Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

can sikhs eat meat?

can sikhs eat meat?

D Kaur · 20 Sep 2005

waheyguru ji ka khalsa waheyguru ji ke fateh! I went on this sikhi website and this is what it said: "One area of prohibition that is still often debated is the injunction to refrain from eating some meats (kutha). Translations of the Guru Granth Sahib seem simply to forbid the eating of meat that has been ritually slaughtered or prepared for another religion - such as kosher or halal meat. This certainly ties in with the Gurus' aim to remove unnecessary ritual from their lives." I want thought sikhs couldnt eat meat can someone tell me if you can or not? waheyguru ji ka khalsa waheyguru ji ke fateh!

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Sakhi · 20 Sep 2005

No, sikhs should not eat meat. People have managed to translate bani to suit their desires.

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

I hate paintballing :-( · 20 Sep 2005

NO ANY TYPE OF MEAT IS NOT ALLOWED

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Singh · 20 Sep 2005

Jhatka Maas: Argument over Meat Arguments Against Meat Conversation with Akali Koar Singh The three articles against meat eating can be found under the gurmat section of this site. Please read them and if further clarification is required, you can post your questions.

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

S Singh · 20 Sep 2005

Do a search for meat. There are many previous posts on this subject.

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Harjas Kaur · 20 Sep 2005

[quote]Translations of the Guru Granth Sahib seem simply to forbid the eating of meat that has been ritually slaughtered or prepared for another religion - such as kosher or halal meat. This certainly ties in with the Gurus' aim to remove unnecessary ritual from their lives." I want thought sikhs couldnt eat meat can someone tell me if you can or not?[/quote] It's not about removing useless rituals. It's about the hypocrisy of causing suffering and death to a living being and blessing it with the name of God. If you eat meat, you ingest into your body these things. The suffering and stress of the creature as it died. The sorrow and the grief of the animal as it died. The toxins and chemiclas secreted by the fear of the animal as it died. The bacteria and viruses infesting the suffering animal, and most animals for slaughter aren't healthy, but they [i]are[/i] drugged with toxic chemicals, hormones, antibiotics, infected with fecal waste, disease etc. Without pyare, you ingest poison. One thing for sure, cancers are caused by eating meat. Karam is caused by eating meat. And the human body does not require the eating of meat for survival. You cannot eat dead things and expect to ingest health. Maybe you cannibalize some energy from the living, but it is jootha. Maya is deceptive. It packages meats in bright containers, and cooks meats in tasty sauces. But look through the illusion...what is meat? It is a corpse! What do you think Gurbani is saying? Meat is not fit to eat! Life is not something to disrespect! http://www.upc-online.org/thinking/lifeofhen.htm [quote]The greatest risk to human health in the 21st Century is the consumption of commercially produced and intensively reared meat products and the most popular diet of fast food burgers and chicken, which is considered responsible for over 80% of cancers and immunodefficencies. Numerous studies conducted worldwide support our view that a vegetarian organic diet is the one most likely to support health and well-being and least likely to negatively impact on the environment.[/quote] onHee mandai pair na rakhi-o kar sukarit Dharam kamaa-i-aa. They do not place their feet in sin, but do good deeds and live righteously in Dharma. onHee dunee-aa torhay banDhnaa ann paanee thorhaa khaa-i-aa. They burn away the bonds of the world, and eat a simple diet of grain and water. -SGGS p. 467 andaj jayraj ut-bhujaaN khaanee saytjaaNh. the four sources of creation - born of eggs, born of the womb, born of the earth and born of sweat; so mit jaanai naankaa saraaN mayraaN jantaah. oceans, mountains, and all beings - O Nanak, He alone knows their condition. naanak jant upaa-ay kai sammaalay sabhnaah. O Nanak, having created the living beings, He cherishes them all. jin kartai karnaa kee-aa chintaa bhe karnee taah. The Creator who created the creation, takes care of it as well. SGGS p. 467 ---------------------------------------------- mo ka-o kusal bataavhu ko-ee. If only someone would tell me what real happiness is! kusal kusal kartay jag binsai kusal bhee kaisay ho-ee. ||1|| rahaa-o. Speaking of happiness and joy, the world is perishing. How can happiness be found? ||1||Pause|| maatee kay kar dayvee dayvaa tis aagai jee-o dayhee. Making gods and goddesses out of clay, people sacrifice living beings to them. aisay pitar tumaaray kahee-ahi aapan kahi-aa na layhee. ||2|| Such are your dead ancestors, who cannot ask for what they want. ||2|| sarjee-o kaateh nirjee-o poojeh ant kaal ka-o bhaaree. You murder living beings and worship lifeless things; at your very last moment, you shall suffer in terrible pain. -SGGS p. 332 [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Harjas Kaur · 20 Sep 2005

What is Gurbani really saying? kal ho-ee kutay muhee khaaj ho-aa murdaar. In this Dark Age of Kali Yuga, people have faces like dogs; they eat rotting carcasses for food. koorh bol bol bha-ukanaa chookaa Dharam beechaar. They bark and speak, telling only lies; all thought of righteousness has left them. jin jeevandi-aa pat nahee mu-i-aa mandee so-ay. Those who have no honor while alive, will have an evil reputation after they die. -SGGS p. 1242 Torture and imprisonment is a terrible karam. Think of the future you create out of your own life being a part of these things. [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

... · 20 Sep 2005

no we can't its completely wrong!!!

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Jitinder Singh · 20 Sep 2005

Vahiguru Jee Ka Khalsa! Vahiguru Jee Kee Fateh! This matter has been resolved by Akaal Takht; from http://www.sikhs.org/meat.htm : Final Ruling from Akal Takht The Akal Takht represents the final authority on controversial issues concerning the Sikh Panth, in this regard the issue of meat eating has been settled. Hukamnama issued by Akal Takht Jathedar Sandhu Singh Bhaura dated February 15th 1980 that Amritdhari Sikhs can eat meat as long as it is jhatka meat and that eating meat does not go against the code of conduct, Kurehit, of the Sikhs. Thus a Sikh cannot be excommunicated for eating meat. Note that Akaal Takht did not encourage meat eating, nor did the hukamnama say that it is necessary. It simply said that there is nothing wrong with an Amritdhari Sikh - and therefore any Sikh - eating meat, as long as it is jhatka. Personally, I think this is a very sensible and healthy outcome and helps us separate from the Brahmanistic-Vedic-superstitious-unscientific practitioners that dominate Hindustan. There is a much fuller explanation given at http://www.sikhs.org/meat.htm So this question has been answered, yet you will find that most Sikhs still choose to debate it. You will probably find the same happening here. - Jitinder Singh Vahiguru Jee Ka Khalsa! Vahiguru Jee Kee Fateh! [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

