Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

South Singh · 07 Sep 2005

Guru sahib has been retrived from a very dangerous mission in neworleans, The singhs needed the help of special opps divers to break into the gurdwara sahib. When the singhs Reached maharaj, Guru sahib was gloriously sitting higher than 9 ft of water, at the height of 10 ft Guru granth sahib ji floated like a lotus and was not even touched by the water, The special opps police was shocked at the miracle. DHAN GURU DHAN GURU PIARAE~ the holiest of the holy

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

The Khalsa Fauj · 07 Sep 2005

That is some crazy news.

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Harjas Kaur · 07 Sep 2005

Waheguru!

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

wow · 07 Sep 2005

wow VAHEGURU VAHEGURU

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

::: · 07 Sep 2005

yaaaay

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

::: · 07 Sep 2005

can someone please post more info on this - how guru sahib was retrieved, who the sevadaars were, etc

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Guru ji help me i'm so weak · 08 Sep 2005

DHAN GURU GRANTH SAHIB VAHEGURU VAHEGURU VAHEGURU DHAN ARE THSOE GURSIKHS WHO WENT TO RETRIEVE GURU MAHRAJ AND THE GUYS FROM SPECIAL OPPS

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

.... · 08 Sep 2005

Waheguru

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

wow · 08 Sep 2005

Waheguroooooooooo

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

....................... · 08 Sep 2005

Dhan Guru Granth Sahib JI

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Manvir Singh Khalsa · 08 Sep 2005

Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji!!! Vaahegurooo, Vaaheguroo, Vaaheguroo! Amazin!

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Trying to be Logical Singh · 08 Sep 2005

Amazing ...... just wondering when the New orleans Sikhs evacuated. Why did they not take Guru Maharaj with them?

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

MS · 08 Sep 2005

WICKED PICTURES PLEASE!

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

gabroo · 08 Sep 2005

WAHEGURU DHAN DHAN DHAN SAHIB SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB, AKAL PURAKH MAHARAJ JI WAAHEGURU

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

walking the path... · 08 Sep 2005

http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=13519&st=0&p=118392&#entry118392

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Sukhjeet Singh · 08 Sep 2005

www.unitedsikhs.org/PressReleases/PRSRLS-08-09-2005-00.htm Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji! [%sig%]

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

charanjeev singh · 08 Sep 2005

Home / Press Release 0809200500 Press Release Thursday, 08 September 2005 24th Bhaadon (Samvat 537 Nanakshahi) UNITED SIKHS Rescue Team Recovers Sikh Scriptures from Submerged New Orleans Gurdwara To donate go to www.unitedsikhs.org/donate New Orleans, Louisiana Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, the Sikh Scriptures and eternal Guru of the Sikhs, was recovered yesterday from the submerged New Orleans Gurdwara (Sikh place of worship) after a rescue operation spanning 22 hours by a team of UNITED SIKHS volunteers led by rescue experts. UNITED SIKHS rescue squad with Sri Guru Granth Sahib on the Zodiac Boat. File Picture of The New Orleans Gurdwara. The Gurdwara on Morris Rd., East New Orleans, built about fifteen years ago, which was under 9-feet deep water, bore the brunt when the flood waters of Hurricane Katrina unleashed its fury on the city. The Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji could not be removed from the Gurdwara before mandatory evacuation orders were issued. UNITED SIKHS requested federal and state government agencies for immediate removal of the Holy Scriptures from the submerged Gurdwara. A letter was sent to President Bush on 4-Sep seeking assistance to airlift the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. But there was no response. The UNITED SIKHS emergency relief team then sought the help of UNITED SIKHS volunteer, Ranbir Kaur, a US Army National Guard from Bakersfield CA, to hire the rescue services of SRT (A private helicopter special response and training company of California) and launched the rescue operation. It took three days to obtain clearance from different agencies before SRT could access the flood affected area. In a precarious environment, amidst curfew and random shootings the UNITED SIKHS rescue squad comprising Hardayal Singh and Bhai Nirmal Singh teamed up with air force rescue experts David Cruz and Tom Bausmas of SRT to remove the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji in an operation that lasted over a period of 22 hours from 5pm on Tuesday until 3pm yesterday. Zodiac Boats equipped with under water cameras and rescue equipment were used to reach the flooded Gurdwara building. It was completely damaged inside. The Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji's swarup was on the Palki (palanquin) and floating on water when Hardayal Singh, a rescue team member, entered the building. "I was amazed, looking at the Guru Sahib's sukhasan on the palki, floating on five feet of water and untouched by the flood waters," he said. UNITED SIKHS volunteers speaking to the local media. Hardayal Singh paid his respects and carried the Sikh Scriptures to the rescue boat. He also retrieved gutkas, pothis, khanda, kirpans and other religious material from the building. A joyful gathering of Sikhs paid their respects as the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji was brought to the president of the Gurdwara, Sumir Kaur's, home, which is also the UNITED SIKHS Katrina relief command center. "I am overwhelmed and glad that Guru Granth Sahib ji has been recovered from the floods. I am honored to have been part of this rescue operation" said Ranbir Kaur of Bakersfield, CA. Meanwhile, UNITED SIKHS volunteers and members continue to serve hot meals to over 1300 evacuees in Donaldsonville, Louisiana. More volunteers are flying to Baton Rouge from California and New Jersey to meet the demand of the UNITED SIKHS GHANAIA Katrina Relief efforts. "More supplies and funds will be channelled to the UNITED SIKHS command centre in Louisiana to meet the demand of Meal Ready-to-eat in Donaldsonville" said Dr Satwant Kaur Dhamoon, NJ Director of UNITED SIKHS. Katrina Hurricane Relief Links Updates Donate Volunteer Relief Supplies Currently Required Katrina Hurricane Relief Effort Gallery Issued By: Kuldip Singh Director UNITED SIKHS [address removed] Tel: 1 404 5508356, Toll Free: 1-888-243-1690 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Our Mission To transform underprivileged and minority communities and individuals into informed and vibrant members of society through civic, educational and personal development programs, by fostering active participation in social and economic activity. UNITED SIKHS is also an avenue for networking between like-minded organisations to establish and nurture meaningful projects and dialogues - whether social, cultural or political- to promote harmony, understanding and reciprocity in our villages, towns and cities. UNITED SIKHS is a coalition of organisations and individuals, who share a common vision based on the belief that there is no greater endeavour than to serve, empower and uplift fellow beings. The core of our philosophy is an unwavering commitment to civic service and social progress on behalf of the common good. Accordingly, UNITED SIKHS has sought to fulfil its mission not only by informing, educating and uplifting fellow beings but also by participating in cross-cultural and political exchanges to ensure that the promises and benefits of democracy are realized by all. We at UNITED SIKHS believe that the development of enlightened and progressive societies can be made possible by socially conscious groups of people who make a commitment to develop and direct human potential. Our work, efforts and achievements stand as a testament to our faith in this vision. [%sig%]

