Forum
Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
singh · 19 Sep 2005
http://www.sikhsangat.org/
Breaking News from Sikh Sangat News
An Amrit Sanchar Ceremony was conducted at the Historic Gurudwara Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib in Chandigarh. Two sikh women participated in the Amrit Sanchar Ceremony as part of Punj Piyarey in which 35 Sikhs took Khandey Di Pahul (Amrit).
http://www.sikhsangat.org/
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
reply · 19 Sep 2005
Do these ladies think they are better than Dhan-Dhan Mata Sahiban of the Guru's House who were apparently not fit to be inducted into any grouping of 5 Singhs? Or do they perhaps think Guru Sahib was a coward, afraid of what "society" would say if there were female members of the 5 Piyare?
Perhaps someone should have made the Sikh missionaries God so they could have had the right people appointed as Guru and in councils of 5 Singhs. (5 male Gurus and 5 female).
Pargatio Khalsa parmatam ki mauaj.
Did God know and preordain who would be in the 5 piyare of 1699? Is it for some reason necessary for women to be members as well? Alas, the missionaries weren't there to advise God.
Or did it all happen by chance? God didn't know who would be inducted. So an event which has been planned by God for millions of years just has a random element which God didn't foresee and now it's being corrected by the Missionaries and their collaborators. Shabash.
Oh well, it is God himself who causes people to slander him either by words or by their actions. All the greater glory my Lord.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
h · 19 Sep 2005
i think its wrong to have women in the panj.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
i hate paintballing :-( · 19 Sep 2005
i agree with 'h'
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
RoopKaur · 19 Sep 2005
>Do these ladies think they are better than Dhan-Dhan Mata Sahiban of the Guru's House who were apparently not fit to be inducted into any grouping of 5 Singhs? Or do they perhaps think Guru Sahib was a coward, afraid of what "society" would say if there were female members of the 5 Piyare?<
There were many Sikhs, both Singhs and Singhniaa, who did not give their head the first time when guru made panj pyarey. Why are only Singhneea penalised for this, yet Singhs are not?
>Perhaps someone should have made the Sikh missionaries God so they could have had the right people appointed as Guru and in councils of 5 Singhs. (5 male Gurus and 5 female).<
What a dumb thing to say. There is no substance in this comment to reply back to.
>Pargatio Khalsa parmatam ki mauaj.<
Guru ji said pargatio KHALSA parmatam kee mauj. He did not make a seperate tuk saying pargatio Khalsee parmatam kee mauj. You are either suggesting both Singh/Singhneeaa are Khalsa, or that only Singhs are Khalsa, and Singhneea are not, which begs the question, then what are they? If we go with the former analysis, then gender does not seem to matter, as long as the person is a KHALSA, why are you making a non issue an issue than? If we go with the latter analysis, than you should answer the question, if Singhneaa are not Khalsa, what are they?
>Did God know and preordain who would be in the 5 piyare of 1699?<
Yes
>Is it for some reason necessary for women to be members as well?<
What is necessary is that the person have kamaaee and be a rehitvaan, naam abhaasee Sikh of Guru ji.
>Or did it all happen by chance? God didn't know who would be inducted. So an event which has been planned by God for millions of years just has a random element which God didn't foresee and now it's being corrected by the Missionaries and their collaborators. Shabash.<
Nothing happens by chance. Everything happens according to what has been written by Akaal Purkh. But what are you trying to say, that something wrong occured on that Vasakhi day? That day happened occording to Guru ji, how could you ever call it wrong?
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Psycho Browny · 19 Sep 2005
where were the women when guru asked for 5 heads????
if they couldnt stand up then...why now?
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Maybe · 19 Sep 2005
this is hellva sad day for the Panth...
disgraceful...
bowing to the pressures of western "equality"...all a bunch of out of control femenism.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Tarrandeep Kaur · 19 Sep 2005
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh
For the first time, Roop Kaur penji, i am going to disagree with you.
FIVE MALES came foward, forming the panj piayre, these wer five singhs.
wen u see the panj piayre now, who do we see? we see bhai deya singh, bhai dharam singh, bhai himmat singh, bhai sahib singh, bhai mokham singh. This is the true form of the panj piayre.
How can we see bhai deya singh, bhai dharam singh, bhai himmat singh, bhai sahib singh, bhai mokham singh, if there are singhneea in the panj piayre. This is the true roop of panj piayre, five singhs. Some people are so wrapped up in equality issues, they cannot accept this.
bhul chuk maaf karna
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
S Singh · 19 Sep 2005
This is good news. This will set a precedent for future generations. All those people who now object to women becoming Panj Pyaray are no different from those Sanatan Sikhs a hundred years ago who objected when Singh Sabhias began reintroducing so-called low caste Sikhs into sevas such as Panj Pyarayia di seva, Langar-seva, Karsevas etc.
These people who now object to women doing these sevas need to feel ashamed. Please leave your sexist attitudes back to the Stone Age where it belongs. Sikhi is not like Islam, Catholicism, or Hinduism where women are restricted. The sevas men can do, women can do as well. It is very unfortunate that the leading organizations of the Panth such as Nanaksar also have these disgusting attitudes towards women, by no allowing them to even do kirtan. Such shameless creatures these people are. I don’t even know how they look at themselves in the mirror every morning and still have the audacity to call themselves Sikhs.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
S Singh · 19 Sep 2005
This is good news. This will set a precedent for future generations. All those people who now object to women becoming Panj Pyaray are no different from those Sanatan Sikhs a hundred years ago who objected when Singh Sabhias began reintroducing so-called low caste Sikhs into sevas such as Panj Pyarayia di seva, Langar-seva, Karsevas etc.
These people who now object to women doing these sevas need to feel ashamed. Please leave your sexist attitudes back to the Stone Age where it belongs. Sikhi is not like Islam, Catholicism, or Hinduism where women are restricted. The sevas men can do, women can do as well. It is very unfortunate that the leading organizations of the Panth such as Nanaksar also have these disgusting attitudes towards women, by no allowing them to even do kirtan. Such shameless creatures these people are. I don’t even know how they look at themselves in the mirror every morning and still have the audacity to call themselves Sikhs.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
singh · 19 Sep 2005
The majority of the Sikh women were probably in the langar, making and distributing food for the thousands of men gathered at Anandpur Sahib!
Either Sikhism has complete equality between all Sikhs or it doesn't. Take your pick. If you don't think that Singhnees should be doing kirtan at darbar sahib, sitting at maharaj's tabia, or in the panj piyaree, then stop paying lip service to "equality" within the panth, and admit to your misogyny. Don't try to cover it with empty rhetoric.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Dogma · 19 Sep 2005
S Singh Jeeo..
"The sevas men can do, women can do as well. It is very unfortunate that the leading organizations of the Panth such as Nanaksar also have these disgusting attitudes towards women, by no allowing them to even do kirtan. Such shameless creatures these people are."
...just to add a little information veerji. I played tabla with a woman on stage doing kirtan at a Nanaksar Gurudwara in Canada. Afterwards, the pardhaan of the Gurudwara enjoyed the kirtan very much and invited her to do kirtan again whenever she wished.
Not that I have an opinion about all of this, I just wanted to add a little information on this subject that you may not have been aware of.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
S Singh · 19 Sep 2005
Dogma Jee, I am glad that the Pardhan at your local Nanaksar Thaath allowed a woman to do kirtan. This in itself can lead as an example for other Nanaksari Thaaths around the world. I remember a few years ago I went to the Nanaksari Gurdwara in Brampton. There I began talking to one of the Bihangam Baba sevadars. At the time I did not know anything about Nanaksar beleifs, and I was shocked to hear from him that women are not allowed and should not be allowed to do kirtan at the darbar.
Bhain Tarandeep Kaur, even if we go by your argument that only men can do seva since the original Panj who volunteered were also males. Using this logic of ‘originality’ we should also imitate the original Panj by their birth caste where by one can only become a Panj Pyara who belong to the same caste as the original Panj, since the original Panj belonged to the following castes: Khatri, Jaat, Chimba, Ghumar and Nai.
BTW, the Jaat here does not mean the Punjabi jatt. Jaats are found in Haryana, UP, Rajasthan, Madhya Pardesh and Delhi. Since none of the original Panj were Punjabi Jats, does that mean that a Sikh born from a Punjabi Jat family is not allowed to join the Panj Pyara seva?
Since gender based discrimination is being promoted in the name of ‘originality’, then maybe caste based discrimination should also be a part of who does and doesn't qualify to join the Panj Pyara seva.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
* · 19 Sep 2005
Tarrandeep Kaur Jee,
Yes, five males came forward to form the Punj Pyaaray. But what QUALITY gave them the form of Punj Pyaaray? Was it based on them being Sikhs of the Guru or simply by virtue of them being males? "Khalsa mero roop hai khaas", right? Do you classify Singhnees as being part of the Khalsa? If Guru Sahib says Singhnees can be his own form, then Singhnees can definitely take the form of Punj Pyaaray as well.
Today when Punj Pyaaray are formed for an Amrit Sinchaar, do we pick the first five Singhs who stand up, or do we go through a thorough process to decide who is worthy of the sevaa? There's no race, it's not based on the first to stand or the first to cross a finish line. It's based on the jeevan of a person, on their Sikhi. Singhs practice the same Sikhi that Singhnees do, and we all take Guru Sahib's form as the Khalsa. When Punj Pyaaray are formed, they are the form of Guru Sahib as well. Why would Guru Sahib include Singhnees as the Khalsa being his form but then neglect to include them as Punj Pyaaray? Makes no sense. The original Punj Pyaaray were five Sikhs willing to give their heads to their Guru without hesitation. That is why they became the Punj Pyaaray. Guru Sahib asked for a head, not for a male.
Afterwards, obviously other sets of men who didn't have the courage to rise upon Guru Sahib's request THAT day later served as Punj Pyaaray. If these men who lacked courage that day can do the sevaa now, then why shouldn't the women who didn't rise that day be allowed to do it now too?
And to the author "Maybe" who posted the following comment: "all a bunch of out of control femenism":
Maybe you'd be better off sticking to words you can actually spell and you might even know how to use them in a sentence. Knowing what a word really means as opposed to basing it on your own ignorance can also be helpful.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
fatjoe · 19 Sep 2005
both man and woman have soul inside of them wich is a woman it say so in gurbani
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
khalistani · 19 Sep 2005
guru je no wher ein gurbanee has said women can do everythingmen can do, vise versa
first of all when u READ BANEE
read it carefully
in asa de vaar it says dont call WOMEN BAD
who the hell is calling women bad
if u want TOTAL EQUALITY
then walk arounf with shirts
y not?
i mean sall gud right?
then y is it wrong for me to hit bibis?
i guess not
i think some bibis gave me cvcut eye yest.
dw, ill jump them at skool tom
and man wat about VAHEGURU
he made it sooo unfair
y can only women have the ability and gift of being able to give life?
y did god become so biased?
man vaheeeguru
yyyyyy??
btw thas ALL SARCASTIC
i wudnt tell bibis to talka round with no shirts
i wudnt go aroud jumping bhenjees
i wudnt think god is biased
everyone knows this is a new thing, bibis coming in panj and etc.
NEVER BEFORE ANYONE EVEN heard of fact bibis go in panj
some sikhs try to hard to fit in with western society
women are not lower than men
bugt even in nature itself
women and men BOTH have different tasks that the other cannot do
in sikhi, bibis CANNOT goin panj
this has been maryada IN EVERY SINGLE jatha until now some people are making rola
thi NEVER even came up before
but noweveryone is sooo ck, look att he state of our panth
i mean look how ck it is
we keep on going away from he maryada given to us by guru je, and look at wat is happening around us to the panth
its never been in this condition
the main leader of the pro panj bibis is a frekin daughter murder, aka jagiro
its panj pyarai
bibis cannot do this seva
just like i cant go and have a baby
only bibis can do this
men cant
liek i said
we shud stop tryin to change sikhi so much
bhula chuka maf
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
charanjeev singh · 19 Sep 2005
Dya Singh representd - Dya Compassoin - a Virtue
Dharam Singh represented - Righteous Living - a Virtue
Himmat Singh represented - Udham and Force - a Virtue
Mokham Singh represented - Adholta (unshakable faith) - a Virtue
Sahib Singh represented - Royalty (child of Waheguruu) - a Virtue
These are the 5 virtues that are Pyara to the Guru.
The Guru does not see male and female. The panj pyareh are reflections of these virtues. Gursikh Marayada, as ordered and given Asis (blessings) by Guru Gobind Singh Jee is known as Guru Panth. Bibiya can absolutely do Panj Pyareh Dee Seva.
Unparh people (no knowledge people), who follow sants and brahmgyanis are deluded by duality.
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Dangit · 19 Sep 2005
absolute rubbish...but i know most decent people won't go against Gur maryada and get 'amrit' from such "sanchaars".
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
AS · 19 Sep 2005
An excerpt from the Sikh Reht Maryada: The Code of Sikh Conduct & Conventions
-published by: Dharam Parchar Committee (Shirmonani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee) Amritsar
Ceremony of Baptism or Initiation
Article XXIV
(b)At the place where ambrosial baptism is to be administered, the holy Guru Granth Sahib should be installed and ceremonially opened. Also present should be six committed baptised Sikhs, one of whom should sit in attendance of the Guru Granth and the other five should be there to administer the ambrosial baptism. These six may even include Sikh women.
