Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Gurpreet Kaur · 24 Sep 2005

>>>Another extract from Sicques, Tigers Or Thieves! Since the Sikhs have beomce powerful, and confederated for the purpose of conquest, they have called their conferancy Khalsa Gee, or the State, and their grand army Dull Khalsa Gee or the Army of the State. As the extent of their possessions is clearly expressed in the accompanying map as well as the names of their chiefs, and the number of ther forces from the best authorities, I shall only observe, that the country is said to be in high cultivation, which I believe, because they carry into all cattle it for tillage, which come into their possession by plunder, collect a very moderate rent, and mostly in kind, and during any intestine disputes, their soldiery never molest the husbandman. Trade however, is in a low state, owing to the insecurity of merchants going backward and forwards through the territories of so manyindependantt chiefs. Of their manufactures, the prinicipal are very fine cloth, which they make in Lahore ,as also the best arms in Hindostan. Their cavalry is remarkably good, the men being very hardy and well armed with sabres and excellent matchlocks, which they use with great dexterity; the horses bred in their country are of one of the best breeds in the empire, owing to the use formerly made there of Arabian and Persian stallion, and something in the temperature of the air and water of that country. Most of these soldiers have two or three horses each, by which means their incursions are mde with great rapidity, their armies marching from fifty to one hundred and twenty miles a day; - their dress is dark blue, as ordered by Gooroo Gobind and gives them, when collected in large bodies together, a very dismal appearance. The chiefs are only distinguishable from their followers, by finer horses and arms. I have conversed with several Sicks, who were sent to me by different chiefs on complimentayy messages; and I perceived a manly boldness in their manne and conversation, very unlike the other inhabitants of Hindostan, owing no doubt to the freedom of their government. In their camps they use no tents, even the chiefs are sheltered by nothing more then small Numgheras (square canopies of coarse cotton cloth) supported on four slender poles - the common soldiers pitch a blanket on two sticks, and fasten corners down to the ground with wooden pins, so that they encamp or decamp in a few minutes. Among their customs, the following are remarkable: They will not use tobacco, though its use is universal to all inhabitants of Hindostan, yet they drink spirits and smoke Bang (the leaves of the hemp [ Note: I think the guy actually means DRINK bhang, as smoking was abhorred by all Singhs ]to the greatest excess of intoxication. In admitting a proselyte, they make him drink Sherbet out of a large cup, which certain ceeremonies, as will be seen hereafter, and which are designed to signify, that every distinction is abolished, except that of being a Sick, even a Mussulman may become a Sick on these conditions. -From the time that he is admitted into the fraternity, he wears a steel ring around one of his wrists, lets his hair and beard grow to full length, and calls on the name of the Gooroo in confirmation of all engagements.<< What are your thoughts on this extract, it mentions Singhs consuming Bhang and there is reference to Kara and Kesh, which tells us these two were obviously Kakaars or part of the Khalsa image.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

098 · 25 Sep 2005

Nihaang singh's still drink Bhang in Punjab, I have seen it myself. Nihaang's in Punjab are know for drinking Bhang, as one Nihaang Singh once told me that they do nothing all their life but get ready for war if needed and give their life to panth so guru have granted them the libertry to drink Bhang. I don't have to agree with this statement but this is what I got from a Nihaang Singh.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

098 · 25 Sep 2005

...one more thing to add, I was seen plenty of amritdhari sikhs who take off their kirpan (gatra) at evening and then drink liquor. I know this is not right but a big number of amritdhari sikh's do this in Punjab (this includes some very senior members of SGPC, akali dall's).

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

... · 25 Sep 2005

Like I said before, lots of Sikhs do wrong things today. If someone describes us in a history text book and it's read 200 years from now, they'll say, "Sikhs all drank and most were addicted to drugs (if they describe Punjab). Sikhs didn't like to have female children and aborted pregnancies when they found out a girl was coming. About 75% cut their hair but there is a group amongst them who do not. There is an even smaller group amongst them called the amritdharis but their number is not significant" So is it surprising that some people that looked like Singhs in the 1800s drank alcohol and bhang?

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Singh · 25 Sep 2005

Sicques, Tigers or Thieves is an interesting book but I noticed that the vast majority of the accounts were from the late 18th or early 19th century. Considering the book is meant to cover a 200 year time span, the entire 17th and early 18th century seem vastly untouched... (BTW, the account itself by Lt-Col James Browne most definately mentions Sikhs *smoking* cannabis not drinking it - which personally makes me take it even less seriously)

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Singh · 25 Sep 2005

it is written by paramjit, who is nidar right hand man. He has said before he gives more emphasis to historical reports, then even Gurbani. He eats meat himself, and wants to destroy the grip of the Singh sabha movement and its idealogy on Sikhs. Although this book is presented as historical research, I do think there is a very clear agenda behind these books. Amazing how accounts like Bhat Vaahiss and other texts that support mainstream sikh views get no mention in their historical research....

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 25 Sep 2005

Singh makes a good point. It seems that both the authors have purposely chosen to have most of their sources from the late 18th and early 19th century. A time when the Sikhs had just achieved political power and a large number of Hindus and many Muslims were becoming Sikhs. They were becoming Sikhs to become a part of the ruling power and with them they were bringing in all their previous superstitions into Sikhism with them. The purest Sikhism was seen during the times of the Gurus and then to the period just before the Sikhs achieved political power ( around 1770's ) later it lapsed further during Maharaja Ranjit Singh's time and during the early British period. Pure Sikhism then made a comeback during the Singh Sabha/ Akali movement. Reverted back to superstitions and Gurudom cults until 1980. Made a good comeback until 1992 and now is in the period of superstition. The above of course relates to just India. So as poster .... said if you chose a period during which a religion is in a bad state then you will get writings that show that religion being practised totally differently to how it was first created by its founders. This is why any books by the Parmjeet Singh - Amandeep Madra duo are highly suspect. They think that excerpts of writing by a few Englishmen who had no knowledge of Sikhism and a few photographs are more reliable that Guru Granth Sahib and Sikh writings of the Guru period and directly after.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

098 · 25 Sep 2005

I haven't read the book and neither I know who are Parmajit and Amandeep...??? but all I know is that Nihaang singhs still drink Bhang in Punjab at present time....I guess all I am trying to say is if you adopt and gursikh image then better respect it or don't adopt it at all if you are going to tarnish it. thanks.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Stranger · 27 Sep 2005

Fact 1: Amandeep and Paramjit are NOT anti-Gurmat and NEVER have been. What they have done is compiled the writings found on sikhs done by people who met and saw the Sikhs of the period!! These two lads spent so much of their personal time and sacrificed valuable time with the families looking up and digging through millions of pages of history in the great libararies of london to show the wider Sikh nation what great forefathers we had!!! Fact 2 These europeans wrote what they saw and if they saw Sikhs eating meat or taking Bhang they wrote it and thats History whether you like it or not. All the two boys have done is added editorial notes to clarify some of the extracts. Fact 3: Just because Paramjit support the Nihang movement and practices their (Nihang) way of life does not mean he is anti-Gurmat. Nihangs have been around since the days of the Gurus and they have always been doing Bhang and eating chatka meat. Plus the Akal Takhat supports chatka meat which suggest the nihangs are not doing anything anti-Gurmat. About bhang thats the individuals choice. We all take medication in one form or another. Besides who are you to judge any individual. In Dharm Raj's court you will be on your own and who deeds will be judged without character witnesses and references!! Stop this witch hunt. I have grown up with these two great Sikhs and no for a fact that they are not ANTI-GURMAT or Anti-Panthic or Anti-Sikh - and certainly not mis-guided. The facts are there in black and white and not just cunjured up by someone's imagination. I have been reading this forum for a while and i am surprised at the level of ignorance and intolerance towards people who do not fit the tapoban way of life. If you are the so-called purists then where is the tolerance in you and where is the humility in you?

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 27 Sep 2005

Thanks for the 'facts', no one said they just sit around lazing about, even Sant Nirankaris and other anti-Sikh movements spend time and energy to promote their manmat. Spending time digging up photos of Sikhs as well as writings of European writers is comendable but when one of the duo is known to have said that in some cases adultery is ok and is well known to promote the Nang cult then Sikhs will naturally ask questions. As for the time spent by these guys, most of their extracts from this book have already been published in the Punjab Past and Present, Punjab History Conference, Journal of Sikhs studies journals as well as in books by Ganda Singh. Their research is not exactly original or adding anything new to Sikh studies. I now expect the usual Punjabi response 'What have you done for Sikh studies' Its strange you have to defend Bhang taking first by claiming that it's a personal choice, then it's medication and finally the who are you to judge argument.lol The personal choice argument can be ued for anything as can the judgemental argument. I'm sure theft, adultery, trimming hair can also be argued as a personal choice, but by doing so we take ourselves out of Gurmat. There is a vast difference between supporting that Nihang way of life as practised in India and being a UK Nang. If you don't know the different then I feel sorry for you but the fact remains that Parmjeet Singh is one of the chief Nangs active in promoting the Nang cult. If anything he probably ranks above Niddar Singh who I think is probably just a figurehead a 'patsy' to take the flak whilst the real Nang brains work behind the scenes.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Stranger · 27 Sep 2005

Jpeg get a life!!! You are so busy judging others that you have forgotten to look in a mirror!!

