Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

lareedar saroop

lareedar saroop

daas · 13 Sep 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh i was jus reading one of the other posts and they mentioned the 2 terms lareedar saroop and padd ched.. can anyone plz tell me the differences.. . bhul chuk maaf waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ka fateh

Re: lareedar saroop

Ek Kaur · 13 Sep 2005

I believe the original body of The Guru Granth Sahib was composed in joined up writing and is referred to as lareedar saroop. (I think lareedar means continuous and saroop means image.) Paad Chedd ... he hee.. well I don't think this is really a technical term. It's just used to indicate interference or rather distruction. (Paad means to rip... and ched means to touch or interfere)

Re: lareedar saroop

... · 13 Sep 2005

actually , Pad=word Chhed=split It is indeed a technical term.

Re: lareedar saroop

Ek Kaur · 13 Sep 2005

oops! I apologise. Please forgive my ignorance.

Re: lareedar saroop

daas · 13 Sep 2005

so would gutkas etc be classified as pad chedd?

Re: lareedar saroop

lost · 14 Sep 2005

Having seen the handwritten moolmantars i have lost the enthusiasm i gained at Khalsa Camp to ensure all Gurdwaras have only lareedar saroops. why are the moolmantars padd-ched... someone reply

Re: lareedar saroop

Singh · 14 Sep 2005

lost, Dont' be so 'lost' over the hukumnamas. These mool mantars are signatures to authenticate that Guru Sahib authorised them. When you write a signature, is it your regular handwriting? No of course not. The main and unmistakable fact remains that Guru Granth Sahib saroops were ALL in laridaar. But ok, lets even do a little analysis of the hukumnamas that are being called "pad-chhed". First as i said they are signatures, not a normal writing of bani. If you want to see Guru Hargobind Sahib's gutka Sahib (kept in Ghudani Kalan village) it is laridaar. Guru Hargobind Sahib's mool mantar signature is clearly not pad chhed. It breaks the words Nir and bo and moorat and parsaad. It is obviously not pad-chhed. The top one (seems to be a fake actually since the kartarpuri bir is not authentic and the supposed signature of Guru Sahib here does not match the others samples we have) even it, breaks nirvair. The signature of Guru Har Rai Sahib also can't be called 'pad chhed' since it is not all that spaced and it is missing a lot of laganmatras. Even words are spaced, like A-joonee is spaced and Satnam is written S A T N (a) M. Is that pad-chhed to you? Moving right along to Guru Tegh Bahadur jee's signature (yes, again, these are signature which are different than usual writing), Nirvair and Akal are joined. Notice the long strokes like for a usual signature. Saibhang and Gurparsaad are also joined. Are they one word? Is this pad-chhed? Where is the pad chhed????? Don't get confused. It's crystal clear. All birs of Guru Granth Sahib are not written in this signature format. They are all unbroken laridaar. Even Guru Sahib's writing outside of signatures is unbroken and in laridaar. Where's the doubt??

Re: lareedar saroop

. · 15 Sep 2005

http://www.sikhitothemax.com/new/Larree.asp?PageNo=1

Re: lareedar saroop

ummm · 16 Sep 2005

is that all you gained at KC, to try and make sure all g'waras have laredar saroop ???? perhaps you should learn to do paat from this saroop first, no point in removing the birs if no one can read the paat !!!!

Re: lareedar saroop

Bani is my Guru · 16 Sep 2005

"singh " that s poor argument yaar , the point is Guru is bani and not the paper or the ink , and unfortunatly some people get caught up in the paper and ink rather than the bani itself. At least with a pad shed saroop a Gurmukh scholar would have doen khooj to see where teh words should split , rather than some nornal gursikh trying to read laridaar and making a billion mistakes. I'm sorry but in my eyes all of you who think that pad shed saroop is not Guru have not undertood who your Guru is.

Re: lareedar saroop

999 · 16 Sep 2005

couldnt agrre more great post -bani is mu guru

Re: lareedar saroop

other singh · 16 Sep 2005

bani is my guru, yes, bani is the guru, but the gurgadi was undeniably given to a saroop in which the bani was placed. Just like when the guru's were in human form, the bani was within them. When dealing with the guru's in human form, would you use the same argument? The skin and bones isn't the guru? Granted, bani is the guru, but that bani is placed in a complete form within a saroop for us to access and that saroop is included in the guruship. The point of keeping a lareedhar saroop is to keep that banee in its complete form as given by our gurusaahib. It has to be noted as well, that Gurbanee was around since the time of Guru Nanak Dev Jee, well before gurgadi was given to Guru Granth Saahib Jee. Perhaps you need to think a little more about what the gurgadii represents and how it relates to gurbani in it's more abstract form. I think Guru Gobind Singh Jee was well aware of how difficult or easy it would be for someone to do paat from lareedhar. This is actually quite a simple matter. Most of us will agree that our guru is perfect. Those who support padched will say that both lareedhar and padched are essentially the same (same banee) and are both just as perfect. Well, if that were the case, then there would have been no need to replace lareedhar with padched. The reason we replaced it is because we say that it is easier to read and gives more access for regular sikhs. In other words, the lareedhar saroop given gurgadi by guru sahib was too difficult. It was perfect in every other sense, but had one flaw and we, the sikhs, have removed this flaw and 'improved' our guru. There was no other reason to replace Lareedhar saroop other than that we thought that we had added some new quality to it (ease of reading and accessibility) that the original was lacking. Can a guru ka sikh find a fault in his guru and make changes to his guru? Or does the sikh change to walk the path of the guru, no matter how difficult? By the way, this has nothing to do with ink and paper. As far as I am aware, both lareedhar and padched require ink and paper. The point is how gurbani in it's written and complete form was presented to us. About the moolmanters, the singh above has answered that quite nicely. There is no clear pad ched pattern there. The breaks happen in different positions, possibly due to lifting the pen while writing quickly (as would happen in a signature). This is just a wild guess though and only Guru Saahib knows why they did what they did. Bottom line though, banee found in granths from the time of the guru's is always in lareedhar format. Always. Despite how they may have signed hukamnamas and letters, gurbanee in Guru Granth Sahib was in lareedhar format.

Re: lareedar saroop

Singh · 16 Sep 2005

Bani is my guru, The Guru is bani. But the form Guru Sahib gave to us. Guru Sahib gave us laridaar. A Gurmukh scholar may have broken the words but what if he broke them wrong? Is "panakaj moh" right (and the Guru) or is "pank ju moh"? If it's already broken by someone you have no choice. You dont' reflect, you just read what is there. Any "normal" gursikh can read laridaar with just a bit of effort. And they may make mistakes but those mistakes can be corrected. If it's pad-chhed, you can be a perfect reader but that mistake that is enshrined in the wrong pad-chhed can't be corrected. It is my mistake vs. the mistake in the Gurbani. And we all know gurbani can't be wrong. I have understood perfectly what my Guru is. Would it be ok to re-arrange Gurbani according to Gurus? Ie. Guru Nanak then Guru Angad then Guru Amardas? No? Why not? It's still bani right? What's the harm? Same answer: we can't alter what GUru Sahib gave to us.

Re: lareedar saroop

Kulbir Singh · 16 Sep 2005

Last two posts - Amazing posts! Thanks, Kulbir Singh

Re: lareedar saroop

sad · 16 Sep 2005

yes other singh, bani was placed inthe saroop and guru jee gave gurgaddi,then he only gave gurgaddi to the one saroop so thats the true saroop yes? all other lareddaars are copies or printed....no? instead of wasting time on these issues we should we be doing as much paath,simran keertan for who knows how long we have left, these issues were here b4 us and they will be here after us, best to love and respect guru jee as much as we can rather than worrying which saroop is on the thabiya when we goto the gurdwara, as we will then loose as soon as we walk in as we question is this the right guru is this the wrong guru- anyone doing this will spiritually feel the loss themselves if u dont believe me test it and see

Re: lareedar saroop

. · 16 Sep 2005

http://www.sikhitothemax.com/new/Larree.asp?PageNo=1

Re: lareedar saroop

other singh · 16 Sep 2005

'sad,' what's truly sad is that sikhs today consider issues about our guru a waste of time. Our spirituality comes from our guru. If we have a passive attitude towards issues concerning our Guru, can we truly be spiritual sikhs? Just because this issue was before our time... so what? Many issues have been around since before us, should we stick our heads in the dirt for all these issues? Do you really think it doesn't matter what sits on tabiyaa? What if we did what 'singh' mentioned above (changing the order of Guru Granth Saahib Jee around) and did prakash of that, would that be okay too? We place our heads at the feet of this guru, we dedicate our lives to this guru, you don't think we should be concerned about changes made to this guru? If Guru Gobind Singh Jee was sitting there and someone slashed Guru Saahib, would we not be concerned? We talk about respect and bayadvee of Guru Saahib all the time. Deciding that Guru Saahib, isn't good enough for us and changing the guru to meet our desires, is the biggest form of disrespect ever. Do you really think this hasn't and won't have an effect on us? sad said, "then he only gave gurgaddi to the one saroop so thats the true saroop yes?" No, not quite. What we are discussing is the form of the guru, the form in which Gurbanee was passed to us. In His divine wisdom, Guru Gobind Singh Jee presented us with Gurbanee in such a saroop that sikhs could make copies of it and the copies would also represent the Guru. In fact, at the time of passing the Gurgaddi to Guru Granth Saahib Jee, there were other copies around as well. Guru Saahib gave status of Guru to the Granth Saahib and this status went to all the Granths that contained Gurbanee in its complete and full form as given by Guru Saahib. Just as when status of Guru was given to the Panth and 5 piaray were declared guru roop, the status wasn't bestowed simply on only those five particular singhs. It extended to any who could fit that mould and could represent the panth. Guruship was given to 'Granth Saahib' and any Bir containing Gurbanee in it's full and unaldultered form was considered as Granth Saahib. Sad Jee, please don't try to cloud the issue. The issue of Lareedhar saroop is quite clear and the issue of a specific Bir is unrelated to the topic at hand.

Re: lareedar saroop

ummm · 19 Sep 2005

"Guruship was given to 'Granth Saahib' and any Bir containing Gurbanee in it's full and unaldultered form was considered as Granth Saahib." This is an interesting point, for months I have been reading posts on this subject and as of yet there are still quesitons on this topic which remain unanswered, the question of the saroop is a very specific, the saroop as changed format many a time for the Bir that rec'd Guruship to the birs today which are printed nice and tidly, perhaps someone who has done khoj on the older birs can clairfy that the lines ended like the do now ?? or did the roll over to the next line ??? where the word broken even further like the mool mantars are ?? The thing I can't get out of my head is the we are basically talking about styles of writing ??? why would guru ji worry about a style of writing ??? its like we are talking about the presentation a lot more than what Bani is ??? when the printers print with their templates, i would expect them to use Gurmukhi fonts etc, a font type cannot be considered the be all and end all of a bir, confusing I know but what the above writers write is more confusing for me. The panj pyare analogy cannot be used in this context or you are belittling this idealogy, the panj pyare that gave their heads to Guru ji were unique and always will be, sevadars who do seva in panj anywhere in the world cannot be even considered in the same category, these sevadars would be the first to say this, so the argument you have presented against the concept of the orginal saroop in invalid and very weak, one thing you have to accept is that if you are going off about jyot etc, there can only be one bir that is accpeted in this argument and that is the bir which Guru ji passed the Gurgaddi too, just as when Guru Nanak Dev ji passed on the Guruship to Guru Angad dev ji. Perhaps its one of those discussions which can go on and on, people are 100% pro will find new points to convince others and peopl who are not pro will find arguments to refute it. As others have said perhaps its better to get on with learning Gurbani paath to the best of your ability and being comfortable enough to do paath from either saroop, which in itself will take dedication and effort on any individual.

Re: lareedar saroop

KS · 19 Sep 2005

which Saroop did Guru Gobind Singh Ji pass on the Gurgadi to? Anyone know of its location?

Re: lareedar saroop

999 · 19 Sep 2005

well said other singh, you seem very adamant on your thoughts you are right we place our heads in front of guru jee and TRY to dedicate our life to guru jee in yearning for his blessings. we are not guru gobind singh and not above guru jee to decide who is guru, guru granth sahib jee is the guru and will always be. sad has pointed out we should spend more time doing paath/simran and keertan as these are the only beneficial acts we can do. when doing paath there is no such thing as laredaar paath all gurbani is pad ched to the listener. and we as listeners are yearning for the rass not going to check which bir it is as that is the real mistake. bani is the guru the more we understand that the further we will progress.

