Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

"Cultural" Sikhs

"Cultural" Sikhs

Singh too! · 17 Oct 2003

Lately I've notice a new brand of Sikhs. These aren't fundamentalists, or orthodox or moderate, but CULTURAL Sikhs. What does this mean? Well, they usually have dastars and beards but their interest in Sikhi is not spiritual, it's cultural. They are proud of being Sikhs not because it's the greatest revelation to humanity, but because of the history and art. They organize exhibitions and display weapons and paintings or other cultural events with speakers, etc. At these events they have nice wine and pheasant dinners and try to act as cultured as possible. Bhangra is also a big part of cultural Sikhism and MUST be at all big functions. Although Sikh history and culture is amazing, I dont' understand how people can forget what drove Sikhs to do what they did: naam/bani/Guru, etc. I find that these cultural Sikhs are well educated but try to act like Westerners. They seem to have no conception of spirituality at all. Without naam/bani, how is a Sikh any different than anyone else? My advice to such people is to stop trying to make Sikhi an ethnic group and understand it's a spirtual faith. Be proud of the culture but be MORE proud of the gifts Guru Sahib gave us.

Re: "Cultural" Sikhs

sikh · 17 Oct 2003

who cares jus carry on wid your own sikhi...

Re: "Cultural" Sikhs

GPD · 17 Oct 2003

it's usually the Sikhs in the UK that are doing all of these cultural things. To them Sikhs are an ethnic group, and not a spiritual group.

Re: "Cultural" Sikhs

Singh · 17 Oct 2003

"who cares jus carry on wid your own sikhi..." What exactly do you mean by this? That what goes on in the panth and what effects the panth should be ignored by us? That we should just stick our heads in the dirt and only worry about oursevles and completely ignore anything that might affect thousands of sikh youth? Discussions are good and comments like your's don't contribute. If you don't care, then by all means, sit at home and practice your own sikhee. Don't waste your valuable bhagtee time by preaching to others about not caring.

Re: "Cultural" Sikhs

sikh · 18 Oct 2003

then i suggest get off your pc go to your local gurdwara hold a petition against this if u feel it is against ur beliefs singh. if that doesnt work, and u feel it is affecting the panth big time then i suggest u get to punjab and take the issue up with akhal takhat. i dont see what this kind of talk will do any benefit for the panth than pointing fingers, or to say they are this they shud be that, do something positive like seva. its not as if theyr gonna change, its a lil obvious for the last 20 odd years whats been going on in the uk it doesnt take much to figure that.

Re: "Cultural" Sikhs

Singh too! · 18 Oct 2003

Actually, I'm in Toronto and was talking about this trend here. I'd make a petition, but then who'd I send it to? I think the "holier than thou" attitude is not helpful. Just worry about your own sikhi....oh-kayyyy, then why do we discuss anything at all? My point was that Sikhi is not a cultural or ethnic group, it's a faith. I find it hippocritical when "Sikh" organizations have events which do blatantly anti-Sikh things like serve alcohol and meat and have things like keertan mixed with bhangra displays. What can we do? Well, I say don't support events like that and try to be aware that turning Sikhi into something cultural is counter-productive. It's like taking the spirituality out of Sikhi and turning Sikhs into a group like the Serbians or the Greeks.

Re: "Cultural" Sikhs

sikh · 18 Oct 2003

fair enuff singh im sorry maaf kardoh

Re: "Cultural" Sikhs

microphone fro · 18 Oct 2003

If they serve alcohol and meat, that doesnt sound like a Sikh gathering. It sounds more like a tea party.

Re: "Cultural" Sikhs

dalla · 18 Oct 2003

there r sum jus into culture, others part into culture partt religion, others more into religion. some parts of culture is weird n wrong ie bhangra lori rituals, outdated customs, others r right its where sikh heritage was born in punjab, within punjabi traditions, of izzat, our language, maboli, ie gorey have different set of customs where free mingling of women n men, go to a fellow gursikhs house is it right that bibia mix freely and talk about anything with singhs, like the 3rd generation of sikhs r doing in the west?. no. things were done for certrain reasons, that benefit growth of family in different ways. even in bani people are described as various with different pathways. if someone wants to drink, one day god will send a powerful message to that person, if someone eats meat, that person will give their account, we are going to give our account they theirs. the good will exist with the bad, however disheartening veer pray for positive dont condemn. theres many of us who did exactly those things many years ago. i was in college i thought going to gigs and drinking was part of sikhism nobody told me otherwise. then after enjoyment, i was taken to a new episode in life i found my own friends were not around when there was no drink, they backstabbed each other over kurris. i went down n questioned who is my tru friend? who is my tru family? one of my friends transformed gave up evberything and took amrit, i was lucky i found sangat the right way and gave up things to me which were bad, but at the time if anyone told me i wud fought tooth n nail cos i was egoistic and thought i know it all. if someone tells me oi u shudnt drink or do this its mentality u jus get up n ruck cos u aint gonna sit der n say whos right n wrong, its like whos dis man trying it? ego gets da bettr of a man. u guys r right. sikh orgs shudnt support the use of bhangra meat alcohol, but thise shud be taken directly from a higher level. when akhal takhat itself says eat it or dont eat it what these individuals in these groups gonna say? as for drink clear cut, bhangra is evil but so many amritdharis do it nowdays as well as others as if saying it dont matter we jus chilling with the crowd. lets see how they like it when its their sister amongst a crowd of drunk men.see one day dat message will come.

Re: "Cultural" Sikhs

gtroadster · 19 Oct 2003

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh do your bhagti, just forget about these groups and do ardas for our brothers and sisters to see the light through gurmat. not much else you can do unless you wanna end up with an irrate crowd ready to take your throat. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: "Cultural" Sikhs

S Singh. · 20 Oct 2003

I think that it is lack of awareness amongst Punjabi Sikh people. They cannot separate the culture from the religion. We need to bring awareness to our people.

Re: "Cultural" Sikhs

singh · 20 Oct 2003

there are good parts of culture, there are bad parts which need to be seperated. the sikh religion fits in perfectly with the good parts and contradicts the bad parts.

Re: "Cultural" Sikhs

sikh · 20 Oct 2003

Great Saints (Sants) said change your own life and by seeing you hundreds of thousands will change. People ask, “What will happen to the Khalsa Panth, the Khalsa nation?” But I ask, why are you worried about the Khalsa Panth? Worry about yourselves and the Khalsa Panth will be taken care of by God. The Khalsa Panth has the five pillars of the beloved five Panj Pyare, it has the blood of the four sons of Guru Gobind Singh Jee as the cement! People ask, “When will the Khalsa rule?” The simple answer to this question is, when we become Khalsa. But look inside yourselves, while we are doing impure things we cannot be Khalsa.