Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

bsb · 12 Sep 2005

I was walking today in my new university. There aren't many Sikhs at all in the town or the university. I was walking past the bus stop and saw a young Sikh boy with a patka and untied beard. I looked at him and was about to at least nod my head and maybe stop for a word. He saw me. I was dressed in my blue baaNaa and dastaar. He turned to look the other way. Very consciously. He looked behind him at a wall but wouldn't look at me. It was a bit confusing. Then I was walking again and lo and behold, another young Sikh student. This time this young student had a patka but a long uncut beart. Quite bushy actually. He saw me and the same reaction. Looked the opposite direction. Why are Sikhs ashamed of seeing other Sikhs? I mean even if you don't want to talk, what's the harm in a nod of the head? Or is it that a Singh in BaaNaa is something that makes them feel ashamed? It really shouldn't I don't think. I mean I can understand if a Singh in his BaaNaa felt a bit funny being associated with a goofy looking guy in shorts and t-shirt with what a tiny joora covered with a patka. I mean to the lay Western person, the patka looks really really odd. Like a golf ball balanced on a smooth head. But I don't have hangups like that. So I dont' understand how I would be embarassing to be seen with compared to that. Maybe it was partly my fault that I should have approached them even though they turned their heads when I looked at them. Any suggestions? Or any explanations why this happens (because this is not the first time I have seen this).

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

jss · 12 Sep 2005

i've had similar experiences....funny thing..it's been in places where there's a large density of singhs....i'd say fateh to people and be completely ignored... and i dont wear bana (well the way it is defined by people here...to me..bana is wearing my 5 kakkars as gifted to me by guru ji)... i've also met people in full bana (dummalla and chola) and been totally ignored when i say fateh to them... so i don't think it's something to do with patka or dastar or dumalla...or clothing...i think it's just individuals who have some sort of personal issue that doesn't allow them to interact in a loving way with their fellow sikhs, and probably others also...

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

N Singh · 12 Sep 2005

BSB Jee I know exactly what you are talking about. I have noticed that our community has the same reaction to me when I go out wearing a Bana, by which I mean a blue chola or a blue Kurta-pjama. Maybe it is an inferiority complex they might have or something else. But I have noticed that when I go out wearing western clothing, our people have no problem greeting me or even approaching me to start a conversation. JSS, how can you say that you are wearing 'bana' when wearing western clothing?

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

... · 12 Sep 2005

I find most..almost all sikhs interact with me alot at school. Wether it be a nod of the head if i see a sikh walking around, or a small chat. I do not have this problem at all.

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

me. · 12 Sep 2005

The above situation stated is very common. Not even just in schools but even walking around the street or in a park or any other largely populated area. I find that most of our elders, when seeing someone in baaNaa walking around in public, are very happy to see someone so dedicated to Sikhi. I remember my first year of University, I’d be walking down the street and Sikh taxi drivers stopped at a red light or a stop sign would always wave or smile or give me a nod of the head. At school – or anywhere with the younger generations – I find that the situation is very different. I’ve been in both situations where I’ve met and talked to lots of Sikhs at school. But I’ve also been in situations where if the person doesn’t look the other way, he/she just STARES with some riduculous look on their faces like they can’t believe someone would wear baaNaa to school. I personally think that individuals are just surprised/shocked to see a Singh/Singhnee in baaNaa in public just because it’s not something someone would see EVERYDAY. Also, the situation changes if the person is with a group of people, or just alone. I find that those who are sitting alone will be more friendly with me, than if they were with a group of their friends where they would ignore or just stare at me. I personally find that still acknowledging them and giving them a Fateh or a nod of the head is still more appropriate to do, rather than do what they did and just ignore someone back. [%sig%]

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

Sakhi · 12 Sep 2005

Neither do I, actually everybody regardless of if they are sikh or not greet me with a smile............maybe I'm just lucky