Re: lareedar saroop

RoopKaur · 19 Sep 2005

>The thing I can't get out of my head is the we are basically talking about styles of writing ??? why would guru ji worry about a style of writing ??? < The difference between laridaar and pad ched is not just a style of writing. It is a difference of languages. bani is written in gurmukhi, and we use our own mat to put punjabi on it and make it pad ched. We mistakenly think that Punjai and Gurmukhi are the same, but they are not. Many people say we need to do more paath and simran, rather than looking at what bir it is. It is this kind of passivist opinions prevalent in the panth that have led us to the dire situation of today, where the panth on a whole has lost their guru. These attitudes belittle the importance of guru ji. Guru ji was perfect, how can we manukhs use our own mat to slash gurbani apart? How can a bir that is based on a manukhs logic and mat ever be equal to the perfect bir (Laridar bir) that guru ji gave their jot to? If this is the case, then any person that prints their version of guru jis bir in pad ched will have differences, which one will you call guru ji? If guru ji is sat. and there can only be one TRUTH, how can we have multiple guru jis? In our history, since Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji, we have had only one Guru ji at a specific time, never did we have two guru jis. How can we have two now? This issue is not one the panth can afford to dismiss and ignore. Before people make passivist comments, they should think of the consequences of their comments. What are you accomplishing by leading the panth astray from their real guru ji. It is time we stop pad ched birs, and bring back our guru ji in their Laridar saroop.

Re: lareedar saroop

.......... · 19 Sep 2005

dear roopkaur way to go, did you know that bhai sahib was alive when the pad-ched was done he did not make half the hoo hah you are making over this matter, we should learn from our elders. yes guru ji gave his jyot to gurbani.... it might be passivist to you but you are the one confused, yes padched is created by a number of scholars only guru jee knows if they were right or wrong(bear in mind the above point about bhai sahib) dont get me wrong i am not against laredaar to me my guru is gurbani therefore bothe saroops have equal respect in my eyes, i am against people thinking they can give guruship to a guru whos already here and on the throne for the last 300 years. there is not multiple guru jees just the one as the gurbani is the same read 999s post again its what you listen to it wont sound any different unless your an unexperienced pathi doing path from laredaar saroop with xxxxxx mistakes

Re: lareedar saroop

other singh · 19 Sep 2005

"the one as the gurbani is the same " There are several hundred differences in padched in padched saroops printed by different printers. So no, the gurbani actually isn't the same. Even meanings change. I don't know what's so difficult to understand about this. Many people have pointed this out, yet people keep claiming that the gurbani is the same. One of the main points for lareedhar is that the banee isn't the same. We're talking hundreds of differences put in intentionally. It's one thing if patees do paat differently. If they screw up, it's their mistake. It's another thing altogether to make these differences permanent by enshrining them in Guru Granth Saahib Jee. We don't have that right, only guru saahib does. Also, about Bhai Sahib, he wrote against it in quite strong language and the AKJ was adamantly for Lareedhar saroop until today. It's only in the last few years, with the jatha reaching it's current super chardi kala state, that singhs in the AKJ have started questioning the need for lareedhar. Also, at the time Bhai Saahib was alive, padched printing had started, but the majority of saroops were still lareedhar. Bhai Saahib Randheer Singh still spoke out against it quite strongly.

Re: lareedar saroop

other singh · 19 Sep 2005

"there can only be one bir that is accpeted in this argument and that is the bir which Guru ji passed the Gurgaddi too" Explain why. Why can the jot only be in one saroop? If you're saying that bani is the guru (which it is) and if that bani is left unchanged and placed in a saroop as the original was, then why won't the jot be there? If you change the banee, only then is there a problem. When you make banee padched, you are changing it. In mool mantar, scholars who have done ched, can't yet agree on whether it is Satnaam or Sat Naam. And yes, by changing the pad ched of this, you do modify the meaning. Which saroop contains the intended message of guru saahib? The Sat Naam saroop or the Satnaam saroop? Why not let the saroop remain as it was and let the patee make a mistake rather than putting the mistake in Guru Saahib. By making padched, you are invariably making changes to the meanings of certain shabads, so the Gurbani is not the same. Of course, guru saahib is bakshanhaar and can overlook mistakes. However, unlike unintentional mistakes made in printing, these padched 'mistakes' aren't really mistakes. They are put in purposely. The panj piaray were unique, however, the institution of panj is the same. Panj giving amrit today are just as guru roop as the panj back then. If you don't believe this, then you are invalidating the amrit sinchaar process.

Re: lareedar saroop

.......... · 19 Sep 2005

yes bhai sahib did write strongly against pad ched, his words were doing pad ched is manmatt, on the next page of bhai sahibs book he writes even printing gurbani padched is manmtt... THEN WHY did bhai sahib not make a huge fuss when most of his books were printed while they were alive and have them destroyed and reprint them with laredaar gurbani??????? i dont think we have understood bhai sahib, his actions spoke louder than words...thats why i say please think before you say something that will damage yourselves....you will find xyz reasons but no reason is bigger than bhai sahibs actions.. most sangat across the world accept guru granth sahib as guru jee and regularly goto the gurdwara for their various mangaa as per there shardaa, to destroy there faith in guru jee(gurbani) will be the biggest manmatt.there are many people taking gursikhs away from guru jee iekalaafghana, sdo, radhaswami, etc we should be focussing our energy on them where we could help someone back onto the path of gursikhi not push away the sangat we haave

Re: lareedar saroop

ummm · 20 Sep 2005

"In our history, since Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji, we have had only one Guru ji at a specific time, never did we have two guru jis. How can we have two now? This was the question that I was going to ask, I have heard this before as well, lets not think with our limited maat on this question, when Guru nanak dev ji passed the Guruship on to Bhai Lehna ji who in turn was Guru Angad Dev ji. Did Guru Nanak Dev ji stop being Guru ???? Think about what you are saying, we can all get carried away with this discussion but don't try and change what happened, it would be interesting to hear the thought of other learned virs on this point, this whole Jyot thing is being totally misunderstood, what is this Jyot that we think we know about ??? Gurjot ?? maharaj tells us "ssabh mehi joth joth hai soe || this dhai chaanan sabh mehi chaanan hoe || gur saakhee joth paragatt hoe ||" need we say more about jyot... we could do start going to n'th degreee on this, questions such as when does the jyot reside in the bir ?? when the pannea are being printed ??, when the bir is put into one jilad ?? when when when ???? do we see what we are actually doing here ???? we are begining to question everthing and anything.... yes Bhai sahib wrote agains padched, as Veer Kulbir Singh has stated in the past, but when asked the question why are all bhai sahibs books contatin bani in padched ??? there is no concrete answer. We need to think about how we want to reintroduce laridar bir back into the panth, to type on message boards and basically condemn everything about Pad ched bir is not syanip, because if we truly believe this then why did singhs in Toronto go and help rescue a bir from Narinder grewal, sikhs in the UK go out of their way in "respect Guru Granth Sahib" campaign, is this all a waste of time ??? since according to the majority of emails on this board this bir isn't even Guru Ji ???? let us think about a system of how to teach Gurbani Paath to the masses, create something online, think about the future, if we want the laridar bir parkashed and not the pad ched bir, start educating through teaching, this is the only way that people will appreciate what you are saying. Some of the points made or questions raised go down a dangerous path, as every point raised either way can be ripped apart by the other side, what is the benefit ??? only education of teaching gurbani santhiya will bring about awareness and understanding.

< Lareedaar and other slippages >

jugroop singh · 20 Sep 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Dearest Veer/Bhain '..........' ji, you wrote: "did you know that bhai sahib was alive when the pad-ched was done he did not make half the hoo hah you are making over this matter" Veer/Bhain Ji, this comment is absolutely irrelevant? you're simply detracting from the issue. lets just imagine that Bhai Sahib never did any parchaar against it, which is ofcourse highly unlikely given his outspoken views on other issues such as Keski, Raagmala, Maas etc., your point is still neither here nor there...my point is that Bhai Sahib was an awe-inspiring GurMukh...one could say a prime example - but he was NOT Siree Guru Sahib Ji - remember i'm saying this all DESPITE the fact that besides Siree Guru Sahib Ji, i find him to be one of the most inspiring humans i have ever had the pleasure to learnt about! the reason i'm saying all this is because the arguments that have been put forward by the pro-Lareedar Veers and Bhains have been put forward in the name of Siree Guru Sahib Ji NOT Bhai Sahib so if you wish to argue against Lareedar, then please argue against the One who is above ALL awe-inspiring GurSikhs/Sants/MahaPurakhs etc. after all, is is Siree GurBani Sahib Ji Himself, who Himself as Sareer-Roop, committed Bani to its present day Granth-Roop...not any GurMukh/Sant/MahaPurakh. how can a human-being even dare to 'compete' by deciding with their MUN what kind of MAT should be applied to breakage of GurShabad Roop GurBani??? Dearest Veer/Bhain Ji, when you look at it from this perspective, you will soon realise that there can be no valid argument against Lareedaar; Pad-Chedd is the act of LIMITED human-beings KNOWINGLY re-wording/re-phrasing GurBani which is, in its original SHABAD-ROOP, ALL-PERFECT... how else to describe Pad-Chedd but, as one prominent GurMukh did, as Maha-MunMat...i don't mean to offend but this is such a basic issue - the WHOLE PANTH should be fighting the Lareedaar corner! why should Jatha, primarily, have to bear the responsibility...all other Panthic organisations should take a stand, and promote GurMat over MunMat. despite not being blessed with Amrit yet and therefore not chardi-kalaa in any way, i feel i still must say the following...because we shouldn't hold-back from speaking in favour of Siree Guru Sahib Ji just because we're 'worried' what others may say...or how they may judge us. i personally find it truly tragic that (at least here in the UK) Jatha does not always understand and implement promotion of Lareedaar...even though it 'implicitly' is supposed to be pro-Lareedaar. this is truly sad because at one point, it was this very Jatha who truly understood, enshrined and implemented such a FUNDAMENTAL GURU-BLESSED CONCEPT... this is just one issue amongst a set of broader Panthic issues. it is my humble opinion that if Jatha does not correct its stance worldwide, then it will soon diminish...this is just a feeling; only Siree Guru Sahib Ji knows. Siree Guru Sahib ji blesses His Panth with Seva just as he blesses it with His Nadar - according to it's devotion and Udham... in my humble opinion, Jatha-affiliated Singhs were only ever-blessed with Mahaan Seva such as imprisonment, torture and Shaheedian in the first place because of their REHIT AND ASOOLS which were the very reason behind their Prem for Siree Guru Sahib Ji...devotion to LareeDaar Saroop, GurMat Swaas-Swaas Naam Abhiyaas Kamaee, strict NitNem, attachment to Keski/Dastaar for ALL and Bibek. it is Seva and not 'anti-Ekta' to promote GurMat; despite others pointing fingers and saying: 'why are you splitting-up the Panth'. the Panth is only weak when it MOVES AWAY from Siree Guru Sahib Ji; not when people point to major issues which place KIRPA upon the Panth... these are just my feelings and not meant to offend - if they do offend some UK Jatha Singhs who think all the above is a bit 'hardcore', then i beg that you please understand my sincere intentions...i think we should ALWAYS call a spade a spade; ESPECIALLY when applying GurMat Bibek to our own beliefs and actions. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: lareedar saroop

ummmm.... · 20 Sep 2005

Veer Jugroop Singh,Do you consider all those guriskhs in AJKUK who have had amrit in prescence of a pad ched bir amritdhari or not ??? Do you consider all the marriages that have taken place in front of a padched bir legitmate or not ???? Basically people say things and don't have a clue what they are implying, "after all, is is Siree GurBani Sahib Ji Himself, who Himself as Sareer-Roop, committed Bani to its present day Granth-Roop...not any GurMukh/Sant/MahaPurakh. how can a human-being even dare to 'compete' by deciding with their MUN what kind of MAT should be applied to breakage of GurShabad Roop GurBani???" It is humans who print the birs !!! it is humans who have changed the layout of the pages from the orginal bir !!!, it is humans who have removed nearly 400 pages from the orginal bir by condensing it !!!, the list could go on and on, yet all your argument is that style of writing was joined up ???? "this is just one issue amongst a set of broader Panthic issues. it is my humble opinion that if Jatha does not correct its stance worldwide, then it will soon diminish...this is just a feeling; only Siree Guru Sahib Ji knows. Siree Guru Sahib ji blesses His Panth with Seva just as he blesses it with His Nadar - according to it's devotion and Udham... " If you believe that this one issue will be the diminshing of jatha, i think you live in a different world to the rest of us, through guru jis grace akj uk continues to seva, parchar, amrit sanchars around UK & Europe, if you are talking about time being a factor, jathas generally come and go, the only thing that is permanent is panth and sikhi... to me it sounds like you have accepted one argument and are 100% fixated on that, perhaps you need to look at the bigger picture of what you are saying, you yourself openly admit that you haven't rec'd amrit yet, but are openly questioning the sikhi of those who have done seva for 35 years in the UK ??? Veer ji, please answer the above question so I can work out wheter or not its worth wasting my time debating with someone who has decided who is amritdhari or not ????? when no other the Guru ji can decide who is my sikh and who isn't !!!

