Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

Singh · 03 Oct 2005

Gatka mix tape volume 2 is now on-line....BREATH TAKING!!!! http://www.gatkaonline.com/

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

Guru-Charan-Preet Kaur · 03 Oct 2005

very good

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

moorakh · 03 Oct 2005

aaaaawwwwwwwwweeeeeeesooooooooommmmmmmeeeee

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

dsingh · 03 Oct 2005

it was the craziest video i have seen,u must watch it.

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

--- · 04 Oct 2005

i think the background music could've been swapped for Thadi Vaaran or something. THe music doesn't fit in with gursikhi martil arts

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

dsingh · 04 Oct 2005

i think the music goes really well with the video,i think the video is targeted to the youth who listen to hip hop music,and they relate to it.i can understand where u are coming from though,but the music is a very hype you up kind of music and i think it really works cause seeing that video,i really wanna learn gatka,its so amazing.

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

moorakh · 04 Oct 2005

amazing video!!!!!

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

oh · 04 Oct 2005

the music is good... we must remember, its not the music thats bad, its the lyrics. Did you know that for hundreds of years, tabla and vaja has been used for girls dancing around to lustful songs?...does that mean we should stop using tabla and vaja in Kirtan? I think the music actually brings about alot of BIR-RUS!!

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Oct 2005

Good...very Good. I enjoyed it with my family...

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

DDT · 05 Oct 2005

i liked the first one better. volume 3 should come back to T-dot

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

--- · 05 Oct 2005

hmmmmm... Yes I kinda see where ur coming frm 'dsingh' and 'oh'

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

DDT 2 · 05 Oct 2005

nah this one's wicked, "ddt".. dont hate! spread the love.. one akhara, t dot india or surrey maaaaad video man i loved it.. The end is wicked too

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

DDT · 05 Oct 2005

i still think the video is wicked but i want some t dot singhs in it 2. nex time we should mix it up. atleast Ustaad Bhai Charanjit SIngh ji was in it, he helped out in toronto 2. i still got love for the B.C Singhs. and ya i loved the end. that little kids my hero.

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

DDT 2 · 05 Oct 2005

yea we should mix it up next time, tru. one akhara one love. the kid rocks it at the end and when bhai charanjit singhs face shows with bhai parminder singh and bibi rena kaur it's krazi

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

Singh · 06 Oct 2005

I personally was very sad after watching the video. Not only was the music completely anti Gurmat but aside from a few moments of good martial arts skills, the rest left me refusing to believe that the techniques practised in this video are those that Guru Gobind Singh Jee practised. Showing this video to any real experienced non-Sikh martial artist they will most likely not be impressed at all. Most the strikes, had they made contact, were completely out of range - it seems none of them were even meant to hit seriously. The fighting on the floor just appeared ridiculous. Other than that the majority of the video was fast repetitive swinging of a stick/sword/two swords in a particular motion. Sorry if I have offended anyone, but these are my views after watching the video. It really seemed a case of style over substance.

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

DDT · 06 Oct 2005

singh you have no clue wat ure talking about. kirpan or lathi spinning was a technique used back in the day. wat else are u gonna do when ure fighting like 100 ppl stand there and wait. it is also mostly demo stuff so its meant to look impressive. any non sikh martial artist would recogniise the immense amount of skill involved in the vaars that the singhs are doing. unless u no for sure that ure better then the singhs dont critisize.

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

Singh · 06 Oct 2005

"DDT" there is no need to be rude. I have shown other similar clips to non-Sikh martial artists and they have not understood. Please show these clips of people fighting from outside striking distance (often just hitting each others shields) to an experienced non Sikh martial artist and tell the result.

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

sooooo · 06 Oct 2005

So are you guys saying that these people should hit each other with swords and kataars? I don't think many people are willing to fight to kill each other. I know that some of the stuff in the video is for show, but the fact is that if it came down to it, you would obviously not purposely hit the other guy's shield (and i don't think the guys playing Gakta in the video would either). But remember...THIS IS A DEMOSTRATION...nobody is trying to kill each other here. It is a display of the kinds of vaars one could use in a fight. So, YES they are purposely hitting the shields, but show me one video, where they are not...and you will see people dying or losing body parts. I have seen Singhs fighting for real, but only with Sotis...so, you will get bruised, but can still fight the next day.

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

DDT · 06 Oct 2005

look Bhai Charanjit singh taught them to block with their arms fully extended. it looks like they are aiming at the dhals. they arent aiming to kill with every blow. however singhs here in toronto have actually tried and they ahve been injured badly.

