Forum
Caste or Class?
Caste or Class?
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 08 Oct 2005
Having read on numerous occasions about caste and Sikhi, I would like to share the following thoughts. I recently saw a BBC documentary about toilet cleaners in London and this made me think. It was a comment from a person featured on the program, who said there are very few British people doing cleaning jobs anymore- the workforce is predominantly foreign and many are illegally living here. The person mentioned that this was like Britain's very own caste system- just without the names/structure back in India.
After the program I started thinking about caste problems within Sikhi and how we are failing to escape from caste.
But is it caste or class?? Have a think about the following:
Take a British born and bred doctor. He is well off, has a nice house, car etc and is financially very settled. Is he really likely to marry a girl who cleans toilets for a living? Be honest- it is extremely unlikely- may happen 1 in 500 cases.
Next, in the place of the doctor, take a Jatt (Sikh) living in Panjab, who is amritdhari and has acres and acres of land, big kotthi and is finacially very secure. Would he want to marry a girl of chamaar caste- whether is she is amritdhari or not? (very unlikely, and the number of amritdharis from chamaar caste is extremely low whether we like it or not)
The only difference from the above 2 examples is the girl in Panjab has a specific caste name- the goree does not- she is just a toilet cleaner.
A lot of the time, the caste issue is really to do with class- how many people, if they are honest, do not want a decent husband/wife for their daughter/son. If your son has a degree and is a dentist, how many people would be happy if he married a girl who sews clothes for a living.
The "castes" in the Panjab are all linked with jobs- Jatts are farmers, Tarkhaans are carpenters, Jalahay, Shimbay work with cloth... etc etc etc
Even if you share the same faith, it doesn't mean that alone will be able to hold a relationship together, because the way of life, the expectations- what is accepted and what is not is different for each "caste"
I am not trying to be divisive in any way, but it seems that to rid Sikhi of caste is a harder job to do than we think.
Apologies if I have offended anyone- that is NOT my intention.
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Caste or Class?
pantherz · 09 Oct 2005
singh i understand where you are coming from. Here is my thoughts upon this seemingly endless contradictions of reality and spiritual ideals.
As my quest began some years back in sikhi, one of my main concerns after the sikh youth becoming athiest, family breakdowns and dating was the caste situation in sikhi.
At first glance after reading some inspiring books, and comparing bani, rehat maryada to the current situation we are in i was fired up on a mission to stop jaat paat and felt marriage between different groups would help eliminate this. I talked to singhs singhnia about this most actually agreed with me on an ideal level that we should not have jaat paat and if we carefully study it in sikhi, most of the time singhs and singhnia generally have pyar and allegience in sangat and pangat. BUT there is this one issue of marriage where it suddenly rears its head.
I found no matteer how much bani you qoute against it the situation on jaat paat is no different from now 5 years ago 10 years ago 20 years ago. It is a fact but on the good note its limited t marriage alone from the sanagt i frequent. Some youth do love marriages but this is even more manmutt destroying existing relationships with families. Forcefully trieing to overcome jaat paat actually reinforced it in a very subtle way.
I have found building bridges works a lot better in trieing to understand more about each other. Let it be we cannot force people but let us at minimum keep ekta.
I would like us to be caste free but the reality is different and have found rathr than trieing to change people around you its better to focus on oneself.
Jatts are not the only ones with lands mansions and plots nowdays, hence my belief this is not about material position but more so about existing cultures within sikhi. Rajpoots khattris also own big lands but again there is hardly any ekta between these groups in punjab now or before. But most surprisingly pakistani jatts and rajpoots are virtually the same. Into india the landowing classes have parralel allegiences with each other. This caste phenomena is more strong in the sikh punjabi community out of muslims sikhs and hindus. Only sikhs themselvs know why and why they keep silent on it or find exscuses for it.
Over to the spiritual side singh if there were 2 women one was a jatti one was a chammar i would choose the one with the most rocking chardi kala jeevan purely because thats what i want my life to be about. I want to be closer into the jatha live gurmat and my children to be into sikhi. Whether there are 10 chammars who are amritdharis and 10 million jatts jattis my crux is to marry the one with where i could lead a gursikh jeevan. The numbers mean nothing to me what I look at is quality but understand the situation in the panthand can only respect the wishes of singhs and singhnia to live as per their best in the challenging and changing world.
pantherz
Re: Caste or Class?
informer · 09 Oct 2005
Neither in the case of Jatts.
Jatts are a distinct ethnic group/identity which has no relation to occupation what so ever. I'm sorry if you have little grasp of Jatt history but please refrain from associating Jatts with the Brahmin caste system.
I have previously read some excellent posts on Tapoban regarding the correct definition of a Jatt, please look them up.
Re: Caste or Class?
??? · 09 Oct 2005
Don't worry amritdharis will not abolish the so called cast system but the non amritdharis will.
How?
they marry inter cast but the amritdharis don't.
their children will not belong to any cast. in second or third generation cast system will die in western countries and in punjab. not in india.
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
A Singh · 10 Oct 2005
The problem Pardeep Singh “Bilga” is not the rosy picture you paint of a wealthy Jatt farmer with tons of land and the latest automobile not marrying a local Chamar Girl from the Charmarli, it’s a lot more serious than that:
- in the West there are numerous cases, of very educated and affluent Chamar girls and boys (in many case more so than their Jatt, Tarkhan and Khatri counterparts), yet when it comes to marriage, be she a doctor, rich, educated, amritdhari etc etc, in the view of the Jatt family, whether educated or unpar, she will remain a ‘chamari’.
- it is well known in Punjab, that Jatts and others continue to this date to prey upon Charmaria in the pind and subject them to rapes and abuse, simply because they know they’ll get away with it.
A final interesting point I would like to point and really emphasise – I recently in London, UK went to visit a number of Gurdwaras (Singh Sabhas, Ramgharias and Ravi Dasias). Whilst arguably the first two groups had more land and one or two “nice” buildings (such as Havelock Road, Southall), in the majority of cases, even the affluent and arrogant Jatts and Tarkhans on the boards of these Gurdwaras couldn’t maintain basic tidiness in their buildings – in an overwhelming number of cases, Singh Sabha and Ramgharia Gurdwaras, when I compared them to my experiences at Ravi Dasia Gurdwaras left a lot to be desired in terms of basic cleanliness – rather ironic, given all the stick people love to feed the Chamars and Chooras.
Granted the Ravi Dasia Gurdwaras were typically smaller in size and may have some questionable practices centring around Bhagat Ravi Das, however in all cases, their Gurdwaras were well maintained…again, emphasising my point, despite the social-upgrade of people from chamar and choora background in terms of affluence, wealth, education etc, at the end of the day the Jats and Tarkhans will still look down at them as inferior, many to this day refuse to even eat at their houses.
Then we wonder why they have their own Gurdwaras and why many are not maintaining Sikhi Saroop – again, ironically, if a Chamar or Choora becomes patit (i.e. a mona) Jats will regard them as hindu, yet Jats who are clean shaven will still call themselves Singh and Sardar Jee!
Re: Caste or Class?
??? · 10 Oct 2005
many to this day refuse to even eat at their houses.
i my self remember an incedenth appened about 27 years ago in england i just arrived in england when i with my family and friends went to a guru ravi das gurdwarw. at the end of the programe sevadar asked to eat langer and we said yes we will BUT a jatti said to me r u going to eat ratti here, they r chamars. i said to her that u have eaten the parshad so what is wrong with thelanger to my surprise she showed me the parshad she still had in her hand and said i'm going to feed the birds. her husband used to eat and live in a chamar's house. this is their mentality. even the guru ravi dasgurdwara is a chamars place.
i,ve seen jats cleaning toilets here in england but they r still jats.
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
!! · 11 Oct 2005
look at the heathrow air port majority of the cleaners are punjabana and punjabi adammi and when they go back to india they don't let chamar and choore sit near them. because they are low caste.
Re: Caste or Class?
A Singh · 11 Oct 2005
Dear “???”,
I can also relay a similar account from my great grandfather, this time in a regular Singh Sabha Gurdwara (prior to the emergence of partisan Ramgarhia and Ravidasia Gurdwaras).
The Singh serving Degh was of Chamar background. A fellow sat next to my Great Grandfather felt it necessary to begin rubbing his finger on the carpet as the Singh serving the Degh had touched that part of his hand – the idiot can eat the Degh served from his hands, but can’t stand his hands being touched by the so called low-caste Singh!
My Great Grandfather seeing this pulled out his pocket knife and handed it to fellow and told him “if you’re that hung up on being ‘polluted’ by someone’s jaat, then why don’t you cut your finger off altogether!”
Needless to say, the point well made and an example clearly set for others not to try such stupidity again, at least in the Gurdwara / public (and of course, not in front of my Great Grandfather!)
Gur Fateh!
A Singh.
Re: Caste or Class?
123 · 11 Oct 2005
i feel this is going in a wrong direction to blame jatts or any group.
to make one big khalsa group we have to pull our fingers out and put ourselves into action how much khalsa spirit do we really live? we very quickly pull down hindus on caste but are full of it ourselves. We cannot even live by the basic ideals created by Guru Gobind Singh ji.
Nobody on this site not even the gurmukhs will post gurbani, akal takhat rehit on this so far to give a very simple answer to it because secretly your all into caste.
Re: Caste or Class?
kharral mirza fan · 11 Oct 2005
i just want to say last year i was a builder part of my job involved using a broom to sweep floors. My wife to be is of a chamaar background but her parents own 8 houses and 3 regional 3 offices in the legal bussiness. Now i came from a terkaan family, if my wife to be was penniless i would still marry her, if she cleaned toilets i would marry her because it is her personality her sense of strong punjabiat culture ( very useful for family life and hard to find these days) combined with sikhi and her soul the way she is the reason why i am marrying her.
If you marry a girl for the qualifications she holds then i feel sorry for that girl to end up with you. How meaningful to marry someone for their jageera, vah vah what else can we learn?
I have also seen a pattern used by some singhs here to portray chamars as some dirty dark skinned hindus. My wife to be, her family and the locals at ravidas gurdwara in grove rd (off soho rd birmingham) looks very punjabi and chittey more so than the average punjabi. A lot of sweeping statements made against chamaars are very ignorant i would request the sangat educate themselves and break outof their glass walled singh sabhas and make a few friends.
Sikhi is about spirit and unity of mankind.
Re: Caste or Class?
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 11 Oct 2005
Here we go again- Jatt bashing!
As I stated in my original post- I did not want to offend anybody, but the Jatt bashers have come out in full force!
A "Singh" wrote: "Then we wonder why they have their own Gurdwaras and why many are not maintaining Sikhi Saroop – again, ironically, if a Chamar or Choora becomes patit (i.e. a mona) Jats will regard them as hindu, yet Jats who are clean shaven will still call themselves Singh and Sardar Jee!"
Why is it, A "Singh" ji, that Jatts are expected to keep Sikhi saroop and are criticised for being patit - let's not forget Sikhism came after Jatts were around for years and years, so the migration of Jatts to the Sikh religion was en-masse, like any other group. But whenever a chammaar or other non-jatt becomes kesdhari, people like A"Singh" think "let's pat them on the back" as if they have done some kind of favour to Sikhi by joining. Why treat non-jatts as bechaaray? we are all equal.
As for A "Singh"'s comments on Ravidas "gurdwaras"- leave it out- they smoke outside the building openly and nearly all of them have an adjoining "community centre" where they engage in very Jatt activities like drinking alcohol!!!!
The fact that 2 of the most learned people who post on this site are Sikhs who come from the Jatt background - Jarnail Singh Arshi ji and Kulbir Singh ji, is not some kind of co-incidence.
A- How can you call yourself a Singh and then degrade Sikh gurdwaras and praise a sect (Ravidasiay) who do not even believe in Dasam Pita guru Gobind Singh ji maharaj?
Re: Caste or Class?
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 11 Oct 2005
Please see:
http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=33777&t=33487#reply_33777
...for those (especially A "Singh") who think I am promoting Jatts.
Fact of the matter is, Sikhi has flourished with Panjabi Jatts- they make the backbone of the religion.
Sant Jarnail Singh Khalsa Bhindranwale was of Jatt background - OBVIOUSLY a Singh FIRST AND FOREMOST he mentioned sometimes in his speeches "I am a simple minded Jatt" which was a sign of his humility- does A "Singh" think sant ji was promoting "Putt Jattan de"???...should he have been arrested for daring to mention the swear word "Jatt"
Today it has become a crime to even mention the word Jatt - I personally have met many Chamaars (or Harijan as they prefer in Panjab) who I have eaten with and travelled with back in Panjab- they don't have the same discriminatory view of Jatts- it's over here in the UK where it is always "Jatts this, Jatts that".
How many Chamaars in the western countries take amrit if we are really honest with ourselves? How many actually have respect for kesdharis?
How many of the Ravidas temples take part in shaheedi programs and arrange coaches to protest at the Indian High Commission for 1984?
Doesn't the title "Guru Ravidas TEMPLE" give something away? Where is the khanda on their "flag"????
Re: Caste or Class?
singhs no caste ehktaaa · 11 Oct 2005
pardeep singh ji
before you use a respected singhs name like bhai kulbir singh bhai jarnail singh on using their caste backgrounds be sure to consult them first. As far as i am aware bhai kulbir singh himself totally rejects caste and had on one occasion expressed great remorse at a gurmukh bhai who could not marry in the jatha because of his jaat. Bhai kulbir singh is one of the most anti castist veers around and what inspires him? Sahib Sri Guru Granth Sahib.
There are many ravidas, singh sabbha ramgharia gurdwaras dotted around sikh communities. Please tell us how many ravidas gurdwaras you have personally seen where ravidasis have been smoking? I have only heard of this happening.
Most other gurdwaras including our very own singh sabbhas also have these community halls used for weddings where drink is consumed in adjoining buildings. so whats new?
It seems to me some sikhs here are taking caste too personally.
Bhai pardeep singh ji you are trieing to justify caste in sikhi when Dasam Patshah Himself rejects it.
I believe mkhalsa ji has the qoute which goes something like that person who asks the caste of another sikh is no sikh of mine never was never will be.
Now ask bhai mkhalsa politely for the bani from Dasam Patshah and let us see how much of it you can apply to your original post.
Re: Caste or Class?
singhs no caste ehktaaa · 11 Oct 2005
pardeep singh ji please read the statement by "singh" on the following link. Akhand kirtyan jatha singhs who can arrange rishte will not take part if you request castes.
http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=56541&t=56541
Re: Caste or Class?
preet kaur sanghera · 11 Oct 2005
I will be marrying a singh from a saini background i simply could not care what he was. 3 of my sisters had arranged marriages all ended up in divorce i decided no way jose. I am darn lucky to have found a singh who wakes up amritvela dedicated to the sikh way of life what more could i ask for? To all my singhanis out there you marry somebody who makes you happy and sticks with rehat forget their caste thats a pure sharm wali cheez.