reply · 20 Sep 2005

Bhenji, It seems that you have not researched the issue of meat in depth up till this point. As such, I would think you would want to refrain from eating it until you could have enough knowledge to make a decision. Basically, there are a couple of camps regarding this issue: 1) De jure (written) maryada of SGPC as currently printed (emphasis on currently): This says Sikhs may not eat Kutha and then in a footnote, it says Kutha means Halal -- meat obtained by Muslim ritual slaughter. So, basically you can eat anything that isn't Halal. This is the position of the Missionaries, some of whom don't actually eat meat personally. 2) De facto (actual) maryada of Akal Takhat: As far as I know in talking to former head Gianis, at Akal Takhat, new amritdhari Sikhs are told not to eat Halal at all and as for other meat, they could only eat if they were in a Dharam Yudh (sacred war) and if there were absolutely no other means and as a very last resort (for the purposes of Dharam Yudh only). Since the first rarely happens (most battles are just for Kam/Krodh/Lobh/Moh/Hankar) and the second is also highly unlikely in these times were abadi (population) is everywhere and wild animals are scarce, this effectively (de facto) is the same as a no meat position. 3) Modern Sikhs: They eat any and all meat. If they go to Muslim countries, they have no compunction in eating Halal meat whatsoever. If they at all believe there was an injunction given by Guru Govind Singh ji not to eat Kutha (whether that means Halal or all meat), they view it as a discardable historical relic. 4) Many (most?) Nihang Singh jathas: They believe Kutha to be Halal meat, which they don't eat. They believe eating meat was enjoined by Guru Sahib and they eat only meat slaughtered by Singhs with a jaikara. (The latter goes agaist the expansive definition of the meat kurehit as understood by pro-meat Missionaries: i.e., it is a ritual manner of slaughtering, which for them would be prohibited.) Harian Velan jatha and perhaps some others do not eat meat. Some individual Singhs do not eat meat even in meat-eating jathas. 5) Sant/dera/bandgee-types: They differ from the SGPC maryada on a number of points, including meat. They believe Kutha means all meat. Kutha is etymologically derived by them to mean anything which is kuhia, i.e., killed without mercy. They ban use of all meat and eggs. This includes AKJ and some other groups in addition to almost all deras. I think you should make your decision after due deliberation and reading all of Gurbani plus consulting with trusted Gurmukhs. I encourage you to consider that we may only have one life and we should definitely use it get spiritual benefit. There are some articles on this site regarding meat as well. [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

reply · 20 Sep 2005

Another point: Your post mentioned translations. Please don't rely on translations. Why would you want to have a third person between you and your Guru? It may be difficult, but you should definitely make the effort to be able to read Gurbani just as Guru Sahib granted it to us. Do read it all, and not just a few meat-related passages, which you probably couldn't understand without having the background of the rest of Gurbani. I will ask Guru Sahib to please encourage you to read Gurbani in my next Nitnem ardas. [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

... · 20 Sep 2005

Read the meat topic in the literature section of this website.

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Scientific · 20 Sep 2005

Jitinder SInghs point is spot on. The Akal takt mentions halal meat as being prohibited. At the vast majority of places where Amrit sachar occurs in India the panj pyaray default to this view point of the akal takt. Eating or not eating is a different point and one which is personal. If ones conscience based on animal rights and cruelty dont allow them to consume meat this is a valid reason and shouldnt be criticised. Coversely if another Sikh feels comfortable eating meat, it is technically difficult to argue against. Everyone has been down this argument a million times. Bhagat Kabir takes an overtly strong stance against meat in the Guru Granth Sahib. He has harsh words about eating fish, eggs and bhang. Yet history tells a different story which is inconsistent. Its completely undeniable that historically Sikhs have always been renowned for their almost compulsory consumption of meat. We can all cry out that history has been corrupted but the evidence is beyond doubt. Sikhs have (for right or wrong) always been known for having few if any dietary restrictions. The flip side to the argument is that there are few examples of very saintly sikhs condoning meat eating. Even non-sikh saints tend to take the vegetarian stance. The common thought in eastern spiritual philosophy is that the consumption of meat leads to spiritual imbalances which become obstacles to spiritual growth. So there is almost a dilemna between spiritual and martial ideals of this diverse panth. This dilemna to some extent can be rationalised by the idea that the Sikh panth is a pluralistic faith which is not as clear cut as one would make it out to be. It is possible that different sects(for want of a better of a word) have had different world practices' in the past. Today we see the remenants of these different sub-faiths and ways of life and make hopeless attempts to somehow rationalise them through rejection or acceptance. We accuse each other of adhering to fake religous methods. We unlease fury on each other armed with the words of the great gurus. The issue of meat is only one of many which divides this panth. We consistently detract from the ultimate objective of this great religion. If we were to be brave enough to accept that the Sikh panth is pluralistic faith which prides itself on unity through diversity then wouldnt all these issues of inconsistency just fall away leaving the true essence of the Gurus words? Just a thought. Fire away . I have my bullet proof vest on lol Scientific

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

jugroop singh · 21 Sep 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, if tomorrow the Akaal Takhat Rehit Maryada was changed to say that Bhang is ok, i would belive that to be WRONG. Akaal Takhat's role is surely to provide Panthic HukakamNamas IN-LINE with GurBani - in the case of eating murdered animals's carcasses - i believe this particular Hukam is WRONG and not in-keeping with GurMat. - does this make me 'anti-panthic'? - should we not question a Hukam that clearly deviates from GurBani? what do others think about the 'fallibility' of this particular rehit-based Hukam - 'Jhatka is ok'. i've always felt it sad that this was included but such is Siree Guru Sahib Ji's Tamasha and Bhana; it's all for a reason. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Ek Kaur · 21 Sep 2005

What gives us the right to take another life to sustain our own? If we can survive without meat... why eat it?

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Jitinder Singh · 21 Sep 2005

Vahiguru Jee Ka Khalsa! Vahiguru Jee Kee Fateh! This was not one of those hukamnamas sent on a whim by fax from the middle of Madhya Pradesh. It was a carefully considered decision, after much deliberation with numerous learned Sikhs. The current Rehit Maryada was released in 1945, having started discussions in 1929 - hardly a rash decision. Remember, this was to resolve differences within the Panth, e.g. various old rehits and rehits propounded by dera-chaudhris etc. Nobody is being forced to eat meat; it simply says that this matter is a personal choice. We are supposed to follow the decision once it is made, even if we didn't agree with this stance before. Otherwise, what is the point of an agreed Rehit Maryada or an Akal Takht? - Jitinder Singh Vahiguru Jee Ka Khalsa! Vahiguru Jee Kee Fateh!

