Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi
Gurpreet Singh · 02 Oct 2005
Didn't he apologise for that mistake?...I'm just curious. I heard that in one of Bhai Sahib Parminder Singh Ji's Katha
Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi
tarrandeep kaur · 02 Oct 2005
shut up, how can you call him a saint, if he insulted guru gobind singh jee???
Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi
Zorawar Singh · 03 Oct 2005
Gandhi never belived in peaceful agitation. he always encouraged the Babbar Akalis, as they were the only ones who fought an underground campaign. But then Baba Kharak Singh started the Gurdwara Freedoom Movement. This involved 50-100 Sikhs doing Ardas as Siri Akal Thakht sahib, then going to various Gurdwaras and freeing them from British control with peaceful agaitation.
The movement was so succesful, that in 1920`s the British had to hand the keys to all the Gurdwaras back to the Sikhs.
Gandhi was shocked how successful sikhs were. He was also jealous of the popularity of Baba Kharak Singh. So he got Baba Kharak Singh jailed, and then announced he was starting a new movement to free India by peaceful agitation.
It was Baba Kharak Singh jis policies that made Gandhi famous. gandhi being a typical brahmin, stapped Sikhs in the back and does everything to maintain power and popularity.
Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi
SinghNature · 03 Oct 2005
>>Gandhi was a saint
Dont make me laaaaf! Mohandas Randhi was much a Saint, as Hitler was a saviour of the Human Race.
Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi
SinghNature · 03 Oct 2005
Nice Post and clearly shows Randhi in his true light as a feeble human being with a twisted intellect
Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi
most_liberal_extremist · 04 Oct 2005
Gandhi was a typical hindu who was into casteism and PURITY of high castes.He was a RACIST.Kindly read the following:
http://www.thetruthseeker.co.uk/article.asp?ID=2419
What do we know about this “great man”?
His motivations were to become “father of nation” but he never clarified what he meant by “nation”. Sikhs already have a father - Guru Gobind Singh Ji. If he was talking about hindus then since when did hindus become a nation? When British occupied rest of the India and went to war with Sikhs, one of the generals wrote “Now we are going to war with Sikh nation.” This is very important statement because he used the word
“nation” only for Sikhs and not for any other hindu or muslim kingdoms. By 1930 Gandhi had started referring himself as “bapu”. He was quick in changing stances. At one time he would say “If I and congress..” and other time he would say “I am not in congress so I am not responsible for their actions.”
For him Guru Gobind Singh Ji was a “misguided patriot” but at the same time he loved the stories of Krishna helping Arjun to fight his own brothers in the battlefield. Little did he know that whereas Guru Gobind Singh Ji fought for freedom and justice, his savior
lords rama and Krishna fought for personal gains and preached nothing new. Their lifestyle was completely dedicated to caste system and idol worship. His lords fought wars and killed people by attacking from behind but he himself adopted non-violent method. Gandhi himself believed in caste system so how could he be “father of nation” since majority of the Indian people in his eyes were inferior to Brahmins (12% of Indian population)? Guru Gobind Singh Ji fought for human rights. Sikhs have all qualities of a Nation and thus their father Guru Gobind Singh Ji is the real Father of Nation.
He also said “I ask Sikhs to give up Gurmukhi Lipi which has no foundation and uniqueness. They should adopt Devnagri which would prove their loyalty to the country.”
.
What he thought about his countrymen is expressed in his following words:
"We [Indians] can only be granted the responsibility of freedom once we learn to civilze ourselves first. [like the British]"
And further he said:
"I would give up the finest sons of India to save the British empire in it's dying hour"
A man who not only submitted to foreign rule but also tried his best to save that rule is a true coward. His barbaric and contradicting speeches make no sense whatsoever.
Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi
Straight Arrow · 04 Oct 2005
Author: most_liberal_extremist
Date: 10-04-05 13:18
Gandhi was a typical hindu who was into casteism and PURITY of high castes.He was a RACIST.Kindly read the following:
http://www.thetruthseeker.co.uk/article.asp?ID=2419
My dear most liberal extremist. Just one question. If only the typical Hindu believes in the purity of castes, then what are you? Your email Id is:
[address removed]
If that does not signify your underlying racism, I don't know what does.
Please note: I am, in no way, trying to justify what Gandhi did or did not do, or whether or not the "typical Hindu" believes in the caste system but only to underline your duality. You are very quick to criticize but your own ID reeks of racism, else why have JATT in your email ID?
Thank you.
Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi
most_liberal_extremist · 05 Oct 2005
Dear brother straight arrow
sat sri akal
I am a worm among all the worms on this planet.Yes,i was into jatt jatt thing in my life and its then I made this Id.I have changed a lot now.
I was wrong but GANDHI WAS WRONG TOO and the world doesnt know about it.Indian historians have made this hypocrat old man into a PEACE GOD.
If gandhi was present during nadir shah and ahmad shah abdali times,his bald,small famine indicator head would have been removed in a second and this PEACE god would have rested in peace.
I was over proud of my caste(thanks to the punjabi videos and punjabi environment in general) but I never thought of purifying people of low castes.Infact whenever i saw some old sikh driving richshaw etc I feel like giving him so much money so that he doesnt have to drive richshaw again.
