Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 27 Sep 2005

4 Panthic bodies oppose Sant Samaj stir Varinder Walia and Sanjay Bumbroo Tribune News Service Amritsar, September 27 In a major setback to the ongoing `morcha' against the SGPC and Akal Takht, launched by the Damdami Taksal and a section of the Sant Samaj, four Sikh organisations, including Shiromani Akali Dal (Amritsar), Dal Khalsa, Khalsa Panchayat and Khalsa Raj Party yesterday accused them of being spokespersons of the ruling Congress, RSS and the police . Coming down heavily on the Damdami Taksal and the Sant Samaj here, Mr Simranjit Singh Mann, President, SAD (A), alleged that they were being saddled by Capt Amarinder Singh, Chief Minister, and the ruling Congress at the Centre. He said Maryada could not be altered the way the Sant Samaj and Damdami Taksal wanted. The direct confrontation has virtually divided the Sikh Panth on the Maryada (rejected by the Taksal and Sant Samaj) issue. Mr Mann said it was shocking that the Jathedar of Akal Takht had failed to take cognisance of the `morcha', launched by a section of Sant Samaj and Taksal . The four Panthic organisations alleged that whenever elections were on the anvil , certain vested interests made allout efforts to join hands to strengthen their political base in Punjab, even as the state machinery becomes hyperactive and many Sikh organisations fall easy prey to their machinations. The written press note by the four Panthic organisations reads: "Acting at the behest of anti-Sikh forces, the Sant Samaj and the Damdami Taksal have outrightly rejected the Nanakshahi Calendar and the Sikh Rehat Maryada. The very concept of Sant Samaj is against the ideals of Guru Granth Sahib. According to Sikh principles, there is only one Samaj and that is the Khalsa Panth, the Commonwealth of the Khalsa. " The four Panthic organisations alleged that they (Sant Samaj and Taksal) had been secretly confabulating with these anti-Panthic forces and the present statement was also part of that grand design. The so-called Sant Samaj and the Damdami Taksal have blatantly rejected the Panthic Maryada, which they don't follow themselves. We want to ask them as to which Maryada they want to foist on the Sikhs?" "Do they want the Sikhs to follow the Maryada of Una (headquarters of Baba Sarbjot Singh Bedi, President, Sant Samaj), Chowk Mehta (headquarters of Damdami Taksal) or Nanaksar or any other? They have different Maryadas. They should also clarify whether they recognise the Akal Takht or are more close to the Delhi takht?" they said. The four Panthic organisations appealed to the Sikhs to defeat all their moves to divide the Sikhs on this issue. The Khalsa Panth has set up standards and procedure to change Maryadas. In preparation of the Ardas, the Rehat Maryada and the Nanakshahi Calendar, countless meetings were held at Akal Takht and other mutually agreed places, to evolve these documents. No single body or organisations have the right to reject Panthic documents. After substantive debates over a period of 13 years (1932-1945), the Sikh nation gave itself the Sikh Rehat Maryada. It was prepared in consultation with all cross-sections of the Sikh people. This is a code of conduct, to be followed individually and collectively by the Sikhs. It is a unique document which is a summary of hundreds of Rehatnamas, which delineate do's and don'ts for every Sikh. The signatories to the joint statement include Mr Simranjit Singh Mann, President, SAD (A), Mr Kanwarpal Singh , General Secretary, Dal Khalsa, Mr Rajinder Singh, Convener, Shiromani Khalsa Panchayat, and Dr Jagjit Singh Chohan, President, Khalsa Raj Party.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Maybe · 27 Sep 2005

political organizations targeting religious organizations....what a healthy stand. What the hell do politicians know about rehit maryada that they accuse sant Samj And Taksal like this.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Anti Bihpar · 27 Sep 2005

Finally someone has spoken out against these bhramins

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Singh · 28 Sep 2005

Dr Chohan is a Goverment stirrer who just wants to cause internal conflict in Sikhs. He did it very successfully in UK splitting the Federations against each other. However it good other groups are now speaking against Sant samaj.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Me · 28 Sep 2005

Brahmins? I call these Jathedar Brahmins who recently honoured Baba Maan Singh on stage.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Me · 28 Sep 2005

>>After substantive debates over a period of 13 years (1932-1945), the Sikh nation gave itself the Sikh Rehat Maryada. It was prepared in consultation with all cross-sections of the Sikh people. This is a code of conduct, to be followed individually and collectively by the Sikhs. It is a unique document which is a summary of hundreds of Rehatnamas, which delineate do's and don'ts for every Sikh.<< It also doesnt say Keski is a Kakaar and allows Sikhs to eat Jhatka meat, what a joke.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Sep 2005

