Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Two Gurus ??

Two Gurus ??

confused · 21 Sep 2005

Reading another topic on this board has brought about his question in my mind, i'm hoping learned gursikhs will be able to answer this question.. When Guru Nanak Dev Ji passed on Gurgaddi to Guru Angad Dev Ji, was Guru Nanak Dev ji still Guru ji, my thinking is, he was as it is hard to comprehend all of a sudden Guru Nanak Dev ji not being respected as Guru Ji ??? does history, Gurbani say anything on this ???? Also there is the histroical fact of Guru Harkishan Ji and Baba Bakala, Guruship wasn't passed on at the same time so what happended in terms of Gurgaddi being passed on ??? PLease take this question seriously as it is important for me to understand this topic.... Vahegurujikakhalsa,Vahegurujikifateh...

Re: Two Gurus ??

Confused Khalsa · 21 Sep 2005

the jot of guru nanak dev ji went into guru angad dev ji. the outer body was different but within it was the same person/light/jot. so there is only ever one guru at a time. Sabh Sikhan ko Hukam Hai, Guru Manaio Granth!

Re: Two Gurus ??

Guru-Charan-Preet Kaur · 21 Sep 2005

imho..nothing to be confused about. GURUSHIP rests only with ONE at any material time. During GURU NANAK JI SAHIB's life time.... we had Bhai Lehna Ji, Bhai Amardass Ji, and Bhai Jethaa JI alive..BUT ONLY GURU NANAK JI SAHIB were GURU. When Guru Nanak ji passed on Guruship to Guru Angad Ji...then ONLY GURU ANGAD JI were GURU. When Guru Amardass Ji were GURU, we had Bhai Jetha Ji.. When GURU RAMDASS JI were GURU..we had Arjun Ji When GURU ARJUN JI went off to be sacrificed he passed on Gurusuhip to GURU HARGOBIND JI SAHIB.. When Guru hargobind Ji were GURU, we had Har Rai Ji... Teg bahadur Ji.. BUT at any one time ONLY ONE IS GURU. The IMPORTANT POINT toi understand is that GURUSHIP is NOT the HUMAN BODY.... its the GURU-JYOT...So even if there are More than one GURU-BODIES walking about..ONLY One has the GURU-JYOT..and that is the GURU. Once you understand thsi point about the HUMAN BODY being NOT IMPORTANT..you will NEVER fall for the SANT/BABA TRAP....of "worshipping" the Human DEH...matha teking to them and stuff. IF they Tell you to DISREGARD their body and join with GURU GRANTH JYOT..then its OK...but if they encourage to matha tek to their FEET, massage their Legs, Give them GIFTs...like the infamous baba ranjit singh has found to his extreme displeasure..... then its a TRAP..run as far away as possible.

Re: Two Gurus ??

walking the path... · 21 Sep 2005

Good question.... sorry i dont know the answer but i too would like to know???

Re: Two Gurus ??

A Singh · 21 Sep 2005

imho, The Gurus are Gurus, full stop. There is ONE jot in all, however saying that with the passing of the Gurgaddi, that the predecessor is no longer a Guru seems a little flawed - for instance, if Guru Gobind Singh was to come back today, would you not treat him as a Guru? Would you, like some people suggest, view them as only Sants and Babas in the presence of the Guru Granth Sahib?

Re: Two Gurus ??

singh · 21 Sep 2005

How many swaroops of Guru Granth Sahib are there on this earth? You can't say only one of them is Guru. Same with Guru Nanak Sahib and Guru Angad Sahib in that time.

Re: Two Gurus ??

singh · 21 Sep 2005

A singh ji, very good post. I bet you some people will treat siri guru gobind singh ji as mere singh, gurmukh if he were to come today.

Re: Two Gurus ??

