
nirajeeo poojehi marraa saraevehi sabh birathhee ghaal gavaavai ||3||
They worship lifeless stones and serve the tombs of the dead; all their efforts are useless. ||3||
bRhmu ibMdy so siqguru khIAY hir hir kQw suxwvY ]
breham bi(n)dhae so sathigur keheeai har har kathhaa sunaavai ||
He alone is said to be the True Guru, who realizes God, and proclaims the Sermon of the Lord, Har, Har.
iqsu gur kau Cwdn Bojn pwt ptMbr bhu ibiD siq kir muiK sMchu iqsu puMn kI iPir qoit n AwvY ]4]
this gur ko shhaadhan bhojan paatt patta(n)bar bahu bidhh sath kar mukh sa(n)chahu this pu(n)n kee fir thott n aavai ||4||
Offer the Guru sacred foods, clothes, silk and satin robes of all sorts; know that He is True. The merits of this shall never leave you lacking. ||4||
siqguru dyau prqiK hir mUriq jo AMimRq bcn suxwvY ]
sathigur dhaeo parathakh har moorath jo a(n)mrith bachan sunaavai ||
The Divine True Guru is the Embodiment, the Image of the Lord; He utters the Ambrosial Word.
nwnk Bwg Bly iqsu jn ky jo hir crxI icqu lwvY ]5]4]
naanak bhaag bhalae this jan kae jo har charanee chith laavai ||5||4||
O Nanak, blessed and good is the destiny of that humble being, who focuses his consciousness on the Feet of the Lord. ||5||4||
[u]This Shabad is by Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Salok Kabeer Jee on Pannaa 1371[/u]
kbIr kwgd kI EbrI msu ky krm kpwt ]
kabeer kaagadh kee oubaree mas kae karam kapaatt ||
Kabeer, the paper is the prison, and the ink of rituals are the bars on the windows.
pwhn borI iprQmI pMifq pwVI bwt ]137]
paahan boree pirathhamee pa(n)ddith paarree baatt ||137||
The stone idols have drowned the world, and the Pandits, the religious scholars, have plundered it on the way. ||137||
[u]This Shabad is by Bhai Gurdaas Ji in Vaars Bhai Gurdaas on Pannaa 5[/u]
jq sq sMjm hom jg jp qp dwn pun bhuqyry]
jath sath sa(n)jam hom jag jap thap dhaan pun bahuthaerae||
Hypocrisy by and large enters into the praxis of continence, burnt offerings, feasts, penances and gifts.
irD isD inD pwKMf bhu qMqR mMqR nwtk Aglyry]
ridhh sidhh nidhh paakha(n)dd bahu tha(n)thr ma(n)thr naattak agalaerae||
Incantations and spells ultimately turn out to be hypocritical plays.
bIrwrwDx jogxI mVHI mswx ivfwx Gnyry]
beeraaraadhhan joganee marrhee masaan viddaan ghanaerae||
The worship of the fifty-two heroes, of the eight yoginis of cemeteries and of places of cremation leads to whopping dissimulation.
pUrk kuMBk ryckw invlI krm BuieAMgm Gyry]
poorak ku(n)bhak raechakaa nivalee karam bhueia(n)gam ghaerae||
People are obsessed with the pranayam exercises of the inhalation, suspension of breath, the exhalation, the niolr feat and straightening of kundalini the serpent power.
isDwsn prcy Gxy hT ingRhY koqk lK hyry]
sidhhaasan parachae ghanae hat(h) nigrehai kothak lakh haerae||
Many employ themselves in sitting in the siddhasanas and thus we have seen them seeking myriad miracles.
pwrs mxI rswiexw krwmwq kwlk AwnHyry]
paaras manee rasaaeinaa karaamaath kaalak aanhaerae||
The belief in the philospher's stone, the jewel in the serpent's head and the miracle of life immortalising elixir are nothing but the darkness of ignorance.
pUjw vrq aupwrxy vr srwp iSv Skiq lvyry]
poojaa varath oupaaranae var saraap shiv shakath lavaerae||
[u]People are engaged in the worship of idols of gods and goddesses[/u], in fasting, uttering and giving blessings and curses.
swD sMgq gur Sbd ivx QwauN n pwiex Bly Blyry]
saadhh sa(n)gath gur shabadh vin thhaaou(n) n paaein bhalae bhalaerae||
But without the holy congregation of the saints and the recitation of the Guru- sabad even the very good person cannot find acceptance.
kUV iek gMFI sO Pyry ]÷]
koorr eik ga(n)dtee sa faerae ||a||
The superstitions bind themselves with a hundred knots of falsehood.
[u]This Shabad is by Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Raag Aasaa on Pannaa 479 [/u]
Awsw sRI kbIr jIau ky pMcpdy 9 duquky 5
aasaa sree kabeer jeeo kae pa(n)chapadhae 9 dhuthukae 5
Aasaa, Kabeer Jee, 9 Panch-Padas, 5 Du-Tukas:
<> siqgur pRswid ]
ik oa(n)kaar sathigur prasaadh ||
One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru:
pwqI qorY mwilnI pwqI pwqI jIau ]
paathee thorai maalinee paathee paathee jeeo ||
You tear off the leaves, O gardener, but in each and every leaf, there is life.
ijsu pwhn kau pwqI qorY so pwhn inrjIau ]1]
jis paahan ko paathee thorai so paahan nirajeeo ||1||
That stone idol, for which you tear off those leaves - that stone idol is lifeless. ||1||
BUlI mwlnI hY eyau ]
bhoolee maalanee hai eaeo ||
In this, you are mistaken, O gardener.
siqguru jwgqw hY dyau ]1] rhwau ]
sathigur jaagathaa hai dhaeo ||1|| rehaao ||
The True Guru is the Living Lord. ||1||Pause||
bRhmu pwqI ibsnu fwrI PUl sMkrdyau ]
breham paathee bisan ddaaree fool sa(n)karadhaeo ||
Brahma is in the leaves, Vishnu is in the branches, and Shiva is in the flowers.
qIin dyv pRqiK qorih krih iks kI syau ]2]
theen dhaev prathakh thorehi karehi kis kee saeo ||2||
When you break these three gods, whose service are you performing? ||2||
pwKwn giF kY mUriq kIn@I dy kY CwqI pwau ]
paakhaan gadt kai moorath keenhee dhae kai shhaathee paao ||
The sculptor carves the stone and fashions it into an idol, placing his feet upon its chest.
jy eyh mUriq swcI hY qau gVHxhwry Kwau ]3]
jae eaeh moorath saachee hai tho garrhanehaarae khaao ||3||
If this stone god was true, it would devour the sculptor for this! ||3||
Bwqu pihiq Aru lwpsI krkrw kwswru ]
bhaath pehith ar laapasee karakaraa kaasaar ||
Rice and beans, candies, cakes and cookies
Bognhwry BoigAw iesu mUriq ky muK Cwru ]4]
bhoganehaarae bhogiaa eis moorath kae mukh shhaar ||4||
- the priest enjoys these, while he puts ashes into the mouth of the idol. ||4||
mwilin BUlI jgu Bulwnw hm Bulwny nwih ]
maalin bhoolee jag bhulaanaa ham bhulaanae naahi ||
The gardener is mistaken, and the world is mistaken, but I am not mistaken.
khu kbIr hm rwm rwKy ik®pw kir hir rwie ]5]1]14]
kahu kabeer ham raam raakhae kirapaa kar har raae ||5||1||14||
Says Kabeer, the Lord preserves me; the Lord, my King, has showered His Blessings upon me. ||5||1||14||
[u]This Shabad is by Guru Nanak Dev Ji in Raag Saarang on Pannaa 1240[/u]
slok mhlw 1 ]
salok mehalaa 1 ||
Shalok, First Mehl:
Gir nwrwiexu sBw nwil ]
ghar naaraaein sabhaa naal ||
In your home, is the Lord God, along with all your other gods.
pUj kry rKY nwvwil ]
pooj karae rakhai naavaal ||
You wash your stone gods and worship them.
kuMgU cMnxu Pul cVwey ]
ku(n)goo cha(n)nan ful charraaeae ||
You offer saffron, sandalwood and flowers.
pYrI pY pY bhuqu mnwey ]
pairee pai pai bahuth manaaeae ||
Falling at their feet, you try so hard to appease them.
mwxUAw mMig mMig pYn@Y Kwie ]
maanooaa ma(n)g ma(n)g painhai khaae ||
Begging, begging from other people, you get things to wear and eat.
AMDI kMmI AMD sjwie ]
a(n)dhhee ka(n)mee a(n)dhh sajaae ||
For your blind deeds, you will be blindly punished.
BuiKAw dyie n mridAw rKY ]
bhukhiaa dhaee n maradhiaa rakhai ||
Your idol does not feed the hungry, or save the dying.
AMDw JgVw AMDI sQY ]1]
a(n)dhhaa jhagarraa a(n)dhhee sathhai ||1||
The blind assembly argues in blindness. ||1||
[u]This Shabad is by Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Raag Prabhaatee on Pannaa 1349[/u]
pRBwqI ]
prabhaathee ||
Prabhaatee:
Alhu eyku msIiq bsqu hY Avru mulKu iksu kyrw ]
alahu eaek maseeth basath hai avar mulakh kis kaeraa ||
If the Lord Allah lives only in the mosque, then to whom does the rest of the world belong?
[u]ihMdU mUriq nwm invwsI duh mih qqu n hyrw ]1]
hi(n)dhoo moorath naam nivaasee dhuh mehi thath n haeraa ||1||
According to the Hindus, the Lord's Name abides in the idol, but there is no truth in either of these claims. ||1||[/u]
Alh rwm jIvau qyry nweI ]
aleh raam jeevo thaerae naaee ||
O Allah, O Raam, I live by Your Name.
qU kir imhrwmiq sweI ]1] rhwau ]
thoo kar miharaamath saaee ||1|| rehaao ||
Please show mercy to me, O Master. ||1||Pause||
dKn dyis hrI kw bwsw piCim Alh mukwmw ]
dhakhan dhaes haree kaa baasaa pashhim aleh mukaamaa ||
The God of the Hindus lives in the southern lands, and the God of the Muslims lives in the west.
idl mih Koij idlY idil Kojhu eyhI Taur mukwmw ]2]
dhil mehi khoj dhilai dhil khojahu eaehee t(h)our mukaamaa ||2||
So search in your heart - look deep into your heart of hearts; this is the home and the place where God lives. ||2||
bRhmn igAws krih caubIsw kwjI mh rmjwnw ]
brehaman giaas karehi choubeesaa kaajee meh ramajaanaa ||
The Brahmins observe twenty-four fasts during the year, and the Muslims fast during the month of Ramadaan.
igAwrh mws pws kY rwKy eykY mwih inDwnw ]3]
giaareh maas paas kai raakhae eaekai maahi nidhhaanaa ||3||
The Muslims set aside eleven months, and claim that the treasure is only in the one month. ||3||
khw aufIsy mjnu kIAw ikAw msIiq isru nWeyN ]
kehaa ouddeesae majan keeaa kiaa maseeth sir naa(n)eae(n) ||
What is the use of bathing at Orissa? Why do the Muslims bow their heads in the mosque?
idl mih kptu invwj gujwrY ikAw hj kwbY jWeyN ]4]
dhil mehi kapatt nivaaj gujaarai kiaa haj kaabai jaa(n)eae(n) ||4||
If someone has deception in his heart, what good is it for him to utter prayers? And what good is it for him to go on pilgrimage to Mecca? ||4||
eyqy Aaurq mrdw swjy ey sB rUp qum@wry ]
eaethae aourath maradhaa saajae eae sabh roop thumhaarae ||
You fashioned all these men and women, Lord. All these are Your Forms.
kbIru pUMgrw rwm Alh kw sB gur pIr hmwry ]5]
kabeer poo(n)garaa raam aleh kaa sabh gur peer hamaarae ||5||
Kabeer is the child of God, Allah, Raam. All the Gurus and prophets are mine. ||5||
khqu kbIru sunhu nr nrvY prhu eyk kI srnw ]
kehath kabeer sunahu nar naravai parahu eaek kee saranaa ||
Says Kabeer, listen, O men and women: seek the Sanctuary of the One.
kyvl nwmu jphu ry pRwnI qb hI inhcY qrnw ]6]2]
kaeval naam japahu rae praanee thab hee nihachai tharanaa ||6||2||
Chant the Naam, the Name of the Lord, O mortals, and you shall surely be carried across. ||6||2||
THIS ONE IS A DIRECT ANSWER FROM DHANN SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB
[u]This Shabad is by Bhagat Beni Ji in Raag Prabhaatee on Pannaa 1351[/u]
pRBwqI Bgq byxI jI kI
prabhaathee bhagath baenee jee kee
Prabhaatee, The Word Of Devotee Baynee Jee:
<> siqgur pRswid ]
ik oa(n)kaar sathigur prasaadh ||
One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru:
qin cMdnu msqik pwqI ]
than cha(n)dhan masathak paathee ||
You rub your body with sandalwood oil, and place basil leaves on your forehead.
ird AMqir kr ql kwqI ]
ridh a(n)thar kar thal kaathee ||
But you hold a knife in the hand of your heart.