Pardeep singh you need to study sharam naash and karam naash.
ps i hope you will be happy for my marriage :-) waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Caste or Class?
pangha · 11 Oct 2005
caste class no golli mar mere sher eh dekho
http://www.tapoban.org/langar.htm
***[NOTE: proof for the tradition of Bibekee Singhs can be found in the historical records of M.A. Macauliffe who writes "..so amid the general corruption of the religion of Gobind there are to be found about one hundred Sikhs at Naderh in the Dakhan, who are said to have up to the present time preserved intact the faith and ceremonies of Guru Gobind. They have kept aloof from the contact of Brahmins. Brahmin ministrations are not permitted either at their births, their marriages, or their obsequies. Whether they be Brahmin or Sudras who receive the sacramental pahul, all are by this fact admitted within a pale of social and religious equality.
BRAHMIN WEDS SUDRA AND SUDRA WEDS .
No need, therefore, to put their infant daughters to death through fear of not obtaining for them husbands of their own social status, as is the custom among such a large section of the Sikhs of Punjab. And widow marriages, reprobated by Hindus and now consequently by the Sikhs of the Punjab are habitually solemnised with the clearest conscience among the Sikhs of Naderh...At Patna, as at Naderh, the Sikhs pay the strictest attention to the Injunctions of Guru Gobind. Sleeping or waking, they are never without the habiliments known as the "five Ks." So strong is the aversion of the more orthodox among them to Hindus, that they will not even partake of food cooked by their hands. This is carrying orthodoxy a long way, but still further is it carried when they will not partake of food cooked even by a Sikh who has not on his person all the ‘five Ks’" (Macauliffe in "The Sikh Religion under Banda and its Present Condition")
Re: Caste or Class?
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 11 Oct 2005
Dear singhs no caste ehktaaa ji...
the "Singh" I am referring to is "A" "Singh" who constantly uses inverted commas around my name for one reason or another- not THAT Singh whose post you refer to.
Re: Caste or Class?
Harjas Kaur · 11 Oct 2005
If someone cleans toliet bowls for a living, puts up enough money to send her daughter to college to become a doctor, the British doctor may find her an attractive and suitable match. Since they now have profession in common. However, with caste, no matter what profession, the girl would never be given a chance.
Also, the toliet bowl cleaner herself may actually get a better education at some point. Caste is an absolute bar, opportunity isn't.
There are many Indian immigrants of substantial backgrounds who could only find meager labor jobs due to language and cultural barriers. But with opportunity Indians do quite well. So who is to say? If someone's parents were toliet bowl cleaners, it doesn't make them lower class, ignorant and backward. Only prejudiced societies like to form elites to rest on the burden of lower classes, and makes artificial distinctions about the value and devalue of persons. Sikhi doesn't do this.
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
moorakh · 11 Oct 2005
yes, in this age, some people who call themselves Sikhs and they may have even taken khande-ke-pahul will discriminate on caste.
some tarkhans will not marry jatts
some jatts will not marry khatris
some khatris will not marry chamars
whatever...
whoever does this - doesn't matter any of their bhagti
they are NOT GURSIKH.
no gursikh can discriminate on caste.
guru will never be happy with you if you turn somebody away based on caste.
if you turn somebody away due to caste, doors to guru's sach khand will be CLOSED until you ask for forgiveness for this mistake.
Re: Caste or Class?
!! · 12 Oct 2005
harjas kaur
"If someone's parents were toliet bowl cleaners, it doesn't make them lower class, ignorant and backward".
correct
#BUT why chamars from punjab are considered low caste originally it was their job not any caste which turned to be a caste.
but so called high caste people cleaning toilets in england still belong to hihg caste. because of language. point noted.
Re: Caste or Class?
miss kaur · 12 Oct 2005
Part 1
bheerji pradeep singh bilga i too came from this high caste with status but upon taking amrit i am a sikh period!
if you have not taken amrit yet i strongly reccomend it, i believe you have the potential to make a good singh. For you, and these issues bothering yourself i hope the following help.
SIKH REHT MARYADA - DHARM PARCHAR COMMITTEE AMRITSAR
1 ) " A sikh man and woman should enter wedlock without giving thought to the prospective spouses caste and descent." page 26
2) "You have become pure khalsa having renounced your previous lineage, proffesional background, calling ( occupation), beliefs, that is having given up all connections with your caste and descent...." page 37
3) A manuscript written by Ahmed Shah Batalia in 1818 AD and partly published by Sohan Lal Suri in his history book as an appendix to the first volume also mentions the incident of the creation of the khalsa. It reads interalia
4) " I ( Guru Gobind Singh ) wish you all to embrace one creed and follow one path rising above all differences"...
" adopting the way of mutual help and co operation, mix freely with one another."
" Let men of four castes recieve my baptism of the double edges sword, eat out of the same bowl, and feel no aloofness from or contempt for one another.
In the khalsa brotherhood all castes are blended on a democratic basis as all are regarded equal. Though there have been numerous reformers in ancient times who tried to remove the evil of the caste system from the soil each time the disease had outstripped the remedies, for men had gotten into the habit of living with it, nursing the ulcer thriving within the viscera. "
Balbir Singh "The Tenth Master" page 42
5) The untouchable shed their inborn inhibition the men of low orgin put aside their innate repression. they stood liberated.
All the old proffesional labels like that of priests, teachers, bussinessmen, soldiers, weavers, tailors, barbers sweepers were discarded and all were given equal social and religious status.
Re: Caste or Class?
miss kaur · 12 Oct 2005
part 2
The khalsa started on a clean state, he was a monothiest and belonged to the brotherhood for the khalsa God was not only One but there was also nothing except HIM. All that which emanated from God was in a way God himself. Guru Gobind Singh said,
1)Recognise ONE light in ALL HUMAN BEINGS that are known to us.
2) there is no other than God in ALL forms and COLOURS.
3) HE alone resides in all yet all are made to appear different.
(Chaubis Avtar .35 .37 Brahm Avtar .7 .9 Dasam Granth Sahib)
The world witnessed in the unique personality of Guru Gobind Singh a confluence of Bhakti (devotion) and shakti ( power). With the name of God on his lips he launched a revolution through the khalsa.It was a socio - spiritual type of revolution which opened for its participants the gateway of salvation. the Guru taught us love, brotherhood, loyalty and democracy.
Guru Gobind Singh was the renowned leader in the sub continent who taught democratic principles and made his followers regard each other as bhai brother and act by gurmatta.
The Guru had stipulated that the future heir to human civilisation was not the GENOTYPE, a RACIAL group, not the phenotype but the democratic type one who believes and follows up values meaningly manifest in the concious of mankind.
He organised a socio political body of the spiritually awakened but earth aware people who were to spearhead the movement for the liberation of a WHOLE SOCIETY.
He transformed the WHOLE SOCIO POLITICAL SET UP working alongside people for the people, in the interest of the whole people in every sphere of their lives.
Sher Singh has called the KHALSA BROTHERHOOD a GOBINDIAN REPUBLIC.
Guru Gobind Singh thus stood for a new pattern of society a new societal spirit. The position of transcendental self in man not only ensures against reduction of man's essence to an ensemble of social relations but also serves to provide a metaphysical basis for equality of all men. The empirical inequalities - social, economic, political, appear irrational and contrary to the divine theology in the context of the trancsendental unit of all men. Hence the historical thrust of the sikh movement for creating a NON HEIRARCHICAL democratic , egalitarian open society.
After taking amrit devised by the tenth master Guru Gobind Singh all became equal in spirit mind and BODY. The new baptism meant a rebirth of the sikh in the KHALSA BROTHERHOOD.
The KHALSA BROTHERHOOD was the bridge the Guru contructed across the gulf of hate and misunderstanding among different warring creeds. It bought about harmony peace and reconciliation iin a place of strife enmity and animousity. It gave a new ethical and idealistic direction to the individual and society. The khalsa was to have ONE faith One form of worship and ONE code of rules.
Re: Caste or Class?
khalistani machete · 12 Oct 2005
This is not my essay below but prepared by a singh. I just wish to say that If after living in democratic countries outside india which have given you yourselves equality your still finding barriers in sikhs then you will need proffesional help from shrinks to cope with reality. It must be hard to see that old toilet cleaning chammar through education today is well to do driving flashy cars, living in big houses, better looking than you, wearing nice clothes. But what must hurt you more is the bare fact punjabi girls have had enough of guys in old school punjabi culture and call it a day with narrow minded castists, thats the real burning jelousy a desire to create a wedge lets try and bring back the real pride. well son the spell is no longer working. Chammar girls will marry tirkaan guys tirkaan guys will marry cheemba girls, jatt guys will marry whoever they choose and so will jatt girls. Welcome to the year 2005 to your new adopted country outside of punjab. In 10 years no more castes balle balle bilga let us celebrate together with jappees.
1
Most Sikh marriages are organized along the caste lines. Within Sikhs, if a boy or a girl from one caste marries someone from a different caste without mutual consent of their parents, it sometimes turns into a bloody tragedy.
Thus, Jatt Sikh, Saini Sikh, Bhaapaa Sikh, Rorha Sikh, Tarkhaan or Raamgarheeaa Sikh, Mazhabee Sikh, Khatree Sikh, Lavaanaa Sikh, this Sikh or that Sikh, rarely intermarry.
Many Gurdwaaraas are built along the caste lines. In many Sikh villages in Punjab, Mazhabees or Dalits have their own Gurdwaaraas and even separate cremation grounds. Also, even in foreign countries, many places people have separate Gurdwaaraas based on caste system and discrimination.
Many Gurdwaaraa committees are elected along the caste lines.
Many Gurdwaaraa committee members are nominated along the caste lines.
If a group of Sikhs identifying with one caste looses control of management of a particular Gurdwaaraa to Sikhs identifying with another caste, they split and open up another Gurdwaaraa.
Many Gurdwaraas, thus, are built based on ill feelings created by the madness of belief in Jaat-Paat rather than a genuine spiritual cause.
Many times people make donations to particular Gurdwaraas strictly along the caste lines; rather than a just cause.
Many professional Bhaais and Granthees are hired or selected along the caste lines.
Many professional Kirtan singers are invited along the caste lines.
Many social contacts are based on the caste lines.
Political elections are contested along the caste lines (in addition to party lines).
In Gurmat — Divine Teaching or Wisdom of the Gurbani, Sri Guru Granth Sahib — there is no place for the caste system (Jaat-Paat). Baabaa Nanak introduced the concept of a society with no caste distinction. This concept was followed through by all Sikh Masters. Yet, the madness of belief in castes has a very strong hold in Sikhs! In one hand the propagators of the Sikh Dharma mouth platitudes about a casteless society preached by the Masters, but on the other hand, they practice it madly. What a paradox and hypocrisy!
Per Gurmat, any one who believes in Jaat-Paat cannot be a true Sikh; for the castes only relate to the body; not to the Self (Soul, Spirit or Truth). In other words, the caste-conscious person is a material being (Manmukh) who has confounded the Self for the physical body. Consequently, he identifies himself and others as Jatt Sikh, Saini Sikh, Bhaapaa Sikh, Rorra Sikh, Tarkhaan or Raamgarheeaa Sikh, Mazhabee Sikh, Khatree Sikh,Now, there seems to be a new class of Sikhs called Caucasian Sikhs (white or Gore Sikhs)!
What a false pretension! The Gurbani (Sri Guru Granth Sahib, SGGS) roars that the madness of false pride of caste results in two things: Sin and corruption. In spite of such strong warnings and consequences, majority of the Sikhs are inflicted with this grave disease of Jaat-Paat. Having said that, it should be of no surprise to see the prevalence of sin and corruption in the society; including the so-called religious places. In this context, this Gurbani Reflection will attempt to reflect on the following.
Origin Of The Pride Of Caste
Does God, Soul, Or The Self Has A Caste?
Does Caste Help After Death?
Manmukh (materialist) And Jaat-Paat
Gurmukh (spiritual being) And Jaat-Paat
Low And High Caste: What Does It Mean?
The True Caste
Cure From The Disease of Jaat-Paat
Origin Of The Pride Of Caste
Those having the false pride of caste are called "fool" and "ignorant" in the Gurbani. To put it otherwise, as the Gurbani says, those who practice caste distinction and feel pride of their belief in Jaat-Paat are foolish and spiritually ignorant beings.
But, what is ignorance? Material or body-consciousness, which gives rise to false ego (Haume), is the ignorance so much talked about in the scriptures. Opposite of the body-consciousness is the spiritual Consciousness. Therefore, according to the Gurbani, spiritual ignorance or mental blindness is the root cause of this madness called Jaat-Paat or false pride of caste.
Agian andher mahaa panth bikhraa ahankaar bhaar lad leejai: The path of spiritual ignorance is utterly dark and treacherous; the mortal is loaded down with the crushing load of egotism (sggs 1326)
Antar agian dukh bharam hai vich pardaa door payeeaass: There is ignorance and pain of doubt within, like a separating screen between the man and God (sggs 40).
Hayumai meraa jaat hai ati krodh apmaan: Ego, self-centeredness, excessive anger and pride are the caste of men (sggs 429).
Hayumai meraa jaat hai hayumai karam kamaae: This is the nature of ego, that people perform their actions in pride (sggs 466).
All living entities are under the influence of the three modes of Maya's material nature (illusion, conditioned mind, ignorance, duality, etc.). It clings to everyone except the spiritual beings. It affects mortals many ways. And one of the ways Maya snares us into its illusion or hallucination is through our false pride of caste.
Aachaar biyuhaar biaapat ih jaat: It (Maya) impinges upon us through our charactor, occupation, and caste (sggs 182).
Does God, Soul, Or The Self Has A Caste?
Before we seek answer to this question, let's find out if there is any relationship between God, Soul or the Self. According to the Gurbani, in reality, there is no difference between these three. They are virtually synonymous.
Aatam mahi Ram ram mahi aatam: The Lord is in the Soul, and the Soul is in the Lord (1153).
The Gurbani declares that God has no caste. Accordingly, our Soul or the Self is also casteless. If the Spiritual Father is casteless, so are His children. Thus names, shapes, forms, castes, religions, birth, death, etc., are of the temporary material body only. One's Pure Self is free from such limitations. We are time and again reminded by the Gurbani to know this Truth — we are the casteless Self , the "Joti-Svaroop".
Mann toon joti saroop hai apnaa mool pashaan: O my mind, you are That — the true image of the Divine Light — know your Reality (sggs 441).
Then, why so many living entities are engulfed by the razing fire of madness of false pride of caste? It is so because the mortals, due to ignorance, identify themselves with the material body instead of the real Self. A spiritually blind cannot understand this. Why? Because the casteless Infinite Consciousness that the Gurbani talks about is not the subject of unmeaning rituals, lip worship, garbs, ceremonies, mundane history, culture, outer looks, material logic, scholarship, and speculations. Only a Gurmukh or a True Sikh — a Self-realized person — knows it.
Jaat ajaat ajonee sambhayu na tis bhayu na bharmaa: The caste of God is castelessness; He is unborn, self-illumined, without desire and doubt (sggs 597).
Gurmukh jaat pat sach soi: God is the caste and honor of the Gurmukh (sggs 560).
Ekam ekankaar niraalaa. Amar ajonee jaati na jaalaa: The Unique Lord is Peerless, Immortal, unborn, and without caste and involvement (sggs 838).
Naari purukh nahee jaat na janamaa naa ko dukh sukh paaidaa: (Before the rise of material consciousness) neither there was female, nor male, nor caste, nor birth nor did any one suffer pain or pleasure (sggs 1035).