-How much clearer does it have to be that women can be a part of the Panj Piyareh. This was written in 1940s, so why is it still an issue? And for those of you that have a problem with women being included in the Panj, can you please provide a clear, logical, rational answer as to why you have such a problem with it?
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Don't kid ourselves · 20 Sep 2005
Theres is nothing wrong with women doing seva in panj, on what basis can you deny a chardi kala bibi the opportunity to do this seva ???? maharaj claifries "so kio manda akhary, jit jaman rajan", to use the argument of physical differences is wrong, I am sure in the wide ocean of the panth, there are many bibis who have naam kamai and rehat which is the fundamental prerequistes of doing this seva, please think about what you are saying, it seems as though we like to keep everthing so within the box, when something out of the box comes along we try and justify it with arguments which make no sense to the normal average thinking educated sikh.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Shameful · 20 Sep 2005
Such shameless creatures I agree, but not those who stand up for the original maryada, but those who seek to change our most sacred amrit sanchar just so that they can claim 'equality' to the western world in a manner that they understand it!
Disgraceful!!
I agree with singh above, I am all up for equality and i want to give birth. As a man, i want to give birth since guru ji gave me the same rights as my sisters and mothers. Whats that?? I cant do it?? Why not??!! Because it wasnt meant to be!! NEHIIIIIIII .........
Ridiculous!
As for the originality argument, Caste is manmat, and was created by humans, the distinctions based on caste are human creations.
BUT the distinction between the sexes is created by Vaheguru! Very clearly and obviously there ARE differences between men and women, and this is what Vaheguru obviously intended!! So caste in terms of orginiality is a non issue, gender is.
There is nothing else that personally i think women should/could not do. But Amrit Sanchar should be done by PANJ SINGHS.
Ps while we are on the topic of western equality, why are the guys called 'Singhs' and the women called 'kaurs'?
In the case for equality why arent we all just 'SINGHS' or all 'KAURS' why is there a distinction there? And will this be the next thing to be eradicated? In the PANJ PYARIAAH jathe, will they make all abilakees either all SINGHS or all KAURS according to their personal preference?
Finally will all those in favour of this version of 'equality' please state what they did in their amrit sanchar's? i.e. did the guys remove their punjame, while the women kept them on, or did everyone remove them, or everyone keep them on? Did you or will you raise objections as to the blatant discrimination of this process!!!
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Zorawar Singh · 20 Sep 2005
Amazing how insecure some people are just because a bibi or two did some seva....
Would you still judge her if she was mata Bhag Kaur or bebe nanaki ji?
Even if theya re not, just look at the state of theose who seva in the punj pyares at most gurdwaras, they are usually the dodgiest Pardans...
Gurbani say every soul is female, and God is the male. The vessel is of no real importance to Spirituality, just the soul.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
AVTAR · 20 Sep 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh,
only sewa left for women are taking part in the panj pyaara.and doing kritian in sri darbar shiab.Why all of us want to divide the panth. there is alot of sewa to do.The main priority of sikh is ekta in panth and get our homeland than all this issues can be solve by having serbat khalsa.Please
guru ki sangat ,we should not bring up this kind issue.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
walking the path... · 20 Sep 2005
Admin please allow this
=====================================================Either Sikhism has complete equality between all Sikhs or it doesn't. Take your pick. If you don't think that Singhnees should be doing kirtan at darbar sahib, sitting at maharaj's tabia, or in the panj piyaree, then stop paying lip service to "equality" within the panth, and admit to your misogyny. Don't try to cover it with empty rhetoric.
=====================================================
Yes, five males came forward to form the Punj Pyaaray. But what QUALITY gave them the form of Punj Pyaaray? Was it based on them being Sikhs of the Guru or simply by virtue of them being males? "Khalsa mero roop hai khaas", right? Do you classify Singhnees as being part of the Khalsa? If Guru Sahib says Singhnees can be his own form, then Singhnees can definitely take the form of Punj Pyaaray as well.
=====================================================
Yes Sikh is about equality but then why do you not question, why cant men give birth? Why dont they carry the baby for 9months instead of the women? Because this is how Akaal Purkh Made us! It is simple, would you have Jesus played by a woman? Would mohamed be played by a woman? Nope. So why is so important now that women take on the role of 5 Singhs. Guru Ji clearly stated, where there are 5 SINGHS not 5 SINGHNIS! Understand the difference! Then you have Guru Gobind Singh Ji.
Yes he did also say "Khalsa mera roop hai Khas" But heres the deal. Guru Gobind Singh Ji gave us an appearance, he gave us a Dastar - realistically a dhumala due to the times. How many Females keep this? Not many. Its now ok to wear a patkha which really, didnt come into play until the British came into India, so therefore what how is the roop being kept??
Maharaj knows all, he asked for 5 heads, of ANYONE! There were women and children in the crowd as well as muslims, hindus etc not just sikh men. So why was it only 5 men stood up? Because that is the way it happened and to keep Maryada, we have to abide by that same ruling. We dnt change anything else, why change this?
Why were the physical embodiments of the first 10 Gurus Male? (i was first 10 as the 11th is Guru Granth Sahib Ji). Can someone please answer that?? We are quick to pull out everything including the kitchen sink to argue women should be allowed to be in the form of Panj Singh - again SINGH IS MALE not female. Why do you not kick and scream Guru Ji was a female instead?
I have no problem with women doing kirtan etc in Darbar sahib or any other kinds of seva on the basis they are wearing a Dastar and Bana as Guru Wanted. He gave us that roop, until we keep it, whats the point in arguing?? There isnt! As we ourselves dont have the knowledge!
How can i say that? Mai Bhago, She was a female and fought in the wars with Guru Gobind Singh Ji. He did not disrciminate against her, he infact made her general of his army and body guard to! But did he make a Panj Singh? Nope.
Apologies for men and women having difficulties coming to terms with out maryada is kept. If you have problems with it then take it up with Guru Gobind Singh Ji and Akaal Purakh. Yes equality exists in sikhi BUT there are certain things which are just the way they are.
Men do seva, women do seva. Simple as. BUT if maharaj says 5 singhs, then its clear 5 singhs!! IF a singh is a man, then how can a women do that? Then its fair to say that a man in sikhi can wear female clothing!! Whats the problem with that?? Women say men are weird for doing this but then if its all about equality why cant they since women can wear mens tshirts and tracksuit bottoms and stuff if they fit. - i dont do this so please dont think i do!!! But its a simple example.
Men do certain things, women do certain things.
Women give Birth to babies, Mata Sahib Kaur put the patasay in to amrit, not the 5 singhs, therefore the phenji if she wants to do seva in amrit sanchar should do this seva.
Why the need to raise this issue now?? for the past 300yrs its not been a problem but now it is?? Why? Because people become educated in western thinking and forget the way SIkhs have lived for this period. Why change a way of life set out by Guru Ji just for sake of, women should be able to particpate as a man!?!?!
Sorry, im against it, its not correct, the amrit given that day was not formal as it was not given by 5 singhs.
A while ago on this forum, there was a topic saying coventry amrit sanchar was not valid as the singhs were not from the jatha. Well then clearly this amrit sanchar was not valid as it was not done according to maryada.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Sep 2005
A Mail I received from a friend..
Women in Panj Piaras.
The Editor,
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh.
In my view, the president of the SGPC, Bibi Jagir Kaur has taken the right decision to enforce the clause (b) of the Sikh Rehit Maryada regarding women’s participation in the Panj Piaras. In this respect, Singh Sahib Giani Joginder Singh Vedhanti should have readily joined Bibi Jagir Kaur without any question and helped her to tow the line in the right direction.
The Sikh Rehit Maryada in its English version, on page 33, Ceremony of Baptism and Initiation - Article XXIV, clause (b) already takes very good care of the issue. It clearly states that, “At the place where ambrosial baptism is to be administered, the holy Guru Granth Sahib should be installed and ceremonially opened. Also present should be six committed baptized Sikhs, one of whom should sit in attendance of the Guru Granth Sahib and the other five should be there to administer the ambrosial baptism. These six may even include Sikh women. All of them must have taken bath and washed their hair.
The implementation of the specified clause (b) which is an integral part of the existing Sikh Rehit Maryada needs no further discussion whatsoever or even an of approval from the main server (mukh sevadaar) of Sri Akaal Takht, Singh Sahib Gyani Joginder Singh Vedhanti. Somehow, Singh Sahib got involved and he decided to hold a formal meeting with his ‘shreek bhaees’, the mukh sevadaars, Singh Sahibaan of the four Takhts so as to reach a conclusive decision.
The Sikh nation is fully aware that Singh Sahib and his four equally unpredictable ‘shreek bhai’ characters who are well-known for their age-old unscrupulous and hostile views on the Sikh Rehit Maryada, Sikh beliefs and practices, could/would not have ever come to terms with an issue that would have turned their own world upside-down. Therefore, inevitably for the obvious reasons they left the matter hanging in the air indefinitely. The whole episode was a gross despicable act and a complete waste of resources. This is what I would call ‘a blind leading the blind’ situation where the decision-making skills have not only been misconstrued but also voided entirely.
Sadly the ever increasing number of the unscrupulous, mindless fanatics and the most selfish Sant Babas, leaders of the mainly male- dominated Taksaals, Sant Smaj, Deras and the like, have no remorse whatsoever in undermining the fundamentals of the Sikh ideology. In the recent weeks gone, millions of people saw them on the television screens acting in direct confrontation with Bibi Jagir Kaur’s decision. This illustrated their sheer stubbornness, aggressiveness, threatening behaviour, their hostility, stupidity, their intentional discrimination against women, and a complete failure to practice the Divine Teachings of Guru Nanak’s message of equality, which is a complete negation of the Sikh values and cultures.
These ‘Masands or the Keshdhari Hindus’ that include some of the so-called prominent Sikhs such as Bhai Ranjit Singh, who has served as a mukh sevadaar at the Akaal Takht, together with his supporters who now question the Sikh Rehit Maryada are nothing but a total disgrace who may be construed as blasphemous to the Sikh religious teaching and the Sikh nation. I wonder if they ever did protest as strongly as they are doing now against those Hindu fundamentalist writers sponsored by the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh and many other Sikh Panth Virodhi organisations like them who have been constantly publishing books, distributing leaflets in which they have deliberately carried out systematic character assassination of all our Great Sikh Gurus, Great Sikh Martyrs and the Great Sikh warriors and those writers who are fully determined to destroy, distort or rewrite the entire Sikh History. These ‘Masands or the Keshdhari Hindus’ are the biggest enemies of the Sikh Panth. They should be condemned in totality and they do not deserve to be referred to as Sikhs at all.
To the good fortune of the Sikh nation, majority of Shardavaan Gursikh families, Gursikh scholars, thousands of ordinary like-minded men, women and numerous Sikh organisations across the world who have true love for Guru and Gursikhi and a thorough understanding of the Sikh ideology, have very rightly welcomed Bibi Ji’s decision. We have also heard about numerous Sikh organisations in Panjab where women are now known to be actively participating in the Panj Piaras for the past many, many years. It is even more encouraging to learn that more and more organisations would now be coming forward to follow suit. I sincerely hope that all major Sikh organisations in the UK would also do likewise in the near future.
In the recent weeks, Alpha Punjabi News and one UK based Satellite Radio Station reported the highlights of this disturbing issue. I followed the news and the discussion programme with some interest and I was shocked to hear some of the most irresponsible, unintelligent comments that directly contradicted the Sikh Rehit Maryada and the Great Gurus’ divine teachings. Equally disappointing was the fact that most of such comments came from not only ordinary Sikh men and women, but also came from the few so-called prominent Sikh leaders who represent well-known and established Sikh institutions in India and the UK.
Obviously, the selfish and the ‘Haumai and Hankaar’ infested so-called Sikh community leaders are persistently engaged and are fully determined to destroy the remnants of the rich Sikh heritage anyway. They oppose the issue of women’s seva in the majority of the Gurdwaras across the world. They have never bothered to study the Sikh Rehit Maryada or to follow the Gurus’ teachings enshrined in Sri Guru Granth Sahib themselves. Additionally, the people who argue that women are not hygienic during their menstrual cycle are very wrong indeed. Through their true reflection of absurdity, immaturity and immoral personal characters, they have failed to comprehend the law of the nature, that the chemical and biological make-up of human bodies, whether male or female is no different when it comes to natural connotation of human body’s functioning and re-productiveness. Consequently, all fertile women and men are obliged to conscientiously and gracefully honour that significant adolescence cycle. Naturally, they are conscientiously prepared to face all situations with great sense of pride. Similarly, during adolescence when a young man goes through that same natural process and wets his Kachera does that make him an unclean person in the same sense?
Over the past few decades, we have experienced an ever-growing number of so-called deraedaars, sants and the spiritual leaders who frequently indulge and engage themselves in immoral activities such as deception, child abuse and rape of women. Would such a group of filthy-minded characters ever have the courage to question or reject their own mothers, sisters, wives, daughters, nieces, daughters-in-law who may be at their disposal to look after their household affairs, cook and serve their meals promptly and possibly handling Gutkaas to recite ‘Nit Name banees’ at home in such situations? I am sure they would not dare to do that in their own home. However, I do find it very disturbing and distressful to note that without any justifiable argument, these arrogant ‘Masands’ are causing unnecessary havoc in the Sikh world.