Jatt was more of a bravery and no fear type image for me rather than
thinking in terms of upper caste and lower caste.
take care
KHALISTAN ZINDABAD
Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi
JEEVAN SINGH · 02 Jan 2006
KHALISTAN ZINDABAD !!!!
KHALSA WILL HAVE RAJJ ALL OVER INDIA
[%sig%]
Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi
GUNGU IN HIS OWN WORDS · 07 Jan 2006
A HYPOCRITE, LIER, RACIST, OPPRESSOR AND A BIGOT... IN HIS OWN WORDS!
"Being a Hindu Gujrati myself… I only wish that institutions will crop up all over India and be the means of preserving the Aryan Religion in its purity!" ....
....from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.4 pg.407)
[The Hindu, 28/10/1896 Visit to Hindu Theological High School]
A baffoons idea about the formation of Sikhi
".. he [Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji] accepted the reasoning of Kabir and made similar attempts to fuse the two religions. But while doing so, he felt that Hinduism should be defended against Islam. This gave rise to Sikhism and produced the Sikh Warriors." ...
.... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.4 pg.407)
[25/3/1905, speech in Johannesburg]
This prat will not let it go!!
"The influence of Mohammedanism on Hinduism gave rise to Sikhism and it brought out one of the chief characteristics of the religion, namely, tolerance, in its true light and fullness." ...
... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.4 pg.376)
[11/3/1905, speech in Johannesburg]
Gungu has the audacity in insulting our Gurus, desh mesh pita and obviously lacks knowledge or blessings of our Gurus.
"The Sikh Gurus.. were all Hindus and that Guru Gobind Singh was one of the greatest defenders of Hinduism." ...
.. from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.28 pg.263)
[Young India, 1/10/1925]
Pir bulle shah said aboujt Sri SatGuru Gobind Singhjee "I do not talk of the past, nor the future, I talk of now! If it was not for Guru Gobind Singh, the whole of India would have been circumcised and converted to a foreign faith"
But what does ungrateful Gungu Ram say ...
"..Guru Gobind Singh was a misguided patriot because he believed in warfare for noble cause." ...
... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.26 pg.490)
[Young India, 9/4/1925]
Further insults...
"..had I lived as their contemporary.. Including Guru Govind Singh..I would have called.. everyone of them a misguided patriot." ...
... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.28 pg.263)
[Young India, 1/10/1925]
ABOUT UNTOUCHABLES CONVERTING TO OTHER FAITHS
"I don’t mind Untouchables (Shudra) if they do desire, being converted to Islam or Christianity." ...
... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.48 pg.98)
WHAT ABOUT CONVERTING TO SIKHI?
"Today I will only say that to me Sikhism is part of Hinduism. But the situation is different from a legal point of view. Dr Ambedkar wants a change of religion. If becoming a Sikh amounts to conversion, then this kind of conversion on the parts of Harijans is dangerous"
"If you can persuade the Sikhs to accept that Sikhism is a part of Hinduism and if you can make them give up the separate electorate, then I will have no objections to Harijans calling themselves Sikhs."
... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.63, pg.267)
This shows that Gungu had unrelenting hatred for the Guru Panth and the Guru Granth.
WHAT DOES "MAHATMA" GUNGU HAVE TO SAY ABOUT THE KIRPAN?
"The Guru has not said anywhere that you must grow your beards, carry Kirpans(swords) and so on." ...
... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.68, pg.2)
[Talking to Khudai Khidmatgors-I on 15/10/1938]
"Today the Sikhs say that if they give up the Kirpan they give up everything. They seem to have made the Kirpan into their religion. By discarding it, they think., they will become weak and cowardly. I tell them, this is idol fear!" ...
... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.68, pg.2)
[Talk to Khudai Khidmatgors-I on 15/10/1938]
GUNGU AND GURMUKHI
".. I wish you would persuade enlightened Sikhs to take Devnagri script in the place of the Gurmukhi." ...
... from "(Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.64, pg.41)
[Letter dated 14/11/1936 to Amrit Kaur]
The COngress Leaders obviously have shown their true mettle..
"I venture to suggest that the non-violence creed of the congress party is the surest guarantee of its good faith… and our Sikhs friends have no reason to fear betrayal at its hands ..For the moment it did so, the Congress would not only seal its own doom but that of the country too. Moreover, the Sikhs are a brave people, they will know how to safeguard their right by the exercise of arms if it shall ever come to that.
Why can you have no faith? If Congress shall play false afterwards you can well settle surely with it, for you have the sword. I ask you to accept my word. Let God be witness of the bond that binds me and the Congress with you." ...
... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.45, pg.231-33)
[Young India 5/3/1931]
".. We have not done justice to the Sikhs." ...
... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.38, pg.315)
[Young India 5/3/1931]
LETTER FROM LALPAT RAI ...
"Our Sikh friends deserve all the praise one can bestow on brave, noble, sufferers in the cause of truth." ...
... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.22, pg.25)
[Letter from Lajpat Rai dated 3/12/1921]
GUNGU RAMS RESPONSE...
"I fully endorse Lalaji’s tribute to the Sikhs. Their resolute behaviour, their religious fervour, their calmness and their suffering command my highest admiration"...
.. from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.22, pg.25)
[Young India, 15/12/1921]