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 27 Sep 2005

I see you're still high on your medicational/personal choice Bhang..lol

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 27 Sep 2005

Jpeg You need to learn your history and be more constructive in your arguments. Before slating Parmjit SIngh and Amandeep Singh do the same level of research and discount their facts with facts. Anything short of this is just lame. Accusing them of propagating a cult is no better than the temple committee guys accussing each other of being indian government agents. Complete rubbish. S

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

stranger · 27 Sep 2005

I agree with Scientific on what he says. Jpeg - Get your facts to counter the facts in the book together Otherwise go and hide in your cave away from the real world......

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 27 Sep 2005

Messrs Scientific and Stranger You guys (if you're not the same person) should read my posts again where have I slated their 'scholarship'.. how could I when no such scholarship exists. The book we are discussing is just a collection of previously published articles with a few notes from the 'scholars'. Most of these articles can be read in back issues of the journals that I listed in my other post. I'm not surprised that you cannot understand my previous post, most Sikhs who have read the book seem to think that Parmjeet Singh and Amandeep Madra did an Indiana Jones, raced through jungles, dodged poisoned arrows, climbed tall peaks to get these articles for their book.lol A visit to Singh Bros in Bazaar Mai Sewan in Amritsar is all one needs to do and ask for the back issues of these old journals! Sorry to burst their bubble of scholarship but this book is anything but scholarship

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 27 Sep 2005

Jpeg, We are not the same person. You may be quite alarmed to know that there are more than two people who hold these editors in high regard. The work that has gone into this book is outstanding and the first of its kind. If it was easy as you would like to believe, it would have been done years ago. The likes of Khushwant Singh (who i guess is also not up to your academic standards lol???) also writes highly of this piece of work. Locating, collating and analysing this information is a true labour of love. In the bazaars of Mai Sewan you will indeed find the indian jones hollywood version of sikhism which you appear to be customed to reading about. The real issue here is that you and others have taken exception to their implications of these historical accounts. They undermine what has traditionally been accepted as Sikhism. Surely we must rise above blind faith and be more academic in our pursuit of the truth Scientific

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

bgt · 27 Sep 2005

Stranger Sahb, I don't believe any of the Tapoban sangat have posted in this thread. the board is open to all, and so you make quite a judging statement yourself regarding them. there's no point telling others to look in the mirror unless we do so ourselves. the book is good in the sense that it shows the state of Sikhs and Sikhi of that era. It by no-means displays Sikhi straight after Guru's era. But nevertheless IS invaluable history. Unless of course "Singh" 's post is true regarding missiing out some historical texts and including only certain observations. anyway, you two/three, continue to bring your points in but, rather than arguing and making even minutely hurtful comments please, just look in the mirror yourselves. a great message for all the posters on this site too!!

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Amandeep Madra · 28 Sep 2005

I wasn’t going to write on this thread simply because Jpeg was making unsubstantiated and subjective comments and they really weren’t worthy of any comment. However there are two factually incorrect statements that need to be corrected and reveals Jpegs personal issues with us and the book 1. That we have been selective in reproducing accounts that push a particular ideology. Sicques, Tigers or Thieves is an attempt to reproduce a canonical set of early EUROPEAN accounts of the Sikhs from the very first account that we could find (1606) to a convenient ending which we selected at 1809 because that was the year that John Malcolm first published "A sketch of the Sikhs". Nothing in between these two dates has been left out. Someone mentioned a Persian account - this isn’t in the scope of our study and these have been brilliantly covered in JS Grewals work "Sikh History from Persian Sources" 2. That this book is simply a compilation of recently reproduced accounts in various journals. This is a laughable half-truth and an attempt by people like Jpeg to pull the wool over the sangats eyes by quoting journals that no one will be able to access to try to prove a point. I have just gone through the table of contents and hardly any of these accounts have been previously published since their first publication in books that are now so rare that few libraries even hold them. Furthermore we have got access to the original first editions (and where possible manuscript accounts) and in some cases uncovered lost pages/ judiciously edited chapters that were left out of print editions. (see below). This field of study is problematic as when you start delving into the hidden history of the Sikhs it occasionally clashes with religious sensibilities and religious ideologies. In previous generations historians from India have chosen a different tack and have simply edited texts to make them more palatable - we haven’t. Therefore it’s worth republishing accounts such as Polier's (above) without the edits that previous historians haven’t been able to do so. This also explains the extreme reaction of people like Jpeg who have had to resort to slander and lies to try to avoid trying to reconcile history with their personal ideology. Below are the chapter headings with a note (in caps) to denote whether this account has been reproduced since its original publication some 200-250 years ago. AS you can see only about 3-4 of the total 35 chapters have been published before. The vast bulk of the accounts are only available to the most dedicated researchers by getting access to obscure and very scarce journals or original mss through the British Library. What this explains is the poor understanding of Sikh history in the 18th century because our written accounts are so difficult to access. What Sicques does is bring primary written resources available to researches and Sikh historians together for the first time. Just like with Warrior Saints where we bought together a collection of visual heritage that looks into our martial heritage this books looks at the Sikhs of the period through the eyes of travellers, empire builders, missionaries and orientalists. 1 A Jesuit Account of Guru Arjan’s Martyrdom, 1606 - A NEW TRANSLATION THAT HAS NEVER BEEN PUBLISHED BEFORE 2 Wendel’s History of the Jats, Pathans, and Sikhs, 1768 - NEVER BEFORE PUBLISHED — Wendel’s Letter Recounting a Battle between the Jats and the Sikhs, 1770 - TRANSLATED INTO ENGLISH FOR THE FIRST TIME 3 Du Perron’s Indian Researches, 1788 TRANSLATED INTO ENGLISH FOR THE FIRST TIME PART II COMPANY MEN 41 4 Execution of Banda Singh Bahadur in Delhi, 1716 PUBLISHED, BUT IN LOOKING BACK AT THE ORIGINAL MSS WE FOUND A FEW NEW LINES ABOUT BANDAS ENTRY INTO DELHI. 5 Omichand, the Plassey Protagonist, 1757 - NEVER PUBLISHED AND THE SIKH ROLE IN THE BATTLE OF PLASSEY HAS NEVER BEEN RECOGNISED 6 Of the Seikh’s or Sikhan, c. 1760 TRANSLATED INTO ENGLISH FOR THE FIRST TIME 7 Warren Hastings’s Memorandum on the Threat of the Sikhs, 1784 - NOT REPUBLISHED SINCE 1784 8 The Writings of Colonel Polier on the Sikhs, 1776–1802 67 — “A Snake with Many Heads”: Polier’s Warning to the English, 1776 72 — Polier’s Mughal Memoirs on the Sikh Incursions, 1776 73 — A Treatise on the History, Religion and Culture of the Sikhs, 1787 77 — A Character of the Sikhs, 1802 82 ( SOME OF THE ABOVE HAVE BEEN PUBLISHED BEFORE BUT HAVE BEEN EDITED BY HISTORIANS FOR A VARIETY OF REASONS. THESE ARE REPRODUCED IN FULL FOR THE FIRST TIME) 9 Browne’s Treatise on the Sikhs, 1788 - RE PUBLISHED A FEW TIMES. 10 Ranjit Singh’s Correspondence with the British, 1803 _NOT PUBLISHED SINCE 1803 11 A Statesman’s Note from the Afghan Frontier, 1809 - NEVER REPUBLISHED SINCE 1809 12 “Sicques, Tigers, or Thieves,” George Forster, 1783 RE-PUBLISHED by DR GANDA SINGH EXLCUDING LARGE PARTS OF LETTER XI 13 “Extraordinary Modern People”: Dominions of the Sikhs, 1794 - NOT BEEN REPUBLISHED 14 Massacre of Fakirs, Hardwicke, 1796 NOT BEEN REPUBLISHED 15 An Artist’s Impressions of the Sikhs, Balt Solvyns, 1796 VERY RECENTLY REPUBLISHED BY HARDGRAVE 16 Francklin’s History of the Reign of Shah Alum, 1798 ? 17 Memoirs of an Irish Maharaja, 1803 195 - NEW SECTION FOUND IN MSS ACCOUNT AND REPRODUCED FOR THE FIRST TIME 18 Standoff in Ranjit Singh’s Punjab, 1806 ? I DONT BELIEVE THIS HAS EVER BEEN REPUBLISHED 19 A Failed Spying Mission to Lahore, 1808 NOT PUBLISHED SINCE 1808 20 Sikh Troop Movements in Patiala, 1784 NOT PUBLISHED SINCE 1784 21 Maha Singh Sukkarchakia, NOT PUBLISHED SINCE 1808 1786 22 Sikhs Invade Delhi, NOT PUBLISHED SINCE 1787 23 The Collapse of Mughal Power in Lahore, NOT PUBLISHED SINCE 1789 24 Zeman Shah and the Sikhs, NOT PUBLISHED SINCE 1798 25 Submission to Zeman Shah, NOT PUBLISHED SINCE 1799 26 Sikhs Gather to Oppose Afghan Rule, NOT PUBLISHED SINCE 1800 27 Attack on Fakirs at Haridvar by Sikhs, NOT PUBLISHED SINCE 1801 28 An Account of George Thomas, NOT PUBLISHED SINCE 1802 29 Ferishtah’s History of Hindustan, 1770 ? 30 Visit to the Takht at Patna, 1781 PUBLISHED BY DR GANDA SINGH IN THE 1960s and now well out of print 31 Memoirs of a Mughal Nobleman, 1786 ? NOT IN A SIKH/PUNJAB JOURNAL 32 A Muslim Account of Sikh History, 1789 ? 33 Afghan Retreat Signals Sikh Prosperity, 1790 NEVER REPUBLISHED 34 Ferishtah’s History of the Deccan, 1794 ? 35 A Modern History of Hindustan, 1803 NEVER REPUBLISHED

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

A Singh · 28 Sep 2005

<<2 Wendel’s History of the Jats, Pathans, and Sikhs, 1768 - NEVER BEFORE PUBLISHED — Wendel’s Letter Recounting a Battle between the Jats and the Sikhs, 1770 - TRANSLATED INTO ENGLISH FOR THE FIRST TIME >> Seems, even back in the 1700s, the Jats regarded themselves as some form of separate community (no doubt surperior because of the Scthiyan roots!) and this was also evident to the foreign observer (Wendell), who even placed them independently of Sikhs?