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

harkirin kaur · 21 Sep 2005

it this what you want to eat? can we eat these suffering anamials and call it Sikhi? READ PETA INVESTIGATIONS FOR YOURSELF SEE THEIR MOVIES OF ACTUAL EVENTS THEN TELL ME IF EATING THIS IS WHAT A SIKH SHOULD BE DOING Report from PETA: AgriProcessors workers ignore the suffering of cows who are still sensible to pain after having their throats slit by the ritual slaughterer. The animals stagger and slip in blood while their tracheas dangle from their necks. PETA Investigation reveals slaughter horrors at Agriprocessors Peta asks USDA to Demand Standards for Religious Slaughter Campaign Updates PETA Launches National Ad Campaign Against AgriProcessors AgriProcessors, the world's largest glatt kosher slaughterhouse, has been ignoring the Jewish commitment to compassion and federal law by mutilating fully conscious animals, shocking them in the face, and slaughtering them in a way that has allowed many to stand and attempt to flee, even minutes after their throats had been slit. Don't think that if you don't eat kosher meat, this doesn't apply to you: Kosher slaughter is more than twice as well regulated as conventional slaughter. Also, most meat from kosher slaughterhouses is sold as conventional, not kosher meat. As PETA's previous investigations have shown, cruel treatment of animals is routine—from standard procedures like cutting horns, testicles, and beaks off without painkillers to sadism in which workers mutilate, throw, stomp on, and torture animals for kicks. At Belcross Farm in North Carolina, we videotaped a pig having her leg sawed off and her skin peeled off while she was still fully conscious. At Seaboard Farms in Guymon, Oklahoma, we found dying pigs left on freezing cement for days, pigs who were clubbed in the head, and ammonia levels so high that the animals contracted pneumonia. At Pilgrim's Pride workers smashed chickens against cement block walls, stomped on them, and ripped their legs and beaks off, while managers casually walked through the area. YOU CAN WATCH ALL THESE BY GOING TO THE PETA SITE

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Harjas Kaur · 21 Sep 2005

All the science and all the politics still have to answer in their lives and in their bodies for any wrongdoing. This "food" has a curse of suffering in it. If you don't know what is jootha, you will be eating poisons. [quote]REDUCE MEAT AND LESSEN RISK OF CANCER LONDON (Reuter) - Cancer is preventable and eating less. meat and more fruits and vegetables could reduce cases of the disease by up to 40 p.c. a year, medical experts said yesterday. "Dietary imbalance is a cause of cancer," Prof. Tony McMichael, of the University of London, told a news conference to launch a major report by the World Cancer Research Fund on nutrition and cancer. 'We are running the human biological engine on the wrong type of food," he added. http://www.houseofsteed.com/sons/meat.htm[/quote] [quote]The beef industry is one that is steeped in destructive practices, and artificial growth hormones are just one of the many sources of problems. If these hormones can leak into streams and affect fish as a side effect, imagine how they affect consumers of red meat and cow's milk! I believe that science will ultimately link prostate cancer and other forms of cancer to the intake of hormones through beef and milk. Remember: many of these hormones are banned throughout the world (Canada, the U.K., etc.) but are allowed in the U.S. only because profits took precedence over consumer health. The beef industry has problems far beyond growth hormones, of course: mad cow is now ravaging the industry. As many as 35 countries have banned the import of U.S. beef, and U.S. consumers are turning to alternative choices for dietary protein. Mad cow is no accident: it is the result of sickening practices in the beef industry, such as feeding chicken litter to cows, grinding up dead, diseased cows and feeding them to other cows, and the rampant use of antibiotics across cattle populations. I have nothing good to say about the mainstream U.S. beef industry. It is cruel, it is unclean, and if I may use the term, it is unholy. It has even been described as a holocaust against animals. http://www.newstarget.com/000672.html[/quote] [quote]Not only can red meat itself be carcinogenic, but how you prepare it can also elevate the cancer risk. Grilling under high heat (such as searing or flame-cooking meat to well- done) can release carcinogens into the meat called heterocyclicamines, which can damage cellular DNA. Poaching , stewing, microwaving , or slow low-heat cooking releases fewer carcinogens.... 5. Switch from an animal-based diet to a plant-based diet. The most compelling research linking diet to cancer are studies of groups of people who have primarily plant-based diets, for example vegetarians and Seventh Day Adventists, and who have a much, lower risk of cancer. One of the theories on the high incidence of cancer in modern times is the belief that the switch from plant based to animal based diets correlates with the increase in cancer. Plant food / less cancer correlation is primarily due to three health-promoting factors: Plants have less fat, more fiber, and more phytonutrients. Besides providing the anti-cancer properties of fiber, legumes (such as seeds, rice, soy beans, beans, and chick peas) contain anticancer properties called protease inhibitors, which have been shown to reduce the growth of breast, colon, and skin cancers in experimental animals.... THE TOP ANTI-CANCER FOODS Anti-cancer vegetables: * broccoli * brussel sprouts * cabbage * carrots * cauliflower * eggplant * green beans * kale * onions (red) * peppers * radishes * soy * squash * sweet potatoes * tomatoes * yams Anti-cancer fruits: * apricots * blueberries * grapefruit * grapes * lemons * mangoes * oranges * papayas * peaches * persimmons * strawberries, organic * tangerines Good nutrition is one of many ways you can help your body fight this daily battle. If you think of phytonutrients in plant foods as chemo-prevention, you may someday spare yourself chemotherapy. Enjoy your food and your health! Since one-third of cancers are diet related, change your diet and you drastically decrease your chances of getting cancer. http://www.askdrsears.com/html/4/T040300.asp[/quote] [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Harjas Kaur · 21 Sep 2005