Varan jaat chihan nahee koee sabh hukme sarist upaaidaa: God has no color, caste and mark; by His Will, He creates the whole world (sggs 1075).
The above verses of the Gurbani make it very clear that God is casteless. Also, God has no ancestry or family. Therefore, the Self or the Soul made in His True Image is also casteless. After reading this, it should not be surprising to anybody as to why Baabaa Nanak introduced the concept of a casteless society!
Jaanahu joti na pooshahu jaatee aagai jaat na he: Recognize God’s Light within all, and do not inquire or consider caste, as there is no caste in the world hereafter (sggs 349).
Does Caste Help After Death?
In the end, the body of a Gurmukh (Spiritual being) as well as a wicked person meets the death. But there is a difference in the death of both entities — a pure devotee (Gurmukh) dies in God-Consciousness and links back to the Original Source. However, to the contrary, a wicked person full of worldly nonsense dies in Spiritual blindness (or material consciousness) and suffers repeatedly.
According to Indic scriptures, death means destruction of the material body, not the Spirit Soul. Upon death of the body, the bundle of memories or energy move on to the next field of experiences. And that new experience very much depends upon one's state of being at the time of death. The state of mentality at the time of death is determined by what we practice throughout our life!
Jit laago man baasnaa ant saayee pragtaanee: That Vaasnaa or desire, to which the mind is attached, at the last moment, becomes manifest (sggs 242).
Physical body, caste, material status, titles, power, beauty, name, fame, and so on, do not go along one's Soul. The Gurbani compares the pride of caste with poison. Since the poison's function is to kill, whoever tastes the poison of this false pride of caste dies in Spiritual blindness, and suffers the consequences.
Jaatee dai kiaa hath sach parkheeai. Mahuraa hovai hath mareeai chakheeai: What merits is in the caste? Truthfulness is measured within. Pride in one’s caste is like poison—he who taste it will die (sggs 142).
Dehee jaat na aagai jaae. Jitahi lekhaa mangeeai tithai chhuttai sach kamaae: Man's body and caste will not go with him to the world hereafter. Where one is called to answer for his account, there, he will be emancipated only by the practice of Truth (sggs 112).
Aggai jaat na jor hai aggai jeeoo nave: In the next world, caste and power do not count; the mortal has to deal with new beings there (sggs 469).
Why is it that the body, pride of caste, etc., do not count in the world hereafter? The reason being is that these things are external, hence, not the Real Essence. The Real Essence is the Truth, Waheguru, who is the Divine Substance in all things and beings. He is all there is. Therefore, focusing on external things would be meaningless if this inside Reality is ignored.
Manmukh And Jaat-Paat
According to the Gurbani, one who believes in Jaat-Paat is a Manmukh (egotistic or material being). He is Spiritually blind; hence, without Intuitive Wisdom. His life is perplexed due to ignorance of his True Nature, which is Pure Consciousness. In such a perplexed state of mind, a materialist thinks that this world is solid or permanent. However, the inside reality is to the contrary. The only thing that is permanent is the Spirit (Infinite Consciousness) that pervades within evrybody and everything.
People in material perplexities are called in the Gurbani by different names. Such names include Manmukh, Saakat (faithless cynics), Kusang (bad company), Aatam Ghaatee (self-murderer), Chor (thief), Mayadhaaree (Maya-stricken), Bimukhan (nonbeliever), Jhooth or Koorh (false or fake), nondevotee, demon, beast, idiot, fool, animal, material-being, spiritually ignorant, etc.
Thus, a Manmukh is a stubborn fanatic. Consequently, he suffers from the ailment of duality (Doojaa Bhaav), resulting in his separation from his Source, which resides in the cave of his heart. He has no Intuitive Understanding of the Shabad (Naam, Bani, Hukam or God's Will), the purpose of life, his relationship with God, and the Way of life. Due to such egotistic life, he suffers repeatedly.
Aggai naayu jaat na jaaisee Manmukh dukh khaataa: The body and caste will not go hereafter, and the Manmukh suffers (sggs 514).
Gurmukh And Jaat-Paat
A Gurmukh is a Self-Realized person. By awakening Divine Grace within, he has killed his inner ego. He is a humble being, who is jealous of no one. Ever engaged in meditaion on the Divine (Japa or Name-Simran), he is completely immersed in the Infinite Consciousness, Waheguru. Hence, a Gurmukh is a casteless being. As the Infinite Consciousness or Waheguru is casteless, so is he. All his actions are selfless; for he is purified in and out. He sees the All-pure in all. Being spiritually wise, he knows the Essence of the Divinity as all there is; in everything, everywhere, and beyond measures. That's his casteless caste! This is the sign of a true Sikh. No other mundane qualification matters.
Nanak Gurmukh gian praapat hovai timar agian andher chukaayaa: O Nanak, the Gurmukh attains spiritual wisdom, and the pitch-black darkness of ignorance is dispelled (sggs 512).
Gurmukh jaat pat Name vadiaaee: God's Name is the caste, honor, and glory of the True Sikh or Gurmukh (sggs 230).
Hari Bhagta kee jaat pat hai Ram: The caste and honor of the Lord's devotees is His Naam (sggs 768).
Hamree jaat pat sach naayu: The Name is my caste and honor (sggs 353).
Sant janaa kee jaat Hari Suaamee tum Thaaku ham saangee: God is the caste of the saintly person. You are the Lord; I am just Your puppet (sggs 667).
Naam jaat Naam meree pat hai Naam merai parvaarai: The Name is my caste, the Name is my honor, and the Name is my family (sggs 713).
Nanak Gurmukh gian praapat hovai timar agian andher chukaayaa: O Nanak, the Gurmukh attains spiritual wisdom, and the pitch-black darkness of ignorance is dispelled (sggs 512).
Thus, a pure Sikh (a Self-realized person) is beyond any mundane caste and related false pride. Because of his pure love and devotion for God, he depends only on God. For that, God is his caste, honor, glory, family, etc.
Laale apnee jaat gavaaee: The Lord's slave lays aside his caste (sggs 363).
Re: Caste or Class?
Kharku Jatt · 12 Oct 2005
Jatts are NOT a caste, why can't you haters just accept it. You know nothing about history and the facts, you are all blind to the truth. Who cares what the rehit maryada says, it doesn’t say that anywhere in the Guru Granth Sahib about marriage AND "caste". The Gurus were all born into Khatri families, they didn't marry out of their "caste". ALL men are equal, yes. But Jatts don't marry out of their ethnic group, this has been the case for thousands of years before the advent of Sikhism. It has continued after Sikhi as well. Low castes were treated worse than animals, it was this that Guru Ji wanted to abolish.
We don't marry other Jatts, Hindus or Muslims, we marry Sikhs of our own blood. There is nothing wrong or anti-Sikh about this. The biggest thing that annoys me is that Khatris marry their Hindu cousins, Jatt Sikhs never ever do this. So why the hell is it on every single caste thread on the Internet about Jatts, even though you have other groups marrying the same groups of different religions. It comes down to jealousy and envy. Jattpuna has nothing to do with status or money, we are honourable people, proud people, we are willing to work our way up even if we have nothing, we are proud because of our history, from the times before Sikhi when Sidhu/Brar tribes were at war with the Moguls, to the 80's, where it was Jatt Sikhs who had the ankh to fight and die for Sikhi. We are proud because the name of Punjab rides on the back of Jatts, the culture, the land, the religion.
I'm happy for all the "low" caste Sikhs who are doing well in the West, so you are proud of that, fair enough. Jatts hold pride in their character and values not material goods. You only have to study Punjabi folk tales and look at characters as Sucha Singh Soorma and Jeona Maur, not about being rich or status, they were about ankh and character. You Jatt bashers have nothing to do in your sad pathetic lives, but to blame others. Why can't you just get on with your lives and stop concerning yourselves with the affairs of Jatts.
Some of you people will never understand Jatts and how deep our blood runs.
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
Deep · 13 Oct 2005
How can you call yourself Jatt and Sikh? Why should you call yourself a Singh then? the whole Jatt being a race thing is just started by FEW views and especially the website jattworld promoting that.. Jatt clans are based on last name just as any other CASTE of Punjab or anywhere in India. They look at other castes based on thier last names when making decisions about dating, marriage, even associating. The chamars accepted Ravidas's view on equality and have seperate gurudwaras because of the way they were treated. Not all chamars are ravidasi.. that is a religious SECT. and they go to any Gurudwara. Ramgharias, Tarkhaans, etc. are different castes not religious sects. Jatt is widely accepted as a farming/landowning class or caste of people. At times before Sikhi when they were fighting the moguls what do you think they were then? Some Jatts would prefer to marry a Jatt from another religion than to marry a "low" caste Sikh or a Sikh who can't trace thier roots back to punjab.
Re: Caste or Class?
A Singh · 13 Oct 2005
Dear Pardeep Singh “Bilga”,
Gur Fateh!
You asked:
<<< Why is it, A "Singh" ji, that Jatts are expected to keep Sikhi saroop and are criticised for being patit - let's not forget Sikhism came after Jatts were around for years and years, so the migration of Jatts to the Sikh religion was en-masse, like any other group. But whenever a chammaar or other non-jatt becomes kesdhari, people like A"Singh" think "let's pat them on the back" as if they have done some kind of favour to Sikhi by joining. Why treat non-jatts as bechaaray? we are all equal.>>>
Pardeep Singh, firstly I am not “bashing jatts” as my criticism was also aired on the Ramgarhias as well in both the posts. If it makes you feel better, I can make a circle wider and start on Khatris as well, but that’s not the point here – note however, YOU were the one who chose to use the Jat and Choora examples, so subsequent discussions are based upon the parameters set up by YOU.
Moreover, Bhai Sahib, your claim that <> is absolutely nonsense.
No where have (a) I termed or suggested that chamars or chooras are “becharay” – this again is YOUR assertion, clearly showing YOUR attitude to these two groups despite your feeble attempt to mutter “we are all equal” in the same breath, or (b) indicated that I “expect” Jats or for that matter any to be Keshdhari. Besides it is not for me to expect in any event.
My point is that it is quite notable in social circles in Punjab and abroad in the West that mona Jats feel they are still “sardars” and “singhs” yet reluctantly concede theses titles to those of “low caste” backgrounds even if they are Keshdhari. Bhai Sahib, it is quite common to hear from the mouths of Mona Jats and even Keshdhari Tarkhans words to the effect “since when did these chooras become Sikhs?” I personally, although not from these background have been told “since when did you Bahmans become Singhs” or “your not Sikh, you’re a Kala Afrikoo” and that too from a group of people amongst whom the majority were not even Keshdhari.
It is nothing to do with ‘expectations’, it is simply highlighting the attitude of many Mona Jats (and for that matter Tarkhans and Brahmins) who on one hand criticise Amritdharis of their own background (usually because some local Gyani was caught in a compromising position or some Sant was recently exposed for some misdeed) and at the same time, when those who they perceive to be lower than them on the ‘caste’ hierarchy adopt Sikhi, they have problems accepting them as Sikhs – all this whilst they themselves remain clean shaven, drinking and at times even smoking.
You then go on to state <<< The fact that 2 of the most learned people who post on this site are Sikhs who come from the Jatt background - Jarnail Singh Arshi ji and Kulbir Singh ji, is not some kind of co-incidence. >>>
And that both people are educated and well learned Singhs, “who put there money where their mouths are” so to speak – i.e. practice what they preach. However they are not ‘learned people’ on account of their “jatt background” but because they have put the effort in to acquire their knowledge and moreover, life lives as Gursikhs.
Again, YOUR biased matt is available here for all to see again, as according to you, it is no coincidence that two learned people are from Jatt background – this is a ridiculous claim, for one you ignore all the scholars and ‘educated’ people who are clearly not from Jat backgrounds and secondly you choose to ignore the numerous problems that have been caused in the past and present by people from ‘Jat’ backgrounds.
Bhai “Bilga” Sahib, please be clear in your view, you undoubtedly do believe in Jat superiority and this post, initiated by YOU was nothing but a feeble attempt to try and find an excuse for that through your example which chooses to show only one angle of Jats (i.e. the much loved Land owner and wealthy farmer) and the stereotypical image of Chooras and Chamars (i.e. dirty and living in a Chamarli, despite it being adequately shown that in India and abroad many people from this background have actually undergone significant social upward mobility through the means of education).
Your final comment asked me <<< A- How can you call yourself a Singh and then degrade Sikh gurdwaras and praise a sect (Ravidasiay) who do not even believe in Dasam Pita guru Gobind Singh ji maharaj?>>>
Pradeep Singh, you again show your true motives. Where have I ‘degraded’ Sikh Gurdwaras? I have used the example to show the futility of the social-paradigm presently witnessed by Gurdwaras being based on Caste groupings and those belonging to Jat, Tarkhan and Khatri communities, whilst having disputes with each other, all consider themselves to be superior largely on account of the wealth they have managed as individuals to amass in the past century through various modes of upward social mobility. All three are equally guilty of this and all three, are unanimous in their treatment of “Mazbis” – which is evident in India and abroad.
As I mentioned, whilst it is unfortunate that Ravi Dasia have chosen to adopt certain practises which go contrary to that of mainstream Sikh belief, the point I was trying to make was to dispel misfounded notion that all people from Mazbi / Ravidasia / Harijan / Choora etc etc whatever term you wish to use are somehow ‘unclean’ (see the various accounts above for the types of attitudes including your own initial post). Perhaps you could reread the information and kindly tell me how I have ‘degraded’ Gurdwaras?
Finally, Pardeep Singh “Bilga”, Ravidasias, even despite their focus on Bhagat Ravi Das, who they elevate to the level of “Guru”, still believe in the teachings of the 10 Sikh Gurus and undertake all the necessary customs within their Gurdwaras with regard to Guru Granth Sahib, to whom they bow down and revere as Guru Sahib. As I have said before on other topics, let’s not attack the branch – focus instead on the root cause – perhaps on another thread we can look at issues like “why Ravidasi communities elevate Bhagat Ravi Das to a Guru” or why “Ramgarhia Gurdwaras restrict their committee membership to only Ramgarhias”. In any event, there is nothing to indicate that they do not “believe in Dasam Pita Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj?” as I have seen amongst Ravidasia Gurdwara Sangat, albeit a small proportion, members who are in full Singh Saroop – the small proportion is not unique to them, as the same is true for most Gurdwaras where the predominant members are Jats, particularly when compared to their Tarkhan, Khatri and Brahmin counterparts.
So how do I call myself a Singh – simple, I was given this honour by the Punj Pyare and I try my best to follow the rehit that they laid out for me.
Gur Fateh!
A Singh
Re: Caste or Class?
A Singh · 13 Oct 2005
In addition to my comments above, since further points have been asked of me by Pradeep Singh “Bilga” (the inverted commas are around your surname not around “singh” as you have put on my name, clearly you have doubts concerning me being one, perhaps because in your opinion I’m not one of those ‘forming the backbone of the Panth’ type Jats – you are of course entitled to your opinion).
<<>>
This is nonsense. Have a look at the Yudh at Bangi – not a single Jat is found to have fought alongside Guru Sahib.
