Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Karva chauth

Karva chauth

Gabroo Singh · 16 Oct 2003

WahegurujekakhalsaWahegurujekefateh!! Some may know what karva chauth is and some may not. I see a lotta "sikhs" women following this hindu ritual. Can someone pls post up some info on this ritual and why "sikh" women should NOT perform it?? Thanx in advance Dasan Daas

Re: Karva chauth

((((:-) · 16 Oct 2003

wat is karva chauth? it would help if sum1 xplained that...

Re: Karva chauth

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 17 Oct 2003

its a sexist fast, that females do for their husbands

Re: Karva chauth

. · 17 Oct 2003

karva chauth is a hindu ritual which celebrates the slavery of women. Some women fast on this day because they think that fasting will grant their husbands longer lives. But their husbands never fast for them, what a surprise. Some girls also fast before they get married, in order to make sure that they will have a good-looking husband when they grow up... In my opinion, this is all a joke.. kabeer har kaa simaran shhaadd kai ahoee raakhai naar || Kabeer, the woman who gives up meditation on the Lord, and observes the ritual fast of Ahoi, gadhehee hoe kai aoutharai bhaar sehai man chaar ||108|| shall be reincarnated as a donkey, to carry heavy burdens. ||108|| -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- theerathh barath ar dhaan kar man mai dhharai gumaan || Those who make pilgrimages to sacred shrines, observe ritualistic fasts and make donations to charity while still taking pride in their minds naanak nihafal jaath thih jio ku(n)char eisanaan ||46|| - O Nanak, their actions are useless, like the elephant, who takes a bath, and then rolls in the dust. ||46|| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ varath naem such sa(n)jam poojaa paakha(n)dd bharam n jaae || By ritualistic fasts, vows, purities, self-disciplines and worship ceremonies, they still cannot get rid of their hypocrisy and doubt. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ theerathh varath such sa(n)jam naahee karam dhharam nehee poojaa || Pilgrimages, fasts, purification and self-discipline are of no use, nor are rituals, religious ceremonies or empty worship.

Re: Karva chauth

GPD · 17 Oct 2003

Maybe alot of those women do it purely out of love for there husbands. Of course if we judge them from our perspective based on our religion and culture, then it would seem sexist. But ask a Hindu woman what karva chouth means to her. Ask her about he sentiments behind this “sexist” ritual. Based on that it wouldn’t seem sexist. Just my opinion. But I have to say that a Sikh woman should never observe Karva Chouth. That’s totally wrong, it's not part of our religion or culture.

Re: Karva chauth

Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 17 Oct 2003

shhoddehi a(n)n karehi paakha(n)dd || One who discards this grain, is practicing hypocrisy. naa sohaagan naa ouhi ra(n)dd || She is neither a happy soul-bride, nor a widow. http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=3261

Re: Karva chauth

jul jeerah · 17 Oct 2003

precisely what happens when we are a minority. no role models, follow on rituals and cultures of different religions. same thing happening to sikhs living in large muslim stronghols, so many sikhs have started to copy pakistani image of dressing, close crop haircuts, the goatie, talking slang, wudnt it be great if we cud have 960 million khalsa who were rehet pakhey then where wud bibia or naujwaan copy nex religion? all due respects to muslims hindus their cultures and their methods if its for them makes them happy im happy for our brothers and sisters whatever they are, but this clearly is defined previous posts in bani stance on the issue of fasting no place in sikhi end of! i think it wud be more effective to rather than condemn a bibi for doing karva chauth, to add in sum humour , that will also make her think logically t, like pick up a blade of grass for a laff and point it to the moon and u pretend to fast with her and say your also doing it for a future gud wife, or eat your mates favourite food on the day she is fasting tease the hell out of her as if your really enjoying it, or ask her challanging things that will make her think what the hell am i doing? . cos otherwise if you bang on about how bad or contradictory it is she will jus get defensive, women r sensitive, and we all know defensive vibes leave bad echoeing effects when dat person sees u next. ah heres a gud one, ask her if this wud be a universal principle for hindus, then ask but hey if ur medically ill then it wud be damaging to your health? hence principally as a religious practice it cannot even be collectively be applied by hindu women.

Re: Karva chauth

moi · 18 Oct 2003

Pretty scary that now SIKH women are practicing this Hindu tradition with even more dedication than the Hindus. __________________________________________ More and more Sikh women embracing Hindu custom HT Live Correspondent Kharar, October 14 Fascinated by the custom of Karva Chauth, many Sikh women adopted the Hindu tradition of fasting on this day. Whereas for the typical Indian married women, the western concept of Valentine’s Day as an “_expression of love” has not really caught the imagination, Karva Chauth has found the acceptance of other faiths too, if increasing trend of observing fast by Sikh women was any indication. It was interesting to note that the Hindu married women had relaxed the conditions of the fast, which does not even allow a drop of water to be consumed before sighting and being drenched in the moonlight, by having a cup of tea or a glass of water, the Sikh women, who voluntarily observe the fast out of no family compulsions, were extremely staunch about the tradition. In this Chandigarh scenario, what actually came across was that love conquers all. No barriers were strong enough to banish the one emotion of love.