Author: Maybe Date: 09-27-05 19:35 political organizations targeting religious organizations....what a healthy stand. What the hell do politicians know about rehit maryada that they accuse sant Samj And Taksal like this. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Maybe...you are forgetting that Sikhe is MIRI+PIRI.... Guru hargobind Ji COMBINED these two in Akal takhat and Harmandir sahib. For me I have more respect for Mann than all the "sants" put together because at least he stood up against the GOI.and suffered in JAIL...losing his job. He REFUSED to even set foot inside Parliament WITHOUT his KIRPAN ( ALL - 100% of the Sants and Jathedars take OFF their KIPANS at the drop of a hat ( in malaysia one Jathedar - GRADE A... even handed his Kirpan to a Muslim security Guard ( chaprrasee) even while his accompanying malaysian sikhs were going to see the Guards boss and explain that this man is our HIGHEST RELIGIOUS AUTHORITY...and he should retain his Kirpan...by then its was too late...) And it is NO MORE A "SECRET" that all this Fuss by sant samaaj and its cohorts...is all at the BESHEST of the Congress Politicians to CAPTURE SGPC from the Badal Gang. The SANT SAMAJ tried this TRICK ten YEARS ago and LOST so BADLY ( all of them Lost their DEPOSITS)..that they complained all thsi due to badal having bought bhaiyas and sehajdharees . WELL ALL thta may be TRUE ( it is true imho)..BUT then WHAT THE HECK DO SANTS and SAMAJS and TAKSAALS know about POLITICS ?? A "BABA DARSHAN SINGH" Stood as Sant Samaj candidate agaisnt TOHRA and LOST HIS DEPOSIT ?? Tohra was a politican..BUT BABA JI...??? Why did he stand ?? At that time also the SANT SAMAJ had brought out their version of a "SIKH REHAT MARYADA"....and circulated Video Tapes of HUGE SAMAGAMS.... their chelas were showing them in MALAYSIA and saying..hun badal de baraan wajj gayeh....bhog pai giya....tohrre da kirtan sohila parriah giya....what really happened was Tohrra WON hands down...and defeated BABA JI came over to MALAYSIA...to start his .."parchaar..."""all those "huge smagams" and vast "amrtifharees in their LAKHS."......was just a smokescreen which is also very common today..just listen to any sant samagam or see their videos...every SANT claims lakhaan amrtidharee banna dhittey....where these lakhs are ?? nobody knows for sure...

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

AVTAR · 28 Sep 2005

Damdami taksal, nanaksar have always diffrent maryada than sgpc since day one, why now mann and his group doing this? Damdami taksal is the only taksal stand for sikh rights. they have sacrifice alot. sgpc did not stand at all. the attack on harmindar shaib was arrange by mr thora (sgpc president) so who should we follow.?

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

>>>> · 28 Sep 2005

mann is a babbar sher. i appreciate mann for taking stand against DT and ku-sant samaj.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Me · 28 Sep 2005

Lets all read Bhai Randhir Singh Je's books.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

ekta · 28 Sep 2005

i am in full agreeance with bhai sahib bhai simranjit singh mann he is correct.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

agyani · 28 Sep 2005

what about akj maryada...thats different to?

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Sep 2005

Author: agyani Date: 09-28-05 14:37 what about akj maryada...thats different to? ............................................... Not really..AKJ Maryada is just keeping strictly to Puratan Gurmatt Maryada and has no "conflicts" with what GURBANI says.....unlike DT Maryada and Others. Just read their maryadas and you will see..amny blatantly anti-Gurbani acts are compulsory.. I am not a AKJ..but i do know where they are coming from...sarbloh bibek is ancient Gurmatt, more Banis in Nitnem are also tatt gurmatt, Equality to ALL KHALSA irrespective of Gender is also as per Gurbani..etc etc. Maybe Bhai Kulbir Singh ji might be able to further elaborate..but as far as I know none of akj maryada is contra to gurmatt.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

do not know · 28 Sep 2005

what is sant samaj. pl elaborate. if i am not mistaken, it seems like a ku-sant gang. i thiink real sant samaj can be permanently only n sachkhand or temporarily where true gurmukhs do sangat in the presence of guru granth sahib ji no offence. just learning. too much confusion. pl help. [%sig%]

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

....... · 28 Sep 2005

to do not know bha ji: Current leader of Sant Samaj is Baba Sarbjot Singh Ji Bedi the 17th descendants of Guru Nanak Dev Ji, general secretary is Baba Hari Singh Ji Rhandawae Walae. Sant Samaj has been around since the time of Baba Sahib Singh Ji Bedi the 11th descendants of Guru Nanak Dev Ji during the times of maharaja Ranjit Singh Ji. Sant Samaj Lineage are the descendant of Guru Nanak Dev Ji all sants look to them as leaders. These days Sant Samaj also has a political party of Panthik Morcha as they are trying to get rid of the corruption done by Prakash Singh Badal over the last number of years and other sikh groups who crete distrust in authentic Bani. Sant samaj is the society of saints. Here are some of the members: Baba Sabjit Singh Ji Bedi are the leader of the sant samaj (they are the 17th descendants of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji) other sants in it are Baba Hari Singh Ji Rahdhawae Walae Baba Jagjeet Singh Ji Harkhowalae Baba Sukhchen Singh Ji Dharampur Walae Baba Sewa Singh Ji Rampur Khera Walae Baba Baljeet Singh Ji Dadoo Sahib Walae Sachkhand vasi Baba Thakur Singh Ji Damdami Taksal Baba Avtar Singh Ji Badni Kala Walae Baba Amar Singh Ji Barundi Walae Baba Darshan Singh Ji Dhakki Sahib Walae Baba Lakhbir Singh Ji Ratwara Sahib Walae Baba Hardev Singh Ji Lolowalae Baba Maan Singh Ji Peehova Walae Baba Balwant Singh Ji Rara Sahib Walae Baba Teja Singh Ji Rara Sahib Baba Baljinder Singh Ji Rara Sahib Hoti mardan wale mahapursh the list goes on far. I hope this helps.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Anti Bihpar · 28 Sep 2005

