Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

suki singh · 08 Sep 2005

Following on from the ganesh drinking milk thread (this was shown to be a scam)...what do people/science think about the ganga sagar issue? For those that do not know, the ganga sagar was supposedly given by Guru Gobind Singh Ji to a muslim family who helped him once. It is made of metal, shaped like an jug and has lots of holes in the bottom. When you pour water into it, and it gets full up, no more water comes out from the holes. baba amar singh (dodgy nanaksar guy) brought it over from india with its muslim owner and made a mint from the publicity. does anyone know any scientific theories behind this? thanks s

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

Hari Singh · 08 Sep 2005

ACtually, I always thought milk didn't leak from the ganga sagar but everything else (water, sand) did. I want to know if the Ganga Sagar is sarbloh. And was it meant for storage of food stuffs?

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

ssingh · 08 Sep 2005

if it's fake, which makes more sense because of the way they're profiting from it... (and although to question it becomes sort of ashardak, one should when everyones coming up with claims of descent, magic, special association, etc. when gurmat rejects this focus) probably has to do with high surface tension of water. You can have a transparent material, once someone/something stops touching it, liquid will stop flowing through. (maybe designed so it moves once water reaches top, or the "presenter" stop touching a certain spot, etc. ) The criteria that it stops leaking only once full makes it very suspect. Or buy this magic trick... Anti-Gravico PLEASE NOTE YOU CAN NOW WORK THIS TRICK ON THE NEW SIZE COKE BOTTLE This is a spellbinding trick, don't let the low price put you off. Effect. An empty Coca Cola bottle is filled with water, a playing card or beer mat is placed on top and the bottle turned upside down, a little water is seen to drip from the mat. Now slowly remove your hand, the card or mat remains on the upturned bottle and no water runs out. In the eyes of the average audience this is fairly amazing. However one person is bound to say "Oh yes it's atmospheric pressure which holds the card in place". Then you remove the card and still the water stays in the bottle. Picking up a few matches, one match is slipped into the neck of the bottle, magically it remains suspended half in and half out of the upturned bottle, it is given a little tap and up it goes into the upturned bottle. This is unmistakable proof that the opening of the bottle is REAL A GREAT LITTLE TRICK! So is it possible that this can be done by some sort of device/magic trick - yes.

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

Give it a rest... · 08 Sep 2005

What Saps, all of you. The ganga sagar was blessed by Guru Gobind Singh Ji as the family he was staying with had nothing to pour drinks with for Guru Sahib, and all they had was that. He said well give it to me in that then, and even wit the holes they gave drinks to Guru Sahib. You're always looking for "real" answers, why not just accept that Guru Ji was amazing and whatsoever they wanted to happen could, did, and is.

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

Gurpreet Kaur (London) · 08 Sep 2005

Suki Singh, I dont know why people as thick as you post on the forums, the money donated towards the Ganga Sagar was taken away by the Rai family (go ask 'em), and I'd look at myself before calling someone else dodgy, grow up and get a life!

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

Bundha · 09 Sep 2005

Well said 'give it a rest' and Gurpreet Kaur, this is a blessing from Guru Sahib Ji why are we trying to knock it ?

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

MS · 09 Sep 2005

Wow very nice sweet speech Gurpreet Kaur! I saw this as a kid, was very impressed. But when you think of it from a Gurmat perspective its obviously a loada crap... You have to remember backwards punjabi people who know nothing of Gumat are going to belive in putting eggs on your body to heal wounds, dont shower on wednesdays because it increases ur chances of getting married (because of the smell i presume), the moon turning orange on wednesdays which results in a buy1 get 1 free cinema ticket....