Cows fed human sewage Tue, Oct 26, 1999 By Geoff Meade, European Editor, PA News in Brussels Europe's food safety Commissioner, David Byrne, was under fire today after telling Euro-MPs that he had known about the French sewage scandal for more than two months. Last night he disclosed that he had been aware since August 12 that animal feed in France was being made from human waste. Conservative Euro-MPs said they were "stunned" -- and stepped up calls on Brussels to take swift action against the French authorities. After Mr Byrne's admission to the European Parliament's environment committee, Tory MEP John Bowis said: "EU officials are taking too long to act over this latest food scare... Mr Bowis, the Conservative Euro-spokesman on the environment, went on: "The European Commission has had the power to act immediately against France and any other EU countries that are breaking the rules on animal feed. "Consumers across Europe are feeling sick at the thought of French animals being fed on excrement and sewage. The term `sludge' fails to describe the full horror of what has been going on." ...The Aberdeen University academic highlighted the potential disaster in a strong attack on the French stance over British beef, saying that meat from this country was now amongst the best and safest in the world. Asked about the implications of the sewage scandal, Prof Pennington told BBC Radio Five Live Breakfast: "This could be a re-run of the BSE problem, which started because we were recycling dead beef into beef.... German authorities have denied the reports, but Dutch health officials have admitted finding human sewage being added during the manufacture of animal feed. It is apparently perfectly normal in Holland to add sludge from slaughterhouse water-purification systems to animal feed. At one plant, it was discovered company lavatories were connected to the water system.... "Clearly, the material that these animals have been getting is potentially full of nasty bugs. It is a classic way of spreading disease by actually eating manure, not to put too fine a point on it. "It may well have been satisfactorily controlled and the bugs `may' have been killed stone dead three times over -- but to be safe they would `have' to be killed three times over." http://www.mad-cow.org/oct99_vlate_news.html[/quote] [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Harjas Kaur · 21 Sep 2005

[quote]Could meat give you Alzheimer's? August 10, 2004 The Times (London) by Jerome Burne WHEN the former agriculture minster John Gummer fed his six-year-old daughter a hamburger during the BSE crisis, it was to show that there was no risk of bovine spongiform encephalitis being passed to human beings. We now know that the same prions -or malformed proteins in the meat -that cause BSE can cause a human version known as new variant CJD, but nvCJD seems to be extremely rare. Could the Gummer hamburger, however, have posed the threat of a far more common disorder? According to a highly controversial book published next month, prions could also be the cause of Alzheimer's disease.... Waldman begins by asking: "Is Alzheimer's a new disease?" Although its cause is unknown, most accounts tend to assume that cognitive decline has always been associated with growing old. However, Waldman's review of pre-20th-century literature shows no evidence for our assumption that old age goes with mental decline. In fact, the medical definition of "senile" did not include "dementia" until 1962. Most remarkably, the number of articles on Alzheimer's disease in medical journals increased by 5,000 times between 1966 and 2000, compared with six times and four times for prostate cancer and heart disease. "It is hard to avoid the conclusion that Alzheimer's is a new disease," Waldman writes. The villain, he claims, is some sort of prion, an abnormal protein found in brain tissue which clumps together with other proteins and is responsible for certain rare neurological disorders known as "prion diseases". To begin with there is guilt by association. The similarities between Alzheimer's and prion diseases -BSE/nvCJD are not the only ones -include taking a long time to emerge, driving their victims mad and being associated with plaques and tangles in the brain. What's more, cases of nvCJD can be misdiagnosed as Alzheimer's and vice versa. Crucially, there is the fact that Alzheimer's emerged in the wake of the industrialised farming and meat-packaging production-line techniques that allowed the BSE prions to get into the food chain. Where these techniques have been introduced, first in Europe and America and more recently in the countries of the Pacific Rim, processed meat consumption has soared along with rates of Alzheimer's. Waldman points out that levels of Alzheimer's in largely vegetarian India are still very low. http://www.organicconsumers.org/madcow/alzheimers81004.cfm[/quote] [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Harjas Kaur · 21 Sep 2005

[quote]Mad Cow: worse than you think. Finally, the USDA's 1997 ban on animal products in feed for cattle, enacted in the wake of the British disaster, stops far short of what most scientists agree would prevent transmission of TSEs to human meat-eaters. Since 1997, it has been illegal for US cattle feed to contain any cattle byproducts. However, it's still legal for dead cows to be fed to non-ruminant animals, such as pigs, which can then be rendered and added to dairy bypass protein, with the prions coming along for the ride. (Pork may not be a good beef alternative for worried consumers, as most pigs are slaughtered at 30 months, well before TSE symptoms would likely show up, and "downer" pigs are regularly slaughtered for human consumption.) Experts, such as researcher Carleton Gajdusek, who studied kuru--a prion disease found in New Guineans who ate human flesh--think that chickens may represent another vector by which cow prions can infect humans, if the chickens are fed contaminated meal. http://www.organicconsumers.org/madcow/worse62204.cfm[/quote] [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Harjas Kaur · 21 Sep 2005

[quote]How do cows get the disease? The agent responsible for mad cow (and vCJD) is called a prion (pronounced pree-on.) It is a type of protein found in all mammals. When deformed, the prion creates tiny, sponge-like holes and eats away the cow's brain, which ultimately results in death.... Scientists have proven that mad cow can be transmitted through infected feed and blood, and most believe the disease can also happen spontaneously in an animal. Infected feed and blood Cows are by nature vegetarians, but the animal industry – especially large dairy operations – frequently supplement the animals' diet with meat and bone meal. In addition, calves in these large factory farm dairy operations are often separated from their mothers at birth so the milk can be used for human consumption. The calves are fed a milk replacer that often contains cow's blood. In 1997, the government banned the practice of feeding ruminant protein to other ruminants (cows are ruminants), but loopholes and enforcement problems allowed cow remains to still be fed back to cows. For example, "plate waste" from restaurants was permitted, so an unfinished steak could be fed back to cows. (Cooking does not destroy mad cow disease, nor does chemical disinfection or irradiation.) Cows could be fed ground up pigs and chickens, and those animals could have been given feed containing cow. Poultry litter, containing material such as chicken feces, feathers, sawdust and uneaten feed containing cow parts, was exempt from the feed ban and continued to be fed to the animals. How can we stop mad cow? There is no known cure or vaccine for mad cow or vCJD, and it always kills its victims. http://www.sustainabletable.org/issues/madcow/[/quote] [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Harjas Kaur · 21 Sep 2005

[quote]Finally, USA Today tackles the issue with a pointed article that questions why the FDA hasn't simply banned the use of dead cows in cattle feed. Let's face it: mad cow disease only happens when you feed dead cows to live cows. It's a sickening, inhumane practice, but it makes ranchers money, and so there's tremendous political pressure to make it happen. If you've been eating red meat all this time, hopefully you're at least a little bit shocked that you've been eating meat from cows that were fed chicken litter, and those chickens were fed dead, diseased cows containing spinal cord material that could carry mad cow disease. Knowing this, I'm not sure why any decent human being would eat beef anymore. It's technically not that different from reaching into your toilet bowl and chowing down on your own feces. http://www.newstarget.com/000664.html[/quote] [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Harjas Kaur · 21 Sep 2005

