Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

long .. but do let me know wheather i m wrong or right..

long .. but do let me know wheather i m wrong or right..

confused/or may be not · 28 Sep 2005

reading many topics on different forums .. i want to put some views and i want to know one thing .. that each and every religion has similarities .. like : 1. god is one 2. god is love, infinite, universal, in every one , on this urinverse 3. get rid of ego, lust, anger, attachment,greed 4. love everyone, help everyone, share with everyone, care for everyone, don't hate anyone, forgive everyone who hurst u 5. remember god all the time. 6. do good for mankind since god is only in human beings [i know sikhi teaches more of it that god is in everything from humans to worms] 7. be happy with what god gives. 8. become like god. QUESTION : **aren't you guys get/got confused that each religion teaches same.. so how we [sikhs] are different ?? cuz i was/got confused.. or don't u guyz when read bani .. sometimes doesn't ur mind says that others says samething??.. lolll mine does.. so i m trying to figure out*** and now VIEW: cuz god tried to make them remember god .. so offcourse .. jot will come out of each and every religion .. since god tried and tried .. and each got failed .. but i don't believe that .. god can't fail .. god must have some plan .. seeing that .. if each and every religion has similarities and teaches everything same ... how come each religion .. has kamiya [weekness] if they say truth .. like hindu religion .. not criticizing any religion here.. if that religion speaks the truth then why they came to guru sahib for protection .. how come that religion didn't have strength to fight mughals???? .. why they were changing ??? same with chrisitians .. we all know that they used to believe in reincarnations .. so if that religion also speak truth nothing but truth .. then how come they got week and they changed .. if that bible is word of god .. then how come god didn't have enough strength to protect his words [bible] from who destroyed it and changed it ??.. islam .. if that is also truth .. word of god .. then how come islam and christianity .. form from same root .. so how come they r fighting ??? are there many many gods ??? like hindu gods.. jesus [god] .. allah ??? or one god ??? sikhi teaches us what everything was hidden from christians or wrong things too, , or wrong things in islam, or teaches that number of rituals won't get us to god .. and that all these good things or good deeds would not get us to god .. but only NAAM .. gurbani teaches us that we are god[following the path of gurbani .. there will be no difference between us and god we will be one].. and other teaches us that be like god ..may be that's why cuz of NAAM .. in all history of every religions.. there was one person who fought with his head on his hand and won that battle.. or one person who got cut in half and still NAAM or GURBANI can be heard by a person who was cutting that sikh .. or one person who got cut into piece by piece but still didn't cry .. or say ouch .. or one person whoes khopdi got cut but he was still alive.. and the person who got his khopdi he died first ..or one sikh/guru who sat on tatti tavi but nothing happend to him .. or even those ladies who wore their kids bodies around their neck .. but never said one word .. or question "why god? " that means women are strong not weak as other religions teaches us. yes there was also one person who got on the cross, but he only got four/five nails in his body. no sacrifice is bigger than the other one .. true .. he got sacrificed so that people can be safe from sin .. or for mankind .. so that people come to jesus .. not saying jesus said that .. saying what bible says .. but if he did so that people get rid of sin .. how's that possible?? .. wasn't that a sin that one of his diciple did chugly and people got scared that he is making new religion and got him killed??? that means sinner is saying that he got sacrificed to save us from sin???? or that means one of his true diciple said that he got sacrificed for our sin....i still don't get it.. i mean if he got sacrificed for our sin .. what about other religions who follow same teachings what jesus said .. that means even though they follow same teachings but still they gonna go to hell.??? means more than half of the world will go to hell ??.. may be sure jeus would have known that he is gonna get killed or whatever .. i mean if he did get sacrificed then how come bible or his teachings got changed or lost, or burned or hidden??? i figure out that first they killed him and then changed his teachings for politics .. after all that was kaljug.. it also point a questions .. that still his sacrifice got wasted since after his death .. his teachings got changed ?? that he got sacrificed for our sin but still what was the use .. sin was still there?? ok . so guru sahib's teachings are similar as other religions and there are some changes too .. .. so how come it didn't fail .. many many other religions tried to change sikhi .. or change sri guru granth sahib ji .. then how come bani didn't change?? .. how come bani tell us everything b4 science find out about life , about universe, about galaxie , etc. that means religion and science goes together. right?? if other prophets would have written their teachings then i m pretty sure that they would have said all the right things about science. if other religion prophets would have written their teaching with their own hands .. then i guess they wouldn't have failed either. but since .. human wrote those teachings but not prophets .. so they are finding out errors in their religions or finding out what were hidden from them... now we read other religious prayers which says good things about God .. our heart cries .. why cuz it is prayer about god .. mine does .. does any one else heart cries when u hear lovely prayer about god in different religion?? every religion teaches or say their views .. jesus will save mankind.. mohammad will save mankind .. or ram/krishen will save us in the end .. i mean i don't get it .. i read bible .. i read quran .. and i read little about bhagvat gita .. and little bit of gurbani .. found same teachings .. reading bible, quran .. and bhagvat gita i found out one thing .. that yes they have jot .. and they does make us believe that we are light .. we have god in us .. to get god we have to come out of kaam, krodh, lobh, moh, and ehankar and earth or heaven also made