taksal was great until Baba Jarnail Singh Ji became Shaheed in June 1984. After this everything has been going downhill for the taksal. First they deny his Shaheedi get Jujharoo Singhs arrested by police dont tell the truth to the Khalsa Panth by making up fake dates on the return of baba ji accuse great warriors such as Shaheed Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal of trying to become jathedhar of taksal (they say thats why he was declaring Baba Ji to be Shaheed) totally abandon the goals that Baba Ji fought for and encourged all Sikhs to fight for then come out 21 years later and say that Baba Ji did become Shaheed in 84 heavily infiltrated by the RSS dhumma who is a big thug becomes jathedhar (everyone in USA knows this) Now once again they show their true bhramin character

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Singh · 29 Sep 2005

Sant samaj is the Union of Sants, basically, Akalis had power and initially they got so high on themselves, they thought they would also set up a sant samaj with the help of Congress and defeat Akalis. But Akalis wipped them, and so they have since used their set-up with help from RSS to cause conflict in the Panth everytime something good is about to happen. Tell me something - which Mahapursh, who is one with God, is interested in Punjab Chief Minister politics? Since when has mahapurshes needed white cars with police lights, and police bodygurads. These are in Punjab only reserved for ministers. A mahapursh has the whole world at his feet! The smamaj has just helped them get favours from politicains in return for votes. This has helped them get visas for foreign trips, helped them make their deras bigger, or helped them get off rape charges when they are caught red handed. They make these occasional stunts to make them look important again. Basically they prey like Mahants of old on the uneducated masses. They are like modern day Pundits! The saddest things is the youth followers of sants, who make like one sants, but feel they have to stick up for every sant no matter how dodgy just for sake the sky will not fall on their heads.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

mr singh · 29 Sep 2005

does the akj maryada not say that a keski must be worn at all times?? is this not different to what the sgpc maryada says? do the akj's agree with the maryada set about eating meat?? we can not pik n choose what u want out of the sgpc maryada!! yes, mann deserves credit, for the stance he has made, but had he used his intelligence abit more, he might have made a greater affect with his political power! after the attack on darbar sahib, mann had political power, instead of losing his seat in parliment, for not being allowed to take in his 3ft kirpan, he should have entered with his normal 6inch kirpan!! i understand the fact the he wanted to make a stance, but in doing so he lost alot of politcal power! somebody said above, that the sants etc take off their kirpans in a second, when flying over to another country....well i wonder what the majority of other amrithdaris do when they fly? i wonder what mann did when he came to the uk a few yrs bak?? i remember one sant in particular not to mention his name, when im and his jatha when on a fligh never used to eat nothing, as when the were without there panj kakkar they wouldnt eat! i wonder what the other mahann gursikh do when they fly over to other countries?? there are many, bhai amolak singh, bhai jeevan singh ji, etc, i wonder what the gurskihs do when they fly ova?? the reason y i am saying this, as u have proberly already guessed, is just to show that we shouldnt critise others if we are not better!! the gursikhs mentioned above, bhai jeevan singh, bhai amolak singh, are gursikhs of the highest level, but what do they do when the travel?? lets not critise othere for no justifiable reason.... the sant samaj went aginst congress, etc by go up for election again them!they wanted to go against badal, tohra etc...these people have done nothing but try an kill the sikh faith off....whether or not u agree or disagree with their actions, lets remember to judge ourselves before we judge anybody else!! bhul chuk marf karna waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

agyani · 29 Sep 2005

Not really..AKJ Maryada is just keeping strictly to Puratan Gurmatt Maryada and has no "conflicts" with what GURBANI says.....unlike DT Maryada and Others. Just read their maryadas and you will see..amny blatantly anti-Gurbani acts are compulsory.. ________________________________________________ but this still goes against what the SGPC maryada says....a) keski as kakaar b) amount of bani done in the morning c) meat issue etc etc etc d) naam dhrir