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

amritsaria · 28 Sep 2005

I don't wish to get into this who is the best scholar argument but I think Amandeep you will find that the majority of the chapters you have written as having not been republished is incorrect. As a scholar I would have thought that you would have taken care to double check your facts before posting here. I suggest you recheck your sources

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 28 Sep 2005

Dear Amrtisaria Why not complete your observation with some facts about where and when they have been published. This is an academic argument. Feel free to join in with some facts and figures. S

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

S Singh · 28 Sep 2005

A Singh Ji, >>Seems, even back in the 1700s, the Jats regarded themselves as some form of separate community (no doubt surperior because of the Scthiyan roots!) and this was also evident to the foreign observer (Wendell), who even placed them independently of Sikhs? The reference to Jats more than likely refers to the Jats of Bhartpur and NOT the "Jat" Sikhs you think it refers to ! The Jats of Bhartpur under Raja Suraj Mal fought against the Afghans etc and they were a major power in northern India.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 29 Sep 2005

It appears that no one has any facts to counter Amandeep Singhs points, so i guess its case closed. I suggest those of you who havent read the book buy it from Amazon. Its gives us a fascinating window into an era not previously focused on. It doesnt matter if the historical facts are not one hundred percent consistent with what we have been told in the past. Keep an open mind and just read it for what it is. S

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Singh · 29 Sep 2005

Amandeep you may have done alot of work in collating these works. No doubt the Sikh community has appluaded you for the work. But you cannot also doubt that your co-hort Paramjeet mischieviously used some of these quotes to push his Anti-Singh sabha and pro-Snanatanistic agenda. As that agenda is remarkably similar to the RSS one, it raises a real question on him and his gang. He openly states that Singh sabha destroyed Sikhism. A few years ago many youth believed him, as they had no real knowledge on history. Niddar and Paramjeet have created more interest in History. However as more people have done more research the youth have realised that the arguments that Paramjeet and niddar have used are completely false. Let me take one for example - for years now Paramjeet, Niddar and jagdeep have said groups like Singh sabha and AKJ have been creations by the British. Clearly not a scholarly conclusion backed with evidence. There is so much evidence to the contrary such as the Bhai sahib having the longest sentence in jail during the Freedom struggle, plus all his writings backed by Gurbani only, no-ones opinions or influence, just the influence of Gurbani.. Despite the blatant facts Niddar, Paramjeet and jagdeep continued their campaign. Then they started the old is best and true. So nihangs are oldest so our maryada is best. But as more evidence and debate occured it has now been shown that nihangs maryada pushed by Niddar is nothing but a mish mash, and historical accounts based around the 19th century. The very people they were slagging off such as AKJ have now started showing Bhatt vahiis and other older sources, the most important being Gurbani to back their interpretation of Sikhi. So now where does this leave the years of lies and false propogandas done by Niddar, Jagdeep and Paramjeet. They have serious mud of their face because of all the venom they displayed have all gone back on them. For example, it was them who first introduced the word Nang, and they used it for Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh! No one today calls Bhai Fauja Singh a nang, but everyone calls Niddar, paramjeet and jagdeep the UK Nangs! So please carry on with your research, but do not come here and try and play Paramjeet as some victim. Paramjeet has still got a clear agenda. What is not clear is if you are just an innocent collegeue or also influenced by this agenda? If you are an innocent collegue, then some will say you are a "patsy" who is being used by them. If not, and you are part of this agenda, just stand up and be counted. At least everyone knows where they stand?

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 29 Sep 2005

Singh ji This strand was started by someone analysing an extract from the book. Just to bring back the original question... "What are your thoughts on this extract, it mentions Singhs consuming Bhang and there is reference to Kara and Kesh, which tells us these two were obviously Kakaars or part of the Khalsa image." From there various people have raised points to challenge the credibility of the sources in this book. When asked to discount these facts with facts the strand seems to have died a miserable death (not suprisingly because i doubt there is anyone out there who has done the same level of research). What we are now seeing is personal slander. Rise above this and stick to the strand's theme. If you want to start another strand called " I hate nangs" then that would be more appropriate for the above discussions. This strand is about the Sicques, Tigers or Thieves. Scientific

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Singh · 29 Sep 2005

Scientific Ji, I have posed specific questions to Amandeep relating to his response and his stand on UK nangs. Just let him answer the post. Thanks.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 29 Sep 2005

Scientific wrote >>It appears that no one has any facts to counter Amandeep Singhs points, so i guess its case closed. << No so fast, a day goes by and suddenly because there is no asnwer to Amandeep's post you want the matter closed..lol Just going through the list provided Jesuit account - this was translated and published by Ganda Singh in the Punjab past and present journal in 70's. I think wendel's work was edited by Jean Delouche in the late 80's. Banda's execution, translated and published in early annals of english in bengal published in c1900. translated by Ganda Singh in 70's and published in Sikh Review and Punjab past and present. - a few lines found hardly qualifies to have it republished!! Brownes treatise on Sikhs published many times lastly by Ganda Singh Just a few that I can think of Both our scholars might want to consult Ganda Singh ' A Bibliography of Punjab' which lists all their the works as well as a brief of what relates to Sikhs/Punjab in that work!

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 29 Sep 2005

Singh wrote >>So please carry on with your research, but do not come here and try and play Paramjeet as some victim. Paramjeet has still got a clear agenda. What is not clear is if you are just an innocent collegeue or also influenced by this agenda? If you are an innocent collegue, then some will say you are a "patsy" who is being used by them. If not, and you are part of this agenda, just stand up and be counted. At least everyone knows where they stand?<< You're judged by the company you keep. An expression that Amandeep Singh would to well to advised to reflect on

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 30 Sep 2005

Jpeg ji I can see you editing a historical account with references at the end reading something like..... Notes 1. Jean Delouche did this one. Dont remember the date but thats irrelevant! 2. This one was published many times lastly by Ganda singh somtime in the 70s 3. Cant remember but i am sure someone has published this one! Come on! you are challenging an academic here. I hope no readers are impressed with your vague recollections of dates but its rubbish like this which leads to the hollywood history that we have had to accept as Sikh history. Not good enough. S

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

............. · 30 Sep 2005

whats the matter scienticfic, cannot Amandeep defend himself?

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 30 Sep 2005

Scientific Sorry but I don't carry copies of everything I've read! Maybe you do! Challenging an academic here?? Lol All these scholars did was take a copy of Ganda Singh's Bibliography of Punjab and used it to become familiar with the works which give some information on Sikhs. The biggest con here is that these two scholars would consider they are better scholars than Ganda Singh and consider him a 'Singh Sabha' scholar, you know the ones who corrupted Sikhism. A true scholar is someone like Ganda Singh who travelled to various places in India and abroad, located works without a having a nicely laid out list of all the works he needs and where and when they were published. Ganda Singh was knowledgabe in Punjabi, Urdu, Persian and Arabic as well as other Indian languages like Marathi. I wonder if both our scholars are such experts in these languages

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 30 Sep 2005

If you dont have access to these sources and cant give hard facts dont comment on history. History is based purely and only on facts, not on pie in the sky assumptions and comments. Start a strand on personal slander and you wont be challenged for the facts. Scientific

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Stranger · 30 Sep 2005

Jpeg your argument is pretty pathetic and baseless. You cannot remember dates yet you seem to be able to compare Ganda Singh's bibilography with Sicques, Tigers or Thieves!!! Did you buy the two books and compare them line for line? Wow you are some character. BTW Since when did Amandeep S and Paramjit S call themselves scholars anyway?!!! You obvisously cannot handle the truth and it is becoming clear from your 'character assisination' that the base on which you have built your belief in sikhi is becoming very unstable. Same actually applies to all the others on the thread and elsewhere who are attacking the authors of the great book. Your feeling very insecure in your beliefs because they are being challenged by the truth!!! I feel sorry for you all

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 30 Sep 2005

It does seem strange that there seems to be a few people who go around on Sikh forums saying how great this book is! We've just seen two of them saying what great Sikhs these guys are even when confronted with proof of what Parmjeet Singh believes they still think he's the greatest thing since sliced bread! I was on another forum a few days ago and one guy was saying what a waste of £50 this book is.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

uk singh · 30 Sep 2005

As far as I know Parmjeet Singh who is not even here to defend himself, played no part in Jagdeeps websites. Additionally, I have never heard Niddar Singh slate any shaheeds in any of his public discourses. Jagdeep has dug a hole for himself and as far as I know, the majority of youth with any 'budhi' have distanced themselves from him. I have not read the book yet, but do intend to purchase it soon. Surely we cannot judge the authors on the eye witness accounts of others and more importantly, until we have read the book!