Re: Karva chauth

JK · 18 Oct 2003

GPD wrote: "Maybe alot of those women do it purely out of love for there husbands. Of course if we judge them from our perspective based on our religion and culture, then it would seem sexist. But ask a Hindu woman what karva chouth means to her. Ask her about he sentiments behind this “sexist” ritual. Based on that it wouldn’t seem sexist. Just my opinion." I think for the most part, many do it as a ritual, as something they're SUPPOSED to do, but I can't see how a woman who thinks logically would find it to be anything BUT sexist. If it's an expression of love, why not express it everyday by fasting everyday?

Re: Karva chauth

. · 18 Oct 2003

im no one to judge other peoples actions, honestly, but i honestly think that for most women, it's just pakhand... i mean.... we had a paat at our house the other day, a sukhmani sahib dha paat, and my mom invited all her friends (it was just for ladies). All of her friends are from sikh families, and they consider themselves sikhs, but at least 5 or 6 of them out of 15 were keeping the karva chaut fast!! and these are supposedly SIKH woman.. the thing that disturbed me more is that even after reading the sukhmani sahib, such a beautiful bani which is one of the most easy to understand, they wouldn't even eat PARSHAAD or LANGAR... its so sad, when sikhs(?) turn down langar and parshaad, because they're keeping a hindu fast... honestly, i tried to look into the eyes of these ladies who kept fasts and i found no contentment... there were some women who were actually there for the right reasons, though, and you could tell that from their faces -they were almost glowing, after doing the paat.. but the others looked more tense, they couldnt concentrate on the paat, and they kept on telling everyone "i'm keeping a fast today"', as if they were proud of it.. oh well may guru have kirpa on them im stupid for looking at the ladies anyway... shouldve kept to myself

Re: Karva chauth

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 18 Oct 2003

tha's sick turning down langaar or parshaad for a hindu fast

Re: Karva chauth

sooorma · 19 Oct 2003

gabru sian i doubt the women see it as a hindu thing but more like romantic feat for their husband. i tell ya one thing made me think this singh talked about 84 and stuff who moved in 2 doors away from my house. he was telling me at da tyme in birmingham how his chachey thai and cousins led a demo against the indian banks, causing raphud. Then i went to his house he had a lil mandir dedicated to shera vali mata. i asked singh do u mind if i ask you why you got this? he was being bullied at work, didnt know how to handle it and felt praying to durga ji work. but the logical point is if you have had enuff of being bullied , your mind mentally is made up that it will no longer take crap, then it will start to operate with other parts of your brain to face the challanges, and gather yourself , that is human nature common sense, . but this guy thought that praying to durga did it. hence he became a part time sikh going to gurdwara on sundays and also to the mandir although his forefathers and cousins are all sikh. i think its cos people aint doing bani, their loosing big time, cos the effects of gurmat bani wud kick in by doing it regular and you wudnt look for external help cos bani wud talk inside u to face what u gotto face, raise ur conciousness to heightened levels and turn u into a sher urself. they think i go gurdwara, i bow my head i dont get nuttin i cant face my challanges. thats whats gonna happen if you aint doing ur bhagti bani n paat. not to condemn, or judge , pyar to veer and panjis , but the pivot effect the raas of sikhi is not in bowing your matta to guru ji and lead a life without your guru , that raas is inside bani and helps u in every aspect of life if you carry out your bandghi your guru will sort it out. even if they aint got naam bani wud still help dem. a woman big fear loose her husband, instead of doing bani if she hasnt felt the ras of it will look for summit else ie fast. n it looks romantic at the face of it. she aint gonna be thinking its hindu , to her an external deed looks real. u gotto understand how people work, if you say to dem thats not sikhi, they can knock u bak and say yuour being judgemental, thats what giannis tell us look at them, they secretly drink do all kinds of things they will say all this knowledge hasnt changed the gianni down the rd so what will it do for me? i think one way around this, rather than knock some1 down for doing their stuff lets just introduce them to gurbani with pyaaaaaaaaaar, start off japji then other banis, let their soul feel the peace, ras, happiness within gurmat bani then that wud speak for itself. bani wud soak into a persons subconciousness they wud automatically get the message of fasts without you telling them. think about it someone tells you " oi what ur doing is digusting" youl get angry more than anything. then other way let bani talk to a human, which way wud work???

Re: Karva chauth

Kulbir Singh · 20 Oct 2003

Very well said Soorma jee!

Re: Karva chauth

vsg · 22 Oct 2003

this is sick ! Can't believe that this is happening... :O