<<>>
Pradeep Singh, why don’t you read Sant Jee’s statement again – I have no problem with it and neither should anyone else, why? Because he’s not using as some means to make himself to be the Supeior Aryan race or as you put it promoting “Putt Jattan de!” - again, this is another feeble attempt on your part to cover up for your blatant prejudice against non-Jatts. First you have used Veer Kulbir Singh and Gyani Jarnail Singh “Arshi” as props for your weak arguments and now you are using Sant Jee.
<<>>
Pradeep Singh “Bilga”, perhaps we are now coming to the crux of the matter. This may come as a surprise to you, but there is no crime in mentioning the word Jatt, in fact one should in my personal opinion be aware of their background for positive and negative. I suggest next time you go to Punjab have a closer look at how the Jatts treat the Chamars when things don’t go the way they want them to, particularly the way in which they treat their women.
<<>>
Singh Sahib, the same can be true for Jats and Tarkhans – the majority of whom are monas or ‘trim-singhs’. Again, as above, look at the root cause and don’t simply judge on the basis of what you only see with your blinkered vision. As for respect, Singh Sahib, everytime I have walked into a Ravidasia Gurdwara, from the Gyani to the youngest person, they have all shown immense respect upon seeing me with full Singh Saroop and I’m only 20-something. To the contrary, Jatts throughout my childhood would join non-Sikhs and tease me about my ‘top-knot’ – to them, I was a pendoo because I kept my kesh, this was particularly true for Jattis, despite the fact that their academic records and general knowledge were pretty appalling for someone who considered themselves to be so “sophisticated”. The same was latter true of “trim-singh” tarkhans, who would consider anyone with a full dhari to be a bacharay. So go check your “facts”…
<<>>
Ask the same question of Ramgarhias as well? It is clear that the movement has been in later stages hijacked by Jats like “DR” Chohan and others and many non-Jatt communities have as a result moved away from significant participation – this is not unique to Ravidasias only. By the same token, you cannot say that none of these communities have no role in the Shaheedi Programs, what do you do Mr Bilga have a tick list with members of the Sangat declaring their caste??? You intentions are becoming clearer and clearer…
<<>>
Bhai Sahib, as stated above, why don’t we look into why they elevate Bhagat Jee to a “Guru”? At Ravidasia Gurdwaras, Guru Sahib is present nonetheless. As per the Khanda question, ask the same of Nanaksarias, they don’t even have a Nishan Sahib – so let me guess, according to you they’re not Sikhs either??? Pradeep Singh, I think your message is loud and clear for all to see…
Finally for “kharkoo Jatt”,
I personally am not against people ‘acknowledging’ their castes or even people (i.e. those who are actually getting married not the overriding blackmail of elders) wanting to marry within their own caste, or even using caste names. So there is no issue of ‘Jatt-bashing’, it is simply when idiots make rubbish claims like ‘Jats are the backbone of Sikhi’ and ‘Jats have done so much for Sikhi’ as if all other communities are trivial – moreover, there is plenty of historical evidence to prove to the contrary anyway.
Secondly, the point concerning a Mona Jat still calling himself a “sardar” and a “singh” whilst finding it hard to accept a Mazbi as Sikh even if he is Amritdhari.
My personal view on the subject of caste within Sikhi is clear – Gurbani tells us not to essentially ‘discriminate’ on the basis of caste, the same way race relations literature seeks to rid society of racial discrimination. However just as being non-racist, doesn’t mean one should somehow pretend that ‘race’ doesn’t exist, treating all equal regardless of caste-background, doesn’t mean we should pretend that we are not also from Jatt, Tarkhan, Khatri, Chamar, Brahmin, Kalal etc backgrounds or communities.
Gur Fateh!
A Singh
Re: Caste or Class?
jatt da puth · 13 Oct 2005
its about lifestyle. a farmer has an everyday lifestyle which is different then another person. they want similarities.
Re: Caste or Class?
singh shady · 13 Oct 2005
pardeep singh and jatt kharku are you both amritdhari?
Tapoban preserves the maryada of Guru Gobind Singh ,paratan reht is the very reasons why akj and tapoban were created hence reht is of utmost importance to the khalsa.
Although myself comin from the farming community in punjab i understand both sides of the argument and feel open minded for a conclusion to this whole debate while the regular posters at tapoban have not yet posted i would appeciate a response from guru vale sikh like bhai balpreet singh bhai kulbeer singh bhai jagroop singh bhenji kaur bhenji bhujangan bhenji singhani and the rest.
The matter is not being discussed sensibly by some while the real deal fauj of the khalsa are keeping gupat.
It is a fact jatts are a group with customs , and they do happen to make a majority in the sikh religion, hence they do not feel the need to assimilate with other groups who are microscopic in numbers and will inevitably struggle when it coms to marriage issues in the world of rehitvan sikhs.
If jatts for whatever reasons do not wish to marry with others then please understand the facts things are not going to change with a khalsa josh type reaction against caste, but will lead to silent invisible lines. It is too heavily embedded eventhough i have no objection to mixed marriages.
There are some things we can protest against past the border, but within the lines we will cause more collosal damage by fighting each other over this madness of caste which will be better tackled by an educated generation away from the fields of punjab.
We have to learn to live with something we do not like because it is there and nobody is willing to change, but we can live and grow amongst it here is how -
Instead i suggest sikhs from minority groups to establish a group within a group kind of thing so they will not have to struggle in finding partners. let jatts marry into their own if they are not ready to mix in for whatever reasons while the rest begin this process of marrying different castes amongst themselves, do not rely on the majority to make a change.
If this is what Guru ji would want then let us not blame each other but lead by example. then maybe others will see the difference in a generation or so and agree it can work.
Look long term forget about fighting each other, time is short.
Re: Caste or Class?
singh shady · 13 Oct 2005
jatt kharku ji your logic raises a question. While sikh reht ultimatly commands sikhs to rid themselvs of caste which would point to tirkaans chamars cheembas khattris would it suddenly excuse jatts because they happen to be a race?
Re: Caste or Class?
/ · 13 Oct 2005
please people, not only people who are jatts have issues about castes
thukarns only marry thukarns, chumars only marry chumars
dnt make it out as if jatts r 2 blame, if anything othercastes make more issues out of jatts beeing jatts then jatts themselves do!
if tha makes sense:S
Re: Caste or Class?
Kulbir Singh · 13 Oct 2005
The stand of Khalsa on caste is not a secret. After taking amrit and adopting Khalsa way of life, one loses one’s previous jaat-paat and kul. When getting married, a Rehitvaan Tyaar Bar Tyaar Khalsa only looks at Rehit and Sikhi. Caste is not considered when doing rishta.
Having said that, I should mention that unless one keeps Rehit and obeys hukams of Guru Sahib, jaat-paat does not get destroyed. If a person does not adopt Khalsa way of life and continues to do previous life's manmukhi karams then he or she does not lose the traits of his previous life including jaat paat. So ones’ who are kachay pillay (dhillay in rehit) do carry traits of their previous jaat paat. This is just my opinion. Only after amrit-chhak and keeping rehit one loses jaat paat.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Caste or Class?
kharral mirza fan · 13 Oct 2005
kulbir singh you smashed it may waheguru bless you with more
Re: Caste or Class?
bilgeyah di rani · 13 Oct 2005
ask any singhani here how she would feel if somebody married her for her wealth, or proffession.
This is the dhill of not just non amritdharis but most of the world today wants money respect and power. Slowly people will not even care about religion and just shag the manager for a position.
Re: Caste or Class?
???? · 13 Oct 2005
I married a Singh of a different caste. When I was first introduced to him, I did not know or cared less about his Caste or class and vice versa. I fell in love with his Love for Sikhi and saw how determined he was to follow the teachings of our Gurus.
For people out there who justify marrying within the caste systems for the purpose of living a way of life, this was never an issue within our marriage. I looked at him as a SIngh and he saw me as a SInghnee. He never questioned my background and i never questioned his background.
As a matter of fact, our marriage has set an example for the rest of Singhs and Singhnians. I am very thankful for meeting such an amazing Singh, he has helped me with my Sikhi. He is also my role model who's helped me become a better SIkh.
SOme advice i would like to pass along -- when finding a marriage partner, leave out caste and class, because gursikhs live according to Rehit Maryada that is our way of life. The Gurus set an example for us to be loving and caring, which will also help us in our marriage. There is no reason to fight and argue over wordly things when you can spend your time making eachother strong.
~Bhul Chuk Maaf~
Re: Caste or Class?
** · 13 Oct 2005
in gurbani word JAT is used for an idiot or fool
"loore dakh bajjorian kiker bejjei jat"
Re: Caste or Class?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 13 Oct 2005
Author: **
Date: 10-13-05 13:50
in gurbani word JAT is used for an idiot or fool
"loore dakh bajjorian kiker bejjei jat"
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Jatt just means FARMER.
The tuk could have read..lorre daakh bajorian kikkar beejeh BRAHMIN...but then a Brahmin doesnt DO BEEJJNA...or FARMING ?? get it ?? Only a JATT does FARMING.
Re: Caste or Class?
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 14 Oct 2005
Kulbir Singh ji is 100% correct- ONLY after taking khande-ki-pahul is caste removed.
Again, how many "Ravidasiay" take amrit???
ps- A "Singh" -YOU started off using the inverted commas around my Pind name- as you have done on NUMEROUS other occasions in the past.
But you did not answer a question I asked months ago, as to why I cannot use my village name INSTEAD of my surname (which promotes caste)?
Pardeep Singh Sanghera
Re: Caste or Class?
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 14 Oct 2005
Also- A "Singh"- as a matter of fact, I do NOT believe you are a Sikh, judging by your pro-bahman views on other subjects.
Let's keep to THIS subject anyway- instead of personal attacks for which you have become well-known on the site.
A "Singh" - you state in one of your earlier posts: "it is well known in Punjab, that Jatts and others continue to this date to prey upon Charmaria in the pind and subject them to rapes and abuse, simply because they know they’ll get away with it"
Do you have any proof of this, or have you been watching too many 70's pervy Panjabi films? Can you back up this myth? On the one hand you criticise Jatts for avoiding contact with chamaars, then you accuse them of raping chamaarian? Many of my relations in Panjab are sarpanch of their respective pinds and I have not to date ever heard of such nonsence- so get some proof before you start making up your far fetched stories.
Re you comments on Dr Chohan- yes he may be a GOI agent- but what about the only decent politician who actually speaks up for Sikhs? Sardar Simranjit Singh Mann - he is a Jatt (sorry for swearing) too!
Also- my name is PARDEEP not PRADEEP as you have spelt it- cleverly changing my name to the Hindi version won't convert me to your beliefs, SORRY!
Re: Caste or Class?
** · 14 Oct 2005
gyani ji u seemed to be very learned but do not try to twist the gurbani to suit u r jattism.
some one on this forum mentioned about u to be above and untouched by csate but your above post proves it contrary.
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
A Singh · 14 Oct 2005
<<<>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Jatt just means FARMER.
The tuk could have read..lorre daakh bajorian kikkar beejeh BRAHMIN...but then a Brahmin doesnt DO BEEJJNA...or FARMING ?? get it ?? Only a JATT does FARMING.>>>
Gyani Jee, come on – let’s be real, this reference to jat is clearly in the context of a ‘fool’ because a Jat in the context of a farmer would obviously know the difference between “dakh” and “kiker”, the tuk is talking about a “fool” who seeks “Dakh” but instead farms for “kiker”.
If I am incorrect, then the shabd would mean that a Jat (farmer) is stupid, since he cannot sow the correct seeds (i.e. whilst wanting Dakh, he farms for Kiker).
I personally cannot accept this second interpretation as being correct, for clearly the word “jat” in Gurbani does not refer to the “jat caste” (i.e. to a farmer) but to a “fool” or “uneducated” person.
Gur Fateh!
A Singh
Re: Caste or Class?
A Singh · 14 Oct 2005
Dear Pardeep Singh Sanghera “Bilga”
Gur Fateh!
<>
Please could let me know, what exactly are my pro-“bahman” views on any subject.
<>
Mr Sanghera, perhaps you should familiarize yourself with your own posts, not too long ago you spoke quite out of turn against not only non-sikh member of this forum, but also against our own brethren in your belittling comments concerning the Guru Nanak Nishkaam Sevak Jatha. Anyhow, that is perhaps your style, in any event, you are the one you has chosen to now attack my very Sikh identity – I have nothing to prove, as the judge of my Sikhi is only Maharaj, in any event, please do bring forth the support for these accusations.
<>
Bhai Sahib, I don’t watch Punjabi or Hindi films, much less any pervy ones (I didn’t realise one could find those in Punjab, maybe the truth about your private life is best left out of this discussion). If you would like to know more about this, have a look at the following:
http://www.frontlineonnet.com/fl2025/stories/20031219002304500.htm
http://www.frontlineonnet.com/fl2009/stories/20030509002609300.htm
http://www.deccanherald.com/deccanherald/jan042005/n38.asp
And in case you can’t be bothered, here is an extract from the following website:
http://vancouver.indymedia.org/news/2004/03/121796.php
<<<<<>>>
And whilst your on it, also have a look at your beloved wealthy Jat landowner’s mentality towards female infanticide:
http://www.sikhtimes.com/news_021504c.html
<< Can you back up this myth? On the one hand you criticise Jatts for avoiding contact with chamaars, then you accuse them of raping chamaarian? Many of my relations in Panjab are sarpanch of their respective pinds and I have not to date ever heard of such nonsence- so get some proof before you start making up your far fetched stories.>>
I’m glad to hear that your folks are doing well. Perhaps put yourself into the shoes of those in less privileged positions, do you really think that they would want to make a fuss against the Sarpanch even over serious issues like this, which may well involve family member of the leading family? Perhaps this is too hard for you to think about as you’ve had such a great life and its easy to overlook such items.
<>
Mr Singh, you are missing my point, again and again, I am not anti-Jatt, and I am not pro-another caste, I also have no problem with people expressing their affiliation with any caste, but what you have been doing is trying to justify your “prejudice” on the basis of caste by using a pathetic argument like the class system, then name dropping Veers like Kulbir Singh and Gyani Jarnail Singh and even Sant Jarnail Singh Bindrawale to justify your personal problems and issues. The fact that Simranjit Singh Mann is a Jatt is largely irrelevant to his abilities as a politician. To make things clearer for you, the reference on Dr Chohan was to illustrate the futility of your argument, however clearly your mind fails to grasp that.
<>
Please don’t apologise, as I have no intention to ‘convert’ anyone, but when blatant lies are being told by people like you, for the general information of others and also for healthy discussions, I’m more than glad to participate – most often I learn many things myself from these forums. As per spelling your name incorrectly, I apologise for that and confirm that it was simply an oversight than anything intentional, however please note that Pardeep and Pradeep need not be Sikh or Hindu.
<>
Bhai Kulbir Singh is entitled to his view and he has good reason for it. However your question again, shows that YOU are really hung up on YOUR sheer arrogance and pitiful opinion that ONLY Jatts have supported the Khalsa and that Ravidasiyas are not Amritdhari – Pardeep Singh, no doubt you are a Khalistani, it’s a shame that you are unaware of many of our Shaheeds (Amritdhari Singhs) who were from Ravidasia / Mazbhi background.