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Amandeep Madra · 30 Sep 2005

To answer some specifc points: Your worte "Jesuit account - this was translated and published by Ganda Singh in the Punjab past and present journal in 70's." It was trans by CH Payne in 1929 and later E Hambye. All the instances of previous publication are listed in the book on page 8 Note11. Previous translations have been inadequate and we had a Portuguese scholar work on the original text to provide a fresh new translation You wrote "I think wendel's work was edited by Jean Delouche in the late 80's." Yes you are quite correct, he did an abrdiged version in French. We can't read French so we commissioned another scholar to translate it. You wrote "Banda's execution, translated and published in early annals of english in bengal published in c1900. translated by Ganda Singh in 70's and published in Sikh Review and Punjab past and present. - a few lines found hardly qualifies to have it republished!!" You are right again (although it doesnt need translating as it is already in English). We had to include this for the sake of completeness. You previously accused us of only selecting certain texts to reproduce and now youare saying that the book is too complete ! Whilst the text is quite well known little is known about the three principals and we carried out a great deal of research on their backgrounds and the context of their mission. I also spent 2 days with the original manuscript version of the text to make sure that their were no other stray references to Sikhs or Banda. This is vital becuase the Surman text is the only known european eyewitness account of Banda Bahadur and his excecution in Delhi. You wrote: "Brownes treatise on Sikhs published many times lastly by Ganda Singh" Right again and we freely admit this. Again we need to include this for completeness. We hope that we have added to richness of knowledge on Brownes famous treatise by adding both a detail bio of Browne and many more explicatory notes. You wrote "Both our scholars might want to consult Ganda Singh ' A Bibliography of Punjab' which lists all their the works as well as a brief of what relates to Sikhs/Punjab in that work" We did - its in the Bibliogrpahy and an excellent piece of work it is too. I want to reproduce a few paragraphs from the Preface of the book so that you can read exactly what the book is about, its scope, our methods and why we embarked on it. Whilst this wont satisfy some of you I do hope that most of you will understand what this book is about and what we hope to inspire: [Preface, xvii-xx] The eighteenth century remains, to most writers of Sikh history, an enigma: a mysterious period between the sacred era of the Sikh Gurus and the heady days of the Sikh courts. This is due largely to the dearth of historical material that supports this critical episode in the formation and development of the Sikh panth. Whilst the earlier periods have a wealth of religious liturgy that provides some view on early Sikh thought and the later periods aroused the curiosity of neighboring empire builders as well as court chroniclers, the eighteenth century occupies a dark phase in Sikh history. The need to improve our own understanding of the Sikhs who lived in this lawless century, and to take a closer look at traditions that are now almost foreign to the modern-day perception of the Sikh way of life, were our prime motivations for embarking on this work. When Sir John Malcolm, military man and early empire-builder, first published his pioneering Sketch of the Sikhs in the Asiatick Researches in 1810 (published later as a book in 1812), he blew the cover on the Sikhs for the first time for most Europeans. Malcolm drew on primary accounts, local historians, and Muslim news writers and chroniclers to compile his treatise. The accuracy and breadth of his work sustain his writings as some of the most often quoted words on the Sikhs, even to this day. However, Malcolm was by no means the first writer to chart the progress, history, and fate of the Sikh people. For the previous two centuries, soldiers, travelers, administrators, scholars, missionaries, and empire-builders had borne witness to the development of the Sikh people. In letters, footnotes, and passing references, these men and women join to shed light on a little-understood period of Sikh history. Whilst Malcolm’s work certainly did not usher in a golden period in the study of Sikh history or religion, it does provide a convenient point at which to cease the collection of the accounts presented in this work. The vast majority of the accounts presented within Sicques, Tigers, or Thieves are lodged firmly in the eighteenth century... The accounts herein span some two centuries and only represent those written by European travelers to India. These early journeymen and women, formed the basis of the intelligence that the British establishment and interested general public would have received throughout the eighteenth century and well into the nineteenth. In some cases, the accounts are not first hand at all, but are translations of earlier works from Persian or local languages. These have been included where the translation was published prior to 1809, simply because they would have contributed to Western consciousness of the Sikhs. Later translations of earlier works were not included within the scope of this study. Previous attempts at this type of study [note 1] have proven to be sources of inspiration for this work; however, where they have faltered in presenting either incomplete, judiciously edited, or simply missing accounts, we believe that we have tried to present as complete a picture as we possibly can of the earliest European accounts of the Sikhs. Our attempt to try to collate every surviving written text on the Sikhs between 1606 and 1809, will inevitably reveal unpublished, undiscovered fragments and accounts that will further illuminate the early history of the Sikh people. For these gaps we apologize in advance, and hope to redress them someday in a further edition. There is a similar canon of texts that are drawn from Persian and the vernacular languages of Punjab, which form an incredibly important repository of information of the Sikh people viewed from Mughal eyes. Fortunately, many of these accounts have been critically examined and published in J.S. Grewal and Irfan Habib eds. and trans., Sikh History from Persian Sources (New Delhi: Tulika, 2001). For the accounts reproduced here, we have prefaced each one with a short biography of the writer or translator, which is an important precursor to the text that follows. Often the authors have occupied a precarious position, finely balancing the weight of scholarship with the basic prudence and expediency of a politician. The background to the account, the authors’ own vested interests and biases are vital pre-reading before their written work is entered into, and in each case within this text, these dimensions are articulated. Throughout the account, we have tried to clarify, illustrate, and cross-reference pertinent points that are being made. The resulting notes have been appended as endnotes to each chapter. These form the bulk of our work on this project and are by no means exclusive explicatory annotations on the subject. These references, together with the readers’ own interpretation, form a useful link to further reading, research, or just food for thought. … “Sicques, Tigers, or Thieves” has been an immensely rewarding and exciting piece of work to be involved in. We hope that in presenting these long-forgotten accounts, we render some service to scholars, students, and general readers keen to better understand the early history of the Sikhs, and maybe inspire others to compile the next great challenge: that of the early Punjabi accounts of the Sikhs. Amandeep Singh Madra Parmjit Singh [Note 1. The most notable being Ganda Singh ed., Early European Accounts of the Sikhs (New Delhi: Today & Tomorrow’s Printers & Publishers, 1974).]

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Singh · 30 Sep 2005

Please stick to facts and not hearsay. In front of me, Niddar said he stands by every word in the websites, especially everything against AKJ, Singh Sabha, Taksal, etc. Paramjeet also was hand in hand with the websites. Where do you think Jagdeep got all the info from if it was not Paramjeet and Niddar. Also Paramjeet was the one who distributed the flyers and posters advertising the websites. So we come back the main question, where does Amandeep stand with paramjeet, Niddar and the websites. If this book just another vehicle for them to become popular, then afterwards promote the anti-Sikh beliefs, which is the real agenda? Why is Amandeep refusing to disassociate himself from them? Stranger, scientific and all the rest of the "Paramjeet fanclub", stop intentionally deflecting the conversation and let Amandeep answer for himself.......

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Stranger · 30 Sep 2005

UK Singh Thanks for pointing out the obvious wrt to the book Jpeg you point out someone on another site somewhere stating that they bought the book and found it a waste of 50 pounds. The book has not been written for those who believe in the "bollywood sikhi" so nicely put by scientific. Hence many will not read it.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Singh · 30 Sep 2005

Amandeep why do you keep ignoring the question. What is your position with what Niddar, jagdeep and Paramjit promote????

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

uk singh · 30 Sep 2005

Singh Ji writes 'Please stick to facts and not hearsay. In front of me, Niddar said he stands by every word in the websites, especially everything against AKJ, Singh Sabha, Taksal, etc.' What I stated was not a half-truth as I have been to several Niddar Singh talks. Not once has he mentioned the above. Though he has slated the 'jaar' gatka techniques used by 'modern' day Sikhs. His words not mine. True enough, these beliefs are reflected on Jagdeeps site. Like I said earlier, Jagdeep has not done himself any favours and has lost all respect with many of his friends/sangat due to his blatant disrespect of Shaheeds and great Sikh personalities. Trying to meld Sikhi with a Sanatan bias has not helped either. No one in their right mind can slate the two authors for the personal time and energy they have spent writing 'The Warrior Saints' and now this. Personally, I think they have performed a huge seva and should be commended rather than grilled. What do the Sangat here think they should have done? Expect them to pick and choose quotes that are biased towards our sentiments? Amandeep Singh - Please do not waste too much energy entering into a cul-de-sac debate.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 01 Oct 2005

Well put UK Singh. The expectations of these narrow minded people is exactly that no one should uncover any truth which rocks their fragile religious beliefs.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Singh · 01 Oct 2005

Why are you all so eager to stop Amandeep answering the question? It is such an easy question- Where does Amandeep stand according to the writings of Niddar, Paramjit, and Jagdeep on their websites? Please stop making Jagdeep the sole scapegoat for the websites. Yes he was a decietful and hatefilled individual, but the writings are more the work of Paramjit and Niddar. I have never doubted the effort that goes into producing these books, but we need to know if they are part of some hidden agenda, or a just reserach, and Amandeep was innocently used as a patsy by Paramjit in his agenda. So Amandeep please answer the question. Otherwise your silence indicates there is more to this than meets the eye...

