What is Naam DriR and how can someone RECEIVE it?
SenghSational · 17 Sep 2005
VJKK VJKF Thank you.
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
SenghSational · 17 Sep 2005
VJKK VJKF Thank you.Guru ji help me i'm so weak · 19 Sep 2005
The answer can only be given by panj payaray and it can ONLy be given by panj pyaaray. Some people say well i don't need to go to panj pyaray to learn it i now it already. Inthe same way most people know that waheguru is gurmantar so then theres no need to go to panj pyaray then casue yougot gurmantar <<Harjas Kaur · 19 Sep 2005
A lot of people do Naam simran. A lot of people can't get much into it because all they are doing is singing, or chanting Gurmantar and there's not a lot of change in their lives. So you know there are techniques you could learn that might bring you closer to a meditative state. But you realize techniques aren't much either. Then you start thinking you want what chardi kala Gursikh people have. And you want Naam drir. Its more than just a way to do swas swas simran. It channels a vibration from Gurmanter into your very life-breath and cleanses your mind. You can't learn it, or copy it or get it on your own. You have to give your head to Guruji, become a Gursikh and get Amrit chukk from Panj Pyare. All amrit is amrit. But, for Naam drir, you need to get amrit chukk from AKJ Panj Piare. Because far as I know they are the only ones that give it. I don't mean to offend any jatha or anything, but not all Amrit sinchars are the same. Believe me, if you get Amrit chukk from AKJ, you will understand the difference. Again, I am not disrespecting anyone at all. It's just my experience AKJ Panj Pyare have something powerful and true and good. Much more powerful than any breathing exercise or any song or any chant. They have Naam drir. It is the true Gurmantar. Just saying a name isn't going to liberate you. You need the powerful Naam to vibrate in your whole body-mind. If you want to know if your Naam simran is good, just look at your life over time. Are you becoming more dedicated chardi kala Gursikh in love with Waheguruji? Because real Naam will give you deepening love. it is a cure for struggle of life and gives you mukti by Guru's grace. [quote]gurmukhay gurmukh nadree raam pi-aaraa raam. As Gurmukh, the Gurmukh beholds the Lord, the Beloved Lord. raam naam pi-aaraa jagat nistaaraa raam naam vadi-aa-ee. The Name of the Lord, the Emancipator of the world, is dear to him; the Name of the Lord is his glory. kalijug raam naam bohithaa gurmukh paar laghaa-ee. In this Dark Age of Kali Yuga, the Lord's Name is the boat, which carries the Gurmukh across. halat palat raam naam suhaylay gurmukh karnee saaree. This world, and the world hereafter, are adorned with the Lord's Name; the Gurmukh's lifestyle is the most excellent. naanak daat da-i-aa kar dayvai raam naam nistaaree. ||1|| O Nanak, bestowing His kindness, the Lord gives the gift of His emancipating Name. ||1|| raamo raam naam japi-aa dukh kilvikh naas gavaa-i-aa raam. I chant the Name of the Lord, Raam, Raam, which destroys my sorrows and erases my sins. gur parchai gur parchai Dhi-aa-i-aa mai hirdai raam ravaa-i-aa raam. Associating with the Guru, associating with the Guru, I practice meditation; I have enshrined the Lord within my heart. ravi-aa raam hirdai param gat paa-ee jaa gur sarnaa-ee aa-ay. I enshrined the Lord within my heart, and obtained the supreme status, when I came to the Sanctuary of the Guru. obh vikaar naav dubdee niklee jaa satgur naam dirhaa-ay. My boat was sinking under the weight of greed and corruption, but it was uplifted when the True Guru implanted the Naam, the Name of the Lord, within me. jee-a daan gur poorai dee-aa raam naam chit laa-ay. The Perfect Guru has given me the gift of spiritual life, and I center my consciousness on the Lord's Name. aap kirpaal kirpaa kar dayvai naanak gur sarnaa-ay. ||2|| The Merciful Lord Himself has mercifully given this gift to me; O Nanak, I take to the Sanctuary of the Guru. ||2|| banee raam naam sunee siDh kaaraj sabh suhaa-ay raam. Hearing the Bani of the Lord's Name, all my affairs were brought to perfection and embellished. romay rom rom romay mai gurmukh raam Dhi-aa-ay raam. With each and every hair, with each and every hair, as Gurmukh, I meditate on the Lord. -SGGS p. 444[/quote] [%sig%]KS · 19 Sep 2005
"Believe me, if you get Amrit chukk from AKJ, you will understand the difference" Harjas Kaur your words make me wonder what state the panth must have been before the formation of the AKJA Singh · 19 Sep 2005
Dear Har Jas Kaur Gur Fateh! Your stated the following:- <> Your views are not only incorrect, but also a disgusting use of dharma to cover up for your personal political affiliations and outlook. You (and MANY others like you with the same political bias) are no different from the situation described in George Orwell’s Animal Farm “ALL animals are equal, but some are more equal than others”. There seems to be a clear pattern here, first those like you, begin to feel it necessary to justify the view that only Sikhi is the way for ALL mankind and all other ways are futile, rather like the though process of Semetic religious groups and far right Hindu groups. The next logically step for you is to then turn on your Sikh brethren and defile the sanctity of Panthic Ekta. Usually when one asks even the AKJ about “Naam Dhrir” they are quick to resort that many Panthic groups also practice this and many non-AKJ Gursikhs have done so in the past – now, you for some reason seem to think that only the AKJ have a monopoly on such a method, which is known to also exist within Namdharis, who also once did a great service for the Panth under the leadership of Baba Ram Singh, however their present position speaks loudly enough. You then go on to say “I don't mean to offend any jatha or anything, but not all Amrit sinchars are the same” Well, Ms Har Jas Kaur, you are intending to offend, not just “Jatha or anything”, but the Panth. It is precisely because of this ‘my way or the high way’ mindset of today’s so called “chardi kala full time bana wearing singhs and singhnees” that we have so little ekta – people like you have the sheer audacity to even claim monopoly over the sanctity of GURU SAHIB’s Amrit Sanchar. Again, even when the AKJ are questioned about their rehit, they always indicate that they support the Akal Thakt – however according to those (and many there are) adopting your mindset, even the Akal Thakt is nothing when it comes to the crunch – oh of course, you will then seek to have Gurbani as the backing for your beliefs, however as many examples have shown, your “selection” and “interpretation” is heavily biased here as well. The utter nonsense of your statement “It's just my experience AKJ Panj Pyare have something powerful and true and good” is hardly surprising – on one hand, people subscribing to your view, take the Punj Pyare to unknown heights with your regular “pesh” requests over every minute matter (rather like the confession at the Christian Church) since you consider them collectively to be the embodiment of Guru Sahib as per his closing orders, yet you now consider yourself as an individual to be in a position to verify and assess the quality of the Punj??? What did you do, go from Amrit Sanchar to Amrit Sanchar taking the interviews of the Punj Pyare??? Who do you consider yourself to be? A brahmgyani??? That you, singularly, can assess and pass judgement on the Punj Pyare??? The true Gurmantra is Vahiguroo, not Naam Dhrir, again it amazing to see people who go to lengthy arguments to support notions like this and others that have been discussed several times on this forum in the name of Gurmat and Gurmaryada. Bhai Gurdas Jee in his Varan and Guru Sahib in both the Sri Guru Granth Sahib and Dasam Granth Sahib, even the Sri Sarabloh Prakash have stated clearly what this is and that should be sufficient for us. Additional arguments on this are futile – but what can one expect from the legacy of those who once tried to change the Gurmantra to “Vah! Guru!”. Gur Fateh! A Singh.i hate paintballing :-( · 19 Sep 2005