moorakh · 21 Sep 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh! i agree with the post by singh, above. there are many lareevaar suroops of guru granth sahib jee maharaaj - they are different suroops but ONE jyot in the same way the different "cholas" or "jaamaas" or "human bodies" were more than one, but the jyot is ONE the gurgadhi ceremony is not something "flimsy" that as soon as one Guru Sahib passed the Guru-jyot to the next Guru Sahib, that the previous Gurgadhi became NULL ! Does that mean we should call only Guru Granth Sahib ji as Guru and all of the previous Gurus are NULL - back to "Baba" ? NO - they had Guru-jyot from their Gurgadhi until their "Jyoti Jyot" and still now they are HERE in their 10 different suroops but ONE jyot and their 11th suroop is the most powerful and has the strength of them all , that is why guru granth sahib ji is the highest - even in the amrit sanchar when punj pyare are in hajoori of guru granth sahib ji, then punj pyare = guru gobind singh ji and guru granth sahib ji = guru granth sahib ji BUT guru granth sahib ji is ultimately higher, because even punj pyare tell you to keep your "dhiaan" on guru granth sahib ji, but punj pyare are still suroop of guru gobind singh ji and they are treated like guru and when guru arjan dev ji did prakash of aad granth sahib ji at harimandir sahib, guru arjan dev ji sat LOWER guru arjan dev ji was GURU, but already the BANI was ultimate about the Baba Bakala question --- this is my humble benti please do not think that this was a mistake or a flaw. it was hukam. the human body that sri guru harkrishan ji was in, became inflicted with small pox, and the soul of sri guru harkrishan ji had to depart from that body. the guru-light was still there. and since divine illuminated gurmukh souls are capable of being in two or more places at one time, baba tegh bahadur ji was doing bhagti under the ground and his physical body could not be removed from there because it was in hukam for him to do bhagti so sri guru harkrishan ji did the gurgadhi ceremony at their home and baba tegh bahadur ji became GURU tegh bahadur ji at their home in Bakala when sri guru harkrishan ji was doing the gurgadhi ceremony, Baba Tegh Bahadur ji's SOUL must have been there in front of guru harkrishan ji. and the JYOT of akaal purakh does not have limitations so it could travel from sri guru harkrishan ji into sri guru tegh bahadur ji. the bodies were two but the soul was one same with guru angad dev ji and guru nanak dev ji If that was not the case then why was he called *ANG*ad they were inseperable. same guru-jyot, different human bodies. please forgive my mistakes waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh!

Re: Two Gurus ??

. · 21 Sep 2005

from one light another can be lit the first light will not go out

Re: Two Gurus ??

singh · 21 Sep 2005

Author Moorakh Ji wrote: "and their 11th suroop is the most powerful and has the strength of them all , that is why guru granth sahib ji is the highest - even in the amrit sanchar" I think you will agree the 11th swaroon is the same as the other 10 swaroops. None of the swaroops are either more or less powerful in spirit than one another. Each Guru is Guru - not less not more. Puran Jyot. 5 Pyare tell us to put dhayaan on Guru Granth Sahib Ji so we don't make the mistake of thinking of 5 individuals as being our Gurus (individually) - Guru Gobind Singh Ji also told us "Guru Manyo Granth."

Re: Two Gurus ??

Maybe · 21 Sep 2005

like Nirankaar, Guruji can also be Ik and Anek at the same time. these are mysteries beyond most people's comprehension... what i;ve learned from Gursikhs of the Taksal, is that it was Guruji's play when he was both Guru Nanak and Bhai Lehnaa...to the outside world it appeared that it was "Bhai Lehnaaa" "learning" from Guru Nanak...infact it was all a play by Guru ji. he was both. and when the jot was passed to Bhai Lehnaa (Guru Angad Dev ji)...Guru Nanak didn't become just a body without the jot....see what i mean....but to the outside world, of course they had to show that officially the transfer had happened... hope that made a tiny bit a sense, cause it's hard expressing it... bhul chuk maafi from Guruji and Sangat if i've misinterpreted anything.

Re: Two Gurus ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 22 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. I agree with everybody's views...Guru Ji di Kala Guru Ji hee jaanann. But there is this to consider. When Gurgadhee is "passed" on to the next Guru..then ONLY was GURBANI uchared by that GURU JI. When Guru nanak ji sahib were GURU...they wrote GURBANI and passed that Kitab on to Guru Angad Ji sahib. IMHO after that moment GURU NANAK JI sahib DID NOT Uchaar any Gurbani. Similarly Guru Amardass Ji DID NOT begin writing any gurbani until He was GURU. ONLY a GURU can write Gurbani. The point about a Candle not going out just becasue another candle is lighted from it is FLAWED. A NEW FRESH candle is LIGHTED only when the PREVIOUS CANDLE is nearing its END. Thus it is a historical Fact that GURU NANAK JI SAHIB passed on to NIRANKAAREE ABODE SACH KHAND soon after He had passed on gurgadhi to Guru Angad Ji Sahib. So for the World there was ONLY the ONE CANDLE of Guru angad Ji !!!...and this was the way it happened with each succeeding Guru Ji. This Kala was shown by Guur Ji for this World.... we are not able to understand much. Such questions are actually called Rirrking water....nothing will coem out of it.

Re: Two Gurus ??

singh · 23 Sep 2005

Perhaps there is a difference between Jot and Gurgaddi?

Re: Two Gurus ??

Benti · 23 Sep 2005

no offence gyani ji, how much water have you rirrked in the past, the post on sarovar were questioning, fair enough you've changed your mind there, it seems you change your mind quite regularl according to whatever tapoban write, you were a very ardent believer that Bhai Gurdas Jis bani was mis represented but after debate you changed your mind on that, personally i think this is a valid question, i have learn't much from sangats replies, your reply also opened a new way of thinking.