Only recently, one of my dear friends, Harmandar Singh quoted in one of his e-mails, ‘The illiterate of the 21st Century, are not those who cannot read and write, but those who cannot learn, unlearn and relearn [AlvinTofler] and he further asked, “Don’t you think this applies to some of our leaders”? Of course, it does and in addition, I would say that, ‘There is none so blind as those who will not see’ and ‘There is none so deaf as those who will not hear.’ This new breed of so-called community leaders and the unscrupulous Holy men are uprooting the fundamentals of the Khalsa Panth, who are utter disgrace but have no shame at all.
Sikh history has it, when Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh created Khalsa in 1699 at Sri Kesgarh Sahib; there were SEVEN great personalities present in the tent; Guru Sahib Ji, Mata Sahib Deva[n] Ji and the five would-be Panj Piaray. Guru Sahib Ji, aided by Mata Ji who sweetened the water with ‘pataasae’, prepared Amrit and baptised the Five Loved Ones. The infallible Guru Ji’s well thought-out agenda and his action made Mata Ji his equal collaborate in the Historic Baptismal Ceremony - thus he set the ceremonial procedure in line with the Sikh Gurus’ Divine Teachings and revealed the Khalsa. Henceforth, it is recorded that whenever Amrit Sanchar ceremony took place, Mata Ji was always by Guru Ji’s side and helped Guru Sahib respectfully and attained the title of the ‘mother of Khalsa’.
The word ‘Khalsa’ meaning ‘pure’ applies to both men and women alike. Therefore, it is a neutral gender. As Khalsas, all males, females hold equal status, and as mentioned in Gurbani, we are all brides of One Creator husband, the Akaal Purkh Vaheguru.
The main cause for concern is that the egoistic biparvaadi ‘Kursi and Gohlak’ loving leaders attach great importance to their self-styled organisations and insist on their ‘Parampra [s]’ that deliberately deny women the right to do seva. For many decades such people, their organisations and their ‘Parampra [s]’ have done a great deal of irreparable damage to Sikhi and the entire Sikh Nation. Whatever the word ‘Parampra’ means to them, in reality, it is insignificant after all and certainly, no ‘Parampra’ could ever be above our Great Guru Ji’s Divine Teachings.
As for my personal knowledge, I would be very grateful if someone could enlighten me as to who gave the men [Panj Pyaras] an absolute right to shunt off the ‘mother of Khalsa’ and to play her role in the present day Amrit Sanchar ceremonies.
We Sikhs must learn to organise ourselves in order to safeguard our rich Sikh Heritage, Sikh History, and the Sikh Identity. Furthermore, we have to address numerous burning issues that the entire Sikh community faces throughout the world with promptness and One Strong Voice.
Panth da sevadaar
Swaran Singh Panesar, Leeds, West Yorkshire
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Singh · 20 Sep 2005
Tarrandeep Kaur, khalistani and others,
You seem to know who can and can't do sewa in an amrit sanchar, so I can only assume that you know the process behind what makes sugary water into amrit.
Please explain for our benefit and also include an explanation of how the gender of the punj pyare effects this process.
Also, please consider that the first 10 gurus were human males.
Then by your logic, guru granth sahib can't be our guru, because the joyt resides in a book.
If you don't accept that a women can be in punj then how can you accept guru granth sahib as guru?
Your arguments are baseless. I was especially shocked when I read Tarrandeep Kaur's post. Then I was repulsed.
I didn't expect Singhnis to have such weak minds and spirit. and such shallow thinkin.
I can't find the words to express the disgust I felt when i read some of these comments.
Also, please consider this: "Khalsa mero roop hai khaas".
If women can't do sewa in punj then we're saying that they are not Khalsa.
If they are not Khalsa it means they did not receive amrit.
If they didn't receive amrit it means they can't be one with God.
By claiming that bibis can't do sewa in punj you have essentially said that they aren't capable of being one with Guru sahib.
Your shallow minds are stuck on mere physical differences, you can't seem to look beyond them. You have no concept of the soul.
Khalistani your comments especially seem to me those of a teenager.
Overall, this thread is really sad.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Gandalf · 20 Sep 2005
Wow...rather than moving forward hundreds of years since 1699, Sikhism seems to be regressing hundreds and years...We are moving back towards the thinking pre-Guru Nanak where women were confined to the kitchen and expected to be baby machines...
Is the amrit sanchar a ritualistic event now, where we totally follow everything that was done (in a physical sense i.e. 5 males then, 5 males now). If so, do we make sure that a female gives the patasas? If we continue to treat the amrit sanchar as such, then all it is is a meaningless ritual...nothing else.
If we treat it within the confines of what Guru Jee taught us (again, look to the simple basic principles people - and you realize how beautiful Sikhi is...don't make it too complicated) that all people are equal, and look past the gender/castes/race/skin color, of all the individiduals...then it does not become a ritual, and it actually means something...
Im not that shocked by Tarrandeep Kaur's response...I know a lot of women who are close minded and do not think that they should have equal rights to be panj pyaaray...
I think this is a reflection of our punjabi nature (treat women as below men), rather than our Sikhi....we need to separate the 2.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
tarrandeep kaur · 20 Sep 2005
wer have i said that women are not part of khalsa????
im talking about panj piayre seva, its a simpla fact. wen you see the panj piayre you should see bhai deya singh, bhai dharam singh, bhai himmat singh, bhai sahib singh, bhai mokham singh. yes they all represent virtues but they are also all SINGHS! lol im not close minded, yes we shud have eqaulity but ther is an extent. firstly i disagree that we shud wer bana without pyjama and women should not be in the panj piayre. i dnt undastand why people get upset bout equality issues. women have been created different to men, why should we expect to have exactly the same rights?
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
vichar · 20 Sep 2005
roop kaur -
Guru ji said pargatio KHALSA parmatam kee mauj. He did not make a seperate tuk saying pargatio Khalsee parmatam kee mauj. You are either suggesting both Singh/Singhneeaa are Khalsa, or that only Singhs are Khalsa, and Singhneea are not, which begs the question, then what are they? If we go with the former analysis, then gender does not seem to matter, as long as the person is a KHALSA, why are you making a non issue an issue than? If we go with the latter analysis, than you should answer the question, if Singhneaa are not Khalsa, what are they?
yes singhnea are khalsa, however so is a singh who has got an angh missing, a singh with a missing limb is khalsa, yet still cannot do seva in panj,
just as a singhnee is khalsa, but this doesnt mean she can do seva in panj.
panj pyare were and still are 5 singhs, not 3 singhs and 2 singhnees, or 5 singhnees, or 4 singhs and 1 singhnee etc etc.
in Bhai sahibs era only singhs did seva in panj, you tapoban lot love changing rules,and making up stories.
jus like you sed bhai sahib used to wear a dumalla....sorry if you go to balbir singh (sons house) theres not one photo of him with dumalla.
you sed theres a story in his book (laga mantra) bout a singh which dasm patsah visited, and told the singh that his sikhs will decide where to put bhindia in gurbani......(this claim is false there no such story)
you say bhai sahib says in his books you shud wash your kes first, then body (absolute rubbish) dsnt say this anywhere.
stop using bhai sahibs name to support youre manmat.
why do you choose to turn some jujja's (j's) into zazza's (z) by placing a dot underneath
gurbani shud be pronounced as it is written, as gurbani is perfect in everyway....( bhai dsnt support altering gurbani in anyway, you shud read laga mantra wit hmore care.)
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
akjgreat · 20 Sep 2005
what RUBBISH !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i expect more from you tapoban lot.....you say you believe bhai sahib reminded us of rehit left by dasm patsah.......well akj dnt believe in singhnea in panj, because when dasm patsah asked for 5 heads, 5 singhs gave heads...NOT COMPLICATED
DONT COMPLICATE THINGS!!!!!!!!!
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
vivek · 20 Sep 2005
why are ppl talking about equality,?
do you think gods unfair because all 10 guru's were male?
some things are just as they are, you try and explain things but you cannot explain gods hukam!!!!
panj pyare are 5 singhs, thats how god wanted it, thats how it is.
wen dasm patsah asked for 5 heads, 5 singhs came up....this is NOT coincincidence.......it was written by god to happen as so.
it is manmat to try and justify singhnee's in panj...manmat manmat manmat
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
* · 20 Sep 2005
Don't degrade Sikhi with your sexist thinking. We aren't like other religions which don't allow women priests or have separate rules and dress codes for each gender. Recognize the greatness of Gurmat! Realize that our Gurus have shown us a perfect religion without any hypocrisy or double-standards!
And to those Singhnees who feel that they are so inferior that they can't be part of the Punj Pyaaray -- wake up!! Realize your potential!! Guru Sahib has given you every right that he has given to Singhs! Rise up and TAKE that right, claim that which is already yours! If you feel you aren't worthy, MAKE yourselves worthy. There is nothing stopping you from doing as much naam baani and keeping as much rehit as the next Singh. And there is nothing stopping you from partaking in all the sevaa that males participate in...nothing stopping you except YOU!
People bring up so many irrelevant points such as physical differences between males and females. How is it relevant to Sikhi if a woman can or cannot remove her shirt in public? During the process of choosing Punj Pyaaray, have you ever heard of a candidate being asked if he removes his shirt in public? No, because it isn't relevant. Why would you then bring such ridiculous points forward now in order to exclude Singhnees from partaking in this sevaa?
No one is in favour of letting a woman without a dastaar take part in the Punj Pyaaray, just as we wouldn't let a monaa male or one in a patka partake in the sevaa. The right to partake in Punj Pyaaray is reserved for the Khalsa. The only way to exclude Singhnees is to argue that they are not part of the Khalsa. There is no way anyone could possibly propose anything so preposterous, so it really is a closed case.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
reply · 20 Sep 2005
Singh ji,
>I didn't expect Singhnis to have such weak minds and spirit. and such shallow thinkin.
Weak are those who bow to manmat, Western culture and the missionaries who are out to show Guru ji made some mistakes which they are now correcting.
Strong are those who believe in their Guru is perfect.
You've called Tarandeep Kaur bhenji weak. But do you have it in you to face a huge group of Marxists/feminists and tell them your Guru was right when he appointed 5 Gursikh as Panj Piyare before, during, and after 1699?
Singh ji, I hope you are not making the same mistake that Ram Rai made when he went to the Mughal court. Surrounded by Muslim influence, he couldn't bring himself to defend Guru Nanak Dev ji's line in Asa di Var. Similarly, many of our brothers and sisters today find themselves without the courage to accept their Guru's actions and words in the feminist/Marxist milieu.
Remember that Ram Rai was Guru ji's saka (by blood) son. What are we? We should tremble for our very souls when even thinking about tampering with Guru-made institutions.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
reply · 20 Sep 2005
>I didn't expect Singhnis to have such weak minds and spirit. and such shallow thinkin.
Singh ji,
Although the daughters of Guru Govind Singh ji do not participate in the Panj Piyare in accordance with the guidance and instruction of our Divine Father, I think you will find you out just how weak or rather strong they are: They will not countenance any disrespect to our Father's guidance and commands and his blessed institutions and neither will their brothers.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
reply · 20 Sep 2005
>I didn't expect Singhnis to have such weak minds and spirit. and such shallow thinkin.
Singh ji,
Did you expect them to be cowards, going with the Kaljugi/feminist/Marxist flow? The princesses of the Khalsa panth are the same ones who ground flour in Lahore in Meer Mannu's prisons, the ones who had their children cut up, and the ones who put garlands around the necks of their husbands, brothers, and sons in the Gurdwara morchas (campaigns).
They however, had respect, as did all Singhs and Kaurs for their Beloved Father's (Pritam Pita's) guidance and commands. Not once is there an instance where they were inducted into Panj Piyare.
And yet, do you think that you or other feminists (people who put a certain ideology before Guru Sahib) are stronger than these pearls of the Panth? When you make the argument for introducing women into the Panj Piyare, you are actually saying (indirectly) that these Singhnis were too weak and only now do we have strong Singhnis who are standing up for their "rights" to be in the Panj Piyare. You are profaning the sacred memory of our Shaheed (martyred) mayeean.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
reply · 20 Sep 2005
>I didn't expect Singhnis to have such weak minds and spirit. and such shallow thinkin.
Singh ji,
The services performed for our panth by Satikar-yog Mata Bhag Kaur jee are known to all. Yet even with her level of service, Guru Govind Singh ji did not appoint her in any grouping of Panj Piyare (such as after 1699, after Muktsar at Sabo ki Talwandi, or at Nanded). In accordance with Guru Sahib's commands, only 5 Singhs are made members of the Panj Piyare.
Do the feminists and Marxists (people who put a foreign ideology above their Guru) think that they can come up with a greater paragon of Gursikh virtues than Mata Bhag Kaur ji in female form? If even Mata Bhag Kaur ji cannot be appointed a member of the 5 Singhs, who else is hankari (egotistical) enough to think that she can?