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

mu-har-har-har · 12 Sep 2005

i have no problems reacting with singhs

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

Kulbir Singh · 13 Sep 2005

I totally agree with the observations of bsb. I travel to and from work in a public train and I have noticed the following: 1) Monnay who are brought up in Canada are reluctant to associate with me. 2) Monnay from India have no problem associating with me. 3) Keshadhari from Canada shy away from other keshadhari. 4) Keshadhari from India have no problem associating with other Keshadhari. Even if two keshadharis from Canada are sitting together, they are almost always talking in English. Once I happened to sit with two Keshadhari (one of them was an amritdhari) persons who were in their thirties. We were coming back from work and sitting in a public transit train. They both kept talking in English and were talking about Hockey, Baseball and other stuff that goray would talk about. I kept sitting as a spectator and in about 10 minutes my patience ran out. I said to one of them, who was acting like a gora, as follows: Kulbir Singh: Yaar bass kar hunn. Mere kann dukhan lag paye han tudaadi bakk bakk sunn ke. (O friend, please cut it out now. My ears have started aching listening to your rubbish). I must say that two fully keshadhari and amritdhari persons sitting together and talking in English about Baseball and Hockey look very absurd. It is an ugly sight. Keshadhari Number 1: (Getting defensive), what is wrong with speaking English. I have not read it anywhere in Gurbani that speaking English is wrong. Kulbir Singh: So you must be speaking English at home with your wife and children, right? Keshadhari Number 1: Of course I do. I am not comfortable with speaking in Punjabi. Kulbir Singh: At least, you can converse in Punjabi but I have a feeling that your children cannot speak a sentence of pure Punjabi. You probably are able to understand and speak Punjabi since your parents spoke Punjabi to you but your children will not speak Punjabi at all because you don’t speak Punjabi to them. Keshadhari Number 1: As I said before, I don’t thing there is any problem with not speaking Punjabi and speaking English only. Kulbir Singh: But how will you understand the message of Gurbani then? Keshadhari Number 1: I have access to translations. This is the new age Singh jee. When we can read translations, then what is the need to learn the old language of Gurbani? Kulbir Singh: But why do you want to rely on a third person to interpret Gurbani for you? Isn’t it better to get the message of Gurbani directly from Guru Sahib? He kept arguing like this but in the end, after much persuasion, he agreed that we should understand Punjabi and that learning Punjabi can help us become better Sikhs. I think it is our duty to learn Punjabi and ensure that our kids learn Punjabi. All our scriptures are in Punjabi and if we don’t learn Punjabi, how will we understand them? Why depend on a third person to interpret the most simple pankities of Gurbani? Coming back to the subject, I think it is really bad that now a days, a Sikh shies away from a Sikh and avoids him. In olden days, Singhs used to long for darshan of other Singhs and this is evident from Gurbani pankitis like: Gursikhaan kee Har dhoor deh, Hum paapi bhee gatt paahe|| (O Hari, give me the dust of charan of Gursikhs, so that sinner like me may be saved). Aaye Mil Gursikh aaye mil, tu mere Guru ke pyaaray|| (Come meet me O Gursikh, O my Guru’s beloved, come meet me) Kulbir Singh

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

numero uno · 13 Sep 2005

heres how it is, kesdhari especially indian granthis look down on monei as if their some kind of cursed muck they only smile and greet other kesdharis. this means monei intrepret kesdaris around them as only looking at someones outer appearance. If you go through it once ok twice hm thrice hmm quadruaple merga hmmm then countless times they will automatically feel kesdharis to be distant themselves. this affcets the decent kesdaris who do want to associatew with fellow sikhs and monei while the minority of screwfaced giani types walk away causing their own little walls to make themselves feel bigger than monei. Dont blame the gianni types though they themselves get it roughshodd from the sangats in gurdwaras and arfe treated like baiyeh. So they get their own little revenge back to boost their own ego thats all it is. In fact we should bear the oputcome and work on relations with people this will help to break miscionceptions diffuse barriers and create exposeure to gurmat life as being the funky thing rather than something that is viewed using giani types as examples let us educate the mass on guremat living through love and slowly wean em in.

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

realhistory · 13 Sep 2005

I don't know about the situation in Canada, but in England most monay, keshdhari guys ignore people in Bana because they assume that anyone in Bana is a member of the UK Nangs and is a bhang drinking, alcohol swigging, goat killing druggie. Sorry but these Nangs have brought disgrace on the Bana

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

Gandalf · 13 Sep 2005

This may be due to the promotion of a lifestyle where some people won't affiliate with or eat food made by people they view to be non-Sikhs? I personally try to at least acknowledge everyone who I think is Sikh (sardar), but if I see someone who I know would not sit down and have a meal with me, I don't want anything to do with that person. I will be polite with that person, but will not go out of my way for that person. If you are going to shun people because of their beliefs, don't be surprised when people shun you back. Don't complain about it either. I have experienced myself Singhs who have looked the other way when I have said Fateh to them (and I am certain it is because I do not live up to their measuring stick of Sikhi). And we shouldn't be preaching to others, who we don't know, about how they live their lives. We don't know what other peoples' situations are. Focus on improving ourselves. Not others. Being preachy and forcing your views on others usually pushes people away from Sikhi. bsb - I am not saying that you do this, but I am saying that this does happen in our community.