Re: Two Gurus ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 23 Sep 2005

Author: Benti Date: 09-23-05 16:47 no offence gyani ji, how much water have you rirrked in the past, the post on sarovar were questioning, fair enough you've changed your mind there, it seems you change your mind quite regularl according to whatever tapoban write, you were a very ardent believer that Bhai Gurdas Jis bani was mis represented but after debate you changed your mind on that, personally i think this is a valid question, i have learn't much from sangats replies, your reply also opened a new way of thinking. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Dear benti Jio, You seem to be very annoyed that i "change my mind very often". That my friend shows that I am a genuine SIKH..a LEARNER...for LIFE. What can I do when I have been PROVED WRONG ?? Thus I MUST Change my mind..or are you suggesting that i stubbornly carry on Main Na Manoo...main na manoo..whining. I am sorry to disappoint..thats not my style. And TAPOBAN WRITE ?? you suggest that this is some magic wand that changes my mind for me....well Prof Sahib Singh jis Darpan changed a lot of my mind for me scores of times..so did Bhai Veer Singh Jis Teeka..and Guru nanaK Guru Dasmesh Chamatkaar series of his books...just becasue some posters on Tapoban Forum may be "just youngsters".....doesnt preclude them being RIGHT and ME WRONG on some topics....especailly when backed up by GURBANI VICHAAR. I dont feel at all "small" or "intimidated" when a teenager/ youngher person proves me WRONG...no skin off my back. MY White Dharra is no guarantee of being "always RIGHT". Heck i even "learned" a few things from Kala Afghana ( maybe MORE than A few !!)..AND ALSO MANY Fine points about Gur Itihass and Gurbani Vichaar from even mohinder Singh SDO..NO BODY is 100% BAD or GOOD. That is an attribute of GURU JI ONLY. Bhullan a ndhar sabh ko abhull GURU Kartaar. Bhul Chuk Maaf. I am still LEARNING..from anyone who can TEACH ME... as per GURBANI. no holds barred.

Re: Two Gurus ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 24 Sep 2005

another take on Panee rirrkanna.... I just came back from an ankhand paath raol and this shabd about panee rrirrkanna came up. What I understood was that IF..panee rirrkanna gets one a TIKKEE of GHIO in the end it is satisfactory...so all my pannee rirrkann on the Sarovar/Bhai gurdass Ji bani....ended up in me getting a ghee tikee... so i am satisfied. As far as this Question of TWO GURUS or ONE is concerned....WHAT are we possibly going to get out of it. Just for argument's sake IF it is proved that there were in fact 11 GURU JYOTS all present at any one time..or just ONR GURU JYOT on the Gurgadhi....HOW does this INFORMATION improve our Gurbani vichaar/Jeewan/rehit/etc. ? Are we better SIKHS if there were 11 Gurus as compared to just one GURU...or the other way around ?/ Thsi si hwat i eamnt by Panee Rirrkanna...there will be no worthwhile result..this question can go either way....with no effect on our PRESENT SIKHI/JEEWAN/REHIT etc.

Re: Two Gurus ??

Benti · 25 Sep 2005

that can be said about all questions on this board, there is never really any effect other than the mind deciding I accept this or that, I am surprised that you are willing to accept vichars from kala afgana and sdo, for me and prob many others these people are bemukhs from the guru, why would you accpet their views ??? or anything the may have to say ??? again each to their own but it seems as though you would accept things from people who are classed as anti panthic and totally rip up those who in their way try and bring sikhi back to panth, again as you say no one is 100% perfect....

Re: Two Gurus ??

Confused Khalsa · 25 Sep 2005

"Then Gurgadhee is "passed" on to the next Guru..then ONLY was GURBANI uchared by that GURU JI. When Guru nanak ji sahib were GURU...they wrote GURBANI and passed that Kitab on to Guru Angad Ji sahib. IMHO after that moment GURU NANAK JI sahib DID NOT Uchaar any Gurbani. Similarly Guru Amardass Ji DID NOT begin writing any gurbani until He was GURU. ONLY a GURU can write Gurbani." Gyani Arshi Ji, this isnt necessarily true. For example, Shabd Hazare. This bani was written by Arjan (later to become Guru Arjan Dev Ji) but when he wrote it he was not Guru - and yet it is bani. As far as this Question of TWO GURUS or ONE is concerned....WHAT are we possibly going to get out of it. Just for argument's sake IF it is proved that there were in fact 11 GURU JYOTS all present at any one time..or just ONR GURU JYOT on the Gurgadhi....HOW does this INFORMATION improve our Gurbani vichaar/Jeewan/rehit/etc. This however is awesome, really does end many comments/threads on this forum. So many times we ask questions that will have no real effect on anything or anyone. These are just random ideas our minds spew up, and on many occasions they actually take us away from thinking about Vaheguru. VAHEGURUUUUUUUUUUUUU!!!!!!!!