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 01 Oct 2005

Uk singh there is a number of disassociations happening within nang circles. Francisco Luis aka Bahadar Singh is trying to do the same as parmjeet Singh is doing. I'm not sure if these are just tactical disassociations because of the heat they are getting for their views and just aim to come back with bigger bull next time around. Once a nang always a nang in my view especially when it come to top class nangs such as these guys.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 01 Oct 2005

Scientific wrote >>Well put UK Singh. The expectations of these narrow minded people is exactly that no one should uncover any truth which rocks their fragile religious beliefs.<< What's with the fragile religious beliefs?, bollywood Sikhi? You've been on the bhang too much my friend! I'm quite firm in my beliefs and i look to Guru Granth Sahibji for guidence and do not need validation of these beliefs from anyone else. This is quite unlike the validation that Nangs need from the Nang websites and from books such as these for their use of bhang. It seems like you are the one who has fragile religious belief and not us.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 01 Oct 2005

Singh I doubt you will get any reply from Amandeep Singh. His silence as they say is deafening. The organisations that these two guys are involved in seem to use the cover of historical research to promote their nang beliefs. I asked on another thread why taxpayers money is used to pay for Niddar Singh to give lectures and promote Nangism, he didn't reply there either. All we get a couple of fans of his trying to prevent him from having to give a reply. It would be good that the Sikhs around the world as well as in UK understand what kind of agenda the UKPHA has.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 02 Oct 2005

Jpeg What a pathetic conclusion to jump to that I am a Nihang. Lol you are quite a basic individual indeed. I have no where in my statements pledged support for nihang philosophy (and neither have i rejected it). Unlike you I am able to stick to the topic which for you once again is "Sicques, Tigers or Thieves!". Cant believe you are so incapable of sticking to the topic. You are only embarassing yourself with your posts but keep them coming because they have comedy value. Scientific

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 02 Oct 2005

Keep the comedy lines coming JPEG ji. They are highly entertaining!

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 02 Oct 2005

When it comes you pathetic conclusions you seem to top the list. Bollywood Sikhi, fragile religious beliefs..blah blah blah. Typical Nang thought process. You could be a first though, a nang without knowing it. Keep it up my friend, your the comedian. Now can I request the two fans of Amandeep Singh (scientific and stranger) to not try and cloud the issue and let's have Amandeep answer Singh's questions.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 03 Oct 2005

"When it comes you pathetic conclusions you seem to top the list." What language is this???lol Stick to panjabi my friend!

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 03 Oct 2005

Jpeg do you ever get the feeling that you are talking to yourself? It just seems that you ask the same question over and over and no one wants to give you an answer.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

confused · 03 Oct 2005

Jpeg since you clearly are unable to provide a reasonable and mature argument i suggest you take the following advice: 1. Stop assumming we are Nihangs or Nangs. Besides if i was I would not be afraid to admit it. I live with my convictions. 2. Just because you have lost the argument on the subject matter quite clearly displayed in the title of this thread - stop your attacks on anyone individual. So much for you bhagti - it does not seem to have worked on the krodh in you!!!!!!!!!!!!! 3. Amandeep does not need to answer to anyone - he is respected in much wider intellectual community and does not need to answer to some pathetic individual on this forum who cannot stick to the argument as stated in point number 2. If however he does decide to answer thats his personal choice. Ah nearly forgot 4. I will not waste my time and energy arguing with a murakh like you. So i suggest you switch to other threads where your advice and comments maybe respected.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 03 Oct 2005

Scientific Look for a typo and add a lol and there you have a response..no my friend it may be a response in your world but not on this forum. If you have nothing positive to offer to the debate you may wish to stay off this thread and go to a forum better suited to your intellectual level, maybe one set up specifically for young kids. Confused Is that all you have to offer, not much of a debater are you? You know it's funny how asking a question of Amandeep Singh suddenly becomes a personal attack! Amandeep was asked some questions initially by Singh and then I added to the request. It does seem to be surprising that a group on here seem to wish him not to have to answer any questions put to him. He may or he may not be respected in the wider intellectual community but unless he clarifies his position about Parmjeet Singh then I am afraid he will not or has not much of a reputation in the Sikh community. I am sure this thread will help those Sikhs wishing to buy the book to decide whether they wish to purchase it and thereby have their money go towards furthering the nang cause. No doubt we will see a similar debate when the niddar and parmjeet book comes out. Forewarned is forearmed Can I ask admin to not allow the childish diversionary tactics of the Amandeep groupies on this thread. If Amandeep wishes to answer the questions put to him then that is fine.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Lion King · 03 Oct 2005

Some solid advise to JPEG there. I have followed this argument on the quite and now feel compelled to write something. This book is a tremendous piece of work that should be read by every Sikh. It is beautifully edited and really makes sense of so many accounts written over a couple hundred years. Truely amazing piece of work. Well done to Amandeep and Paramjit Singh. Read this book.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Simran · 03 Oct 2005

Brilliant book! I really hope this is the first of many to come. Its going to be a hard act to follow. Finally we are seeing Sikh academics taking control of SIkh history Simran

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jolly · 03 Oct 2005

I bought this book off Amazon. It just provides such a fascinating window into a time that is just not understood so well. If these guys hadnt undetaken this laborious task of editing so many diverse texts and accounts we would continue to remain in the dark with respect to this very turbulent period in our history. Applaudable work guys

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jatinder · 03 Oct 2005

Jpeg You seem to be getting all personal for nothing. Dont intrude into peoples personal lives. I dont think you would like it if you had to explain all of your personal or professional relationships to everyone. Its not anyones business. Judge the book for what it is and not what you have heard. If you spent the time you are wasting writing on this strand, actually reading the book you may actually be able to evaluate the book. Who knows you may even learn something. Jatinder

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 03 Oct 2005

Funny how this thread has been on for two weeks and apart from Amandeep's groupies no one praised the book. Suddenly 4 people praise the book! Nice try guys :)

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Singh · 03 Oct 2005

The question is very important. No doubt the book is good, but it is important to ask if there is a hidden intention behind the book, because one of the co-authors has now been widely exposed for hidden agendas to divert many youth from mainstream sikhi. When the conclusions made by Paramjit in the websites he advertises and supports shows his intentions, we need to ask if Amandeep also believes in the same Snatanaism. So Amandeep will you answer the question, or should we assume from your silence that you are completely in agreement with Parmjit, Niddar, and Jagdeep? Before anyone responds with anymore deflective comments, please read all my posts above!

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Lion King · 03 Oct 2005

Jpeg Cant believe that every time someone writes something in support of the book you assume its the same person. Very weird!

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Amandeep Madra · 04 Oct 2005

Against my better judgement I am going to respond, but I doubt it will satisfy jpeg/singh. Its clear to anyone reading this thread that they first started attacking our work as incomplete, then they moved to saying it was too complete (!). Both times it was clear that they were making baseless allegations and it was highly unlikely that they had read the book. they have since moved to making baseless personal attacks. I am not a professional scholar or academic, I have a very demanding full time job and a young family. In the spare time I get while travelling I read, research and write. I am extremely honoured to work with one of finest researcher I have ever met and someone who has uncovered an absolute treasure trove of the hidden history and heritage of the Sikhs. More than that he freely and openly shares that and works with me to present that in innovative and open ways. We hope in the future to share more of what we have found in expansions to the Punjab archive site, through a travel site on the hidden heritage in East Punjab, through new books on photography and other projects on the archives in the UK. I spend thousands of pounds on books and travel and hundreds of hours away from family travelling to photograph and research Sikh history. I do this in my spare time and I do this because I have a great love for our heritage and our culture and I want to make that available to anyone who has even a passing interest. I do this because I want to see our heritage preserved for future generations and because our kids won’t thank us for arguing on the internet when we should have been stopping kar sevaks pulling down the Built heritage of the Gurus or cremating important Sikh manuscripts. And whilst I sometimes wonder why I bother (like right now)something about the beauty, the richness, the absolute joy of our fabulous Sikh heritage and history keeps me going. This is our hidden agenda - that's it, there really nothing more sinister than that. Rather than revert to the obscene hearsay read our books or look at the websites and measure us by our output. If there is a hidden agenda it must be from people who use pseudonyms on the internet and make a series of baseless attacks. If you have issues with certain people or content on certain websites then take it up with them. I have bee writing on this thread to defend and explain my own work (which I will continue to do) I don’t come here to condemn or condone other people’s websites. This is the last word I have to say on this topic. Amandeep Madra

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

stranger · 04 Oct 2005

Singh and JPEG Amandeep has responded - so get off his case. People like Amandeep / Paramjit are the only ones making any concerted effort to log and attempt to preserve our beautiful and rich culture and heritage. If you cannot provide decent and worthy input I suggest you stay out of these arguments

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 04 Oct 2005

Amandeep can you stop beating about the bush, no one asked you how much money you spend or how great you think your friend is, the question asked was what do you have to say about the views of Parmjeet Singh? It is clear you do not wish to answer the question but what is the use in placing a paragraph which has not relevance to the questions asked?