mmmmmm harjas kaur i understand what you are saying however i disagree with you when you say """"But, for Naam drir, you need to get amrit chukk from AKJ Panj Piare. Because far as I know they are the only ones that give it. I don't mean to offend any jatha or anything, but not all Amrit sinchars are the same. Believe me, if you get Amrit chukk from AKJ, you will understand the difference. Again, I am not disrespecting anyone at all. It's just my experience AKJ Panj Pyare have something powerful and true and good."""""" there is no such thing as 'akj' panj piayre. i agree with you that yes its important to recieve naam driRh, but we receive this naam driRh from the PANJ PIAYRE not from 'akj'. when you take amrit from the panj piayre they even tell you at the end, that you havent taken amrit from any jatha. we shouldnt label ourselves as 'akj'. we are sikhs of guru gobind singh jee :-) bhul chuk maaf karna vahigurujikakhalsa vahigurujikifateh... · 19 Sep 2005
"Believe me, if you get Amrit chukk from AKJ, you will understand the difference" That is such a disgusting and bigoted statement. Truly astonishing. Gurbani says "Nanak Amrit Aek Hai, Dooja Amrit Nahi". There is only one Amrit - let's not split the Panth by saying that on Jathebandi is above all others. AKJ is only one part of the Panth - it is not the Panth itself. AKJ guys that agree with the above statement really need to get out of their narrow tunnel visioned viewset of Sikhi, and learn to love the whole Khalsa Panth.Kulbir Singh · 19 Sep 2005
Excellent post Bhain Harjas Kaur jeeo. A.Singh jeeo, I think you are over reacting to Bhain jee’s post. There is no doubt that all amrit sinchaars are not same. It is not about Taksal or AKJ but wherever Punj Pyaray conduct amrit sinchaar with full maryada, that amrit sinchaar is acceptable to Guru Sahib. Here are some of the points about this: 1) Many amrit sinchaars today are conducted without the presence of Guru Sahib i.e. Laridaar Saroop of Guru Sahib. If Guru Sahib is not present, such amrit sinchaars cannot be valid. 2) Many amrit sinchaars are such where Gursikhs doing sewa in Punj Pyaray are not keeping even basic rehit. Don’t know how these Punj Pyaray can give updesh of keeping rehit to new abhilaakhis. 3) It is a well-known fact that when administering amrit, punj pyaray give 5 choolay of amrit to drink, sprinkle amrit in eyes five times and put amrit in kesh five times. The problem is that in most amrit sinchaars, this all is done by one of the Punj Pyaray not all five. There is a clear indication in rehitnamas (Paanch Sikh Amrit jo deve ..) and by tradition that this should be done by all Punj Pyaray and this is why all this is done five times – i.e. five choolay, five times in kesh and eyes. The correct way to do this is that each of the Punj Pyaray Gursikhs should give choola once, sprinkle in eyes once and same thing with kesh as opposed to one of the Punj Pyaray doing all this. 4) As stated in “3”, amrit is prepared by Punj Pyaray in all amrit sinchaars but in all amrit sinchaars, Punj Pyaray don’t give amrit to abhilaakhis but only one or two of the punj pyaray do so. This is a big violation of the principle of Punj Pyaray who jointly represent Guru Sahib. If one of the punj Pyaray give amrit to abhilakhis, then I humbly say that one cannot say that one has received amrit from Guru roopi punj pyaray but will have to say that one has received amrit from one of the punj pyaray. It is foolish to think that no matter what, all punj pyaray are same and all amrit sinchaars are same. Amrit sinchaars where Gurmat Maryada is not followed or where Guru Sahib is not present, cannot be classified as amrit sinchaars. Small differences are fine and natural but when there are big deviations from Maryada, then one has to come to the conclusion that amrit sinchaars are different and some amrit sinchaars are not valid. What is Naam Drir? Naam drir is the process through which the Punj Pyaray implant the seed of Naam in the hirda of abhilaakhis. This is done after the amrit is adminstered to the seeker and should be done to each abhilaakhi one on one basis as opposed to just having the whole group of abhilaakhis say Gurmantar five times. As for the Naam technique, how would one japp Naam if one does not know how to japp it? Is it not logical that when Naam is given to abhilaakhis, at the same time they also be taught how to japp Naam? Who should the abhilaakhis ask how to japp Naam - Punj Pyaray or some so called sant mahapurakh? We must rise above jathebandis and groups and follow Gurmat Maryada. Every AKJ amrit sinchaar is not good and every Taksali amrit sinchaar is not bad. Where ever proper Gurmat Maryada is followed, that amrit sinchaar is acceptable to Guru Sahib. Rest is chauraasi daa maal. Kulbir Singha singh · 19 Sep 2005
was Naam DriRtha around before the times of Bhai Randheer Singh Jee? Or was this technique revealed to him? thank you. ps "AKJ is only one part of the Panth - it is not the Panth itself." veer jee/bhenjee i agree with you totally but it seems as if your not AKJ your not part of the Panth. :(Gurpreet Kaur · 19 Sep 2005
Wah Kulbir Singh Jee, you have blatantly said that anyone who has taken Amrit or will take Amrit from anyone other than the Punj Pyare is not a Amritdharee and the Sanchaar is NOT valid. I wasnt going to post on this thread but this line caught my attention: >>Who should the abhilaakhis ask how to japp Naam - Punj Pyaray or some so called sant mahapurakh?<< So quick to criticise and accuse Sants, but quicker to judge every single Amrit Sanchaar which takes place outside the AKJ rules. That is so bigoted that I am shocked. You are now basically saying that people like Bhai Jarnail Singh, Baba Nand Singh, Baba Isher Singh Jee were actually not Amritdharee's and even if they were, they didn't have Naam implanted in them as they didnt take Amrit from the Jatha you think is VALID. Now, you say Naam has to be implaned in your heart, I disagree. Naam is Vaheguru, Im sure you would agree with that, and He is in every one of us, so is the Naam merely reactivated or is it planted there? Maybe you could explain how Naam was implanted into Sikhs before the time of Guru Gobind Singh Jee also? WJKK WJKF!RoopKaur · 19 Sep 2005
I totally agree with bhain ji harjas Kaur's post. The reason AKJ amrit sanchaars are different are not because of the title AKJ, it is because they are done according to the maryada guru ji layed down. The amrit sanchaars that are done with full maryada, only they can be expected to reap the results. Naam Drirtaa was done from the time of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji, Bhai Sahib did not start it, he just merely reintroduced the panth to it, just like a lot of other things like Sarbloh bibek etc. It is no hidden fact that the panth had lost many of its rehits during the time of the mahants in our gurdvaras, and we can see the affect of this loss till today in the panth. >There seems to be a clear pattern here, first those like you, begin to feel it necessary to justify the view that only Sikhi is the way for ALL mankind and all other ways are futile, rather like the though process of Semetic religious groups and far right Hindu groups. The next logically step for you is to then turn on your Sikh brethren and defile the sanctity of Panthic Ekta.< We as Sikhs are bound by what gurbani says, and gurbani says Bin satgur kinai na paaeo, bin satguru jinai na paaeaa. To a Sikh, it does not matter what the latest political correct thing to beleive is, because guru ji comes before worldly ideas of political correctness. So, yes, for a Sikh, It is only through guru jis sharn that true religion can be found.... · 19 Sep 2005