of light. and to get god or become like god .. we have to respect everyone, forgive everyone, share with everyone, love everyone, help everyone, cuz god's character are all these [love, share, respect, forgive]. i mean if they wouldn't have jot then i guess there would be no uddhar or people who are not sikhs.. i mean they would have been killing everyone, hate everyone, i mean more than half of the world would be animal.. or act like animal.. so keep on track some light was important to them also.. If prophet [jesus] was really send by god .. .. and we know he was send by god .. so wouldn't it be possible for him to say that no one will save u but only one god?? but he didn't say.. read bible and i didn't find one line says..that "god will save u .. no one can but god can" he says i will save u .. come to me and i will save u .. he was a messenger of god .. so why would he say "i will save u" .. but not god?? i m pretty sure very sure that if he would have written bible with his own hands .. then yes he would have said samething as guru ji says .. god will save u.. no matter what religion u r in... same thing goes with mohammad.. he also got killed but no .. we know and those people [christians, muslims] alsoknow that bible or quran wasn't written by their prophets. on the other hand .. guru ji says .. god will save u .. no matter what religion u r in god will save u .. and why guru ji says that "gur bin mukht hui [in anand sahib]" .. to my understanding .. i figure out that each religious books says that "i will save u" or "kill everyone[kafir] cuz they don't believe in me that i will save u" if gurbani wouldn't have come then i m pretty sure .. everyone would have killed everyone .. no peace at all .. christians would have killed other religions cuz they don't believe in jesus .. or islam would have killed others cuz others don't believe in mohammad.. and seeing the history if there was no gurbani then we all wouldn't been muslims and killing kafirs... reading gurbani figures out that and get knowladge that not even jesus can save us nor mohammad or ram .. but only god .. if gurbani wasn't been there then i guess we all humans would be in this soch that what are we .. or who will save us .. jesus .. ram .. or mohammad.. guru ji says "gurbani will get us mukhti" .. i don't think guru ji says that i will save u .. i mean if guru ji have said samething as other religion says .. then loll .. there would have been another new religion by now .. or new phrophet.. loll .. gurbani is a the mixture of all teachings .. and plus one thing more NAAM .. if other religions would have naam .. then im pretty sure none of them have got weak that they wouldn't have either changed thier believes or hide them or kill others.. by meaning of "gur bin mukht hoye" b4 guru ji came everyone was killing everyone .. for their religions .. no one knew that neither jesus will save us or mohammad but only god .. we came to know about this from gurbani .. guru.. cuz gurbani is direct word of god .. that's why no one able to change it yet.. and can never .. we all know .. that first all gurus were sikhs .. sevak .. and then they became guru .. and what ever they teach us in gurbani got from their guru b4 him .. and guru nanak dev ji got it from god .. akal purkh .. waheguru .. that's why guru nanak dev ji said "gura ek deh bhujai sub na jiya ek data so mai visar na jai" .. that my guru taught me or teaches me all people or jiya has one god .. sikhi is the only religion in the world which says women are equal .. hmm .. interesting .. if other religious prophets have written religious scriptures with their own hands .. wouldn't it be possible for them to write that women are equal??? .. if not that mean god change mind ?? people who said menstruation is a curse [sorry i m being too open here] science now found out that it is the only way for a life to give life .. that means it is a blessed curse .. loll .. reading other religious books find out taht women are week .. how ??? if women are week .. then how come we tolerate men .. loll .. or pain to give life .. if there were no women then there would have been no men .. so now if god gave blessed cursed to women to bring new life to this world .. then how come it is impure .. that mean baby who is born of same blood is also impure doesn't matter if that baby is he or she??? now other religion says that women is born of men's rib .. interesting .. i mean if that women who was born of men's rib so the baby she would gave birth to either boy or girl .. would be of rib .. but not those five element??? so that mean men's rib =women= baby boy .. right??? cuz that rib woman gave birth to a baby boy so that baby boy is also made of rib .. right ?? if women is not equal .. then according to me .. first there would be no men .. man without woman is nothing .. and woman without man is nothing .. that means they hold 50 50 right?? so i read that other religiuos books said that women are the reason of lust .. they can give nothing but birth to lust .. so men should be carefull .. y .. men has no brain how to control it .. is it women's fault that god mad them beautiful .. woman would be walking with no intention that there is a man who eyes are on her .. that mean it is still woman's fault .. so if woman is the birth of lust .. that mean woman who give birth to men .. he is also give birth to lust??? if jesus and mohamadd would have wrote bible or quran with their own hands .. wouldn't it be possible for them to write that drink [vine or any kind of drink and tobacco is bad for health] i think vine also consider as alcohal right ???? but in bible jesus says .. drink vine in my remembrance .. really would that be possible for god to change mind time by time ????? i get scared or shocked that wow .. and how these christians. muslims or hindus are doing good things that guru ji tell us .. but i guess if they wouldn't then keep on doing bad things then no one would be able to reach heaven .. and do good deeds so that can get good deeds in next life and reach god ..or become one with god so there will be no difference between them and god.. i mean guru sahib would give them chance to do effort to good deeds so that u can come near to god day by day or life by life .. i was thinking one thing .. i could be wrong but want to share .. christian people says that dead will come alive .. didn't guru ji did that ??? first guru call them .. first they died and the became alive with amrit .. thanx .. please do let me know when i m wrong or right ..