Tg idsit bgw ilv lwgw ]
t(h)ag dhisatt bagaa liv laagaa ||
You look like a thug; pretending to meditate, you pose like a crane.
dyiK bYsno pRwn muK Bwgw ]1]
dhaekh baisano praan mukh bhaagaa ||1||
You try to look like a Vaishnaav, but the breath of life escapes through your mouth. ||1||
kil Bgvq bMd icrWmM ]
kal bhagavath ba(n)dh chiraa(n)ma(n) ||
You pray for hours to God the Beautiful.
k®¨r idsit rqw inis bwdM ]1] rhwau ]
kroor dhisatt rathaa nis baadha(n) ||1|| rehaao ||
But your gaze is evil, and your nights are wasted in conflict. ||1||Pause||
inqpRiq iesnwnu srIrM ]
nithaprath eisanaan sareera(n) ||
You perform daily cleansing rituals,
duie DoqI krm muiK KIrM ]
dhue dhhothee karam mukh kheera(n) ||
wear two loin-cloths, perform religious rituals and put only milk in your mouth.
irdY CurI sMiDAwnI ]
ridhai shhuree sa(n)dhhiaanee ||
But in your heart, you have drawn out the sword.
pr drbu ihrn kI bwnI ]2]
par dharab hiran kee baanee ||2||
You routinely steal the property of others. ||2||
[u]isl pUjis ck® gxysM ]
sil poojas chakr ganaesa(n) ||
You worship the stone idol, and paint ceremonial marks of Ganesha.[/u]
inis jwgis Bgiq pRvysM ]
nis jaagas bhagath pravaesa(n) ||
You remain awake throughout the night, pretending to worship God.
pg nwcis icqu AkrmM ]
pag naachas chith akarama(n) ||
You dance, but your consciousness is filled with evil.
ey lµpt nwc ADrmM ]3]
eae la(n)patt naach adhharama(n) ||3||
You are lewd and depraved - this is such an unrighteous dance! ||3||
imRg Awsxu qulsI mwlw ]
mrig aasan thulasee maalaa ||
You sit on a deer-skin, and chant on your mala.
kr aUjl iqlku kpwlw ]
kar oojal thilak kapaalaa ||
You put the sacred mark, the tilak, on your forehead.
[u]irdY kUVu kMiT rudRwKM ]
ridhai koorr ka(n)t(h) rudhraakha(n) ||
You wear the rosary beads of Shiva around your neck, but your heart is filled with falsehood.[/u]
ry lµpt ik®snu ABwKM ]4]
rae la(n)patt kirasan abhaakha(n) ||4||
You are lewd and depraved - you do not chant God's Name. ||4||
ijin Awqm qqu n cIin@Aw ]
jin aatham thath n cheenihaaa ||
Whoever does not realize the essence of the soul
sB Pokt Drm AbIinAw ]
sabh fokatt dhharam abeeniaa ||
all his religious actions are hollow and false.
khu byxI gurmuiK iDAwvY ]
kahu baenee guramukh dhhiaavai ||
Says Baynee, as Gurmukh, meditate.
[u]ibnu siqgur bwt n pwvY ]5]1]
bin sathigur baatt n paavai ||5||1||
Without the True Guru, you shall not find the Way. ||5||1||[/u]
[u]This Shabad is by Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Salok Kabeer Jee on Pannaa 1371[/u]
kbIr pwhnu prmysuru kIAw pUjY sBu sMswru ]
kabeer paahan paramaesur keeaa poojai sabh sa(n)saar ||
Kabeer, someone sets up a stone idol and all the world worships it as the Lord.
ies Brvwsy jo rhy bUfy kwlI Dwr ]136]
eis bharavaasae jo rehae booddae kaalee dhhaar ||136||
Those who hold to this belief will be drowned in the river of darkness. ||136||
Having pasted all this, let me also point out another fact. I heard in Bhai Pinderpal Singh ji's katha ([i]forgot the name of the Gurmukh who said these words as stated by Bhai Pinderpal Singh ji[/i]). We all are idol worshippers! How? We see someone, and while reciting Bani we think of their bodies. That makes us all idol-worshippers. Those are who are not like this way, my head is at your feet!
And Sitara jee, its all good if you want to worship idols. Just please don't compare Dhann Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee to one. Thanks.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
sunil · 09 Sep 2005
the statues of the hindu gods drinking milk happened in the summer of 1995 a hot summer as i recall this was happening in all the temples all over the world a lot of people were saying this and that but no so called expert proved it was a fake trick the vishwa hindu mandhir was overun with all sorts who came to see this holy miricle some people say the hindu mythology worships statues but the hindu religen is no differant than the greeks and the vikings who also worshiped many gods
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
shaddy · 09 Sep 2005
firstly i would like to say to jagjit singh i remember that programe on the bbc in 1995 yea they tried to say it was milk that vapourised into the idols because it was made of marble or stone but they never proved it was a scam as you have wrote in your article a scam can happen in one place but not everywere at the same time
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Singh · 09 Sep 2005
Ok, let's for a moment assume Ganesh did drink the milk.
Good stuff.
It took gallons and gallons of milk. Milk that could have gone to the poor or to children. There were tonnes of milk being poured into a stone and at the same time, the streets of Delhi and Bombay were were lined with children who needed that milk MUCH more than already quite well-fed Ganesh.
I really don't think any Sikh would be trying to pour milk on Guru Granth Sahib jee so something simmilar happening is impossible.
So, I really don't have much respect or reverence for a "god" that drinks tonnes of milk that could have gone to much better sources
But that again is assuming the rock did drink the milk. I think I recall a newstory from the time saying how there was a vacuum system hooked up to one idol.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Sitara · 09 Sep 2005
Mehtab Singh,
Every religion has it fair share of miracles. Sikhism is not the only one! You are displaying an Islamic like attitude in your post. Be more open minded brother!
OK SGGS is not an idol, happy?
Regarding your last statement, I appreciate your sentiments similarly I hope you can appreciate the sentiments of Hindus (I beleive that you were one). I have seen you write some very hurtfull and derogotary things - both in this message board and other message boards - that you have written about Hindu Gods/Goddesses. If you don't want to believe/pooj then then fine, but don't write evil stuff about them please!
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
random sikh brother · 09 Sep 2005
But if the stone idols did consume milk, what was the significance? waht did it mean? what happend after?
I mean is that it?? the stone idols just consumed milk, seems like a pointless excorsise, but sayin that, evcerythin hsppens for a reason.
I remember the day after the 'miricle' in london 1995 , back in my primary school days, someone braught in a small statue of ganesh, he wanted to show it drinkin milk, but after leaving it for a cupla hours nutin happend,non of the milk put under in contact with ganesh's trunk was consumed, did the miricle happen on just a single day?
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Mehtab Singh · 09 Sep 2005
[i]You are displaying an Islamic like attitude in your post. Be more open minded brother![/i]
I am only quoting Gurbani, nothing else. And why do you always label all that you don't find very nice as Islamic?
[i]I appreciate your sentiments similarly I hope you can appreciate the sentiments of Hindus[/i]
I don't think I have spoken against or in favor of Ganesh ji accepting milk.
[i]I beleive that you were one[/i]
I sure was!
[i]I have seen you write some very hurtfull and derogotary things - both in this message board and other message boards - that you have written about Hindu Gods/Goddesses.[/i]
What about the posts where I defended Hinduism after everyone else was mocking the Hindu gods and goddesses? I may have quoted Gurbani there as well. On my own I don't believe I have personally written anything offensive about any Hindu god/goddess. I don't come online to make Sikhs happy or to defend Hindus. I prefer to stick to Gurbani and try to understand all the topics in the light of Gurbani. There are numerous references in Dhann Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee where Guruji looks upon the Hindu gods as blessed beings as well.
This Shabad is by Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Raag Maajh on Pannaa 98
mwJ mhlw 5 ]
maajh mehalaa 5 ||
Maajh, Fifth Mehl:
pwrbRhm AprMpr dyvw ]
paarabreham apara(n)par dhaevaa ||
The Supreme Lord God is Infinite and Divine;
Agm Agocr AlK AByvw ]
agam agochar alakh abhaevaa ||
He is Inaccessible, Incomprehensible, Invisible and Inscrutable.
dIn dieAwl gopwl goibMdw hir iDAwvhu gurmuiK gwqI jIau ]1]
dheen dhaeiaal gopaal gobi(n)dhaa har dhhiaavahu guramukh gaathee jeeo ||1||
Merciful to the meek, Sustainer of the World, Lord of the Universe-meditating on the Lord, the Gurmukhs find salvation. ||1||
gurmuiK mDusUdnu insqwry ]
guramukh madhhusoodhan nisathaarae ||
The Gurmukhs are emancipated by the Lord.
gurmuiK sMgI ik®sn murwry ]
guramukh sa(n)gee kirasan muraarae ||
The Lord Krishna becomes the Gurmukh's Companion.
dieAwl dmodru gurmuiK pweIAY horqu ikqY n BwqI jIau ]2]
dhaeiaal dhamodhar guramukh paaeeai horath kithai n bhaathee jeeo ||2||
The Gurmukh finds the Merciful Lord. He is not found any other way. ||2||
inrhwrI kysv inrvYrw ]
nirehaaree kaesav niravairaa ||
He does not need to eat; His Hair is Wondrous and Beautiful; He is free of hate.
koit jnw jw ky pUjih pYrw ]
kott janaa jaa kae poojehi pairaa ||
Millions of people worship His Feet.
gurmuiK ihrdY jw kY hir hir soeI Bgqu iekwqI jIau ]3]
guramukh hiradhai jaa kai har har soee bhagath eikaathee jeeo ||3||
He alone is a devotee, who becomes Gurmukh, whose heart is filled with the Lord, Har, Har. ||3||
AmoG drsn byAMq Apwrw ]
amogh dharasan baea(n)th apaaraa ||
Forever fruitful is the Blessed Vision of His Darshan; He is Infinite and Incomparable.
vf smrQu sdw dwqwrw ]
vadd samarathh sadhaa dhaathaaraa ||
He is Awesome and All-powerful; He is forever the Great Giver.
gurmuiK nwmu jpIAY iqqu qrIAY giq nwnk ivrlI jwqI jIau ]4]6]13]
guramukh naam japeeai thith thareeai gath naanak viralee jaathee jeeo ||4||6||13||
As Gurmukh, chant the Naam, the Name of the Lord, and you shall be carried across. O Nanak, rare are those who know this state! ||4||6||13||
This Shabad is by Guru Raam Daas Ji in Raag Gauree on Pannaa 174
gauVI mwJ mhlw 4 ]
gourree maajh mehalaa 4 ||
Gauree Maajh, Fourth Mehl:
cojI myry goivMdw cojI myry ipAwirAw hir pRBu myrw cojI jIau ]
chojee maerae govi(n)dhaa chojee maerae piaariaa har prabh maeraa chojee jeeo ||
Playful is my Lord of the Universe; playful is my Beloved. My Lord God is wondrous and playful.
hir Awpy kwn@ü aupwiedw myry goivdw hir Awpy gopI KojI jIau ]
har aapae kaanha oupaaeidhaa maerae govidhaa har aapae gopee khojee jeeo ||
The Lord Himself created Krishna, O my Lord of the Universe; the Lord Himself is the milkmaids who seek Him.
hir Awpy sB Gt Bogdw myry goivMdw Awpy rsIAw BogI jIau ]
har aapae sabh ghatt bhogadhaa maerae govi(n)dhaa aapae raseeaa bhogee jeeo ||
The Lord Himself enjoys every heart, O my Lord of the Universe; He Himself is the Ravisher and the Enjoyer.
hir sujwxu n BuleI myry goivMdw Awpy siqguru jogI jIau ]1]
har sujaan n bhulee maerae govi(n)dhaa aapae sathigur jogee jeeo ||1||
The Lord is All-knowing - He cannot be fooled, O my Lord of the Universe. He is the True Guru, the Yogi. ||1||
Awpy jgqu aupwiedw myry goivdw hir Awip KylY bhu rMgI jIau ]
aapae jagath oupaaeidhaa maerae govidhaa har aap khaelai bahu ra(n)gee jeeo ||
He Himself created the world, O my Lord of the Universe; the Lord Himself plays in so many ways!
ieknw Bog Bogwiedw myry goivMdw ieik ngn iPrih nµg nµgI jIau ]
eikanaa bhog bhogaaeidhaa maerae govi(n)dhaa eik nagan firehi na(n)g na(n)gee jeeo ||
Some enjoy enjoyments, O my Lord of the Universe, while others wander around naked, the poorest of the poor.