Kulbir Singh - where is the evidence for the Amrit Sanchaar technique that you have provided. The Panthic Rehit Maryada, as approved by Akal Takhat does not state the method above. Akal Takhat represents the Panth - not AKJ Rehit Maryada. How come AKJ always says follow the Panthic Rehit Maryada, but when they disagree with something, they always maintain that they are right over the rest of the Panth and Panthic Maryada? Similarly, when another Jathebandi like Taksaal or Nanaksar does a longer Rehiraas da Paath, they always criticise those Jathebandis for being Anti-Panthic and undermining Panthic Rehit Maryada. It seems that AKJ only uses the Panthic Rehit Maryada as a front to do whatever it wants and pleases, and again, it always assumes that its views represent the Panth. Once again, I repeat, AKJ is not the Panth - it is only a part, but very valued part, of the Panth, just like Nanaksar, Taksal, Rara Sahib, Nihangs, GNNSJ, etc are. You say that not all Amrit Sanchaars are bad - but actually, the technique stated above, only AKJ uses it!! Even then, nearly all of AKJ does not use a Lareedar Saroop in its Amrit Sanchaars. Are you saying that all Sikhs are not really Amritdhari and haven't given their heads to Guru Sahib if they do not use the "Kulbir Singh" method?Gurpreet Kaur · 19 Sep 2005
>>Naam Drirtaa was done from the time of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji<< RoopKaur Jee, what is your source or reference for this statement? Im intrigued to know more about this.Kulbir Singh · 19 Sep 2005
Bhain Gurpreet Kaur jee, --------- Wah Kulbir Singh Jee, you have blatantly said that anyone who has taken Amrit or will take Amrit from anyone other than the Punj Pyare is not a Amritdharee and the Sanchaar is NOT valid. I wasnt going to post on this thread but this line caught my attention: ----------- Bhain jee, gussa na karo. All I am saying is that amrit should be taken from Punj Pyaray and not one individual. What is wrong with this? The whole purpose of having choola 5 times is to enable each of the Punj Pyaray to give amrit. Same reason for placing it five times in kesh and sprinkling five times in hair. What is the purpose of having punj pyaray when just one person is going to give amrit? --------------- >>Who should the abhilaakhis ask how to japp Naam - Punj Pyaray or some so called sant mahapurakh?<< So quick to criticise and accuse Sants, but quicker to judge every single Amrit Sanchaar which takes place outside the AKJ rules. That is so bigoted that I am shocked. ------------- I did not mention akj any place. All I stated was that important activities like amrit sinchaar should be done with Gurmat Maryada. I did not criticize any sants, just fake sants. It is a known and proven Gurmat principle that Naam can only be obtained from Punj Pyaray and not from any Mahapurakh or so called sant. ----------- You are now basically saying that people like Bhai Jarnail Singh, Baba Nand Singh, Baba Isher Singh Jee were actually not Amritdharee's and even if they were, they didn't have Naam implanted in them as they didnt take Amrit from the Jatha you think is VALID. ------------- Don’t press the emotional buttons. Let us stick to the principles and not what this sant did and that sant did. You were not there and I was not there when Baba Nand Singh took amrit and when Baba Jarnail Singh too amrit. It is quite possible that all this dilution of maryada took place in the last 40-45 years. --------- Now, you say Naam has to be implaned in your heart, I disagree. Naam is Vaheguru, Im sure you would agree with that, and He is in every one of us, so is the Naam merely reactivated or is it planted there? ------------- You have taken my comments out of context. I was merely using the metaphor of seed when I said implanting Naam. I am sorry if I confused you. You are right. DriR does not translate into implanting. I don’t know what word I should use. Perhaps reactivation is a good word. But Naam dee driRta is done after amrit chhak on one by one basis, by the Punj Pyaray. Kulbir SinghKulbir Singh · 19 Sep 2005
Instead of getting upset, for a moment thing about it. Shouldn’t all punj pyaray be involved when giving amrit? “paanch sikh amrit jo deve” and in one of the hukamnama Guru Gobind Singh jee has stated – “tusa amrit panja tau laina” (you should take amrit from punj). I agree that amrit is prepared by punj in all amrit sinchaars but in all amrit sinchaars, punj pyaray collectively don’t give amrit, rather only one person or two persons out of Punj Pyaray do it. Don’t you think all punj pyaray should be involved? Kulbir SinghSingh · 19 Sep 2005
Everyone seems to be getting upset over Bibi Harjas Kaur's comments but I am sure this is because she had an extremely powerful experience when she was given Naam Drirrh, as many people do. Try and understand why she has this much enthusiasm for Naam Drirrh and even read her past posts, rather than dismissing it as "AKJ propaganda".... · 19 Sep 2005
Kulbir Singh - even though you say that it seems logical that each Pyaara should give Amrit, where does it say that this is the only way of Gurmat Maryada and all other Amrit Sanchaars are improper pls provide historical evidence - ie prior to Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh, to prove that the rest of the Panth is acting to improper MaryadaGurpreet Singh · 19 Sep 2005
Kulbir Singh Ji, About nam Drirr, we do not need to ask anyone how to do naam simran Guru CLEARLY states "Har araadh n jaanaa rae HAR HAR GUR GUR kartha rae" Guru Sahib clearly tells us that for one who doesnt know how to do naam simran, just repeat the name of akaal purakh. The rest will take care of itself.charanjeev singh · 19 Sep 2005
Pyareh veer and bhenjis, let bhen Harjas Kaur, and veer Kulbir Singh give their opinions, and everybody else whom have had Amrit dee Daath from Panj Pyareh, just enjoy the bliss, no need to argue. Anand Manloh. Those whom have had Amrit dee Daath, know the difference it has made in their life. There is no need to argue with others, just enjoy the bliss of this Ambrosial Nectar. Those whom think they know the way, in reality have no clue. Guru Sahib is very dyaalu, everybody whom have had Amrit from Panj Pyareh, just enjoy the bliss. It truly is the essence of human jeevan. Those whom try to make Amrit into a technical thing, have lost the scope. The maryada for your blissful life is known as the Rehat Maryada. Living by this, your life will undoubtly be Amrit Jeevan. waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikfatehkaur1978 · 20 Sep 2005
great post Gurpreet Singh..Zorawar Singh · 20 Sep 2005
If we look today in the Panth, Nihangs or Snaatanists state only their Amrit is Amrit. Niskam Sevak Jatha say their Amrit is superior. Taksal say they were started by Guru Gobind Singh ji, so only what they say should be accepted. However AKJ is not saying only their Amrit is Amrit. "nanak Amrit ek hai, dooja nahin koe". The seed is always the same. AKJ is saying the method of giving the Gurmantar has been lost over the years. We know this ourselves, when we see large sant mass Amrit sanchaars, where people come back not even knowing the Gurmantar, or being told, they do not need to worry about kirpans, or make up or jewellery. What AKJ is saying is the method of giving Naam needs to be re-introduced into the Panth for the benefit of the Panth. If every Amrit Sanchaar did give Naam Dritha, then it would no longer be an issue. NO-ONE SHOULD EVER COMPROMISE ON NAAM! This does not mean they are saying that AKJ Amrit is higher, as no AKJ Amrit exists. It is only Guru Ke Khande Bate ki Amrit. So the debate is nothing to do with Amrit, but with Naam. Now can anyone say that they are Naam abyassi to the level that they are content. If not then get Naam Drihh. Even if you have already had it. Just go again and get another boost of Naam. Even those who are Naam drihh, it means nothing if you do not do abyass afterwards. It is only of value, if you attempt for 24/7 simran. So those who say, I got Naam drihh, and it was nothing special, they need to think, how much simran did I do afterwards. It takes about one month of Amrit vela just to get your Naam going in your breaths, and then the more you do the better. Those who say naam Drihh is of no value, need to think, am I really doing as much simran as I should? If not then why am I restricting others from finding out about Naam?msingh · 20 Sep 2005