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

rsingh · 08 Sep 2005

Vaheguroo jee kaa khalsa vaheguroo jee kee fateh UNITED SIKHS rescue squad with Sri Guru Granth Sahib on the Zodiac Boat. File Picture of The New Orleans Gurdwara. Vaheguroo jee kaa khalsa vaheguroo jee kee fateh

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

singh · 08 Sep 2005

very well done. Bolleh Soooo Nihaaaaal Just one query to tapoban singhs: If the rescuers were tapoban singhs... and they found out that saroop is not lardivar saroop.. would you guys still have saved it/retain it? I had this question on my mind last night. so i thought of asking it on the forum to know the views of the singh.

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Kulbir Singh · 08 Sep 2005

Even if one Gutka was there, Singhs would like to retrieve it from there. Respect for Gurbani is there for sure. As for Laridaar saroop, our stand is very clear on this. We only accept Laridaar Saroop to be Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Padd-chhed is not Guru. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee called Padd chhed "mahamatt". Sant Kartar Singh Bhindranwale called padd-chhed a big mistake. Sant Rarewalay, Sant Jawala Singh Harkhowal were all against padd-chhed. A huge paap has been committed by overturning what our Guru Sahibaan did and breaking baani into pieces by doing padd-chhed of it. Doing piece piece of paper used in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is less offensive than doing piece piece of Gurbani. Paper used in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is respectful since Gurbani is written on it but ultimately it is shabad that is our Guru. If we change shabad, then it no longer remains Guru. So far, scholars have not even been able to decide whether it is “Ik OankaarSat Naam”, Ik Oankaar Satnaam” or “Ik OankaarSatNaam”. If they can’t decide on the first few words of Gurbani, who gave them right to do padd-chhed of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee? Who gave them right to do piece piece of my Guru? It is pure manmatt to accept this grave sin of doing padd-chhed. Ones who accept padd-chhed as Guru and ones who do their samagams using Padd-chhed are making a mute acceptance of this desecration of Gurbani i.e. breaking of baani i.e. doing piece piece of Gurbani. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

singh · 08 Sep 2005

i compeletly agree with your sentiments kulbir singh... i do remember there was one event where all the mahapursh from different sampardha- sant baba isher singh ji rara sahib & nanaksar, sant baba gurbachan singh ji bhindranwaley, sant baba jawala singh ji and full sant samaj started morcha against sgpc implementation of pad ched saroop. I think they did succeded. However, after a while SGPC went back to their same old kurtuta and did implementated padched saroop of siri guru granth sahib ji..unfortunately after the full implementation whole panth including all the sampardha's - taksal, rara sahib, nanaksar, harkhowaley went very relaxed on this issue. In sant baba jawala singh biography. sant baba jawala singh became soo furious that he was willing to scarifice his body to resolve this issue. I agree this issue should not be taken very lightly. But I also think it's not good idea- not to matha taik to padched saroop because guru bani is jot roop/enternal at the end of day and not bowing down it just takes it too extreme. Anyway sorry for off-topic. just wanted to post my 2 cents. [%sig%]

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

charanjeev singh · 08 Sep 2005

Dhan is the Guru who saves the shardhaa of his Sikhs. Only one who floats across the ocean can cross others. Dhan is this bohit. Dhan is the Guru Himself. waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

::::: · 08 Sep 2005

aisay gur kau bal bal jaaeeay|| aap mukat mohe taarai!!!!!