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

dsingh · 06 Oct 2005

seriously why do people have to hate,so u dont like the music,what is it that u dont like?there is no lyrics in the music at all.if you go to a sporting event,do you complain about the music there.there is absolutly nothing anti-gurmat about the music,because there is no words,its just a beat.the whole gatka mixtape was born out of the basketball mixtape scene,where there is people slam dunking the ball,doing three throw shots ,doing crazy moves,set to music that gets the crowd excited.well thats excactly what the gatka mixtapes are doing,trying to showcase their skills,and the people who dont like the fact that their not actually attacking each other,well think about it,the have swords in their hands.do you want them to kill each other,their all family,brothers and sisters.their not fighting against the mughals.it's all about showcasing there skills,not killing each other.if you have nothing positive to say,please dont say anything at all.the gatka mixtapes are put out to make people feel good,not for them to be spit on.

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

DDT3 · 06 Oct 2005

video kiks!!!!!!

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

singh1 · 06 Oct 2005

the performances of singhs on ther own spinning shasters shows many of them are very skilled.

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

daas · 07 Oct 2005

WOW !!! what a great video !!!!!

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

DDT · 07 Oct 2005

gatka mixtapes also help get other people involved. someone mite think gatka is interesting and they mite learn more about which will probably get them more involved in sikhi.

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

guest · 07 Oct 2005

People shouldn't hate so much unless theyd be ready to face any of those Singhs in a match. You should look at the positives, quite honestly, the video inspired me to fight and brought up my blood pressure, inspiring me to learn more gatka. Plus obviously its just a demo and showin how you could fight in a real fight, Singhs have got hurt before playing this shaster vidya when they couldn't block properly or something, but obviously if ur doing it in a demo, ur trying to use proper blocks so you dont get ur fingers cut off, and in some cases u see that one singh was about to hit the other singh but stopped, showing u could use that in a real fight, but u wont cuz its just a demo.. This kinda shaster vidya also helps you in day to day fighting, it makes you a lot more confident and you learn good ways of how to hit someone or target them, even with ur kirpan or fist. Thats what we were taught

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

again · 07 Oct 2005

it just shows the power of the khalsa youth. It was also inspirational to see some singhniya getting up in there. At the end also it is really cool, it looks like everyone is really fighting in jung

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

AS · 07 Oct 2005

Some people jus gotta hate no matter what....Singh, u should get out there and show them how it's done, brother. Since you know how gatka shouldn't be done, then you probably know how it should be done, right? Teach all of us poor moorakhs. Anyway, I really appreciate the prem and pyar that these Singhs and Singhnis must have put into learning the Shashter Vidya. Unlike so many Sikhs today, these young men and women haven't made the mistake of forgetting about the Siphai aspect of Sant-Siphai. DEGH TEGH FATEH

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Oct 2005

I agree. Take this just as a demo/entertainment/practising..reviving the martial traditions in sikh youth..whatever. Perhaps you people in Canada get to see alot of this stuff...BUT in MALAYSIA such a "tape" is a sight for "sore eyes"....i take whatever i get. Many things "MAY" be "wrong"..not done professionally enough..or whatever....the bottom line is THEY DID IT..made an EFFORT..lets not knock them down for small imperfections if any....ENCOURAGE them ...please. I am sure they will get better with time and practise... Bole So Nihal Sat sri Akal..Carry on Singho..I look forward to Tape 3..and 4...and 5...and.....many many more Jarnail Singh

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

singh1 · 08 Oct 2005

there should be a ddt/akj gatka mixtape, that would be wicked.

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

-- · 08 Oct 2005

what do u mean get better? they're already wicked. Unless you can do better Anways yeah I'm looking forward to the next one too an it'll be cool if it has the different locations mixed like singhs/singhnees from everywhere

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

Singh · 09 Oct 2005

Firstly I am not "hating" on anyone. I don't train in the style of Gatka specifically so unfortunately I would not be able to help them. In the modern western world learning to wield a long stick is not particularly helpful when the majority of the time encounters would be unarmed or with small weapons (bottles, knives) in very small spaces. If this particular style of Gatka is so effective could you give examples of Gatka practitioners who have sparred with students of other styles (eg, Kali, Escrima, Arnis) Apologies if I have offended - these are my views. I do not believe what is practicised in this video is what Guru Sahib did. If it is then why is Gatka not a more successful martial art? Could a practitioner of Gatka stand up to a well trained practitioner of a Filipino stick fighting style, or empty handed would they have a chance against a Jiu Jitsu or Wing Chun practitioner?

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

DDT · 10 Oct 2005

a friend of mine went to his uni's boshido class for fun and other stick martial arts. he has been doing gatka for about a year and he murked all of them. there is hand to hand gatka its just not as prominent in the western world. lots of singhs in india now how to do it its just no one teaches it here and if they did it wouldnt be in a demo. overall i think someone who knows shaster vidyia would be able to stand up to some other martial art practitioner even if there un armed. gatka makes u have very good reaction time and overall strength.... plus they would be a singh/singhni which is a trump card on anyone.