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 09 Sep 2005

Author: Bundha Date: 09-09-05 00:52 Well said 'give it a rest' and Gurpreet Kaur, this is a blessing from Guru Sahib Ji why are we trying to knock it ? <<<<<<<<<<<< "Blessing" ?? what a load of.. Dhan Dhan Guru Granth Ji Sahib IS THE BLESSING...the REAL ONE.... and GURU JI GAVE this to US to Guru manoyao GRANTH..Pargat Guraan Ke Deh...Thats what I call a Real Blessing... not a pot full of as many "holes" as this "blessing thingy".. (Money doesnt seem to "leak" out of it...what a "blessing" !!!) Sorry to be blunt....no offense..

< 1st hand account >

jugroop singh · 11 Sep 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, taken fromt he inspirational stories section - Bhai Surjan Singh Ji's experiences: "Testing the Ganga Saagar At Rai Kot there are some relics of Sree Guru Gobind Singh jee. This is the place where Guru jee asked for news about the younger Saahibzadas. At Rai Kot, we went to the house of a Muslim and saw the Ganga Saagar. The Ganga Saagar is filled with holes. Bhai Saahib jee asked me to bring water and poured it in the Ganga Saagar, but not one drop came out. Then, I took a small stick and put it in the holes, but the stick came out. When Bhai Sahib saw me, he became every upset and said “You shouldn’t test that much!”. I asked for forgiveness from Bhai Sahib as I had erred. We then all returned to Narangvaal". VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

suki singh · 12 Sep 2005

Thanks for that posting Jugroop Singh. The issue remains over so called Baba Amar Singh-the guy who brought over the ganga sagar with the muslim owner (who now apparently has this relic in a swiss bank fault?). Amar Singh is WIDELY discredited, I am sure many of you have heard the audio tapes! Hundreds of thousands of pounds were raised when people went to see this demonstration of the ganga sagar...did any of those people then take amrit, or become better Sikhs? If so...did dhur ki bani not have an effect on them before, or doing satsang?

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

Gurpreet Kaur · 12 Sep 2005

Sukhi Singh, have you done anything for people to take Amrit? Its very well to go around throwing mud at others but what have you actively done for Sikhi? Im not gonna say anything more because you're twisted mind will just spew out more hatred. The people you mention have done more in their lifetime than you could ever do in 5 minutes.

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

Hari Singh · 12 Sep 2005

Gurpreet Kaur, You are losing your touch. >>> The people you mention have done more in their lifetime than you could ever do in 5 minutes. >>> I think it would have more sense if you said the opposite. "The people you mention have done more in 5 minutes then you could ever do in a lifetime" Now, this statement sounds like an insult and will put Sukhi Singh "in his place", as was your intention.

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

Gurpreet Kaur · 12 Sep 2005

Thanks for the correction, well pointed out, nice to see you taking such an interest.

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

S Singh · 13 Sep 2005

>>Author: Gurpreet Kaur Date: 09-12-05 10:04 >> The people you mention have done more in their lifetime than you could ever do in 5 minutes. You are 100% correct. It is not easy to make millions, have huge estates in India, have court cases against you and defraud people across the world. Sukhi Singh I hope you can match these great achievements during your lifetime. They are things we should all aspire to do.

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

singh1234 · 13 Sep 2005

Suki Singh Do you know Amar Singh personally…in order to make those statements. Which audio tapes are you talking about?

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

singh1234 · 13 Sep 2005

Just my observation from reading the thread It seems that Gurpreet Kaur and Suki Singh know each other from the way they are personally attacking each other's views

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

Gurpreet Kaur · 13 Sep 2005

I dont know him, he can say what he likes, I couldnt care less anymore.

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

tara · 13 Sep 2005

i think some people have issues with guru jis association and blessings with muslims. Thee firstthing is they were not the type of muslims like you get in england we on about more sufic or muslim but sikh influenced towards the spiritual side than the world side. The thing is real my relatives see it.