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

khalistani · 08 Sep 2005

how come they didnt take pictures of the floating saroop? bhula chuka maf

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

ekta · 08 Sep 2005

first that is truley amazing, like wow, and 2nd why don't these sikhs help in the rescue, guru ji would be much more pleased with them rescuing ppl then their saroop

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Interesting · 09 Sep 2005

"If we change shabad, then it no longer remains Guru. " this is an interesting point, the shabad has been changed in printed laridar saroops, you may say how and when, well the bir now only contains 1430 page, if you look back at hath likhat bira they were well over 1800 pages, so where have 400 pages gone, condensed to suit the printers templates, but that means the shabad has been changed.... we should only print the bir according to the way it was layed out in the pratan birs... like how this site likes to uses sants on points of contention that they agee on, other wise sant this and sant that.... you quote bhai sahib but all books I've seen have Gurbani printed in pad ched..... last point, which is an interesting one, have we really tied down Guru ji to a style of writing ???? also its obvious from some of the mool mantars prints that have been shown, Guru sahibs did write in pad ched as well.... do we dare question that as well ???? why don't you guys accept that bani is the guru and not the style of writing, you can only do paath pad ched...

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Guru-Charan Preet Kaur · 09 Sep 2005

During the Tsunami last year, a small boy sleeping on a mattress in his dad's hut on the beach, was swept out to sea...First the Huge wave swamped his Hut, ...and then when the Wave retuirned to SEA..the Mattress witht ehsleeping boy went to sea.... and then a few hours later..the mattress returned to Shore...witht the still sleeping boy safe and sound. IS this a miracle... the mattress was not made of wood ( which naturally FLOATS) but dunlop type..filled with fibre and steel springs.. I have seen people sitting on Sofa sets floating about inside their home...during a flood.....and TV sets/Fridges placed on Tables also floating away merrily.... Lets not bring in the Lariddar sroop/molmantar etc into this. They are separate topics. Wadhaiyyee to the Gursikhs. Good Job.

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Kulbir Singh · 09 Sep 2005

----------- "If we change shabad, then it no longer remains Guru. " this is an interesting point, the shabad has been changed in printed laridar saroops, you may say how and when, well the bir now only contains 1430 page, if you look back at hath likhat bira they were well over 1800 pages, so where have 400 pages gone, condensed to suit the printers templates, but that means the shabad has been changed.... we should only print the bir according to the way it was layed out in the pratan birs... ------------- What I meant by changing Shabad was not the writing style but the shabad has actually been changed. Here are some examples: 1) Jo Mar Jammay so Kach Nikach. This is the paath in non-Sampradayak Gutkas but Sampradayak (including Taksali) Gutkay do the paath “Jo Marr Jammay so Kachan Kach”. Only one of these is correct. Some Padd-chhed saroops have one paath others have other paath. Only one of these is Gurbani. Other is not. If it was left laridaar, paathis would still do paath based on their intelligence but then no one could have said that the shabad is written wrongly in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. There are many more examples. Right in Siri Jap jee Sahib there are around 10 differences. Depending on who prints the saroop, the paath is changed. If the shabad is changed, then how can it stay Guru? One of the paaths is wrong and that saroop that has the wrong paath is not Guru. Kulbir Singh

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

random sikh brother · 09 Sep 2005

well in the u.k i tink a few years back a gurdwara had burnt down, the fire brigade and police where baffled as to why the sri guru grant sahib wasnt touchd by the intense heat as for EVERYTHING ELSE around it was incinerated

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Bundha · 09 Sep 2005

<<<< Padd-chhed is not Guru. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee called Padd chhed "mahamatt". Sant Kartar Singh Bhindranwale called padd-chhed a big mistake. Sant Rarewalay, Sant Jawala Singh Harkhowal were all against padd-chhed. >>>> Funny how when it suits you guys you will write out names of Sants, just to back up your point, other wise it is a nindhiya free for all, hypocrits or what? [%sig%]

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

TavPrasad Singh · 09 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!! Bundha wrote: > > Funny how when it suits you guys you will write out names of > Sants, just to back up your point, other wise it is a nindhiya > free for all, hypocrits or what? > Very true. They are all part of the same brotherhood, whether we like it or not!