What a discussion thread! To me sikhi is not a cult or a magical way of obtaining salvation. The key to progress is 'kmaee', understanding guru ji's message and acting on it. I don't see how the arguments here will help anybody become a better sikh. Sadly we sound like a bunch of manmukhs (I included) bickering over matters we know little about, and probably don't need to concern ourselves with. Full stop. (bhul chuk maf) Why do I make such a harsh statement? Because I think it is absolutly essential that the first step is we should be reading gurbani, understanding the message and trying to mould our lives accordingly. Matters about nam drir, intricacies of amrit, etc come later – some things are better practiced that talked about. To put it another way, nam drir, or amrit from a special jatha is useless if are not willing to listen to guru ji's teaching, such as dealing with kam, krod, lob, moh, ahnkar. I can't imagine gursikhs who are near to Guru ji going on about what's being discussed here, they will quietly go on with their kmaee and work to promote chardi kala of the panth. As I say sikhi is not acult and has no magic solutions to spirituality - so to say a particular form of amrit administered by some special jatha is going to give you salvation, well it's rather silly and childish to think like this. It's the effect of amrit, the inner transformation that is important. Let’s heed what Guru ji is saying: gurmukh kaar kamaavnee sach ghat pargat ho-ay. The Gurmukh practices good deeds, and the truth is revealed in the heart. Page 27, Line 2 -- Guru Amar Das jinee gurmukh naam Dhi-aa-i-aa vichahu aap gavaa-ay. The Gurmukhs meditate on the Naam; they eradicate selfishness and conceit from within. Page 28, Line 11 -- Guru Amar Das ha-umai gurmukh kho-ee-ai naam ratay sukh ho-ay. ||1| The Gurmukhs shed their ego; attuned to the Naam, they find peace. ||1|| Page 29, Line 11 -- Guru Amar Das gurmukh laahaa lai ga-ay manmukh chalay mool gavaa-ay jee-o. ||19|| The Gurmukhs reap their profits and leave, while the self-willed manmukhs lose their investment and depart. ||19|| Page 74, Line 11 -- Guru Arjan Dev gurmukh karam Dharam sach ho-ee. Through karma and Dharma, good actions and righteous faith, the Gurmukh becomes true. Page 230, Line 2 -- Guru Amar Das gurmukh sayvaa paraan aDhaaraa. Selfless service is the support of the breath of life of the Gurmukh. Page 229, Line 18 -- Guru Amar Das msingh [%sig%]420 · 20 Sep 2005
answer the questions... · 20 Sep 2005
i think gurpreet singh and charanjeev singh's posts smashed it!!!Harjas Kaur · 20 Sep 2005
I do not speak for AKJ. I am only my own voice. I share experiences which are with AKJ and answering someone questions about what is Naam drir and how can you get it. I do not say Sant Jarnail Singhji Bhindranwale was not Khalsa because he did not have Naam Drir through the AKJ Panj Pyare. I did not say amrit received anywhere else is not valid. I did not say I have all the magic answers and everyone must listen to my opinion. I said what I believe. Some amrit sinchars are not according to rehat Maryada and leave a person clueless and they do not have Naam and their lives do not change and sometimes they leave Sikhi. And I answered the question, the only way I know to receive Naam drir is through Panj Pyare who are affiliated with AKJ. [quote]AKJ is saying the method of giving the Gurmantar has been lost over the years... What AKJ is saying is the method of giving Naam needs to be re-introduced into the Panth for the benefit of the Panth. If every Amrit Sanchaar did give Naam Dritha, then it would no longer be an issue. NO-ONE SHOULD EVER COMPROMISE ON NAAM![/quote] Actually, I agree 100% with Zorowar Singh on these points. If I am wrong, I am sincerely believing this. No need for upset or anger or grief. It's an opinion board. We learn from each other. But if you think Im a bigot or a cultist, or a danger to the Panth that is fine. So many Sikh children who get amrit chukk from amrit Sinchars with no chardi kala Gursikh people and no Naam DIE to Sikhi! This is bigger danger than anything I could ever say. And I have this experience. I know these kids. They sit at waja and say empty words, their heart is not in it. Then they run off with bad friends and learn evil things. They take amrit from Panj Pyare they don't even respect! Why let these kids die spiritually when you can encourage them to do something beautiful that will change their life for the better? THESE KIDS NEED NAAM DRIR! I believe in Naam drir because I have experienced it. So this is what I share. How could I speak for anything else? If you have beautiful experience to share that is not AKJ, then share it! Then we can all learn something. To answer the question, as far as I know only Panj Pyare affiliated with AKJ give Naam drir during Amrit Sinchar. They are not a cult. They have strong loyalty to the Rehat Maryada, are Sarbloh bibekis, do NOT trim any hairs, do NOT eat meat, wear keski, say paat every day etc. No one is perfect, but I believe in this strictness. I trust it! Absolutely, without question. It is LIFE in a world of DEATH! I only want to bless these kids and encourage them to some goodness of God. I can only share what I know about. If any of you had experience of Naam drir, this whole topic would not even be an issue. I do not say the jatha is perfect. But I do know beyond the shadow of a doubt that the jatha has something authentic that is a gift to the entire Panth! It is a gift to a lot of kids who are getting lost. Think about that before you start bashing AKJ. [%sig%]Abhiyaas.Blogspot.Com · 20 Sep 2005
It is calamitous to see that people think Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh was their Guru. No one has explicity stated it, but it is apparant when people ask questions such as did Bhai Sahib start Naam Dhrir. Yes, Bhai Sahib was a Gurmukh Jan and did alot of sevaa for the Panth but there is only one Guru. Guru Nanak Dev Jee. We should follow examples and learn from the lives of Gurmukhs like Bhai Sahib but above all we should take inspiration from the True Guru - Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Baanee Guru, Guru Hai Baanee Vich Banee Amrit Saarey, Gurbaanee Kehai Sevak Jan Maanai Partakh Guru Nistaaray|| Naam Dhrir was given in the Amrit Sanchaars in Guru Nanak Dev Jees times. The AKJ is just promoting Tat Gurmat, and in no way started Naam Dhrir. [%sig%]charanjeev singh · 20 Sep 2005
"The AKJ is just promoting Tat Gurmat" was raag keertan part of tat gurmat? or was that just a huge mirage and akj is correcting this by coming back to the way it should be with filmy tunes? and how about changing the Gurmantar from Waheguruu, to Vah Guruu, is that also tat gurmat? oh what about not following and backbiting panthic decisions by Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib, is that also tat gurmat? as long as akj uses words as 'we follow tat gurmat', and dewover keertan from its precious gift of raag, their words are empty and hollow and filled with hypocrisy. when the akj does follow tat gurmat, then they wont be any more akj, but until then, all those who say they practice tat gurmat, good for you, keertan is the base of tat gurmat, and raag is the base of keertan. until then bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]Harjas Kaur · 20 Sep 2005
Are you saying AKJ is not Khalsa because they follow a false Guru? Gursikh people that I know respect bhai Randhir Singh [i]because[/i] he followed a Satguru. Not because he was their Guru..... · 21 Sep 2005
What is Tat GurmatGurpreet Kaur · 21 Sep 2005