Awpy jgqu aupwiedw myry goivdw hir dwnu dyvY sB mMgI jIau ]
aapae jagath oupaaeidhaa maerae govidhaa har dhaan dhaevai sabh ma(n)gee jeeo ||
He Himself created the world, O my Lord of the Universe; the Lord gives His gifts to all who beg for them.
Bgqw nwmu AwDwru hY myry goivMdw hir kQw mMgih hir cMgI jIau ]2]
bhagathaa naam aadhhaar hai maerae govi(n)dhaa har kathhaa ma(n)gehi har cha(n)gee jeeo ||2||
His devotees have the Support of the Naam, O my Lord of the Universe; they beg for the sublime sermon of the Lord. ||2||
hir Awpy Bgiq krwiedw myry goivMdw hir Bgqw loc min pUrI jIau ]
har aapae bhagath karaaeidhaa maerae govi(n)dhaa har bhagathaa loch man pooree jeeo ||
The Lord Himself inspires His devotees to worship Him, O my Lord of the Universe; the Lord fulfills the desires of the minds of His devotees.
Awpy jil Qil vrqdw myry goivdw riv rihAw nhI dUrI jIau ]
aapae jal thhal varathadhaa maerae govidhaa rav rehiaa nehee dhooree jeeo ||
He Himself is permeating and pervading the waters and the lands, O my Lord of the Universe; He is All-pervading - He is not far away.
hir AMqir bwhir Awip hY myry goivdw hir Awip rihAw BrpUrI jIau ]
har a(n)thar baahar aap hai maerae govidhaa har aap rehiaa bharapooree jeeo ||
The Lord Himself is within the self, and outside as well, O my Lord of the Universe; the Lord Himself is fully pervading everywhere.
hir Awqm rwmu pswirAw myry goivMdw hir vyKY Awip hdUrI jIau ]3]
har aatham raam pasaariaa maerae govi(n)dhaa har vaekhai aap hadhooree jeeo ||3||
The Lord, the Supreme Soul, is diffused everywhere, O my Lord of the Universe. The Lord Himself beholds all; His Immanent Presence is pervading everywhere. ||3||
hir AMqir vwjw pauxu hY myry goivMdw hir Awip vjwey iqau vwjY jIau ]
har a(n)thar vaajaa poun hai maerae govi(n)dhaa har aap vajaaeae thio vaajai jeeo ||
O Lord, the music of the praanic wind is deep within, O my Lord of the Universe; as the Lord Himself plays this music, so does it vibrate and resound.
hir AMqir nwmu inDwnu hY myry goivMdw gur sbdI hir pRBu gwjY jIau ]
har a(n)thar naam nidhhaan hai maerae govi(n)dhaa gur sabadhee har prabh gaajai jeeo ||
O Lord, the treasure of the Naam is deep within, O my Lord of the Universe; through the Word of the Guru's Shabad, the Lord God is revealed.
Awpy srix pvwiedw myry goivMdw hir Bgq jnw rwKu lwjY jIau ]
aapae saran pavaaeidhaa maerae govi(n)dhaa har bhagath janaa raakh laajai jeeo ||
He Himself leads us to enter His Sanctuary, O my Lord of the Universe; the Lord preserves the honor of His devotees.
vfBwgI imlu sMgqI myry goivMdw jn nwnk nwm isiD kwjY jIau ]4]4]30]68]
vaddabhaagee mil sa(n)gathee maerae govi(n)dhaa jan naanak naam sidhh kaajai jeeo ||4||4||30||68||
By great good fortune, one joins the Sangat, the Holy Congregation, O my Lord of the Universe; O servant Nanak, through the Naam, one's affairs are resolved. ||4||4||30||68||
This Shabad is by Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Raag Gauree on Pannaa 338
gauVI ]
gourree ||
Gauree:
lK caurwsIh jIA join mih BRmq nµdu bhu Qwko ry ]
lakh chouraaseeh jeea jon mehi bhramath na(n)dh bahu thhaako rae ||
Wandering through 8.4 million incarnations, Krishna's father Nand was totally exhausted.
Bgiq hyiq Avqwru lIE hY Bwgu bfo bpurw ko ry ]1]
bhagath haeth avathaar leeou hai bhaag baddo bapuraa ko rae ||1||
Because of his devotion, Krishna was incarnated in his home; how great was the good fortune of this poor man! ||1||
qum@ ju khq hau nµd ko nµdnu nµd su nµdnu kw ko ry ]
thumh j kehath ho na(n)dh ko na(n)dhan na(n)dh s na(n)dhan kaa ko rae ||
You say that Krishna was Nand's son, but whose son was Nand himself?
Drin Akwsu dso ids nwhI qb iehu nµdu khw Qo ry ]1] rhwau ]
dhharan akaas dhaso dhis naahee thab eihu na(n)dh kehaa thho rae ||1|| rehaao ||
When there was no earth or ether or the ten directions, where was this Nand then? ||1||Pause||
sMkit nhI prY join nhI AwvY nwmu inrMjn jw ko ry ]
sa(n)katt nehee parai jon nehee aavai naam nira(n)jan jaa ko rae ||
He does not fall into misfortune, and He does not take birth; His Name is the Immaculate Lord.
kbIr ko suAwmI AYso Twkuru jw kY mweI n bwpo ry ]2]19]70]
kabeer ko suaamee aiso t(h)aakur jaa kai maaee n baapo rae ||2||19||70||
Kabeer's Lord is such a Lord and Master, who has no mother or father. ||2||19||70||
This Shabad is by Guru Angad Dev Ji in Raag Aasaa on Pannaa 469
mÚ 2 ]
ma 2 ||
Second Mehl:
eyk ik®snµ srb dyvw dyv dyvw q Awqmw ]
eaek kirasana(n) sarab dhaevaa dhaev dhaevaa th aathamaa ||
The One Lord Krishna is the Divine Lord of all; He is the Divinity of the individual soul.
Awqmw bwsudyvis´ jy ko jwxY Byau ] nwnku qw kw dwsu hY soeI inrMjn dyau ]4]
aathamaa baasudhaevasiy jae ko jaanai bhaeo || naanak thaa kaa dhaas hai soee nira(n)jan dhaeo ||4||
Nanak is a slave to anyone who understands this mystery of the all-pervading Lord; he himself is the Immaculate Divine Lord. ||4||
This Shabad is by Guru Raam Daas Ji in Raag Sorath on Pannaa 606
soriT mhlw 4 ]
sorat(h) mehalaa 4 ||
Sorat'h, Fourth Mehl:
Awpy syvw lwiedw ipAwrw Awpy Bgiq aumwhw ]
aapae saevaa laaeidhaa piaaraa aapae bhagath oumaahaa ||
The Beloved Himself commits some to His service; He Himself blesses them with the joy of devotional worship.
Awpy gux gwvwiedw ipAwrw Awpy sbid smwhw ]
aapae gun gaavaaeidhaa piaaraa aapae sabadh samaahaa ||
The Beloved Himself causes us to sing His Glorious Praises; He Himself is absorbed in the Word of His Shabad.
Awpy lyKix Awip ilKwrI Awpy lyKu ilKwhw ]1]
aapae laekhan aap likhaaree aapae laekh likhaahaa ||1||
He Himself is the pen, and He Himself is the scribe; He Himself inscribes His inscription. ||1||
myry mn jip rwm nwmu Emwhw ]
maerae man jap raam naam oumaahaa ||
O my mind, joyfully chant the Name of the Lord.
Anidnu Andu hovY vfBwgI lY guir pUrY hir lwhw ] rhwau ]
anadhin anadh hovai vaddabhaagee lai gur poorai har laahaa || rehaao ||
Those very fortunate ones are in ecstasy night and day; through the Perfect Guru, they obtain the profit of the Lord's Name. ||Pause||
Awpy gopI kwnu hY ipAwrw bin Awpy gaU crwhw ]
aapae gopee kaan hai piaaraa ban aapae goo charaahaa ||
The Beloved Himself is the milk-maid and Krishna; He Himself herds the cows in the woods.
Awpy swvl suMdrw ipAwrw Awpy vMsu vjwhw ]
aapae saaval su(n)dharaa piaaraa aapae va(n)s vajaahaa ||
The Beloved Himself is the blue-skinned, handsome one; He Himself plays on His flute.
kuvlIAw pIVu Awip mrwiedw ipAwrw kir bwlk rUip pcwhw ]2]
kuvaleeaa peerr aap maraaeidhaa piaaraa kar baalak roop pachaahaa ||2||
The Beloved Himself took the form of a child, and destroyed Kuwalia-peer, the mad elephant. ||2||
Awip AKwVw pwiedw ipAwrw kir vyKY Awip cojwhw ]
aap akhaarraa paaeidhaa piaaraa kar vaekhai aap chojaahaa ||
The Beloved Himself sets the stage; He performs the plays, and He Himself watches them.
kir bwlk rUp aupwiedw ipAwrw cMfUru kMsu kysu mwrwhw ]
kar baalak roop oupaaeidhaa piaaraa cha(n)ddoor ka(n)s kaes maaraahaa ||
The Beloved Himself assumed the form of the child, and killed the demons Chandoor, Kansa and Kaysee.
Awpy hI blu Awip hY ipAwrw blu BMnY mUrK mugDwhw ]3]
aapae hee bal aap hai piaaraa bal bha(n)nai moorakh mugadhhaahaa ||3||
The Beloved Himself, by Himself, is the embodiment of power; He shatters the power of the fools and idiots. ||3||
sBu Awpy jgqu aupwiedw ipAwrw vis Awpy jugiq hQwhw ]
sabh aapae jagath oupaaeidhaa piaaraa vas aapae jugath hathhaahaa ||
The Beloved Himself created the whole world. In His hands He holds the power of the ages.
gil jyvVI Awpy pwiedw ipAwrw ijau pRBu iKMcY iqau jwhw ]
gal jaevarree aapae paaeidhaa piaaraa jio prabh khi(n)chai thio jaahaa ||
The Beloved Himself puts the chains around their necks; as God pulls them, must they go.
jo grbY so pcsI ipAwry jip nwnk Bgiq smwhw ]4]6]
jo garabai so pachasee piaarae jap naanak bhagath samaahaa ||4||6||
Whoever harbors pride shall be destroyed, O Beloved; meditating on the Lord, Nanak is absorbed in devotional worship. ||4||6||
This Shabad is by Bhagat Naam Dev Ji in Raag Dhanaasree on Pannaa 693
pihl purIey puMfrk vnw ]
pehil pureeeae pu(n)ddarak vanaa ||
First of all, the lotuses bloomed in the woods;
qw cy hMsw sgly jnW ]
thaa chae ha(n)saa sagalae janaa(n) ||
from them, all the swan-souls came into being.
ik®s~w qy jwnaU hir hir nwcMqI nwcnw ]1]
kirasaa thae jaanoo har har naacha(n)thee naachanaa ||1||
Know that, through Krishna, the Lord, Har, Har, the dance of creation dances. ||1||
pihl purswibrw ]
pehil purasaabiraa ||
First of all, there was only the Primal Being.
AQon purswdmrw ]
athhon purasaadhamaraa ||
From that Primal Being, Maya was produced.
