Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Muslims, Hindus, and Sikhs

Muslims, Hindus, and Sikhs

Sukhshinder Singh · 05 Oct 2005

In trying to explain my Sikh faith to others, they keep coming back to the fact that we're just hindus who believe in one God (from Islam). Why do people of other faiths simplify Sikhs to just that? As much as I try to explain the wonders of our religion, they do not understand......Please, do not let this turn into an attack on other religions, but rather why sikhism is not differentiated and understood like the other major religions....Thank you for any responses.

Re: Muslims, Hindus, and Sikhs

billa · 06 Oct 2005

somebody else will giv you religious info mine is purely histroical and ethnological. ask these hindus what is a hindu? define a hindu then ask them how sikhs ae defined as hindus? to my knowledge hindu is a word used by muslims to describe a slave or those from the river sindh in india. Sikhs religiously were never anybodies slaves but instead asserted authority from day one. Punjabi malwa clans never payed jizia tax to any islamic authority hence they were never enslaved before or after sikhi. Majority of sikhs from punjab are scythian in descent entering punjab from the north west just a few hundred years before arab muslims. Historically sikhs are not from india by ethnocological lineage to be linked with hindus either religiously historically or by anthropology standards. Muslims themselves however have a pagan history in india and their own emblems ( moon) , beliefs (ritual baths, pilgrimages, credit debit sin accounts, farishtas ( virtual acceptance of devi devtas) ritual sacrifice o meat, veiling ( ancient vedic custom) the site of kabba itself once a home to pagan culture is built on top of an area accustomed with shiv jis private part.

Re: Muslims, Hindus, and Sikhs

Comment · 06 Oct 2005

The word Hindu is a refrence to the Sidhu river. Westerners / Muslims, traveling near the Sidhu river. They noticed local rituals and beliefs and called it Hinduism. The name stuck. The Scythians have been all over Eur-Asia for who really knows how long. The Indian Supreme Court definds hindus as a group that believes in a cyclical time continum, reverence for a guru, reincarnation, vows, ahimsa, the possiblity of mukti. According to the court, Sikhs practice a from of hinduism. Most people on this web site vehemently disagree. To me, this seems academic. All I know is that Sikhi is greater then Hinduism, and I choose Sikhi. I know I can't find Satguru in Hinduism.

Re: Muslims, Hindus, and Sikhs

daas · 07 Oct 2005

i would like to share an experience with the sangat. i had not been to a hindu temple so i was curious what is it about and coincidently a family friend invited me to their function held on a religious day. I asked myself if i would be wrong in attending? but then i came to a decision where i agreed i would not bow to the murtis or sit in the prayer hall but instead walk from the prayer hall entrance to the langar section where i copuld help lay the langar out and then leave. During my stay this is what i noticed. 1) the hygeine levels were bad, parshada were accidently slipped onto the floor and one of the ladies just picked it up washed one side and tried to put it back beforei told her off. ( then a lady complained about gurdwaras strict rules). 2) anyone can wear shoes in the langar section even whiule they serve the langar? so is it langar or just a good old munch? 3) there were chairs inside the prayer hall where the men would face the women rather than the chairs facing the murtis this was odd. 4) it appeared there was no rehat no codes to abide by, men and women freely liased openly. It was a big culture shock from a gurdwara. But i did feelk happy i went regardless of how angry some singhs will be with me here. At the end i took a long breath and thanked God i was on the right path of sikhi. There were many nice hindus there too who i think will one day get blessed with sikhi if they become good hindus, but equally i did feel a great emptiness spiritually when passing in the prayer hall it just felt like an ordinary room. But i did strangely feel positive after seva in the langar and the sangat felt happy upon seeing me. My conclusioon was although in one part i felt slightly positive on th seva side of it ultimatly i realised out of attending the place i did not gain spiritually. It was more like a social event. I have learnt sikhi and hinduism are worlds apart sikhi is not just unmatched it provides so much as a pillar to our lives that we just take for granted, but spiritual people will always feel some good vibes to each other whatever their religion. From that experience my resolve in sikhi and faith strengthened i will not be visiting a mandir again i see no need to, but it was an educating experience to understand more about hindus and this often more than repeated mantra of how sikhs and hindus are alike. I failed to see the affinity and similiarities at all other than showing respect to hindus on an individual level and recieving the same. [%sig%]

Re: Muslims, Hindus, and Sikhs

desidalip · 09 Oct 2005

Are you CRAZY? You went to a Hindu mundir! You are definitely a horrible Sikh!!! Sikhs these days thihk they can do anything they want. You can go worship Shiva and Guruji the next day. That is not Sikhi. I am very disappointed in your choice.

Re: Muslims, Hindus, and Sikhs

??? · 09 Oct 2005

Word hindu is not mentioned in any religious books of "hinduism" veds purans upnashidas manuu simrtee gita or ramayan. word hindu is an islamic invention to describe thieves, slaves or infadals on india. early invaders called the river sindh "hindh" and people living near the river also called hindhu. pershion and arabic poets also used hindu word to describe blacks people of india. [%sig%]

Re: Muslims, Hindus, and Sikhs

singh-2 · 09 Oct 2005

www.whyichosesikhism.com

Re: Muslims, Hindus, and Sikhs

LionKing · 10 Oct 2005

On this website you can find major differences between SIkhi and different religions.. http://www.sikhs.org/religion.htm Hope that helps.

Re: Muslims, Hindus, and Sikhs

Singa 5 Singa · 10 Oct 2005

The word was coined by the Old persians for the people living east of River Sindu, which is the present day river Indus running through pakistan.Most of the attacks by the persians were made from the border with sind, the indus was reffered to as the sindu river in sind. They referred to the people livingeast of the river sindu as hindu-meaning dogs>.....they were not able to fight the invaders...and the invaders treated them like slaves and dogs...that is how the word came about.I cannot remember but this can be found in the persian history and older annals of punjab and Indian history. This is factual.

Re: Muslims, Hindus, and Sikhs

**- · 11 Oct 2005

Singa 5 Singa Yeah those pathetic Hindus hey? Hindus are a such a poor excuse for human beings aren't they? Bet this makes you [Sikhs] feel real good about yourselves...bravo

Re: Muslims, Hindus, and Sikhs

khalistani · 11 Oct 2005

y is there always hindu bashing going on just go on ure path let the other go on there path bol vaheguru bol raam dont turn into those jehvoahs witness who have nothin better to do than tell u ure religion is 100 percent lie travle ure own path let other travel theres do veechara if others willing, peacefull, to LEARN but left the bashing and arguing bhula chuka maf