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 29 Sep 2005

author:. Sant Samaj has been around since the time of Baba Sahib Singh Ji Bedi the 11th descendants of Guru Nanak Dev Ji during the times of maharaja Ranjit Singh Ji. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< not really..... that is just the INDIVIDUAL SANTS and their deras and taksaals... The SANT SAMAJ GROUPING that is Registered as "Gurmat Sidhant Parcharak SANT SAMAJ", printed its own BOOKLET called "Sikh Rehat Maryada"..and FOUGHT the SGPC ELECTIONS about ten years ago..came into being only ten years ago after 1984 Ghallughara. It was formed by the Congress to Wipe out the Akalis from SGPC/Punjab Politics. Thsi time around also it is acting as PROXY for the CONGRESS to capture the SGPC....as the Akalis are already in power. The REJECTION of the nanaksahi Calendar is the most Solid Proof that this Samaj is politically motivated to destroy the PANTH and make RSS supreme. Manna and all the other DISGRACED/CONVICTED sants are STILL HONOURED MEMBERS of this "samaj". Not a single statement from the "sant Samaj" about them proves that they are all "ek Khurlee de bacheah". Even totally bankrupt parties like Congress REMOVE people like Tytler...when the TRUTH comes out..But not our "Holy (BLOOD) descendatnts of Guru nanak...Wake UP..WE the KHALSA are the REAL DESCENDANTS of GURU NANAK JI.....Guur Ji Himself REJECTED these blood relations while He was ALIVE in this Human Form.....whay we "matha tek" to them ??...17th peerrhee indeed ?? so what ? GURU JI REJECTED His FIRST BORN..baba sri chand...are we WISER to accept his 17th Descendant ??

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

we all got names · 30 Sep 2005

u know what we all going on a path to god, we all start from the begining but when we make it close to the end we look back and start criticizing the begining. u know if we had more people telling us to do the right thing, motivating us, telling us good things, the world would be a better place we have enough people telling us whats wrong. its the same things. if u walk into a room where people fighting u walk away thinking people were fighting lets talk about how great sikhi is inspire people not what everyones doing wrong guru ji knows whos doing what right and what wrong to best way to stop the people that are doing wrong things is to set an example i'm a mona i just wanna say one thing i respect singhs to the max but to be honest with u the people that are doing things wrong are more friendly then you guys and i aint saying all of u i've got alot of love from the singhs but u know what i bring my buddies along and they feel like they aint welcome this aint a few people this is alot of people i can see past that but think about the rest of the world they dont u know alot of people lost out there and confused when they come home they dont feel welcome most of them aint gonna stay there show more love u know what i had a buddy i know we've all gone off on baba ranjit singh about what he doing this and that, u know what i'm not down with things he does. and u know when he came down here i got alot of buddies who drink do drugs the whole works. the surprising thing is they called me and said they all going to the gurudwara. and u know what they changed. i aint down with some of the things he does. but u got to look at what he's doing right. he showed them alot of love. so everyone just smile seriously be more friendly if u disagree u disagree but there is a thin line between disagreeing and hating and u know the funny thing is most people that are punjabi i aint saying sikh u know what i mean cuz i dont even consider myself a sikh punjabi dont know anything about sikhi and what u guys fighting over they dont know about jathabandi's i didnt know till i started getting more into it WORD OF ADVICE I GOT SO CONFUSED WHEN I START GETTING MORE INTO IT. I STOPPED DRINKING , I STOPPED DOING DRUGS, I STOPPED EATING MEAT, I ADMIT ITS BEEN A SLOW PROGRESS, AND U KNOW WHAT GOD DID IT FOR ME I DIDNT STOP THOSE THINGS, GURU JI DID IT FOR ME, AND WHEN IT COMES TO WHAT GURU JI WANTS, ASK HIM WE CAN READ ALL WE WANT WE CAN LISTEN TO WHOEVER WE WANT WE CAN GET RAISED IN WHATEVER WE WANT END OF THE DAY ITS WHAT HE WANTS SO JUST ASK HIM HAVE FAITH IN GURU JI DHAN DHAN SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI SIT THERE AND ASK HIM DONT GO TO HIM THINKING U ALREADY KNOW GO TO HIM WITH NOTHING U ARE NOTHING U KNOW NOTHING AND SOMETIMES IVE READ ON THIS MONA CANT DO SIMRAN THIS AND THAT HAHA IT MAKES ME LAUGH THE ONLY REASON I'M HERE TODAY IS CUZ OF SIMRAN THROUGH SIMRAN I CHANGED DONT DISCOURAGE PEOPLE and if u want to hate on me cuz i'm a mona saying this its all good just one request i'm a sinner i know it please dont waste your time doing nindya on me i'll do it for u i'm a sinner i dotn know nothing i cant even give my head to guru ji

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Singh · 30 Sep 2005

People keep saying Dhumma was a thug is USA. What did he do in USA?