Re: lareedar saroop

other singh · 20 Sep 2005

The question as to why Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh and other gursikhs who condemned pad ched allowed their books to be printed in pad ched seems to come up quite a bit. The answer to this is quite simple and forms one of the basic principles for promoting lareedhar, yet many of our brothers and sisters seem to think there is no concrete answer. I'm beginning to think that many of us don't actually read the posts that are 'against' our position thoroughly. If we did, this question wouldn't need to be asked. I ask all the gursikhs reading this thread to do so with an open mind. It's a gursikh's duty to listen to all sides and make up your mind without personal biases. If someone presents a convincing argument showing that there is no difference between lareedhar and padched, I'll definitely be willing to listen. As far as Bhai Saahib having padched in his books goes....the key thing to understand here is that... it was padched in HIS BOOKS, not in Guru Granth Saahib Jee. Since gurbanee is gurbanee, what is the difference? Quite a lot actually. In his books, Bhai Saahib either explains concepts in Sikhi using Gurbanee tuks, or simply explains the meaning of Gubanee Tuks. In other words, he's translating Gurbanee and explaining it according to his own understanding. The first step to translating gurbanee is the padched. If someone else came along and did the padched differently, they would get different meanings. Since Bhai Sahib is trying to explain the meanings of these tuks, he presents them with padched as he believes it should be. In some places, there are even commas to indicate vishraams. Does this mean that Bhai Saahib would approve placing commas in Guru Granth Saahib Jee? Obviously not. Anyone reading these books is well aware that these books are by Bhai Saahib Randheer Singh Jee (not by Guru Saahib) and that Bhai Saahib has written his thoughts and understanding of gurmat. That's why the books have Bhai Saahib's name prominently on the cover. And as such, the reader is also well aware that Bhai Saahib has done the pad ched of and translated the gurbanee tuks according to his matt. Say a Taksalee or a Missionary Veer were to read these tuks.. would they agree with how all the padched was done and all the meanings presented? Highly unlikely. So would it now make sense if Bhai Saahib had prepared an entire saroop by doing padched according to his understanding and placed it in gurdvaras in place of a lareedhar saroop? Perhaps if his name were placed on the cover as the editor, it might be acceptable as a pothi showing padched, but otherwise, no. This point, about tuks in Bhai Saahib's books, illustrates perfectly why having padched saroops is wrong. Doing padched is the first step of translating gurbanee. It is useful for essays, books and Gurbanee Steeks but NOT for Guru Granth Saahib Jee. Pad Ched represents one person's, or two people's or 100 people's understanding of gurbanee. It is not neccessarily the correct understanding and may not be what our Guru's wanted us to understand. We have absolutely no right to alter Guru Saahib's Gurbanee and present it as if it were still the original. For god's sake, I don't even have the right to change some modern author's writing and pass if off as the original. Yet we think we can do this for Guru Saahib. Bhai Saahib was well aware of why padched is wrong and never attempted to place his mat on Guru Saahib. When his books were printed, padched and commas (occasionaly) were used, since he was translating Gurbanee. This is similar to pothees written by Sant Gurbachan Singh and other singhs. Never was padched used as a replacement for the original. This is why Bhai Saahib uses such strong language to condemn padched. Doing padched places one person's understanding on Gurbanee and we cannot do this to Guru Granth Saahib Jee. If you insist that in fact, these books didn't represent translations and that Bhai Saahib was okay with padched saroops, and you also agree that he condemned padched saroops (which you have to since it is stated in his books), then you are calling this jewel of a gursikh, a hypocrite. Perhaps it is your understanding that is flawed. You need to take a step back and try to understand the lareedhar issue properly. Bhai Saahib's books were basically translations and explanations; Guru Granth Saahib Jee is not. It is the source.

Re: lareedar saroop

Mr. Singh · 20 Sep 2005

ummm said, "to type on message boards and basically condemn everything about Pad ched bir is not syanip, because if we truly believe this then why did singhs in Toronto go and help rescue a bir from Narinder grewal, sikhs in the UK go out of their way in "respect Guru Granth Sahib" campaign, is this all a waste of time ??? since according to the majority of emails on this board this bir isn't even Guru Ji ????" If a gutka was being disrespected, would you not do anything? How about a pothi? Kulbir Singh has stated this very nicely many times on this website. Lareedhar saroop is the only true saroop of Guru saahib.... but a gursikh should be able to sacrifice everything for even a letter of gurbanee. Just because someone doesn't accept padched saroop as a replacement for Lareedhar saroop, doesn't mean that they will now accept someone disrespecting the banee in it.

Re: lareedar saroop

other singh · 20 Sep 2005

ummm...... said, "It is humans who print the birs !!! it is humans who have changed the layout of the pages from the orginal bir !!!, it is humans who have removed nearly 400 pages from the orginal bir by condensing it !!!, the list could go on and on, yet all your argument is that style of writing was joined up ????" Umm, do you actually read what anyone else says? Writing style? Will you please just answer 1 simple question for me? It'll clear up a lot of confusion for everyone. <> Is it 'satnaam' (meaning something like 'true is his name') or is it 'sat naam' ('sat' meaning that he is true, eternal and 'naam' meaning that he is naam roop') These are the two different meanings in the panth (there may be more) that are based simply on 'writing style' as you call it. Please explain to everyone which one is correct and should be enshrined in Guru Granth Saahib Jee forevermore and also let us know how it is that writing styles change meanings. Please do answer this, and do so sincerely. There is only a point in debating this if we are sincere in our intentions. This also means that we are willing to accept that we might be wrong. If you are simply arguing this because you feel the need to defend the actions of your elders or the status quo of the AKJ UK and can't accept that perhaps those who you have looked up to may have been wrong in something, then there is nothing to discuss. By the way, the 400 extra angs you mention, weren't found in all puratan saroops. The current saroop that is used is supposed to be based on the Damdamaa saroop, which was written by Bhai Mani Singh Jee as Guru Gobind Singh Jee dictated Gurbanee to him. The Saroop that was present at Nander when Guru Saahib bestowed GurGadi on Guru Saahib, was lost during one of Abdalee's raids, so nobody really knows how many angs it had. Despite differences in ang layout and number of angs, all puratan saroops are larreedhar.

Re: lareedar saroop

!!! · 20 Sep 2005

>>It is humans who print the birs !!! it is humans who have changed the layout of the pages from the orginal bir !!!, it is humans who have removed nearly 400 pages from the orginal bir by condensing it !!!, the list could go on and on, yet all your argument is that style of writing was joined up ????<< you should think before you start typing. itwas humans who bound the original guru granth sahib during SRI GURU Arjun Dev Jees time and GURU Gobind SIngh Jee's times. they also wrote it an d everythng else. but the bani was guru jee's, including how it was written. even teh letters were developed by GURU Angad Dev Jee and of course the writing style was made by guru jee and shabads were written by guru jee and these original shabads and pothies were compiled. so of course humans are going to do the printing and layouts, same as they did back then. but they can't change the actual bani by changing how its written and sounds

Re: lareedar saroop

. · 20 Sep 2005

http://www.sikhitothemax.com/new/Larree.asp?PageNo=1

Re: lareedar saroop

.......... · 20 Sep 2005

dear other singh maybe you should read bhai sahibs books in more detail, on the next page of the book where bhai sahib padched is manmatt he write even printing gurbani padched is manmatt, your answer is not sufficient as you cant see beyond your thinking, try to understand what bhai sahib did and said there is no way i would call bhai sahib a hypocrite as he was one of the greatest gursikhs of all time. also i agree bhai sahib was not guru jee but from reading bhai sahibs books many times over he was alot closer to guru jee than we are. i say again gurbani is guru and both saroops contain gurbani there are printing mistakes in both and could you also answer the points raised by umm....

Re: lareedar saroop

. · 20 Sep 2005

Akaal Purkh > Siri Guru Naanak Dev Sahib Jee > Siri Guru Angad Dev Sahib Jee > Siri Guru Amar Daas Sahib Jee > Siri Guru Raam Daas Sahib Jee > Siri Guru Arjan Dev Sahib Jee > Siri Guru HarGobind Sahib Jee > Siri Guru Har Rai Sahib Jee > Siri Guru Har Krishan Sahib Jee > Siri Guru Teg Bahadur Sahib Jee > Siri Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Jee > Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Gur Parmeshar Aiko Jaan (Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee) PaarBrahm Parmeshar Anoop Safal Moorat Gur Tis Ka Roop (Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee) Bhullan Andar Sabh Ko Abhull Guru Kartaar (Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee)

Re: lareedar saroop

moorakh · 20 Sep 2005

Why do some people say "lareeDAAR" and some say "lareeVAAR" what is the difference and which one is ABSOLUTE MANMAT SO WE CAN BOYCOTT IT (hahahaha, joking).

Re: lareedar saroop

other singh · 20 Sep 2005

........., which other points by ummm would you like me to answer? As far as Bhai Saahib goes, perhaps I am stuck in my own thinking. Or perhaps you're stuck in your thinking. You say he is one of the greastest gursikhs of all time (which I strongly agree with) and that he was much closer to guru Jee than us, which I also strongly agree with. So then if he wrote that padched is manmat, why can't you accept that? There aren't really two ways to interpret what he said. You can also ask the gurmukhs of that time what his stance on Lareedhar was, and they will give you a clear answer, that he was very much against it. So if my explanation isn't good enough, what's yours? He wrote against lareedhar, but he wasn't actually against it? That makes loads of sense. The only way to interpret that is what I've already written in the previous post.

Re: lareedar saroop

.......... · 21 Sep 2005

yes he wrote padched is manmatt and gurbani should not be printed in padched as that is also manmatt butt all 50+books have gurbani printed in them in padched....he did not burn all the books and order reprints, as thiswould have been the case according to bhai sahibs own words but he let it be, why you cannot see that i dont know the other questions i wanted u to answer were inan above post they are "Do you consider all those guriskhs in jatha who have had amrit in prescence of a pad ched bir amritdhari or not ??? Do you consider all the marriages that have taken place in front of a padched bir legitmate or not ????" the gurbani is the same as it was during guru sahibs times, and fyi i understand the laredaar issue better than you think and that is why i say gurbani is guru both saroops are the same the jyot is in gurbani and one day perhaps if we are blessed by guru jee we will see the same

Re: lareedar saroop

Amrik Singh · 21 Sep 2005

I would like to ask a question to canada sangat. My Gursikh friend gave me a laReedaar gutka with nitnem banis. On the Gutka it said it that the gutka was made in Vancoover - Canada. I would like to ask is there a printing place where Gursikhs print lareedaar saroops of maharaj, if this is true, it is a really good seva. Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa Vahiguru ji ki fateh

Re: lareedar saroop

Jugraj Singh · 21 Sep 2005

I think Singh has said it very nicely. >>> think Guru Gobind Singh Jee was well aware of how difficult or easy it would be for someone to do paat from lareedhar. This is actually quite a simple matter. Most of us will agree that our guru is perfect. Those who support padched will say that both lareedhar and padched are essentially the same (same banee) and are both just as perfect. Well, if that were the case, then there would have been no need to replace lareedhar with padched. The reason we replaced it is because we say that it is easier to read and gives more access for regular sikhs. In other words, the lareedhar saroop given gurgadi by guru sahib was too difficult. It was perfect in every other sense, but had one flaw and we, the sikhs, have removed this flaw and 'improved' our guru. There was no other reason to replace Lareedhar saroop other than that we thought that we had added some new quality to it (ease of reading and accessibility) that the original was lacking. Can a guru ka sikh find a fault in his guru and make changes to his guru? Or does the sikh change to walk the path of the guru, no matter how difficult? >>> How a Sikh can argue against this is beyond me.

Re: lareedar saroop

Guru ji help me i'm so weak · 21 Sep 2005

Bani is Guru , guru is bani <<

Re: lareedar saroop

Common Sense · 21 Sep 2005

So many 'well-intentioned' people misinterpret Gurbani to fit it into their own way of thinking. They think they KNOW the true meaning of all of Gurbani, but do they really? I do not think so. So when your 'regular sikh' learns to read 'padd ched' of lareedhar saroop from these sikh scholars, he learns 'their specific way of padd ched'. This could be very dangerous because he will then go on to teach others all the mistakes that he aquired from his santhia teacher who taught him based on his own jatha influence, rehit preference and personal biases. Problem is that most of us just close our eyes and follow these people like sheep. We are just too LAZY to read, learn and understand the "true message" of Gurbani ourselves to become enlightened lions. For example, some singhs will refuse to even accept a grain of food or a sip of water from others for all sorts of reason but they will gladly take their hard earned money. Money that comes from the BLOOD and SWEAT of these very people they condemn as nigurrey, paapi and saakat!!!! I consider such hypocrites totally corrupted in their very basic sikh rehit because they manipulate Gurbani to feed their own selfish purpose. Would they ever see that? No, they are too busy to make everyone else just as 'PERFECT' as themselves.