As I have stated before, Gurbani tells us not to discriminate or victimise one on the basis of Caste, Race, Sex etc – clearly this is a message you repeatedly have chosen to overlook as you are no doubt getting wound up by my presence here. Chullo, I’ll leave you to cool down,
<< A "Singh" -YOU started off using the inverted commas around my Pind name- as you have done on NUMEROUS other occasions in the past. But you did not answer a question I asked months ago, as to why I cannot use my village name INSTEAD of my surname (which promotes caste)?>>
Pardeep BhaJee, tusi vi naa both zaada hi serious ho jande eh! The inverted commas were around your pind name (bilga), i.e. differentiating you from any other Pardeep Singh poster on this forum. I never said that there was anything wrong in using this name or even your surname for that matter, you simply assumed that from the inverted commas. In actual fact, I like the sound of “Bilga”, kind of cool! ;)
Of course, you have made clear your opinions, as placing inverted commas around “Singh” in my name, you cannot except me as a Sikh – again, chullo, you are entitled to your opinions.
Gur Fateh!
A Singh
Re: Caste or Class?
!! · 14 Oct 2005
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi"
>>>>"The tuk could have read..lorre daakh bajorian kikkar beejeh BRAHMIN".<<<<
Wah Wah Wah Wah Wah Wah Wah Wah
Baba Farid ji made this big mistake he did not know the difference between jatt and brahmin. u r more intelligent to point out baba ji's mistake. please correct the gurbani. Guru Arjun Dev ji did not pick up this big mistake but u have.
YOU ARE GREAT
Read and understand the whole shabad it does not point the comment to brahmin but to a jatt.
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
dara singh no caste vala · 14 Oct 2005
Caste and race pride has no place in sikhism. Guru Granth Sahib is very clear on this there are not one set of rules for daily life and another contrary to gurmat for marriage. Jatt jeona maur was a hindu what does he have to do with gurmat path?
There are some singhs out there who served both in the babbar khalsa who have bore the brunt of indian tortures who came from chammar backgrounds one was very close to the singh who had his eyes and legs taken out after being burned in salt water . If one of them appeared before us for marriage they are free to marry our sisters it would be an honour. On the western front there are singhs from chammar backgrounds in the panth one of whom i know personally who comes to this site who do seva for the panth through parchar to the youth weekly.
We have no intrest in jeona maurs or jatts from jattworld.com are not worth the dirt on the floor of the singhs who have walked with their heads on their palms and or singhs who carry out panthic seva.
Pardeep singh as a singh who has left my khetti background behind let me advise you about the mindset of jatha singhs. This jatha looks at quality not quantity, we are based on principles not superiority complexes. So no guru da singh or singhani will care how many chamars are amritdhari we open our arms to all with one equal eye to each sikh brother and sikh sister. But i am personally disgusted by this stupudity of caste your all grown men not children. We will not tolerate anti gurmat activities.
1
JoSikhaKoPucheJaatSohSikhNahiMeroAadJugaad
Those who ask a sikh's caste, they are not my sikh, they never were, and they never will be --Sache Patsha Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee
2
varanaa varan n bhaavanee khehi khehi jalan baa(n)s a(n)gayaaraa||
Different sections(castes) of society develop hatred for one another and finish themselves through squabbles as the bamboos, due to their mutual friction, producing fire burn themselves as well as others.
ni(n)dhaa chaalai vaedh kee samajhan nehi agiaan gubaaraa||
Condemnation of the knowledge starts and in the darkness of ignorance nothing remains visible.
This Shabad is by Bhai Gurdaas Ji in Vaars Bhai Gurdaas on Pannaa 1
3
guramukh varan avaran hoe ra(n)g sura(n)g tha(n)bol parachai||
Gurmukhs go beyond the castes, colours and go about in equanimity like the red colour of betel leaf.
Bhai Gurdaas Ji
Vaars Bhai Gurdaas
5
4
jaanahu joth n pooshhahu jaathee aagai jaath n hae ||1|| rehaao ||
Recognize the Lord's Light within all, and do not consider social class or status; there are no classes or castes in the world hereafter. ||1||Pause||
Guru Nanak Dev Ji
Raag Aasaa
349
5
neh baran baran neh kuleh kul ||
You have no caste or social class, no ancestry or family.
naanak prabh kirapaal thoo ||2||9||138||
Nanak: God, You are Merciful. ||2||9||138||
This Shabad is by Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Raag Saarang on Pannaa 1231
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
s1nghanee · 14 Oct 2005
to do my bit to break down the caste system i will purposely marry out of caste.
The caste system is dieing, if i was you guys i would give up your pride and take amrit and become sikhs. Everywhere in the world peopl are "mixing up" its like the governments with a paint brush were gonna get you type of thing. You may as well mix up the right way in the safe secure confines of sikhi rather than be ousted into the dreadful waves of maya where you can loose everything by blending out with different religions.
So trieing to be exclusive on caste will work against you because everyuthing is changing too fast anyway. Stick to sikhi
Re: Caste or Class?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Oct 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh.
I am always against people who take HALF a TUK and twist its MEANING to suit their own TWISTED methodology.
This is slok from Sheikh Farid Ji.
[gurbani]PrIdw loVY dwK ibjaurIAW, ikkir bIjY jtu ] hMFY auNn kqwiedw, pYDw loVY ptu ]23] {pMnw 1379}[/gurbani]
The actual meaning has NOTHING whatsoever to do with any CASTE per se...BUT for ALL of US... the JATT (Farmer) is used as an EXAMPLE of such people....
Prof sahib singh ji explains the entire slok in full..
[gurbani]pd ArQ:— ibjaurIAW—ibjOr dy ielwky dI (ieh ielwkw pTwxI dys ivc mwlwkMd sÍwq qoN pry hY) [ dwKu—Cotw AMgUr [ ikkir—ikkrIAW [ hMFY—iPrdw hY [ pYDw loVY—pihnxw cwhuMdw hY [
ArQ:— hy PrId ! (bMdgI qoN ibnw suKI jIvn dI Aws r`Kx vwlw mnu`K aus j`t vWg hY) jo j`t ikkrIAW bIjdw hY pr (auhnW ikkrIAW qoN) ibjOr dy ielwky dw Cotw AMgUr (Kwxw) cwhuMdw hY, (swrI aumr) au~n kqWdw iPrdw hY, pr rySm pihnxw cwhMudw hY [23[/gurbani]
There are LOTS of US..who..."PLANT" kikers... ( who do bad things, have bad habits..etc) but want to REAP.... goodness. Thsi wont happen and This SLOK proves it.
Which Jatt also KNITS WOOL ?? as is referred to in the second part of the Slok...but wants to wear SILK. Again LOTS of US...go about knitting WOOL but expect to WEAR SILK !!!! dont we ??
Read this slok..
[gurbani]kMiD kuhwVw, isir GVw, vix kY sru lohwru ] PrIdw hau loVI shu Awpxw, qU loVih AMigAwr ]43] {pMnw 1380}
[/gurbani]
It implies that the LOHAAR..a wood cutter is the KING of the JUNGLE ?? Is every wood cutter a "KING"...in fact every wood cutter is a poor man just surviving....but here Farid Ji calles him Vann ke sr..Head of the FOREST ?? Why because the "poor woodcutter"..may be poor day labourer..but when he is in the FOREST..he is "KING" because he can put his Axe to cut ANY TREE he wishes...
Please READ and Vichaar...the COMPLETE SHABAD..TUK..and keep the other shabads, rahao panktees in view. ISOLATED tuks always lead one astray ( whether intentionally or otherwise)
The "Jatt" referred to by farid Ji is a "FARMER" as the EXAMPLE deals with PLANTING...BEEJAANA...and we are ALL "JATTS" because Gurbani plainly tells us that WE WILL REAP WHAT WE SOW. The SAME type of metaphor is used when Gurbani tells us WE ARE ALL WOMEN ( the one and only MAN is WAHEGURU)....now I am sure "Author: and Singh" above will definitlely DENY they are BOTH "WOMEN" just as they so vehemently try to put the "fool".tag on JATTS ......But the SAD FACT is that Gurbani is RIGHT..we are ALL JATTS/FOOLS/FARMERS/and WOMEN as well. ..take YOUR PICK.
Jarnail Singh.
Benti to all posters" PLEASE give Author/aang/raag and complete GURBANI. Not everyone has memeorised the entire Guru Granth ji sahib...
Re: Caste or Class?
A Singh · 14 Oct 2005
Thanks for the clarification Gyani Jee, this was exactly my point, the tuk cannot be referring to what we today term "Jatt" (i.e. as a caste), i.e. the one that you as a "Dhillon" belong to, otherwise it would obviously be implying that all Jats are fools, wherein that particular tuk, as shown uses it as an example of a fool.
Gur Fateh!
A Singh
Re: Caste or Class?
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 15 Oct 2005
Dear A "Singh" - You are truly something else - you go and use names of people - i.e. your comments re Dr. Chohan being bad AND a Jatt -but then, when I mention a decent Jatt Sikh like Simranjit Singh Mann- you pretend to be NOT anti-Jatt by saying: "To make things clearer for you, the reference on Dr Chohan was to illustrate the futility of your argument, however clearly your mind fails to grasp that" erm, let's get back to basics - you used "bad Jatt = Dr Chohan" so I responded with "good Jatt - Sardar Simranjit Singh Mann" - so now you are trying to get out of it and then tell ME, that MY MIND is having "difficulty grasping"...it is always the same story with people like you (people who have a problem with Jatts) - you love to find any example of a Jatt who has slipped up or done something bad- well we ALL make mistakes- NEVER did I say that ALL jatts are perfect.
However, when it comes to the good that Jatts have done for the panth, then you and your kind always overlook this.
Re: Caste or Class?
Sukh Singh · 17 Oct 2005
Well said Kharku Jatt.
Re: Caste or Class?
s.grewal · 17 Oct 2005
A noteworthy point here i have not seen one regular posting bibi in support of caste or racial pride division. Why is that my dear brothers?
pardeep singh once a singh takes amrit he has no caste or past tribal customs. Rehit is what makes a sikh. If a sikh has no rehit then he is not a sikh.
Therefore if simranjeet singh maan is a sikh then he will be amritdhari and being so he will not be a jatt but a sikh a singh a khalsa.
Bhai Rama singh a prominenent jatha singh with lifetime of naam,bani,seva kamai has stated in his book that in khalsa raj white sikhs will marry punjabi sikhs and vica versa . Bhai rama singh was not the only singh to have these visions many other gupt naam rasia singhs and singhnia have.
Whether the point be caste or race sikh dharm has no place for it. Sikhs were created from kabul, punjab, rajhistaan, delhi, south india. If anybody wishes to understand why The gurus married in the khattris then first keep rehit and do ardas from your heart and ask hukam from your Guru. Singho be warned Guru Granth Sahib instructs one against caste and division pride which applies to racists too.
Sikhi is universal and will weather the storm of time. But i cannot say the same for caste or race divisive customs, perhaps the reason why racists and castists attempt to push their agenda without any success.
the castists have had their day, nowdays its hardly an issue, we have gyms and centres uniting sikhs of different castes within gurdwaras a new onemanship uniting us with common causes.
what will you do when your kid comes home and asks to marry someone of a different caste my dear racist brothers?
Re: Caste or Class?
jas kaur · 17 Oct 2005
sikhs should have no caste period!
Maharaja bhupinder singh of patiala offered to marry his daughter or sister to ambedkars nephew .
I have heard when the jatha started bhai sahib randhir singh ji had sikhs married into different castes, i would like to ask knowledgable singhs like bhai kulbir singh if this is true?
caste has never came up in my life oir family. I think we have a lot of wrongly influenced people on this thread.
Re: Caste or Class?
unreal · 19 Oct 2005
Dear Pardeep Singh Bilga,
Take this however you will, but having read through your posts in this thread, it is more than apparent caste is an important distinction in your life. This nonsense of Jats not being a caste or class is just that, nonsense. After taking amrit, I consciously rid myself of this caste/class "membership"
When looking at the kurbanis of our shaheeds, I think you will find most did so as Guru da Khalsa, not as Jats. Khalsa and Jat (or any other caste) are mutually exclusive;
One is either a Sikh or a caste-member - one cannot be both.
Regards
Re: Caste or Class?
Randhawa · 19 Oct 2005
i am sick of this anti jatt hatred.
Jatts made sikh history you need us! jatts are the best soldiers! jattis raise the best sikhs and fighters. We are kings warriors and lifeline of the sikh nation. Where do you think all great sikhs came from?
No self respecting jatt would ever marry his children out of caste this is the height of desparation and perversion on jatts! You stick to your own kind we will not be mixing our blood to produce confused hybrids. A jatt is a jatt putt jatta de jatt jatta de.!!!!!
We made civilisation in punjab therefore we reserve all rights to do as we wish as per jatt codes of honour for which we live and die for. Our fathers before us have contributed to sikhism so who are any of you to tell us?
Jatt di Yaari ittah naalo pakhi yaara picho marjanthai - this bond is not found in any other group.
It makes me cringe to say this but if it came to a choice in marriage between a different caste and a jatt jatti of another religion i and the majority would marry a jatti jatt but never into other caste groups thats just how it is. How can you ask us to dilute ourselves in this way? you should have shame and learn self respect and honour. If you ask us to marry into you then let us first see you marry somalians africans. This is my point jatts are a seperate race with complete set of traditions and codes of honour only found amongst jatts.
We will never mix ourselves if i was you get used to it for the better so we all get on in other ways but do not try to pressure us using religion.
Re: Caste or Class?
cheema786 · 19 Oct 2005
jatts have contributed in positions
prime ministers
presidents
chief ministers
royal recorded lineage
politicians in canada
missals ( sikh and muslim)
shaheeds
liberations
soldiery
created green belts
history
what has any other group done that is comparable to us?
Re: Caste or Class?
A Singh · 19 Oct 2005
Messrs Randhawa and Cheema,
Gur Fateh!
No one is doubting the accomplishments of Jats nor are we 'bashing' Jats, the points have been made quite clearly time and again.
The Tapoban Sevadars have presented clearly with reference from Gurbani their view that they do not wish to consider caste period.
Those who are happy acknowledges this diversity, like myself, are happy with others doing so, the issue we have is that certain folk believe that this then gives them an excuse to argue that only their particular tribe (caste) are the best Sikhs, to the extent of the only Sikhs - this is the issue everyone has, been it with Jats, Ramgarhias or Khatris.
On a more social level - which is where this thread begun, the issue I have had is the clear 'stereotype' image made on Mazbhis which as shown repeated over the course of this discussion is not valid or even appropriate for this day.
Bashing each other around the head with ego-filled statements about how much so and so did for the Panth and oh look he was a Jat / Tarkhan / Bahman etc is hardly contructive, let alone in line with Gurmat.
Gur Fateh!
A Singh.
Re: Caste or Class?
moossa wains · 20 Oct 2005
all others are insignificant jatts are numerically and politically the strongest.
Jatt spirit is borderless we are all religion some sikh muslims and hindus with a common bond found unique only amongst each other from sindh to lahore to ludiaana ambala to hissar.