Do you think that Mata Bhag Kaur ji complained to Guru Govind Singh ji that His Holiness did not appoint her as a member of Panj Piyare? True Gursikhs are completely, 100% devoted to their Guru. When you have given your tan (body), man (mind), dhan (money) to the Guru, what else is left? When we merge with the Satguru, none of our own thinking remains. After that, we only act in accordance with the Guru's own line of thinking.
Mata Bhag Kaur ji is such a Gursikh. Are we?
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
reply · 20 Sep 2005
>Im not that shocked by Tarrandeep Kaur's response...I know a lot of women who are close minded and do not think that they should have equal rights to be panj pyaaray...
So, Gandalf ji, are all people who don't appoint Kaurs to the 5 Piyare closed-minded? Does that include Pritam Pita ji (Beloved Father)? Can you cite an instance where Guru appointed Kaurs into 5 piyare at Anandpur Sahib, Sabo ki Talwandi, the way to Nanded, or at Nanded?
>I think this is a reflection of our punjabi nature (treat women as below men), rather than our Sikhi....we need to separate the 2.
Gandalf piyario, again, did this evil Punjabi nature also manifest itself in Guru Sahib? Piyare ji, have we reached the point that our Guru seems to be doing Manmat and somehow our mann (mind) tells us that we know the true Gurmat?
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
reply · 20 Sep 2005
Charanjeev Singh ji,
You are always on this board providing reasonable and knowledgable commentary. Above, you called the people who are not in favor of tampering with Maharaj's institutions "unparh" (uneducated). Although I don't know if you also included me in this group, I will happily accept it if you do.
The reason:
It is sometimes said that the Turks who fell to the sword of puran (pure) Gursikhs also obtained some measure of uplift. So, similarly, if such a Guru ka piyara has given a jhirka (scolding) to the likes of me, I consider it an honor. (Gur ka jhirka meeta lagai.)
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
reply · 20 Sep 2005
>The main priority of sikh is ekta in panth and get our homeland than all this issues can be solve by having serbat khalsa.Please
guru ki sangat ,we should not bring up this kind issue.
AVTAR ji,
That is a point that we should all be remembering. For example, during the Dharam Yudh Morcha, Giani Jarnail Singh ji Bhindrawale did not bring up the matter of the meat or Ragmala on a panthic level and actually scolded those who tried to bring up these issues or change the de facto maryada of Akal Takhat.
They used to say that once we get Fateh in the morcha, we can discuss such issues at our leisure.
If we had any sense, we would do the same thing and not bring up such controversies and if we did we would discuss them without making fools of ourselves in front of others.
The same thing happened during the langar controversy. Even if you were in favor of the puratan maryada (which I was), the way in which it was handled (bungled, rather) made us look like fools and effected rifts.
But, of course, we just don't have any sense -- we keep doing the same kind of things over and over.
I think the next controversy by the missionaries may be over Parkash and Sukhasan of Guru Sahib in Darbar Sahib. (Apparently, the Kala Afganas object to the ceremonial way in which Guru Sahib is taken to Darbar Sahib. But, how do they propose Guru Sahib be taken, unceremoniously? Maybe like a Bible in the arms of priest?)
Bibian in the punj is just a starting point. We haven't seen anything yet.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
reply · 20 Sep 2005
>Wow...rather than moving forward hundreds of years since 1699, Sikhism seems to be regressing hundreds and years.
Well, that's the attitude right there.
Gandalf ji, if I am reading you right, you apparently believe the Gurus of the Sikhs were not Parbraham Aap, but rather just some nice people who preached whatever seemed to come mind. And now we're supposed to improve on them.
Even if this isn't your belief, I think it is the belief of some others, the main instigators of all of this: They actually believe that they are better than Guru Sahib.
Here is an episode (recorded, I believe in Bachitar Natak) which I believe aptly illustrates this whole situation: During one judh (battle), Guru ji stayed behind while the Khalsa went forward without their Guru. When they sustained a loss and humiliation from the Mughals and came back, they realized the lesson of that poignant incident: Khalsa is nothing without its Guru and it shall always see loss without him.
So too, today, the Khalsa can do whatever in the world in wants to do and has been doing so for a long with a long string of mann-marjian. They already thought they are smarter than the Perfect Guru by improving upon the written text of Gurbani and now some appear to want to prove their intelligence over the Satguru on the other aspect of Guruship.
Guru Sahib sumatt bakhshan.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
AS · 20 Sep 2005
Because there were no Africans, or Chinese, or Whites in the original Panj does that mean that even if they may be full fledged Khalsa now, they can't be a part of the Panj Piyare. Sikhi is a modern, liberal, straight forward Dharam that whole heartedly strives for equality for ALL, even women. So your saying that if Mai Bhago was alive today, she wouldn't be allowed to serve in the Panj just because she was a woman...even though she was strong and intelligent enough to LEAD an army into battle to serve her Guru and punish the Dushman with her blood soaked, Nangi Talwar waiving in the air? I agree there are somethings that men can do better than women, like maybe, pee while standing up (just a joke, relax ;-)... but I know that women have just as much of an oppurtunity to be Sant-Siphai's as men do. If we're restricting women from certain religious duties just based on the fact that they're women....what makes us any different than Bahmins/Pandits. It reaks of Bipran Ki Reet. Therefore, I firmly believe that women should be allowed to serve in the Panj. Even though it's long over due, I'm so happy for all the Singhnees and all the Panth that steps are being taken to ensure the equality of women in Sikhi. Furthermore, I wanna say good job to the AKhand Kirtani Jatha Singhs and Singhnees all over the world for being such positive role models when it comes to this issue. Thank you!
RAJ KAREGA KHALSA
DEGH TEGH FATEH
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Singh · 20 Sep 2005
How do you know mata bhag kaur never did sewa in punj.
Is there a record available of all amrit sanchars ever conducted? Because if there is please do share.
How do you know a bibi never did sewa in punj? The fact is that you don't.
People continue to claim that bibi's can't do sewa in punj but can't seem to answer this one simple question?
What is it that they are lacking that adversely affects the amrit sanchar process?
Please explain or keep your uninformed opinion to yourself.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Singh · 20 Sep 2005
"its a simpla fact. wen you see the panj piayre you should see bhai deya singh, bhai dharam singh, bhai himmat singh, bhai sahib singh, bhai mokham singh. yes they all represent virtues but they are also all SINGHS"
If you're supposed to see the original punj pyaaray, should you also note their ethnicity and their skin colour and tone?
Should we be looking towards the punj pyaaray for physical characteristics or the jot? Should we be looking for bearded men or should we looking for chardi kala naam abhyasis?
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Singh · 20 Sep 2005
For the many so called "moderates" who find it unacceptable that Tapoban/AKJ/"fanatic" Sikhs simply view some Amrit Sanchars are more in accordance to Gurmat than others:
If you believe Bibian should NOT be in the Panj Pyare, if 5 Bibian gave Amrit to a seeker, would this not count as "Amrit"? And if it does count as "Amrit" why the hoo-haa on whether or not Bibian are allowed in the Panj, since all Amrit is equal?
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Gandalf · 20 Sep 2005
reply jee, I love how you twist words.
Did Guru Jee appoint the Panj, or ask for the Panj? I think he asked for 5 heads. He had no control over who showed up (I think that societal factors - i.e. male dominism - determined who would volunteer their heads).
If, as you say, guru Jee selected the first Panj to be 100% male can you explain why they were all male? Why did Guru Jee want all male Panj Pyaarays? Why did he ignore the teachings of Guru Nanak and select males only? Why did he ignore 50% of the population? If you can give me a good answer to these questions you will convert me to your side. (nothing wishy washy either - I want to know why you believe deep down what you believe)
All I am saying is keep things simple. Guru Jee told us to ignore gender/race/caste/creed/height/weight/age/number of eyes/ number of teeth etc. You can't judge a person based on that FOR ANYTHING. I’m not saying that I am smarter than Guru Jee, but if a Singhnee wants to answer the call of her Guru and do Panj dee seva, she should do it. She should never think that she is not allowed to do it because of her gender.
And as far as moving ahead of gurus, I have never said my thinking is ahead of gurus. I am very imperfect. I view Gurus teachings as word of God. Guru Nanak Dev Jee broke limits for females more than 200 years before the 1st Amrit Sanchar. We are moving backwards to pre-Guru Nanak era thinking. Try to think in line with the Gurus.
If the first punj pyaaray were male, should we only allow male punj forever now? Gurujee also rode a horse, never used a phone, never used the Internet, or never watched TV. You should sell your car, phone, TV and get off the computer if you want to live exactly as GuruJee did. You need to get out of your box and grow with the times. Our Gurus were ahead of their time. You seem to have similar thinking pre-Gurus.
You expect women to follow the same rules as you (i.e. bana, bibek etc), but you do not allow women the same privileges as you do (i.e. seva of guru) And who are you to say no to someone who wants to do Guru's seva. That is up to Guru to decide. Not you.
I await your response to my question above (i.e. why did guru select males only?) - they are in bold to make it easier for you to find.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Walking the path... · 20 Sep 2005
Author: Singh
Date: 09-20-05 06:01
Also, please consider that the first 10 gurus were human males.
Then by your logic, guru granth sahib can't be our guru, because the joyt resides in a book.
=====================================================
Then by my logic i cant accept Maharaj as Guru becomes the joyt resides in a what??
Singh, if someone said that to me in the street, id slap them. Sorry but its the truth. Why? Because you use the name, Singh, and then say a comment like maharaj is a book.
"Bani Guru, Guru Hai Bani. Bani Vich Amrit Saaray". The Bani is the true Guru so my point is still valid.
Which also answers your point rather nicely.
The point being, if you were intellectual enough to read, the Gurgadi was passed on to a male. Even though there were female sevadars of each Guru carrying out next level seva! So again, sorry, point valid, and you again, have no indication to use the terminology Maharaj is a book.
"Sabh Sikhan Ko Hukham Hai, Guru Maneo Granth"
Again, thats the answer to you post.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Sep 2005
Dear "Walking the path Jio"..
You SHOULD SLAP anyone who callas Guru Ji a "book"... I would also DO the SAME...but hiding behind the 'book" remark and getting angry wont save the "pesky question"
BUT you failed to answer the QUESTION.... IF the First Ten Guurs were GURUS ( becasue of GENDER)....then how do you explain that GRANTH JI is now our GURU ( What is the GENDER of GRANTH JI ?? )
The Logical answer I would Give is that GURU JYOT is NOT LIMITED TO ANY GENDER....but you seem to be stuck with MALES ONLY.
2. SECONDLY answer this. AT Vasakhi 1699 GURU JI BESTOWED the TITLE of KHALSA JI DEE MATA on Mata Sahib kaur. There Guur Ji, the PUNJ and Mata Ji.....SEVEN PERSONS were PRESENT...when KHALSA JI was "born".
Now With What Authority have the SANT SAMAJISTS and Derawaddees REMOVED the MOTHER FIGURE of the KHALSA ( like removing a waal from makhan ) from the All IMPORTANT Amrit Sanchaar ceremony.
Mata Ji is VITAL to the ceremony..I never for a second beleived that her presence was just as an "afterthought" ( OH..so you are also here..so what can you do ? Oh you brought some patashay..ok then put them in..and MOVE ASIDE or GET OUT ?????... WHO removed Mata Ji from the subsequent Amrit Sanchaars ??
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Singh · 20 Sep 2005
" Jyot resides inside the form of a book. "
What's wrong with this statement?
The physical form of Guru Granth Sahib jee maharaj is a book is it not.
Just like the physical form of Guru Nanak was a male human body.
But I must admit that I was typing away and didn't bother to re-read my words and I understand how the wording might have sounded crude or disrespectful.
For this I apologize to Sangat and probably do deserve the slap.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
AVTAR · 21 Sep 2005
wAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH,
GYANI JI, WE ARE TALKING WOMEN AS PANJ PIAYRE.WOMEN CAN DO SEWA AS MATA JI BUT THEY HAVE NO INTEREST IN SEWA.THEY HAVE ONLY INTEREST TO BE ONE OR MORE AS PANJ PAAYRE. THERE IS ALOT OF SEWA WOMEN CAN DO. BUT WE JUST ARGUE AND DIVIDE THE PANTH INTO MANY GROUPS ,SOME SAY WOMEN SHOULD TAKE PART IN 5 PIAYRE,DO KRITIAN IN DARBAR SHIAB AT AMRITSAR,BUT WHY?.ONLY THIS SEWA LEFT? MY GURU GOBIND SINGH IS ALMIGHTY GOD.
IF MY GURU ONLY CHOOSE MAN THAN ONLY MAN CAN BE THE PANJ PIAYRE.
ONLY SERBAT KHALSA CAN CHANGE THIS NOT BY OUR INTELLECTUAL BRAIN.SO PLEASE DO NOT ARGUE ON THIS TOPIC.A BENTI TO ALL MY SISTERS PLS DO OTHER SEWA .THERE IS ALOT OF SEWA TO DO.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Jugraj Singh · 21 Sep 2005
So since the first punj pyare were all males some of you are saying that only men should be able to do sewa.
This point is easily refuted.
By your own logic only women can be Sikhs because Bebe Nanaki was the first Sikh. She was the first to recognize the guru for who he was.