Re: long .. but do let me know wheather i m wrong or right..

Jasmin · 28 Sep 2005

Yes, both are resurrection stories. The Amrit end the cycle of rebirth, because of the strength of the sacrife. Those who take amrit are off the ride. Follows of Jesus have a more dualist view, imagining an ideal abode, rather like the Hari Krishnas. In the end, maybe you just have to follow heart/gut. Maybe you are over thinking? WkjkWkjf

Re: long .. but do let me know wheather i m wrong or right..

... · 28 Sep 2005

1. god is one 2. god is love, infinite, universal, in every one , on this urinverse 3. get rid of ego, lust, anger, attachment,greed 4. love everyone, help everyone, share with everyone, care for everyone, don't hate anyone, forgive everyone who hurst u 5. remember god all the time. 6. do good for mankind since god is only in human beings [i know sikhi teaches more of it that god is in everything from humans to worms] 7. be happy with what god gives. 8. become like god. >>>>>>>>>>> 1) Some religions don't believe in God (Budhists and Jains) others don't believe in just one God. 2) God according to the Semitic scriptures is NOT in everyone and everything. God is very much separate from his creation. 3) I don't think all scriptures really believe this. God is angry in the Semitic scriptures and so if they worship an angry God, they'll be angry as well. The 5 vikaars aren't really avoided the way they are in Sikhi. 4) No, Islam teaches to hate and smite the "non believers". Those not accepting Christianity and Islam are bound to hell so how is that love? 5) Remembering God at all times; they teach God is near at all times, but remember him? I don't think teh concept of simran exists in those religions. 6) as noted before, God ISN'T in humans according to Semitic religions. God Isn't at all according to the Bodhis and Jains. 7) I guess that can be said. 8) Saying that you can become like God is a sin in itself in Islam. It's not conceivable. All religions are not alike. Naam is only available in Gurmat. No other path compares to Gurmat.

