Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

very interesting and very well articulated

very interesting and very well articulated

manjit · 22 Sep 2005

Check this out - it's very interesting and very well articulated: http://www.bethecause.org/wordpress/?p=117 Posted by Sukh on January 27th 2002 Ik Onkar. Satnam. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa. Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. “There is no such thing as a Hindu or a Muslim, there is only one religion: Humanity” – Guru Nanak Dev Ji. There have been many spiritual teachers that each have prescribed a path of unity to us all. Each teaching us that there is no reason to divide us as humans. To live as one, to live as truth, to live as love. So why do my Sikh leaders always ask me why I trim my beard, or why I don’t wear a turban. Why do they state that I have to become a Sikh because of what Islamic extremists did to “our” people hundreds of years ago? Don’t they understand that my people are all people. Don’t they understand that my soul has no religion, that my soul knows no history. Before I was born, I was not a Sikh concerned about the welfare of the religion, before I was born I was with God, who knows no Muslim, Sikh, Christian, Jew, or Hindu religions. My history is God. If my goal is to be as close to God as possible, then my religion is meditation and community service, my religion is kindness, love and unity. And understand this my Sikh brethren, Guru Nanak Dev Ji had no religion. He was at one with God. Do not become a member of the Sikh religion but rather become a Student of the 11 Great Gurus, hence become a Sikh, a Philomath. Understanding the Gurus requires an understanding of what was irrational with the world at the time of their existence and an understanding of what they did to change that irrational behavior. The question to ponder now is not whether we are Sikhs or not, but whether we are still on the same path that the Gurus were on. Do we still look at the world and try to correct the injustices, the inconsistencies, the inequalities that plague this world of ours? What would Nanak do if he were alive today… and would we follow him? The beauty of Nanak, and all of the 10 living Guru’s, was not the religion that we started in their name, but the purpose of their existence. They questioned everything and attacked the real issues and problems that infested the societies they lived in. Great Students of Nanak, ask yourself this: if Nanak existed today would he care whether his followers sat on floors during the free langar (lunch), or would he be more concerned with women’s continuous plight for equality, the rights of the poverty stricken, and the rights of all people to worship as they please? Would he be more concerned about people trimming their beards or the fact that 1/5th of the earth’s population doesn’t have access to clean drinking water, the fact that every year thousands of young Asian girls are unwillingly forced into a life of prostitution, or the fact that world peace is not considered a realistic possibility? The fact that after 500 years of his teachings on love his so-called followers kill each other because of disagreements on where to eat lunch, the fact that after speaking out against the caste system in the Hindu religion his Sikh followers have created one of their own. Great Students of Nanak, what would Nanak be concerned about today, and what do you find yourself concerned about. If Guru Gobind Singh Ji were alive today, what would he be concerned with. I gather that he would take up sword against the rich corrupt tyrants that keep the poor in their current status. He would fight the system that keeps things the way they are. He would fight the hate that exists in all of our hearts. What do you concern yourself with? What do you take up arms against? Chughzy’s Beard. A Sikh is someone who is constantly learning, constantly meditating, and constantly doing community service. Wearing a turban does not mean that you are no longer inflicted by the five deadly sins our scriptures speak of. Wearing a turban does not mean that you can hide behind your uniform and sneak your way into God’s arms. Watch for the ego that comes with wearing turbans, the automatic assumption that you are closer to God as a result of your headdress. You have created an all new caste system, with the Sikhs again divided, the turban wearers at a higher class than the cuttsurdhs. Great followers of Nanak, question everything. Ask yourself why hair is to be kept uncut. Hair is a God given gift so one should not trim God’s gift. But what about your Liver? Is your liver provided by the devil thus making it acceptable to drink oneself into a state of retardation? And your digestive system, your heart, your bones, all provided by the devil, so is it okay to neglect your health? Work 12 hour days, neglect your wife and your kids… because they are not God’s gifts… and when you ulcer acts up because you are too greedy, remember, do not trim your beard. Wearing a turban does not mean that you have given into all of your Guru’s wishes. Your Guru’s wishes go beyond just uniform. Hair is a God given gift, as is everything else. Treat everything and everyone with respect. Treat your hair with respect, clean it, don’t cut it, but don’t turn it into a commercialized commodity either. Do it because you believe in the philosophy and follow the philosophy. Know that the uniform you wear is a uniform of sainthood. Know that it is essential to be a saint on the inside before you gavintly display your affections of the almighty to the public. All uniforms from all societies are granted, they are a privilege to wear. Police officers have to graduate from their academy before they are put into their costumes. Judges have to first become veteran lawyers before they can wear their robes to court. Similarly, in order to obtain the divine grant to wear the Sikh uniform you must have an understanding of what a Sikh is, what she believes in, and what she stands for. Most non-Sikhs don’t understand why you wear turbans.. they need to be educated. Most Sikhs themselves don’t understand why they wear turbans, they shouldn’t. Ask yourself why you do the things you do. If your response is that it was written; If your entire purpose of doing something is that it was written some hundreds of years ago; If it is because your parents implore you; If it is because it is the way it is, or because of your culture or society: Then know that you are not a Sikh/Learner/Student, you are a Follower. Keep your hair because you believe that God can create a more beautiful face for you than you can for yourself. Believe that you wear your turban out of respect. The Gurus didn’t teach us how to wear turbans, they taught us how to recognize injustices and how to fight for a unified world focused on God’s glorious energy. Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. Victory will belong to God. – Chughzy