Re: lareedar saroop

other singh · 21 Sep 2005

.........., Bhai Saahib's books are explanations and translations. At the end of the day, they are books, not Guru Granth Saahib Jee. I am discussing Guru Granth Saahib Jee, not Bhai Randheer Singh's books. If you can't understand the difference, that's your issue. You also haven't given an adequate explanation about why Bhai wrote so strongly against padched. Look, Bhai Saahib's stance on Lareedhar is not a mystery. There is no grey area, no fine lines. He spoke against padched quite openly, wrote against it and and his close companions were all against it as well. The other questions you have asked me to answer were not actually asked of me, but of Veer Jugroop Singh, which is why I didn't bother answering them. My concern is promoting lareedhar saroop and trying to educate people on this. Determining who is amritdharee and what is valid or isn't in terms of ceremonies, is not something that I dwell on and is beyond my scope of thinking, at this point in time. You also stated, "the gurbani is the same as it was during guru sahibs times, and fyi i understand the laredaar issue better than you think and that is why i say gurbani is guru both saroops are the same..." I asked a 'ummm' a question in a previous post. I'll restate it for you as well. <> Is it 'satnaam' (meaning something like 'true is his name') or is it 'sat naam' ('sat' meaning that he is true, eternal and 'naam' meaning that he is naam roop') These are the two different meanings in the panth (there may be more) that are based simply on 'writing style' as you call it. Please explain to everyone which one is correct and should be enshrined in Guru Granth Saahib Jee forevermore and also let us know how it is that writing styles change meanings. Please answer this as it will help me understand your point of view. There are also several hundred other examples that I could ask you about, but we'll leave it at this for now.

Re: lareedar saroop

jugroop singh · 21 Sep 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Dearest Veer/Bhain 'Ummm....' Ji, i wasn't intending to cause such offense...neither do i believe that Pad-Chedd renders everything, such as marriage and Amrit Sanchaar, completely impotent...please do not even think such a thing of me. all i was trying to say is that such an important GurMat issue as the very grammatical structure of GurBani should be accepted by everyone. i then talked about what i sincerely feel are some of UK Jatha's shortcomings; i didn't mean to question personal levels of Seva, Avastha or any other such thing by stating that Jatha is steadily changing its stand on certain key issues. my Sangat is over 99.9% what people would call 'Jatha Singhs'...even though i have not been blessed with Amrit, i am often referred to as a 'Jatha Singh' (i am not worthy of such a comparison). so please do not feel this is 'Jatha-bashing'. if it wasn't Siree Guru Sahib Ji's Kirpa through the UK Jatha Singhs, i wouldn't even be interested in Sikhi; that's how much love i have for the UK Jatha. i did have second thoughts just before i clicked on the 'post' button, but then thought: 'why are you being a coward - you are not saying anything wrong...you are simply in fear of what other Singhs will think of you and so won't speak out for your Siree Guru Ji'. the fact is we should speak out; especially about the things we love dearly. Dear Veer/Bhain Ji, i have not been blessed with Amrit but that shouldn't make me think 'shut-up jugroop singh' out of fear of judgement of others - it felt right to say what i did when i did...i still humbly stand by it 100%. please understand that there should not be a holding-back when we start looking at why things are the way they are...small problems turn into massive problems when people remain quiet. and it is in this sense i made my points - i sincerely think that if Jatha re-embraces the very GurMat practices that have blessed it since the early 20th Century, the example of Pristine Khalsa Practice will once again shine that brightly...in theory, there is no reason why the kind of Sangat that existed in Bhai Sahib's days cannot exist today. i am not the only person who thinks this; many UK Jatha Singhs feel the same way. i think we are seeing such changes in our lifetime; from what i have learnt and personally experienced, the Tapoban Sahib Jatha Singhs have been given a very important Seva by Siree Guru Sahib Ji...and that is to re-introduce those very things i feel have slowly but surely been disappearing. is it ok if i make this my last msg on this thread - i have probably hurt a lot of sentiments and did not intend to...i also can't possibly think as to what other response i can give to anything that has been raised, which hasn't been written in my two posts. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: lareedar saroop

.......... · 21 Sep 2005

yes other singh but he wrote printing gurbani padched is also manmatt and the books conbtain gurbani lines and shabads- maybe you should read the book and think about what bhai sahib did!!!!!!! and regarding the meaning of sat-naam i tend to agree with gyani harbans singhs steek ie.sat=true naam=naam roop vaho vaho!!! i do noway claim to know what is correct for only guru sahib knows that, but this is from what ive read yes sorry those were asked to jugroop singh i thought maybe you could shed some light but never mind these were some points raised bya very pro-laredaar person which i found very sadd, as only guru jee decides who gets blessed there is no way we can demand a blessing, we can only do udham but by doing say x hours simran keertan paath we think we have earnt his blessing we are mistaken for only guru jee will decide, my mind is made up and you could never influence me from considering one saroop to the other GURBANI is my guru and always will be. by the way i know of a very close companion to bhai sahib and althoough he did say doing pad-ched is manmatt he did not carry on about day in day out, hence not destroying his books as he knew gurbani is gurbani and that is where the jyot is not in the writing style, ink or cover.which is why bhai sahib and saathees stayed engrossed in simran/paath and keertan for days on end. also according to the late bhai joginder singh jee talwaras research there is approx 400-500 printing mistakes in both saroops... i wont be writing any more on the issue but hope guru jee will one day bless allof us if not in this life maybe the next.....only he knows

Re: lareedar saroop

. · 21 Sep 2005

ikongkaarsatnaamkartapurkhnirbhounirvaerakaalmooratajoonee saebhanggurparsaadjapaadsachjugaadsachhaebheesach naanhoaseebheesachsochaysoachnahoaveejaisoacheelakhvaar chupaychupnahoveejaylaaayrahalivtaar bhukhaiaabhukhnautreejaybanaapureeabhaar sehassiaanapalakhhoaytaiknachalaynaal kivsachiaarahoeeaykivkoorhaytutaipaalhukamrajaaeechalna naanaklikhyanaal. http://www.sikhitothemax.com/new/Larree.asp?PageNo=1 http://www.sikhitothemax.com/new/Larree.asp?PageNo=1 http://www.sikhitothemax.com/new/Larree.asp?PageNo=1 http://www.sikhitothemax.com/new/Larree.asp?PageNo=1 http://www.sikhitothemax.com/new/Larree.asp?PageNo=1

Re: lareedar saroop

. · 21 Sep 2005

ikongkaarsatnaamkartapurkhnirbhounirvaerakaalmoorat ajooneesaebhang gurparsaadjapaadsachjugaadsachhaebheesachnaanhoaseebhee sachsoc haysoachnahoaveejaisoacheelakhvaarchupaychupnahoveejaylaaayrahaliv taarbhukhaiaabhukhnautreejaybanaapureeabhaarsehassiaanapalakhhoa ytaiknachalaynaalkivsachiaarahoeeaykivkoorhaytutaipaal hukamrajaaeecha lnanaanaklikhyanaal.

Re: lareedar saroop

. · 21 Sep 2005

hukmeehovanaakaarhukamnakahyajaaeehukmeehovanjeehukammilayvad yaeehukameeutamneechhukamlikhdukhsukhpaaeeayiknahukameebakhsh eeshikhukmeesadabhvaeeayhukmayandersabhkobaaharhukamnakoayna anakhukmayjaybhujhaytaahoumaekahaynakoay. http://www.sikhitothemax.com/new/Larree.asp?PageNo=1

Re: lareedar saroop

ummmm.... · 22 Sep 2005

are the above two posts exceptable in this whole argument ??? as this is not written in gurmukhi script ???? would be acceptable in french ??? I've decided to not waste anymore time on this discussion, regarding Veer Jugroop Singhs reply, I accept his view of we should speak out about anything that we feel incorrect but we should also take into consideration what we are implying, regarding the whole akj uk thing, I know for a fact that this topic has risen many a time and akj uk have never refused anyone willing to get parkash of laridar bir done, the problem is many talk about it, many lecture about it, when it comes down to it only a few will get up and go and make arrangements, the sadddest thing is that many youth can't even read laridar in the UK, just as many youth can't read pad ched, as in the UK it seems as though the parchar of learning gurbani isn't at the fore front of sikhi. Gurudwaras very rarely arrange santhiya. Perhaps this is the path we should be going down, getting all the youth to learn Gurbani paath !!! Regarding the whole Sat Naam question, this question is invalid in my opinion as we are all brain washed one way or another, now let me explain, If i come to Tapoban g'wara and get santhiya I will learn according to whichever syllabus they follow, if i go to taksaal it will not be the same, If i go to the local gyani it will also be different, , the school of thought for a majority on this board will be Bhai Sahibs books, nothing wrong in that whatsoever but you will find scholars who disagree with him on certain lines, the follwoing line is a prime example "eaethae kookar ho baegaanaa bhoukaa eis than thaaee ||" it can also be padched as "eaethae kooka rho baegaanaa bhoukaa eis than thaaee ||" the second version of pad ched bhai sahib agrees with, however there are many scholars who agree with the first version, now if we are going to say that whatever padched was done by bhai sahib can only be correct would be a disservice to bhai sahib as he always wrote "this is what i think with my limited intelligence only guru ji knows the truth". The point of the above example is to point out that we can all sit their and say, with pad ched there is no effort and with laridar the mistakes will be the paathis and not the birs, but a BIG BUT, the school of thought of that paathi will come from somewhere, NO ONE will know how to pad ched of laridar without the teaching of paath from someone or some school, so automatically the argument of the mistake is of the paathi is disappears. The mistakes will come from the teacher and his teacher and his teacher etc etc etc..... Anyways I think this argument has been exhausted enough by both sides, basically it comes down to one thing, we need to learn Gurbani Paath and become one with Gurbani, this will only happen with a lot of abyhaas of Gurbani paath, once this happens it won't make a difference if you sit on the tabiya and either bir is present as you will through Guru jis grace be a very competent Paathi, at the moment this argument is argued by many of us who can't even do paath. Vaheguru ji ka khalsa, Vaheguru ji ki fateh....

Re: lareedar saroop

other singh · 22 Sep 2005

Dear Ummmm and ........ I thank you both for responding to the Sat Naam question. '.......' has a view as to which meaning he accepts, while ummm thinks the question is invalid as the meaning will depend on which background you come from. Ummm has also provided another tuk of whidh there is pad ched done two different ways and goes on to quote, "this is what i think with my limited intelligence only guru ji knows the truth". Ummm, THANK-YOU. This is the point I've been trying to make the whole time. Different ways of doing pad ched changes the meanings of gurbanee. Thus, it isn't simply a difference in writing style, as you initially tried to claim. Now if I accept '.......'s meaning of sat naam and some other veer accepts the first meaning, and we both want to have padched saroops, then what? We have different pad ched saroops for each? Perhaps a different version of Guru Granth Saahib Jee for Sikh Missionaries, a different version for Taksal, a dfferent one for AKJ? With the differences based on someones mat, not the guru's? Well, that's precisely what we have today. Different Guru Granth Saahibs for different mats. So what happens if my version is wrong but I now have made the saroop? Say 50 years down the line, some singh comes and does paaht from it, will he even know there was another way (a correct way) of doing the paaht? I've permanently tried to change my Guru according to my thinking. How is this acceptable to any Gursikh? Lareedhar is what our guru's gave us and unless we think we know Gurbanee at the level of our Guru's, we have absolutely no right to replace lareedhar saroops with padched ones. Using our unwillingness to put in the effort to learn gurbani as an excuse to change Gurbanee, is not acceptable. As far as various school's of thought teaching banee differently goes, yes, of course this is the case. But most people that I know that learn paaht, do put in some thinking of their own and don't just blindly accept what they are told. This is what I've seen in my experience. And in the end, it doesn't change the result. If we accept that a mistake made in padched while reading lareedhar is not the paahtee's any longer, but rather his school's, it's still some mortal's mistake. At least the saroop hasn't been changed to reflect this mistake and the next paahtee that comes along will be able to do paaht from the original. ummmm, if the youth in UK don't know how to do paaht, then why doesn't the AKJ UKspend some time working on this, rather than simply accepting the flawed alternative? Is there any bigger seva they could be doing? You complain about people lecturing and then not doing anything about it, why don't you and others make the effort yourselves? It's your Guru. Why wait for someone else to make the effort? In the end, thank-you both for answering the question and showing that lareedhar is not simply a writing style but is crucial for keeping the essence of gurbanee unchanged.