So, where does that leave all the males?
The people saying that Bibian can't do sewa in the punj haven't been able to answer one simple question?
How does the gender of the punj pyare effect the preparation of amrit?
Eagerly awaiting your reponse. Please englighten us.
Nobody want to hear your opinion on women's rights, or other nonsense. Just logical, well thoughout arguments for why bibian can't do sewa.
"Because she's a bibi" doesn't qualify as an answer.
Also, how do you explain this pankti. "Khalsa mero roop hai khaas".
How can anyone go against this furmaan of guru sahib? If we're all his Khalsa we are his roop and can do sewa. And as RoopKaur has pointed out, if only Singhs are Khalsa then what are Bibian?
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
S Singh · 21 Sep 2005
Since non of the original Panj PYaray were Punjabi Jatts, does that mean today all of those Panj Pyaray which include males who were born in Punjabi Jatt families are doing Manmat? just curious to know...
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Singhni MiriPiri · 21 Sep 2005
WaheguruJiKiKhalsaWaheguruJiKiFateh
Zorawar Singh,
*,
Singh,
Jugraj Singh,
RoopKaur
and others
I could have not said it better myself!
In the past no one cared that the Gurus were males because they weren’t judged by their sex. This is just a human body that we are in, not a soul. We only have this body for worldly purposes.
gurmuiK eyk idRsit kir dyKhu Git Git joiq smoeI jIau ]2]
guramukh eaek dhrisatt kar dhaekhahu ghatt ghatt joth samoee jeeo ||2||
As Gurmukh, look upon all with the single eye of equality; in each and every heart, the Divine Light is contained. ||2||
This line shows that if a being does not see equality does not become one with God.
This makes sense doesn’t it?
As the new generation has been going on no one has been seeing equality in females. In addition, women were treated terribly by being treated as sex objects who leads to women being raped and their husbands beating them. Women had no choice to what they ever wanted to do. For instance, even when women were married they were forced by men if they didn’t wish to take part in sexual activities. They were forced in to prostitution. This all began in the newer generation. This inequality only occurred because it was at this time when they began to think that there was no high status for females because there were no female profits.
This is probably the reason why there are less people reaching saach Khand because they are brainwashed by media and manmukhs of what they see of women.
We are forgetting that this separation of the human body doesn’t occur with religious purposes. Yes, I know female’s body has been made to give birth but this is not the only virtue they have. They can do anything that a male is allowed to do in Sikhism.
And we don’t say you can’t take part in so and so of such a thing just because you are a female. This sounds extremely sexist and destroys the equality and righteousness in Sikhism.
The reason why God made more men religious than women in the past, is to see how us human beings will react to this. Everything has happened for a reason!
Most people reacted negatively towards this situation and shows that we only judge people from their physical body.
How dare you look at the moral of people by their physical body. So, if a female had a sexual surgery to become a man is it then when that being is allowed to take part in religious obligations such as panj pyaree.
This is ridiculous! What kind of mind are people gaining these days?
Men and women’s physical body has only been made for earthly purposes; hint, so that they can bring the new generation. But I don’t see any point for a female to be born because what meaning does she have?
If you keep on treating women like this now it will become worse in the future.
People are only converting to Sikhism is because the rights it has for women. Buddhism for an example has no status for females. They believe that women cannot reach enlightenment.
Do you want Sikhi to sound disgraceful as that towards females?
In Gurbani all worldly beings are considered as soul brides and the lord as husband.
Does this now prove that the worldly body does not matter in the significance of sikhi? We are all females not literally.
Don’t put women in categories.
WaheguruJiKiKhalsaWaheguruJiKiFateh
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
amarjeet singh · 21 Sep 2005
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh
"I await your response to my question above (i.e. why did guru select males only?) - they are in bold to make it easier for you to find."
what a dumb question. why are you questioning guru ji's hukam? would you say why do women have babys and men dont? or why is grass green?? somethings just are.
"Did Guru Jee appoint the Panj, or ask for the Panj? I think he asked for 5 heads. He had no control over who showed up (I think that societal factors - i.e. male dominism - determined who would volunteer their heads)."
another stupid statement. everything is in guru ji's hands. guru ji has control over every thing.
and how is having 5 singhs in the panj pyare ignoring guru nanak dev ji's teaching of equality?? its just the way it is. there wasnt meant to be women in the panj pyare so there wasnt, why cant people just accept simple things?? you are questiong guru ji's hukam???
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
khalistani · 21 Sep 2005
thankyou
i see the light now
equality
tmm im gonna beat the crap out of a bibi
then im gonna tell some to walk around without tops
then im gonna go to gurughar and get mad at guru je for making women only able to give birth
i mean wa happened to men can do eveerything women can do, vise versa
i mean seriously
god is biased!
wa we gonna do
o ma vaheguru
( i was sarcastic, not serious)
bhula chuka maf
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Jugraj Singh · 21 Sep 2005
Some posts reek of teenage sentiments supercharged by hormones. Please review what you write before you post it.
Putting aside nonsensical babble, most posts have no real susbstance.
The people in favor of Bibian not doing sewa are like parrots, simply repeating that bibi's can't do sewa while offering no gurmat related evidence or reasoning to support their claims.
All of you must still answer for the following points:
1) By your own logic only women can be Sikhs because Bebe Nanaki was the first Sikh. She was the first to recognize the guru for who he was.
So, where does that leave all the males?
2) How does the gender of the punj pyare effect the preparation of amrit?
3) "Khalsa mero roop hai khaas". How can anyone go against this furmaan of guru sahib? If we're all his Khalsa, we are his roop, so we can do sewa. And as RoopKaur has pointed out, if only Singhs are Khalsa then what are Bibian?
4) IF the First Ten Guurs were GURUS ( becasue of GENDER)....then how do you explain that GRANTH JI is now our GURU ( What is the GENDER of GRANTH JI ?? )
Frankly, I'm tired of the childish whining.
Most of the posts in favor of bibian not being able to do sewa can be summarized in one sentence, "Bibian can't do sewa because they're bibian".
This is not how you debate.
Just becuase you say it, doesn't make it so. Majority of the panth doesn't follow sarbloh rehit, does that mean it is not a rehit that we should keep? Majority of the panth is ignorant of lareedar saroop, does that mean we should forget our guru?
If you can, answer the above 4 points.
It is okay to admit you are wrong. You will get Guru sahib's khushi.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
history · 22 Sep 2005
I was listening to radio show on this, and a lady mentioned that when Guru Amar Das ji (i think) appointed 52 parcharks (not sure), but 2 of those were women, i'm sure i'm mixed up can someone clairfy ??? basically she was pointing out that women had been given status previously anyway.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Seeker · 22 Sep 2005
Heres another question to add to your list... when did the gursikhs of the panth gain awareness of this issue?
People say that there is n evidence that women were NOT in the panj, but equally as a group who is seeking to 'revert' to the truth, please show an example of where a bibi HAS taken part in the last 290 odd years.
Q1. No Guru ji had many women and male sikhs, this example is irrelevant as during the life of guru gobind singh ji there were other panj singha de jathe i.e. panj pyareh giving amrit, but no women as far as we know.
Q2. The gender does not affect the amrit, but the Gurus buchan does. There are many things we cant explain but we do them cus guru ji told us to.
Q3. Everyone brings up this one bhangti, which sorry has nothing to do with the amrit sanchar. From my knowledge, perhaps someone can confirm, guru ji is said to have said you can see me in panj tyaar batyaar singhs, that panj singhs must prepare the amrit etc. the word here is SINGH.
As i posted earlier but people seemed to have missed the point, why does guru ji call males SINGHS and females KAURS? Why the distinction? Why not call us all kaurs, or all singhs or to make it easy for you guys just have given us the name khalsa and not have singh or kaur!
IF guru ji has used the words SINGHS then that means SINGHS, not singhnian, who are called KAURS, but SINGHS!
Q4. Guru Granth Sahib Ji is guru because Guru Gobind singh gave his buchan, cant believe you guys bring this up! Sound like the dehtdharis who argue as how could guru ji make 'a book' the guru etc.
Regrading caste, please see above i believe i answered that point, regarding colour of skin etc, again depends on where you are born, essentially male from all parts of the world are the same, as are women. However, men are not women and vice versa. There is a difference.
Equally just because YOU say bibian can do it, doesnt mean they should.
We have had people talking about how 'weak bibian' are for refusing to tow the line! Have some shame brother, if we need to debate lets at least do it sensibly. The language and tone of the peope in favour of women doing the seva has been really quite rude. We who favour keeping the maryada of 5 singhs are not women haters, we do not seek the opression of women!! if we did it would make ur job so much easier as then it is a simple case! Fact is we have just as much respect for our sisters as u do, just that we believe that it was our gurus decision to have 5 singhs in this instance and we do not think that should be chnaged. that doesnt mean women are inferior by any means!!
A man CANNOT give birth, hence by defualt is he inferior?
And please will the pro-party please answer these;
1. During amrit sanchar, will males be told to keep their trousers on? Or will women have to take theirs off, its only equal.
2. Since there is no diff between us, 'as according to u western equality arguments' will we dispose of the blatantly sexist and obviously divisive names of KAUR and SINGH, as how can it be that when 2 people take amrit, one is a lion and the other a princess/prince just because of their gender!!!
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Jugraj Singh · 22 Sep 2005
>>>
People say that there is n evidence that women were NOT in the panj, but equally as a group who is seeking to 'revert' to the truth, please show an example of where a bibi HAS taken part in the last 290 odd years.
>>>
Like I said, no one kept a record.
Did you know that at Weston Gurdwara Sahib, a bibi did sewa. This wasn't recorded anywhere but that doesn't make it untrue.
Just because you didn't hear about it, doesn't mean it didn't happen.
>>>
Q1. No Guru ji had many women and male sikhs, this example is irrelevant as during the life of guru gobind singh ji there were other panj singha de jathe i.e. panj pyareh giving amrit, but no women as far as we know.
>>>
I have no idea what the first part of your sentence is saying.
But like I said before, as far as YOU know a bibi didn't do sewa. But that doesn't mean a bibi never did sewa. And no one bothered to record every amrit sanchar that ever happened in the panth and they surely didn't bother to record the names and gender of those who did sewa.
Seeker jee, because you aren't aware of something makes you ignorant, not right.
>>>
Q2. The gender does not affect the amrit, but the Gurus buchan does. There are many things we cant explain but we do them cus guru ji told us to.
>>>
So you admit that gender doesn't affect amrit. Then there is no issue of debate at all because Guru sahib NEVER did a bachan that a bibi can't do sewa in amrit sanchar. If you belive he did, please provide a reference.
>>>
Everyone brings up this one bhangti, which sorry has nothing to do with the amrit sanchar.
>>>
What do you mean has nothing to do with amrit sanchar? It clearly shows that Guru sahib is saying that Khalsa is his roop.
And amrit sanchar is the process where Khalsa initiate others into the fold.
The pankti gives guru's authority to his Khalsa. What else do you want?
>>>
From my knowledge, perhaps someone can confirm, guru ji is said to have said you can see me in panj tyaar batyaar singhs, that panj singhs must prepare the amrit etc. the word here is SINGH.
>>>
guru ji is said to have said ... to who? Where? Can i find this hukamnama in writing anywhere?
Where did you get this knowledge from? Please share the source.
>>>
Q4. Guru Granth Sahib Ji is guru because Guru Gobind singh gave his buchan, cant believe you guys bring this up! Sound like the dehtdharis who argue as how could guru ji make 'a book' the guru etc.
>>>
Well guru sahib also gave a bachan. "Khalsa mero roop hai khaas" You don't want to belive this bachan so why do you belive the one about "Guru maneyo granth".
I firmly believe all of Guru's bachans. But you seem to pick and choose and have some sort of a standard that you apply to guru sahib bachans so you know which ones were correct.
If Guru sahib has said, "Khalsa mero roop hai Khaas" What exaclty is the issue of debate here?
Belive all of Guru sahib's bachans.
>>>
we believe that it was our gurus decision to have 5 singhs in this instance and we do not think that should be chnaged. that doesnt mean women are inferior by any means!!
A man CANNOT give birth, hence by defualt is he inferior?
>>>
Please prove that it was gurus decision to have only males doing sewa.
I never claimed that you are saying women are inferior. I said you are ignorant of gurmat.
Some women can't give birth either... so where does that leave your argument?
Some men can't do there part in creating babies? so what?
What do these irrelevant comments have to do with making of amrit?
You still have failed to answer one simple question:
How is the process of amrit sanchar affected by the gender of the punj?
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 22 Sep 2005
[u]Singh and Kaur Names[/u]
As we all know, Guru Sahib did not create the Panth on a lark. God and Guru had deliberated on the matter even before Guru Sahib's descent in human form. Afterward, Guru ji asked God to bless him as his son. (I don't think a debate on Bachittar Natak would be fruitful in this thread; even if for some reason you have doubts about some aspect of Bachittar Natak, Guru Govind Singh ji's actions in 1699 cannot be said to have been spur-of-the-moment.)
It should be noted that while sketching out the form of his Panth, Guru Govind Singh ji started out with a blank slate. Upon it could have been inscribed anything. But the particular things that Guru ji inscribed should make us think.