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Hari Singh · 09 Sep 2005

Bundha, The truth hardly needs to be "backed up". If it needed back-up it wouldn't be the truth. I think Kulbir Singhs' intention was to relay that the whole panth was against the printing of pad ched saroop but due to lack of education and action on our part, the pad-ched saroop is now widely used. Nindhiya is when we conjure stories and incidents about a person with the intention of making them look bad. Please point to a post where Kulbir Singh or any of the moderators (I assume the moderators are the people your referring to when you say "you guys") have done nindya of someone.

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Dalrajkaur · 09 Sep 2005

Bundha, Kulbir Singh only used those names as examples of who is against pad ched saroops. What has he done wrong? He doesn't need to use any Sants or anyone for that matter to back up what he is saying. If you look at all puratan hand written saroop's, they are all laridaar, not pad ched. Gur gadhi was given to laridaar saroop and not pad ched. yes, please do tell us when Kulbir Singh or whoever else you are referring to has done nindya of anyone? I suggest you reread his post carefully, and you will see that he has not said anything wrong.

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Niranjan Singh · 09 Sep 2005

Image of Guru Sahib's saroop in New Orleans posted on bcsikhyouth.com. One question that comes to mind is why did the Singhs leave Guru Granth Sahib Ji's saroop at the Gurduara Sahib and evacuated only themselves ? Perhaps our Gurduara committees need to review their priorities. Do we leave our Guru behind in an Earthquake, war, or flood, or do we risk our lives in honour of our Guru ? How many Gurduara Sahib have an evacuation or contigency plan for such events ? Does it include procedures and plans for taking care of Guru Sahib's saroops, Gutkay, Shashtars, etc, or just themselves ? [%sig%]

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Sikher · 09 Sep 2005

Maharaj is so great - the above pic is an awesome sight :-) _________________________________________________________ This is a good debate on lareedar saroops, i am a supporter of Lareedar saroops of Maharaj but i wouldn't go to the extent of not bowing to Padd chedd Saroops. "also its obvious from some of the mool mantars prints that have been shown, Guru sahibs did write in pad ched as well" why did Guru Sahib do Padd-ched of the (untitled) mool mantar hukamnaamas shown?

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

... · 09 Sep 2005

Bani guru, guru he bani. Bani is bani. That is extreme, you not seeing ped ched as guru. That is manmat thinking.

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 10 Sep 2005

Dear Bundha.. I spent over three hours going through ALL messages by Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji on this Forum going very far back....and I couldnt find a single one where he did NINDIYA of any SANT... ( or anyone else for that matter). Please do show me any such messages. Or withdraw YOUR own NINDIYA of a Gursikh. It is commonsense to write "sant" in front of people already commonly known as such....other than that NOTHING. For example if we just write Kartar singh..you would turn around and say ?? Which kartar singh ?/ who ?? and if we write "sant" kartar singh..you then turn around and say..ahhhhh so you do beleive in Sants as you havge stated in your message above. As for me..i am different.... my views on sants are well known....and i dont think that is nindiya either...becasue the word is misused by many many many shady characters.

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

charanjeev singh · 10 Sep 2005

Author: Kulbir Singh Date: 08-27-05 00:23 Guru roop Khalsa jeeo, If after watching the dhadrian video, some of you still are defending this manmukh fellow dhadrian, then all I can say is that there is a serious lack of bibek-budh here. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee never allowed anyone to matha tek to him and he never gave them blessings as this fellow is giving. Sant Bhindranwalay never allowed himself to be seated on a throne, wearing green chola and dressing up like bibiyaan in gidha. Sarblohi Bir Khalsa can never favour or support this kind of manmukh who is not a Sant but 'Banaras ka Thug'. Veer Manjot Singh jeeo, it is my humble benti in your charan: 'Please don't support this manmukh pakhandi saadh. Apnay Singhs all over India are against him and I heard many disturbing things about this pakhand saadh when I was in India last year.' Shameless are those people who bow to this manmukh person dhadrian and shameless is dhadrian himself. In my opinion, what he needs is the same treatment that Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee gave to that nanga saadh in Siri Amritsar Sahib. (Bhai Sahib and his sangi Singhs beat up that naanga saadh mercilessly with sticks). http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=25563&t=25227#reply_25563 This pakhandi has no spirituality on his face. His face is full of laahnat (Fittay mooh). Gursikhs who have given their heads to Siri Guru Nanak Dashmesh jee can never bow their head in front of this clown who does not even know how to dress up like Mard Khalsa. He dresses up like bibiyaan dress up in Gidha. Kulbir Singh (Currently in Slough (UK), coming back to Toronto in couple of days) I would also like to add, that nindya is nindya, no matter what. I know people will rationalize and say, oh 'i am panthic', blah blah blah, but nindya is nindya, just like how i am doing nindya by posting this. Also, so what if bhai randhir singh beat the saadh? so what? what does that mean, we have to follow his actions? give me a break. Tell me one instance where Guru Sahib from Guru Nanak to Guru Gobind Singh beat up somebody (a particular person). Don't tell me Guru sahib didnt come across rakhshish kind of people. Give me a break, Guru Nanak met up with cannibals, murderers, huge theives, did i mention CANNIBALS, MURDERERS, and Guru Sahib made them into Gurmukhs! I feel sorry for people who follow bhai randhir singh.