>>I don't mean to offend any jatha or anything, but not all Amrit sinchars are the same. Believe me, if you get Amrit chukk from AKJ, you will understand the difference.<< Harjas Kaur, read your words again. You are saying that Amrit Sanchaar's are not equal, do you realise how confusing this is for people thinking of taking Amrit? Furthermore you promise if we take Amrit from AKJ we will understand the difference, sorry to burst your bubble, but noone takes Amrit from 'AKJ' or any other Jatha, you take Amrit from your Guru, end of story.Zorawar Singh · 21 Sep 2005
Bhai Charanjeev Singh:- I am surprsied at your post. Are you basically saying that raag keertan is Tat Gurmat. Tat Gurmat is much wider and deeper scope than just raag keertan. Many AKJ singhs are now doing raag keertan. But it is bani that is most important. How has AKJ ever changed the Gurmantar? It is given by the Panj Pyares. I have been naam dhirr and I say Vaheguru, even if to you it may sound like Vahh Gurr. You are making a wild assumption here to say that it has been changed. Please stop trying to make white black just for the sake of argument.. All AKJ has done is to promote the spirituality back into Amrit sanchaars. Most people would be happy about this. The only ones who are not, seem to be those who are insecure in themselves. Why is anyone threatened by someone else being gifted the beauty of Naam? Lets face it, most Amrit sanchaars nowadays are mass amritsanchaars, where the individual is of no importance, just the numbers. Or they are done at the local gurdwara by the dodgy pardan and his mates. Speak to any of them about spirituality and you will get nothing? Is that what Guru ji created in Amrit?? AKJ does proper Amrit sanchaars with jeevan wale Gursikhs, and when you take Amrit and the Panj place their hands on your head, you feel that electricity of Naam. You walk away knowing that today my Guru has blessed me with something special. No amount of debate, arguments, can ever replace that.... If AKJ are the only ones doing that seva, Then Great, because at least someone is. Like I said before in my post, AKJ has never said its Amrit is higher like others. Neither has AKJ ever said Bhai sahib is the Guru, not sure where anyone has got that one? All AKJ has ever said, is never compromise on NAAM ! That is whole root and essence of SIKHI ! Compromise on that, then what is left?curious singh · 21 Sep 2005
two thumbs up to charanjeev singh. loved your last post veer jee. raag kirtan all the way!!" · 21 Sep 2005
i am amritdhari alreday and i wasnt shown how to do naam drir yet i would love to know how to meditate on naam in the most respectful and fulfilling way in order to obtain maharajs blessings and mercy...........please understand that i am truly serious and not jus seeking to know wot this is for the sake of it. " [%sig%]agyani · 21 Sep 2005
naam dhrir is just a jogti, it is great to recieve it from the panj - it is NOT naam but infact is a jogti. This stage can be achieved if one just starts meditating on naam (assuming they have recieve NAAM, not naam dhrir, from the Panj.)gursikh · 21 Sep 2005
i recieved Naam DriR when I went Pesh to Panj Pyare. However no-one said, "this is a secret" or "this is gupt". I hear "some" people say "Swaas Swaas Simran is gupt and only those who have had Naam DriR can do Naam Abhiyaas together." This sounds bit like a secret group who have a monopoly on naam abhiyaas. i would like the learned gursikhs to clarify some points which (i stress) "SOME" people claim: 1) that Swaas Swaas simran cannot be practiced infront of those people who have not recieved Naam DriR (even if Amritdhari) 2) that the method of Swaas Swaas simran is "Gupt" or "Secret" even though i read in several posts what Swaas Swaas simran involves, i.e. breathing in and breathing out Wahe-guru. This is mentioned in Bhai Balpreet Singh's post for "evidence of Naam DriR". I agree that Naam DriR can only be carried out by Panj Pyare, but I don't see what is wrong with someone knowing how to swas swas simran (but still knowing that for full experience and reality of Naam DriR you need Panj Pyare). I don't know whether anyone understands what I am saying, I am running out of words and how to put what i wish to say. anyway. if anyone can help with my querries, i would be grateful. humble daas,Uk Singh · 21 Sep 2005
Fateh, Can Tapoban Singhs like Kulbir Singh Jee and Balpreet singh Jee answer 'Gursikh' post as i have heard that Tapoban Singhs are quite adamant that only Naam Dhrirr Gursikhs can do simran together. I totally agree but am from the point of view like most AKJ Singhs that Simran should be done in sangat of other Naam dhrirr Gursikhs but if some other amritdharis Gursikh attends then they should be allowed to participate and feel the power of Naam. Then Guru Jee would bless them and it will be up to them and no one else to make a decision to get Naam Dhrirr via the panj. This is probably the same view as Great Gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Bhai Rama Singh and Bhai Sahib Bhai Jeevan Singh, who were and are great Gursikhs of the Panth and their seva would be very hard to match in encouraging youth and others to follow Guru Jee's path. I from reading tapoban forum since it began know Tapoban do not share this veiw or might have changed their stance to a more user freindly stance (even though from Kulbir Singhs latest post and discussions at KC 05 most singhs know their views, which I am not saying are wrong!!!) Fateh!! [%sig%]Kulbir Singh · 21 Sep 2005
UK Singh, ------------ Can Tapoban Singhs like Kulbir Singh Jee and Balpreet singh Jee answer 'Gursikh' post as i have heard that Tapoban Singhs are quite adamant that only Naam Dhrirr Gursikhs can do simran together. ---------- We are not adamant about doing abhyaas only with Naam DriR Gursikhs. Who told you we are? ---------- I from reading tapoban forum since it began know Tapoban do not share this veiw or might have changed their stance to a more user freindly stance (even though from Kulbir Singhs latest post and discussions at KC 05 most singhs know their views, which I am not saying are wrong!!!) ------------- We have not changed any stance to be “more user friendly”. The stance always was that even if one does not have Naam Drir but is an amritdhaari, we don’t stop such person from doing abhyaas with us. In any case, we don't ask anyone whether they have Naam DriR or not. Whoever wants to come can come. Kulbir Singhsingh145 · 21 Sep 2005
how do u recieve naam? how does the process work?Harjas Kaur · 21 Sep 2005
[quote]>>I don't mean to offend any jatha or anything, but not all Amrit sinchars are the same. Believe me, if you get Amrit chukk from AKJ, you will understand the difference.<< Harjas Kaur, read your words again. You are saying that Amrit Sanchaar's are not equal, do you realise how confusing this is for people thinking of taking Amrit? Furthermore you promise if we take Amrit from AKJ we will understand the difference, sorry to burst your bubble, but noone takes Amrit from 'AKJ' or any other Jatha, you take Amrit from your Guru, end of story.