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 04 Oct 2005

Its a shame that we cant all take an open mind and judge a piece of work for what it is. Its an absolute tragedy that our community is plagued with alegations and accusations about each other. I am pretty certain that there will a load of responses to Amandeeps response wanting to know more about his stance on the 'Nang' philosophy and Paramjeet Singh etc but his response is more than adequate for those who are interested. For those of you who just like a good old 'desi' argument , continue aimlessly at your pleasure. You will gain nothing apart from heightening your own frustrations. Over and out Scientific

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Singh · 04 Oct 2005

Amandeep why is it such a difficult question for you? Look at all the youth in Uk, most do seva while having young families and with demanding jobs. Many youth spend thousands doing camps, workshops, and other seva. This is the path we have all choosen when we do seva. You are not unique in this. I agree at times it is very fulfilling, but at other times when you face criticisms you may get feed up, but it is only Guru`s play to keep our egos in place. But you have to accept Parmjit, Niddar, and Jagdeep, who many consider associates of yours have widely offended many people, have encouraged youth with anti-Gurmat sentiments. Some midlands youth have even had fights. The source of all this strife within the youth are these 3 and their websites. You have aligned yourself with them, and you fail to dis-associate yourself. Yet you seem to play the victim aswell, when you are associated with them. You have been given ample opportunity to dis-associate yourself. If you choose not to accept it, then do not whine about the baggage that you have got. No matter what good work you do, the legacy of these 3 and their actions will always be a burden on you. All the work you do also will have a question mark, and it is clear that you are sympathetic to Snaanatan idealogue.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Singh Man · 04 Oct 2005

Why don't all these people against this books references etc, go and write book themselves, put your money where your mouth is instead of slating people. Think a gora today might go to a wedding and say "We went to sikh temple, the couple went around a book, 3 turban priests sung loud preyers and then we went to party hall were everyone danced and a bottle of alcohol and rich foods were served was on the table and the men shouted braah , braah" They just wrote what they saw So all people that don't like this book BUY it or if not why not instead of pussyfooting around spend hours/time and labour in doing what these two sinhgs ahve done and show otherwise and write your own, then i can buy your book too WJKK WJKF

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 04 Oct 2005

I think this thread has come to an end. Amandeep has chosen not to give any clear cut response to the questions put to him. It is usual for those who do not want to answer a particular question to play the victim and complain about personal attacks! Reminds me of the politicians, Amandeep you may wish to pursue a career in politics.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

jhamka · 04 Oct 2005

vaheguru typical response by the nangs, amandeep u got ur agenda, spoke to a few older singhs who now u from ur early days in southall, guess what they not suprised about where u have landed. u might spend thounds of pounds hours but the damage u are doing with the nangs is worse then the sgpc, u lot are destorying innocent sikh youth lives. some of the kids are on drugs and ruining innocent girls lives, shame on u. u can play on words etc but the thing is damage is being done by u nangs either directly (

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

SSAJAHK · 04 Oct 2005

First the list of questions: >Paramjeet has still got a clear agenda. What is not clear is if you > are just an innocent collegeue or also influenced by this agenda? > If you are an innocent collegue, then some will say you are a "patsy" >So Amandeep please answer the question. Otherwise your silence > indicates there is >more to this than meets the eye... >doubt you will get any reply from Amandeep Singh. His silence as they > say is deafening. >Amandeep why do you keep ignoring the question. > What is your position with what Niddar, jagdeep and Paramjit promote???? >So we come back the main question, where does Amandeep stand with > paramjeet, Niddar and the websites. If this book just another vehicle > for them to become popular, then afterwards promote the anti-Sikh > beliefs, which is the real agenda? >Why is >Amandeep refusing to disassociate himself from them? Second the Answer! Ok jpeg or tiff or bmp I'll bite: Hi my name is Amandeep and here is my response and answer to that earth-shattering question. What was the question again? Am I a Pasty? No that's not it!. Hmm was it: Am I innocent.? Hmmm No that is not it. Hmm yes the question was is my silence deafening? Right! Next!! The question that jpeg or bmp or tiff needs an answer to so that she/he can finally get some much needed sleep is: Is Amandeep (me) really involved with the villainous websites and propaganda promotion and are his books really "vehicle for them to become popular, then afterwards promote the anti-Sikh beliefs" Here goes: (please only chose one!) Drum roll please!! Response number 1) Yes I am in complete absolute agreement with those websites and totally support the contents. And can't wait to get popular by researching and writing books and then afterward when no one is looking stealthily spread the propaganda. Yes jpeg, tiff and bmp you have exposed the elusive "weapons of mass destruction". Congratulations for detecting the "hidden agenda" Sherlock. (You win the Nobel prize for intuition) You have triumphed! There. Now go have your warm milk , grab your pillow and blanket. (and wipe that victory smile off your face) Response number 2) No way! What are you on drugs? Me support those crackpots and that propaganda on those websites. You must be sniffing something really strong cause how can you actually read that information found on those websites with a straight face. (Yea you jpeg tiff and bmp stop smiling.. hey you still here I thought the first response number 1 above was sufficient and you had packed it in for the night .. hmm guess not ..curious to learn more are we…"Impressive, most impressive” ..Lord Vader in empire) Oh yea where was I ?…Yea now I remember my response # 2 I categorically completely dissociate myself with those websites and that group in general and can't wait to get popular just cause I like being popular (doesn't everyone) Please only select one response from above! There now everyone in this thread and message board should be happy. Just pick the response that suits you and don't bother with the book Sicques, Tigers or thieves or its contents since that is entirely and completely irrelevant. The point is regardless of the answer you decide to choose the content of the book is what needs to be examined in an objective impartial approach! (without the personal bias) What a novel idea! (get it novel idea!) signed, AM (posting in the PM) =================================================== Great now that everyone is ready to jump all over this post I must fess up I am not really Amandeep. Surprise Surprise. Nor do I have much knowledge of the history of this particular passionate debate nor can I write with as much precision as some of the posters (as should be evident by my writing so far! ) and I am not a historian or a scholar! (as should also be evident by my writing ) But here is what I did do after reading these posts. I decided to Google Amandeep Madra and to see for myself what up? (Yes I said what up.. the S is silent .. never mind). To be balanced I would have also googled the other person in this hot debate but sticking the phrase"Jpeg" into a search engine is dangerous and may produce results that may not be family oriented! (nor acceptable on this board) So now follow along at home and complete these steps with me: Start your browser and get to google.com. Type in Amandeep Madra and analyze the results in an unbiased fashion: Count for yourself the Anti-Sikh, Anti-Panth etc.. sites etc…in the results Shocking what you will find! Now once you wade past the numerous websites of the publishers attempting to sell Amans books there are some interesting and wacky results from googling Amandeep .. Wacky yes .. Anti Sikh ..well no not really. I discovered that Amandeep has been researching (as documenting on Google at least ) for over 10 years on Sikh History, Sikh Weapons etc .. e.g: from 1997 (at 4:00 am in the morning) ========== Amandeep Singh Madra Nov 15 1997, 4:00 am Newsgroups: soc.culture.japan Date: 1997/11/15 Hi there I am researching for a tv documentry about the role of Indian soldiers in the burmese front during ww2. Can anyone please suggest any sources of japanese accounts of these soldiers. I specifically looking for military and personal accounts fo japanese meeting indian (and specifically Sikh) soldiers for trge first time. Mnay Thanks Amandeep =============== Another url that I found interesting in the search results from googling Amandeep http://www.movinghere.org.uk/stories/story9/story9.htm There are countless other bits of obscure Sikh historical facts that Aman has attempted to reveal i.e. I found a totally unusual post by Aman looking for Jung's writings on Guru Gobind Singh. Wow! Jung writing on Guru Gobind Singh cool! ( FYI: CARL GUSTAV JUNG (1875-1961) Jung's fame is second only to Sigmund Freud's in the brief history of human psychoanalysis (http://www.answers.com/topic/carl-jung) Talk about obscure and wacky but anti Sikh no I don't really think so (see below) ============== Jung and Guru Gobind Singh Amandeep S Madra May 6 1998, 3:00 am Newsgroups: alt.psychology.jung Date: 1998/05/06 Subject: Jung and Guru Gobind Singh Hi all, I have a question to all of the learned contributors of this newsgroup...... I have been trying to track down a number of articles that were written by Jung towards the end of his life regarding the tenth Guru of the Sikhs, Guru Gobind Singh. I have been given a number of frustrating leads which have gone nowhere I would appreciate any help Many Thanks Amandeep ======================================== I don't consider Google to be a litmus test for anything nor is it a barometer for evaluating ones individual Sikhi coefficient (no I am not a mathematician either) however in the era of the internet it is all I have at my disposal to use as tool to objectively evaluate this discussion. For the sake of argument why not place your own real name (not jpeg or whatever) in the search engine and view the results and count the total number of pro-Sikh and pro- panth articles and sites that are associated with your respective names in the search results! Nuff said ( My guess is that the number will be far less than for the search results for Aman.) So now go back to your glass house and shut the door and don't forget your pillow! I am out of here! And so please bhula chukka maaf ..and no offence meant to anyone by the heavy dose of sarcasm in the post above. I sincerely and genuinely mean that. Have a great night/morning/day ..pick your own time zone! Wahe Guru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahe Guru Jee Kee Fateh SSAJAHK (my email is [address removed] should you wish to comment ..don’t really get a chance to visit the message board often but did stumble across this madcap and totally personal debate) [%sig%]

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 05 Oct 2005

SSAJHK, another distracting response. No doubt you took some time over the post but it isn't really contributing to the debate. You may think it was clever but totally irrevelant to the matter at hand. Amandeep and his fans only defence is that he is a great researcher! So that would just about justify everything. To anyone reading this thread it should be obvious that given the Amandeep's totally off track response and his fans swooning that there is something to hide. Amandeep I hope you do not mind but I need to act on my convictions so please do not be surprised if posts similar to this appear on other Sikh forums.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 05 Oct 2005