Guru ji chose to call all the female Sikhs Kaur and male Sikhs Singh. First of all, there was no requirement to introduce a naming scheme in the new Panth (There's no how-to manual for creating new religions that says you have to name the adherents, is there?). But Guru ji did. Two things to note here: All male Sikhs are named the same way. No matter what the former caste, the geographical location, color, shape of nose, wealth, social status, etc., all males are named Singh. The same for all women: they are all named Kaur disregarding former caste, color, "beauty", etc.
This makes for a leveling among all Singhs: i.e., all Singhs become equal and the caste, location, color, etc. fade away. Similarly, all Kaurs become equal.
Yet, secondly, males and females are not named equally. The difference is entirely on the basis of nothing other than sex. The naming scheme makes for a division between Singhs and Kaurs and neatly divides the Panth up on sexual lines.
[u]The coming attack on Singh and Kaur names[/u]
Guru Sahib chose this plan. In place of this, if Guru ji wanted a unisexual naming system, His Holiness could just have surnamed everybody Sikh or Khalsa:
Jagir Kaur -> Jagir Sikh
Amrinder Singh -> Amrinder Sikh
or
Jagir Kaur -> Jagir Khalsa
Amrinder Singh -> Amrinder Khalsa
Just as the command for the Kachera obviates nudism in Sikhi, so too Guru ji's divinely ordained naming scheme obviates unisexualism. As well, Guru Sahib has commanded that 5 Singhs will be His Holiness's roop (form). As explained above, Singh means any male follower of the Sikh religion.
Although for some reason they haven't done anything about this, the naming scheme will turn out to be a thorn in the feminist's side and they will eventually have do something. They will probably ask, "Where is it written in Gurbani that we have to have Singh and Kaur names?" Well, as everyone knows, nowhere. This echoes what they are asking now "Where is it written in Gurbani that Singhs prepare Khande-Bate da Amrit?" But, then, if this is to be the standard, where is Khande-Bate da Amrit written about in Gurbani? Nowhere, of course.
You can well appreciate that the feminists are starting up the movement for annihilation of the Panth.
"Don't turn my beautiful Sikhi into a feminist dreamland" (With thanks and apologies to Kulbir Singh ji UK vale)
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 22 Sep 2005
>All the youth on this forum must accept that they are only opposing this because the baba or group are against it, just like they did with Sant jarnail singh shaheedi.
Zorawar Singh ji, why must they accept this if it's not true?
Do you do everything you do because a Missionary told you?
The only Baba that matters is Baba Guru Govind Singh ji.
>There is no basis in Gurbani for it.
Is there any basis in Gurbani for Khande-bate da Amrit? None whatsoever. So why bring Gurbani into this? Are you an Amritdhari Sikh or one who believes in taking it? What answer do you have for someone (say, a mona) who asks what basis there is in Gurbani for Khande-bate da amrit? You would have to say that this is tradition and command given by Guru Govind Singh ji and passed on.
Well, exactly. So why do you challenge it's basis? You are cutting your hand with your own sickle.
>I can produce many that state bibian are special, equal and every humans soul is female.
And? Did the writer of this Gurbani not have the special knowledge of Gurmat that you do in order to appoint just one Kaur into the Panj Piyare (even after 1699)?
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
amarjeet singh · 22 Sep 2005
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh
"How is the process of amrit sanchar affected by the gender of the punj?"
it is effected because it is not in accordance with the way an amrit sanchaar is supposed to be conducted, ie with 5 singhs.
answer me this, you say that because of "Khalsa mero roop hai khaas" this means women as well as men should be able to take part in panj pyare seva. well if a singh has a missing limb he is not able to do seva in the panj. does that mean that he is not khalsa? no. it means that he is not able to do seva in the panj, it is simply guru's hukam why bother trying to argue about it. the form of the panj pyare was, is and always will be 5 SINGHS in full roop, (no angs missing) thats just the way it is.
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Gandalf · 22 Sep 2005
amarjeet singh..."Reply" jee....you both can't answer the following...
why 5 singhs though? can you answer that? I know you will say that I am questioning hukam (I am not). I just like to ask myself why do we do what we do. That way I can determine whether what is done is right (for example, why do gurdwaras serve parshad before hukamnama, why do gurdaras burn incense, why were there 5 women in the Panj)?
What is it about women that prevents them from doing this seva?? Just answer that (and don't answer because that is how guru did it). Tell me WHY there were 5 male Panj. WHY weren't there female Panj.
You can't find an answer other than "Guru jee did it". WHY DID GURU JEE DO THAT...
peel back a layer of the onion for me please...and provide me with a deeper explanation for your answer...because I am not getting a lot of knowledge out of you guys.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
khalistani · 22 Sep 2005
man im tellineveryone no matter wat u tell anyone no ones gonna belive it shud only be singh
even if u show em the writings of bhai nand lal je, ie panch SINGH amrit jo devai...
theyre stil not gonna belive, yet rather deny it with soem next respnse
w/e
there will never be total equality
if there is this world will be fulll of sharm
and people kno that
stop being hpocritcal
either let bibi do EVERYTHING men can do and start debating with akaal himself too for being biased, or stop letting bibis in panj
btw, i am luck enough to have many older people in m famil
and ive asked them all, they never even HEARD of panj pyarai and bibis
and never till this day have even i read in BHAI SAHIBS BOOKs read panj shud be bibis as well
no where
its NOW this is happenin
all the older older i mean like 90 have told me they never heard of,like everyone i asked, never even heard of pannj being with bibis
this is a new thing
like i said, well never let bibis do everything men, and also vice versa
bhula chuka maf
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
AS · 22 Sep 2005
OK, some say that women can't do seva in the Panj (for whatever reason it may be) but according to Sant Samaj and Taksal, women shouldn't be allowed to do Kirtan and some other Sewas at Sri Darbar Sahib either. What's the reasoning behind that?
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Seeker · 23 Sep 2005
Jagraj Singh, just to clarify my post was not directed at any individual but at the 'pro panj women' camp, hence when i say 'you accuse us of putting women down' etc i refer to many of the various posts i have read from various people as oppossed to specifics.
Secondly let me just clarify with you, i very much do accept ALL the bachans of Guru Sahib, which unfortunetly is more than can be said for many of the users of this forum. Nothing more to be said on THAT topic i believe. As such please do not pressume that you know anything regarding my beliefs. I do not pick and choose i either understand or dont understand but ACCEPT that due to my limited knowledge much of what guru ji says is beyond me.
The reason i say that bhangti is irrelevant here is that there must be a number of sources re amrit sanchars be they writings hukumname etc, why hasnt anybody discussed those which RELATE DIRECTLY to the issue at hand. Does it say Singhs administer amrit, or does it say khalse (in which case THEN you go on to discuss this bhangti)
Replying to gandalf as to why Guru sahib did what he did, etc, how can the son explain the actions of his father? If i were able to do that, i would not be sitting typing on a internet forum! Please brother following from your argument explain each of the other wonders the guru and vaheguru has created!
Reply, i agree the names thing will be the next to go which is why i believe it is something very vital to discuss.
Khalistani thank u i was pretty sure it said 'singhs' in one of the hukumnamas regarding amrit sanchars.
Brother many of us here who oppose women administering amrit DO NOT oppose the keertan in darbar sahib which to me personally is much much less of an issue. My own belief is that there is nothing wrong with them doing keertan there
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
amarjeet singh · 23 Sep 2005
Gandalf, why were all the guru's male??
its just the way maharaj intended it to be.
same way five singhs are panj piayre, just how its supposed to be.
we cant question guruji's hukam, just accept it.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Singh · 23 Sep 2005
They are just worried one day, a bibi maybe the jathedar of taksal, or the next sant. They cannot handle the thought that they will not be the top dog one day.
AS wrote:
> OK, some say that women can't do seva in the Panj (for whatever
> reason it may be) but according to Sant Samaj and Taksal, women
> shouldn't be allowed to do Kirtan and some other Sewas at Sri
> Darbar Sahib either. What's the reasoning behind that?
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Jugraj Singh · 23 Sep 2005
Reply jee,
You wrote a nice story. But you are misinformed.
>>>
Just as the command for the Kachera obviates nudism in Sikhi, so too Guru ji's divinely ordained naming scheme obviates unisexualism.
>>>
No one ever claimed sikhi promoted unisexualism.
>>>
As well, Guru Sahib has commanded that 5 Singhs will be His Holiness's roop (form). As explained above, Singh means any male follower of the Sikh religion.
>>>
Where has Guru sahib commanded this? Please explain or show with a reference.
I am only aware of "Khalsa mero roop hai khaas"
Your perception of the whole issue is flawed. It has nothing to do with feminism.
The concept of feminism is a moot one in Sikhi, because Guru sahib looks at devotion and kamaiee and not at the gender of the person. Gurbani says this over and over again.
"karmi aapo aapnee kai na-re kai dooor"
As for amrit sanchar in 1699 having all male as punj pyare, then what of the first Sikh, bebe Nanki, why did guru sahib appoint a female as the first sikh?
Your argument is stupid and baseless. You are choosing to ignore the contradictions in your own logic.
This is equivalent to covering your ears with your hands and simply refusing to listen. This is not the way a Sikh behaves.
Ask the older generation how many Women Granthis' they have seen. The first Granthi of darbar sahib was Baba Buddha jee and after that it has always been a male. Does that mean women can't be granthis?
I have yet to see any proof that Guru sahib said only Singhs can do sewa.
YOu have provided none what so ever.
Your only argument is that the first punj were males, and this has been refuted and your logic proven false over and over again.
You still haven't answered the questions I've posted, yet continue to repeat like parrots that women can't do sewa. This only proves to me that you have no real understanding of the issue and lack the insight to answer the questions.
Being ignorant of gurmat is one thing, but conciously choosing to stay ignorant is a paap.
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
waheguru ji kee fateh
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
vichar · 23 Sep 2005
any gursikh with a small amount of knowlegde knows PANJ PYARE have a TRUA FORM
a SINGH cannot do seva in panj if he has an angh missing, this is not a new fact, everyone in the jatha knows this.
now, all u in favour of singhnees in panj - what do you think of a pregnant bibi in panj?
is it then 5 pyare or 6 pyare?..........the unborn child isnt amritdharee, how can it do seva in panj.....................?
what if the bibi has a periodic bleed? stop the amrit sanchar??? or carry on with dirty kachere?
lifes not fair is it? why cant singhs have babies? why cant singhs breast feed babies?..............its not fair, singhs shud be able to do evetything singhnees can.............................shudnt they?
shoudnt they?
sikhism issnt fair!!!!! all guru's were male!! why werent theyre any female guru's??????????
you all have to wake up, stop trying to figure out why things are they are...........the physical form of 5 singhs WITHOUT missing ANGH is how panj pyare should be.
not 5 pregnant bibis, with 5 children...........lol.....................10 pyare, 5 of which are non amritdharee............hahahaha
panj pyare with bloody kachere............whats happened to the truth?
no one wants to kno about the truth, every1 wnt to follow their own mat.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
akjgreat · 23 Sep 2005
jus cause some1s khalsa dnt mean they can do seva in panj
a singh who is khalsa, but has angh missing cannot do seva in panj
this ends that FALSA ARGUMENT
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
amarjeet singh · 23 Sep 2005
"You can't find an answer other than "Guru jee did it". WHY DID GURU JEE DO THAT..."
gandalf, no one can answer why guru ji did something. how can us mere sinners realise why guru ji did something?? are you a brahmgyani or something? if you think that you can provide an answer for everything in wahegurus creation then good 4 u. but things just are
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Gandalf · 23 Sep 2005
Blindly accepting something can be dangerous...thats where we get into ritualistic situations (i.e. I do something because that is the way it was done).
You should find out the meaning of why things are done. You'll find that over time, the message gets distorted, things change and you might find that what you are doing is actually wrong.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Gandalf · 23 Sep 2005
This is why I say to you to analyze (and not just blindly accept).
As far as I can tell....Guru Jee asked for 5 heads
Not for 5 males
Not for 5 Singhs (he gave the name Singh after the amrit sanchar)
Just 5 heads (he didn't specify male and female)....it just so happened that 5 males stepped up (I think that societal influences may have had something to do with this)
Anyone could have given their head. Thats why a female is eligible to be in the Panj.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Seeker · 23 Sep 2005
Jagraj Singh the same could be said of you, that you also do not answer questions put forth to you.
And please i will ask again, speak with some pyaar, you are NOT my saviour and i very much doubt you are the saviour of 'reply' etc, you throw around words like 'ignorant of gurmat' and paap as if you are some authority? If one wished, he could easily throw the same terms back at you and accuse you of manmat and ignorance etc, but what does that achieve? Does it make you feel better that we are ignorant fools while you are all knowing?
You say the argument that the first 5 were singhs has been refuted? How has it been? IT IS A FACT that the first 5 were singhs. That cannot be refuted! As an argument IT stands. Whether it is a good or bad argument is debatable however IT IS A UNREFUTABLE argument.
Further to which myself and others have put forward a number of issues or problems we foresee with this move towards complete western equality. Equally these points are not being considered, and whilst you seem to think it is a good idea to have 5 women as the panj pyareh, practically you seem to strugle to show/discuss how it would work? In particular the names discussion. Please give your thoughts on this.