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Jasmin · 10 Sep 2005

The truth is the boat that takes us across the most turbulent waters, the kali yu's worst storms.

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

charanjeev singh · 10 Sep 2005

On the same note, as mentioned in my above post. I am not discrediting Bhai Sahib in any way. I have no doubt that Bhai Sahib was a Panch, Gurmukh Jan. What i am saying is that following a Panch is not what Guru Sahib made us to do. Guru Sahib made us to follow Guru Granth and Guru Panth. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Kulbir Singh · 10 Sep 2005

Chiranjeev Singh jeeo, Guru Sahib has made us Singhs and not cows. If someone would try to desecrate the Sikhi principles, no Sikh can keep quiet. It would not be out of place to mention an incident from Sant Bhindranwale's life. After the tragedy of Chando Kalan in which Gurbani pothis were burned by fundamentalist Hindus, Sant jee got a chance to speak in a samagam where all Sants were present. Many sants gave lectures but not one of them said a word about the tragedy. They did not want to say anything against the govt. Even when Sant jee asked them to say anything they stayed quiet. At this Sant jee, in full josh (Bir Rass) said all the so called sants (maybe he used some other word) were "Hijday" (khusray). A Singh later on asked Sant jee why he had used such harsh words for sant mahapurakhs since many sant mahapurakhs were very spiritual persons. Sant jee, with tears in his eyes said, "if a Sikh stays quiet even after such gross desecration of gurbani, what else should I have said but "khusray". Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee's baani is full of such truths about naqli and fake godmen. He has never minced words when talking about them and even calls them "Sirr Khuthay Shaitaani"(Satans). Bhagat Kabir jee in his baani comes down very heavy on fake sants and calls them "Banaras ke Thug". ----------- would also like to add, that nindya is nindya, no matter what. I know people will rationalize and say, oh 'i am panthic', blah blah blah, but nindya is nindya, just like how i am doing nindya by posting this. ------------ Chiranjeev Singh jeeo, please answer this question. If nindiya is nindiya no matter what, why does Guru Sahib in Gurbani condemn fake sants? Are you suggesting that we are to keep quiet no matter how badly these fake sants rip all principles of Gurmat apart? Such jain-kind of fake nimrata and impotent Ahimsa (non-violence) may be a principle or rehit of a follower of Mohan Das Karam Chand Gandhi but not of an Annin Sikh of Siri Guru Dasmesh jee. -------- Tell me one instance where Guru Sahib from Guru Nanak to Guru Gobind Singh beat up somebody (a particular person). --------- Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj burned fake godmen alive. When Guru Sahib heard complaints from Sikhs about Masands, Guru Sahib ordered Singhs to drag the masands to Gur-darbaar by their beards. Singhs full of weapons were sent to different corners of India to get these Masands. Masand originally was a very pious name but when they started doing evil Karam, they were severely punished. Guru Sahib burned some of the Masands alive. ------ I feel sorry for people who follow bhai randhir singh. -------- Sorry Chiranjeev Singh jeeo, but I feel sorry for people like you who follow Mohan Das Gandhi (Mahatma Gandhi) or that atheist holy man Buddha and Mahavira. Followers of sants can never like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee because Bhai Sahib all his life opposed such fake sants who try to act like Gurus and try to become something higher than Sikhs. Bhai Sahib in his monumental book "Sant Padd Nirnay" has come down very heavily on fake sants. So how can we expect the cheley of sants to like Bhai Sahib or gursikhs who admire Bhai Sahib for being an amazing Sikh. Guru Sahib made us shasterdhaari for a reason. If fake sants who dress up like bibiyaan (wearing bibiyaan kind of suits, with gotta and kadhaayee) and act like Guru Sahib, do all the anti-Gurmat things like allowing matha-tek, are we to keep quiet under the fear that lest we do nindiya? It seems to me that you are not aware of the definition of nindiya. Nindiya is not to say truth. Nindiya is when you fabricate the truth for malicious intent. I don't think calling a duck a duck is nindiya. Calling a fake sant a fake sant is not nindiya. What do you want us to do when we see a 22 years old chhokra like dhadrian allowing Sikhs to matha tek to him? Are we supposed to follow suit and matha tek? Perhaps you would like us to stay quiet. But we cannot keep quiet in the face of such gross anti-Gurmat activity. I don't think making sangat aware of the black deeds of these fake sants is nindiya. Kulbir Singh