Sant Samaj

sewak · 30 Sep 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh With respect to everybody, I would request all Sikhs on this platform, do not criticise Sant Samaj. Sant Samaj upholds all the priniciples of Sikhi. They have practised rehat Maryada and also show us the way of life. Whenever there is a real issue facing the panth, Sant Samaj has given us the way. It is not wise to criticize Sant Samaj. Father can only give wealth to son, and then its upto son to use this wealth in any many different ways to benefit from it and others. Father is Guru Son is Sant Wealth is Gurbani Rehat Maryada is the way to use this Wealth So to us the rehat maryada followed in Sant Samaj maybe different as we percieve but in reality its all within the borders of Sikhism. So please think twice before saying anything wrong to Sant. It will not bring anything good to us. Also I would request all to read the following: 1. Please read 13th pauri of Sukhmani Sahib again and again before saying anything. 2. Interpret the meaning of 'Sant' from Gurbani and not from what we think. And as we call 'chele', even if he is serving such a 'Sant' as depicted in Gurbani then he is 1000 times better than us, who sit ideally and kill our time talking about others. [%sig%]

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Harpartap Singh · 30 Sep 2005

Jarnail Singh Arshi As usual your posts are full of hate and cannot see beyond your own viewpoint. You take every opportunity to rubbish those who try to follow the preaching done by Damdami Taksal. What is there in the Gurmat Rehat Maryada as published by DDT that is against Gurbani? It is strange that people like you are against certain symbolic practices conducted in Guru ji's House but are in favour of retaining others i.e. why is the chaur acceptible and the chanani, and dhuuf isn't. There are many practices which took place in a royal court and were practised in Guru ji's Darbar, but nowadays people know better!?!? A principled stand would be to reject all such external paraphanalia but I don't see you advocating that. As for your argument about those who are against the Julian calendar adopted by the SGPC (NOT the Panth) as being agents of RSS - this is a complete joke. There are many of us who take a principled stand on this and yes, our view point is in NO way against Gurbani or Gurmat. Rather the motivations of those who raked up this issue in th first place is suspect for creating further divisions where there were none before. And as regards the isssue of women doing Paanj Piaray seva - what sort of logic leads you to conclude that those not in favour are agents of RSS? Sant Giani Jarnail Singh ji Bhindrawalay took a stand aginst this practice - so how is it that those who follow hhis line in this matter are in league with GOI? It makes no sense...

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Singh · 30 Sep 2005

Harpratap singh you said what practice of Taksal is against Gurbani? The first answer is why cannot bibian do keertan? Why when the rehat maryada says that bibian should all wear dastaars, why is it not imposed? Also Dhumma still has to explain the havan thing? Sevak, sorry but I disagree sant is not the son. Gurbani is everything, a sant only has saintly virtues because of Gurbani. But the sant samaj does not even have that. Why have they taken no stand on sant rapists, but they have enough time for stopping bibian doing keertan.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

AS · 30 Sep 2005

An awesome post, We All Got Names. Everything you said was 100% true and I admire your honesty. After reading your post...it made me wonder about how foolish we all probably sound bickering over anything and evrything. Instead of pointing out everything that's wrong around us, we ALL should look in the mirror and point out what's wrong with ourselves and then go about changing that and making ourselves better. Just like you, I too am a Mona who has done all kinds of stupid things in the past but through listening to Gurbani and learning about how great the Khalsa was and still is, am starting to change my ways. I still have a long ways to go and am no where close to being as good of a Sikh as I should be. Even if you do feel like something is wrong in the Panth, there is a constructive way of getting your point across and a destructive way of getting your point across. What I see on this forum is quite destructive at times. Even if the person is making sense and has a good point, he or she usually says it in a way that is full of arrogance and sometimes even hate. Not the way to do things. If we want to bring people together and into the folds of Sikhi, people should be taught about their mistakes with prem, pyar, and respect. We have neough external enemies that we can show our wrath to, why show it to your own fellow Sikhs. Sorry if this sounds cheesed out or sappy, but I seriously think we need to reexamine the way we treat and look at others. They're probably not worth much...but they're just my 2 cents. Bhul Chuk Maaf Degh Tegh Fateh

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Guru-Charan-Preet Kaur · 01 Oct 2005

Jarnail Singh Arshi As usual your posts are full of hate and cannot see beyond your own viewpoint. <<<<<<<<<<<<< Really veer wake up....or at least READ the DT Maryada/ and books by the Sant Gyainis of DT. There are at least 300 BLATANTLY ANTI GURMATT Statements written down there....and I am NOT talking about Channian and chaurs or dhuffs... THESE are SMOKE SCREENS !!! to make it look like we are all making a BIG FUSS baout dhuffs and chaurs.. we are NOT..we are concerned with anti-Gurmat... An example of a BLATANT ANTI-GURMAT and ANTI-GURBANI statement is one by SANT-GYANI-PANTH RATTAN_VIDYA MAARTAAND_KHALSA..etc etc.s Gurbachan Singh Khalsa in his book on Maryada Called GURBANI PAATH DARSHAN.. 1. Pg 15..Guur Ji har Rai Ji married 8 times... 2. PG 18..Guru Teg bahadur ji "sent": the Gurgadhee from DELHI.... 3.PG 22..a Pati Barta Lady stopped the SUN from rising becasue her husband died.... The SUN..DOESNT RISE..it is THERE ALWAYS..it looks like rising ebcasue the Earth spins on its axis...and IF ir Ever STOPS Spinning..it will SELF DESTRUCT IMMEDIATELY... And statements like''READ this Particular shabad so many times in such amanner..and One will WIN the Court Case.. ( Funny with DT having so many such Mahapurashs..FAILED to READ this SHABAD to win the Court case of Ex Jathedar Ranjit Singh....who lost and went to JAIL....Avar Updesseh aap na kareh.. I leave you with your "LOVE" ( since all i do is HATE ),,and waste time reading that NONSENSE. IF I begin to PUBLISH all those anti Gurmat statements one by one...this lekh will becoem too long. For the moemtn just answer the ones I have raised above back them up with GURBANI TUKS PLease.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

