Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Mother and Children Suicide

Mother and Children Suicide

? · 14 Sep 2005

Depressed Mother Commits Suicide With Children http://panthic.org/news/124/ARTICLE/1728/2005-09-04.html Father Speaks of Family Suicide http://panthic.org/news/124/ARTICLE/1757/2005-09-11.html Sunday 11th September, 2005 Fauja Singh - Panthic Weekly Staff London, UK (KP) – Two weeks since the suicide of Navjeet Kaur Sidhu, a loving mother and wife, her husband has spoken out on his heartache of losing his family. Navjeet Kaur loving mother and wife last week leapt to her death with her two children, a year old girl named Simran and a 23 month old son named Aman in front of a 100mph train at Southall Station. Navjeet Kaur 27 is pictured here with her two children at a fair a week before the horrific incident. Her husband Manjit Singh of Southall, West London, last night said: “I miss them immensely and am in a lot of pain." These words of a father and husband after losing his family speak volumes themselves. Manjit Singh Sidhu has this week paid a heartbreaking tribute, remembering his wife and children, saying he would "miss them forever.” "I am trying to cope with the tragic loss of my family whom I loved so dearly. I miss them immensely and am in a lot of pain," said Manjit Singh, 31 years old. "To my darling wife and kids, all I can say is that I love you with all my heart and one day we will be together forever." His heartfelt comments came as British Transport Police released CCTV footage from Southall station, West London, taken last Wednesday. In the CCTV footage, can be seen mother Navjeet Sidhu calmly pushing her toddler son in a buggy as her five year old girl innocently walked alongside. Minutes later she and daughter Simran were dead... killed instantly when depressed mother Navjeet threw herself and the children in the path of the 100mph Heathrow Express. The boy, 23-month-old Aman, survived the impact but died soon after arriving in the hospital. A security guard had confronted Navjeet, 27, about being too close to the track two hours earlier, but she said to him: "I'm taking my children to see the fast trains." Her husband raced to the station after receiving a phone call from her saying she was going "far, far away". After parking his car nearby, he arrived at the station finding his critically-injured son on the line. Navjeet at the station with her children A bunch of purple and white carnations left at the scene carry a poignant message from Manjit: "I love you all and will miss you all forever.” "My life will never be the same without you all. Thank you for the love, laughter and happiness you all brought to my life." It has emerged that Navjeet was four months pregnant, looked relaxed on an outing to Skegness two weeks ago. But some people in the local community have claimed she had been arguing with her mother-in-law. The former receptionist married Manjit at 20 years of age. It has also emerged from British Transport Police that CCTV does not operate at the platform where the tragedy took place and police had not been able to speak to witnesses. . This case has brought to light a key problem in the community. Navjeet having killed herself then questions need to be asked as to why? A community dialogue then needs to be established to non-judgementally explore causes and issues . The community needs to encourage people to seek professional help and offer more guidance. The stigma related to receiving professional help in the Punjabi community must be removed if it is to prevent further tragedies such as this. The stigma propagated by community members by labeling people because they seek professional advise needs to be addressed. Until such positive proactive steps are taken, people will not seek help and sadly we will see more of these tragic incidents.

Re: Mother and Children Suicide

* · 14 Sep 2005

This is so tragic. I've been doing a lot of reading about depression lately and this story sets off all sorts of alarms in my head. A lot of people suffer from depression, especially a lot of women, but it often remains undiagnosed and leads to these types of tragedies. I don’t know anything about this specific incident nor what could have led this woman to choose death for herself and for her children, but the article ends with a key point – there’s no shame in seeking help. Whether it’s professional help or talking to someone in your sangat, a friend, a family member....it’s extremely difficult and even detrimental to your wellbeing to keep your problems to yourself. Sharing the load and the burden makes it a lot easier to deal with your issues. Even if you think no one can help you, you’d be surprised at the difference made by simply talking about what you’re facing. Sometimes while talking about your problems, you end up talking yourself right to the other end of the tunnel and right to the solution you were looking for. If you know someone that is depressed, don’t try to con them out of their feelings. All too often people say, “Don’t worry about it!” or “it’s not so bad!", but essentially, these types of statements force the person to keep their problems to themselves and belittles their experience. Being there to lend an ear and showing some empathy can make all the difference in the world.

Re: Mother and Children Suicide

Kaurvs Singh · 14 Sep 2005

All I can say is that most of our community never tries to understand the feelings of a woman specially when is is expecting a baby. The emotional changes she goes through are never discussed. The trauma she goes through with the feeling given to her that she is probably gone disabled carrying a baby as most of us have to be out of job.( In most cases, unable to earn money because of certain restrictions like not having a permanent job) Then, Asian Community men never tries hard enough to bring the words to the wife that lets love our children with whatever we've got. Lets share it. they don't understand how hard a woman's life is to stay at home and bring up children in such a pressurised atmosphere. Still, its all a woman's fault. Please, don't take the matter said as anyone's personal life but its a fact of our asian society. Something needs to be done!