I politely request our sikh brothers to educate their jeevans on jatta di itihaas by bhai sahib hs dullah to whom we owe a lot of respect for preserving compiling jatt historical records.
Whether mazhbis be rich or poor a jatt will always remain a jatt in traits, physical characteristics greekish looks, manliness, genetic warblood and share commonunion with all jatt groups through open minded living andneutral stance in religious politics putting jatt unity at the very front.
We are light skinned and share no links with non jatts.
As a mere observer it would serve in the best interests of all parties concerned to not bash jatts or any group and to preserve mutual respect.
Jatts will always be jatts you cannot get rid of us we are the physical backbone of north pakistan and indian punjab.
Moosa Wains
West Brom.
Re: Caste or Class?
unreal · 20 Oct 2005
Dear Randhawa -
No problems - enjoy your caste, be proud of your caste, wear a t-shirt advertising your caste but please, please do not disrespect Sikhi by calling yourself a Sikh.
You either have Sikhi or you have your caste - you either have your Guru ji's hukum or you have your caste - you cannot have both.
You said "..do not try to pressure us using religion" - your comments show Sikhi falls on a lower rank than your caste; that religion is secondary to your caste. So sad but you are entitled to live your life how you wish (manmat).
But for those of us who place our Guru's hukum above everything else and wish to live our lives accordingly (Gurmat), Sikhi is head and shoulers above any caste consideration. In fact, foolish caste divisions play no part in a Sikh's life - they're beneath us.
But we'll live our life as Sikhs and you feel free to live yours as a Jatt (interchange Jatt with Chamar, Tharkhan, Saini, Lubana, whatever) - believe me, it is no loss to anyone else.
Randhawa wrote:
> i am sick of this anti jatt hatred.
>
> Jatts made sikh history you need us! jatts are the best
> soldiers! jattis raise the best sikhs and fighters. We are
> kings warriors and lifeline of the sikh nation. Where do you
> think all great sikhs came from?
>
> No self respecting jatt would ever marry his children out of
> caste this is the height of desparation and perversion on
> jatts! You stick to your own kind we will not be mixing our
> blood to produce confused hybrids. A jatt is a jatt putt jatta
> de jatt jatta de.!!!!!
>
> We made civilisation in punjab therefore we reserve all rights
> to do as we wish as per jatt codes of honour for which we live
> and die for. Our fathers before us have contributed to sikhism
> so who are any of you to tell us?
>
> Jatt di Yaari ittah naalo pakhi yaara picho marjanthai - this
> bond is not found in any other group.
>
> It makes me cringe to say this but if it came to a choice in
> marriage between a different caste and a jatt jatti of
> another religion i and the majority would marry a jatti jatt
> but never into other caste groups thats just how it is. How
> can you ask us to dilute ourselves in this way? you should have
> shame and learn self respect and honour. If you ask us to marry
> into you then let us first see you marry somalians africans.
> This is my point jatts are a seperate race with complete set of
> traditions and codes of honour only found amongst jatts.
>
> We will never mix ourselves if i was you get used to it for the
> better so we all get on in other ways but do not try to
> pressure us using religion.
Re: Caste or Class?
unreal · 20 Oct 2005
Moosa Wains -
Your post sounds like old 1940's Nazi/Eugenics talks on the concept of race.
If the physical traits you mention are indicative of the jatt caste - in your words "a jatt will always remain a jatt" - one has to wonder about the cowardly, dark-skinned Jatts out there - are they pretenders to the caste?
"Genetic warblood" lol - please. If you are referring to a disposition towards warfare, I think you will find peoples all across the world with such a disposition. From the Romans and the Germanic tribes they fought to the Chingez Khan's Mongols and the Japanese samurai they fought.
The Spartans were also highly touted for this disposition.
However, go to Sparta now, or Mongolia or Japan and this "genetic warblood" doesn't seem to be evident. .........The reason? Because it doesn't exist. The debate between nature and nurture on human development is centuries old but when it comes to things like disposition to war - I think you'll find environment plays, by far, the largest role.
Here's part of an article which is similar to your post:
Eugenics
written by the late Ben Klassen.
The CHURCH OF THE C****** deems it extremely important that if we want the White Race of the future to be more healthy, happy and intelligent that we must also look to our genetic health. If we want healthier children (and adults) we must stop the breeding and proliferation of genetically diseased derelicts. We all know that like begets like, and scum begets scum. Now healthy, beautiful and intelligent parents may not always reproduce children that are exact replicas of themselves, but by the law of averages they are going to have children that are similar to themselves, some even superior, some not. Similarly, idiots, misfits, mental and physical cripples, the genetically diseased, are going the reproduce more of their tragic ilk to plague not only the present society, but also future generations.
Unfortunately, as I have pointed out in the WHITE MAN'S BIBLE (and also in NATURE'S ETERNAL RELIGION) present day society is so geared and structured that the inferior are encouraged to far outbreed the superior, and the mud races to far outbreed the White Race. The Jewish power establishment wants it that way, and does everything in its considerable power to make it happen. (See Chapters 26, 27, 28, and 41 of The WHITE MAN'S BIBLE). In past centuries (before welfare and subsidization became the monsters they are today) there was a natural curb on the proliferation of the inferior. Whereas they could breed, their proliferation was strictly limited by their inability to feed themselves. As a result the niggers of Africa, for instance, never increased their numbers over thousands of years. This degenerate black population of the African continent stabilized at the starvation level and stayed there. The ability (or inability) to produce food was the limiting curb. Until the advent of the White Man their numbers changed very little and for a huge continent fabulously rich in natural resources it supported a relatively small population. Furthermore, that population, by our standards lived continuously in dire poverty with the specter of starvation perpetually stalking the land.
The advancing technology of the White Race changed all that, both at home and abroad. With new inventions created by the genius of the White Man a single farmer could now feed 50 families whereas a few centuries ago he could feed perhaps two at most.
Now we are all proud of the genius of the White Man and the multitude of marvelous inventions his creative mind has produced. We are proud of such geniuses as Leonardo di Vinci, who was far ahead of his time; of Edison who dedicated most of his adult life to producing hundreds of inventions; of James Watt, who produced the first steam engine; of Henry Ford who revolutionized manufacturing techniques and put America on wheels; of Robert Fulton who built the first working steamboat; of Robert McCormick who produced the first horse drawn reaper and thereby tripled the productivity of the average grain farmer. We are proud of Daimler, Diesel, Marconi, Morse, Bell and hundred, yes, thousands of geniuses who have contributed tremendously to the advance of our civilization and culture.
The one overriding observation about all these geniuses is that they were White-members of Nature’s Elite—the White Race.
......
..What do we mean by Eugenics? Basically it means racial health. All species of Nature practice it instinctively. All species, whether it is a herd of buffalo, or deer, or caribou, or a flock of ducks, do basically two things to keep the genetics of the herd or the flock healthy: (a)There is a continuous culling out of the misfits in order to improve the genetic quality of the herd or the flock (survival of the fittest), and, (b) They do not interbreed with another similar species, no matter how closely related that species may be.
...When I was a kid, I was brought up on a farm in Saskatchewan. A few hundreds yards below our barn was a slough of water, about a mile long, and I spent many happy summer days rafting on it.
Now this slough happened to be a favorite nesting area for many species of wild ducks who flew north for the summer to breed and usher in the next generation. Among these I had the opportunity to observe many different species of ducks-pintail ducks, teal ducks, canvasback ducks, mallard ducks, mud hens, helldivers and others that I could not identify. There is one cogent lesson I learned from all these different species and it is this: Whereas they all belonged to the duck family each sub-species mated only with its own, pintails with pintails, canvasbacks with canvasbacks, teal with teal, etc. Never did they interbreed, never was there any miscegenation despite the fact they were all ducks and despite the fact that they all nested in the same pond. Nature hates bastards. Whereas domesticated animals (having too long been guided by, and interdependent on their human masters) have long lost their identity and the instincts of a pure species, the creatures of the wild have not and will faithfully abide by the laws of Nature. I repeat-Nature hates bastards. Nature frowns on miscegenation and ruthlessly relegates to the scrap heap of evolution those species which would arrogantly violate her laws.
We now come to the human species and focus particular attention on the White Race with whose welfare CREATIVITY is exclusively and solely concerned. After setting forth the goals and objectives of Creativity in the first chapter of the WHITE MAN'S BIBLE we lay down a hard and fast principle in the second chapter, namely we are concerned basically with the survival, expansion and advancement of the White Race. Everything we say, every opinion we express is through the eyes of the White Race. The White Race is the supreme yardstick by which we measure all things. Why? Because we ARE the White Race and Nature imposes upon us the same demands and the same laws as on every other creature—and that is: LOOK TO THE SURVIVAL AND WELFARE OF YOUR OWN KIND.
Nature, however, has done more than that for the White Race. In fact, it is on the White Race that she has lavished her most generous gifts. On no other creature in all the billions of years life has existed on this earth has Nature so generously dispensed as much INTELLIGENCE, CREATIVITY and PRODUCTIVITY AS SHE HAS ON THE White Race in just the last instant of geologic time. No other creature has occupied such predominance, such exclusiveness, so much control over its own environment and the destiny of other creatures as has the White Race in modern times. Without doubt, in the White Race Nature has produced her highest creature, her Elite, with no even near rivals.
moossa wains wrote:
> a jatt will always remain a jatt in traits, physical characteristics greekish looks,
> manliness, genetic warblood and share commonunion with all jatt
> groups through open minded living andneutral stance in
> religious politics putting jatt unity at the very front.
>
> We are light skinned and share no links with non jatts.
> As a mere observer it would serve in the best interests of all
> parties concerned to not bash jatts or any group and to
> preserve mutual respect.
>
> Jatts will always be jatts you cannot get rid of us we are the
> physical backbone of north pakistan and indian punjab.
>
> Moosa Wains
>
> West Brom.
Re: Caste or Class?
Rashid Ghumman · 21 Oct 2005
On behalf of the ghumman jatt clan of sialkot comprising part of the entire jatt nation from north south east to west We extend our complete solidarity and endorse the views of all jatt nation aspirants.
While marriage is not such a big problem, jatts do have a certain psyche patterns of living and different lifestyle totally seperate from others. its a hard fact.
Why do some sikhs have a grudge against this?
Do you have any idea how hurt a jatt sikh jatt muslim or jatt hinu would be asked to give up something very dear to them? Some of our jatt brothers and sisters may not wish debates and just move on but after this there will be bitterness as we will not be changing our lives to mix our way of life up something that we have been for thousands of years.
I ask you kindly and if you wish you may ask the jatt sikhs here personally how they feel that please do not undermine jatt traditions way of life and history and our bold identity. Please accept it because the last thing you ant is brother fighting brother. let there be no divisions we must stand united but please accept the reality here. Religion is not demanding us to stop being jatts.
Rashid Ghumman
Re: Caste or Class?
unreal · 21 Oct 2005
Au contraire my friend, the Sikh religion asks all of its adherents to shed themselves of their castes.
It doesn't just ask, it pretty much makes it a requirement.
Rashid Ghumman wrote:
Religion is not
> demanding us to stop being jatts.
>
> Rashid Ghumman
Re: Caste or Class?
Babbar Jat · 21 Oct 2005
Does anyone know what shardul caste means or what it is?
Re: Caste or Class?
Manjit kaur · 21 Oct 2005
Author: Babbar Jat
Date: 10-21-05 17:22
Does anyone know what shardul caste means or what it is?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>
do you mean "SCHEDULED CASTES" ?? that is a GOI invented word for all the supposedly LOW CASTES...and Gandhi had another euphemism..he called them HARIJANS !!! as if just calling them differently will change them into HIGH CASTE !!!
Joke of the Millineum
Re: Caste or Class?
Noor of Lahore · 22 Oct 2005
unreal saahb jatts do not consider themself to be caste but a distinguished race.
Even if we were a caste jatt sikhs will always carry on the way it is because thats what a jatt is about from day 1. Jatt culture has evolved in certain respects but remained static on other points, change is not something that can be demanded.
By asking us to give up our identification, honour, our culture you will in fact be doing the opposite to what you aim for. Jatts will further become disenchanted and marginalised. Jatts are the majority, this would not be a good move and make jatts feel as though they have fingers pointing at them.
Sometimes we have to ask ourselves how feasable is the change? i for one feel this is being personally targetting us why are others allowed to have caste distinctions?
Its not fair to blame jatts all the time.
Its not like we are the number 1 enemy we ourselves are divided into religions, countries, and even sub regions.
Jatts should be jatts blood in blood out
Re: Caste or Class?
unreal · 22 Oct 2005
One's own considerations are insignificant in the face of objectivity.
I see nothing pointing to jatts being anything more than a caste.
You say they are a race? Hardly. Today we see colonial concepts of race being scrutinized on the rather flimsy ground upon which they were based - you are taking an already shaky distinction and applying it to jatts?
Are Chamars a race too? How about Lubanas - are they a race too?
What about Kashmiri Pandits - are they a distinct race too? Lets not forget the Thurkhans, Sainis, and Khatris - surely they must all be distinct races as well.
Now you see how ridiculous it all is - jatts, chamars, thurkhans, sainis, khatris, lubanas - these are all castes, nothing more.
They are no more a racial identifier, then different clan names in Scotland are racial identifiers.
Let's end this topic.
This is a Sikh message-board about Sikhi and the Sikhs have spoken strongly and with no hesitation as to the outright and complete rejection of caste in Sikhi. Personally, I've never had a problem with the word Jatt because most often its used to denote a farming class people (to which I incidentally belonged before taking amrit).
But the problem is when after we take amrit, we don't let go of these brahministic distinctions - it hurts us as Sikhs and creates boundaries which we are better off without.
For those of you who wish to promote your caste, please do so on websites designed for that purpose.
Dear Admin - perhaps enough has been said on this particular topic of caste.
Noor of Lahore wrote:
> unreal saahb jatts do not consider themself to be caste but a
> distinguished race.
>
>
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
Jujharu · 23 Oct 2005
Unreal, you are an uneducated pindu. Jatts are a distinct ETHNIC GROUP belonging to the Scythian RACE, below is a break down of Punjabi ethnic groups:
Jatts, Rajput, Gujjars – Scythian (The 2nd to last wave of invaders into Northern India)
Khatris, Brahmins - Indo-Aryan (1st wave settlers)
Chura, Chammars – Dravidian (Native people of Indian subcontinent)
Jatts are not a caste, there are other farming communities in Punjab aswell, they are Kamboj and Saini, the Punjabi word for farmer is Kisaan.
Jatts are broken down into numerous clans like Sandhu, Sidhu/Brar, Mann, Gill, Dhillon, Dhaliwal. Each Jatt clan has its own history. Jatts have NEVER conformed to Brahmin ideology, we are independent people. Rural Punjab is Jatt territory, it is alien land to a Brahmin.
Chammars and Tharkhans come from a Sanatan Hindu fold. Jatts had there own customs and culture, like ancestor worship. We are completely different people, completely different mentality and values. This difference in mentality manifested itself in the 80's where you had Jatt Sikhs dieing for Sikhi and you had other communities supporting the GOI or acting neutral.
Most of you people are a joke. You have never been or lived in Punjab long enough to understand the huge difference in Jatts are others. We are a separate people with our own culture, values and history.
Re: Caste or Class?
