BSB Randhir Singh afraid of Hinduism ?
bobo · 30 Sep 2005
This is an esssay from Jasdev Singh Rai (on GLZ) he says that Bhai Sahib was afraid of HInduism so much that he made Sikhi into a Chritianised faith. He later talks about the Singh Sabhas failures and other pro-nang views. what does the sangat think? From: jasdev singh Date: Tue Sep 20, 2005 6:56 pm Subject: sikh studies in the west dear jagpal singh ji no conspiracies, the enemy is among us and not us. it is our failure to critically evaluate what we have been indoctrinated for 150 years and which indoctricnation is becoming complete with every generation of sikhs. Edward Said managed to recover islam from this to some extent. Rushdie has however thrown a poisoned spear into his work. Khomenei took it to another extreme of rejection of indoctrination but had to concede to teh logic of modernity to soem extent. Gandhi saw through this and was able to recover Hinduism to some extent from this, Nehru on the other hand was complertely indoctrinated and remained Gandhi's biggest problem. Gandhi lost in the end but interestingly the 'Maths' in Hinduism started to recover their lost place in Hindu dharma. Vivekanand reinterpreted Hindu dharma with this doctrine to some extent and Dayanand was the complete product of this indoctrination producing a semitised version of Hinduism. the BJP is a result of these. Radhakrishna on the other hand set Hinduism to some form of recovery but Indira gandhi destroyed his work. Manmohan Singh interestingly is completing her work. among Sikhs, the singh sabha movement was the first partial product of this indoctrination, unable to reconcile some of the most complex aspects of Sikhi, they had to leave these concepts alone. Bhai Randhir Singh saw through it, but his fear of the Hindu influence distorted a proper recovery and ended up with a version of Sikhi with some semitisation. The Akali Dal was a confused product of this with its village majority critically evaluating the indoctrination of sikhi in public sphere. Baba isher Singh rarewala understood the indoctrination and has set in motion an attempt of recovery, but it has again misfored. kala Afgana is the complete version of the indoctrination and the baton now is in teh hands of the scholars.,