Re: very interesting and very well articulated

Jasmin · 22 Sep 2005

This is beautifully written and well articulated. Contains much truth. Yet why do I think the author is bending over backward to find an elaborate exuse for bread trimming and not wearing a turban? Maybe he should admit to these short comings, instead of ennobling them, with award winning articles. Just my gut feelings. I don't mean to be too negative, the article makes a lot of very valid relevant points.

Re: very interesting and very well articulated

chughzy da mama · 22 Sep 2005

this person in his writing has seemingly separated guru nanak and guru gobind singh, as though they and their teachings were seprate entities. his writing skills are decent at best, manjit should not flatter him. however, his knowledge of gurbani is limited, and it shows. he is picking and choosing certain aspects of sikhi and moulding them to justify his points, but does not mention the other aspects of sikhi which are not mentioned with the parts he has carefully selected, thus making his argument void. "Great followers of Nanak, question everything. Ask yourself why hair is to be kept uncut. Hair is a God given gift so one should not trim God’s gift. But what about your Liver?.................… and when you ulcer acts up because you are too greedy, remember, do not trim your beard. Wearing a turban does not mean that you have given into all of your Guru’s wishes. Your Guru’s wishes go beyond just uniform." This quote from his essay makes it extremely clear his lack of knowledge of sikhi and gurbani. these questions he poses, in trying to somehow inform the sangat on some type of new 'discovery' or 'glitch' in sikhi, can be answered thousands of times in gurbani. Yet, his stupidity does not realize that these questions have been asked before and answered countless times. he is not the first to ask such ignorant and absurd questions in order to 'stump' sikhi, sangatji, and unfortunately he wont be the last. this man is looking for attention to somehow boost his ego that he has uncovered the 'secrets' to prove gurbani wrong, which is laughable, yet insulting to me at the same time. If you want to cut your hair, cut it. If you want to live your life a certain way, live it. If you want to promote, noone is stopping you. But, do not try to twist and contort bani to convert or encourage your lifestyle. Being a Sikh is defined by the guru, not a chughzy. This person has taken such time and effort into writing this, but for what reason? Is he trying to start a revolution against gurbani, against sikhi? I dont understand. What causes a person to write such nonsense and unintelligent work is beyond my belief. Sitting behind a computer screen he is brave and courageous, but if encountered by a Singh face to face, the coward shall kneel. Where will your ego be then? your clever tricks or cowardice to humiliate gurbani will not help you. If Chugzhy is reading this write now, please, do yourself and the whole literary community a favour and rethink what you write and grow up. Not that im saying dont write. If you feel you have something to say, by all means say it, but do not write something that has no base, and about something which you have done absolutely no research on and have absolutley no knowledge about. the sangat should ignore this person.

Re: very interesting and very well articulated

... · 22 Sep 2005

“There is no such thing as a Hindu or a Muslim, there is only one religion: Humanity” – Guru Nanak Dev Ji. Really?? Guru Nanak?? With such an important and far reaching statement, it must be recorded in Guru Granth Sahib? Which ang? It's not there. Bhai Gurdas has already told us that “the Guru has created the mighty Gurmukh panth. This panth keeps itself away from the boundaries of the Vedas and the Semitic scriptures." >>>> "The Gurus didn’t teach us how to wear turbans, they taught us how to recognize injustices and how to fight for a unified world focused on God’s glorious energy." >>>> No...actually he DID teach us to wear turbans. He was quite clear on the fact actually. Guru Nanak to Guru Gobind Singh were one jot and they had a lot more in mind than creating just social activists out to fight injustice. That's a definite part of it. But the main focus is Naam and spirituality. Only a naam abhyasi can be a social activist anyways. The rest are confused and don't know the truth.