Asgw As ausgw ]
asagaa as ousagaa ||
All that is, is His.
hir kw bwgrw nwcY ipMDI mih swgrw ]1] rhwau ]
har kaa baagaraa naachai pi(n)dhhee mehi saagaraa ||1|| rehaao ||
In this Garden of the Lord, we all dance, like water in the pots of the Persian wheel. ||1||Pause||
nwcMqI gopI jMnw ]
naacha(n)thee gopee ja(n)naa ||
Women and men both dance.
neIAw qy bYry kMnw ]
neeaa thae bairae ka(n)naa ||
There is no other than the Lord.
qrku n cw ]
tharak n chaa ||
Don't dispute this,
BRmIAw cw ]
bhrameeaa chaa ||
and don't doubt this.
kysvw bcaunI AeIey meIey eyk Awn jIau ]2]
kaesavaa bachounee aeeeae meeeae eaek aan jeeo ||2||
The Lord says, ""This creation and I are one and the same.""||2||
ipMDI auBkly sMswrw ]
pi(n)dhhee oubhakalae sa(n)saaraa ||
Like the pots on the Persian wheel, sometimes the world is high, and sometimes it is low.
BRim BRim Awey qum cy duAwrw ]
bhram bhram aaeae thum chae dhuaaraa ||
Wandering and roaming around, I have come at last to Your Door.
qU kunu ry ]
thoo kun rae ||
"Who are you?"
mY jI ] nwmw ] ho jI ]
mai jee || naamaa || ho jee ||
"I am Naam Dayv, Sir."
Awlw qy invwrxw jm kwrxw ]3]4]
aalaa thae nivaaranaa jam kaaranaa ||3||4||
O Lord, please save me from Maya, the cause of death. ||3||4||
This Shabad is by Bhagat Naam Dev Ji in Raag Tilang on Pannaa 727
hly XwrW hly XwrW KuisKbrI ]
halae yaaraa(n) halae yaaraa(n) khusikhabaree ||
Hello, my friend, hello my friend. Is there any good news?
bil bil jWau hau bil bil jWau ]
bal bal jaa(n)o ho bal bal jaa(n)o ||
I am a sacrifice, a devoted sacrifice, a dedicated and devoted sacrifice, to You.
nIkI qyrI ibgwrI Awly qyrw nwau ]1] rhwau ]
neekee thaeree bigaaree aalae thaeraa naao ||1|| rehaao ||
Slavery to You is so sublime; Your Name is noble and exalted. ||1||Pause||
kujw Awmd kujw rPqI kujw my rvI ]
kujaa aamadh kujaa rafathee kujaa mae ravee ||
Where did you come from? Where have You been? And where are You going?
dÍwirkw ngrI rwis bugoeI ]1]
dhvaarikaa nagaree raas bugoee ||1||
Tell me the truth, in the holy city of Dwaarikaa. ||1||
KUbu qyrI pgrI mITy qyry bol ]
khoob thaeree pagaree meet(h)ae thaerae bol ||
How handsome is your turban! And how sweet is your speech.
dÍwirkw ngrI kwhy ky mgol ]2]
dhvaarikaa nagaree kaahae kae magol ||2||
Why are there Moghals in the holy city of Dwaarikaa? ||2||
cMdNØI hjwr Awlm eykl KwnW ]
cha(n)dha(n)aee hajaar aalam eaekal khaanaa(n) ||
You alone are the Lord of so many thousands of worlds.
hm icnI pwiqswh sWvly brnW ]3]
ham chinee paathisaah saa(n)valae baranaa(n) ||3||
You are my Lord King, like the dark-skinned Krishna. ||3||
Aspiq gjpiq nrh nirMd ]
asapath gajapath nareh nari(n)dh ||
You are the Lord of the sun, Lord Indra and Lord Brahma, the King of men.
nwmy ky sÍwmI mIr mukMd ]4]2]3]
naamae kae svaamee meer muka(n)dh ||4||2||3||
You are the Lord and Master of Naam Dayv, the King, the Liberator of all. ||4||2||3||
This Shabad is by Bhagat Naam Dev Ji in Raag Maalee Gauraa on Pannaa 988
mwlI gauVw bwxI Bgq nwmdyv jI kI
maalee gourraa baanee bhagath naamadhaev jee kee
Maalee Gauraa, The Word Of Devotee Naam Dayv Jee:
<> siqgur pRswid ]
ik oa(n)kaar sathigur prasaadh ||
One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru:
Din DMin E rwm bynu bwjY ]
dhhan dhha(n)n ou raam baen baajai ||
Blessed, blessed is that flute which the Lord plays.
mDur mDur Duin Anhq gwjY ]1] rhwau ]
madhhur madhhur dhhun anehath gaajai ||1|| rehaao ||
The sweet, sweet unstruck sound current sings forth. ||1||Pause||
Din Din myGw romwvlI ]
dhhan dhhan maeghaa romaavalee ||
Blessed, blessed is the wool of the sheep;
Din Din ik®sn EFY kWblI ]1]
dhhan dhhan kirasan oudtai kaa(n)balee ||1||
blessed, blessed is the blanket worn by Krishna. ||1||
Din Din qU mwqw dyvkI ]
dhhan dhhan thoo maathaa dhaevakee ||
Blessed, blessed are you, O mother Dayvakee;
ijh igRh rmeIAw kvlwpqI ]2]
jih grih rameeaa kavalaapathee ||2||
into your home the Lord was born. ||2||
Din Din bn KMf ibMdRwbnw ]
dhhan dhhan ban kha(n)dd bi(n)dhraabanaa ||
Blessed, blessed are the forests of Brindaaban;
jh KylY sRI nwrwienw ]3]
jeh khaelai sree naaraaeinaa ||3||
the Supreme Lord plays there. ||3||
bynu bjwvY goDnu crY ]
baen bajaavai godhhan charai ||
He plays the flute, and herds the cows;
nwmy kw suAwmI Awnd krY ]4]1]
naamae kaa suaamee aanadh karai ||4||1||
Naam Dayv's Lord and Master plays happily. ||4||1||
This Shabad is by Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Raag Maaroo on Pannaa 1082
mwrU mhlw 5 ]
maaroo mehalaa 5 ||
Maaroo, Fifth Mehl:
Acuq pwrbRhm prmysur AMqrjwmI ]
achuth paarabreham paramaesur a(n)tharajaamee ||
The Supreme Lord God is imperishable, the Transcendent Lord, the Inner-knower, the Searcher of hearts.
mDusUdn dwmodr suAwmI ]
madhhusoodhan dhaamodhar suaamee ||
He is the Slayer of demons, our Supreme Lord and Master.
irKIkys govrDn DwrI murlI mnohr hir rMgw ]1]
rikheekaes govaradhhan dhhaaree muralee manohar har ra(n)gaa ||1||
The Supreme Rishi, the Master of the sensory organs, the uplifter of mountains, the joyful Lord playing His enticing flute. ||1||
mohn mwDv ik®s~ murwry ]
mohan maadhhav kirasa muraarae ||
The Enticer of Hearts, the Lord of wealth, Krishna, the Enemy of ego.
jgdIsur hir jIau Asur sMGwry ]
jagadheesur har jeeo asur sa(n)ghaarae ||
The Lord of the Universe, the Dear Lord, the Destroyer of demons.
jgjIvn AibnwsI Twkur Gt Gt vwsI hY sMgw ]2]
jagajeevan abinaasee t(h)aakur ghatt ghatt vaasee hai sa(n)gaa ||2||
The Life of the World, our eternal and ever-stable Lord and Master dwells within each and every heart, and is always with us. ||2||
DrxIDr eIs nrisMG nwrwiex ]
dhharaneedhhar ees narasi(n)gh naaraaein ||
The Support of the Earth, the man-lion, the Supreme Lord God.
dwVw AgRy ipRQim Drwiex ]
dhaarraa agrae prithham dhharaaein ||
The Protector who tears apart demons with His teeth, the Upholder of the earth.
bwvn rUpu kIAw quDu krqy sB hI syqI hY cMgw ]3]
baavan roop keeaa thudhh karathae sabh hee saethee hai cha(n)gaa ||3||
O Creator, You assumed the form of the pygmy to humble the demons; You are the Lord God of all. ||3||
sRI rwmcMd ijsu rUpu n ryiKAw ]
sree raamacha(n)dh jis roop n raekhiaa ||
You are the Great Raam Chand, who has no form or feature.
bnvwlI ck®pwix dris AnUipAw ]
banavaalee chakrapaan dharas anoopiaa ||
Adorned with flowers, holding the chakra in Your hand, Your form is incomparably beautiful.
shs nyqR mUriq hY shsw ieku dwqw sB hY mMgw ]4]
sehas naethr moorath hai sehasaa eik dhaathaa sabh hai ma(n)gaa ||4||
You have thousands of eyes, and thousands of forms. You alone are the Giver, and all are beggars of You. ||4||
Bgiq vClu AnwQh nwQy ]
bhagath vashhal anaathheh naathhae ||
You are the Lover of Your devotees, the Master of the masterless.
gopI nwQu sgl hY swQy ]
gopee naathh sagal hai saathhae ||
The Lord and Master of the milk-maids, You are the companion of all.
bwsudyv inrMjn dwqy brin n swkau gux AMgw ]5]
baasudhaev nira(n)jan dhaathae baran n saako gun a(n)gaa ||5||
O Lord, Immacuate Great Giver, I cannot describe even an iota of Your Glorious Virtues. ||5||
mukMd mnohr lKmI nwrwiex ]
muka(n)dh manohar lakhamee naaraaein ||
Liberator, Enticing Lord, Lord of Lakshmi, Supreme Lord God.
dRopqI ljw invwir auDwrx ]
dhropathee lajaa nivaar oudhhaaran ||
Savior of Dropadi's honor.
kmlwkMq krih kMqUhl And ibnodI inhsMgw ]6]
kamalaaka(n)th karehi ka(n)thoohal anadh binodhee nihasa(n)gaa ||6||
Lord of Maya, miracle-worker, absorbed in delightful play, unattached. ||6||
AmoG drsn AwjUnI sMBau ]
amogh dharasan aajoonee sa(n)bho ||
The Blessed Vision of His Darshan is fruitful and rewarding; He is not born, He is self-existent.
Akwl mUriq ijsu kdy nwhI Kau ]
akaal moorath jis kadhae naahee kho ||
His form is undying; it is never destroyed.
AibnwsI Aibgq Agocr sBu ikCu quJ hI hY lgw ]7]
abinaasee abigath agochar sabh kishh thujh hee hai lagaa ||7||
O imperishable, eternal, unfathomable Lord, everything is attached to You. ||7||
sRIrMg bYkuMT ky vwsI ]
sreera(n)g baiku(n)t(h) kae vaasee ||
The Lover of greatness, who dwells in heaven.
mCu kCu kUrmu AwigAw AauqrwsI ]
mashh kashh kooram aagiaa aoutharaasee ||
By the Pleasure of His Will, He took incarnation as the great fish and the tortoise.
kysv clq krih inrwly kIqw loVih so hoiegw ]8]
kaesav chalath karehi niraalae keethaa lorrehi so hoeigaa ||8||
The Lord of beauteous hair, the Worker of miraculous deeds, whatever He wishes, comes to pass. ||8||
inrwhwrI inrvYru smwieAw ]
niraahaaree niravair samaaeiaa ||
He is beyond need of any sustenance, free of hate and all-pervading.
Dwir Kylu cqurBuju khwieAw ]
dhhaar khael chathurabhuj kehaaeiaa ||
He has staged His play; He is called the four-armed Lord.
swvl suMdr rUp bxwvih byxu sunq sB mohYgw ]9]
saaval su(n)dhar roop banaavehi baen sunath sabh mohaigaa ||9||
He assumed the beautiful form of the blue-skinned Krishna; hearing His flute, all are fascinated and enticed. ||9||
bnmwlw ibBUKn kml nYn ]
banamaalaa bibhookhan kamal nain ||
He is adorned with garlands of flowers, with lotus eyes.
suMdr kuMfl mukt bYn ]
su(n)dhar ku(n)ddal mukatt bain ||
His ear-rings, crown and flute are so beautiful.
sMK ck® gdw hY DwrI mhw swrQI sqsMgw ]10]
sa(n)kh chakr gadhaa hai dhhaaree mehaa saarathhee sathasa(n)gaa ||10||
He carries the conch, the chakra and the war club; He is the Great Charioteer, who stays with His Saints. ||10||
pIq pIqMbr iqRBvx DxI ]
peeth peetha(n)bar thribhavan dhhanee ||
The Lord of yellow robes, the Master of the three worlds.
jgMnwQu gopwlu muiK BxI ]
jaga(n)naathh gopaal mukh bhanee ||
The Lord of the Universe, the Lord of the world; with my mouth, I chant His Name.
swirMgDr Bgvwn bITulw mY gxq n AwvY srbMgw ]11]
saari(n)gadhhar bhagavaan beet(h)ulaa mai ganath n aavai saraba(n)gaa ||11||
The Archer who draws the bow, the Beloved Lord God; I cannot count all His limbs. ||11||
inhkMtku inhkyvlu khIAY ]
nihaka(n)ttak nihakaeval keheeai ||
He is said to be free of anguish, and absolutely immaculate.