Re: Mother and Children Suicide

! · 14 Sep 2005

Good point above. Although we can't make assumptions about what really caused this tragedy, it is far too common in our community that the woman carries a lot of responsibility, often more than most people can really carry by themselves. This particular woman was married at the age of 20, and by the age of 27, was expecting her third child. It's challenging to be both a mother and a professional. It's hard to run a household, raise children, take care of a husband and in-laws quite possibly. All this constitutes a full-time job in itself. But this woman worked outside the home as well. That which is labelled as "woman's work" is frankly the most difficult kind of work, yet also the most under-appreciated. How many men out there hold down two full-time jobs? Not many. How many work 24/7? Many many many women work full-time outside the home and then come home to their second jobs. The job within the household that a woman does is not a 9-5 job, there's no coffee breaks or weekends off, no vacations or sick days.

Re: Mother and Children Suicide

Harjas Kaur · 15 Sep 2005

Didn't sound like she had too many friends to help her share feelings or shoulder responsibilities. That she was fighting with he in-laws just shows she needed more support than she had. Again, in my opinion these tragedies are not need for professional services and government intervention bringing anti-God beliefs and worldly social workers into the family. What is needed are religious communities which are close-knit and help care for each other in the spirit of Gursikhi. Modern society is fast-paced, stressed, and isolated. People need real community, neighbors that are Gursikhs. They need sewa of someone who can bring groceries or help watch the kids once in awhile. This family needed real sisters and brothers with love and concern to help care for the pregnant mother when husband was away working. At least there could have been older, wiser heads to help her with struggles with in-laws and give supportive advice. Again, all I have to say is orthodox Jewish communities have a lot of success surviving in modern society with strong loyalty for traditions because they stay close together and take care of each other. It's way too much for one little family to handle alone. It's so easy to get overlooked, isolated, overwhelmed and lost. The sadhsangat shouldn't live an hour drive away where they don't even notice someone is sad. People need to live so much closer. Close enough to actually make a difference. How many of you have your loved ones and sangat living an hours drive away, in another city, another state, another country? I think that has to change. Especially for our vulnerable members, old people, children, pregnant ladies, and the newly married. Poor husband probably didn't even know what to do. Is there any way we can write to him, help him out? [%sig%]

Re: Mother and Children Suicide

singh · 15 Sep 2005

this woman didnot work.....left work a year ago

Re: Mother and Children Suicide

Kaur vs Singh · 18 Sep 2005

HarJas Kaur ji, which religious communities of today's date are YOU talking about . Mainly, most of them are after running gurdwaras and throw dirt onto others. Noone seems to be understanding the the problems of a woman. If she talks about her feelings at home, she is said to be too demanding AND If she talks about it to someone else, they start to take advantage of all that by sort of blackmailing.I've got living examples with me as this sort of work is a part of my job. Our girls are taught TO LIVE WITHE HUSBAND< NO MATTER WHAT HE IS UPTO THE PHRASE NEVER ENDS WITH THE WORDS: '........LEAVE HIM' And what about her feelings for her children. A case known to me says that when she stood up for her rights, her son was snatched off her. Although the legal papers orders her to see the child, but there is always a constant obtacle from her in-laws. A BIG SHAME ON OUR SOCIETY although everyone is not the same but in majority of the cases, its always a woman who suffers, silently or asking for justice!!!! PRACTICAL LIFE IS SO MUCH DIFFERENT TO WHAT WE SAY.

Re: Mother and Children Suicide

rsingh · 18 Sep 2005

yes society... its about the way of thinking... if she leaves him then people will talk about her behind her back no matter what the reason they will label her as the one who "broke her home up". its stupid but true. people are affraid of getting proffesional help because they will get labbeled. really annoying thing is these labels stick people in our community have long memmories when it comes to these things and short memmory when it comes to gurmat... loll Gurdwaras are ment to be comunitty centra, can u imagine them providing counciling, etc. they are all about building a bigger gurdwara then one next door. time to wake up!!