Re: lareedar saroop

Guru ji help me i'm so weak · 23 Sep 2005

Thats a nonesense argument casue if your reading lardaar thenyou would have to maek the same choice is ti satnaam , sat naam etc.... people stop being samosay Guru is bani , BANI IS THE GURU , not a writing style not the ink type not the paper not the reader, noT the raag , not the volume of the bani being read , GURU IS THE BANI !!!!!!!!!

Re: lareedar saroop

learner singh · 23 Sep 2005

That was a good debate i learnt so much about this issue that i didnt know. I agree that guruship was given to laredaar and padched shouldnt have been done but from this discussion i learnt that we are noone to criticise our guru.Other singh the discusion hasnt proved that laredaar is more than a writing style because in an earlier post someone explained that there are printing mistakes in both saroops.so how do we know which print is write hence making me believe in gurbani as my guru. I have seen old hukamnami of Guru Sahib in laredaar form which proves that at that time laredaar was the style of writing. And also there is no way any of the Gurus could speak laredaar Gurbani it all came padched. After this discussion ive realised there is no difference in the two saroops and Gurbani is my Guru Dhan Dhan Sree Guru Granth Sahib Jee

Re: lareedar saroop

Kulbir Singh · 23 Sep 2005

Learner Singh, ------------ That was a good debate i learnt so much about this issue that i didnt know. I agree that guruship was given to laredaar and padched shouldnt have been done but from this discussion i learnt that we are noone to criticise our guru. ---------- You write that no one should criticize our Guru Sahib. But is it okay to change our Guru Sahib? Is it okay to rip apart our Guru Sahib? Gurbani is our Guru and if we write it differently, it ceases to be Guru. As an example let’s assume Gurbani “Nanak Daras Reeta” but if someone writes this as “Nanak Dar Sareeta”, how will it remain baani? Padd chhed saroop is full of such differences and thus all padd-chhed saroops contain non-Gurbani material. This drops padd-chhed saroop from the martaba of Guru. Guru is only laridaar saroop. For a minute, if we all agree that doing padd-chhed is okay, the problem arises, how to ensure that correct padd-chhed is done. The issue is that other than Siri Guru jee, no one can claim to do padd chhed correctly. If someone claims that they can do padd-chhed (separation of words) correctly, then that person is claiming that they have mastered Gurbani and “Gurbani da anth paa liya hai”. This is impossible. No one in the universe, other than Siri Guru jee, can claim that they have discovered the end of Gurbani. Only Guru Sahib knows the end of Gurbani. No one else. -------------- Other singh the discusion hasnt proved that laredaar is more than a writing style because in an earlier post someone explained that there are printing mistakes in both saroops.so how do we know which print is write hence making me believe in gurbani as my guru. --------- Printing mistakes are innocent mistakes that Guru Sahib does not consider but padd-chhed is a deliberate mistake that Guru Sahib will never forgive. ------------ I have seen old hukamnami of Guru Sahib in laredaar form which proves that at that time laredaar was the style of writing. And also there is no way any of the Gurus could speak laredaar Gurbani it all came padched. ---------- I agree that Guru Sahib spoke padd-chhed but the problem is how do we and who in this world can do correct padd-chhed of Gurbani? Who can claim to have discovered the end of Gurbani? How can we do correct padd-chhed? It is impossible. Only Guru Sahib could have done padd-chhed and now no one can do padd-chhed of Gurbani. Even if the whole panth gathers, still padd-chhed is not possible. Why attempt something that we are not capable of doing? ---------- After this discussion ive realised there is no difference in the two saroops and Gurbani is my Guru ---------- I feel sorry for you since you see no difference in a God-made and man-made Saroop. Kulbir Singh

Re: lareedar saroop

Guru ji help me i'm so weak · 23 Sep 2005

Kulbir singh wrote:- """The issue is that other than Siri Guru jee, no one can claim to do padd chhed correctly. If someone claims that they can do padd-chhed (separation of words) correctly, then that person is claiming that they have mastered Gurbani and “Gurbani da anth paa liya hai”. This is impossible. No one in the universe, other than Siri Guru jee, can claim that they have discovered the end of Gurbani. Only Guru Sahib knows the end of Gurbani. No one else. """ Khalsa ji the same goes for lareedar saroop then , how can anyone do the correct recitaiton other than Guru ji ?? the argument is fultile. BANI IS THE GURU NOT THE HANDWRITING STYLE. ""I feel sorry for you since you see no difference in a God-made and man-made Saroop""" Veer kulbir singh, I feel sorry for you casue you are a amritdhari gursikh and keep rehit and abyaas yet how can you progress when you still don't know who your Guru ji is , when you have dubdha in your mind over who the guru is i.e you got a Gurudwara where pad shed saroop of Guru granth sahib is parkaash and you don't see your Guru i'm sorry but in this case you are the unfortunate one.

Re: lareedar saroop

other singh · 23 Sep 2005

"if your reading lardaar thenyou would have to maek the same choice is ti satnaam , sat naam etc.... " Yes, you would have to make the choice, obviously. But your choice wouldn't permanently change the Guru Granth Saahib. Someone else could come along and your choice wouldn't neccessarily affect how they would read it. That's the whole point here. Don't change Guru Saahib to reflect your understanding. Perhaps you and some others need to go investigate what writing styles are. Educate yourselves a little bit before you start making claims about what a writing style is. Changing the style of writing will not change the meaning of what is written. Doing padched can clearly lead to different meanings depending on who does the padched. Therefore, it is much more than simply a writing style. Learner Singh, your post starts and ends with a massive contradiction. Let's ignore that for now. You are correct about mistakes made when printing Sri Guru Granth Saahib Jee. But how does this justify doing Pad Ched? If I have 500 printing mistakes, I should add another 600 Padched mistakes to make things better? Instead of trying to fix the printing mistakes, let's really screw things up, huh? Remember, two wrongs don't make a right. Also, there is a huge difference between unintentional mistakes and intentional 'mistakes.' With printing mistakes, I'm not trying to change my guru. With Padched, I am. You also mention writing styles again. Simple. Explain how writing styles change the meanings. As far as having to do padched when we speak Gurbanee, yes, obviously. Try to understand the difference between the written shabd contained in Guru Granth Saahib Jee and someone speaking gurbanee. There is a world of difference. When I do paat, I speak it and read it with whatever understanding I have and according to what I have learnt. I can do padched according to my mat. This spoken word is powerful, no doubt, as it is what will affect me and change me. But, this spoken word can change, depending on how my understanding progresses. I can change how I do padched, I can change where I put vishraams (pauses, commas), where I place adhaks on words (remember, no adhaks are found in written gurbanee, but every paahtee places them at some place or another according to his or her understanding) and where I place bindis or H sounds in the foot of the word or whatever. These can all be changed as I change my understanding. However, the written shabd cannot be changed to reflect my growth. Guru Granth Saahib Jee, containing the written shabad, is the source of gurbanee for us, and this source can't be changed. I can't place vishrams, I can't place adhaks, I can't place bindis or lower letters and I can't do the padched. If I do so, I will be colouring the source of gurbanee, my guru, with my intellect, with my avasthaa and understanding. Then what happens if my understanding changes or someone with a better understanding comes along? The Guru becomes obsolete and we have to rework it? The written shabad contained in Guru Granth Saahib Jee is our source of Gurbanee and is eternal and can't be changed. There is no greater disrespect of gurbanee than trying to impose our understaning on this limitless source. As a last example, consider this hypothetical situation. The Singhs at Tapoban suddenly reverse their stance and decide they will now produce a padched version of Guru Granth Saahib in which Padched is done according to how they do paaht. Kulbir Singh and some other Singhs are unhappy with how the padched is done in other saroops (it doesn't convey the meanings that they should) and feel the need to having everyone doing paaht the 'correct' way. So they go to work and after many, many hours of sevaa, they produce a Guru Granth Saahib with padched done to match their explanations of certain tuks. They then go to some publisher in India, and after paying them some nice chunk of money, get thousands of copies printed off. They then distribute these all over the world. Would you be happy to accept this? Would you blindly accept that the way they broke up words was exactly the way Guru Saahib did it? Would you be willing to replace the original lareedhar version, free of all editing, with a copy edited to match the thinking of the Tapoban Singhs? Then what if someone else came along, say AKJ UK, and decided they weren't happy with this version and made their own edition? Which edition would be the real deal? Unfortunately, this is exactly what took place and can take place again as well. Initially, it was the British who brought in padched and it was rejected by most of the panth. Today, we are willing to blindly accept it with ignorant remarks like 'oh, it's just writing style' or 'bani is the guru, it's all the same.' Yet none of these people can answer a simple question about which version of padched in moolmanter (sat naam) is the correct one according to guru saahib and should be placed in Guru Granth Saahib. Or is it okay to have different editions of Guru Granth Saahib depending on which school of thought you prescribe to?

Re: lareedar saroop

Kulbir Singh · 23 Sep 2005

Excellent post "Other Singh". If they don't get convinced with this, I don't know what it will take to convince them. May Guru Sahib give them Sumatt. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: lareedar saroop

Common Sense · 23 Sep 2005

""""" ---------- After this discussion ive realised there is no difference in the two saroops and Gurbani is my Guru ---------- I feel sorry for you since you see no difference in a God-made and man-made Saroop. """"" Kulbir Singh, if we were to record your recitation of Guru Granth Sahib jee and find mistakes or 'disagreements' over how certain pankaties should be recited, would you consider your paath of Ilaahi Gurbani 'worthless' as your recitation turned Guru Sahib into a man-made saroop from the perfect vaheguru-made saroop?? People make mistakes from both saroops but atleast padd ched saroop has been done collectively by high-avastha wale great gursikhs, not by anyone of the street doing santhia. Gursikhs can read and do vichaar to point out and correct man-made mistakes in writing "PERFECT GURU SAHIB" like you have done with “Nanak Daras Reeta”. """""""" There is no greater disrespect of gurbanee than trying to impose our understaning on this limitless source. As a last example, consider this hypothetical situation. The Singhs at Tapoban suddenly reverse their stance and decide they will now produce a padched version of Guru Granth Saahib in which Padched is done according to how they do paaht. Kulbir Singh and some other Singhs are unhappy with how the padched is done in other saroops (it doesn't convey the meanings that they should) and feel the need to having everyone doing paaht the 'correct' way. So they go to work and after many, many hours of sevaa, they produce a Guru Granth Saahib with padched done to match their explanations of certain tuks. """"""""" So! Don't you think it's already happening with laridaar saroop thru santhia di seva? Anyone who takes santhia from AKJ will recite laridaar saroop exactly the way AKJ would teach him. Most Singh memorize Grubani from padd ched and stick to what they learn in santhia. Mistakes are bound to happen. That's why we ask for forgiveness in ardass to Guru Sahib. Having said that, if we serously want to have only laridaar saroop of Guru Sahib, we need lots and lots of highly knowledgeable gursikhs to do sewa o f teaching others. You can't have any "kachey-pilley' singh teaching others to do paath from laridaar saroop.