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Singh · 10 Sep 2005

>>> Kulbir Singh you said: It would not be out of place to mention an incident from Sant Bhindranwale's life. After the tragedy of Chando Kalan in which Gurbani pothis were burned by fundamentalist Hindus, Sant jee got a chance to speak in a samagam where all Sants were present. Many sants gave lectures but not one of them said a word about the tragedy. They did not want to say anything against the govt. Even when Sant jee asked them to say anything they stayed quiet. At this Sant jee, in full josh (Bir Rass) said all the so called sants (maybe he used some other word) were "Hijday" (khusray). A Singh later on asked Sant jee why he had used such harsh words for sant mahapurakhs since many sant mahapurakhs were very spiritual persons. Sant jee, with tears in his eyes said, "if a Sikh stays quiet even after such gross desecration of gurbani, what else should I have said but "khusray". >>> I am just curious where did u read the sakhi. Can you please provide the sangat page number ...i just wanted to find out which sants were there in spefically? Also your views on baba ranjit singh ..good to know what you think about him? But i wonder why didn't you let your views out when he was here in malton, toronto...to me, if i have a problem with you....i ll approach you and ask you for meeting and tell you infront of your face what i think about you..talking on somebody back is called back bitting.. you being shagrid of bhai randhir singh ji..i expected lot more for you..you can go to lectures by paramjit singh and amandeep singh madra and confornted them as per your post but you couldn't go up to bhai ranjit singh confornted him - why what happened veer ji? were you busy when he was here? Lets take if you were busy indeed, would u meet him next time he comes in toronto and let your feeling out to him?? whatever you said on the internet ..word by word. As a Khalsa of siri guru gobind singh ji we shouldn't fear anyone nor we should give fear to anyone. [%sig%]

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Kulbir Singh · 11 Sep 2005

-------- Also your views on baba ranjit singh ..good to know what you think about him? But i wonder why didn't you let your views out when he was here in malton, toronto...to me, if i have a problem with you....i ll approach you and ask you for meeting and tell you infront of your face what i think about you..talking on somebody back is called back bitting.. you being shagrid of bhai randhir singh ji..i expected lot more for you..you can go to lectures by paramjit singh and amandeep singh madra and confornted them as per your post but you couldn't go up to bhai ranjit singh confornted him - why what happened veer ji? were you busy when he was here? ------------ At that time, his video in which he shamelessly allowed people to matha-tek had not come out and I did not have a firm opinion about him at that time. I had never listened to his diwan at that time. I have listened to him only for few minutes and I could not stand it. They are trying to imitate Mahapurakhs like Mastuanewalay Sant but they don't have the kamaayee to do what Abhyaasees like Mastuanay walay did. As for confronting him in person, if Guru Sahib blesses me with the opportunity to do so, I will be glad to do it. There are many dhadrians in this world and I have not made it my mission to confront each one of them in person. There are many ways to confront fakers and openly writing, using your real name is one of the ways. Other way would be to speak about them in public. I am not hiding behind anonymous names like "Singh" to express my views about fake sants. So the allegation of back-biting does not apply on me. Given many restraints I have, I am doing what I can do. Thanks for your advice though. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. Here I would like anybody who can do it.....to POST the names of the SANTS who OPENLY CONDEMNED the GOI in the period of Sant SIPAHI jarnail Singh Ji. Please provide Page numbers/ casset speeches etc. POST the Names of all the SANTS who were impriosned/tortured/had their DERAS closed Down..were other wise harrassed by the Police..for supporting the Kharkoos/Khalsitanis/Sikh Lehr fro Self detrmination in Punjab. Post the List of SANTS who went to Jail in PUNJABI SUBA MORCHA ( SANT FATEH SINGH did ardass and BACKED OUT SHAMELESSLY) SANT LONGOWAAL betrayed the Panth to rajiv gandhi) Post the list of SANTS who led JATHAS to march in jaito/ Gurdwara Sudhaar lehr Morchas... any SANT was in Bhai lachhman Singh Jis' Jatha at nankanna Sahib ?? SANT Dhadriawalla is giving a SIROPA to a Police Officer in the video....it is common knowledge that they get these from many many DERAS and SANT SAMAJISTS....REGULARLY even NOW a days.

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Sep 2005

a letter I received from my good friend...read on... Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Shiromani, Sundar Saroop Sri Khalsa Ji: It is my feeling that we are using inappropriate language whe we say: "We saved Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji". Who are we to save Guru Granth Sahib ji? or anybody else for that matter. How could we save an entity that INFACT saves us at all moments? Is n't it the same mistake we commit when we place Rumalas upon Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji and recite: Prem patola tai saho ditta dhakkan ku patt meri?? Who are we to provide protection and cover to our Sabad Guru?? Also we should avoid talking about shallow miracles that Guru Granth Sahib ji was floating etc as if the divine power that brought the Katrina was something different that the Hukam of Sri Akal?? Jadon sabh os Waheguru ji da Bhanaa hi chall rihaa hai taan eh dubidha keon? Sabh aiko Brhum passryiaa hai taan aseee kehdiaan Karamataan labhday firday haan?? Pray we remain alert about the language we use in divine matters for sure. Jal tay thall kar thall tay kooaaa, koop tay meir krawaiy...He is the creator of deserts and oceans and reverses their locations, in an eye blink...Harn bharn ja ka neittrr phorr!! Charhdee Kalaa to all. Harkinder Singh London Ontario Canada

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

098 · 11 Sep 2005

what is padd-chhed ?