DnµjY jil Qil hY mhIAY ]
dhhana(n)jai jal thhal hai meheeai ||
The Lord of prosperity, pervading the water, the land and the sky.
imrq lok pieAwl smIpq AsiQr Qwnu ijsu hY ABgw ]12]
mirath lok paeiaal sameepath asathhir thhaan jis hai abhagaa ||12||
He is near this world and the nether regions of the underworld; His Place is permanent, ever-stable and imperishable. ||12||
piqq pwvn duK BY BMjnu ]
pathith paavan dhukh bhai bha(n)jan ||
The Purifier of sinners, the Destroyer of pain and fear.
AhMkwr invwrxu hY Bv KMfnu ]
aha(n)kaar nivaaran hai bhav kha(n)ddan ||
The Eliminator of egotism, the Eradicator of coming and going.
BgqI qoiKq dIn ik®pwlw guxy n ikq hI hY iBgw ]13]
bhagathee thokhith dheen kirapaalaa gunae n kith hee hai bhigaa ||13||
He is pleased with devotional worship, and merciful to the meek; He cannot be appeased by any other qualities. ||13||
inrMkwru ACl Afolo ]
nira(n)kaar ashhal addolo ||
The Formless Lord is undeceivable and unchanging.
joiq srUpI sBu jgu maulo ]
joth saroopee sabh jag moulo ||
He is the Embodiment of Light; through Him, the whole world blossoms forth.
so imlY ijsu Awip imlwey Awphu koie n pwvYgw ]14]
so milai jis aap milaaeae aapahu koe n paavaigaa ||14||
He alone unites with Him, whom He unites with Himself. No one can attain the Lord by himself. ||14||
Awpy gopI Awpy kwnw ]
aapae gopee aapae kaanaa ||
He Himself is the milk-maid, and He Himself is Krishna.
Awpy gaU crwvY bwnw ]
aapae goo charaavai baanaa ||
He Himself grazes the cows in the forest.
Awip aupwvih Awip Kpwvih quDu lypu nhI ieku iqlu rMgw ]15]
aap oupaavehi aap khapaavehi thudhh laep nehee eik thil ra(n)gaa ||15||
You Yourself create, and You Yourself destroy. Not even a particle of filth attaches to You. ||15||
eyk jIh gux kvn bKwnY ]
eaek jeeh gun kavan bakhaanai ||
Which of Your Glorious Virtues can I chant with my one tongue?
shs PnI syK AMqu n jwnY ]
sehas fanee saekh a(n)th n jaanai ||
Even the thousand-headed serpent does not know Your limit.
nvqn nwm jpY idnu rwqI ieku guxu nwhI pRB kih sMgw ]16]
navathan naam japai dhin raathee eik gun naahee prabh kehi sa(n)gaa ||16||
One may chant new names for You day and night, but even so, O God, no one can describe even one of Your Glorious Virtues. ||16||
Et ghI jgq ipq srxwieAw ]
outt gehee jagath pith saranaaeiaa ||
I have grasped the Support, and entered the Sanctuary of the Lord, the Father of the world.
BY BieAwnk jmdUq duqr hY mwieAw ]
bhai bhaeiaanak jamadhooth dhuthar hai maaeiaa ||
The Messenger of Death is terrifying and horrendous, and sea of Maya is impassable.
hohu ik®pwl ieCw kir rwKhu swD sMqn kY sMig sMgw ]17]
hohu kirapaal eishhaa kar raakhahu saadhh sa(n)than kai sa(n)g sa(n)gaa ||17||
Please be merciful, Lord, and save me, if it is Your Will; please lead me to join with the Saadh Sangat, the Company of the Holy. ||17||
idRsitmwn hY sgl imQynw ]
dhrisattimaan hai sagal mithhaenaa ||
All that is seen is an illusion.
ieku mwgau dwnu goibd sMq rynw ]
eik maago dhaan gobidh sa(n)th raenaa ||
I beg for this one gift, for the dust of the feet of the Saints, O Lord of the Universe.
msqik lwie prm pdu pwvau ijsu pRwpiq so pwvYgw ]18]
masathak laae param padh paavo jis praapath so paavaigaa ||18||
Applying it to my forehead, I obtain the supreme status; he alone obtains it, unto whom You give it. ||18||
ijn kau ik®pw krI suKdwqy ]
jin ko kirapaa karee sukhadhaathae ||
Those, unto whom the Lord, the Giver of peace, grants His Mercy,
iqn swDU crx lY irdY prwqy ]
thin saadhhoo charan lai ridhai paraathae ||
grasp the feet of the Holy, and weave them into their hearts.
sgl nwm inDwnu iqn pwieAw Anhd sbd min vwjMgw ]19]
sagal naam nidhhaan thin paaeiaa anehadh sabadh man vaaja(n)gaa ||19||
They obtain all the wealth of the Naam, the Name of the Lord; the unstruck sound current of the Shabad vibrates and resounds within their minds. ||19||
ikrqm nwm kQy qyry ijhbw ]
kiratham naam kathhae thaerae jihabaa ||
With my tongue I chant the Names given to You.
siq nwmu qyrw prw pUrblw ]
sath naam thaeraa paraa poorabalaa ||
'Sat Naam' is Your perfect, primal Name.
khu nwnk Bgq pey srxweI dyhu drsu min rMgu lgw ]20]
kahu naanak bhagath peae saranaaee dhaehu dharas man ra(n)g lagaa ||20||
Says Nanak, Your devotees have entered Your Sanctuary. Please bestow the Blessed Vision of Your Darshan; their minds are filled with love for You. ||20||
qyrI giq imiq qUhY jwxih ]
thaeree gath mith thoohai jaanehi ||
You alone know Your state and extent.
qU Awpy kQih qY Awip vKwxih ]
thoo aapae kathhehi thai aap vakhaanehi ||
You Yourself speak, and You Yourself describe it.
nwnk dwsu dwsn ko krIAhu hir BwvY dwsw rwKu sMgw ]21]2]11]
naanak dhaas dhaasan ko kareeahu har bhaavai dhaasaa raakh sa(n)gaa ||21||2||11||
Please make Nanak the slave of Your slaves, O Lord; as it pleases Your Will, please keep him with Your slaves. ||21||2||11||
This Shabad is by Bhatt Gayandh in Svaiyay Mehl 5 on Pannaa 1402
vwihgurU vwihgurU vwihgurU vwih jIau ]
vaahiguroo vaahiguroo vaahiguroo vaahi jeeo ||
Waahay Guru, Waahay Guru, Waahay Guru, Waahay Jee-o.
kvl nYn mDur bYn koit sYn sMg soB khq mw jsod ijsih dhI Bwqu Kwih jIau ]
kaval nain madhhur bain kott sain sa(n)g sobh kehath maa jasodh jisehi dhehee bhaath khaahi jeeo ||
You are lotus-eyed, with sweet speech, exalted and embellished with millions of companions. Mother Yashoda invited You as Krishna to eat the sweet rice.
dyiK rUpu Aiq AnUpu moh mhw mg BeI ikMknI sbd Jnqkwr Kylu pwih jIau ]
dhaekh roop ath anoop moh mehaa mag bhee ki(n)kanee sabadh jhanathakaar khael paahi jeeo ||
Gazing upon Your supremely beautiful form, and hearing the musical sounds of Your silver bells tinkling, she was intoxicated with delight.
kwl klm hukmu hwiQ khhu kaunu myit skY eIsu bMm´ü g´wnu D´wnu Drq hIAY cwih jIau ]
kaal kalam hukam haathh kehahu koun maett sakai ees ba(n)mya gyaan dhhyaan dhharath heeai chaahi jeeo ||
Death's pen and command are in Your hands. Tell me, who can erase it? Shiva and Brahma yearn to enshrine Your spiritual wisdom in their hearts.
siq swcu sRI invwsu Awid purKu sdw quhI vwihgurU vwihgurU vwihgurU vwih jIau ]1]6]
sath saach sree nivaas aadh purakh sadhaa thuhee vaahiguroo vaahiguroo vaahiguroo vaahi jeeo ||1||6||
You are forever True, the Home of Excellence, the Primal Supreme Being. Waahay Guru, Waahay Guru, Waahay Guru, Waahay Jee-o. ||1||6||
This Shabad is by Bhatt Gayandh in Svaiyay Mehl 5 on Pannaa 1402
pIq bsn kuMd dsn ipRA sihq kMT mwl muktu sIis mor pMK cwih jIau ]
peeth basan ku(n)dh dhasan pria sehith ka(n)t(h) maal mukatt sees mor pa(n)kh chaahi jeeo ||
As Krishna, You wear yellow robes, with teeth like jasmine flowers; You dwell with Your lovers, with Your mala around Your neck, and You joyfully adorn Your head with the crow of peacock feathers.
byvjIr bfy DIr Drm AMg AlK Agm Kylu kIAw AwpxY auCwih jIau ]
baevajeer baddae dhheer dhharam a(n)g alakh agam khael keeaa aapanai oushhaahi jeeo ||
You have no advisors, You are so very patient; You are the Upholder of the Dharma, unseen and unfathomable. You have staged the play of the Universe with joy and delight.
AkQ kQw kQI n jwie qIin lok rihAw smwie suqh isD rUpu DirE swhn kY swih jIau ]
akathh kathhaa kathhee n jaae theen lok rehiaa samaae sutheh sidhh roop dhhariou saahan kai saahi jeeo ||
No one can speak Your Unspoken Speech. You are pervading the three worlds. You assume the form of spiritual perfection, O King of kings.
siq swcu sRI invwsu Awid purKu sdw quhI vwihgurU vwihgurU vwihgurU vwih jIau ]3]8]
sath saach sree nivaas aadh purakh sadhaa thuhee vaahiguroo vaahiguroo vaahiguroo vaahi jeeo ||3||8||
You are forever True, the Home of Excellence, the Primal Supreme Being. Waahay Guru, Waahay Guru, Waahay Guru, Waahay Jee-o. ||3||8||
What are you gonna say now Sitara ji? Please think twice before accusing someone. Its easy for you to sit there and mock Sikhs and their religion, and to label everything evil as Islamic. Sorry thats not my case. I've grown up with Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, etc. I may dislike a few people for their personal habits but NOT their religion or entire community. Also, you being a non-Sikh can say any crap you want about Sikhism coz it won't pinch you. I can't say crap against Hinduism coz my own parents follow it. You have more freedom to use derogatory terms than me! I have always pointed out what we as Sikhs can learn from non-Sikh communities. If you haven't seen those posts, then its not my fault. And yes, also remember that Dhann Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee has composition by both Hindu bhagats as well as Muslim Sufi Fakeers. No other holy book or scripture of any religion can beat that! ([i]by the way, Dhann Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee is not just a book, its Shabad Guru embodied in book form[/i]). You need to realize that Dhann Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee is not against any religion. SARAB SANJHI GURBANI!!
And yes, you know that I was a Hindu, right? Well guess what, one major reason what brought me to Sikhi was that every human being is respected. There is no one calling anyone a lower caste, and no one calling anyone a Kafir in the house of Guru Nanak.
Please make sure you take the time to read all Gurbani quotes, and thanks for reading.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
jugroop singh · 10 Sep 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Dearest Veer Mehtab Singh Ji,
i agree with all your sentiments regarding Muslim and Hindu-bashing; anyone who does so is basically turning their back upon VahiGuru's Prem - after all, what do they think 'Sarbat Da Bhalla' means...lets cuss them all and in the early morning evening lets say we want them all to be cared for by VahiGuru!
however Veer Ji, could i also point out the following:
GurMat has debunked many of the central concepts which Islam and Hinduism are based upon i.e. circumcision, idol worship, fasting, pilgrimages etc. i am sure you realise all this anyway so sorry for potentially sounding patronising.
when we understand GurMat we realise that Siree Guru Sahib Ji did all of this in order to clear the fog of 'Dharmic misunderstanding' that was shrouding the world - Bhai Gurdass Ji says as much.
also, VahiGuru is the all-in-all; when we accept this then we understand in which manner VahiGuru is being referred to via the name of Krishna. in some of the GurShabads you have kindly pasted, the personage of Krishna is being alluded to in order to portray a very important point - that only VahiGuru can unite anyone with Himself.
hence, Krishna and all his cohorts (i.e. gopis) are all being referred to as VahiGuru and VahiGuru alone; He Himself Unites through Himself - even Krishna's flute is being likened to the Unstruck Shabad! what a beautiful analogy Siree Guru Sahib Ji has conveyed! this analogy is used despite the fact that in many instances we are taught elsewhere that the countless Krishnas, Brahmas etc. have not reached VahiGuru as actual individual entities/atmas and that they are not immortal as a result of this - 'so what is the point of worshipping them' is what Siree Guru Sahib Ji is constantly trying to tell those who worship gods/godesses.
always remember Veer Ji that GurMat is the COMPLETE DHARAM and when one has this sentiment in their heart, and aspires to Love VahiGuru, they will not slander the faiths of others - even when realising and contemplating the in-completeness and hypocrisies in all Dharams aside from GurMat. i think that is your mind-set anyway...