Another point raised is that of the fact that amrit sanchar is not mentioned in Gurbani, so the question to ask is how do we know what to do? Where is this info from? Is it oral tradition or are there some old texts? Khalistani has said that bhai nand lal jis writings say PANJ SINGH perhaps he can eloborate on this fact.
Regrarding the disabilities, again using the western equality argument, a person with missing limbs, or a disability etc should also be allowed to participate in the amrit sanchar. Is it possible to have blind, crippled, dumb (speachless), deaf, physially disabled (wheelchairs), maybe one metal arm etc etc to represent the panj pyareh. Now i am NOT comparing women to deaf and dumb people, simply using your equality argument and that of the kamai to ask whether they took can participate?
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Gandalf · 23 Sep 2005
Now you are discriminating against people w/ out body parts???
What next? Black hair, brown eyes and fair skin only? (Sounds like 1930's Germany to me....)
I can't picture Guru Gobind saying to someone who was willing to give their head to him "Sorry, you can't give your head to me...you are missing a finger'
Again we are focusing on the physical and ignoring the spiritual.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Jugraj Singh · 23 Sep 2005
vichar jee,
So all the other times (which is most of the time), bibian are okay to do sewa then right?
And by your logic, older bibian can do sewa all the time.
akjgreat,
>>>
jus cause some1s khalsa dnt mean they can do seva in panj
a singh who is khalsa, but has angh missing cannot do seva in panj
this ends that FALSA ARGUMENT
>>>
This is illogical. HOw can you compare someone missing an ang to someone being a female?
A singh who has committed a bujjar kurehit (but got amrit again), or has lost an ang can't do sewa either.
You have to give reason as to why a bibi who hasn't committed a bujjar kurehit and hasn't lost an ang can't do sewa.
I don't think you really did vichar before you started typing away.
The only thing you all seem to be capable of is making up stories and continuously repeating that women can't do sewa. You have no real argument to provide support, just stubborness.
Just answer this one question directly.
"How is the process of amrit sanchar affected by the gender of the punj"
Or just admit that you have no idea as to what an amrit sanchar involves and you have wasted everyone's time.
guru rakha.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
amarjeet singh · 23 Sep 2005
no gandalf anyone can give their head, but if you are missing a limb you cant do punj pyare seva, as the panj represent true full roop, and you arent in a full form if u arent complete
"Just 5 heads (he didn't specify male and female)....it just so happened that 5 males stepped up (I think that societal influences may have had something to do with this)
Anyone could have given their head. Thats why a female is eligible to be in the Panj."
everything is in guru's hukam nothing happens by chance, there were 5 singhs who came forward because was the way it was, is supposed to be
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
tarrandeep kaur · 23 Sep 2005
vichar has made sum excellent points, its funny that no one is able to comment on them , cos they know wat he is sayin makes sense. cum on gandalf and jagraj singh, wat have u got 2 say bout vichar's points?
i think he is 100% correct.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Bhudysut · 23 Sep 2005
Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh
Thank you vichar...that is by far the most ill-informed post I think I have ever seen! Posts like yours belong to www.brahmin.com. Highlighting the fact that women are somehow impure because of menstruation is a mind set that belongs to the 15th century (before the times of Guru Nanak Dev Ji). This whole belief that you have regarding women being impure during menstruation was highlighted and totally abandoned during their times. When the Manjha system was established and a large number of women were chosen in those leading roles, I doubt very much that their menstruation preiods were a factor in them being chosen (or not).
You seem to think that the first Amrit Sanchar that took place in 1699 was a total male affair, you seem (and others like you) to the role of Mata Sahib Kaur Ji during that great time! So tell me vichar, was Guru Gobind Singh Ji wrong and everyone else since right.
As any Sikh who reads Guru's Bani knows that as soon as we are born, we are here on borrowed time. Our lives flash by in an instant, our vessels (body's) are only here for the material world. They have no other purpose than this. To say that by having an appendage less than everyone 'normal' will have a direct influence with our relationship with Vahiguru is nonsense!
Dass
Akaal Sahai Singh
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
. · 23 Sep 2005
wat does da tapoban singhs think bout women being in panj Piyarey ?
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 23 Sep 2005
Jugraj Singh ji, (and also Gandalf ji)
I only have limited time to spend on this forum per day (and sometimes one wants to go to other threads as well). If I had a typing speed of 1000 or 2000 I could probably answer all of the questions being posed. Note also not all of the points posted by me or others have been answered, but I haven't said anything yet because I know it's a long thread and people sometimes don't have time. We can make this a long-running thread (as some others have been).
You want to know "Why". Please note that this is a question which can be asked about any part of the Rehit. Such as, Why Bir-Asan? Is Bir-Asan mentioned anywhere in Gurbani (or even Dasmesh Bani)? Can you answer these questions?
By the way, some Gursikhs, when asked "Why Kirpan?" will give slightly differing answers so you may read slightly differing positions from those favoring continuing the de facto maryada of Akal Takhat.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 23 Sep 2005
Can you accept all male Gurus? If so, why can you not accept all male Panj?
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 23 Sep 2005
>Your only argument is that the first punj were males
Jugraj Singh ji, perhaps some of my posts have been too long and have obscured this, but this is not the only point put forward. I've posted this above, but let me elaborate:
[u]Assumption: self-selected Punj[/u]
I think you are arguing this: That the the first Punj just happened to be males because they stood up. That the chance coincidence that they were males doesn't mean anything because they were self-selected, not selected by Guru ji.
For the sake of argument, we will assume it was a totally chance incident which God did not preordain from the beginning of time (or at least from the time that he sent Guru ji to this world) and about which Guru ji didn't know in advance. (Which is a big assumption.)
So we assume first 5 were self-selected. But after that, Guru ji had the opportunity to appoint Kaurs. But Guru ji didn't. No distinction was made on former caste/location/color/etc. but a distinction was made on sex.
[u]Two theories[/u]
So we have two theories: one, the theory that has been prevailing in the Panth since its inception that Guru ji has said 5 Singhs are my Roop and are authorized to perform Amrit Sanchar.
Two, that Guru ji created generic Khalsas and any Khalsas male or female are able to be a member of Panj.
If, for some reason, the divine play ordained for the 10th Master had ended right after taking Amrit from the 5 Piyare, we wouldn't have much source material to test our theories. But we do.
In every case of Guru ji appointing anyone to the 5 Piyare, Guru ji only appointed Singhs. At Anandpur (after that eventful) day, at Sabo ki Talwandi (known as Damdama Sahib), at Nanded.
Just an example, Guru ji appointed the following 5 Singhs or 5 Piyare that gave Amrit to Baba Banda Singh Bahadur at Nanded:
Bhai Daya Singh ji
Bhai Dharam Singh ji
Bhai Santokh Singh ji
Bhai Hari Singh ji
Bhai Gurbaksh Singh ji
There were a separate set of 5 Singhs or 5 Piyare sent along with Banda Singh Bahadur to Punjab from Hazur Sahib, the leader of whom was Baba Binod Singh ji (who was a descendant of Guru Angad Dev ji). No sisters were among them.
[u]Opportunity to appoint women[/u]
So Guru Sahib didn't appoint any women as Panj. But was there perhaps not an opportunity to do so?
There are some posters saying that during Guru ji's time there were no cars, so why drive a car? Well, (ingnoring environmental or other matters) cars are a technology that wasn't not available then, but were women a technology that wasn't available then? (??) Of course not.
In trying to reach for some sort of argument, some veers/bhenjis are making some bold assertions: "Well, maybe there weren't any women there." (Leaving aside the fact that, Is a questionable assertion like this supposed to be the foundation of a major change in Panthic rehit) However, just like all of the other settlements created by Guru Sahib (Kartarpur, Goindwal, Amritsar), families lived at Anandpur. Secondly, the invitations for Basakhi 1699 were sent out 1 yr in advance. People reached there with their families. The families of the original Panj were there; they took Amrit afterwards.
When Guru Sahib was at Sabo ki Talwandi, times were "normal" again and families were visiting Guru Sahib. Dalla (remember him? the fellow who wanted a pirhi jinna than in Sachkhand, but Guru ji wouldn't give it without Amrit) took Amrit "parivar samet" (with family). There were others too.
Guru ji also interacted with Mata Bhag Kaur ji (Amritdhari, Kaur name). She took amrit. I've already asked the question of why Guru ji didn't appoint a single woman as a Panj one of the first posts. I don't think anyone has addressed that. Maybe some think that women were weak then. Even though I think this argument is irreverencing our mothers/sisters of that time, let's accept it. But at least, Mata Bhag Kaur ji (she of the huge kirpans/cannons at Hazur Sahib) would have been fit to be in the Panj? If Guru ji had wanted, His Holiness could have appointed her. But he didn't. (See above on Nanded).
So where does that leave theory two? Not in good shape. Theory two has major problems given our source data. All that holds it up is some speculation.
But theory one fits perfectly -- i.e., that Guru ji did what Guru ji said. So must we.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Jugraj Singh · 23 Sep 2005
Ignorance means not knowing something.
If you none of you can answer the question as to how amrit is affected by the gender of the punj then that makes you ignorant.
>>>
You say the argument that the first 5 were singhs has been refuted? How has it been? IT IS A FACT that the first 5 were singhs. That cannot be refuted! As an argument IT stands. Whether it is a good or bad argument is debatable however IT IS A UNREFUTABLE argument.
>>>
The FACT is irrefutable. It is a FACT that the first punj pyare were males. It is NOT an argument.
The ARGUMENT is that since the first punj pyare were males then all others have to be as well. This argument based on the fact that first punj were all males has been refuted over and over again.
I will post the reasons again for your perusal.
1) Guru Granth Sahib jee maharaj doesn't have a gender while all the previuous gurus were males
2) Baba Buddha jee was teh first Granthi and he was a male, and using your logic only bibis can be granthis.
3) Bebe Nanaki was the first Sikh ...
etc. etc.
>>>
Further to which myself and others have put forward a number of issues or problems we foresee with this move towards complete western equality.
>>>
Thats right, YOU forsee. I don't see this as a move towards western ideas but rather see it as a move away from brahmanvaad.
Gurmat gives us all the equality we need, we don't need to move towards any "western standards". Guru sahib has said, "Khalsa mero roop hai Khaas"
>>>
Equally these points are not being considered, and whilst you seem to think it is a good idea to have 5 women as the panj pyareh, practically you seem to strugle to show/discuss how it would work? In particular the names discussion. Please give your thoughts on this.
>>>
How do we struggle to dicuss how female punj would work? Please explain. Gurmat doesn't distinguish between kamaiee of a male or female. And like mentioned before, bibian can do sewa most of the time anyways. They might not be able/willing for whatever reasons (pregnancy etc.)
If punj Singhs who were given the name "Singh" by Guru sahib can do sewa then why can't the five "Kaur's" who were also given their name by the same guru not do sewa?
Please explain.
>>>
Another point raised is that of the fact that amrit sanchar is not mentioned in Gurbani, so the question to ask is how do we know what to do? Where is this info from? Is it oral tradition or are there some old texts? Khalistani has said that bhai nand lal jis writings say PANJ SINGH perhaps he can eloborate on this fact.
>>>
Guru sahib has said. "Khalsa mero roop hai khaas". This is enough for me thanks.
As for seeena baseena marayada. Giani Harbhajan Singh said that there was a Bibi who did sewa with Bhai Sahib Bhai Daleep Singh jee, and this was before bhai sahib Randhir singh went to jail. Puraatan enough for me.
Perhaps admin can shed more light on this.
You can confirm this if you want. I belive Giani Jee lives in Anandpur Sahib.
>>>
Regrarding the disabilities, again using the western equality argument, a person with missing limbs, or a disability etc should also be allowed to participate in the amrit sanchar.
>>>
You are assuming we used the "western equailty" argument, whatever that might be.
I don't think all people in the west have the same idea of equailty. And I don' think you really took a consensus to determine what "western equality" is. So why use a term that has no meaning?
>>>
Now i am NOT comparing women to deaf and dumb people, simply using your equality argument and that of the kamai to ask whether they took can participate?
>>>
No they can't do sewa because you have to be whole of body. But you can be either gender though. There are many restrictions to those who can't do sewa in punj but NONE of the restrictions are gender biased.
The restrictions apply equally to women and men.
"Can't do sewa because they're women" is not an argument. It's a broken record that is getting boring pretty quickly.
Allow me to explain. If you are going to say that women can't do sewa, you have to be able to explain what it is they are lacking that is a requirement for sewa.
Otherwise you have no argument.
What exactly is a brahmgiani bibi lacking that she shouldn't be accepted for sewa in punj pyare?
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 23 Sep 2005
>I have yet to see any proof that Guru sahib said only Singhs can do sewa.
>YOu have provided none what so ever.
Jugraj Singh ji,
What would you consider proof? You know very well that Gurbani in no way mentions Khandas, batas, or the whole Khande-bate da Amrit.
What would you tell someone who asked for still more proof that Khande-bate da amrit is a real and accepted ceremony in Sikhism? What could you do other than tell him that it is in oral history passed down through the generations, but some of it is also written down in Rehitnamas.
Well, you must certainly know those same Rehitnamas clearly state 5 Singhs will administer amrit.