Desire to eat dead fish is killing our oceans! [quote]Covering more than two-thirds of the Earth's surface, our oceans were once thought to be an inexhaustible resource, too vast to be damaged by the actions of humans. But we have removed such huge numbers of fish and destroyed so many other kinds of sea life that we now know we have the capacity to pluck the sea bare. We have carved up our coastlines to make room for housing, hotels, roads and fish farms, and allowed our waterways to be dumping grounds for toxins and other waste. From icy seas to warm tropical waters, more than two-thirds of the world's fisheries have been fully exploited or overfished. Billions of pounds of fish each year are wasted as unwanted "bycatch" (catch tossed overboard, dead or dying, because of regulatory mandates and lack of market), and hundreds of thousands of seabirds, marine mammals, sea turtles and other marine life are also killed through destructive and inefficient fishing practices. The recent explosion in fish farming to satiate our growing appetite for seafood is polluting our coastal waters with fish waste, antibiotics and other pollutants. Runoff from farms, animal feedlots and streets has created huge "dead zones" in many bays and some estuaries, where few life forms survive. http://www.oceansalive.org/explore.cfm?subnav=oceansintrouble[/quote] [quote] Mercury is a dangerous toxin that has become widespread throughout our environment. Coal-fired power plants, waste incinerators, chlor-alkali plants, and other U.S. sources dump 150 tons of mercury per year into our air. Much of the mercury in the air returns to earth, contaminating our lakes and streams as methylmercury, a powerful neurotoxin. Methylmercury accumulates in fish, which is especially hazardous to the people and wildlife that eat these fish. In 2002, 45 states issued more than 2,000 fish consumption warnings because of mercury contamination. Advisories for mercury increased 11 percent from 2001 to 2002 (1,933 to 2,140) and increased 138 percent from 1993 to 2002 (899 to 2,140). Large predatory ocean fish, such as swordfish, shark, and large tuna, can also have dangerous levels of methylmercury. http://leahy.senate.gov/issues/environment/mercury/[/quote] [quote]What is causing HAB's? Are they a byproduct of modern pollution? Scientists are not certain what causes them, but many believe some may be linked to river-borne runoff which often includes huge quantities of waste from poultry and hog farms, as well as tons of fertilizer. Some of the most harmful blooms, like the Chesapeake Bay incident, occur in estuaries of great rivers. The giant "dead zone" phenomenon in the Gulf of Mexico off Louisiana is a case in point. Affecting an area of about 7,000 square miles, nothing lives in the water covered by this giant algal bloom. http://www.exn.ca/Stories/1998/05/22/60.asp[/quote] Algal blooms, the ocean's "dead zones" now affecting several hundred thousand miles of water and is related to sewage contamination. This creates poisons and neurotoxins which contaminate the fish. Cooking will not kill the toxins which create paralytic shellfish poisoning. Is there karam associated with wantonly killing living beings and cannabalizing our earth? You better believe it! And its completely anti-Gurmat. It is not Sikhi to support such industries and give them your dollars to eat this poison food! You will only reap the consequences in your lives and in your future. Listen to Guruji! He only wants to protect you from ingesting evil. banday chasam deedaN fanaa-ay. O human being, whatever you can see with your eyes, shall perish. duneeN-aa murdaar khurdanee gaafal havaa-ay. rahaa-o. The world eats dead carcasses, living by neglect and greed. ||Pause|| gaibaan haivaan haraam kustanee murdaar bakhoraa-ay. Like a goblin, or a beast, they kill and eat the forbidden carcasses of meat. dil kabaj kabjaa kaadro dojak sajaa-ay. ||2|| So control your urges, or else you will be seized by the Lord, and thrown into the tortures of hell. ||2|| -SGGS p. 723 [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Harjas Kaur · 21 Sep 2005

Just listen to what Gurbani says bevause it is telling you the Truth! kabeer khoob khaanaa kheechree jaa meh amrit lon. Kabeer, the dinner of beans and rice is excellent, if it is flavored with salt. hayraa rotee kaarnay galaa kataavai ka-un. ||188|| Who would cut his throat, to have meat with his bread? ||188| -SGGS p. 1374 Kabir jiya ju maarahi jor kar kahte hahi ju halaal...: Kabeer says, you kill animals by cruelty and call it sanctified food! When the Lord calls for your account, what will your condition be? -SGGS p.1375 Kabir Bhaang maashulee sura paan jo jo praanee khaahi. Teerath barat nem keeye te sabhai rasaatal jaahi: Kabeer, those mortals who consume marijuana, fish and wine — no matter what pilgrimages, fasts and rituals they follow, they will all go to hell. -SGGS p. 1377 [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

D kaur · 22 Sep 2005

Thank you for all your posts considering this point everyone has made a valid point! I no that eating meat is wrong but i just didnt know why? i dont understand the differences in hallal and kushu meat? why can some meats be acceptable but others cant? wahey ji ka khalsa wahey ji ke fateh!

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

T_SINGH · 22 Sep 2005

pyare khalsa ji wjkk wjkf Recently i viewed a short video on the Damdami Taksal. The person being interviewed in this video talks about whether sikhs can eat meat or not. Basically what the person says is that meat should never be eaten to "satisfy ones tongue." Meaning meat should never be eaten just to pleasure the tongue. This person uses numerous examples from gurbani about how bad meat is for the body and numerous examples of how an animal suffers when it is killed. Thus clarifying that eating flesh is unhealthy and very painful for the animal. However, this person mentions that "jhatka" meat can only be eaten under very crucial circumstances. I would imagine that these circumstances be VERY crucial. Furthermore, I believe once a person has reached the stage of being a true Sikh, they have no desire for meat and the and the answer to the question of being allowed to eat meat or not is very straight forward. A definite "no" bhul chuk maaf.. wjkk wjkf

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

D kaur · 22 Sep 2005

youve made a very good point there harkirin kaur!! i would like to take a look at this website in more detail what is the website? How animals are treated is horrible after people know how badly treated animals are how can they still eat the meat knowing hoe he was treated? Wahey ji ka khalsa wahey guru ji ke fateh!

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Scientific · 22 Sep 2005

Giving horrific accounts of animal abuse really detract away from the argument of meat or not. No one agrees that animal torture is fine. Of course any meat eater is going to be sickened at the site of an animal being tortured. So that makes animal torture wrong. It doesnt mean that this is the only way that meat can be prepared. Jhatka meat is meant to be prepared through a single stroke action, to an animal that has been free in its movement and oblivious to any pain. This is why sikhs dont eat halal, which is prepared through sacrificial and quite pain inflicting ways. There is a big difference between the two and writting reams of horrific animal abuse cases really doesnt justify any position. The answer is clear as Jitinder Singh has outlined. If you want to get the ok from the Akal takt it is there in writing. Denial is silly. If you want to get the ok from your soul then you have to address yourself. If you are not comfortable eating meat then that is just as acceptable as eating it. There is no argument in this case. The meat issue is given far too much weighting in sikh debate.