Re: lareedar saroop

Kulbir Singh · 23 Sep 2005

Common Sense, ------------- Kulbir Singh, if we were to record your recitation of Guru Granth Sahib jee and find mistakes or 'disagreements' over how certain pankaties should be recited, would you consider your paath of Ilaahi Gurbani 'worthless' as your recitation turned Guru Sahib into a man-made saroop from the perfect vaheguru-made saroop?? ------------ Good point! But there is one problem. Gursikhs who do paath from Laridaar Saroop and happen to do the wrong paath, seek forgiveness at the end of their paath. When we ask for forgiveness after paath, it is for such mistakes. If you are doing paath from padd-chhed, what is the point in asking for forgiveness? -------------- People make mistakes from both saroops but atleast padd ched saroop has been done collectively by high-avastha wale great gursikhs, not by anyone of the street doing santhia. Gursikhs can read and do vichaar to point out and correct man-made mistakes in writing "PERFECT GURU SAHIB" like you have done with “Nanak Daras Reeta”. ---------- Who says Padd-chhed has been done collectively? Today there are many versions of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Some saroops have “Jo marr jamae so kach nikach”, others have “Jo marr jamae so kachan kach”. Which one is correct? Which saroop has correct baani? The answer is - only laridaar saroop has true baani. No one can claim that they have reached the end of Gurbani and thus can do correct padd-chhed. So the problem with padd-chhed is that it is impossible to do so. -------- Having said that, if we serously want to have only laridaar saroop of Guru Sahib, we need lots and lots of highly knowledgeable gursikhs to do sewa o f teaching others. You can't have any "kachey-pilley' singh teaching others to do paath from laridaar saroop. --------- Here you make a lot of common-sense. We need learned gursikhs teaching us santhiya. Kulbir Singh

Re: lareedar saroop

other singh · 23 Sep 2005

Common sense said, "So! Don't you think it's already happening with laridaar saroop thru santhia di seva? Anyone who takes santhia from AKJ will recite laridaar saroop exactly the way AKJ would teach him. Most Singh memorize Grubani from padd ched and stick to what they learn in santhia. Mistakes are bound to happen. That's why we ask for forgiveness in ardass to Guru Sahib." Is this such a difficult concept to grasp? Is the akj your guru? Is the santhiya teacher your guru? Are you the Guru? If you make a mistake or the santhiya teacher or AKJ teaches you to do paat a certain way, it's still just YOUR mistake or at most, your teachers. Do you honestly not see the difference between someone changing the written shabad in Guru Granth Saahib Jee to reflect their view and someone reciting the paaht to reflect their view? Would you be okay if AKJ or Sikh Missionaries released an edition of Guru Granth Saahib Jee with Bindi's where they believe they should be pronounced? This is how they recite it, so should they change the saroop to reflect their method of recitation? Could you please answer this, as this is what your argument leads to. "Gursikhs can read and do vichaar to point out and correct man-made mistakes in writing "PERFECT GURU SAHIB" like you have done with “Nanak Daras Reeta”. " My god, what's wrong with you? Gursikhs are now going to make the perfect Guru Granth Saahib Jee? What was wrong with the one Guru Gobind Singh gave us? Don't you get this? The 'mistakes' are disagreements between different schools of thought on where the padched should be. You can have a thousand discussions (and there probably have been at least that many) on whether it should be sat naam or satnaam, it won't resolve the issue. They will stick to their views, and now according to people like you, they should have seperate editions of their guru to reflect their views. "People make mistakes from both saroops but atleast padd ched saroop has been done collectively by high-avastha wale great gursikhs," You talk like there is one agreed upon saroop of paddched. There are as many versions as there are publishers. Perhaps you can enlighten us all on which set of high avastha gursikhs COLLECTIVELY did pad-ched of the entire guru granth saahib and produced a padched saroop. I look forward to learning this from you. If you don't have an answer and are just writing for the sake of winning an argument, then perhaps you should think about the consequences of spreading erroneous information about our Guru. Guru Ji help me i'm so weak wrote, "Khalsa ji the same goes for lareedar saroop then , how can anyone do the correct recitaiton other than Guru ji ?? the argument is fultile. BANI IS THE GURU NOT THE HANDWRITING STYLE." Yes, futile. Just keep repeating yourself like a broken record and maybe your point will begin to make sense. This issue has been addressed several times and none of you have given a response. Other than repeating your nonsensical point (this time in capitals), you have nothing to add. You obviously don't have a grasp of what the written shabad represents. Is Guru Granth Saahib Jee only your guru when someone recites it? In other words, only the oral recitation of Gurbani is your guru? Perhaps you should drop the word Granth from Guru Granth Saahib Jee then. I find it mind boggling that a Sikh can equate someone reciting paaht incorrectly with rewriting the saroop incorrectly to match their recitation. If you actually have a point to make, then make it. Otherwise, don't bother wasting your time. You're not engaging in any form of honest debate, you're simply trying to scream over everyone else in the hopes that someone will accept your stance without you having to face the facts. Every point that you've made has been answered in previous posts more than once. You haven't provided a single response to any of these answers and haven't made a single point to back-up your arguments. If anyone else wants to try going with the 'Bani is the guru, writing style doesn't make a difference,' please, for everyone's sake, read all of the above posts and provide answers to how a writing style can change meanings of gurbanee. Also let us all know whether it's okay to have multiple editions to represent different schools of thought. If you can't answer this, then don't bother wasting time with ignorant statements. There seem to be three main categories of people who will refuse to accept lareedhar saroop. 1. The lazy ones. They don't want to take any effort to have to learn to read Gurbanee. Remember, the more effort one makes, the more laha they get. 2. The ones who can't deal with the 'implications' of admitting a mistake. They want to stick to the status quo as this is what their predecessors did and changing now would be admitting that what came before was a mistake. Many Singhs from AKJ UK seem to be stuck in this. They don't want to deal with what the 'implications' might be if they accept lareedhar saroop now. A singh should never shy away from the truth due to fear of implications. If a mistake was made and it's now corrected, so what? All gursikhs are bhulanhaar and a panthwide mistake wouldn't be held against any single entity. 3. The business minded ones. If your gurdvara now has 5 or 10 or 50 akhand paats at a time, what will happen if lareedhar saroop becomes the status quo? You won't be able to just grab any old punjabee person off the street for a raul. You'll actually have to give people proper training and let them learn gurbanee and have extensive practice before they can start doing raul sevaa. In the meantime, no more 50 akhand paats at a time, which will mean significant financial losses.

Re: lareedar saroop

..... · 23 Sep 2005

so is the saroop Guru Gobind Singh Ji gave Gurgaddi to still accessible, if so where is it? sumone asked earlier but they got no reply

Re: lareedar saroop

Benti · 23 Sep 2005

No offence to anyone involved in this topic but this is def sounding like a broken record, if tapoban are so hardcore about this, when they went to india why didn't they meet the akaal takhat jathedars and debate this, why didn't the do a morcha, amazing how easy it is to convince yourself that everyone who doesn't agree needs "summat bakashing", pershaps some of the pro laridar people need to accept that not everyone will agree with them ???? is that so hard to accept ??? also it seems as though all the points that made against laridar are washed away with no real answer, one big question which everyone has failed to answer is what did Guru Gobind Singh ji give the gurhai too ?????answer that through your own khoj and then you'll understand what Guru ji is....

Re: lareedar saroop

Balpreet Singh · 23 Sep 2005

Benti, To be clear, when the Singhs from Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib went to India, they did indeed meet with the Jathedar of Akal Takhat Sahib and discuss this issue. Wasn't much of a debate since he agreed that lareedaar saroop should be parkaash in all Gurdwaras and he himself said he'd work on it. Lareedaar Guru Granth Sahib jee is the rightful holder of the Gurgaddi. Guru Gobind Singhjee gave Gurgaddi to this saroop. If someone keeps repeating like a broken record, "no no, Bani is my Guru. Doesn't matter if it's laridaar or padchhed", I have one question: is it alright then if we re-arrange Guru Sahib's bani in order of Bhagat and Guru? Bani doesn't change does it? I think "other Singh" has nailed this argument anyways. There is no doubt or room for argument left.

Re: lareedar saroop

other singh · 23 Sep 2005

"also it seems as though all the points that made against laridar are washed away with no real answer," Would you care to mention which points didn't receive an answer? As far as I can see, each point (of the 2 or 3 that were repeatedly raised) were answered several times. If you would like, we can repeat that excercise again. Just list your points. A better option might be to get someone else to sit down and read these posts with you so they can point out the answers for you. As for your big question, why don't you enlighten us all with an answer? If you're going to simply say, 'bani,' then don't bother. Go back re-read all the posts and sit down and think carefully. Also, consider the following: banee was guru right from the time of Guru Nanak Dev Jee. Gurbanee itself states this. So what exactly did Guru Gobind Singh Jee give Gurgadi to if Gurbanee was already Guru? As far as going to India is concerned, the Jathedars and commitees there will never argue against lareedhar. They support it, although they don't do anything about it. Remember, prakash of lareedhar is still done, as always, at Sri Darbar Saahib, Sri Akal Takht Saahib and most major historic Gurdvaras. Perhaps you're also aware, that the only panthic decisions taken on this matter banned the printing of pad ched saroops. These decisions were taken some 50 years ago by the SGPC and Chief Khalsa Diwan. Copies of these decisions are still available from the SGPC. Unfortunately, somewhere along the way, these decisions began to be ignored. Perhaps it was due in part to changes in the make-up of the SGPC, with newer, less aware individuals being elected to replace the old guard. Just a guess though. So we don't need morchas to convince anyone. We need education of the masses, which is exactly what is happening. '.....' said, 'so is the saroop Guru Gobind Singh Ji gave Gurgaddi to still accessible, if so where is it? sumone asked earlier but they got no reply' A reply was given, but probably got overlooked amongst everything else. It is believed that the saroop that was present at Nander during the Gurgaddi ceremony was lost during one of the ghallugharay (the big one). Nobody really knows what happened to it. But copies and other Guru Granth Saahibs from Guru Gobind Singh Jee's time were around, thankfully. If you have questions about why we don't accept only that specific Bir as guru, but accept all birs containing gurbanee in its complete and unaldulterated form as Guru, please re-read posts from the first half of this thread.

Re: lareedar saroop

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! · 24 Sep 2005

"If you are doing paath from padd-chhed, what is the point in asking for forgiveness? " this is the bigeest blasphemy i have ever heard,you should be ashamed as someone with your knowledge would have more sense by this line you are saying there is no jyot in that saroop that is nindiya of guru sahib interpret how you will you ar not guru jee to decide that sikhs shouldnt ask for forgiveness as you are not the onee too forgive, onle gurujee can do that the only way you could prove that there is no jyot in padched saroop is put both saroops together and show us that there is a difference deep down you really dont know what guru sahib will show you.... also kulbir singh jee could you answer the 2 questions that were asked of jagroop singh ie.what is your stand on sangat who have done amrit from padched saroop and also got married in front of padched saroop??????? could you tell me what the pad-ched saroop contains is it writngs from the bible , quran or geeta OR is it gurbani... repeating things like a broken record are no use to some people because they cant see past the wall infront of there eyes kulbir singh jee other singh tried to answer that they are bhai sahibs books not guru sahib but gurbani is gurbani right but he didnt understand it properly as you do, so please explain this if you can bhai sahib writes doing padched is manmatt then he writes "PRINTING GURBANI PADCHED IS MANMATT" FULL STOP here it does not say its ok for research as other singh thought, it is full stop then explain why all the books have padched gurbani and most were printed while bhai sahib was alive?????and then why did bhai sahib not do anything about it also other singh you said about mistakes unless you have received guru jees blessings and are jyot vigassi i will assume that besides the 400-5-- mistakes already in the laredaar saroop you will make thousands more beacuse your doing padched with your own matt.... also balpreet singh your question is non sensical because both saroops have gurbani in the same order no one is saying change this change that!! there is no for argument because you cant see past your own views guru jee samatt bakshan other singh keeps on about satnaam or sat naam but let me tell you there are even laredaar paathis who disagree with each on the padched of various shabads what are gonna do then say it is there own understanding as usual, as the saroop is laredaar all i can say is good luck to you as there are millions of sangat that bow to guru jee around the whole world not questioning which saroops there because they see know difference each individual does there own mangaa from guru sahib and some are even blessed with there wants. LIKE A BROKEN RECORD THERE IS NO DIFFERENCE I HOPE GURU JEE SHOWS YOU THIS ONE DAY UNLESS OTHER SINGH OR KULBIR SINGH PROVE ME WRONG BY THE OPTION GIVEN ABOVE

Re: lareedar saroop

. · 24 Sep 2005

This Shabad is by Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Raag Bhairao on Pannaa 1142 (from www.sikhitothemax.com) BYrau mhlw 5 ] bhairo mehalaa 5 || Bhairao, Fifth Mehl: siqguru myrw bymuhqwju ] sathigur maeraa baemuhathaaj || My True Guru is totally independent. siqgur myry scw swju ] sathigur maerae sachaa saaj || My True Guru is adorned with Truth. siqguru myrw sBs kw dwqw ] sathigur maeraa sabhas kaa dhaathaa || My True Guru is the Giver of all. siqguru myrw purKu ibDwqw ]1] sathigur maeraa purakh bidhhaathaa ||1|| My True Guru is the Primal Creator Lord, the Architect of Destiny. ||1|| gur jYsw nwhI ko dyv ] gur jaisaa naahee ko dhaev || There is no deity equal to the Guru. ijsu msqik Bwgu su lwgw syv ]1] rhwau ] jis masathak bhaag s laagaa saev ||1|| rehaao || Whoever has good destiny inscribed on his forehead, applies himself to seva - selfless service. ||1||Pause|| siqguru myrw srb pRiqpwlY ] sathigur maeraa sarab prathipaalai || My True Guru is the Sustainer and Cherisher of all. siqguru myrw mwir jIvwlY ] sathigur maeraa maar jeevaalai || My True Guru kills and revives. siqgur myry kI vifAweI ] pRgtu BeI hY sBnI QweI ]2] sathigur maerae kee vaddiaaee || pragatt bhee hai sabhanee thhaaee ||2|| The glorious greatness of my True Guru has become manifest everywhere. ||2|| siqguru myrw qwxu inqwxu ] sathigur maeraa thaan nithaan || My True Guru is the power of the powerless. siqguru myrw Gir dIbwxu ] sathigur maeraa ghar dheebaan || My True Guru is my home and court. siqgur kY hau sd bil jwieAw ] sathigur kai ho sadh bal jaaeiaa || I am forever a sacrifice to the True Guru. pRgtu mwrgu ijin kir idKlwieAw ]3] pragatt maarag jin kar dhikhalaaeiaa ||3|| He has shown me the path. ||3|| ijin guru syivAw iqsu Bau n ibAwpY ] jin gur saeviaa this bho n biaapai || One who serves the Guru is not afflicted with fear. ijin guru syivAw iqsu duKu n sMqwpY ] jin gur saeviaa this dhukh n sa(n)thaapai || One who serves the Guru does not suffer in pain. nwnk soDy isMimRiq byd ] naanak sodhhae si(n)mrith baedh || Nanak has studied the Simritees and the Vedas. pwrbRhm gur nwhI Byd ]4]11]24] paarabreham gur naahee bhaedh ||4||11||24|| There is no difference between the Supreme Lord God and the Guru. ||4||11||24|| Dhan Dhan SatGuru Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Dhan Dhan SatGuru Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Dhan Dhan SatGuru Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Dhan Dhan SatGuru Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Dhan Dhan SatGuru Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee http://www.sikhitothemax.com/new/Larree.asp?PageNo=1