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Mehtab Singh · 10 Sep 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
jugroop singh veerjee, i agree with u word per word...the quotes were pasted only to make it clear that Dhann Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee is not against any religion...
[i]in some of the GurShabads you have kindly pasted, the personage of Krishna is being alluded to in order to portray a very important point - that only VahiGuru can unite anyone with Himself.[/i]
yes, 100% true!
[i]GurMat is the COMPLETE DHARAM and when one has this sentiment in their heart, and aspires to Love VahiGuru, they will not slander the faiths of others - even when realising and contemplating the in-completeness and hypocrisies in all Dharams aside from GurMat.[/i]
100% true again!
[i]i think that is your mind-set anyway...[/i]
hanji, by Gurujee's grace :)
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
buht shikkan · 11 Sep 2005
i think the anti ganeshists would have had a solid point if water or any other liquids were put towards the murti debunking that ganesh was accepting milk but a stone was accepting any liquid form.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
sitara · 11 Sep 2005
-----
GurMat has debunked many of the central concepts which Islam and Hinduism are based upon i.e. circumcision, idol worship, fasting, pilgrimages etc. i am sure you realise all this anyway so sorry for potentially sounding patronising.
-----
This is only the opinion of Sikhs themselves. Criticising someones beliefs without full understanding is the easiest thing in the world to do. How would you feel it was said that Nirankaris/Radhasoamis/Arya Samaj Mat had debunked many central concepts which GurMat is based on i.e. Kesh, Bibek etc.
I have seen many writing by muslim scholars that have debunked Sikhi, christianity, hinduism, buddhism
I have seen many writing by chrisitan scholars that have debunked Islam, Sikhi, Judaisim, hinduism, buddhism
I have seen many writing by Hindu scholars that have debunked Islam, Sikhi, Judaisim, Jainism, buddhism
...see where I am getting at. This debunking is no use to anyone
I know these statements make you feel better than hindus and muslims but you must remember they are extremely subjective.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Mehtab Singh · 11 Sep 2005
[i]Criticising someones beliefs without full understanding is the easiest thing in the world to do.[/i]
Who is criticising? Anything and everything is said in the light of Gurbani, the word of God. Let me also remind you that even in Sri Bhagvad Gita (which I find to be a good source of spiritual knowledge) Bhagwan Shri Krishna speaks against hollow rituals (correct me if I am wrong).
[i]How would you feel it was said that Nirankaris/Radhasoamis/Arya Samaj Mat had debunked many central concepts which GurMat is based on i.e. Kesh, Bibek etc.[/i]
None of these sects are accepted as Sikhs. And how do they debunk Sikhi? Narkdhari Bachana called himself a "guru", even though Dasmesh Pita said that Dhann Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee is the eternal Guru. From what I know, Radhasoamis twist and use Gurbani to suit themselves, and they also follow a human "guru", something again contrary to Sikhi. Arya Samaj was founded by Dayanand Saraswati, who according to my knowledge wrote against all non-Hindu avtars in his book called, ummm, was it Satyarth Prakash? So is this how they're going to "debunk" Sikhi?
And I am still not sure how they would "debunk" the only universal and true Guru - Dhann Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee! I say universal because I've already mentioned that there are compositions from both Hindu bhagats and Muslim Sufi Fakeers included in Dhann Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee.
Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Bhindranwale also mentioned that a scripture/holy book of any religion doesn't mention salvation/liberation for anyone of another faith, except the Shabad Guru of the Sikhs - Dhann Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. You cannot comprehend uttering "Allah" in a mandir, or "Ram" in a mosque. But in the Gurughar we sing "Nahi chhodoo re baba Ram naam" as well as "Awal Allah noor upaya", both compositions by Bhagat Kabir ji. Debunking such divine and universal Gurbani, is it even close to possible?
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
. · 11 Sep 2005
This Shabad is by Bhagat Naam Dev Ji in Raag Bhairao on Pannaa 1163
dUDu ktorY gfvY pwnI ] kpl gwie nwmY duih AwnI ]1]
dhoodhh kattorai gaddavai paanee || kapal gaae naamai dhuhi aanee ||1||
Naam Dayv milked the brown cow, and brought a cup of milk and a jug of water to his family god. ||1||
dUDu pIau goibMdy rwie ]
dhoodhh peeo gobi(n)dhae raae ||
"Please drink this milk, O my Sovereign Lord God.
dUDu pIau myro mnu pqIAwie ]
dhoodhh peeo maero man patheeaae ||
Drink this milk and my mind will be happy.
nwhI q Gr ko bwpu irswie ]1] rhwau ]
naahee th ghar ko baap risaae ||1|| rehaao ||
Otherwise, my father will be angry with me.""||1||Pause||
suoien ktorI AMimRq BrI ]
suoein kattoree a(n)mrith bharee ||
Taking the golden cup, Naam Dayv filled it with the ambrosial milk,
lY nwmY hir AwgY DrI ]2]
lai naamai har aagai dhharee ||2||
and placed it before the Lord. ||2||
eyku Bgqu myry ihrdy bsY ] nwmy dyiK nrwienu hsY ]3]
eaek bhagath maerae hiradhae basai || naamae dhaekh naraaein hasai ||3||
The Lord looked upon Naam Dayv and smiled. ""This one devotee abides within my heart.""||3||
dUDu pIAwie Bgqu Gir gieAw ]
dhoodhh peeaae bhagath ghar gaeiaa ||
The Lord drank the milk, and the devotee returned home.
nwmy hir kw drsnu BieAw ]4]3]
naamae har kaa dharasan bhaeiaa ||4||3||
Thus did Naam Dayv come to receive the Blessed Vision of the Lord's Darshan. ||4||3||
(Siri Guru Granth sahib Jee)
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Sep 2005
Dear Sitara Ji,
I have absolutley no doubt that you have read all thsoe DEBUNKING writings....
BUT have you ever read any say by the JEWS..that INSIST the Christians adn the Muslims are JEWS ??
Have you read any writings by the Muslims claiming all JEWS are MUSLIMS....or the Christians saying all JEWS are MUSLIMS etc..
HINDUS keep on CLAIMING that SIKHS are HINDUS...Sikh gurus are HINDUS..Guru garnth ji is HINDU..etc etc.
ONLy and ONLY HINDUS inssit on this ILLOGICAL "logic"..they keep inssiting Sikhs are Hindus while the SIKHS keep saying HUM HINDU NAHIN..
SO where does the Hindu debunking of Sikhi lead to ?? NOWHERE.
Sikhi debunking of Hinduism leads to SIKHI.
have a nice day.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
HINDU · 11 Sep 2005
It was very cool summer that year. I did offer milk to Ganeshji.
I am not a very clean person as I as all is always saying bad about others, maybe lied. still he took milk from me. AND the idol was made of stainless steel. go figure. so that miracle did happen. was caught on tape
by cbs and city tv and ctv. They took a murti from temple and checked it. did xrays you name it no fakery was found. Independent test away from hindus was done.
MAY GURU NANAK GIVE US ALL INSIGHT TO LIVE IN HARMONEY
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Mehtab Singh · 11 Sep 2005
[i]Author: HINDU
Date: 09-11-05 09:26
It was very cool summer that year. I did offer milk to Ganeshji.
I am not a very clean person as I as all is always saying bad about others, maybe lied. still he took milk from me. AND the idol was made of stainless steel. go figure. so that miracle did happen. was caught on tape
by cbs and city tv and ctv. They took a murti from temple and checked it. did xrays you name it no fakery was found. Independent test away from hindus was done.[/i]
I believe you brother. Many people experienced similar miracles exactly 10 years ago during these very days, which is why I haven't anywhere said anything against that happening.
[i]MAY GURU NANAK GIVE US ALL INSIGHT TO LIVE IN HARMONEY[/i]
True!
[%sig%]
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
pandava Bheem Sen · 12 Sep 2005
even if ghanesh drank milk so what? mary weeped, muslims have found stuff like 100 foot skeletons from ancient sites. If ganesh ji drinking milk helped the world then we would welcome it. But the world after has seen wars, devastation, starvation, racial tension. What use is this milk drinking?
soime say it is an omen. then everything happening can effctively be an omen as disaster would be predicted due to the sheer advancement of the world not taking nture into consideartion.
hinduism does have good things to offer in terms of ayurvedic treatments, health yoga, treating animals humanely but thse miracles are meaningless.
i am sorry for hurting our hindu friends coming here but what else can i say? what am i supposed to feel if someone drank som dud? wish him good luck to healthy bones? i do not want to offend anyone but we have to be realistic if it actually helped someone then its good.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
me · 12 Sep 2005
I think that even if ganesh drank milk nothing good happened. It is belived when Ganesh comes he will bring good. But bad has to be removed from the earth. If you are open minded then read vedas, they are bases of all i mean all religions. In vedas it is said a saint will come to this earth welcomed by Ganesh. When that saint becomes of age then evil will be taken care off and good will prevail. Guruji came because bad was happening and he formed sikhi.
Guru Nanak jee bless you all.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Bhishma Ganga Puttar · 13 Sep 2005
ganesh will come? then where has he been when babur came? when millions in india starve?
whather ganesh ji drank milk macdonalds strawberry milkshake diet tango red bull or water what use is it for a diety of supernatural realms to drink on physical domains? (thats if such a being exists)
saints have always predicted good will come from many thousands of years ago. The reality is the rich get richer the poor poorer in the vain hope someone will intervene to sort their problems oiut.
Sikhs are no stranger to this, the mainstream have planted their backside firmly and await the second coming of guru ji a neklank avtaar or second rising of bhindrawala with something erupting in tibet. But this happens will humanity is allowed to slip into a worse state. The early rise of sikhism was down to determination, will power, faith, and the attitude to get things done whatever the outcome. Singhs in lakhi jungles did not await omens for some sut yog. they fought with their muscles and weopons everything is in the khet of doing karni karna.
once we back out of that we will end up like those millions of hindus poor destitute waiting for some miracle.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
tara · 13 Sep 2005
ganesh bro drink some supermalt and wipe out the rss out to the jum for us then i will chill with you and drink loads of mango lassis
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
mu-har-har-har · 13 Sep 2005
I think that the crap about sant jarnail singh khalsa bhindrawale comingto save us is beaing drilld outa the youth no adays, how do you ask, just guide them to the sri guru grant sahib, which makes a clear sikhs dont wait for past matyrs no matter how great they were, we fight for ourselves,
if we wait for sant jaranil singh khalsa bhindranwale to come back, why stop their!!! lets wait for banda singh bahadur, baba deep singh and some anonamous singhs that are unamed but given their all and attained matyrdom.
No wto all sikhs who thikn past matyrs will come and save us, our GURU thats sri guru grant sahib says difrent.
im also happy that ppl are coming acros RSS and various Extrme islamic scumbags who are distorting sikhiacros the net cuz the unsure confused sikhs runs back to the sri guru grant sahib then realises the TRUTH, (as i did ) .
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
shaddy · 13 Sep 2005
hello i would like to ask these uneducated people like bhisma pandava and me who cares what people like you say if this miracle of ganesh ji drinking milk happened what problem have you got with it miricles do happen and can in any faith and why are you people waiting for something good to happen for you in your lives if you people are nobodys in your life what do you want ganesh ji to do about it remember each to his own you worry about yourselves and let the hindus do what they do its not your role to judge starving people racial tension wars have been around from time whats that got to do with ganesh ji you heard the saying what gos around comes around
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Min Singh · 13 Sep 2005
I also remember that year. Personally I would have to agree with Bhai Mehtab Singh Jee on this. This incident was covered by every TV station/newspaper/magazine. It didn’t just happen in one or two moorties, but happened all over the world with hundreds of thousands of moorties. Surely all of these could not be hoaxes or scams.