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

we all got names · 02 Oct 2005

Testing the Ganga Saagar At Rai Kot, there are some relics of Sree Guru Gobind Singh jee. This is the place where Guru jee asked for news about the younger Saahibzadas. At Rai Kot, we went to the house of a Muslim and saw the Ganga Saagar. The Ganga Saagar is filled with holes. Bhai Saahib jee asked me to bring water and poured it in the Ganga Saagar, but not one drop came out. Then, I took a small stick and put it in the holes, but the stick came out. When Bhai Sahib saw me, he became every upset and said “You shouldn’t test that much!”. I asked for forgiveness from Bhai Sahib as I had erred. We then all returned to Narangvaal. THIS IS FROM THE INSPIRATIONAL STORIES SECTION OF TAPOBAN, The Seen, Heard and Personally Experienced Bhai Saahib Randheer Singh jee by Baba Surjan Singh jee Gujarvaal PAGE 6

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

gfg · 02 Oct 2005

ganga sagar is ok, nothing wrong with it. but why matha tek to something the GURU gaev a PERSON when we have the GURU there HIMSELF???!?!?!?!?!?!??! WHATS SO SACRED ABOUT THIS THING TO PEOPLE? WHY DONT THEY SHOW THE GURU GRANTH THAT MUCH HOMAGE? THESE PEOPLE AMAZE ME!!!!!!

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

guy · 02 Oct 2005

i believe that the ganga saagar is not a fake because,when the mulim brother brought it to my hometown, baba takhur singh jee(ddt jathedaar, passed away in december 2004) gave him a suroopa for the work he is doing. he evn showed the demonstration infront of the sangat and infront or guru jee and baba thakur singh jee. baba thakur singh jee wouldnt of givn the bro a suroopa if it was a fake. vjkk vjkf

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

suki singh · 03 Oct 2005

Baba Takur Singh (or some other enlightened person at DT) also gave a siropa to the Butcher of Punjab KPS Gill in honour for his slaying of tens of thousands of innocent Sikh youth- does this exonerate KPS Gill of his crimes? I don't think so....

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

Jpeg · 03 Oct 2005

Ganga Sagar may or may not be a fake. But do you guys really think that Guruji gave the Ganga Sagar to Rai Kalha so a descendent of his could take it around the world and have the Guru's Sikhs donate their jewellery to it. What does that say about the Rai family and what does that say about us Sikhs? Surely the person who wishes to have Sikhs view the Ganga Sagar can make arrangements to have a few members of the Rai family accommodated, their air fares paid for etc and make sure that nobody donates jewellery towards it. But it seems like th Rai family is just using it to rake in money from ignorant Sikhs. A nice little earner as Del Boy would say!

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

Bundha · 03 Oct 2005

<<<<< WHATS SO SACRED ABOUT THIS THING TO PEOPLE? WHY DONT THEY SHOW THE GURU GRANTH THAT MUCH HOMAGE? >>>>>> What makes you assume that people do not give Guru Granth Sahib Ji THAT MUCH homage ??? People day in day out bow infornt of Guru Sahib Ji, is this not respect ? If they do bow infornt of an article that was once touched by Guru Gobind Singh Ji then is this not showing devotion - not to the article - but to the memory and the connection that Guru Sahib Ji has with the article. If you bow to Ganga-sagar you not bowing to the material article but you are bowing because of your love of Guru Sahib Ji, Guru Ji once touched this item isn't that enough to show it great respect ..............because you love your GURU.

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

sikh and proud · 03 Oct 2005

why would you have a jug with holes in it in the first place??? i Saw it as a youngster, and was amazed at how the sangat was taking off their gold jewellery to donate towards a gold cover for it. DId it ever materialize??? no! seems like a big a con to make money out of the trusting sangat