... · 01 Oct 2005

Author: Harpartap Singh "What is there in the Gurmat Rehat Maryada as published by DDT that is against Gurbani?" Author: Gurmat Rehat Maryada as published by DDT: "A Singh must look upon his wife as his faithful Singhni and a Singhni should look upon her husband as Parmeshwar(God)."

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Singh · 01 Oct 2005

Pati Parmeshwar concept is against Gurmat BIG TIME!

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

. · 01 Oct 2005

"1. Pg 15..Guur Ji har Rai Ji married 8 times..." Sixth Guru Ji married three times and Guru Gobind Singh Ji married three times. This is supported by numerous scholars. Of course you can disagree and we can have long debate over it but that is not the point. Just because you disagree with something doesn't make it anti-gurmat. So please provide sources which prove your point. I look forward to it. "2. PG 18..Guru Teg bahadur ji "sent": the Gurgadhee from DELHI...." Really? What did it look like? Guru Arjan Dev Ji sent gursikhs to tell sixth Guru Ji to adopt Kirpan. Guru Harkrishan Ji gave hint of "Baba Bakala". So it was a message that was sent not an actual seat for Guru Ji to sit on. "3.PG 22..a Pati Barta Lady stopped the SUN from rising becasue her husband died.... The SUN..DOESNT RISE..it is THERE ALWAYS..it looks like rising ebcasue the Earth spins on its axis...and IF ir Ever STOPS Spinning..it will SELF DESTRUCT IMMEDIATELY..." The story of pati barta is a hindu story that is used for an example and it does not mean every woman will be able to do whatever she wishes. I think the story is related to paras raam who is well mentioned in Gurbani. It is also mentioned that Indar cried after getting infected but it does not mean Guru Ji believed in these stories. Using stories as an example is one thing but believing in them to be the truth is another. We can just ignore this story and come to Sikh history. Bibi Ji from Kabul used to come to do seva everyday and returned home at night. You are probably familiar with how she took care of her infant son. This story is wrong also? Bhai Randhir Singh Ji floated in the air - not possible according to science. Bhai Rama Singh Ji said that 10% of a person's naam kamayee goes to his wife. I did not understand it but I cannot say it is anti-gurmat because I have no proof to prove it wrong. "And statements like''READ this Particular shabad so many times in such amanner..and One will WIN the Court Case.. ( Funny with DT having so many such Mahapurashs..FAILED to READ this SHABAD to win the Court case of Ex Jathedar Ranjit Singh....who lost and went to JAIL....Avar Updesseh aap na kareh.." Yeah I read the same thing in Kala Afghana's book. he is the best isn't he? Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 02 Oct 2005

Page 166..a man became greedy and ate too much Karrah parsaad degh...and he became a LEPER...because the Leprosy Patient had doen this degh and ardass to get cured...Sukh Sukhee !! What a load of BS ( BIG TIME) Page 179..All the Devtas, 84 Sidhs etc came to "help" Guru arjun Ji at His Shahedee and amd all the Mughal Soldiers UNCONSCIOUS..... what a fantastic piece of "new history"....then what did the unconscious soldiers do ?? and what did that accomplish ??..Further..when he saw this "act" Sai main Mir also fell down UNCONSCIOUS...wah wah wah History hoveh taan eho jihee..with such "history" who needs Fairy tales ?? Page 188 Guru Gobind Singh Ji used to listen to the entire Akahnd Paath STANDING UP....and for hsi daily Ishnaan..Guru Ji would have Water poured over him while standing listening to the Paath... Page 195..Do SAMPAT PAATH for 40 days..Har KARAJ SIDH HOVEGA ..Why doesnt DT do this and Make the KARAJ of the SIKH KAUM SIDH ?? ( Dhumma tried this but it FAILED..as the Sikh kaum is till LOST !!! imho we have enough.... i suggest we let this can of worms be kept closed...however if Harpartap Singh Ji wants he can back it all up with Gurbani/authentic Gur Ithias...and I will accept....otherwise accept that DT maryada is full of HOLES/Heavily BIPPARISED and Anti Gurmatt on hundreds of Counts.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

confused · 03 Oct 2005

Hey guys The rumble in the jungle is being repeated for the nth time: AKJ vs DDT Great comedy material and you guys want Khalistan Good Luck!!!