[/quote] It is my belief that not all amrit sanchars are the same, because not all people in the Panj are Gursikh people. We all respect that amrit is amrit, but is this really so? Politically it is. But some amrit is not even given in sarbloh bata! Why is this confusing, I think it is very clear. Wherever a person will receive amrit they should take care. I know that not everyone in the jatha ia s good Gursikh. But the jatha is very strict about amrit sinchaar and I trust that it is a powerful experience because this is what I had. Burst my bubble? Okay. Guruji gives amrit, but the transmission can not be authentic unless it is according to rehat Maryada. I did not say no other Amrit was amrit. I did say, the amrit you can receive from Gursikh Panj Pyare of the AKJ will be powerful, and that is the truth. You don't like this position. Fine. How can I convince you? Impossible. But you do not convince me either. I have friends who attend "Unnamed Gurudwara." Their sons got amrit chukk here. They even have photo album of the amrit sinchaar. One of the Panj is a man even the boys do not respect, he has not the best reputation for Sikhi, but is member of the Gurudwara committee and he was "symbolic reprensentative." They did not use sarbloh bata or even receive instruction of importance of sarbloh bibeki. They were told that an amritdharee Sikh can eat meat. They did not receive Naam drir or any instruction of Naam other than to repeat Waheguru and told they could do this playing waja. One boy has already cut his hair and is going to school to be a doctor. The other boy is staying out late nights and has girlfriend. Neither say nitnam or go to "Unnamed Gurudwara" anymore. This is what I am talking about, not jathabandis. All my experience is with AKJ. So I know that if these boys got amrit chukk from Panj Pyare affiliated with AKJ it would have been a different experience. Why? Because at least jatha people try to select people for Panj Pyare seva who are authentic Gursikhs and not politically prominent commitee members or simply rich donors. Also jatha people believe in strict interpretation of rehat Maryada and sarbloh bibek. Also Jatha people who are selected for Panj Pyare seva will transmit Naam drir during amrit sinchar. So if someone is asking this, I can confidently encourage this. How can I confidently encourage anyone to go get amrit chukk from XYZ Gurudwara when I don't have any experience from there? I am still waiting to here your blessed experience which will share something beautiful other people want to also be a part of. No, all you give are bitter political positions. So still, I would not encourage some young people to go somewhere I didn't know about. I can only speak for what I know about. I happen to have great respect for amrit and I believe AKJ does too. End of story. [%sig%]Gurpreet Kaur · 22 Sep 2005
Harjas Kaur, there is no need to get so angry and defensive, its not worth it really. 'Believe me, if you get Amrit chukk from AKJ, you will understand the difference.' I just wondered why you said this, you admit that not all Amrit Sanchaars are the same? I think you are right in a sense, but not all AKJ Amrit Sanchaar's are the same either? Or is the case that every Amrit Sanchaar conducted by the AKJ is perfect? I think you generalised on this point, that's all I meant. Dont take it personally.A Singh · 23 Sep 2005
Veer Kulbir Singh, With due respect, my reaction to the views of the Bibi are far from being an over reaction. The following information is taken from Piara Singh Padam’s ‘Rehatnamas’ and from the book on ‘rehat maryada’ published by the Chief Khalsa Diwan. Both of these are texts I’m sure as a member of the AKJ, you and most members of this forum are familiar with. To address the point in question, I’ll focus on the references given to the “banis” recited during the Amrit Sanchar of 1699, please refer to the texts mentioned for further details (unsurprisingly, reference to items such as mandatory Blue Dress, Sarabloh Bibek etc are not common). (1) Rehatnama Bhai Daya Singh (Piara): A good Sikh partakes of ‘amrit’ of Sri Amritsar. First, he reads or recites complete Jap ji, from the beginning to the end and the Chaupai - [we can assume this is Benti Chaupai, equally it could be one from Akal Ustat?] - He reads five different sawaiyas: 1. Srawag 2.Dinan Ki Pritpal 3. Papp smooh Binasan 4. Sat sdaiv suda brat, and 5 five stanzas of Anand Sahib. He stirs the ‘amrit’ with a KIRPAN towards himself. Then one Singh places a KIRPAN beside him. – [Interestingly , there is no mention of Jaap Sahib and the complete Anand Sahib, moreover, the ‘Amrit’ is prepared with a Kirpan]. (2) Bhai Chaupa Singh (A Hazoori Sikh of Guru Sahib and childhood playmate): Then the perfect Guru Sahib started testing the Panth. On the seventh day of Sawan, 1756 Sambat, the consecrated drink was sought to be prepared. Guru Sahib said, "Chaupa Singh, bring water in a bowl." When water was brought, Guru Sahib commanded, "Hold the ‘Khanda’ and stir the contents of the bowl." Then all the five started reading out ‘swaiyas’ each – [Again, we can assume this refers to the Punj Pyare and Swaiyas from either Akal Thakt or Chandi Charita] - When these five Singhs started reading out ‘swaiyas’, then Sahib Chand Diwan made a request, "True Sovereign, if ‘ptashas’ are put in the bowl, it will be better." In the meanwhile, Mata Shakti, Mata Sahib kaur, assuming the form of the ‘devi’ put sugar cakes in the bowl. The perfect Guru Sahib took five palmfuls and put them on the eyes, and five palmfuls in the hair. Then he recited the following ‘swaiya’ from the ‘Chandi Charitar’: "Deh Shiva war mohey ehay Shubh karman te kabhon na taron. Na daron ar siyon jab jaye laron nishchay kar apni jeet karon. Ar Sikh hon apne hi mann ko eh lalach han gun ton ochron. Jab aav ki audh nidhan baney At hi run mein tab joojh maron. Guru Sahib administered ‘amrit’ to the five Singh with his own hands. Next day, more Sikhs requested the Master that they too be administered ‘amrit’. He said, ‘prepare ‘Karah Parshad’ and have it from the five Singhs after reading ‘swaiyas’. [Again, this ‘Maryada’ does not accord with any current mainstream practice let alone the supposed “TAT Gurmat” method that the AKJ, Tapoban or DDT claim to have preserved] (3) According to Guru Bilas Patshahi Daswin: [Author: Bhai Koer Singh, p-128] Written in 1808 sambat, i.e. 1751 A.D. about 43 years after the passing away of the Tenth Guru] ‘Sarita jal leen achhoot mangaye kay, Patar loh mein tan prabh beray. Parhtey su udass hai mantron ko, Prabh thadhey hai app bhaiye so saverey.’ (p-25) [Here there is only a mention of reading ‘mantra’ (mool mantra) nothing else] (4) Bansavalinama: [Genealogy] of the ten Guru Sahibaan -Kesar Singh Chhiber (1826 Sambat). Guru Sahib said: ‘Get a bowl of water at once.’ When it was brought, Guru Sahib gave ‘KARAD’ (knife) to a Sikh and asked him to stir the water in the bowl. Then Guru Sahib asked him to read aloud JAPU JI Sahib and ANAND. -[Here again a ‘karad’ is used instead of Khanda and only two ‘banis’ ‘Jap’ and ‘Anand’ are recited, as per “Sikh Sanskar atey maryada”-Chief Khalsa Diwan, p-63] (5) History of the Sikhs, (Khushwant Rai: 1754 A.D). indicated that in the peperation of ‘amrit’ only five swaiyas are recited. (p-63). (6) Pracheen Panth Parkash, (Rattan Singh Bhangu, edited by Bhai Vir Singh Ji, published in 1941 A.D) indicates the followingto be recited; Var Bhagauti, first pauri (stanza) swaiya No. 32, Tribhangi Chhand-Khag Khand.- [All of these are different to those recited today, even by the Akal Thakt] (7) ‘Suraj Parkash’ -Kavi Bhai Santokh Singh Ji indicates Jap Ji, Swaiyas and five stanzas of Anand Sahib. –[There is no mention of reading out Jaap Sahib and Chaupai or the full Anand Sahib] (8) Guru Panth Parkash: (Giani Gian Singh), edited by: Singh Sahib Giani Kirpal Singh, p-1573} indicates ‘Jap Ji Sahib-5pauris, Jaap Sahib-5 pauris, Das Sudh, Anand Sahib, and Chaupai. – [Again this is different, only five ‘pauris’ each of Jap Ji Sahib and Jaap Sahib and this too is not clear which ‘Chaupai’ should be read out-the one in the beginning of ‘Akal Ustat’ "Pranvo Aad Ek…" or Kabiyo Bach Chaupai] (9) ‘Gurbilas Patshahi 10’: (Bhai Sukha Singh, Granthi Patna Sahib): This text mentions the reading out of some ‘mantras’ while preparing ‘amrit’, but doesn’t mention any banis. (10) ‘Guru Sobha; (Darbari Kavi Senapati) this text not even describe any method of administering the ‘pahul of Khanda’. It also gives reference to ‘kurehats’ as mundan (tonsuring), smoking hookah and having relations with ‘minas’ or ‘masands’. (11) Sri Kalgidhar Chamatkar, (Bhai Vir Singh) Page 27-28 indicate as follow: "At the place where yesterday Sikhi was put to test, today there is a throne around which the devotees are sitting. ‘Karah Parsad’ (sweet pudding) for 1100 is kept on white sheets. On the throne is sitting Guru Gobind Singh Ji APPARELLED IN WHITE. Before him lies a shining steel bowl containing water with a two-edged sword in it. In front of him are standing the five Sikhs of yesterday, the liberated ones, who had offered their heads. They too are CLAD IN WHITE. Guru Sahib spoke to them-the five-"‘Waheguru’ is the ‘gurmantra’ chant it with perfect concentration." While the ‘Five’ got busy in chanting ‘Waheguru’, Guru Sahib himself started stirring the ‘Khanda’ in the bowl and reciting ‘banis’. Standing before the ‘Five’ who had offered their heads, he made one of them recite the ‘mool mantra’ five times. Then he gave him five palmfuls of ‘amrit’ sprinkled it on his eyes and put five palmfuls in his hair. In this manner he administered ‘amrit’ to the ‘Five.’ [This extract is taken from an article published in the Khalsa Samachar of 6-13 April 2000). In conclusion, history does not bear witness to Guru Sahib in the preparation of ‘Amrit’ with the ‘Khanda’ recited the five ‘banis’, which are recited today. It is quite clear that in all pre-Singh Sabha era literature no mention is made about the recitation of the five ‘banis’ which we are all familiar with today. This would conclude that pre-Singh Sabha, there are was no definite tradition with respect to which ‘Banis’ are recited when preparing Amrit. This is obviously a lot more serious than the finer points that you have taken issue with (re: Punj Pyare spliting into 2 groups when giving Amrit, Lareevar Saroop of Maharaj etc). It clearly varied from group to group, [‘dera’ to ‘dera’, ‘jatha to jatha’, ‘sampradha to sampradha’ etc]. With this in mind, I humbly request that we take a solid stance on ensuring the type of talk that the Bibi Jee has provided and you are seemingly supporting be prevented as it only serves to split the panth. If this is not possible, then please tell us all, on what grounds you wish to challenge the “Sikh Rehit Maryada” as issued by the Akal Thakt and has been followed by the majority of the Panth for the past 6 decades or so. The point is there is no evidence in Sikh history and religious literature for doing this, other than the long drawn out conclusions based on the opinions of some Baba, Sant or Bhai Sahib. Without conducting any decent research, it is baseless on the part of some individuals and institutions to claim and propagate “THE” Rehit Maryada as stated by Guru Gobind Singh Ji on the Baisakhi of 1699 – this is nothing but propaganda for your institution and derived from imagination and is strongly against Panthic unity. I am well aware, some will claim that they have this right based upon “seena-baseena” maryada that has been coming down from generation to generation for over centuries, this claim is at best hollow and ridiculous given the ample evidence presented above. How exactly did “THE” maryada which could not remain in the same format even amongst Guru Sahib’s court poets, contemporary historians and writers, be passed down INTACT to the present generation who all belong to different institutions and groups? Gur Fateh! A Singh.International Akaali · 23 Sep 2005
what u mean you generlized the point.... you are indirectly saying that all other amrit sanchars are not as good as AKJ's...... " you will understand the difference" and what will that difference be????? only thing i could think of is how is could be better no other thing comes to my mind.... please dont say go to akj amrit sanchaar, taksal amrit sanchar etc..... you are going to khalsa panth's amrit sanchar.... nd yet people still say "WE WANT EKTA"!!!!!!! how in the world are you gonna get ur stinkin ekta if u think this way!!!!!!!!! Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fatehKulbir Singh · 23 Sep 2005
A. Singh jeeo, Irrespective of what you have quoted, there is no dispute over which baanees should be read at the time of Amrit Sinchaar. All Jathay that do amrit sinchaar read the same 5 baaniya. By trying to bring doubt in sangat's mind about this, you are doing service of Kala Afghana who wants to change baanees for amrit. The thing is that today the maryada is pretty much uniform with the exception of these three differences: 1) Amrit is prepared by 5 pyaray but not always administered by 5 pyaray. 2) Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is not present in all amrit sinchaars i.e. laridaar saroop is not present in all amrit sinchaars. In my humble opinion, it makes the amrit sinchaar null. Without Guru Sahib, how can amrit sinchaar be acceptable? 3) Naam is given in all amrit sinchaars but the way to japp it, is not shown. This results in new amritdharis asking sants and other gursikhs, how to japp Naam, where to concentrate etc. A. Singh, you are starting the debate of early 1900s. The issues you have raised have no relevance today. Kulbir Singhamarjeet singh · 23 Sep 2005
"Harjas Kaur, there is no need to get so angry and defensive, its not worth it really." harjas kaur's post didnt seem angry at all to me, and the whole point of debating with someone is to defend your ideas.Gurpreet Kaur · 23 Sep 2005
Well it did to me, hence my post, as you said, everyone is entitled to their opinion.A Singh · 23 Sep 2005
Veer Kulbir Singh, I will agree to disagree here, but I am in no way beginning a debate that has no relevance here. Moreover, I offerred the info purely as my opinion and conclusion, I will say this much that I am more than confident that in what I am saying to take on the idiotic rationale of Kala Afghana. The point I was trying to illustrate, whether or not you consider it relevant today or for the 1900's, is that arguing over these loose fundamentals is not going to get us EKTA, unless in your view, EKTA is a colony consisting of homogenous tribes of 'pure' persons (where of course "pure" is defined by your terms, irrespective of what quotes you may produce) - which sounds more like the vision that Hitler once had of Germany. I'll leave the Sangat to make up their own minds hereafter from the matter presented - some will read into the post as a query over banis, others will understand the underlying message of what was stated in the conclusion. Gur Fateh! A Singh.Singh UK · 23 Sep 2005
Kulbir Singh Point 2 - If Lareedaar Saroop is not present at Amrit Sanchar it is null. Thank Guru Jee that it is just your 'humble' opinion. But then again one must know how to be humble. And from reading your posts for years I can see that your very learned and probably keep a strict rehit, but 'Humble' has never come to mind when actually reading any of your posts. It's normally our way or no way no matter what. I don't think you could see past your own nose in some subjects. You normally would attack the Lareedaar issue if you were in the real world as a promotion of Lareedaar but in no way trying to destroy peoples faith in Sikhi. 99% of the Panth when visiting a Gurdwara have enough Sharda to bow down and accept Guru Jee on its throne. ***admin cut for writing nonsense**** [%sig%]ss · 23 Sep 2005
Kulbir Singh Ji mentions above: "We must rise above jathebandis and groups and follow Gurmat Maryada. Every AKJ amrit sinchaar is not good and every Taksali amrit sinchaar is not bad. Where ever proper Gurmat Maryada is followed, that amrit sinchaar is acceptable to Guru Sahib. Rest is chauraasi daa maal. " "Rest is chauraasi daa maal. " Kulbir Singh are you God.....or what, you are very wrong here to form this judgement.uk singh · 23 Sep 2005
<<<>>> Kulbir Singh Ji – At Taksali amrit sanchars, panj piyare do not all give amrit to each candidate. Secondly, they are not taught on a one to one basis how to Jap naam. But as you stated the whole group sing along with the Panj Piyare RoopKaur Ji, you stated ‘Naam Drirtaa was done from the time of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji, Bhai Sahib did not start it, he just merely reintroduced the panth to it, just like a lot of other things like Sarbloh bibek etc’ When exactly did naam dhrir start/finish before Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji. Zorawar Singh wrote ‘AKJ does proper Amrit sanchaars with jeevan wale Gursikhs, and when you take Amrit and the Panj place their hands on your head, you feel that electricity of Naam.’ See this is where the Jatha fall. No matter how hard they try they make statements like this, which make comparisons. Are you questioning the Jeevan of other non Jatha Gursikhs who do seva in the Panj?A Singh · 23 Sep 2005