For me personally, it did not affect me or my beliefs. I still worship Vaheguru and not Ganesh. So what if a miracle occurred, it doesn’t mean anything to Gursikhs. If you want to see miracles or Ridhi Sidhis, then just go to India and visit some Jogis/Sants/Tantariks who have the Sidhis, yet what have they achieved by displaying miracles? Nothing as far as God realization is concerned.
[%sig%]
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
gopi lala · 14 Sep 2005
shaddy ji thats just it to sikhs ganesh drinking milk is meaningless peiece of nothingness.
whether its a miracle or not if it does no good for the world then its just show . wow some geezer drank a few pints of milk lets clap our hands even a baby can do that.
we can speak about what we like purely because its free speech why do you have a problem with that?
i think some hindus have this urge to try to proove their religion through these miracles. But gurbani is clear on it sorry but thats how it is. There was no hindu diety around when aurangzeb, jehangir general dier came. so what use is a murti drinking a few pints going to do after millions of hindus have been raped and killed by moghuls? whats gwaaning now? celebrations of hybrid offsprings let the milk flow abundantly for ganesh ji. wah wah
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Huh · 14 Sep 2005
Wahey ji ka khalsa waheyguru ji ke fateh
I dont understand why everyone is makin such a big deal out of a stone (idol) drinking milk!
Wahey ji ka khalsa wahey ji ke fateh!
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
N Singh · 14 Sep 2005
because it does the body good.
[%sig%]
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Singh · 14 Sep 2005
It was Guru TEgh Bahadur that saved the Hindu people.
Where was Ganesh when Hinduism was about to be wiped from the face of the earth?
So, a diety comes drinks your milk but doesn't help you any and you still worship him.
Guru sahib on the other hand wasn't given anything by Hindus, infact many opposed him and yet he saved the religion.
Guru sahib showed pyar and later his Sikhs treated Hindu women as sisters and mothers and rescued them from the hands of the likes of abdali and what did the Hindu nation do in return...
they continue to back stab ... they are blinded to the effects of karma and many continue to try and destroy Sikhi.
Guru sahib gave you a way to rise above the life of cowards and stone worshippers and yet many chose to ignore the message. blind leading the blind.
overall sad situation.
Become the might saint-soldiers that the guru wanted you to be. Give up the rituals and lose yourself in the ocean of gurbani.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Siddharth · 14 Sep 2005
<>
Singh - Listen to yourself spewing anti-Hindu venom and then you have the gall to ask us to respect you. How can we?
Point 1 - Guru Tegh bahadur is greatly respected by Hindus. He is not called Hind Di Chaadar for nothing
Point 2 - Who is trying to destroy Sikhi? Who continues to back stab? Your tendency of self-aggrandization has taken frightening proportions. Do you think people have time to hatch plots to destroy Sikhi? This is not you, this is the well-fed propoganda of the Neo-Sikhs.
Point 3 - Cowards and Stone-worshippers. This is a typical response when a Sikh wants to downgrade Hindus (unfortunately, that is the case very often these days). Anyway, it has been said before and I will say it again. Read carefully-may be it will get through to you.
Two inanimate objects - stone and paper. You can make the stone into a staircase or into an idol. Similarly, paper can be used for a Harry Potter book or for Guru Granth Sahib. Now, do you respect a Harry Potter book? Do you bow before it? No right? Why do you bow before the Guru Granth Sahib? Because of the Gurbani on each of its angs. Once the Gurbani is written on it, you see the Jot of all the Gurus. Similarly, once the stone is carved into an idol of Sri Ram, the devout bow to it because they see something in it that, people like you for example, fail to see. I hope you understand this. It is all about faith.
Point 4 - We would like to immerse ourselves in the ocean of Gurbani but NEVER the way you want us to. Who are you to lecture us? We have our rituals and if you don't be;lieve them, stay away from them. Don't tell us what to do. You sound like the Taliban or an evangelical Christian who says the only way to salvation is through Christ. You are happy with your religion and we are happy with ours.
Don't try to hide your own insecurities by blaming the Hindus.
Overall sad situation indeed. How can one think of following Sikhi when one sees people like you claiming to be a "Singh" and doing nothing but spewing hatred about Hindus.
Regards, Sid.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Jugraj Singh · 14 Sep 2005
I hate no one.
I am simply recalling the frightening scenes in 84 where majority of the Hindu neighbours and life long friends couldn't open up their doors for Sikhs.
Hate???
No, not hate. Just extreme disappointment.
Guru Granth sahib has the jyot of Guru. It is the jyot we bow down to and the qualities that are enshrined within the jyot.
What qualties do you assign to an idol?
How do you seek guidance from an idol?
And if as you say it is a matter of faith then tell me this: How do you ever establish a foundation of truth? Because what you "see" in a stone idol might not be what someone else sees.
By a logical extension, what a person sees dictates their religious path.
Meaning you have as many religious paths as you have people because each person will see something different (according to their faith as you have said) when they look at an idol.
How is this any different from not believing in any religion?
"Just do whatever you want" isn't a religous philosophy. It is what most people do anyways.
You have said that Guru Tegh Bahadur saved Hinduism but then doesn't that make you question the validity of your own faith?
Why didn't one your Gods or Godesses help you?
Where was the fruit of all the rituals and idol worshipping?
Please consider for a moment the situation the Hindus were in. The Kashmiri Brahmins sought help not from other Hindus but from the Sikh guru. Why? because they were turned away by everyone else.
If Hinduism couldn't save the HIndu people in such dire circumstance, how can it save you now when we are living in these times?
Ask yourself why Hinduism can no longer be defined?
you have lost your identity...
Why?
Because a lot of Hindus have dedicated themselves to destroying others and in the meanwhile ignored the fire in their own house.
Guru sahib came to help raise the downtrodden people ... to guide them to seek God within ... and not in stone idols.
The mighty saint soldiers of the past were Hindus at one time who chose to be reborn into the house of Nanak. There they reached their full potential.
Their were cannibals, murderers, thieves who began to play at the highest seat of spirituality fater offering themselves to Guru nanak.
Sikhs just didn't appear on the earth, they were Hindus and muslims at one time who fell in love with Guru Nanak's message.
so, no i don't hate Hindus. I just feel they are severly misguided, as we all are at some point in our lives.
These are simply my views and my intention isn't to hurt anyone's feelings nor would I ever wish to sound or be callous to anyone's religious sentiment.
I apologize if any part in the post comes across that way.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Siddharth · 14 Sep 2005
<>
Great - Me neither.
<>
Depends upon whose idol it is. Ram=Integrity, respecting parents. Krishna - Love, Srimad Bhagvat Gita. Durga - Shakti. Shiv - Sacrifice. Hanuman - devotion.
<>
By thinking of their qualities and looking for directions through them.
<>
Yes. Isn't that the greatness of it all? For example, a person is a father, brother, husband, a manager, a subordinate and plays several roles. Similarly, God is viewed by us in several ways. Love for God is the foundation of truth in any faith. The ways could be different.
<>
Of course. It is a question of peace. Wherever you find yourself closest to God should be the way to go. Look at mehtab Singh. he did not find anything in Hinduism, he turned to Sikhi where he is extremely happy. Similarly, some Goras join the Hare Krishna movement and only they know the ras they get from reciting Hare Ram, Hare Krishna. Even within faiths, there are several hundred sects. Christianity, for example, has at least 100 different churches in America itself.
Even within Sikhi, Nihangs are different than moneys who are different from Amritdharis who are different from Namdharis, udasis etc.
<>
Not believing in any religion means not believing in God. here the question is what form of God do you feel closest to?
<>
Well, let me ask you a few questions: Why didn't Jesus help the US on 9/11? Why isn't Allah helping Iraq and Afghanistan? Why didn't Waheguru help the Sikhs in 1984? Why isn't Ram helping the millions of starving Hindus? Why didn't Allah and Jesus interfere in the mass slaughter of Christians and Muslims in Serbia?
Who are you and I to question GOD, my brother. We are all his creations. Only he knows his ways.
Please consider for a moment the situation the Hindus were in. The Kashmiri Brahmins sought help not from other Hindus but from the Sikh guru. Why? because they were turned away by everyone else.
If Hinduism couldn't save the HIndu people in such dire circumstance, how can it save you now when we are living in these times?
<
<>
Hinduism is a religion that is several thousand years old and a religion which is so old will lead to different interpretations and philosophies hence people who are outside of our religion ask us this question. Let me ask you one.
Can you define GOD? If you cannot define GOD, how can you expect to define religion?
There is simply no question of losing our identity. Infact, if anything, our identity has continued to be strenghthened by great souls like Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, Swami Ram Krishna Paramhansa, Shankaracharya, Vivekanand, Madhavacharya etc.
<>
Incorrect. It is not a LOT of Hindus but some misguided souls like RSS/VHP etc. who give a bad name to Hinduism but there are people like that in every religion. I agree with you, though, we have to take care of the fire that is burning in our own house, namely the caste system. May be another 100 years should see a lot of progress.
<>
Yes, but we may not completely follow Guru Sahib's teachings and we are not obligated to since we are not Sikhs.
<>
So was Valmiki. And after uttering Ram nam, he wen on to become a great soul.
<>
I am in love with Guru nanak's message of peace and equality. Are you?
<>
Agreed. Some of us are severaly misguided. However, wouldn't you say that about some souls from every religion?
Regards, Sid.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
charanjeev singh · 14 Sep 2005
Siddarth,
you seem to be a good practicing hindu. i respect that.
[%sig%]
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Mehtab Singh · 15 Sep 2005
[i]Wherever you find yourself closest to God should be the way to go. Look at mehtab Singh. he did not find anything in Hinduism, he turned to Sikhi where he is extremely happy.[/i]
PLEASE DO NOT PULL ME INTO EVERYTHING!!! I was a happy, staunch and devout Hindu before I was blessed. Being a Sikh is a lifelong struggle towards perfection. Becoming a Sikh is a developmental process. If one was to convert to Christianity or Islam, you wouldn’t know the difference by merely looking at them. But in Sikhi, one has to change both internally ([i]by reciting Bani, doing Naam Simran and controlling the 5 vices[/i]) and externally ([i]by growing kes and beard[/i]). Thus the keyword is “to grow”. One grows as a Sikh. “[u]Conversion[/u]” as a word may have a negative connotation for some. Therefore I always prefer to think that I grew as a Sikh. Another belief held is that a person is born a Sikh. Only after “mundan” ([i]ceremonial shaving of the head of an infant[/i]) is one a Hindu and only after “sunnat” or “khitna” ([i]both meaning circumcision[/i]) is one a Muslim. Thus a natural born baby whose body has not been tampered in anyway is a Sikh. It is only by Gurujee’s blessings that someone can actually embark upon this path. No one can make another person a Sikh except Guruji. Not your friends, not preachers, not even parents.
As for my case, I would like to quote from Rehras Sahib:
slok mhlw 5 ]
Shalok, Fifth Mehl:
qyrw kIqw jwqo nwhI mYno jogu kIqoeI ]
I have not appreciated what You have done for me, Lord; only You can make me worthy.
mY inrguixAwry ko guxu nwhI Awpy qrsu pieEeI ]
I am unworthy - I have no worth or virtues at all. You have taken pity on me.
qrsu pieAw imhrwmiq hoeI siqguru sjxu imilAw ]
You took pity on me, and blessed me with Your Mercy, and I have met the True Guru, my Friend.
nwnk nwmu imlY qW jIvW qnu mnu QIvY hirAw ]1]
O Nanak, if I am blessed with the Naam, I live, and my body and mind blossom forth. ||1||
Gurujee has brought on me on this path. Why this happened is only known to Him, how this happened is a result of His own planning. How can you say I didn't find anything in Hinduism? I don't think you know me personally. And its not a hard and fast rule that if you are sick and tired of the religion you are born in that you go for "conversion". It was destined to happen.
I respect the fact that you are steadfast and firm in your beliefs, but please don't generalize or make comments about someone/something you are not fully aware about.
Thanks
[%sig%]
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
kal · 16 Sep 2005
Finally we have an intelligent being amongst us...i bet all the rumours were started off by illiterate women who believe in anything they see......no wonder adam was cast out of paradise because of the stupidity of eve!
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Dogma · 16 Sep 2005
>>>Siddarth,
you seem to be a good practicing hindu. i respect that.<<<
Actually i do too.