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

charanjeev singh · 11 Sep 2005

veer kulbir singh, First i would like to say, that i do not follow any sant, including bhai sahib randhir singh. When ranjit singh was in town holding diwaans, even with persuasion attempts by a friend, i did not want to go, nor did i go to any diwans. I do feel that changing baani as such in dhaarnaa is not right, as well as akj keertan which has eaten raag as a Lion eats its meat, tearing it to pieces, as anti-Gurmat. I do not accept the title sant being given to any human being, no matter of their kamaaee or avastha. The only Sant i do need and hope that this Sant will keep me in His Santuary, is indeed Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee and Saadh Sangat Jee. Furthermore, the masands were using the Gurus' name to collect money and keeping it for themselves if i am correct. Please do correct me if i am wrong. Ranjit Singh, does not say, i am going to collect the money and give it to the Gurus' cause. People, sangat, donate it at their wish, knowingly that it is not going to Guru Sahib per say. The masands were burned alive because they used the Gurus' name to collect money, which they kept for themselves. (correct me if i am wrong) Importantly, ranjit singh, does infact preach the sermon of Guru and Amrit. I know you are probably a very selfish person, who only cares about quality and not quantity, and you dont really give a hoot about others who might really have benefitted from his katha. You are indeed a selfish soul. Also, the people that do matha tek to ranjit singh as we have seen in the video, do so at their own wish. They willingly are doing anti-gurmat acts, and they have the right to do so. The Guru made a democracy, and not an iron fist which you so wish to abide by. I am confident that a gun was not put to their head, that they must matha tek. However, this is an anti-gurmat act, no doubt, but no one was forced to do anything, and that is the true spirit of Gurmat. That a person be free to make their choices, and will reap as they sow. Guru sahib did not make us cows. And Guru Sahib did not make us Nindhaks either. In Gurbaani there is a Gupt message. You know this better than i do. Doing Nindya of anybody is doing Nindya of Waheguruu Himself. Doing ustat of anybody, including bhai randhir singh, is the same as doing Nindya. Everybody is in Hukam, Everybody. Please refer to the pauris in JapJee Sahib about who is in Hukam and who is out, i am sure you are well versed. Just because you feel that a person should wear clothes as you feel, does not make his clothes anti-gurmat. Who cares what a person wears. Bibiya this and bibiya that; give me a break. I know you are a person who wants Gurmat to be ruled with an iron fist, but sorry, that is not Gurmat. Please contemplate over Gurbaani on this, not just read it. But you are a very smart person, i am sure you will be able to bend the meanings to suit your thinking on all matters. I do not agree with ranjit singhs' actions as seen in the video. However if these are the only allegations against him, that does not make him a dusth of the panth. Maybe it makes you one? i dont know. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Singh · 11 Sep 2005

I would just like to point out that the water is only knee height, and not the nine to ten feet that people are saying it is. The palki isn't floating. THIS ISN'T A MIRACLE. Charanjeev Singh, anyone who says that they are a Sikh of the Guru and preaches Sikhi, and then does things that are not in accordance with Gurmat should be punished and the sangat should be informed as to why the things hes doing is not in accordance with Gurmat. To preach that those who allow themselves to be bowed down to are NOT anti gurmat but that the people who are voicing their concern and telling us why it is wrong ARE anti gurmat is not logical and is in fact laughable. I think you need to review the definition of ninda. [%sig%]

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

charanjeev singh · 11 Sep 2005

why dont you tell me what the definition of nindya is veer singh jee please back up your claims with Baani, and do not give the definition of what you feel is best suited if we were never to have met the Guru, would we know what nindya is? i think not. so therefore that would mean that Guru Sahib has indeed taught us about this grave act. so please do enlighten us on your perspective of nindya tell me this as well, did Waheguruu make the lion that eats the goat, or did Waheguruu create the goat as well? are we anybody to call the lion a murderer? please tell me what is nindya. i know what it is and by the Grace of the Guru can recognize it from a mile away, but i want to first hear your side. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Singh · 12 Sep 2005

Charanjeev Singh, I've been going through your posts and I havn't found one tuk from Gurbani nor any explanation of what ninda is. But if you want my perspective of what ninda is then here it is: http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=14937&t=14833 For your next post veer ji, please start off by explaining what ninda is. Over the years i've had many discussions/debates/arguments over whether we have free will or not, because I think that concept is at the heart of this matter. Does Vaheguru do everything or do we have some say in what we do? I think that is the question you are asking me when you ask about the lion and the goat. But in the interest of getting to the bottom of this matter lets save this discussion for later and discuss the topic at hand. [%sig%]

