Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Is this a sikh version of Nanavati Comission ?

Is this a sikh version of Nanavati Comission ?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 30 Sep 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. The Jathedars of the Takhats have set up a "comittee" that will decide whether to allow Sikh BIBIS to do sewa of palki/Kirtan/Panj Piyaras..etc. Today, the so-called High-Priests of Sikhism have set up their own Nanavati Commission to somehow find a way, if the stated Commandment of the Guru..SO KIO MANDA AKHEEAH JIT JAMMEH RAJAAN.. could be successfully manipulated and overturned to sustain the “Bipar Tolla’s” sentiment of keeping the woman as a “Pairan Dee Juttee”. The names of the members of this Commission as reported by the Tribune (Sept 27, 2005) are; ….. Mr. Gurpal Singh Gora, senior vice-president, SGPC, Baba Daya Singh, Baba Sewa Singh (Rampur Khera), Baba Sewa Singh (Khadoor Sahib), Bibi Inderjit Kaur, chief of Pingalwara, Dr Balwant Singh Dhillon of GND University, Sant Ghala Singh, Mr Tarsem Singh, Chairman Dharm Parchar Committee, DSGMC, Mr Satnam Singh Chandigarh and Mahant Tirath Singh. In the present day Punjab settings; the big & long Titles of Babas/Sants/Mahants etc. are as a general rule, a good gauge about the “Biparish” training & thinking of any individual. Therefore, with so many Babas/Sants and Mahants on the Commission, if there is anyone who thinks that there is any intention of providing a a fair deal for the Sikh woman, then one got to be kidding... So we go the way of the "nanavati Comissions" of the GOI....years pass..new reports come out..yet Parnalla otheh da otheh....back to square one..NO ACTION... Sad Day...

Re: Is this a sikh version of Nanavati Comission ?

Singh · 30 Sep 2005

this is a case of RSS getting their own way via their favourite messengers called Sant Samaj. Basically nothing will happen. No report will ever be submitted because the committee itself will not be able to agree. Just like no report has ever appeared about Dasam Granth. Basically a political way to push everything under a carpet and hope it disappears......

Re: Is this a sikh version of Nanavati Comission ?

Reply · 30 Sep 2005

Giani Jarnail Singh ji, This commission is long overdue. These mahants are not appointing Kaurs into the Panj Piyare -- they ought to get some sort of punishment. But some sort of punishment would also be in order for the originator of all of this. I think his name was "Guru Govind Singh ji". The fact he never appointed any Kaurs into any grouping of Panj Piyare (after Baisakhi 1699) even when he had the chance to and when there were such great women as Mata Bhag Kaur available proves him to be a total sexist. (Don't say there were no qualified women available--that's the excuse sexists always use.) He should certainly get some exemplary punishment. Maybe there could be some leniency, though, for the fact that he apparently did not understand Guru Nanak Dev ji's bani or Gurmat, understanding of which has only now descended upon the denizens of certain missionary colleges. [%sig%]

Re: Is this a sikh version of Nanavati Comission ?

Singh · 30 Sep 2005

Reply be very careful. Stopping binging Guru ji into your own Manmat. Gurbani does not back you, so you have no right to use Guru ji name in that way.

Re: Is this a sikh version of Nanavati Comission ?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 30 Sep 2005

Dear reply Ji, Singh Ji is absolutley RIGHT. DONT QUESTION GURU JI. ...or we will get people asking why oh why...wasnt Baba budhha Ji..appointed GURU....why oh why wasnt Bhai gurdass Ji appointed Guru ji ..were THEY "not capable" ?? lacking ?? in what way ?? IF Bhai gurdass Ji can scribe the entire Guru granth ji..why cant his one line be included ?/ etc etc..etc etc GURU JI KNOWS..we DONT. PERIOD. THESE ALL FALL UNDER the BLASPHEMY CLASSIFICATION...as YOUR "questions"....and inuendoes... Quote GURBANI....or the Rehatnamas..Sikh histroical Traditions...Books..if you have anything to say. Thank You. Jarnail Singh.

Re: Is this a sikh version of Nanavati Comission ?

Reply · 01 Oct 2005

Giani Jarnail Singh ji You are right that the above post does not contain specific references. Although I had given references/analysis in other threads (which you might not have seen), I won't go into those again here because in another thread, Zorawar Singh ji has stated that Sri Akal Takhat has called for suspension of (open) discussion. So I suppose we should just let things cool off. I want you to know that the Gursikhs opposing this Panj Piyare move have the best intentions at heart of the welfare of the Panth in Dasam Patshah's hukums, and not some sinister dera-vadi agenda. I hope that's the same for you. [%sig%]