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

5 rivers martyrz · 13 Sep 2005

Realhistory praji it stretches way beyond the nang era. still a good number of singhs with kes think they can demand monez to keep kes by making them feel bad about it. Then they end up getting blanked and causing negative image to visible sikh and themselves. Instead of using their image and kes as confidence to push the people down they should adopt a hug love type attitude so people feel at ease. the nangs do this and make good number, but it should not be nang theng singhs should be open more, and consider the state of sikh affairs first than ritualistically using lines to suit narrow agendas. The biggest problems our ritualistic brothers face is they do not realistically address the sikh world and hence no realistic solutions that could even half work than nothing working. Theres a good number of uk singhs who openly proudly and feel it a religious duty to completly ignore monez because theres a line about kutte kaffar shaitan. In my view no sikh should use guru jis works to justify their own thing but to look at the whole of the banis and then they would be more open minded rather than selecting a line to hate monez.

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

Singh · 13 Sep 2005

"I personally try to at least acknowledge everyone who I think is Sikh (sardar), but if I see someone who I know would not sit down and have a meal with me, I don't want anything to do with that person. I will be polite with that person, but will not go out of my way for that person." Hmm, so if a white person or a chinese or someone else wanted to sit down and share a meal of seafood or something with you and you declined, due to it being against your beliefs, should they then treat you as stated above?

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

.. · 13 Sep 2005

unfortunatly for me i live in a place with very few singhs who are proud enough of themselves to wear full bana however if they did i woudl be more the happy to smile or have a conversation. however if they luked to be very..serious so to speak i may think smiling is wrong as i have chatted to some singhs who say they look to the floor to stop them ever feeling lust or such feelings. for that reason ppl may hesitate to smile as they think it is not appropriate to do so. just a observation thats all.

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

Gandalf · 13 Sep 2005

If someone sat down next to me, I would not eat meat with them. I would eat my meal and let them eat theirs. Many times at work, I go to lunch with other people and they eat whatever they choose. In the end all it comes down to is this: Let people live how they want to live.

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

Singh · 13 Sep 2005

"Many times at work, I go to lunch with other people and they eat whatever they choose. In the end all it comes down to is this: Let people live how they want to live." Exactly. So it shouldn't bother you so much if someone chooses not to go to lunch with people or to eat from other people. If someone brings their meal and eats it and doesn't take your food, it shouldn't be a concern to you. Let them live how they want.

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

lost · 14 Sep 2005

bsb do you wear a chola or kurta pajama to college/university if you wear a kurta pajama... thats wicked but if you wear a chola... ur a gangsta ;-) ...if you do... singh i rate you may you remain in chardi kala ps if i met you or any bana wearing Gursikh i would def say FATEH!

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

The Khalsa Fauj · 14 Sep 2005

Kulbir Singh Ji. You take the go train too? Might have seen mw before. I go to Ryerson. Light blue turban. Talk to me if you see me.

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

harpreet · 15 Sep 2005

Im a amritdari kid (teenager) and I love talking about hockey and baseball. Usually i speak in english with friends on the train or whatever. Didn't know this was against gurmat. GO LEAFS GO!

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

Kulbir Singh · 15 Sep 2005

-------- Im a amritdari kid (teenager) and I love talking about hockey and baseball. Usually i speak in english with friends on the train or whatever. Didn't know this was against gurmat. GO LEAFS GO! ---------- I didn't say that speaking English was against Gurmat. What I mean to say is that to replace our mother tongue Punjabi with English is not a wise thing to do. It is a terrible sight to see two Singhs conversing in pure English, without any regard to Punjabi. -------- GO LEAFS GO! --------- GO NAAM GO!! GO GURBANI GO!! GO REHIT GO!! GO KHALSA GO!! Kulbir Singh

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

observer · 15 Sep 2005

it is true about UK.... 5- 10 year ago, everyone loved wearing bana. Since UK nangs have come the scene, i know alot of Singhs who wear it less coz they do not want to be associated with nangs

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

Singhni MiriPiri · 16 Sep 2005

WaheguruJiKaKhalsaWaheguruJiKiFateh Similar things happen to me as well. When there are Sikhs or monay, they can't even stare at me and just act as if I don't exist. And sometimes they begin to harass me. However, when instead there’s goray, they can’t stop staring at me and smiling. For example, whilst I was waiting for the tube in the station a gori was walking past and she smiled and said hi. This also occurs with males. Plus, I don’t even wear a bana. WaheguruJiKaKhalsaWaheguruJiKiFateh

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

Dogma · 16 Sep 2005

"Since UK nangs have come the scene, i know alot of Singhs who wear it less coz they do not want to be associated with nangs" ....sad.

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

Singh · 16 Sep 2005

there some sikhs at my school like that..i walk through the hallway i no there amritdhari and once they see me they turn away, nothing i can do, atleast there parents say fateh to me when i see them...

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

... · 19 Sep 2005

I have never came across another amritdari singh who turned away from me. That would honestly piss the crap otu of me and im glad its never happened.

Re: Ashamed of Seeing Singhs?

.. · 21 Sep 2005

a chola? what is this?