Re: very interesting and very well articulated

Jasmin · 22 Sep 2005

Glad I went with my gut feelings on this post. Seemed like clever and pretty double talk. Maybe I was to polite in my prior post.

Re: very interesting and very well articulated

daas · 22 Sep 2005

just the same old story again .. manmukhs trying to justify their shortcomings... Dhrm Raee Jb Leykha Mageh Keaa Mukh Leh Keh Jahega | When the Righteous Judge of Dharma calls for your account, what face will you show Him then? waheguru

Re: very interesting and very well articulated

RoopKaur · 22 Sep 2005

These types of flimsy arguments to follow manmat are encountered everywhere. The main point people make is, it is all in the heart, I dont need to amrit shuck or keep my hair or wear panj kakaars, because I love guru ji in my heart. But what I wonder is, if you love guru ji so much, and rehit is pyaee to guru ji, how can it not be pyaree to you? The reason we do not keep rehit is because we do not fear guru ji, and until we start fearing guru ji and Akaal Purkh, we cannot develop love for them. Also, this person advises us to question everything. It is ok to question, but a Sikh needs no other reason to keep rehit except that guru ji told us to do it. Eventually the rest of the "modern" world will catch up to what guru ji has advised his Sikhs. For example, guru ji stopped us from smoking and alcohol hundreds of years before, and now the world is only beginning to realise the damages these evils do to us. Same thing will happen will all rehits of guru ji, eventually the rest of the world will have to catch up with our guru ji. So why need to question our guru ji, who was all knowing? If this makes you a follower, so what, what is wrong with being a follower of rehit? I see nothing wrong in this. If we read Bhai Gurdaas Ji's vaaraa, we find the Sakhi where guru ji dissapeared for three days into the Beas river, where guru ji went to Akaal Purkh and got Naam to give to his followers. This clearly shows that Akaal Purkh Himself has sent guru ji on this earth to give Sikhs his Naam and free them from this world of maya. How can we say Akaal Purkh knows no religion when Sikhi comes straight from Akaal Purkh. Also, our bani is Dhur kee, which means it also came straight from Akaal Purkh. All that poetic language about my soul having no religions is very beautiful, but unfortunately has no basis in bani. I think the main problem for this is the Apologetic ideology that the panth has started to follow. We have started compromising on our ideals, on our beleifs and our way of living just so we can be accepted by others, just to please others. But when will we start working to please guru ji?

Re: very interesting and very well articulated

chughzy da mama · 22 Sep 2005

chugzy did one thing positive though, he let us know there are still many stupid people out there...

Re: very interesting and very well articulated

Manjit · 28 Sep 2005

After reading your comments and then re-reading the article again I can kind of identify with both the writer of the article and the people who have commented on it. There are some parts of the article that are either inaccurate or not well researched. But when I first read the article the things that came to my mind, were that I need to be more accepting of people and less judgmental. And when I say that, I don't mean that I should change any thing about sikhi, e.g. like keeping full kesh. I just mean that I should try to be abit kinder and more understanding of other peoples positions ( even if I don’t agree with them). Not everyone has realised what sikhi is and not everyone has the same point of view. What I'm trying to say is that when I first read the article I thought back to the days when I first started to learn about sikhi and the principles I learn about sikhi then. They attracted me to sikhi, principles like kindness humility and treating everyone with love and respect. One of the things that I’ve noticed about my self as I’ve got more involvd in sikhi is that I have started to practice those principles less and less, which means I am loosing one of the things that is going to help my manmuk mind. Some of the people I met in the early days showed me so much kindness and acceptance ... wow ..... they are the ones who helped me come towards sikhi with their acceptance, (even though I didn't have a clue and I questioned everything). If they hadn’t of been so generous and kind who knows...... It's their gentle guidance that has spurred me on to find out more about sikhi and eventually keep my kesh recently.