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

dismayed · 10 Oct 2005

The video is excellent! All credit to all the Singhs and Singhnian on it. Plus to the person who said it should be DDT and AKJ Gatkha. It has Uptej Singh Gatkha Akhara who are jatha singhs, so it is a mix. But we should not care about groups. They are all Panthik. My only uphappy moment was the initial scene, where it have the logo. It has Baba Deep Singh who is Panthik, and belongs to everyone. It is wrong of DT to associate him with their group. Baba Deep Singh was beyond any group. The only people who accept that Baba Deep Singh was a jathedar of taksal is Taksalis. I feel it is wrong for them to place such great people in groups, and pretend he only belongs to them.

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 10 Oct 2005

vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefatheh!!! This is a message to "Singh" above. Our ustaad Bhai Charnjit Singh ji taught us that "gatka" is actually the term for a 39-inch stick used in old sparring / practice fights in the battle field. Some of real weapons used were kirpans, sheilds, knives, different types of arrows, bows, khandas, chakkars, and other shastars. There were many techniques that our ustaad taught us, and at the end of almost every class he would spend at least 20 minutes on a lecture about battles faught by Sirdar Hari Singh Nalwa or Nawab Kapur Singh or Baba Banda Singh Bahadur or Baba Deep Singh Jee. He had a treasure of knowledge on the history of shastar vidya from the first wrestling matches between Sikhs in the 1500's and upto Baba Buddha Jee and Guru Hargobind Sahib and upto Maharaja Ranjit Singh's time... he understood the depth of Shastar Vidya. He taught us that Shastar Vidya is not just stick-fighting, and there is a philosophy, a mentality, a physical training, and a depth to it. Shastar Vidya is the most comprehensive and best martial art in the world, hands down, but most people don't know what it is about because it has been reduced to stick-fighting only. There is a lot more to shastar vidya than you think, Singh jee, and this video was only a 12 minute glimpse of demonstrations. You have to remember demonstrations are just that, and they are done by people from all ranges of experience. Some of the techniques might have become watered down over the years, but that doesn't have anything to do with the akhara or our ustaad Bhai Charnjit Singh jee, as he gave us a wealth of knowledge and teaching. It is my misfortune that I have dropped away from gatka but I had to step in to reply to your allegations, which are understandable but inaccurate. please forgive my mistakes vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefatheh!!!

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

DDT · 11 Oct 2005

ustaad bhai charanjit singh was wicked. i wish i had started learning gatka earlier i never even got a chance to talk to him. but from learning from the people he taught u can tell how amazing he was. and the Shaheed Baba Deep singh ji gatka ahara is associated to DDT oviously so thats prolly y the connection was made

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

ddt2 · 11 Oct 2005

bhai charanjit singh was an amazing singh not even just in gatka but in so many ways, his knowledge was just endless. He knew so much about sikhi, bani, bana, shaster vidya, sikh history, wow He really was the kind of gold that comes out of a taksal True soorma, he was, and I'm positive he could've beat any jiu jitsu wing chun whatever, because he had the fight inside of him as well as outside. Amazing singh amazing

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

Waheguur · 12 Oct 2005

No offence, but singh is a moron! I have studied martial arts for many years before and when i started learning gatka i picked it up very quickly. The basic hand movement the footwork and getting your blody to flow with the hands and feet adn very similar in most martial arts. HOWEVER one thing which i had to spend hours and hours on practising ws simply to spin a sodhi. You need to do this to losen your wrist up and allow it greater flexibility and strength. That is the only way u can do fast strikes and blockes is by continually practising these so called "swings". That stuff where they are just swingin is a demonstration of their skills, showing their hand flows, their footwork and their co-ordination. I have trained people who were totally unco-ordinated at the start and are now able to fight with the best of people by teaching them how to do swings, how to move their feet, how to be creative with their moves and showing initiative. Yes some of the stuff they are blatantly aiming at hte shield, but with a sword would u want your 15 year old son trying to do that any other way? Remember the majority of those people were under 20. We may not be as knowledgable in gatka as we once were, but we are rebuilding the art. It is a martial art and its foundations and fundamentals are the same. It teaches u how to move, how to react and respond. Even without a sword if u can move and react as fast as those fighters are, you will do well in a fight against an untrained opponent. and if u do have a stick or other weapon, you will be unstoppable, i've seen other stick/sword fighters work, im currently learning fencing, and for what the purpose of gatka is no other martial art comes close. FATEH

Re: GATKA MIX TAPE VOLUME 2 - NOW OUT!!!

Singh · 13 Oct 2005

Yes "Waheguur" Veer Ji I am a moron, please do Ardas so I can understand more. I can only go on what I have seen watching this Gatka video and studying other martial arts. One question - if this form of Gatka that is taught is so effective why are the Western Goras, Chinese peoples, Kalas not going to learn it in large numbers? We are not talking about improving wrist flexibility or reflexes - we are talking about actual techniques. A university Bushido class is not going to be the best example of Bushido martial arts students - rather you should go to a dedicated, serious club. "Waheguur" Veer Ji you are currently learning fencing? If so I am not suprised you regard the style of Gatka in the video so highly!