But Sid Brother...try to avoid responding to every negative post that you read. Some of the posts on this thread were quite positive and I don't think you really gave them the attention that they warranted.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
ssscotty singh · 16 Sep 2005
u shldnt cal anybody stupid especially women. theyr the ones that have the brains to breed and as far as i knw more women are getting into college and uni bcause of their gd grades and that in skl. poola chuka maf karnee
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
khanda kharkuuga · 16 Sep 2005
Could someone please tell me who was Ganesh's mother and father?
Was the father the elephant or was he human? Or was his mother a human?
I find it very dificult to understand how Ganesh was developed? Maybe some american scientist crossed his genes ?
Please enlighten me ?
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Kulbir Singh · 17 Sep 2005
----------
Could someone please tell me who was Ganesh's mother and father?
Was the father the elephant or was he human? Or was his mother a human?
I find it very dificult to understand how Ganesh was developed? Maybe some american scientist crossed his genes ?
Please enlighten me ?
---------
According to Hindu Shasters, Ganesh is the son of Shiv and Parvati. The story that they have stated goes as follows:
Parvati made Ganesh and then put life in him. The reality seems like Parvati must have given birth to Ganesh but it could be that Shiva had been away at the time of Ganesh's birth. Anyway, when Shiva came home to see Parvati, Ganesh was standing guard since Parvati was taking shower. Ganesh did not know that Shiva was his father and as such did not allow him to go inside. Shiva and Ganesh had a fight in which Ganesh won. Shiva left and came back with Vishnu, Brahma and Indra. They all deceived Ganesh and severed his head from his body.
When Parvati saw this, she got furious and invoked her super powers including Durga, Kaali, and other fighters. She gave them orders to destroy Vishnu, Indra and Brahma. In the meantime Shiva realised his mistake and agreed to bring Ganesh back to life. Ganesh's own head was badly damaged. So they took the head of a baby elephant and connected it to Ganesh's body. Ganesh came back to life this way.
Then it was ordained by all Hindu gods that no work would be considered successful without first remembering Ganesh. This is why, all Hindus first remember Ganesh and then begin their business or work.
Ganesh is fond of eating and rides a mouse. He is a good writer and this is why Rishi Vyas chose him to write Mahabharata. The only condition Ganesh had was that he did not want to wait while writing Mahabharata. If he is made to wait, then he will quit writing. Then Rishi Vyas also put a condition that if Ganesh will have to understand the Salok before quiting. So whenever Rishi jee needed time he narrated very complex saloks and while Ganesh would be interpreting them, Vyas would make more saloks.
Ganesh has a brother Karteekay who is very jealous of Ganesh. Once they had an argument about who is greater. They both decided that whoever would come back after making 7 rounds of Earth would be considered superior. Ganesh knew that he being fat would not be able to win, still agreed. While Karteekay rides a beautiful bird, Ganesh rides a mouse. Anyway, Karteekay left and started making rounds of Earth. Ganesh just went to his parents Shiv and Parvati and then sat down with a plate full of Ladoos. After few hours Karteekay came and was all tired. He saw the fat Ganesh sitting with a plate full of ladoos. Not only this, Ganesh claimed that he had already done 7 rounds of Earth. This really irked Karteekay and he attacked Ganesh. Shiva and Parvati intercepted the fight and after listening to Ganesh's argument that for him his parent's Shiva and Parvati were the whole world and by taking 7 rounds of his parents he had done 7 rounds of this world, they decided that Ganesh had won. Karteekay got upset but lost battle to Ganesh forever and ever.
Ganesh is very popular in Maharashtra and I don't think he is popular in Punjab. Punjabi Hindus mostly worship Devis. Central India worships Krishna and Rama. Sound India is more keen on Shiva and Maharashtra loves Ganpati Baba Maurya (Ganesh).
What is Gurmat stand on Ganesh? Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj has written it clearly in his baani:
"Main na Ganeshe pritham manaayoo"
(I don't remember Ganesh before starting any new work).
Kulbir Singh
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
kksingh · 17 Sep 2005
I am of sikh father and hindu mother. My mother has always told me to follow both with open mind. I go to temple and guru dwara. I dont go to dwara any more cause my dad was killed in air india bombing. I know hindu gods saved lots of hindus and sikhs. rajasthan is the most untouched region were hiduism flourish. and thats were i find peace in shree krisna mandir. he has shown lots of miracles, yes to a sikh boy and girl my sister too. i am blessed with both sides, one side is peaceful while other side build bombs and blows up innocent people.
JAI SHREE KRSNA.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
khanda kharkuuga · 17 Sep 2005
Parvati must have been one heck of surgeon to mend ganesh's head.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Guru-Charan-Preet Kaur · 18 Sep 2005
I stay at a place called PUCHONG in Malaysia and just recently there was a "miracle" whereby a 15 metre long Albino King Cobra Snake came and wrapped itself around a Devi Idol in the Hnidu mandir.
Hundreds of thosuands came to vsiit....get "blessed" by the Cobra, chharrawa of 30,000 eggs, uncountable litres of Milk and other things...
After a few days the cobra slithered away into the dense undergrowth at the back of the mandir..
The milk was used to wash the mandir..the eggs were SOLD off..and the other chhrrawa disposed off. Some are still waiting for the snake to return.
All the ones i spoke to consider this a MIRACLE !!
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Indy D · 18 Sep 2005
KHANDA KHARKUUGA.... I just pray that maharaj has mercy upon you and everyone else who mocks on this forum..... Have some respect. Ganesh maharaj is very high and close to the lord..... Look how many do their pooja....... Would you like if somebody sed Baba Deep SIngh fighting headless...YEH RYT GOING TO BELIEVE THAT!!!! Have some decency and respect......If you dont believe in that then leave it as that.....Dont result to mocking.........May the lord have mercy upon thee.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Mehtab Singh · 19 Sep 2005
[i]Author: Indy D
Date: 09-18-05 01:35
KHANDA KHARKUUGA.... I just pray that maharaj has mercy upon you and everyone else who mocks on this forum..... Have some respect. Ganesh maharaj is very high and close to the lord..... Look how many do their pooja....... Would you like if somebody sed Baba Deep SIngh fighting headless...YEH RYT GOING TO BELIEVE THAT!!!! Have some decency and respect......If you dont believe in that then leave it as that.....Dont result to mocking.........May the lord have mercy upon thee.[/i]
waheguru! :)
[%sig%]
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
jai sri krishna · 19 Sep 2005
i am blessed with both sides, one side is peaceful while other side build bombs and blows up innocent people.
sikhiits the religion of the spacxe age, we sikhs believe in equality among men & women of all relgion cuz in the eyes of god every1 is equal, we are free from useles rituals, we dont belive in any hindu gods, but we beleive in a One Infinite Formless Lord God what canot be worshiped in finite form.
You make me laugh you pathtic piece of deficite
You know sikhism dosent stand for killin inocnets,
unlike hindustan has killed all typed of minorities because they dont believe in horrif disgustic hindu aparttheide hey thank god we put a stop to your 'sati' otherwise your mum woulda bin chukt on your dads dead body when he was being cremated. so much for standing for peace hey!
yah!
BTW wher was your miracles wen babur and his cowboys invaded and ruled indian subcontinant for god know how long shifting populations of hindu women gold a cow meat to their arab countries cuz of ther urge for flesh.
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
Jugraj Singh · 19 Sep 2005
I apologize for the delay in my response. Been busy.
>>>
<>
Depends upon whose idol it is. Ram=Integrity, respecting parents. Krishna -
Love, Srimad Bhagvat Gita. Durga - Shakti. Shiv - Sacrifice. Hanuman - devotion.
>>>
The many stories etc. of Krishna are open to interpretation. How I read them isn't how someone else would. So your understanding of love wouldn't be the same as mine.
As you grow as a person your ideas of love and sacrifice will change. As you experience life, you will gain maturity and your beliefs will morph with you.
This process is natural and everyone goes through it. I don't see how
involving an idol in this process helps you worship.
The point I was originally trying to make was that Idols have no role in worship or forming a relationship with God and I think with your explanation you have only strengthened the flaw I was trying to highlight.
You have basically said that it is each individual who assigns qualities to idols. Then you have essentially established as many different forms of Krishna as you have people because each person will have a different level of understanding.
This is what normal life is like without idols. Each individual has their own ideas of love and sacrifice and they change as the person changes. What exactly is the role of the idol?
>>>
<>
By thinking of their qualities and looking for directions through them.
>>>
How do you seek directions through an idol? In your post you said that each person assigns qualities to an idol, but if you are the one who has assigned the qualities to an idol in the first place, then how is the idol of any importance? How exactly does it guide you when you are the one who gave it the attributes that you deemed were necessary.
This is equivalent to you a kid who makes a paper boat but then expects the boat to ferry him across.
>>>
<>
Yes. Isn't that the greatness of it all? For example, a person is a father, brother, husband, a manager, a subordinate and plays several roles. Similarly, God is viewed by us in several ways. Love for God is the foundation of truth in any faith. The ways could be different.
>>>
This is what people all over the world do anyways. People have a role in this world, i.e. brother, son, et. etc. and most people tend to view God in their own way. What exactly is the role of the idol?
>>>
<>
Of course. It is a question of peace. Wherever you find yourself closest to God should be the way to go. Look at mehtab Singh. he did not find anything in Hinduism, he turned to Sikhi where he is extremely happy. Similarly, some Goras join the Hare Krishna movement and only they know the ras they get from reciting Hare Ram, Hare Krishna. Even within faiths, there are several hundred sects. Christianity, for example, has at least 100 different churches in America itself.
Even within Sikhi, Nihangs are different than moneys who are different from Amritdharis who are different from Namdharis, udasis etc.
>>>
The role of a religion is to guide. If Hinduism is different for each practicing Hindu and each practicing Hindu has his own idea of love etc. then where is the guidance?
You yourself have said that each person may assign the qualities to an idol then what exactly is the HIndu religion if it changes from person to person.
>>>
<>
Not believing in any religion means not believing in God. here the question is what form of God do you feel closest to?
>>>
Not true. Many people belive in God but don't follow a religion. They simply do what they feel is right and pray to ask for things and guidance when they feel they need to.
And because the practice of Hindiusm changes from person to person, it sounds exactly like the people who belive in God but not a religion.
>>>
<>
Well, let me ask you a few questions: Why didn't Jesus help the US on 9/11? Why isn't Allah helping Iraq and Afghanistan? Why didn't Waheguru help the Sikhs in 1984? Why isn't Ram helping the millions of starving Hindus? Why didn't Allah and Jesus interfere in the mass slaughter of Christians and Muslims in Serbia?
Who are you and I to question GOD, my brother. We are all his creations. Only he knows his ways.
>>>
My point was that Sikhs held their own. But I must admit that my point was poorly made.
>>>
Please consider for a moment the situation the Hindus were in. The Kashmiri Brahmins sought help not from other Hindus but from the Sikh guru. Why? because they were turned away by everyone else.
If Hinduism couldn't save the HIndu people in such dire circumstance, how can it save you now when we are living in these times?
<
>>>>
Actually you didn't adress the question at all. Please provide an answer. And if you feel you have already answered then simply cut and paste the answer for my benefit.
>>>
<>
Hinduism is a religion that is several thousand years old and a religion which is so old will lead to different interpretations and philosophies hence people who are outside of our religion ask us this question. Let me ask you one.
Can you define GOD? If you cannot define GOD, how can you expect to define religion?
There is simply no question of losing our identity. Infact, if anything, our identity has continued to be strenghthened by great souls like Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, Swami Ram Krishna Paramhansa, Shankaracharya, Vivekanand, Madhavacharya etc.
>>>
Then what exactly is the practice of Hindiusm? "Do what you want" doesn't sound like a religion to me.
>>>
<>
Incorrect. It is not a LOT of Hindus but some misguided souls like RSS/VHP etc. who give a bad name to Hinduism but there are people like that in every religion. I agree with you, though, we have to take care of the fire that is burning in our own house, namely the caste system. May be another 100 years should see a lot of progress.
>>>
Please name the Sikh organization that is funded by the Sikh panth which aims to destroy other religions? Provide a name please.
Throughout this discussion I have tried to understand the role of an idol and you can't seem to explain it. You made a vague comment about assigning qualities but what exactly is the function of the idol? How is the idol important?
Jugraj Singh
Re: Ganesh drinking milk?
kirtan singh · 19 Sep 2005
so truth hurts no guys. when truth is brought forward then all hell breaks loose. i guess it is ok to blow innocent people in the name of nanak.