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 23 Oct 2005
I think everyone is going off the topic somewhat (with the help of people like A "Singh").
My original post was asking if caste in Panjab/Sikh life is more to do with social standing- is having names for these "castes" Jatt, Tarkhan etc more like job titles than anything else?
Taking amrit ensures that you are rid of caste, but what about non-amritdharis? Are those better off with caste boundaries, until they take amrit?
Re: Caste or Class?
Ranjha Ranjha · 23 Oct 2005
Well bilga bro i am muslim but know enuff bout de sikh man religion.
It really don matter too much depending where you live like in europe america we are all coloured peoples so no one gives a rats tail.
But pakistan and india in rural life tribal tradition is almost inbred into a person. I do not like to hurt the sikh mans here but i think its obvious even to these brothers that jatts have too much culture, commonality amongst each other and shared history extending across religions, that we will not just say here its gone lets just stick to religion and leave everything out.
Life has never worked like that not for any religion.
Take christians practicing their religion most time black stick to black and white to white, there are russian, white, dark, ethopian, and even 2 million indian jews , but racially they stick to their own. Muslims most of the time stick to their tribes i admit it it has been like that for thousands of years. Humans from all religions have kept their tribal codes alongside their religion.
Even if for the sake of the argument our tribal honour is just "caste occupational" then one thing needs to be taken into account. All these castes have different cultural habits that have grown. So if they were to marry between each other would there not be clashes in thinking, daily how things are done?
I will give you an example. Jatts, pathans, are generally straight and honourable. But i keep on seeing these fresh indian sikhs with green turbans who approach me my friends and a lot of muslim and sikh jatt ladies trieing to spook us out with foretteling our futures, telling us something bad will happen, then threatening us with curses. I know they are dealing with the other side. But its a fact bhatra sikhs are doing this, it is not the religion but occult practices in certain tribes. So how can a decent honourable jatt or pathan marry into a clan that practices occult things?
So let us forget about races but that certain castes have certain habits that they have held onto. How compatibe can they be? Even if we were to say one is a practicing muslim for another practicing muslim prac sikh for prac sikh what about the asian way where the girl has to settle into nex mans family? It will not work out but cause pain.
You get me star?
i hear you bros that it may not be part of your religion. Thbe bottom line is we are not all alike and when a person marries its prooven scientifically with research that a person prefers to marry someone they have things in common with.
I agree this topic should end everyone has made their own choices and i know this is how it will always remain we will always be what we are.
I feel great respect for my ancesters some of you may not care, but a lot of us whether muslim or sikh do.
Ranjha Ranjha
Lozells Krew
Re: Caste or Class?
unreal · 23 Oct 2005
Dear Jujharu -
On one hand you say "most of you...have never lived in Punjab long enough to understand the huge difference between Jatts and others'
then you say,
"Unreal, you are an uneducated pindu"
Make up your mind!
As to being a "distinct ETHNIC GROUP" belonging to the "Scythian RACE", this still means you are claiming Jatts belong to a race different than the thurkans, sainis, kambojs, khatris etc..............unless you're saying thurkans, sainis, kambojs, khatris also belong to the "Scythian RACE".
You still run into the problem of classifying jatts as a different race than everyone else. This racial difference does not exist. If it did, I would imagine you'd have no problem pointing it out.
With so many waves of invasions, mass rapes, intermixing over the thousands of years, I doubt if any one group in Northern India can claim purity to origin. And even if purity to origin can be claimed - to what point? Purity to tribe X from 3 thousand years ago? Who knows how much intermixing took place in that group from 3 thousands years ago.
In the end, you are left with class/caste distinctions based on an ethnic identity which is nothing more than a solidarity that we are a different group.
That's fine, because what is ethnicity? According to Wikipedia:
"An ethnic group is a culture or subculture whose members are readily distinguishable by outsiders based on traits originating from a common racial, national, linguistic, or religious source. Members of an ethnic group are often presumed to be culturally or biologically similar, although this is not in fact necessarily the case.
Ethnic groups share a common origin, and exhibit a continuity in time, that is, a history and a future as a people. This is achieved through the intergenerational transmission of common language, institutions, values and traditions. It is important to consider this characteristic of ethnic groups if we are to distinguish them from a group of individuals who share a common characteristic, such as ancestry, in a specific point in time. On the political front, ethnic groups are distinguished from nation-states by the former's lack of sovereignty."
Lets examine that statement with re to classe/castes in Northern India.
There are not distinct racial, linguistic or religious traits seperating Jatts, Thurkans, Sainis, Kambojs in North Indians.
Different castes might have different intergenerational transmission of "language, institution, values, and tradition" but I have not seen this.
I have friends who belonged to different castes before taking amrit, and have seen no difference in the values and traditions they pass on to their children and see no difference in their families. My friend's former Jatt family passes on the Sikh ideals of bravery, hard-work, and anakh, the same way my other friend's Saini family does. Where is the difference?
By and large, most northern indians can lay claim to an anceastery stemming from the steppes. Most also have an anceastory marked by numerous invading tribes. But that is it.....................looking back to whatever group we may have come from, today, there is no distinction other than the argument:
"We're different cause we say we're different"
Jujharu wrote:
> Unreal, you are an uneducated pindu. Jatts are a distinct
> ETHNIC GROUP belonging to the Scythian RACE, below is a break
> down of Punjabi ethnic groups:
>
> Jatts, Rajput, Gujjars – Scythian (The 2nd to last wave of
> invaders into Northern India)
> Khatris, Brahmins - Indo-Aryan (1st wave settlers)
> Chura, Chammars – Dravidian (Native people of Indian
> subcontinent)
>
> Jatts are not a caste, there are other farming communities in
> Punjab aswell, they are Kamboj and Saini, the Punjabi word for
> farmer is Kisaan.
>
> Jatts are broken down into numerous clans like Sandhu,
> Sidhu/Brar, Mann, Gill, Dhillon, Dhaliwal. Each Jatt clan has
> its own history. Jatts have NEVER conformed to Brahmin
> ideology, we are independent people. Rural Punjab is Jatt
> territory, it is alien land to a Brahmin.
>
> Chammars and Tharkhans come from a Sanatan Hindu fold. Jatts
> had there own customs and culture, like ancestor worship. We
> are completely different people, completely different mentality
> and values. This difference in mentality manifested itself in
> the 80's where you had Jatt Sikhs dieing for Sikhi and you had
> other communities supporting the GOI or acting neutral.
>
> Most of you people are a joke. You have never been or lived in
> Punjab long enough to understand the huge difference in Jatts
> are others. We are a separate people with our own culture,
> values and history.
Re: Caste or Class?
Mirza jatt · 24 Oct 2005
bro death is worse for a jatt to give his identity up. You can be sikh and jatt and muslim and jatt.
Re: Caste or Class?
A Singh · 24 Oct 2005
<>
This again highlights the points made earlier, Jatts really think themselves as the backbone of Sikhi and are quick to point fingers at non-Jatt inviduals who have not acted in the interests of Sikhi at one time or the other (such as Gyani Zail Singh, Mastar Tara Singh and others) YET when mention is made of Badal, Tohra, KPS Gill and a huge list that can easily be constructed, they feel they are being "based" - well guys, if you want to diss out it, take it too when it comes round to you, like a Jatt is supposed!!!
And for my Veer Pardeep Singh Bilga:
<<>>
I have answered this time and again for you, expect you seem to be unable to understand simple English. The picture you painted is grossly incorrect - the vast majority of Tarkhans, Jatts, Churas etc are hardly in their 'hereditary' profession any longer, you have a serious issue with this I can see...but chullo, I guess for the rest of readers, the truth about Jatt attitudes to life and people in general is becoming clearer and clearer.
Finally, the business of origins is so hilarious, just like the book concerning the Jat History! I suggest one tries reading Indian History sources a little more carefully because drawing such laughable conclusions.
Gur Fateh!
A "Singh"
Re: Caste or Class?
Mirza jatt · 25 Oct 2005
i just want to point out jatts are a brave, tenacious, highly motivated, industrious, race with unique habits known and practiciced only to themselves. This is why others cannot relate to or understand wher ewe are coming from. We are not your enemies but friends brothers, you have to accept us. This mighty jatts keep on roaring for all times.
Re: Caste or Class?
Khalsa · 25 Oct 2005
" Pardeep Singh Bilga"
"a decent Jatt Sikh like Simranjit Singh Mann"
Mr. Bilga do u know that "nana ji" grandfather of Simranjit Singh Mann was the high priest of Harminder Sahib who presented "SIROPA" to Brigadier- General DYER who gave order to open fire at Jalianvala Bagh Amritsar in 1919.
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
Mirza Jatt · 26 Oct 2005
khalsa bhaijaan if your grandfather served the siropa to genrel dair is it fair to hold your father or you responsible or even misjudge you for that? while you may have served your religion to your best capability and sacrificed parts of your life for it meanwhile every other person of your religion reminds you of what your grandfather did??
While i certainly believe in respect for ancestors, for they have given to us a unique heritage and honour i feel its unjustified to taint someone because of what their forefathers did.
Re: Caste or Class?
Sehajvir Singh · 26 Oct 2005
" dara singh no caste vala
Date: 10-14-05 07:09
Caste and race pride has no place in sikhism. Guru Granth Sahib is very clear on this there are not one set of rules for daily life and another contrary to gurmat for marriage. Jatt jeona maur was a hindu what does he have to do with gurmat path?
There are some singhs out there who served both in the babbar khalsa who have bore the brunt of indian tortures who came from chammar backgrounds one was very close to the singh who had his eyes and legs taken out after being burned in salt water . If one of them appeared before us for marriage they are free to marry our sisters it would be an honour. On the western front there are singhs from chammar backgrounds in the panth one of whom i know personally who comes to this site who do seva for the panth through parchar to the youth weekly.
We have no intrest in jeona maurs or jatts from jattworld.com are not worth the dirt on the floor of the singhs who have walked with their heads on their palms and or singhs who carry out panthic seva.
Pardeep singh as a singh who has left my khetti background behind let me advise you about the mindset of jatha singhs. This jatha looks at quality not quantity, we are based on principles not superiority complexes. So no guru da singh or singhani will care how many chamars are amritdhari we open our arms to all with one equal eye to each sikh brother and sikh sister. But i am personally disgusted by this stupudity of caste your all grown men not children. We will not tolerate anti gurmat activities.
1
JoSikhaKoPucheJaatSohSikhNahiMeroAadJugaad
Those who ask a sikh's caste, they are not my sikh, they never were, and they never will be --Sache Patsha Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee
2
varanaa varan n bhaavanee khehi khehi jalan baa(n)s a(n)gayaaraa||
Different sections(castes) of society develop hatred for one another and finish themselves through squabbles as the bamboos, due to their mutual friction, producing fire burn themselves as well as others.
ni(n)dhaa chaalai vaedh kee samajhan nehi agiaan gubaaraa||
Condemnation of the knowledge starts and in the darkness of ignorance nothing remains visible.
This Shabad is by Bhai Gurdaas Ji in Vaars Bhai Gurdaas on Pannaa 1
3
guramukh varan avaran hoe ra(n)g sura(n)g tha(n)bol parachai||
Gurmukhs go beyond the castes, colours and go about in equanimity like the red colour of betel leaf.
Bhai Gurdaas Ji
Vaars Bhai Gurdaas
5
4
jaanahu joth n pooshhahu jaathee aagai jaath n hae ||1|| rehaao ||
Recognize the Lord's Light within all, and do not consider social class or status; there are no classes or castes in the world hereafter. ||1||Pause||
Guru Nanak Dev Ji
Raag Aasaa
349
5
neh baran baran neh kuleh kul ||
You have no caste or social class, no ancestry or family.
naanak prabh kirapaal thoo ||2||9||138||
Nanak: God, You are Merciful. ||2||9||138||
This Shabad is by Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Raag Saarang on Pannaa 1231"
I could not have put it better. Beautiful post KHALSA JI. Why even dignify these people with responses. Let them believe in the myth of their greatness. Before you label me a jatt hater, my background is "jatt" But the day i took amrit i am proud to say i was transformed from a nobody to a KHALSA. Jatt is nothing. Every single self proclaimed JATT that I know is seriously an alcholic who thinks life is one big party. It doesn't matter what caste your parents, grandparents great great great grand parents belonged too. How does that define who you are. Your actions your asool define who you are. All the gurus were chosen based on merit not background. GET THAT STRAIGHT.
ALL you misguided people who want to make claims that "JATTS" are the backbone of sikhi. YOU MAKE ME SICK. Sikhi is so beyond anything you guys could ever imagine. Sikhi is something that is unbelievably beautiful you caste promoters will never understand. To understand something's beauty you have to look at it from a beautiful soul. A soul that has done naam kamai A soul that has delved into the deep paviter ocean of naam rass, A soul that has been cleaned through seva and simran. Tread the path of sikhi first properly and then tell me you believe in jaat paat. I implore all you people who are encouraging jaat paat to watch your mouth and show respect to the great faith of sikhi. Do some serious Naam Kamai then give your opinion about Sikhi. If you are not a Gursikh you have no right to comment on who has done what for our faith. If you are a self proclaimed JATT, Then by all means live in your dream world, just keep Sikhi out of it. THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS A JATT SIKH PERIOD.
Our Gurus were the jot of Akaal manifested here on earth to help elevate the lost masses and you think you guys can "contribute" or "do sikhi a favour". You lost people are nothing but that. Lost human souls who have inferiority complexes. Rise above your ego's and do some naam kamai. Realize the divine inside of you then you will realize that same divine is in every human being. And if every human being has the same divine light in them then how can we say they are lower or higher. It is direct disrespect to Akaal to say you are better then others based on you heritage. If you could ask any Gurmukh Shaheed if he was a jatt. He would probably laugh in your face and tell you to do some naam kamai then come back to him.
I guess Veer Kulbir Singh and other Gursikhs have kept their responses to a minimum on this thread because it is a clear cut answer to them. And to argue with people who believe otherwise is a waste of precious naam simran time.
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
Kulwinder Singh · 27 Oct 2005
Caste or Class?
Pardeep Singh Bilga Ji who do you rather live with,
Arungjeb or Mir Manu ?
Caste or Class both are evil,
Caste is the biggest evil of Asia. (Mostly in India)
Class is an evil in the entire world.
In both cases the effect is exploitation of the weaker.
Do you think Sikhism favour either of these evil?
You are either confused in your mind about the gravity of these two evils or you endorse them.
Sikhism is 100% clearly against both of them, I suggest you need to think deeply about these things before try to justify them with your comments, and yes you are justifying these evils when you try to explain them.
I have been away from the form for many months now, but I thought your comments are hidden endorsement for these evils.
Re: Caste or Class?
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 30 Oct 2005
Dear Khalsa jio- I am fully aware of the Grandfather (Roor Singh) of Simranjit Singh Mann who presented a siropa to the rogue O'Dwyer, BUT you cannot blame Sardar Mann who has on many occasions spoken - in public too about how he is aginst his grandfather for doing such an act.
Also- was Roor Singh his nana or dada?