Re: long .. but do let me know wheather i m wrong or right..

Harjas Kaur · 28 Sep 2005

[quote]aren't you guys get/got confused that each religion teaches same.. so how we [sikhs] are different ??[/quote] Every religion is people's best understanding of the reality of God. So every religion will have some truth in it. If you study language, you will also see this. Every language comes from a root language. And every root language has words in common. What is there to be confused about? It has never been that only Sikh religion has all the truth, and no other religion has any truth. If this were so, we would be like the Muslims trying to convert people. What is unique about Sikhi is that we have the shabad. This is pure and direct transmission of truth. All the truths of past religions are uncorrupted in the Siri Guru Granth Sahibji. Does this mean there is no truth in any other religion? No. We believe that errors have creeped into many other religions. But every religion is welcome in Sikh Gurudwara, because Guruji respected and welcomed every religion as a path to peace, to truth and to God. Guruji defended the rights of Hindu's to be Hindu and not be forced to convert to Islam. Why would he do this if there were no truths in Hindu religion? Yet Guruji was not a Hindu. He was not a Muslim. He taught very high truths, which if you study any religion in the world, you will find even in ancient scriptures thoses truths in the Gurbani. Because Guruji gave us true bani. What you will not find in Gurbani is changes, deletions, corruption, fanciful superstitions, rewritten sections, added sections, invented sections, imagined sections. Because Guruji was so recent, the direct bani is preserved entire, and Guruji put his jyot into it. So it is a living Guru. Every religion has a path to follow to obtain understanding and liberation. But God gives you a Guru. If God gives you a Satguru, and you don't listen, you can follow whoever you want. No one forces you. There probably have been many Guru's through the ages. But the only Guru you will ever have is the one God gives you. So if you don't follow him, you can't get liberated. You have to pray for God to give you a Satguru. And when you find your Satguru, he is a priceless treasure, cling to him with everything you have. Satguru gives you the reality of God, whole, entire, without anything missing. Guruji is my Guru, he is a Satguru. So I don't have any doubt, any question, any concern if someone else has a beautiful truth. I read poetry of all religions. I enjoy all beautiful truths. But I can find them ALL in Gurbani. Every beautiful truth of any religion can be found in Gurbani. So Sikh people aren't missing anything at all. We have a complete truth. And we can bless members of every religion knowing that we have our own. May the sangat please forgive me for any errors, they alone are mine. Gurbani is freedom from error. I recommend if you feel confused or concerned. Stop studying other things and just get grounded in Gurbani. Then there is perfect guidance. [%sig%]

Re: long .. but do let me know wheather i m wrong or right..

yes · 28 Sep 2005

hanji u r right .. .. see if u read old testament u will see god is angry .. but if u read new testament .. u will find that god has no form and is not angry .. but in old testament u will find that ..

Re: long .. but do let me know wheather i m wrong or right..

confused/or may be not · 29 Sep 2005

harjas kaur ji ..i m really sorry .. if i have hurt ur feelings .. i was trying to express my views here how sikhi is different .. like i said i was confused and shocked .. now when i read where guru ji says 'raam rahim puran quran anaik kaheyo mat ek na manyo" i understand why guru ji said that .. cuz there were/are too much errors .. still sometimes when i come to the tuk where guru ji says .. about shastra vad or anything that they couldn't find end or beginning of god or they are wrong .. then i get feeling that why guru ji said that? is guru ji insulting them or .. telling them that with rituals can't find god??