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

charanjeev singh · 12 Sep 2005

Thank you for directing me to that link. I wish to end all discussions on my part from here on on this. I have concluded that if someone is doing Nindya they have the mat (hopefully by Guru Sahihs' Bakshish) to distinguish it for themselves; and we will reap what we sow. If i have done Nindya i would like here to appologize to all for my vice and hope that sangat in their heart will forgive me, for if they do, i am confident that Waheguruu will forgive me as well. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh bairaarree mehalaa 4 || har jan raam naam gun gaavai || jae koee ni(n)dh karae har jan kee apunaa gun n gavaavai ||1|| rehaao || jo kishh karae s aapae suaamee har aapae kaar kamaavai || har aapae hee math dhaevai suaamee har aapae bol bulaavai ||1|| har aapae pa(n)ch thath bisathhaaraa vich dhhaathoo pa(n)ch aap paavai || jan naanak sathigur maelae aapae har aapae jhagar chukaavai ||2||3|| ang 720 Bairaaree, Fourth Mehl: The Lord's humble servant sings the Glorious Praises of the Lord's Name. Even if someone slanders the Lord's humble servant, he does not give up his own goodness. ||1||Pause|| Whatever the Lord and Master does, He does by Himself; the Lord Himself does the deeds. The Lord and Master Himself imparts understanding; the Lord Himself inspires us to speak. ||1|| The Lord Himself directs the evolution of the world of the five elements; He Himself infuses the five senses into it. O servant Nanak, the Lord Himself unites us with the True Guru; He Himself resolves the conflicts. ||2||3|| [%sig%]

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Dogma · 12 Sep 2005

Jarnail Singh Jee... I believe you requested of list of Sants who opposed GOI. I don't think I can give you a list, as my matt is limited. However, I do know that Sant Baba Harnaam Singh Jee (Rampur Kheray) did join the morcha alongside Sant Jarnail Singh Jee. He also offered his arrest by the GOI however the police at that time refused to take him to jail. So Baba Harnaam Singh Jee refused to move until he was taken to jail. His protest led to an impromptu Samagum which led to many people becoming Amritdhari... Furthermore, I believe Sant Seva Singh (Rampur Kheray) again was asked during 1984 to stop holding Amrit Sanchaars to which he flatly refused. He was taken to jail and his legs beaten so badly that he couldn't walk until the swelling went down. Just two examples veerji...:) Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Lucky Singh · 12 Sep 2005

Charanjeev SIngh Jee, please don’t conclude your input from this discussion. I am also curious as to what your interpretation of Ninda is?

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Kulbir Singh · 12 Sep 2005

--------- I don't think I can give you a list, as my matt is limited. However, I do know that Sant Baba Harnaam Singh Jee (Rampur Kheray) did join the morcha alongside Sant Jarnail Singh Jee. He also offered his arrest by the GOI however the police at that time refused to take him to jail. So Baba Harnaam Singh Jee refused to move until he was taken to jail. His protest led to an impromptu Samagum which led to many people becoming Amritdhari... --------- True that Baba Harnam Singh Rampur Khera did participate in the Morcha but don't forget that he never allowed anyone to call him a Sant. Out of respect he was called Baba jee but never Sant Harnam Singh. Kulbir Singh

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 13 Sep 2005

Dera Veer Jis, I have absolutley NO PROBLEM with accepting the names you have provided. Thats exactly what I have been trying to say all along...the "GENUINE" Mahapurashs can be counted on the fingers of our hands. We MUST tackle the problem of those mushrooming fake ones..and as long as we dont take care to distingush the Wheat from the Chaff.... the fake ones will continue to trap the unwary youth. This should settle the doubt anyone has about my position on "sants" and "Mahapurash" and why i always pick on the misuse fo this word. BTW there was also a "Sant" Niranjan Singh of Patiala who called Mahraja Patiala "BHOOPEE" for torturing Akali Singhs in his prison. He was imprisoned also. Famous Akali ( Sewa Singh Theekreewala) was tortured to death by Bhopee by starving him.) For that Niranjan Singh Ji blasted Bhopee and was jailed. This shows that a True "sant" is never deterred from saying the TRUTH no matter what the consequensces..ALMOST all the DERAWADEES have Kept so quiet you can hear a pin drop. I also admire and read the works of another "Sant" Niranjan Singh of Patiala who was named Shiromani kathakar by SGPC just a few years ago. I have put the word "sant" in commas for obvious reasons. Thank You all.

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

John Singh · 13 Sep 2005

I am still wondering why did the sangat leave Babajee Saroop in the Gurdwara like that in the first place?

Re: Guru ji retrieved not even touched by Water

Dogma · 13 Sep 2005

"True that Baba Harnam Singh Rampur Khera did participate in the Morcha but don't forget that he never allowed anyone to call him a Sant. Out of respect he was called Baba jee but never Sant Harnam Singh. " True. "the "GENUINE" Mahapurashs can be counted on the fingers of our hands." Also true. "We MUST tackle the problem of those mushrooming fake ones" What do you propose Singh Jee?