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Reply · 22 Sep 2005

Harjas Kaur ji, In this thread you have posited your opinions against eating meat. In another thread on a different topic, you quoted SGPC SRM, terming it as the Maryada - "Maryada says:" Yet this same maryada that you quote (SGPC Sikh Rehit Maryada) clearly states that Halal meat is the kurehit. As D Kaur ji is looking for guidance on what she should do, it would certainly help to clarify whether she will be OK by Guru ji if she follows SGPC maryada. [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Harjas Kaur · 22 Sep 2005

Personally I follow the Rehat Maryada as interpretated by the Akhand Kirtanee Jatha. A very good article with points of contention can be accessed at this link. http://akj.org/skins/default/books.php?ch=1&bookid=3&start=4 [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Common Sense · 22 Sep 2005

People use a lot of scare tactics to hit emotional buttons and to persuade others to their side. Nobody is condoning torturing and killing defenseless animals but we need to look at the whole picture before deciding one way or the other. Do you have any idea how much life is tortured, destroyed, killed and eliminated to grow fruits, grains and veggies?? Do these millions and millions of insects, chitters, birds, and small animals have any lessor of a SOUL than a chicken? Do they suffer no pain when poisons are sprayed on them mercilessly? Read about the effects of pesticides and herbicides on foods and what havoc they can create inside of human body. You should research the horrible effects of wheat and dairy allergies on human mind and body. You mentioned 'mad cow decease', remember what panic strawberries created in the US just a couple of years ago. You will stop wearing cotton if you knew what it takes to produce it these days, and what happens to the poor people who work in these cotton fields in Punjab and elsewhere. Understanding nature and circle of birth and death isn't that easy. You should read about the millions, if not billions, of sea life that mother nature destroys each and every year by perfectly natural floods and famine to keep 'balance'. I don't eat meat but I do eat non-fertile eggs (eggs that have no life in them). >>>> Mercury is a dangerous toxin that has become widespread throughout our environment. Coal-fired power plants, waste incinerators, chlor-alkali plants, and other U.S. sources dump 150 tons of mercury per year into our air. >>>> Since coal-fired power plants are destroying our environment, don't be a part of the problem and stop using electricity, lol.

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Harjinder Kaur · 23 Sep 2005

Satsriakal, It is not mentioned anywhere in Gurbaanii that its ok to eat meat in fact u will find in some angs it is sin. The problem is we people born in sikk families have been fed non veg from age one. So now it seems very difficult to leave it. Please can anyone advice me also how to stop eating nonveg. Bec i really want to leave it. Waiting for the replies. WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH. Harjinder Kaur

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Harjas Kaur · 23 Sep 2005

Just stop! Practice vegetarian cooking and tasty recipes. Go to Gurudwara more so you can eat langar. You can only do what you decide to do. You can only break temptation when you stop giving yourself permission to do what you know is wrong. As long as the mind says it's okay and finds an excuse, you will keep breaking vegan diet, you will keep ingesting toxins and chemicals, and you will keep building karam to make you sick and lose Guruji. You will stop when you really believe this and really want to. You are what you eat. [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

D kaur · 24 Sep 2005

You can only stop eatin meat if you want to if you get forced you will just turn back to eatin meat in the future! Its easier when you are born vegietarian because it is less likely you will eat meat in the future! wahey ji ka khalsa waheyguru ji ka khalsa!

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Reply · 24 Sep 2005

Harjas Kaur ji, Have you translated these verses yourself, or are you pasting from somewhere? If so, where?

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

singh · 25 Sep 2005

I believe sikhi is based on common sense, and common sense leads you to believe that eating meat is just morally wrong.

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Harjas Kaur · 26 Sep 2005

I am cutting and pasting from diff sites on the internet as I am English speaker and not Punjabi speaker. There are many sites with discussions on meat versus vegan. It's hard to get a really good interpretation of the Gurbani in English, however, in just about any translation the message is fundamentally clear. http://www.sikhitothemax.com/index.asp http://www.sikhnet.com/sggs/translation/sggstran2.html [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Bhavneet Singh · 26 Sep 2005

It has been stated by the critics that the edict in the Sikh Code of Conduct regarding meat eating is: Thou SHALT NOT EAT KOSHER MEAT. It is absolutely incorrect. The edict also does not make it obligatory to eat Jhatka meat, since it does not say 'THOU SHALT EAT JHATKA". The actual wording is "THOU SHALT NOT EAT KUTHHA". The controversy started over the interpretation of the word Kuthha. Even if for the sake of argument, it is assumed that the word Kuthha does really refer to Halaal meat, refraining from all types of meat cannot at all be considered as going against this edict because it automatically excludes eating of Halaal meat.

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

. · 26 Sep 2005

Kabir Bhaang maashulee sura paan jo jo praanee khaahi. Teerath barat nem keeye te sabhai rasaatal jaahi: Kabeer, those mortals who consume marijuana, fish and wine — no matter what pilgrimages, fasts and rituals they follow, they will all go to hell. The word Bhaang in Gurbaanee is not for marijuana but for meat. Jai Kar Sadhna Udraeaa aakheeay Jeea Ghaaay Naa Khaaeeay Bhanga (Bhaaee Sahib Bhaaee Gurdaas Jee) If Sadhna is called Liberated Then Do Not Kill Living Beings and eat their Flesh.

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Singh · 03 Oct 2005

Sikhi is about losing your ego, how can one expect to lose their ego if they claim their superiority over animals and birds by eating them?!

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

we all got names · 03 Oct 2005

do 5 hours of simran each day and keep doing it u'll get your answer

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Singha · 04 Oct 2005

D kaur wrote: > Thank you for all your posts considering this point everyone > has made a valid point! I no that eating meat is wrong but i > just didnt know why? i dont understand the differences in > hallal and kushu meat? why can some meats be acceptable but > others cant? > wahey ji ka khalsa wahey ji ke fateh! If you check you'll see that all the pro meat arguments are not based on Gurbani, and there are plenty of Gurbani based posts saying not to eat meat. Halaal and kosher meats are prepared while using inhumanemethods/ reciting muslim or jewish prayers - we are not allowed to eat by their hands. Meat is made of 5 elements and will place a heavy burden (in terms of karma) on you if you eat it, veggies are made of few elements and will not hinder the souls progress significantly. he who kills will in turn be killed.