Re: lareedar saroop

Balpreet Singh · 24 Sep 2005

The question was this: "if it's ok to have pad-chhed and change what Guru Sahib gave us because "gurbani is our guru", then is it ok to change the order bani is printed in and rearrange it according to Guru? If it's not ok, then why? It'd still be gurbani right? " I we can change one feature of bani ie. lareedaar, then why is there a problem in changing the order? There is a saroop in Delhi that is rearranged like this. Why was that wrong, but pad-chhed is ok? you wrote: "i will assume that besides the 400-5-- mistakes already in the laredaar saroop you will make thousands more beacuse your doing padched with your own matt...." And you are reading the pad-chhed that was done according to Gurmat? Or was it someone elses mat? If there's a mistake in pad-chhed, it's permanent. Someone reading it can't correct it. If I make a mistake reading lareedaar, I can be corrected and better myself. You are stuck in manmat. Pure and simple. You insist on changing what Guru Sahib gave us according to what you think is easier.

Re: lareedar saroop

U.K. Khalsa · 24 Sep 2005

I can't see why people are defending the pad ched saroop, we all know the introduction was a mistake and no major panthic jathebandi supported this move. I've read most of the discussions above and I fail to see how you can still defend the pad ched saroop implemantation. I would assume the people that are defending pad ched don't read from lareevar saroop. For this reason alone I fail to understand how you can make a judgement without practically doing something and seeing if it is the same or there is a difference. For me the basics of Sikhi is to have faith in Guru Sahib and therefore have faith in what ever he does without question. To support pad ched would mean that you do not have faith in Guru Sahib as you think the lareevaar saroop was done without reason. I have one question for for those that say there is no difference in the 2 saroops. That is, if there is no difference then is there any need to keep the Lareedar saroop. I mean what good reason would you give to keeping this saroop in the Panth. People have to make a lot more effort & time in learning how to read lareevaar wouldn't it save a lot time & bother if we did not have it as the claim is ''there is no difference''.

Re: lareedar saroop

. · 24 Sep 2005

Akaal Purkh as Gur Joat has entered the Body of Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee this happened in 1708 and will stay until this earth remains in all the correct Saroops of Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee after that The Gur Joat in Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee will also go and reside with Akaal Purkh in SachKhand like all the previous 10 Gur Joats who are now with Akaal Purkh on the Same Throne. Dhan Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Dhan Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Dhan Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee

Re: lareedar saroop

other singh · 24 Sep 2005

!!!!!!!!!!!!!! said, "the only way you could prove that there is no jyot in padched saroop is put both saroops together and show us that there is a difference deep down you really dont know what guru sahib will show you...." If you can't understand the 60 posts on this so far, then why keep posting idiotic stuff? I haven't mentioned anything about a jot anywhere in my posts, so what relevance does this have to me? I posted that Gurgadi was given to the Lareedhar saroop and showed you that there is a clear difference between the various Padched versions and larreedhar. This is a simple fact beyond debate. I gave you an example of differences and you have absolutely no response other than to say that a paatee reading lareedhar could make a mistake too. And somehow this is supposed to be equivalent to changing the saroop of Guru Saahib. As far as jots go, I wouldn't want to get into a discussion with someone like you about jots. If you can't comprehend and handle a simple issue like this, I would hate to see what would happen in discussing something like jots. Just trying to establish what a jot was and differences between Guru jot and jot in us would be like trying to thread a needle with a log. Stick to what the discussion was and stop going off on tangents. What in the world does it matter to this issue whether Kulbir Singh considers somebody an amritdharee or not? Could you please explain how that will in any way, shape or form change the argument about Lareedhar? Do you worship Kulbir Singh as your Guru? Is he your idol or something that this matters to you so much (Veerjee Kulbir Singh, no offence intended at you)? If Kulbir Singh doesn't consider you amritdharee or if he doesn't consider all of England Amritdharee or if he considers Michael Jackson to be amritdharee, how in the world is that going to change the point about Lareedhar saroop? You're simply trying to get some controversy going in order to derail this debate. Very mature. "could you tell me what the pad-ched saroop contains is it writngs from the bible , quran or geeta OR is it gurbani..." It contains gurbani that has been edited from its original form by people. People who felt that they could edit our source of 'dhur kee baanee' to make it easier and to reflect their understanding. Originally, these people were working for the British Empire. They felt that Guru Jee's saroop given to us by Guru Gobind Singh Jee was inadequate to meet the needs of the masses and so they would 'fix' this saroop and make it better. And now we wind our way back to Bhai Saahib Randheer Singh. Firstly, this issue of Lareedhar goes much beyond Bhai Saahib and the AKJ. It is panthic. It is about our guru. Start thinking outside of your little box. Secondly, if my explanation isn't adequate, then you provide one. You're basically saying that there is a contradiction between what Bhai Sahib wrote and what he practiced. You're calling him a hypocrite. I'm saying that anyone with half a brain will see the difference in writing gurbanee in a book or steek for the purposes of providing translations and meanings (which would also explain why commas are used by Bhai Saahib in some places) and gurbanee in the Guru Granth Saahib. I'm also saying that you probably don't fully understand what Bhai Sahib said in the quote you keep using. If I'm wrong, then correct me. Explain to us why Bhai Saahib would say one thing and do another (which is what you're claiming). Either there is an explanation like the one I gave, or you accept that he contradicted himself. For me the issue is quite simple and clear. For you, it obviously isn't. You're trying to avoid the simple fact of what Bhai Saahib wrote about Padched and instead, trying to twist things to try and show that Bhai Saahib wasn't really against Padched. This is quite disgusting. Bhai Saahib was one of the greatest Gursikhs around and trying to reverse his stance to match yours is quite sick. He wrote against Padched in very strong but easy to understand language. It's written down in black and white. Stop trying to turn him into a padched supporter. To most people, there really is no contradiction in what he wrote. You see one. So either provide an explanation or admit that you think he contradicted himself. Stop playing word games and provide a straight answer. "also other singh you said about mistakes unless you have received guru jees blessings and are jyot vigassi i will assume that besides the 400-5-- mistakes already in the laredaar saroop you will make thousands more beacuse your doing padched with your own matt.... also balpreet singh your question is non sensical because both saroops have gurbani in the same order no one is saying change this change that!!" Are you dense? Do you see no difference between a paahtee making a mistake and editing Guru Granth Saahib to match your style of reading? I've answered this more than enough times and asked you (by you I refer to anyone who read the posts and chose to respond) to comment on the difference between the written shabd contained in Guru Granth Saahib Jee and an oral recitation. Yet you continue posting the same drivel without addressing my response. If you're having trouble reading and comprehending, give 'Hooked on Phonics' a try. Balpreet Singh's question is nonsensical because you once again have no response. The whole debate is about changing this and changing that. You are saying that changing gurbanee in the saroop that Guru Gobind Singh Jee gave us is legitimate. Balpreet Singh is simply asking that would changing it in other ways be okay as well? In fact, simply changing the order around would have less effect on the meanings of Gurbanee than doing padched. So if you're willing to accept Padched as Gurmat, than you should have no issue with accepting what Balpreet Singh mentions. "other singh keeps on about satnaam or sat naam but let me tell you there are even laredaar paathis who disagree with each on the padched of various shabads what are gonna do then say it is there own understanding as usual, as the saroop is laredaar" Yes, that's exactly what I'm going to say. And you don't need to tell me about lareedhar paathis disagreeing on the padched. I'm well aware of this. And what's wrong with it? It shows that people in our panth are actively trying to understand gurbanee, which is good. Having different school's of thought is probably benificial in some ways. At least they don't then try to change Gurbanee to match their method of reading, thus trying to force everyone else to read according to their style and understanding, which is what you are supporting. But you still haven't answered the question about Satnaam and Sat naam. You're still trying to run this way and that and weaving in and out, trying to avoid the question. I can't blame you though. You really have no answer. You don't have a leg to stand on. You're sticking to your point out of pure stubborness. "all i can say is good luck to you as there are millions of sangat that bow to guru jee around the whole world not questioning which saroops there because they see know difference each individual does there own mangaa from guru sahib and some are even blessed with there wants. LIKE A BROKEN RECORD THERE IS NO DIFFERENCE I HOPE GURU JEE SHOWS YOU THIS ONE DAY UNLESS OTHER SINGH OR KULBIR SINGH PROVE ME WRONG BY THE OPTION GIVEN ABOVE" The public at large is uneducated on the issue and so that justifies changing Gurbanee? If we installed the saroop that Balpreet Singh spoke about, most people would eventually go along with that, probably without even knowing that it exists. What does that mean? As far as proving you wrong goes, you've been proven wrong many, many times. You and a few others are the only ones that don't see this. You're basically saying that there was something wrong with the original lareedhar version of Guru Granth Saahib Jee given to us by Guru Gobind Singh Jee and that people fixed it up. Unless you can explain why a padched saroop would need to be made in the first place. As they say, 'if it isn't broken, don't fix it.' So what was wrong with the original that we needed a modified version?

Re: lareedar saroop

wellwisher · 25 Sep 2005

Dear other singh the amount of control you have over krodh and haumai is amazing may Guru Jee bless everyone with such Gursikh qualities ie. Prem, Gareebee, Sath, Santokh, Dheeraj Gurfateh

Re: lareedar saroop

. · 25 Sep 2005

From www.sikhitothemax.com Bulx AMdir sBu ko ABulu gurU krqwru ] bhulan a(n)dhar sabh ko abhul guroo karathaar || Everyone makes mistakes; only the Guru and the Creator are infallible. gurmiq mnu smJwieAw lwgw iqsY ipAwru ] guramath man samajhaaeiaa laagaa thisai piaar || One who instructs his mind with the Guru's Teachings comes to embrace love for the Lord. (Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee - 60)

Re: lareedar saroop

query · 25 Sep 2005

Dear sangat jee, someone earlier said we cant do padched and only Guru Jee can do the correct padched, if this is the case and doing padched is manmatt maybe we should all stop doing paath and keertan and just bow down to Guru Jee. As sangat that does nitnem evry morning does padched too and if thats manmatt then..............????

Re: lareedar saroop

Balbir Singh · 25 Sep 2005

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear all seekers and those who have found HIM! Lareedaar Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji was affirmed by Gurdev. Gurdev did not leave any possibility to change a word in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Pad-chayd Saroop was introduced later to popularize reading and understanding Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Some words may have been written differently in the Pad-chayd Saroop. A lot of care has been taken though. In my view, Lareedaar Saroop is solving its purpose today also in the great way. For those who find it easy to read and understand Gurbani in the Pad-chayd Saroop should be encouraged too. At the same time all those who find God easier by reading and understanding Gurbani in the Lareedaar Saroop should feel free to enjoy the freedom. Both forms of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji are available right now, also its Truth as God. My wish is to receive Darshan of one who has come to know Truth by either way. Balbir Singh

Re: lareedar saroop

. · 25 Sep 2005

The ones who keep saying Baanee is Guru Baanee is Guru, Do you consider Two Senchees of Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee as Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee? if not why not , Does not two Senchees of Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee contain all of the Gurbaanee in Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee? The Debate is about the Saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee There is no contraversy about SatGuru Kee Baanee also being Guru. Our Partakh SatGuru is Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee since 1708 when SatGuru Siri Guru Gobind Singh Jee according to GurVaak GurJoat Gur Arjan Mahay Dharee Put Gur Joat into The Pure Body of Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee and Then Bowed Down to Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee as The SatGuru for All Time. (Remember Siri Guru Gobind Singh Jee had already prepared Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee at Siri DamDama Sahib long before 1708 but was not The SatGuru even all of the Gurbaanee was contained within Because Guru Gobind Singh Jee were The SatGuru Then Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Became SatGuru At SachKhand Siri Hazoor Sahib in 1708) Please Discuss regarding the Saroop, What Kind of Saroop It should be?Should there be two types of Saroop or only One?