And, why must proof be provided for anything that anyone wishes to stand up and challenge? The burden of proof is on whoever wishes to make the change.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 23 Sep 2005
Jugraj Singh ji,
>You wrote a nice story.
Did you like it? :)
>But you are misinformed.
Inform us piare veerji. Please name a single Bibi that took part in the Panj before the modern nonsense started.
>No one ever claimed sikhi promoted unisexualism.
What else is the import of such blithe sayings as "Khalsa has no gender"? You say noone, but at least someone does claim unisexualism. Even if you're not saying this, that is the obvious, logical next step. That is what happens in these sorts of situations: vide the French Revolution.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
vichar · 23 Sep 2005
GANDALF SED-
As far as I can tell....Guru Jee asked for 5 heads
Not for 5 males
---------------------------------
i thought he asked for one head at a time, then stopped after five SINGHS came up
he may not have asked for SINGHs, but dnt you think theres any significance in the fact that 5 pyare were 5 singhs?
it was meant to be, just as it still is now.........5 singhs is panj pyare, not 5 singhnees
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 23 Sep 2005
Gandalf ji,
I know that you're an idealist, and you read and ponder a lot. Your heart's in the right place and I understand where you're coming from.
You're asking some good questions in earnest and I hope to be able to type enough to answer them in the coming days.
You're asking, Why this maryada? Please know that people have written entire books on Why Kesh? Still, some people accept Kes, while others don't. I hope you will.
With Gursikhi piar
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 23 Sep 2005
Gandalf ji,
>Now you are discriminating against people w/ out body parts???
The way you put your question makes me think you must genuinely be unaware of the Amrit maryada. In fact, even the SGPC maryada (which some consider watered-down) clearly states that handicapped Singhs are not to be a part of the Panj Piyare.
Think about it: they are going to be holding tegas (swords) for 8 hours standing up with hardly a few breaks. Then they're going to sit Bir-Asan (one knee down, one up) for 1 hour to do path without letting go of hand-contact with the Bata while stirring with the Khanda. After that, they pick up what is often a huge and heavy Bata filled with water for the Ardas. (Ever carry water? It's heavy, which is perhaps why Gurbani mentions carrying water as a great seva in a lot of places.) After that, they sit Bir Asan for anywhere from 2 to 20 more hours.
This calls for some heavy-duty risht-pusht (hale and hearty) Singhs. You just cannot have handicapped people and they are just not allowed.
>I can't picture Guru Gobind saying to someone who was willing to give their head to him "Sorry, you can't give your head to me...you are missing a finger'
Ji, again, handicapped brothers/sisters can take amrit, but they can't administer it.
If you're talking about the first 5, if Guru ji put their heads on, Guru ji could certainly have made them whole again. Besides the first 5 were preordained anyway.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 23 Sep 2005
Jugraj Singh ji,
You are asking "how amrit is affected by the gender of the punj"?
Could you answer how amrit is affected by the position in which the Panj Piyare sit? (Bir-Asan) Would it still be amrit if they sat in a chownkri? Would it still be amrit if they sat on chairs? Would it still be amrit if a copper bata were used?
The answer you would have to give is that this is Guru ji's hukum.
Exactly.
Also, if you couldn't answer why Bir-Asan, would that mean you are in ignorance? And could we then try out other positions/modifications of the maryada while you are trying to formulate some answer?
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Rely · 23 Sep 2005
-------
jus cause some1s khalsa dnt mean they can do seva in panj
a singh who is khalsa, but has angh missing cannot do seva in panj
this ends that FALSA ARGUMENT
>>>
This is illogical. HOw can you compare someone missing an ang to someone being a female?
>You have to give reason as to why a bibi who hasn't committed a bujjar kurehit and hasn't lost an ang
can't do sewa.
-------
Jugraj Singh ji,
The reason it is an argument is that both angheen situation illustrates that there is no problem with not being able to be a member of the Panj.
Angheen: Can he take Amrit? Yes
Angheen: Can he realize God? Yes
Angheen: Are there tuks talking about the value of the weak in Gurbani? Yes
Angheen: Can he be in Panj: No
Angheen: Does he have a problem with not being in the Panj? No
Angheen: Is is haumai hurt at not being in the Panj? No
Female: Can she take Amrit? Yes
Female: Can she realize God? Yes
Female: Are there tuks talking about the value of the women in Gurbani? Yes
Female: Can she be in Panj: No
Female: Does she have a problem with not being in the Panj? No
Female: Is her haumai hurt at not being in the Panj? No
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 23 Sep 2005
By the way, why exactly is discrimination for females not be in the Panj, but not handicapped people?
Will we have a new movement demanding equal rights for handicapped people to be in the Panj? Well, they, of course, will need chairs (they can't stand for 10 hours) and maybe the swords will just be fixed to the chairs. We'll say goodbye to Bir-Asan (Warrior Position). Also, some people are allergic to iron (I know about a girl who has to wear her karra tied to her gatra). There goes the Khanda. How about a spatula instead.
I had posted an essay in another thread about how ridiculous these neo-Jacobin movements tend to become, but even I hadn't realized how fast we would get here.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 23 Sep 2005
Jugraj Singh ji
>What exactly is a brahmgiani bibi lacking that she shouldn't be accepted for sewa in punj pyare?
You would have to ask this question of Pritam Pita (Beloved Father) Guru Govind Singh ji, who did not induct Mata Bhag Kaur ji in the the Panj. You really don't think we can produce a greater Kaur than her, do you? And if she cannot be in the Panj, which female can? Who wants to be the first to say she is better than Mata Bhag Kaur ji?
Besides, a brahmgiani is in tune with the Master. A female brahmgiani couldn't even think of violating Guru ji's maryada (just as male can't either).
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 23 Sep 2005
Bhudysut ji,
>role of Mata Sahib Kaur Ji
You do know that Mata Sahib Kaur ji was married to Guru ji on 18 Vaisakh, 1757 BK / 1700 CE , right?
Nevertheless, the Khalsa takes blessings from Mata Sahib Kaur ji. Guru ji gave the Khalsa as the offspring that Mata ji would otherwise never have.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 23 Sep 2005
Jugraj Singh ji,
>1) Guru Granth Sahib jee maharaj doesn't have a gender while all the previuous gurus were males
Guru Granth Sahib ji is pure atma.
The sex is in the Panj Piyare.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Harpartap Singh · 23 Sep 2005
All of us debating using our own matt wiill not resolve this issue
However, just as the vessel (bata) in which Amrit is prepared must be of a certain metal (iron), as should the Khanda although other types are available, MAYBE Guru ji chose the male form as the vessel for those atma's who were to create Amrit.
We are talking about external forms - the shell in which the spirit resides, however Guru ji has also made it mandatory for us all to a have certain external forms as well i.e. Kirpaan.
Maybe the male form is required to prepare Amrit (for spiritual birth) as the counterpoint to women giving actual physical birth and thus explain the different categories of Khalsa - Singhs and Kaurs... I don't know...separate roles but equal in the eyes of Vaheguru...
Just my thoughts - please do not be offended :o)
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 23 Sep 2005
Gandalf ji,
>Blindly accepting something can be dangerous...thats where we get into ritualistic situations (i.e. I do something because that is the way it was done).
This can often be the case. And so we're discussing this. And I'm also learning some new thing about why people want to introduce Bibis into the 5 Piyare and I hope to learn more.
At the same time, I hope you would agree that we would continue with the present maryada (not just on this issue but others as well) until there is some overwhelming proof that the whole Panth accepts.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 23 Sep 2005
Gandalf ji
>(nothing wishy washy either - I want to know why you believe deep down what you believe)
You're asking for a big essay, so please hold on or check back later. Or maybe it'll dribble out post-by-post.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Reply · 23 Sep 2005
Anybody find it humorous that the Bibi-Panj camp is claiming women to have been weak while the 5 Singh camp is saying they were strong?
The Bibi-Punj camp has to somehow give a reason for Bibian not being in the first Panj and all Panj subsequently during the 10th Master's lifetime. Well, some among them have come up with "women were weak then". ?? Women under the direct tutelage of the Divine Master were weak? And Mata Bhag Kaur ji too?
On the other hand, the stronger women were in those days (and shortly after the Lord's ascension), the stronger the 5 Singh argument becomes. I.e., that even though women were strong, they still were still not appointed in and cannot be in the Punj.
So, you start out with a slok saying not to call women bad, but you end up by calling them weak.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
vichar · 23 Sep 2005
akjgreat -
jus cause some1s khalsa dnt mean they can do seva in panj
a singh who is khalsa, but has angh missing cannot do seva in panj
this ends that FALSA ARGUMENT
jugraj singh says this dnt make sense...so let me explain as simply as pos.
people have been arguing that as long as youre khalsa you can be in panj pyare
akjgreat has pointed out that one can be a khalsa, yet still be unable to be in panj (ie a singh with a missing limb)
comprende???
therefore the argument which sujjests women are allowed in panj simply because they too are khalsa, does not hold true, because just being a khalsa doesnt alone give you right to be in panj.
some people cannot admitt when theyre are WRONG
jugraj singh, please use some common sense, think before you type!
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
akjgreat · 23 Sep 2005
jugrajsingh sed-
This is illogical. HOw can you compare someone missing an ang to someone being a female?
you can compare them as follows ; both a singhnee and a singh with missing angh are khalsa, however neither can do seva in panj.
understand? or shall i right it in punjabi for you?
some things just are, can you explain why all 10 gurus were in male bodies?
can you explain why there are 5 pyare not 3, 4, 6 etc etc
why did 5 singhs give their heads, and no singhnees?
i wud like to ask you a sensible question, what if a singhnees goin through periods? you kno as well as everyone else panj must have clean clothes on, and must do isnaan before, dont you? dont you?
what if a singhnees pregnant can she still be in panj? how bout the kid, is he in the panj to?
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
akjgreat · 23 Sep 2005
budyshut, so you think its ok for singhnees to go into an amrit sanchar to prepare amrit with bloody kachere?
do you think its ok for singhs to prepare amrit if they had stained kachere?
if you thinks its ok then why do panj have isnaan before the ceremony?
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
waheguru · 23 Sep 2005
akjgreat, learn before u talk. Do you even know how women handle their menstrual cycle? This is just on the side note, nothing to do with the thread, but just asking you learn what you say. It's shameful for someone to say bloody kasheray, you make it sound as if bibia can't take care of themselves..you would not dare talk like that if you were discussing this face to face. So for the sake of sharam lehaaz, Dont talk like that again, expecially when there are bibia around.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
* · 23 Sep 2005
akjgreat, with all due respect, you have just presented absolutely the dumbest argument I have ever heard in my life. Why would a bibi have a bloody kachhera? Without being too explicit here, perhaps you could ask your wife/mother/sister what a tampon/pad is. I'm sure you too will realize that raising points about stained kachheraas is shamefully ridiculous.
In the following thread, "Singh" has outlined the process by which the Punj are selected. Please take a look and see how the gender of the candidates could possibly play any role. You'll see that gender is irrelevant. Candidates are judged solely on their jeevan, on their rehit. Singhnees that keep all the same rehit that Singhs do are just as capable of fulfilling the sevaa.
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=50487&t=50485#reply_50487
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
vichar · 23 Sep 2005
IF any of you in FAVOUR if singhNEES in PANJ, can explain to me why a SINGH with missing ANGH canNOT be in panj, then i will explain to you WHY SINGHNEES CANT BE IN PANJ
otherwise i will not bother wasting my breath.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
vichar · 23 Sep 2005
REPLY ji, you are a gangsta (slang for som1 highly respected)
why cant everyone speak TRUTH like you?
i take my bhog off in salutations............lol
sorry for praising you, i know slander and praise are equally not so great, but never mind.........i jus like the TRUTH.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
tarrandeep kaur · 23 Sep 2005
*, i am sorry but you are wrong.
<<>>>
sorry to be a bit explicit, but you do not know wen your period is going to start. in the middle of the amrit sanchar, your period cud just start. wer you will have no pads or anything, then wat?? your kacchere will be all dirty wich isnt so great.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
vivek · 23 Sep 2005
reply ji, i agree with you all the way.......you have rinsed everyone, no people have resulted in speaking jibberish.
i would never call myself waheguru even in a joke, you shud go infront of guru granth sahib and do ardas
go infront of guruji respectfully with clean kachere and ask for forgiveness.
* ji, you speak nonsense, of course it matters, you cant be in panj with bloody clothing or be it kach or tampon pad or watever
nor can a baby in a womb be in panj pyare. its just wrong
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
* · 23 Sep 2005
Tarrandeep Kaur Jee, why create such hypothetical situations? Anything could happen to anyone at anytime. What if a Singh is doing sevaa and he suddenly gets violently ill all over himself? It could happen. A Singhnee doing sevaa can prepare herself ahead of time to prevent any accidents from occurring. This really isn't an issue and I'm surprised to see a bibi arguing in favour of it. To me, this argument simply shows how desperate some people are to keep Singhnees out of Punj Pyaaray, but it really is a totally non-issue point. A bibi would typically know for herself how to prevent a dirty kachheraa situation.
Re: Sikh women In AMRIT Sanchar
Admin · 23 Sep 2005
We have decided to close this topic for now.
Admin