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

agyani · 03 Oct 2005

2. PG 18..Guru Teg bahadur ji "sent": the Gurgadhee from DELHI... _____________________________________________________- a sikh bought guru sahibs "sees" to guru gobind singh. THATS HOW THE GURGADHEE GOT THERE. lol sant baba gurbachan singh had more gyan then everyone put together on this "unbiased" board and all the fake gyanis etc and the chele of these gyanis (lol) so i dont see where you "youngins" pop up from and claim to know more then our elders (sant baba gurbachan singh KHALSA)

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Oct 2005

Author: agyani Date: 10-03-05 06:25 2. PG 18..Guru Teg bahadur ji "sent": the Gurgadhee from DELHI... _____________________________________________________- a sikh bought guru sahibs "sees" to guru gobind singh. THATS HOW THE GURGADHEE GOT THERE. lol sant baba gurbachan singh had more gyan then everyone put together on this "unbiased" board and all the fake gyanis etc and the chele of these gyanis (lol) so i dont see where you "youngins" pop up from and claim to know more then our elders (sant baba gurbachan singh KHALSA) >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Then answer this..who brought what and from where..when GURU ARJUN JI were martyred in Lahore ?? Is the "SEES" of a mArtyred Guur bestowal of Gurgadhi ?? MY answer is that GURU TEG BAHADUR JI bestowed Gurgadhi on Guru Gobind Rai Ji BEFORE leaving as He knew He was not coming back..JUST like Guur Arjun Ji sahib knew that he wouldnt be coming back from lahore. but since you lols know so much more....tell us.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Harpartap Singh · 04 Oct 2005

So called 'Gyani' ji If it wasn't for the likes of Sant Jarnail Singh ji (who you would have called a brahmanised Sikh) - the Qaum would still be asleep... You apply a double standard - accepting certain miraculous stories connected with the Guru Sahibs and Gursikhs and discounting others with no basis... May Guru ji cleanse you of this hate you have inside you for your fellow Sikhs

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

agyani · 04 Oct 2005

lol i cant remember the sakhi but what i do know is that the sees was replaced by another sees in order to make the mohgul guards think that guru sahibs sees hadnt been taken. This was done by a sikh and he sacrificed his own father in order to do this.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

. · 04 Oct 2005

"MY answer is that GURU TEG BAHADUR JI bestowed Gurgadhi on Guru Gobind Rai Ji BEFORE leaving as He knew He was not coming back..JUST like Guur Arjun Ji sahib knew that he wouldnt be coming back from lahore." This may be true but please tell me me your sources. It is always good to study our history with some rationality. I think it is written in a book by missionaries that Guru Ji sent the message of giving Gurugaddi to His son. Guru Ji was accompanied by five Sikhs. Three became shaheed and other two took the Sees back. I may be wrong so explain more and provide sources. "but what i do know is that the sees was replaced by another sees in order to make the mohgul guards think that guru sahibs sees hadnt been taken." Agyani Ji, this point was refuted by Sant Kartar Singh Ji. According to him this was an insult to Shaheedi of Guru Sahib. In his katha he very well explained it. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Oct 2005

veer HarPARTAP Singh jio, Your name means Har PARTAAP..but you seem to see only HATE in anybody who opposes your ideas... I am sure you will heap praises on me if i agree Haan Ji Haan Ji with you.i have met alot of lols like you.... NO MAN IS 100% PERFECT. ONLY GURU JI is ABHULL. That is GURBANI if you have read any of it. So there goes your argument that i take "certain" facts about Jarnail Singh Khalsa Gyani Gurbachan Singh Ji and REJECT Others..well that is Absolutley RIGHT becasue they can be RIGHT on certian things and 100% WRONG on other facts....you do ADMIT they were HUMAN ?? or are you trying to tell em they are GURU/GOD/WAHEGURU SAMAAN ?? Just an example..ANY ONE who OPPOSES WOMEN as EQUALS in KHALSA is 100% WRONG. Just QUOTE one Tuk from GURBANI thta says this is RIGHT.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

AVTAR · 04 Oct 2005

Jearnail singh Gyani ,You also normal man, maybe you are making mistake, Regarding women in panja pyare .if guru gobind singh did not choose any women in panj pyare why should we included. are we better than guru ji or guru ji also make mistake? Gyani ji, There is alot of sewa to do. Why ,only this sewa left for my sisters or mothers.Sewa is something you wont fight for.why cant my sister or mothers take the role of mata shaib kaur.For me guru gobind singh is almighty god, if he want one of the panj to be women than there will be. why only when women are in panj pyare than only they have equal rights? please dont waste your time for this stupid arguements. Regarding damdami taksal, This taksal have done alot of good for the panth. regarding rehit,those who follow this rehit ,they lay their live for panth ,but people like me who are not following any rehit are question about damdami taksal. dumma did not change any thing in the rehit.so why we must say he is wrong.please gyani ji do good for panth.dont divide the panth. you are doing what india goverment is doing. before attack most people accuse sant baba jernail singh ,he is india s agent,congress and ....... but the truth is the whole SGPC is agent for india goverment. Thora, badla longwal and many others are sikh panths traitors.so the rehit of SGPC i hav doubt. gyani ji in 1978 akj and damdami taksal went together against the nirkari. both accept each other rehit .why now we allway bring up this issue. We should be together and get our khalistan gani ji.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