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

Singh · 03 Oct 2005

The Ganga Sagar is not fake. In fact the way the ganga sagar works is a miracle of God Himself. What happens is that when you pour water into it, water pours out of the holes, then when the lid is closed, the water stops. The same happens with Milk but when you pour sand into it, it all falls straight out. Wouldn't you agree this is a miracle of God, He created atmospheric pressure and gravity, what happens is when the lid is open the air rushes into the top of the ganga sagar to end up inside, the pressure inside and outside the ganga sagar becomes the same leaving gravity to give a little pull to get the the water out of the holes, when the lid is closed, no air can rush in and therefore the pressure outside the ganga sagar is greater than what is inside so the force of gravity is thus resisted preventing the water from escaping. Sand however is much heavier than water and as its a solid, it lets air pass through it, therefore the air from the holes enters, travels through the sand into the top thus creating equal pressure inside and outside the ganga sagar meaning gravity just gives a little tug and the sand all falls out. Its simple science to be honest but this is given to us from Akal Purakh himself. Just because science can explain it, its not considered a mircale by the manmukh. What is disturbing is the way Guru's Sikhs gave way too much homage to a material possession such as the ganga sagar, you must remember our Guru was Guru due to the divine knowledge they had, not due to their body or material aspects! Many Sikhs turned literally turned their backs on the Guru Sahib Maharaj just to matha tek to a metal jug! It is an insult. Then throwing jewellery at the ganga sagar - that is not true charity, they'd have been beter donating their jewels to people who really needed it. Not to a Jug. Wahegure Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Oct 2005

bundha.. Why would Sikhs be concerned with something that a "BODY - HUMAN DEH" touched when we Have GURU JI HIMSELF BEFORE US to TOUCH,SEE, LOVE, READ, TALK TO....a REAL LIFE LIVING GURU....???? I NEVER saw anyone "throwing " Jewellery towards the LIVING GURU..but i sure saw many sikh ladies taking off their jewellery and throwing it at ganga sagar >> Shows that an object...Guur Ji may or may not have "touched" 300 years ago is MORE HOLY and PRECIOUS than the LIVING GURU HIMSELF....???

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

guy · 03 Oct 2005

sukh singh jee, baba thakur singh jee was a BRAHAM GIANI why would he give a suropa to kp gill? do u have any proof that kp gill was given a suropa from a ddt person? if baba jee gave the guy who has the ganga saagar, that means it is not fake.

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

Bundha · 04 Oct 2005

<<<< Why would Sikhs be concerned with something that a "BODY - HUMAN DEH" touched when we Have GURU JI HIMSELF BEFORE US to TOUCH,SEE, LOVE, READ, TALK TO....a REAL LIFE LIVING GURU....???? >>>> Arshi, I agree we do have a real life living Guru, i am in total agreement. I can only speak for myslef, maybe I am weak but I still long to have darshan of Guru Gobind Singh Ji and Guru Nanak Dev Ji, maybe I am being silly. Maybe I am being even more silly when I long to see something that was associated with the Guru's also. <<< Shows that an object...Guur Ji may or may not have "touched" 300 years ago is MORE HOLY and PRECIOUS than the LIVING GURU HIMSELF....??? >>> I would disagree with you here. You cannot paint everyone with the same brush (which you seem to do a lot !!) You will always find people who go over the top. I agree throwing gold bangles will only benifit the persons who look after Ganga Sagar ( On the other hand if one looks deeper one could say that this is the "bakshash" or "kirpa" of Guru Sahib Ji who bestowed the item to a person and even today they are showered with gifts) maybe a better thing to do would have been to place the gold infornt of Guru Granth Sahib Ji so that all the sangat could benifit from it. But this does not mean that veryone holds the Ganga-Sagar in higher esteem then Guru Granth Sahib Ji. [%sig%]

Re: Ganga Sagar-scam or miracle?

Guru-Charan-Preet Kaur · 06 Oct 2005

But this does not mean that veryone holds the Ganga-Sagar in higher esteem then Guru Granth Sahib Ji. ??????????????????/ Really ?? Just look at the vast crowds jostling to have a look/touch/matha tek/get the packets of HOLY WATER ( water poured into the gs and taken out to be given out as blessed Amrit holy water !!)...Not much "excitement" when going to the Gurdwara !! ( same old Guru Ji ??? perhaps ?? sure looks that way to me.. Bundha ji one cannot escape that to soem people ( many more than normal ) such objects seem more "umph" than GURBANI or the Living GURU !! Thats a FACY+T no one can deny. GSK