Re: Mother and Children Suicide

Harjas Kaur · 19 Sep 2005

[quote]which religious communities of today's date are YOU talking about . Mainly, most of them are after running gurdwaras and throw dirt onto others. Noone seems to be understanding the the problems of a woman.[/quote] Im talking about the religious community that begins with you and me. There is always going to be corrupt, ignorant and hypocritical people. Just bless them. What else can you do? If complaining could make the world better it would already be liberated. All we can do is not get discouraged by what these people do and don't do. Keep your eyes on Gurbani and give your head to Guruji. Give your time, say paat, give daswandh, give wise words, give love to people when they need you. It can start with you and me and any good Gursikh people who want to make a difference by living Gurbani. If I am failing then don't look at me. If you are failing, then don't look at you. Just look at Gurbani and you live it. Then there is no failure. If people are throwing dirt, speak up and support the right things. If it;s turning into a fight, just do paat, and be the best support you can. If the whole Gurudwara is full of hypocrites, you become the Gursikh. You'll be surprised only one person can make a difference. One person can heal a lot of wounds. And also this is karam. What you give out also comes back to you. One day you might be the person in need. Imo, wealth is a corrupting influence. It would be better if we were poor and had real love and chardi kala, then palaces full of pain that we pray in. Remeber this is Kaliyug, so don't be discouraged by the things you see. [%sig%]

Re: Mother and Children Suicide

singh · 19 Sep 2005

what you talking about? the news is fraudulent the mother-in-law was not even living with the family mother-in-law lives in india bash the male side what happens when men commit sucide? he was NOT a MAn cos he chickened out????? talk about gender discrimination NOw?

Re: Mother and Children Suicide

i hate paintballing :-( · 19 Sep 2005

i know this sounds really harsh. but murder is a big paap. not only did she commit suicide, she took the lives of two innocent children!! they had ther whole future infront of them, and ther lives wer taken!!! she mite have wanted to die, but the kids didnt :_( thts paap :_(

Re: Mother and Children Suicide

* · 19 Sep 2005

>I've got living examples with me as this sort of work is a part of my job. To "Kaur vs Singh", what is your job? Are you a counsellor or something? To "singh", it's not gender discrimination. What are you talking about?? People have merely pointed out the reality of many women's lives and the difficulties they face. If you don't see the issues, you're terribly blind. You asked what happens when men commit suicide. People talk about it, that's what. They discuss factors that could have caused it and ways to prevent similar tragedies from occurring in the future. That's what people are doing here. This is an especially tragic case -- not only did the woman take her own life, but, like "i hate paintballing" stated above, she murdered her innocent children as well. If you don't see this as a serious issue that should be discussed, I'd be tempted to tell you where you can shove your notions of gender discrimination.. And in regards to this most enlighted statement: >the news is fraudulent >the mother-in-law was not even living with the family Does the mother-in-law have to be living with the family in order to be arguing with the daughter-in-law? I live separate from my own mother, yet we argue almost daily.

Re: Mother and Children Suicide

Scientific · 22 Sep 2005

It is pretty sad that peeple are jumping to all sorts of conclusions as to why this poor woman may have comitted suicide. Instantly assuming that the inlaws or husband is to blame is a dangerous and a rather simplistic presumption. I am a psychiatrist and the study of suicidology is very extensive with people having written encyclopedias on the subject. What i can say is that Suicide is no simple and easy act to attempt let alone pull off. I regular assess patients for risk of deliberate self harm and suicidal ideation. The vast majority of patients talk about wanting to end it all etc but on deeper psychiatric assessment are deemed low risk on the basis of having no active plans and having good social support factors in place to protect them etc. In the case of this young woman any number of things could have resulted in her taking her life and the lives of those so dear to her. It may have been an impulsive act in the backdrop of a longer standing mental illness or even an act which had been planned for months. There could be any number of ways that she could have ended up at the station. There could be any number of reasons for her mental illness (if indeed there was one). The only thing that can be concluded from the whole incident is that she could see no other way. For her this was the only way 'out' of her situation. Having interviewed dozens of failed suicide attempt patients i can draw the conclusion that these people can be so looking forward to ending it all that some even fantasise about the circumstances of how it will end. They have that much desperation and feel that trapped. What her 'situation' was may never be known and shouldnt be commented on without facts. All that can be said is that this was a very tragic heartbreaking incident that may have been averted if there had been help at hand. Scientific

Re: Mother and Children Suicide

suki kaur · 23 Sep 2005

With regard to your email, you have not understood the real world out there, she went to her mothers to stay but, her mother sent her back toher husband. Like the good wife she should be, I see every day how woman struggle to keep,up with the demands of in-laws,husband, kids, and even her own family, she doesn't. WHEN WILL WE SEE THAT SHE IS ONLY HUMAN. I have a very good husband, but even he is sometimes being a typical Indian , mainly when he is around other people. on our own he is a father and husband who does everything with me fifty fifty.

Re: Mother and Children Suicide

suicide prevention panel · 23 Sep 2005

Her husband was very bad to her. He was two-timing his wife. This was unbearable for the bibi ji. The husband will be severley punished by dharam rai. Suicide is a big issue amongst asians in the Ealing and Hounslow Boroughs, the sucide prevention panels will hopefully begin some proper work for once.... kaur.

Re: Mother and Children Suicide

No more... · 24 Sep 2005

u for real... he was 2 timing her.... gosh this is cause we dont have no sikhi in us nowwer days... vaheguroo