Re: lareedar saroop

Common Sense · 25 Sep 2005

other singh, Do you or have you ever matha tek to the padd ched saroop? Do you consider pad ched saroop as your GURU or just gurbani in a Gutka? I read everything you wrote above. You seem to be quite dense and full of krodh. Atleast read what other people are saying before starting your essays. What I am saying is that when 'other singh' recites gurbani from laridaar saroop, he will make coutless mistakes. Would his paath of Guru Sahib's sachi gurbani be considered worthless since his recitation turned Guru Sahib into a man-made saroop by making countless mistakes?? If not, then how does the padd ched saroop cease to be Guru Sahib ji????? Both have mistakes? One in written and the other in spoken words. I don't think 'other singh' can do paath from laridaar saroop WITHOUT doing padd ched. Can he??? Again, if we really want only laridaar saroop of Guru Sahib ji, we need lots and lots of highly knowledgeable and high avastha wale gursikhs to do sewa of teaching others. You can't have "kachey-pilley', full of krodh & haume wale singh teaching others to do paath from laridaar saroop.

Re: lareedar saroop

Benti · 25 Sep 2005

Should be only hath likat saroop, done by chradi kala singhs, having templates that print bani backwards on to paper is wrong, we need to revert back to hath likat biraa, i read once Bhai Ram Singh ji of india did this ??? has anyone got any pics of hath likat bira as they should be reintroduced, as printed biraa are also the introduction of technology.... and we all know what kind of respect these biraa get by printers, how printers have been done for behadbi of the pages they have printed but haven't sansaakared properyly....

Re: lareedar saroop

U.K. Khalsa · 26 Sep 2005

Common Sense jee, Other Singh singh called you dense but I think you are more than just dense you've got to be stupid. How can you conclude that you making the mistake is the same thing as Guru Jee making a mistake. I could not see any krodh in Other Singhs reply may be a bit of fustration but that would logical after replying on the same point over and over again. Naturally this subject would be emotional because we are talking about Guru Sahib. Your last statements just about sums you up, you wrote Again, if we really want only laridaar saroop of Guru Sahib ji, we need lots and lots of highly knowledgeable and high avastha wale gursikhs to do sewa of teaching others. You can't have "kachey-pilley', full of krodh & haume wale singh teaching others to do paath from laridaar saroop. What has someone with Krodh & haume got do with the subject of Lareedaar saroop. I think the biggest people with haume are the one's that think that they know better than Guru Jee & his actions. This last comment proves that you really don't have a clue. Why do you support the need to learn from Lareedaar saroop when you don't think there is a difference.

Re: lareedar saroop

. · 26 Sep 2005

gaavaykotaanhovaykisaytaangaavaykodaatjaanaynishaangaavaykogunva dayeeachaargaavaykovidyavikhamvichaargaavaykosaajkaraytankhaygaav aykojeelaefirdehgaavaykojaapaydisaydoorgaavaykovakhayhaadrahadoor kathnakatheenaaavaytoatkathkathkatheekoateekoatkoatdaindadehlaind aythakpaaayjugajugantarkhaaeekhaaayhukameehukamchlaaayraahnaan akvigasayvaeparvaah http://www.sikhitothemax.com/new/Larree.asp?PageNo=1

Re: lareedar saroop

Balbir Singh · 26 Sep 2005

Satsriakal to all! Jagjit Singh Ji started a topic 'Handwritten Mool Mantars By Guru Sahibaan' on 09-07-05. He provided three photos of handwritten Gurbani from our Gurus Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji, Sri Guru Har Rai Sahib Ji and Sri Guru Teg Bahadur Sahib Ji. The handwritten Gurbani from our Gurus in the above-mentioned photos is not in Lareedaar Saroop. Can someone please explain what has this to say? Balbir Singh

Re: lareedar saroop

Singh · 26 Sep 2005

Balbir Singh, Take the time to read the thread before posting. This is from way up at the top: >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>. Dont' be so 'lost' over the hukumnamas. These mool mantars are signatures to authenticate that Guru Sahib authorised them. When you write a signature, is it your regular handwriting? No of course not. The main and unmistakable fact remains that Guru Granth Sahib saroops were ALL in laridaar. But ok, lets even do a little analysis of the hukumnamas that are being called "pad-chhed". First as i said they are signatures, not a normal writing of bani. If you want to see Guru Hargobind Sahib's gutka Sahib (kept in Ghudani Kalan village) it is laridaar. Guru Hargobind Sahib's mool mantar signature is clearly not pad chhed. It breaks the words Nir and bo and moorat and parsaad. It is obviously not pad-chhed. The top one (seems to be a fake actually since the kartarpuri bir is not authentic and the supposed signature of Guru Sahib here does not match the others samples we have) even it, breaks nirvair. The signature of Guru Har Rai Sahib also can't be called 'pad chhed' since it is not all that spaced and it is missing a lot of laganmatras. Even words are spaced, like A-joonee is spaced and Satnam is written S A T N (a) M. Is that pad-chhed to you? Moving right along to Guru Tegh Bahadur jee's signature (yes, again, these are signature which are different than usual writing), Nirvair and Akal are joined. Notice the long strokes like for a usual signature. Saibhang and Gurparsaad are also joined. Are they one word? Is this pad-chhed? Where is the pad chhed????? Don't get confused. It's crystal clear. All birs of Guru Granth Sahib are not written in this signature format. They are all unbroken laridaar. Even Guru Sahib's writing outside of signatures is unbroken and in laridaar. Where's the doubt??

Re: lareedar saroop

Balbir Singh · 27 Sep 2005

Satsriakal to all! Is it allowed and recommended taking breath during Paath of the Lareedaar Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji? If the answer is yes then where and when? Please elaborate. Balbir Singh

Re: lareedar saroop

other singh · 27 Sep 2005

Common sense, you still haven't provided any response to anything. You claim to have read everything posted, but you obviously haven't understood anything. For about 50 messages now, we've been discussing the difference between the written shabd contained in our source for Gurbanee (Sri Guru Granth Saahib Jee) and oral recitation of Gurbanee by a mortal. You seem to equate them and give them the exact same status. I've asked you to comment on this, but instead, you come back with "What I am saying is that when 'other singh' recites gurbani from laridaar saroop, he will make coutless mistakes. Would his paath of Guru Sahib's sachi gurbani be considered worthless since his recitation turned Guru Sahib into a man-made saroop by making countless mistakes?? If not, then how does the padd ched saroop cease to be Guru Sahib ji????? Both have mistakes? One in written and the other in spoken words. I don't think 'other singh' can do paath from laridaar saroop WITHOUT doing padd ched. Can he???" Shabash Genius. My recitation of Gurbanee is apparently (according to this guy) equivalent to Guru Granth Saahib Jee. Maybe you should stick me on a takht and matha tek to me while I'm doing paat. I've asked you many questions over the last few dozen posts. Why don't you respond to at least one or two, instead of trying to act smart by parroting other people's comments? As far as matha teking goes..... How does my matha teking effect this debate? Why can't you just debate the issue instead of trying to get into people's personal practices and trying to stir up some controversy? Are you that unsure of yourself, that you resort to these cheap tactics? Well, if it makes you feel better, yes, I've matha tekked to a pad-ched saroop. I've also matha tekked to pothees and gutkas. But my matha teking practices don't change the fact that Gurgaddi was given to Lareedhar Saroop. We respect gurbanee, no matter what. We even respect the Gurmukhi letters by themselves, as they are a daat from our Gurus. But as '.' summed up above, the gurgaddi was given to lareedhar saroop only. Gurbanee was always given the utmost respect (who can show more respect than Guru Arjun Dev Jee) but Guru Granth Saahib Jee wasn't declared Guru until 1708, regardless of the fact that Gurbanee was there all along. Gurgaddi was given to the written shabad in the form of Guru Granth Saahib Jee and as much as you insist, we have no right to alter this shabd (our Guru). Now about my Krodh and Houmai. Obviously I have them. I also have abundant amounts of kaam, moh and lobh. I've never claimed to be a Gursikh. If you've overcome your bikaars, congratulations. I'm still a long distance away from that. If something frusterates me, I'm likely to show it at some time. With Guru Saahib's kirpaa, I'll someday be able to have the gunns of a Gursikh. Until then, I would ask that you look past my krodh and houmai (and Kaam, lobh and moh) and deal with the issue at hand.

Re: lareedar saroop

Balbir Singh · 27 Sep 2005

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Singh Ji! The so-called Mool-Mantar is the beginning of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. This appeared before the world through our first Guru, Guru Nanak Dev Ji. The photos of the Mool-Mantar are the rewriting of it by the later Gurus. The separation between letters and words written by our Gurus has set an example for me. Mool-Mantar is the wisdom of the Supreme, in my view, transferred to many as well as other Gurus. This is not the signature as you have explained it. God's Wisdom is not anybody's signature. -------------- Nobody has ever protested against Paathees reading Lareedaar Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. They may please further enjoy reading so. I feel a truthful promoter of Sikhi will encourage all methods of writing, reading and singing of Gurbani that enhances enthusiasm and understanding of it. Our Gurus did not write complete Aadi Granth Sahib with their own hands. They had writers for this. Also copies were needed to rewrite and binding Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Our Gurus chose the Lareedaar Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji to save HIM from any alteration. I feel this purpose is solved in a decent way. -------------- The spiritual progress is not achieved by discussing the rules of writing and reciting Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji nor arguing the combination (sandh-i-aa) of words and its forms. Gurbani says "pustak paath bi-aakaran vakhaanai sanDhi-aa karam tikaal karai." Book reading, discussing its grammar and the act of its combinations he may do three times a day. "bin gur sabad mukat kahaa paraanee raam naam bin urajh marai." SGGS Ang 1127 Without Gurshabad where is Mukti O! Praanee, without the Naam of Raam one dies entangled. I hope you do not mind when God blesses someone with His Truth who has never come to know the Lareedaar Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Balbir Singh [%sig%]

Re: lareedar saroop

Common Sense · 27 Sep 2005

"""""" Are you that unsure of yourself, that you resort to these cheap tactics? Well, if it makes you feel better, yes, I've matha tekked to a pad-ched saroop. I've also matha tekked to pothees and gutkas. """"" So you DoN'T consider the padd ched saroop to be your guru. That's all I wanted to clarify. No, it doesn't make me feel any better. Let me know if you are able to do paath from laridaar saroop WITHOUT doing padd ched. I like to learn to avoid any mistakes. I don't know what few dozen post are you referring to, as I only posted twice to this thread!! You seem to conveniently forget to read last paragraph of my posts.

Re: lareedar saroop

RoopKaur · 27 Sep 2005

>I hope you do not mind when God blesses someone with His Truth who has never come to know the Lareedaar Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.< The truth is The Laridaar Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Inorder to find truth, you need the true guru which is laridaar Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.

Re: lareedar saroop

Common Sense · 28 Sep 2005

""""" The truth is The Laridaar Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Inorder to find truth, you need the true guru which is laridaar Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. """"" I feel really sorry for you that you don't see padd ched saroop of Guru Granth Sahib Ji as your guru. Both saroop are our true guru. Both have same sachi bani. A Few written or spoken mistakes of us mortals in the process of doing padd ched do not turn Ilahi Gurbani into a poem, it still IS the same TRUE WORD!!

Re: lareedar saroop

Singh · 28 Sep 2005

If you’re a supporter of Pad chedd as the Guru, than that means you should never complain about the lazy and uneducated Grathis and raggis in the Gurdwaras. I see the same people supporting Pad chedd in this post and bashing the lazy and uneducated Grathis and raggis in other posts. How do you think they become Grathis and raggis???? If you have a lareedar saroop, not all, but most of the weak Grathis and raggis would be out work or they wouldn’t want to become Granthis or raggis in the first place. For example, while doing seva for an Ahkand paat, we always see them looking around at the sangat, watching the sangat mathta teking or look at the clook to see how much time they have left. However, if you have an Akhand paat from a lareedar saroop, visualize the absolute HORROR and PAIN they would have to go through because they would need to put 100% concentration. What would be wrose for Grathis and raggis than to actually do paat?? Also, by doing pa of lareedar saroop would eliminate mona’s or non Amritdharis from doing paat.

Re: lareedar saroop

sikhi piari · 30 Sep 2005

How would having paath of lareedar saroop keep mona/noon-SIngh from doing paath? I know monas who do path from lareedar saroop. Please enlighten me??