UK Singh, you are absolutely correct, that is exactly what is being done here, and neither reason nor evidence is going to change these puritanical attitudes of the Jatha supporters - who can be clearly seen here as Bipars.Kulbir Singh · 23 Sep 2005
----------- When exactly did naam dhrir start/finish before Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji.---------- As far as we know, at the time of Bhai Sahib Naam DriR was done. We read accounts of Bhai Sahib and Singhs of other jathay doing Naam Abhyaas together. Giani Lal Singh of Panch Khalsa Diwan used to do Naam abhyaas with Bhai Sahib and he used to do it swaas swaas. When Bhai Sahib first met Bayoo Mal Singh, Bayoo jee was doing swaas swaas Naam Abhyaas that he had got driR from amrit sinchaar. If swaas swaas was not the way to do Naam Abhyaas, why would it be mentioned in Gurbani so many times? -------- who can be clearly seen here as Bipars. -------- A. Singh, "Brahm Binday, se Brahmana....||" Kulbir Singhuk singh · 23 Sep 2005
Kulbir Singh Ji, thanks for the clarification. So far only you have stated that it does not matter who administers amrit as long as the chosen Panj are rehitvaan and the sanchaar is performed according to Gur Maryada. 'It is not about Taksal or AKJ but wherever Punj Pyaray conduct amrit sinchaar with full maryada, that amrit sinchaar is acceptable to Guru Sahib.' Leaving aside the evidence provided by A Singh for now, do you believe that any other Jathebandhi other than the Jatha administer amrit with water tight Maryada? I am aware of the saas giraas technique and have reason to believe from a Jatha Singh that many accomplished Sants have also used this style in their bhagti. However, he did state that these advanced souls only utilised this technique after years of normal simran and why all should not learn it from the very beginning. Can anyone clarify if any of the more well known Mahapursh in the last century other than Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji ever used this method of Simran?Singh · 23 Sep 2005
"uk singh", had you been following the discussion, you would have read that Bhai Mani Singh himself, as well as the author of Prem Surag Granth, and not forgetting the author of Sau Sakhi (which depending on your stance, is written by Guru Gobind Singh Ji himself or a 18-19th century author), all explictly and clearly tell us to use the Saas Giraas method for Simran. Is Bhai Mani Singh enough of a "well known Mahapursh" for you?Kulbir Singh · 23 Sep 2005
UK Singh jee, ----------- Kulbir Singh Ji, thanks for the clarification. So far only you have stated that it does not matter who administers amrit as long as the chosen Panj are rehitvaan and the sanchaar is performed according to Gur Maryada. 'It is not about Taksal or AKJ but wherever Punj Pyaray conduct amrit sinchaar with full maryada, that amrit sinchaar is acceptable to Guru Sahib.' Leaving aside the evidence provided by A Singh for now, do you believe that any other Jathebandhi other than the Jatha administer amrit with water tight Maryada? ----------- As I wrote before, I believe that many jathebandees at the time of Bhai Sahib used to administer amrit with the true maryada. In any case, it does not matter if even one jathebandi does not administer amrit with maryada. That will not make it okay to use wrong maryada. Think of it Veeray. What is purpose of give amrit 5 times in mouth, hair and eyes? Doesn’t it make perfect sense that each of the Punj Pyara should be giving it once? Let us not fall in the trap of defending what we believe. Let’s look deeply and try to understand why things are done the way they are done. There must be a reason why amrit is given 5 times in mouth, eyes and kesh. The reason is clear. Each pyara should give it once. Only then it is amrit from Punj Pyaray. Also think about it. When punj pyaray give you naam, are they not supposed to teach you the Vidhee or the method? In many amrit sinchaar, punj pyaray just say Gurmantr five times and the whole group says it behind them. But what about dhyaan or concentration? Where to focus and so on. Punj Pyaray should tell all this. This just makes sense. When they give you mantr, they should also tell you how to japp it. What is so hard to understand here? -------- Can anyone clarify if any of the more well known Mahapursh in the last century other than Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji ever used this method of Simran? --------- I don’t know what your definition of a mahapurash is. I know dozens of Mahapurakhs in Ranglay Sajjan used this technique. Sant Attar Singh Mastuanawalay used to do swaas swaas abhyaas. Bhai Mani Singh Shaheed has written this method in Sikhaan dee Bhagat Mala. Bhai ikk vaar karkay dekho. Try it out once. Then you will know, what happens when Gurmantr is recited with breaths. Ik vaar aazmaa ke dekho. Phir dekhiyo, kaisa rang chaRda hai. Kulbir SinghSingh · 25 Sep 2005
From my observations reading the posts thier tappears to be no proof to back the idea of Naam Drih. It appears this is used used by the AKJ to attract people into the Jatha. With respect to what the proper Maryada is for giving Amrit this has been finalised by the Sikh Rehat Maryada.Singh · 25 Sep 2005
try actually reading the thread above rather than just blindly writing your prejudices. People who have Naam Dhrir have given their personal experiences, they have not been duped, they physically experienced something. That is why they have written about it. If all Amrit sanchaars are the same, then why are those who 12months ago took Amrit from sants now are getting Naam Dhrir from AKJ? It must be they feel they have missed something or they need to know more about Naam? Singh wrote: > From my observations reading the posts thier tappears to be no > proof to back the idea of Naam Drih. It appears this is used > used by the AKJ to attract people into the Jatha. With respect > to what the proper Maryada is for giving Amrit this has been > finalised by the Sikh Rehat Maryada.???? · 25 Sep 2005
vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji can someone please guide me by telling me, what was the title for Balpreet singhs topic on "evidence of Naam DriR". I have used that in the search field and cant find it. vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji... · 25 Sep 2005
The "evidence of naam DriR" is as following: There are references to the naam technique in puraatan sources: Sant Teja Singh wrote the following: "The method of reciting naam (naam japan dee jugath) has been passed down from Gursikh to Gursikh. But this daas has only seen it written in two places. In Sau Sakhi its says that Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj tells Mata Jeetho Ji that the tip of the tounge (jeeb di teesy), with force (jOr naal), should touch the roof of the mouth (thaloo naal), and at all times keep saying Waheguru Waheguru. Shaheed Bhai Mani Singh, the one who sat and listened to the recitation of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji by Sri Guru Gobind Singh himself, in his exposition of Bhai Gurdas Ji's 11th vaar (in Bhagat Ratnavali), In the story of Sheehan and Gajjan, has written that when our breath goes in we should say 'Wahe' and when our breath goes out we should say 'guru'" also, In Prem Sumarag Granth it is written: "oupar saas naabh tay "vaah" say layvai, ar talay kaa saas "guru" say chhoDay. Vahiguru daa jap karai." Clearly this shows that the "technique" is not a new creation and was taught by Guru Nanak Dev himself.japo · 25 Sep 2005
vahe gurrroooo! vahe gurrroooo!Admin · 26 Sep 2005
All arguments have been exhausted. Ones who don't want to understand will not understand. Thread is now closed. Admin.A Singh · 23 Jun 2006
<<>> This is correct, only AKJ have the pooran Gur Maryada from Guru Sahib's time. They are the PANTH KHALSA today. Akal Thakt should be run by the AKJ, then this pooran maryada maybe installed fully without any room for 'dhil'.