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

khalsa · 04 Oct 2005

harjas kaur "One thing for sure, cancers are caused by eating meat". for your information malwa in punjab is known to have more cancer cases than any other part of india report published in the tribune about 2 weeks ago and the majority of these patients are women and how many of these women eat meat daily or weekly when it is very expensive in punjab. eating meat is not the main cause of cancer. anybody please explain what happened to the animals killed by guru gobind singh ji and his sikhs when they were hunting. all sikh of guru's time are known as great hunters. what about the story when guru gobind singh ji visited banda bahadur in his ashram at nander (hazoor sahib). according to mahan kosh "kutha" means hallal meat. when some one takes amrit the panj piyaree say "kutha nahi khana" they do not say "mas nahi khana".

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Baldev Singh · 05 Oct 2005

yeah, and are the eskimos who the merciful lord created and placed on the north pole doomed to the religious fanatics` eternal hell just because they need to eat fish to survive?

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Harjas Kaur · 05 Oct 2005

[quote]"One thing for sure, cancers are caused by eating meat"[/quote] I did not say [i]all[/i] cancers are caused by eating meat. And I stand by my statement. If Guruji was liberating souls from transmigration rebirth as animals, he is Guru! And how he liberates is up to him. But whether I should use this as a justification to eat meat is not a valid point. Because Guruji kills some animals does not mean I will not get cancers from eating meat which is polluted with chemicals, toxins and carcinagens. It is unclean corpse for food. Because there is some other leading cause of cancer in some city does not mean eating meat will not elevate your cancer risk. If there is something wrong in eating meat, it doesn't matter what you believe or accept or ignore. The karam will sow it's seeds in your life. So many people suffer sicknesses and don't even see the relationship between suffering they ingest from murdered animals pumped full of chemicals and hormones, fed on waste products and later diseases they develop. But the reality is evident, regardless of your opinion. These are unfortunate facts which meat eaters do not like to hear. The evidence is undeniable that diets laden with meats cause many types of cancers in the human body. [quote]Cho, an epidemiologist who studies patterns of disease as well as a nutritionist, said it is not clear how animal fat may cause cancer. "Fat intake in general has been hypothesized to increase circulating hormone levels such estrogen levels," she said. Cooked red meat contains cancer-causing agents and is also liked with colon cancer. Eating less meat and full-fat dairy can also help a woman reduce her risk of heart disease, the number one killer of both men and women in the industrialised world, Cho said. http://abc.net.au/science/news/health/HealthRepublish_903406.htm [/quote] [quote]Diet Called Most Important Breast Cancer Risk Factor A unique study of breast cancer mortality rates and dietary factors for 35 countries published January 1 in the journal Cancer presents strong evidence that diet is the most important risk factor for breast cancer. Specifically, the data from the study shows that the fraction of daily calories derived from animal products exhibits a very strong correlation with increased mortality by this cancer, while the fraction derived from vegetable products shows an equally strong correlation with a decreased mortality. This new study finally solves the mystery of why almost all such correlation type studies find a very strong link between dietary fat and the incidence of breast cancer, while other types of cancer studies, such as those involving case-control or the examination of cohorts do not show this effect. The increase is due to the fact that those females living in countries with high-fat diets generally eat a higher fraction of animal products, drink more alcoholic beverages, and eat less fish (a source of vitamin D) than those women living in countries with low-fat diets. Thus, over their lifetime, they produce more estrogen- and more insulin-like growth factor (IGF-1). Both of these compounds are known to be strong factors associated with increased risk of breast cancer, and alcohol increases the effects of estrogen... CONCLUSIONS: It is hypothesized that animal products are associated with risk for breast carcinoma because they are associated with greater amounts of insulin-like growth factor-1 and lifetime doses of estrogen. Vegetable products contain several risk reduction components including antioxidants and phytoestrogens. http://www.alkalizeforhealth.net/Lmeat.htm[/quote] [quote]WASHINGTON (CNN) -- Before you bite into that big, juicy burger, chew on this for a minute: A new study in the Journal of the American Medical Association indicates a possible link between eating red meat and some forms of cancer. A study of 35,000 older women shows those with diets high in meat and animal fat, especially hamburgers, have doubled the risk for lymph node cancer -- also known as non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. Researchers believe that eating too much animal fat and protein could contribute to the development of the disease because it overstimulates the immune system. "We know diets high in saturated fat affect the cells of the immune system and may decrease the ability of the immune system to ward off cancer," said Dr. James Cerhan of the University of Iowa. It's not clear why eating hamburgers seems to increase the risk. Researchers say it may be related to the way it's cooked. At the same time, the study suggests that eating a lot of fruit can protect against lymph node cancer. Although non-Hodgkin's lymphoma accounts for only about 3 percent of all cancers diagnosed in the United States, its incidence has increased 73 percent in the past two decades. Researchers are looking at diet as a possible explanation. http://www.cnn.com/US/9604/30/meat.cancer/[/quote] [quote] Consuming processed meats increases the risk of pancreatic cancer, says new research conducted at the University of Hawaii that followed nearly 200,000 men and women for seven years. According to lead study author Ute Nothlings, people who consumed the most processed meats (hot dogs and sausage) showed a 67% increased risk of pancreatic cancer over those who consumed little or no meat products. But researchers failed to accurately identify the culprit responsible for this increased risk of pancreatic cancer, says one author. The true cause of the heightened cancer risk is the widespread use of a carcinogenic precursor ingredient known as sodium nitrite by food processing companies, says nutritionist Mike Adams, author of the just-published Grocery Warning manual at: http://www.TruthPublishing.com/GroceryWarning.html Nearly all processed meats are made with sodium nitrite: breakfast sausage, hot dogs, jerkies, bacon, lunch meat, and even meats in canned soup products. Yet this ingredient is a precursor to highly carcinogenic nitrosamines -- potent cancer-causing chemicals that accelerate the formation and growth of cancer cells throughout the body. When consumers eat sodium nitrite in popular meat products, nitrosamines are formed in the body where they promote the growth of various cancers, including colorectal cancer and pancreatic cancer, says Adams. "Sodium nitrite is a dangerous, cancer-causing ingredient that has no place in the human food supply," he explains. The USDA actually tried to ban sodium nitrite in the 1970's, but was preempted by the meat processing industry, which relies on the ingredient as a color fixer to make foods look more visually appealing. "The meat industry uses sodium nitrite to sell more meat products at the expense of public health," says Adams. "And this new research clearly demonstrates the link between the consumption of processed meats and cancer." Pancreatic cancer isn't the only negative side effect of consuming processed meats such as hot dogs. Leukemia also skyrockets by 700% following the consumption of hot dogs. (Preston-Martin, S. et al. "N-nitroso compounds and childhood brain tumors: A case-control study." Cancer Res. 1982; 42:5240-5.) [/quote] [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Ignorant Fool · 06 Oct 2005

Of course they can.