Like SSAJAHK I also did a bit of research on Amandeep. Didn't take long but I came across a review of Oberoi's book done by Amandeep. Oberoi's book was controversal and a number of scholars from Punjabi, Punjab and Guru Nanak Dev Universities wrote a book in response to Oberoi's book. It seems rich that someone like Amandeep who complains of personal attacks and judging a book on it's content and yet look at what he says in his review. It comes as no surprise that Amandeep sees nothing wrong in the book. But that's a side point. Apparently Amandeep thinks that the present day Sikhism is an invention of political parties and by extension not the Sikhism created by the Gurus. Seems a very similar argument to Jagdeep's present Sikhism as being a creation of the British. But what is also important is what he has to say about the opposition from Sikhs about Oberoi's book. He says that one of the main detractors was someone who had failed to get Oberoi's job. Doesn't that sound a bit like a personal attack. Maybe questioning Amandeep's motives is a personal attack but Amandeep gossiping about the motives of someone else is 'scholarship' *************************************************** A real eye opener - one of the few new studies on Sikhism, January 17, 2000 Reviewer: Amandeep Madra ([address removed]) from London, UK This book has been shrouded in controversy ever since the author, Canadian academic Harjot Oberoi, was hounded out the chair of Sikh Studies at the university of British Columbia, Canada. Coincidentally, it was the same Chandigarh based academic who had individually failed to get his job as professor of Sikh studies that were his main detractors when this book was published. The Construction of Religious Boundaries opens by recreating 19th century Sikhism - it's religious beliefs, cultural practices and traditions. After reading the initial section it is quite obvious that no writer on Sikh history has carried such a comprehensive task as Oberoi in piecing together early Sikh though and practices. In essence, 19th century Sikhism had no set rules, there was no common belief structure, religious power was held by Guru families and the continuation of Guru tradition, there was an equal veneration of Guru Granth Sahib and Dasam Granth, Caste distinctions were very strong and Dharamsalas were run by hereditary Mahants. This section naturally leads onto the arrival of the British, but more critically the influence of the British on Sikhs and Sikhism, and consequently the creation of a zealous, reformist Sikh intelligentsia. It is this group of reformist Sikhs, the political Akalis, that Oberoi argues, created a standardised version of Sikhism. In this standardised version Sikhism attained new lifecycle rituals (births marriages deaths), a new calendrical cycle and new symbols and power structures. In summary the creation of an -ism and hence the new religious boundaries between those that defined themselves as Sikh and those that defined themselves as Hindus. Having read the book, I fail to see what the controversy is about. This book is a real eye opener and helps to trace the roots of the malaise that Sikhs are currently in with the uneasy religious power structures and conflicting religious beliefs. The real controversy lies in why Sikhs have allowed political parties to re-invent Sikhism to best suites their political ends and why we do not allow voices to challenge or to foster an open debate. This book, however, is a challenge to read. It is written by an academic for academics, and is a book that requires patience and a dictionary to get through. --This text refers to the Hardcover edition.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

DSB · 05 Oct 2005

The point under discussion is the subversion of Sikhi by organised groups.Look at the current SGPC and Akali Dal , once they were great institution but now they are totally under the control of the GOI. Sikh history research is nullified if the authors true views are known to the public. True effort has gone into producing books and websites, but when it is known that some of the authors are actually following a path where they want to damage Sikhi, then it is duty of all Sikhs to be on their guardand prevent it.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Amandeep Madra · 05 Oct 2005

I have been lured back into the debate ! The point I was making in my last post was a bit lost, so I'll try again. You clearly have issues with what is written on a particular website, so you should take it up with them. I will defend what I have written in "Sicques" but I can't be expected to, nor will I, defend anyone else, their views or their writings. I write and research with Parmjit and will most likely continue to do so. We are two different people with differing views on a number of subjects and what we write is oru union view. Here there are no issues (I think). Whatever your feelings towards him and his views are (and I have never heard him express anything like the views you stated) that is between you and him. What I have written and expressed is in the public domain and that is up for critical review by everyone - on that basis I think its fairly clear where I stand on issues. You seem to want to know what I think about "snatanism" and other topics - and you seem to want to spin me into a nexus that I simply am not part of. I know you wont believe me but I really can't do a great deal about it - and maybe I sound like a victim as a result ! but being blamed for "ruining young lives" and kids taking drugs really takes the biscuit. Finally, I really enjoyed Oberoi's book - it was a good read and I would recommend it, it's a really valuabel insight into how sikhs lived and worshipped 100 years ago. In retrospect it was a bit gossipy wasn't it? there you go - you got me aman

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Jpeg · 05 Oct 2005

Once again Amandeep as usual you completely miss the point! The gossipy bit was trying to imply that the chief detractor of Oberoi was against his work because he hadn't got Oberoi's job. You can't complain about personal attacks yet do the same yourself. What exactly did you mean that Sikhism has been re-invented by political parties? This is your view that you put in that review of Oberoi's book. Maybe you either need to read what you are trying to respond to or just don't bother. I think anyone reading this thread has got a good idea of where you're coming from and as DSB said, when authors of books about Sikhism themselves have dodgy views about Sikhism then the Sikhs need to be aware of it.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Singh · 05 Oct 2005

Thank you for your response Amandeep. I am pleased you have shown that you have different views to those of Parmjit and co, who have inspired even Amritdhari youth to start taking Class A drugs. The books are based on research. Can you honestly say that you have just put in the books texts that you have found, or have you selected them according to their content. If so what was the criteria for selection? Questions are raised when Parmjit and co use these texts to make not sensible conclusions, but often absurd conclusions of sikh philosophy, which are completely contrary to Gurbani. A couple of more questions, if you do not mind answering them. Do you believe Snatan idealogue is compatible with Gurbani? Do you consider Niddar & Co with websites as an acceptable role models for young Sikhs? If tomorrow, one of your own kids comes under the influence of an Amritdhari Sikh who led him to do Class A drugs, as part of Snatan Sikhi. Would you honestly consider that person a Sikh?

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

avidya · 06 Oct 2005

Waheguruji Ka Khalsa Waheguruji Ki Fateh Believing Sikhi is expressing a timeless universal truth does not equate to propogating 'class a' drugs! Traditional Sikhs (including Taksal, Sant traditions and samprdas) do not preach the use of class-a drugs. Nihangs do not preach the use of class-a drugs. Do not misrepresent all these traditions with flippant accusations please.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 06 Oct 2005

Singh It is quite worrying that you have mentioned class A drugs in this discussion. Can you give examples of specific people who have come under the influence of Niddar Singh and Paramjit and been influenced into taking one or more of following substances, which are considered class A. (Bhang cetainly isnt class A- (Not that i am advocating it!!!). I just hope you are making these judgements on real facts because it is a horrible allegation to make against someone. Scientific Class A Drugs include: Opiates : Heroin (diamorphine), Methadone, Morphine, Opium, Other opiate drugs (except codeine & dihydrocodeine) Cocaine (including crack & coca leaf) Hallucinogens: LSD, Mescaline, Psilocybin/Psilocin (e.g. Magic Mushrooms when prepared, deliberately dried, or otherwise altered by the hand of man in any way), Other indole-based hallucinogens (e.g. bufotenin) Ecstasy (and virtually all derivatives) THC/Cannabinol (synthetic, or not within cannabis or cannabis resin) Help if ArrestedLegal ServicesExpert WitnessSolicitor FinderMedical NecessityDrug & The LawFill in our SurveyStudent InformationPublicationsAbout I.D.M.U. LtdSurvey ResultsTV OpportunitiesDrug SubcultureMisc Drug SitesForensic/Testing/DrivingAdvice & TreatmentMedicinal UseAcademic/ProfessionalLibrariesJournals/PublishersUK GovtGovt/UN/USLaw EnforcementLegalProhibition/PreventionLaw ReformMedia/NewsOverseas/Drugnet etcIndustrial HempCoffee ShopsDrug PricesReclassificationDrug Survey 2005Legal EnquiriesStudent EnquiriesGeneral EnquiriesSubmit Link requestEmail site Designer Legal Classes of Drugs - UK Misuse of Drugs Act 1971 Class A Drugs include: Opiates : Heroin (diamorphine), Methadone, Morphine, Opium, Other opiate drugs (except codeine & dihydrocodeine) Cocaine (including crack & coca leaf) Hallucinogens: LSD, Mescaline, Psilocybin/Psilocin (e.g. Magic Mushrooms when prepared, deliberately dried, or otherwise altered by the hand of man in any way), Other indole-based hallucinogens (e.g. bufotenin) Ecstasy (and virtually all derivatives) THC/Cannabinol (synthetic, or not within cannabis or cannabis resin) Class B Drugs include: Cannabis/Cannabis Resin Amphetamine & derivatives (other than ecstasy-type) - if prepared for injection becomes class A Methylphenidate (Ritalin) Codeine & dihydrocodeine (except medicinal preparations) Temazepam Most barbiturates

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 09 Oct 2005

Singh I am still waiting for a response to your statement "I am pleased you have shown that you have different views to those of Parmjit and co, who have inspired even Amritdhari youth to start taking Class A drugs. " I think you should refrain from making such accusations unless you are willing to really put your neck on the line and present real evidence with names and details. If the judicial system in the west made judgements on heresay can you imagine what kind of a state we would live in ? A taliban style one! Scientific

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Singh · 10 Oct 2005

So Sceintific - are you denying the fact that some of the birmingham youth are not taking drugs? Did jagdeep website in the past have the recipe for Bhang or not?

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 12 Oct 2005

Singh I am sure there are loads of people in every town that are on drugs. I am not in the least bit interested if someone put the frosties formula for bhang on the net. You dont have to be a rocket scientist to learn how to consume drugs. I am holding you on a point, where you have mentioned that Paramjit et al have encouraged youngsters to take class A drugs. I am sorry to say this but it appears you have no medical knowledge and certainly have no familiarity with drug classifications. The implications of accusing someone of encouraging class A drugs is far fetching and in the future dont make such accusations without the facts. And finally let me tell you one more time , I strongly do not advocate the use of bhang or any class of drugs listed above. My point to you and everyone else who has contributed to this strand is that dont speak without the facts. Its not only embarassing to youselves but also lowers the intellectual standard of debate. No offence meant by these words because I see that you have made some good posts on this site. Scientific

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

anotherSingh · 12 Oct 2005

Scientific - you are not very smart are you? Paramjit distributes flyers for the shastervidya classes, which advocates drugs fr sikhi. They even have the recipe to make it. He supports Niddar on the concept that there is nothing wrong with drugs such as bhang. (marijuana) Youth in birmingham, who attended his classes, who were amritdhari, now are doing drugs. Which bit is hard for you to understand??? It does not matter what class it is, what matters is that it is Anti Gurmat and illegal! By the way a niddar fan like you would know - is it true that Niddar was drunk on alcohol at a wedding a year or so ago, or was it when it had another child?

