Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Marriage

Marriage

Balwant Singh · 14 Oct 2003

Waheguroo jee kaa Khalsaa! Waheguroo jee kee Fateh!! This may seem like a minor concern, but a lot of people's criticisms of my decision have really worried me lately, I'm engaged to be married to someone who's 2 years older than me, I'm 23, and my fiance is 25. The reason I'm worried is because a lot of people who I consider to be gursikhs have told me that my wife should not be older than me. I personally don't see the logic in this, but they argue that gursikhs in old times, and even our Gurus never got married to anyone who was younger than them because it's not "right". I just want to see if there is any logic behind my friends concerns. Waheguroo jee kaa Khalsaa! Waheguroo jee kee Fateh!!

Re: Marriage

Mkhalsa · 14 Oct 2003

did you know its also not right to marry out of your caste?! :O :P

Re: Marriage

nasm · 14 Oct 2003

THis is just a bunch of bs. The only thing that should be taken into account is that it should be relatively same age so that they can live a good life and get along.

Re: Marriage

Gurpreet Kaur · 14 Oct 2003

What if there is a difference of about 12 years?

Re: Marriage

Singh-79 · 14 Oct 2003

Gurpreet Kaur, Which way is the difference directed? Guy older than girl? Girl older than guy? I don't know why, but my gut tells me that it would be more inappropriate if the guy was on the younger side, But there's a good chance I'm wrong about that. So please someone correct me.

Re: Marriage

nirgun · 15 Oct 2003

i dont think it matters very much but there shouldn't be like a generational gap .. sounds stupid of me to say it that way but anything more than 12-13 years is over the top in these days our youth freak out at 2-3 years i think 2-3 years gap is decent.. anything bigger is dangerous - you might have problems understanding each other UNLESS you're both like total gurmukhs and can totally walk together the same path as directed by guru jee - your souls are both several hundred, maybe several thousand years old

Re: Marriage

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 15 Oct 2003

with nirgun ont hsi one 5 yrs at most difference 2-3 is ntn

Re: Marriage

someone · 15 Oct 2003

in my family my mom is a whoping 7 years older than my dad.....they don't get along at all....if she knew before they were married that he was younger than her she would have never married him....then again so many people lie to get rishta to come abroad....not that their bad people they love me and my sibs to death but their relationship ain't all that great.....so yeah i think the couple should be the same age or with a diff of 2-3 yrs.....

Re: Marriage

A Sikh · 15 Oct 2003

The female should definitely be younger then the male. Otherwise there is bound to be conflict within the marriage. The age difference should be within 5 years.

Re: Marriage

Gurpreet Kaur · 15 Oct 2003

Guy older than the girl by 12 years? Do you think it could work or to say it wouldn't is generalising? It's a difficult question I feel, because it may seem all rosy now but in 20 years time things may get difficult.

Re: Marriage

Singh too · 15 Oct 2003

12 years seems like a bit too much of an age gap. And don't women usually have a life expectancy of about 5 years more than men, so that's another factor. But perhaps in certain circumstances it might work out. We can't make overarching generalisations. Just seems difficult.

Re: Marriage

nirgun · 16 Oct 2003

i think the main reason people say the female should be younger is in most cases, females are a few years more mature (in all aspects) than males.. so it compensates.. but that's not the case for everybody

Re: Marriage

Another Sikh · 16 Oct 2003

A Sikh, Why are there bound to be conflicts if the girl is older? I don't think it makes sense to make such generalizations.

Re: Marriage

A Sikh · 16 Oct 2003

Another Sikh, I know because whenever I have seen marriages where the female is older, they always brake up. When the female is older, she is going to start bossing him around. Since he is the man, he's not going to take it, and that's where the conflict starts. Just based on what i have seen and heard.

Re: Marriage

Another Sikh · 16 Oct 2003

That could very possibly be true for most people, However, making that generalization all that time is not always true. Especially when the marriage is between Gursikhs.

Re: Marriage

. · 18 Oct 2003

WHO CARES ABOUT THE AGE GAP! so long as both ppl are of the same mental maturity and get along... some ppl are more mature than others... the reason y everyone thinks a guy shud be a bit older is cuz females are generally more mature than males, and due to that most of the time... a guy being about 2 years older than a girl works out great!!!! but this not always a case....... so long as the two get along, it probs means their maturity and their thinking of life is prob similar, so let them get marreid..... No one should judge you on wat u do, my mate married someon 9 years yoiunger than him...... and his marriage his messed up.... but thats prob in his karma... so it doint matter, it was goinna happen no matter wat. but then again im sure there heaps of ppl with similiar age gaps who are happy as pie!

Re: Marriage

G · 19 Oct 2003

why is this even being discussed? Age does not matter... more importantly sikhi does... if they dont practice the same sikhi have the same rehit... then there is a problem... but age why are you even discussing this... why should it matter if the girl is older or not... I find that to be a sexest comment there's no place in sikhi for that