KK Singh · 05 Oct 2005

Well said, AVTAR.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 05 Oct 2005

Avtar singh ji, Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh OF course i am human and i am wrong on many many counts. I would be very stupid to contest that. But to say SGPC Rehit is "wrong" because of badal/Tohra/Longowal/etc etc is a FATALLY WRONG MISCONCEPTION. The SGPC REhit was formulated nearly 75 years ago...by the entire Guru Khalsa panth for nearly 20 YEARS of discussions and consultations...long before badals and tohhras were even born. ( This Rehit should not even be called SGPC Rehit...its CORRECT Name is AKAL TAKHAT APPROVED SIKH REHIT MARYADA. ( 1935) I too would like to see some "additions and modifications" in the AKAL TAKHAT Approved Sikh rehit maryada..but i dont reject it outright. I would love it if you could quote me a few Gurbani tuks where Guru ji says it is OK to ....some sewa for MEN ONLY and other sewa for WOMEN ONLY. SO far NONE are forthcoming from any sources. Thank You.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Singh · 05 Oct 2005

Although I don't always agree with everything Gyani Jarnail Singh says and I am dubious of his so called multiple students who post here, his posts are always full of life and character no matter what the subject of discussion is and always tend to bring a smile to my face. And many are actually very informative. Keep it up!

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Gurpreet Kaur · 05 Oct 2005

There aren't a lot of Gurbani Tuks which order us to do anything in terms of Rehit really, or are there?

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Guru-Charan-Preet Kaur · 06 Oct 2005

dear gurpreet kaur jio, this equality of ALL KHALSA is NOT a question of "REHIT" per se. Guru Ji has clearly stated that in Gurbani when they said "So kio Manddah akheaayeh jit jammeh rajaan.... so NO ONE has any RIGHT to EXCLUDE women from anything just on the Basis of GENDER as is being done. By the way the so called "consultation committee" set up to discuss this has so many Sants ( who have already publicly declared their "DECISION - NO WOMEN UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES"...and there is not a SINGLE WOMAN on the Committee ?? How can anyone expect a sane balanced decision from such a sham committee ?? as such it is 100% true that this is a "nanavati Comission" to sweep things under the carpet. I wonder why no such "comittee" was set up to discuss Raagmala ?? Meat eating...Question of Banis...etc whcih are more important issues of REHIT than this. GSK

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

A Singh · 06 Oct 2005

The point is everyone has ‘smoke-screens’ and everyone thinks that their ‘brand’ of Sikh Maryada – for that’s all it is, is the ONE and ONLY true rehit – the fact is that the AKAL THAKT has made things perfectly clear, this is not the maryada of the SGPC, have a read over the text, despite claims that it sounds like the ‘articles of the CoE’, it is in fact a document written after much elaboration and consultation with ALL Sikh groups – those who left these discussions, have also left with them the legacy of followers who retain their “my way or the highway” attitude, hence the poster above is absolutely correct:… DDT and AKJ desire “Khalistan” and yet even in the virtual world they cannot see eye to eye – I guess, they are right though it will be a “Khali” stan – “khali” of any reason and rationale, as the continuous ramblings on forums indicate.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

singh no 2 · 06 Oct 2005

<<<<<<<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>>>>>>> If you look up at the make-up of this Committee, it represents a broad cross section of the Panth, making up all major Jathebandis, Taksaals and prominent personalities of the Panth and relevant opinion-holders. Just because it may or may not reach the decision you want does not invalidate the committee. It's very arrogant of you to think that only you know what Gurmat is, or what the Panthic stance is. You are entitled to an opinion ... but to argue that all others are wrong and ManMattiyas is completely bigoted of you. For your information, there is a Bibi on the committee - Bibi Inderjeet Kaur, the current Chair Lady of Pingalwara.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

A Singh · 06 Oct 2005

<> Remarkable lady and a great set up (pingalwara) –one which is paving the way forward for the Panth.

Re: PANTHIC ORGANSIATIONS SPEAK UP AGAISNT SANT SAMAJ

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Oct 2005

YES there is indeed ONE lone Bibi in the Group of 13.....many of whom have also publicly declared that they dont want BIBIS.... But I can assure you NOTHING will come out of this committee.....can anyone remember how many other comittees set up have delivered their decisions ?? But as many have said..let the matter rest.... RIP....with this latest committee.