Re: very interesting and very well articulated

thekedaar · 29 Sep 2005

manjit and chugzy are right we shouldnt be so judgemental as sikhs of the guru - the "judgementalism" of the sikhs is increasing day by day - we always want to pick the faults of others, and forget the spirit within us. we are so quick to judge the actions of others as Manmat, when we do not even know the persons involved, nor do we know the intentions with which they do certain actions. we not going to reach waheguru by criticising others, but discovering Him within us. once that spirit has been discovered within us, the Mehak or Fragrance of love for the Guru will rub itself on others - they'll beg to live on the Gurmat path - we need to stop judging people and do more loving!!! we must live by the rehits prescribed by the gurus, so chugzy is wrong to justify his trimming of beard, but as a whole, amritdharis need to be less prescriptive in their parchaar. ppl will be persudaed by love not prescription. amritdharis need to be less judgemental!!!

Re: very interesting and very well articulated

desidalip · 29 Sep 2005

This post is in response to "chughzy da mama" and his comments. Not that I support the posted article, but your arguments are not relevant at all. You used what are called ad hominem arguments; that is you attacked the writer of the article rather than the very clear arguments he presents. For example, Quote: "he is not the first to ask such ignorant and absurd questions in order to 'stump' sikhi, sangatji, and unfortunately he wont be the last. " Let's analyze what you say here. First, you call his questions ignorant and absurd as a means of demeaning him; however, you fail to tell us why they are absurd or why they are ignorant. Perhaps on religious matters you are willing to accept arguments on faith; but most rational human beings would need a justification of these arguments (usually with logic or evidence). One these two grounds your argument is void. Second, you attack the author. Granted, he may be ignorant, he may be an evil person, in fact he may even be the world's most evil person in the history of the world...but that does not diminish his arguments. Those if based on sound reasoning would hold true. For example, if I said the earth was round, that would be a true statement. I may be ignorant of the specifics of geology or astronomy or science in general but if I support the argument with reasonable arguments it still holds true. Another example would be you. Let's say hypothetically that Adolf Hitler (an evil man no doubt) said that war was wrong because people were harmed. Calling him an evil man would have no effect on his argument. Therefore, attacking the author of a claim or argument is simply wasted bandwith on this message board. It does hurt to see people respond so defensively to the idea that we should all try to be better people rather than prove our superiority with external symbols. Unfortunately, it seems (and many of this thread in particular) have so much invested in the symbols of Sikhism that they can't see the forest in the trees. For example, in this thread rather than agree with certain points most (with notable exception of manjit and thekedaar) have just attacked ruthlessly. I would suggest that human beings have been given the gift of rationality by God. The ability to reason and evaluate arguments based on rationality is a pure expression of that gift which no other of God's creations (i.e. animals, plants, rocks, etc) possess. I suggest we all (myself included) try to use it more often.

Re: very interesting and very well articulated

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 30 Sep 2005

This man is not "stupid" or "ignorant"...in fact he is a PHD holder based around Toronto....and it is his life long mission to "attack" Khande Batte de Pahul, Kesh, Kakaars..on all SIKH Forums. He has been doing it for the past 15 years ever since the internet first began....Every Single Person whose Bnai is in the GURU GRANTH JI had untrimmed Hair as Guru Ji would never allow anyone that contravenes this Basic Principle of Sabat soorat Raab dee bhanne beimaan to be included in Guur Granth ji. Secondly Guur Granth Ji is ample proof that Guru nanak Ji - Guur Gobind Singh ji JYOT is One and the SAME. Jarnail Singh.

Re: very interesting and very well articulated

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 01 Oct 2005

I recived this private mail form the writer of this article.. Shows his "maturity" and articulation..very well indeed... Sukhdeep Singh to me More options 1:55 am (16 hours ago) Ive read your posts on Tapoban.org and I am quite amused. Your narrowminded views of Sikhi really turn me off, not to mention your judgemental characteristic. You in no way sound chardi kala when describing the state of the Guroo Khhalsaa Panth. Your posts sound as if you are 8 years old. Please put some thought before posting whatever you feel. -- Vahiguroo Ji Ka Khhalsa!!, Vahiguroo Ji Ki Fatey!!! Dal Panth Ka Daas SukhdeepSingh

Re: very interesting and very well articulated

Jasmin · 01 Oct 2005

Dear Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Thanks for the warning, I thought it was "fishy". WjkkWjkf