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Harjas Kaur · 06 Oct 2005

[quote]yeah, and are the eskimos who the merciful lord created and placed on the north pole doomed to the religious fanatics` eternal hell just because they need to eat fish to survive?[/quote] I have no power to doom anyone to hell, and I don't believe hell is eternal. So you make only an insulting and outrageous statement attacking religious people because you don't like a religious opinion. As far as I know, Eskimo society does not follow Sikh traditions. And in the past many societies had to eat meat. But in this modern time, that isn't the case. Just because of necessity does not excuse karam associated with an act. You will reap the karam of all your actions. Anyone can do what they want, it's a big world. But if someone is doing something wrong, there are going to be karams associated with it. Like the famous saying, "You are punished by your sins, not so much for them." Why insult religious people? Just eat whatever you want to. No one is stopping you. If you want to bless it and make it religious activity, go ahead. But don't expect others to agree with you. Whether or not you're going to hell is something you have to talk to Guruji about. What do religious people have to do with it? That's between you and your Guru. [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

..... · 07 Oct 2005

u can eat meat if it is chatka i guess. but u cant do chatka to a fish because it is causing the animal pain to be out of the water.

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

... · 07 Oct 2005

da gurooz killed animals cuz dey hunted n dey took ppl widdem 2 hunt n kill. plus purataan sikhs depend on ppl killin goats so dey kin get da goat flesh 4 tabla skinz n stuff like dat

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

LionKing · 08 Oct 2005

Personally, I acknowledge the fact that Akal Takhat Accepted Rehit Maryada says Hallal is not allowed, and therefore some of the Sangat that is blessed with Amrit there, might be eating chatka-ed meat. I would personally say that I think it's wrong, and think the Panth needs to get together and get this out - but SLOWLY SLOWLY - I think it's wrong to say that they are not SIKHS because they eat meat - cause they've been told by Panj that they can - so I would say it's something we as a whole need to change, but saying they arn't Sikhs is wrong. Personally i see tha most historic and scripture-ic reference says halla is wrong, but what made up my mind is the Hukamnama by the Sixth Guru ( Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji) More of the Hukamnamas by Guru Ji's can be found on www.DhurKiBani.com for those interested =)

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Gurpreet Singh Cheema · 03 Feb 2006

No, for even if sikhy were to say we can eat meat would you? If you even question this then I think your not doing enought pat. Pat allows us to reach the higher states of thinking that are required for sikhs to evolve into what we long for "o waheyguru" How would you feel or reach had you been in the 8.4 million life cycle and you died because someone wanted to eat you. How would you feel to be trochered and killed against your will. To even think we have the right to harm gods creations in such a manner just to please our palets... SHAME ON ANY SIKH WHO DARE DISSRESPECT WAHEYGURU'S CREATION. YOU DARE even THINK about feasting on waheyguru's flesh. Siri Guru Arjan Dev Ji "I am a sacrifice to he who lives within his own creation.";" I alone beseech thee o mighty waheyguru" If the guru's could sacrifice them selfs for waheyguru's creation then who are we ,the guru's sikhs, to say we'd rather kill those whom god resides in. This should not even be something to question I am ashamed of sikh who'd ask this question. What sets us apart from other religions is we have a unifiyed set of moral code. Christens are lost and looking for answers because they are MUNMUK. They do not follow there religion they follow there mind. IF we want to preserve sikhi through the rest of time like the sikhs before us we have to stop this questing of the reht and stop our segregation. No one can bring an end to sikhi.... but the sikhs who question and divide us. I Get on my knees and pray to god to bring all those sikhs who have gone astray from the path of light to once again reuneit. I'm not saying don't question but question silently and look to the SGGS for the answers you long....One key not here the SGGS is writen in poetic verse and thus metaphor which means it was MEANT to be understood differently by each person who can read its prophecy. I may only be 15 but i know for a fact that if sikhi does not get back on the path to such kund we will bring upon our own demise. Like guru Nanak said there are 9 continets... but modern day geologists tell us this is not so....The 2 continents no longer exist to our eye's any more because the people whom enhabited them strayed to far from becoming spirtually inclined. Unless u want to bring the same fate upon our kind stop this heracy NOW! If i offended anyone in my post im am sorry: unjan bucha sumjkay, maf karna WJKK WJKF [%sig%]

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

uk-ute · 04 Feb 2006

kabeer bhaa(n)g maashhulee suraa paan jo jo praanee khaa(n)hi || Kabeer, those mortals who consume marijuana, fish and wine theerathh barath naem keeeae thae sabhai rasaathal jaa(n)hi ||233|| - no matter what pilgrimages, fasts and rituals they follow, they will all go to hell.

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

P walla! · 04 Feb 2006

Waheguroo....Thu Than Hai!! Eating meat is very very wrong.....ok daas thinks the point about not eating meat has been discussed!! But daas would like to make a point on the people, that eat meat and say that it makes them stronger, like chatka!! "you cant get biger and stronger then a elephant and it does not even touch meat!" Well Daas would like to say this....when in the process of harrasing the animal and killing it...other animals can see, then they look at each other!! ...they know there turn is next...they get affraid which creates hormones. So they have 'darpokh' hormones!! When there turn comes then the chatka walle eat the meat but also the hormones...making that person a 'darpokh'!! soo Daas will leave it to the sangat to decide shall we or shall we not eat darpokh meat!! Gurrrrrrrroooo Maharj jee blees us with sojhi....this is the time of kaljug we need your hand, mahraj on our heads!! Gurrrrrrrrrrooooo the rest carry on jaaping naam the darpokh walle carry on eating darpokh meat!! Gurrrrrooo

Re: can sikhs eat meat?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 05 Feb 2006

Author: uk-ute Date: 02-04-06 04:21 kabeer bhaa(n)g maashhulee suraa paan jo jo praanee khaa(n)hi || Kabeer, those mortals who consume marijuana, fish and wine theerathh barath naem keeeae thae sabhai rasaathal jaa(n)hi ||233|| - no matter what pilgrimages, fasts and rituals they follow, they will all go to hell. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< This verse is quoted umpteen times.... has anyone even stopped to consider we SIKHS..Dont have any FASTS, PILGRIMAGES and RITUALS.. ????????????