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

JS · 12 Oct 2005

At a recent Sikh camp for youth the Niddar clan encouraged other immoral behaviour regarding girls.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

JB · 12 Oct 2005

Author: A Singh Date: 09-28-05 04:13 <<2 Wendel’s History of the Jats, Pathans, and Sikhs, 1768 - NEVER BEFORE PUBLISHED — Wendel’s Letter Recounting a Battle between the Jats and the Sikhs, 1770 - TRANSLATED INTO ENGLISH FOR THE FIRST TIME >> Seems, even back in the 1700s, the Jats regarded themselves as some form of separate community (no doubt surperior because of the Scthiyan roots!) and this was also evident to the foreign observer (Wendell), who even placed them independently of Sikhs? ------------------------------------------------------ yaar, not Jats / Jatts are sikh. there are muslim and hindu's among jats aswell. this is nothing new...

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 13 Oct 2005

A singh I think your intelligence is highly questionable because you obviously do not read what i write. I have condemmed the use of marijuana. I guess someone of your level may need a leaflet to learn how to make bhang but most people would be more than capable of doing a google search. My point (and i would like to reiterate - dont shoot your mouth without the facts) was that they have not advocated Class A drugs (this was in response to a comment made by 'singh'. Next time read and think before typing a silly reply. Scientific

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 13 Oct 2005

Apology 'A Singh' that last post was for 'Another Singh' ! Too many similar aliase names!

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

A Singh · 13 Oct 2005

No worries "Scientific' - in any event, I'm pretty sure my intelligence is highly questionable! I like your post - it highlights what I've tried to say elsewhere, essentially that the 'real' issues are missed and everyone decides to go down the route of 'character assination' and personality ridicule. RSS and others are easy to defeat using their own literature - but no one wishes to read this literature and prefer to hold big arguments instead. Now we have Sikhs complaining that others are attacking our history - well what about you? I've seen so many Sikhs belittle the history of others without really knowing much about it and now cry when they retaliate. Just about any book published in the last 20 years portrays non-Sikh Indians as weak "bahmans", with no backbone or honour, which is clearly far from the truth...is it any wonder when these communities then fight back with tit-for-tat tactics? The same is true within the Panth and accounts for the 'waring' evident between AKJ, Nihangs, Taksal, Nanaksar, SGPC, Nirmalas etc etc. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 13 Oct 2005

A Singh, I am glad you understand what i am trying to say here. I am absolutely dumbfounded by the desire of sikhs to paint such a rosy picture of history. A history where there are no inconsistensies. In the effort to smooth it all out and keep everything in sync, the desire to know the truth has been lost and we are fast becoming a narrow minded group of people. The moment someone challenges the norm of accepted fact we see the onslaught of character assasination (as you have mentioned), wild accusations and assumptions (none of which are based on fact). As an example, in this and other strands I have been repeatedly accused of being a 'nang' (whatever that is). This is simply because i have pledged support for the great work that Amandeep Singh has done.The fact is i have no affiliation with any group, sect etc. I have at no point advocated the use of any drugs , yet some dummies on this strand have made assumptions that I advocate drugs (I have the unfortunate task as a psychiatrist of admitting at least two patients each week with cannabis induced psychoses! I am hardly likely to advocate drugs! ). When confronted for facts, there is more abuse and change of questions. Complete shambles from an argumentative point of view. The quality here is so poor that you could get away with accusing someone of rape and not have to present an iota of evidence because "someone told me you did it so dont argue with me" type of attitude. Is it any wonder that the world has not flocked to become Sikhs with the pathetic, segragational, illiterate representation that we have? Its a complete tragedy that this faith which has the foundations and openess of a beautiful universal faith, is failing to hold onto its own. This need not be denied. All you have to do is look around. I am pretty certain there will be plenty of assumption based replies to these words. So get your shooters out because I am fully loaded. Scientific

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Zorawar Singh · 13 Oct 2005

I am amazed how confident you guys have become just because no one bothered responding to you in the last few days. You both seem drunk on your own egos based upon your apparent superior knowledge of Sikh History. (Funny Niddar and Jagdeep spoke like that before aswell) There are so many experts on Sikh History in the Panth, past and present. All of whom agree with mainstream Sikh History and idealogue, and do not agree with Nihang, Sanataan or whatever else you call this mish mash. You said - "Is it any wonder that the world has not flocked to become Sikhs with the pathetic, segragational, illiterate representation that we have? Its a complete tragedy that this faith which has the foundations and openess of a beautiful universal faith, is failing to hold onto its own. This need not be denied. All you have to do is look around." Firstly Singh Sabha Movement had some of the most educated Gursikhs that we have had. Then I see thousands attending Singh Sabha Gurdwaras around the world. Not seeing thousands attending Niddars classes. In fact, even those who did speak openly against him now, or actively disassociate from him. You accuse people of calling you nangs. This is because you and A Singh have on tapoban just come up with the same stuff that Jagdeep and co did under numerous alliases on all other forums. Best of Luck with your hairy fairy Sikhi. It is you that you seem obsessed with making childish arguments disguised as intellectual debate. Then afterwards just say, "OH I am just a neutral. I have nothing to do with them anyway..." Sorry people on these messageboards are not that thick...Nobody believes you...

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 13 Oct 2005

Zorowar Singh It appears you have a one dimensional view on the Sikh faith. In none of my posts have i pledged support for any of the above named characters. Never even met them. Neither is there any evidence of me slating the singh sabha movement. I think you fail on both accounts my friend. Next? Scientific

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Seema · 14 Oct 2005

Zorowar You are a great example of someone not even being able to understand a simple point being made. But dont worry you are not alone as can be seen from many of the replies above. What scientific bhaji is trying to say here is: " Dont make assumptions, present facts" Its so true what he says about being able to accuse anyone of anything without having to present any facts. Complete joke. Seema

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

owned... · 14 Oct 2005

Zorowar Singh It appears you have a one dimensional view on the Sikh faith. In none of my posts have i pledged support for any of the above named characters. Never even met them. Neither is there any evidence of me slating the singh sabha movement. I think you fail on both accounts my friend. Next? Scientific -------------------------------- owned! hahahaha

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

A Singh · 14 Oct 2005

Dear Zorawar Singh, Gur Fateh! <> It seems the only person ‘drunk on their own ego’ is you. Have a re-read of this thread, my only contribution has been the joke post concerning “Sikhs and Jats!” and a response to Mr Scientific Veer’s post addressed to me, so I cannot see the relevance of your comment “I am amazed how confident you guys have become just because no one bothered responding to you in the last few days”. But anyway, the main point I would like to take up with you is your patently false and grossly inaccurate assumption and accusation that I have come up with the same stuff as Jagdeep and co. This is sheer nonsense – have a look at my posts (all of them again, you’re that keen on really knowing my views) you’ll find plenty in them which go heavily against the notions presented by the “Sanatan Sikh” camp – however you and the Sanatanis both seem to suffer from the same disease: If someone agrees with even one point of another’s view then that automatically puts them into “their” camp, likewise if someone doesn’t agree with every single thing that you agree with, then they are anti-Sikh because only you have the ‘true’ Sikhi. You’re a real piece of work Mr Singh. Have a look at the thread on Udasis started by me, with factual references which clearly point to conclusions contrary to that of the Sanatan Sikhs, however with the exception of Bhai Kulbir Singh, no one wished to have a discussion on that topic, why? Because, it’s too hard to actually discuss items which don’t allow you to chant Nang Nang Nang! or British Brainwashed SGPC Sikh, British Brainwashed SGPC Sikh, British Brainwashed SGPC Sikh! at each other!!! Veer Scientific is not known to me, so I’ll leave him to answer for himself – my views are quite clear on most matters – the Sikh Rehit Maryada is the minimum standards set for Sikhs, deal with them, other Jathas, Taksals, movements, sampradhas have certain variations in their maryada, which is perfectly acceptable so long as the bare essentials are met (i.e. 5 Kakkar, 5 Banis and 4 Kurehits), in view of this, the repeated arguments on topics such as Meat, Sarabloh Bibek, Raagmala, Neela Bana etc etc are nothing but a waste of time causing further fractions in the Panth. Some people oppose this view, they feel that their particular Jatha or Institution has the one and only true maryada, even though it can be and has been proven many times to the contrary using their own arguments (of course, when one does this the old “nang” or “British Brainwashed SGPC Sikh” chants begin again). These people feel unity can only be achieved through homogeneity and that their version of events, maryada and outlook is the only acceptable basis for this homogeneity to occur – that sounds more like a Nazi vision rather than the Sikhi of Guru Gobind Singh concerning the world macro and micro outlook which has been adequately captured in his writings within the Akal Ustat. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

observer · 14 Oct 2005

If all you guys are so innocent, why are you going out of your way to justify yourselves?

Re: Sicques, Tigers or Thieves..extract!

Scientific · 14 Oct 2005

Dear Observer Only replying to the dumb questions that i have been asked. No need to justify anything to anyone. Everyone should be free to believe what they like. If everyone accepted that there would be no problems. S