Re: Caste or Class?
preetum kaur · 30 Oct 2005
caste and class are both against sikhi thats fine but jatts are a seperate race with their own culture. Yep there are shrabi jatts who are bad examples but there are many good examples of honourable simple minded jatt sikhs who extend their piar to all out there and good examples in sikhi.
Common not all jatst are bad or evil or promoite caste. if you want jatts to stop calling themselves jatts then you have to stop using the term white western sikhs indian sikhs european sikhs.
Re: Caste or Class?
Kulwinder Singh · 30 Oct 2005
Dear Preetum Kaur Ji,
I have not even once given reference about any particular caste in my comments, unlike you are doing clearly and in addition you are actually endorsing caste system , For me a human being is a human being without any thing else attach to it for the basis of discrimination, Sikhi however is a Philosophy to tune one's life for betterment, and a sikh is a sikh, notion of caste does not exist if you subscribe to Sikhism, You can’t say I believe in equality and then differentiates when it comes to marriages and being partners or have superiority or inferiority complex.
The Idea of using terms as term white western Sikhs is equally evil, as it discriminate against one and another, The term Indian Sikh or European Sikhs for addressing somebody where they live to address them is fine as long as they do not in anyway refer to them for the sake of discrimination either way ( positive or negative),
If you are collecting a census about people on the basis of post code area and address them with their post code area for the sake of referencing then it is ok, if that reference becomes a discriminating factor then it becomes an evil.
You can say one sex is male and another is female that is fine to identify them, but to discriminate on this basis is evil.
I hope I have cleared your doubts now.
Dear Pardeep Singh Bilga Ji have not commented back on my comments, I am looking forward to his reply.
Re: Caste or Class?
baseline · 01 Nov 2005
hey kully where has preetum endorsed caste? she has categorically stated jatts are a race.
Just like white sikhs are reffered to as white sikhs, and nepali sikhs would be nepali sikhs. Whats the big crime in that?
I have not found an iota of discrimination in preetums post, so why are you guys trying to exaagerate her and other jatt sikhs are some kind of hateful types?
Jatt sikhs can marry who they want nowdays but they have the right to choose jatt sikhs in marriage if they wish too why does that bother you as discriminatory? You have the right to marry who you want so why cant jatt sikhs? This may hurt a lot of our caste free zone brethren but jatt sikhs can and do love marriages with other groups but still the majority prefer other jatt sikhs even when they have the choice to marry out.
There is no superiority inferiority notion, jatt sikhs majority just happen to prefer to marry other jatt sikhs end of story. Thats how it is. caste is wrong and evil jatts are not a caste brother.
I do not know what you think you will get by trying to use religion to stop jatt sikhs being jatt sikhs but its not working. You exaggerate a person who has a lifetimes beliefs to a discriminatory level, do you really think that person or most you interact with will actually start marrying a kala somalian bengali sri lankan just because religion says we are equal. Bani and dasam granth also say even hindus and muslims and all men ar eequal that does not mean tomorow majority of sikhs are going to marry brahmins, muslims and red indians.
A long time ago sikhs used to really stand together from all groups until people like you tried this rss type brainwashing of jatt sikhs. sikhnet.coms intention was to unite this caste thing but instead drove a massive wedge between sikhs dividing sikhs up further. Now you will find jatt sikhs becoming more exclusive the more you to try to hold us down.
Think about what you are doing.
Re: Caste or Class?
nav virdi · 01 Nov 2005
its been prooven by many research surveys that when choosing partners people prefer someone close to their own type of thing, whether thats looks, culture, or whatever. Women being more refined themselves generally prefer guys with refined features this is just one example .
It just so happens that cultures patterns of living have evolved a certain way in existance to make people stick to this thing. I am kinda afro looking and get a lot of attraction from kalis but i do not mind can be good.
Re: Caste or Class?
Kulwinder Singh · 01 Nov 2005
Dear Baseline,
Neither you have bothered to read my comments carefully nor comments from Preetum,
Read the facts from my comments and Preetum’s comments:
1. I have not mentioned any particular caste in my comments, unlike you and Preetum.
2. I have said that “You can’t say I believe in equality and then differentiates when it comes to marriages and being partners or have superiority or inferiority complex.”
This Comment state that you can identify your self as anything but do not use that identity as a factor for discrimination
3. Pretum have written “jatts are a separate race with their own culture” , Sikhism do not have problem with different culture, Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is a Garden full of many cultures and language and diversity is fantastic, Problem is when you discriminate on the basis of difference and make caste or culture or anything else to stick to the evils of Brahmanwad ( And for a Sikhs this is the most dangrus evil of all which still divide Sikhs and degrade Sikhism to mere an extension of Hinduism)
4. Pretum has also written “there are many good examples of honourable simple minded jatt Sikhs who extend their piar to all out there and good examples in sikhi” Dear Pretum Ji even Manu (the man who wrote Manu Simrities ) would say that he loved all human beings regardless of their caste, but as his god created the caste it is beyond his role to undo the doing of his god and treat everybody one.”
5. Pretum have also written “Common not all jatst are bad or evil or promote caste” She is the one who is hinting some things which I think is completely bonkers mad, to label some people like that.
And before you go any further on this point , I like to make it clear that cast system’s evil existence in Sikhism is not a fault of one Major or minor group, it is a virus which is eating Sikhism from all corners.
6. Preetum have also said “if you want jatts to stop calling themselves jatts then you have to stop using the term white western Sikhs Indian Sikhs European Sikhs. “
I like to make it clear that anybody can call themselves what ever they want to call themselves. I do not have problem with that, I and Sikhism have extremely serious problem with that if what ever they want to use to identify themselves become a base for discrimination.
Baseline you have written “she has categorically stated jatts are a race. Just like white Sikhs are referred to as white Sikhs, and nepali Sikhs would be nepali Sikhs. What’s the big crime in that? “
And I have said “If you are collecting a census about people on the basis of post code area and address them with their post code area for the sake of referencing then it is ok, if that reference becomes a discriminating factor then it becomes an evil. “.
Baseline you have said “Jatt Sikhs can marry who they want nowadays but they have the right to choose jatt Sikhs in marriage if they wish too why does that bother you as discriminatory? You have the right to marry who you want so why cant jatt Sikhs? This may hurt a lot of our caste free zone brethren but jatt Sikhs can and do love marriages with other groups but still the majority prefer other jatt Sikhs even when they have the choice to marry out “
What is your point in the above comments ?
Then you saying “There is no superiority inferiority notion, jatt Sikhs majority just happen to prefer to marry other jatt Sikhs end of story. That’s how it is. caste is wrong and evil jatts are not a caste brother.”
Obliviously you did not read my comments previously written as “If you are collecting a census about people on the basis of post code area and address them with their post code area for the sake of referencing then it is ok, if that reference becomes a discriminating factor then it becomes an evil.
You can say one sex is male and another is female that is fine to identify them, but to discriminate on this basis is evil.”
Baseline does this make clear for you why I am against is Discrimination
Baseline you have written “I do not know what you think you will get by trying to use religion to stop jatt Sikhs being jatt Sikhs but its not working.”
Well Baseline Ji it has not stopped even when Guru Gobind Singh ji himself stated “ Jab eh kare bipren ke reet Ma Na Karu in kee par-teet” and till this day large number of so called Sikhs are doing exactly Bipren ke reet.
So who the hell I am to get this evil stopped by using Internet Forum ?
I think you comments “ But it is not working” are true my dear, never mind my attempts Even the attempts of 11 Sikh Guru’s have not worked because there are some elements who love one or another way of avoiding to acknowledge the fact that we are ONE, because for these people belief in their evil system is far more dear then the word of Guru.
But you know Give about 100 years more, the idea of caste will not exist in Sikhism, as more people become knowledgeable they can understand the power of this evil and all evils run away from knowledge, not because Knowledge have some fearsome weapon to destroy this evil, it is the weakness of the evil system which divide people on caste, Colour, race, Language and money , status , political power and class that simply can not stand in front of knowledgeable people so this evil will not survive as it is unsustainable evil.
You have said “Bani and dasam granth also say even hindus and muslims and all men ar eequal that does not mean tomorow majority of Sikhs are going to marry brahmins, muslims and red indians.”
A Guru Sikh should marry Guru Sikh as I consider Guru Nanak’s philophy the best in the world.
You have also written “A long time ago Sikhs used to really stand together from all groups until people like you tried this rss type brainwashing of jatt Sikhs. sikhnet.coms intention was to unite this caste thing but instead drove a massive wedge between Sikhs dividing Sikhs up further. Now you will find jatt Sikhs becoming more exclusive the more you to try to hold us down.”
Dear Basline Ji First thing I am not brainwashing anybody, But my real father ( Guru Gobind Sinhg Ji) did and still do try to clean people’s mind with his vision and fantastic philophy, I am certainly would love to see all the Sikhs as one force above all I would love to see the whole world as one strong human force who take guide from Guru Nanak, if sikhnet.com is trying to achieve this I can only congratulate them with deepest pleasure in my heart.
Baseline it is horribly Sad to see that you have written “the more you to try to hold us down.” No my dear why would a Sikh want to hold anybody down, My 9th Guru gave his life to protect the rights of people who believed in the complete opposite of what he was preaching. So do not think I am holding you down, But I like to point out that it seems like you do want to hold the Sikhism down with that kind of point of view, Luckily that is certainly will not work as I said the discrimination on these stupid bases when it comes to marriage is unsustainable and these evils will be wiped out not because I want them to be wiped out but because they are evil and will not stand against the knowledge which is getting stronger everyday, which is good news.
You last question basline ji is “Think about what you are doing.”
I do not need to think about this kind of things, caste or class both are evil,
In the west at least people did not have to believe in the evil cast system and in today’s world which is predominately capitalist, even under these system most of the world leaders want to create classless society in their countries.
Which is FANTASTIC, Ironically Even people who are the master of creating jobs and profits in capitalist economies want classless societies and they do not have caste system so who do you think is more close to GOD.
A pretending Sikh or simple human being who believe in One GOD and oneness of his order and one human race.
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
' · 01 Nov 2005
This Shabad is by Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Raag Aasaa on Pannaa 487
mhlw 5 ]
mehalaa 5 ||
Fifth Mehl:
goibMd goibMd goibMd sMig nwmdyau mnu lIxw ]
gobi(n)dh gobi(n)dh gobi(n)dh sa(n)g naamadhaeo man leenaa ||
Naam Dayv's mind was absorbed into God, Gobind, Gobind, Gobind.
AwF dwm ko CIpro hoieE lwKIxw ]1] rhwau ]
aadt dhaam ko shheeparo hoeiou laakheenaa ||1|| rehaao ||
The calico-printer, worth half a shell, became worth millions. ||1||Pause||
bunnw qnnw iqAwig kY pRIiq crn kbIrw ]
bunanaa thananaa thiaag kai preeth charan kabeeraa ||
Abandoning weaving and stretching thread, Kabeer enshrined love for the Lord's lotus feet.
nIc kulw jolwhrw BieE gunIX ghIrw ]1]
neech kulaa jolaaharaa bhaeiou guneey geheeraa ||1||
A weaver from a lowly family, he became an ocean of excellence. ||1||
rivdwsu FuvMqw For nIiq iqin iqAwgI mwieAw ]
ravidhaas dtuva(n)thaa dtor neeth thin thiaagee maaeiaa ||
Ravi Daas, who used to carry dead cows every day, renounced the world of Maya.
prgtu hoAw swDsMig hir drsnu pwieAw ]2]
paragatt hoaa saadhhasa(n)g har dharasan paaeiaa ||2||
He became famous in the Saadh Sangat, the Company of the Holy, and obtained the Blessed Vision of the Lord's Darshan. ||2||
sYnu nweI buqkwrIAw Ehu Gir Gir suinAw ]
sain naaee buthakaareeaa ouhu ghar ghar suniaa ||
Sain, the barber, the village drudge, became famous in each and every house.
ihrdy visAw pwrbRhmu Bgqw mih ginAw ]3]
hiradhae vasiaa paarabreham bhagathaa mehi ganiaa ||3||
The Supreme Lord God dwelled in his heart, and he was counted among the devotees. ||3||
ieh ibiD suin kY jwtro auiT BgqI lwgw ]
eih bidhh sun kai jaattaro out(h) bhagathee laagaa ||
Hearing this, Dhanna the Jaat applied himself to devotional worship.
imly pRqiK gusweIAw DMnw vfBwgw ]4]2]
milae prathakh gusaaeeaa dhha(n)naa vaddabhaagaa ||4||2||
The Lord of the Universe met him personally; Dhanna was so very blessed. ||4||2||
(Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee)
from www.sikhitothemax.com
Re: Caste or Class?
' · 01 Nov 2005
This Shabad is by Bhagat Naam Dev Ji in Raag Bhairao on Pannaa 1164
hsq Kylq qyry dyhury AwieAw ]
hasath khaelath thaerae dhaehurae aaeiaa ||
Laughing and playing, I came to Your Temple, O Lord.
Bgiq krq nwmw pkir auTwieAw ]1]
bhagath karath naamaa pakar out(h)aaeiaa ||1||
While Naam Dayv was worshipping, he was grabbed and driven out. ||1||
hInVI jwiq myrI jwidm rwieAw ]
heenarree jaath maeree jaadhim raaeiaa ||
I am of a low social class, O Lord;
CIpy ky jnim kwhy kau AwieAw ]1] rhwau ]
shheepae kae janam kaahae ko aaeiaa ||1|| rehaao ||
why was I born into a family of fabric dyers? ||1||Pause||
lY kmlI cilE pltwie ]
lai kamalee chaliou palattaae ||
I picked up my blanket and went back,
dyhurY pwCY bYTw jwie ]2]
dhaehurai paashhai bait(h)aa jaae ||2||
to sit behind the temple. ||2||
ijau ijau nwmw hir gux aucrY ]
jio jio naamaa har gun oucharai ||
As Naam Dayv uttered the Glorious Praises of the Lord,
Bgq jnW kau dyhurw iPrY ]3]6]
bhagath janaa(n) ko dhaehuraa firai ||3||6||
the temple turned around to face the Lord's humble devotee. ||3||6||
(Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee)
from www.sikhitothemax.com
Re: Caste or Class?
Kulwinder Singh · 02 Nov 2005
Simply Fantastic ! Thanks for the kind reference to Panna 487 and 1164 very valuable Shabad, I hope people can change and understand what Guru's Ji is saying.
Many thanks again my dear friend.
Re: Caste or Class?
gunpowder · 04 Nov 2005
guys i just want to say jatts gnerally feel they have racial traits tall fair big broad hawkish.
Maybe some do not fit that description, but we all know stereotyps do stick and they certainly do amongst sikhs.
It just so happens people prefer to stick to someone they feel closer with. Like white sikhs do marry white sikhs. white hare krishnas prefer to marry white hare krishnas and i have found white sangats prefer to socialise with other whites while indians stick to indians no matter what religion they are in. Blacks are cool, but they feel a greater closeness to indians who have more fat nak and big lips. It is getting more like that even pakistanis the kashmiris stick to kashmiris now and punjabi paks stick to their own, while pathans to theirs. T
I do agre with kulwinder singh but from what i have sene in life its not about caste as much as it is about people grouping themself into races. I know it might not be good but its there what can you do? its in your face everywhere you go.
Re: Caste or Class?
bagga · 05 Nov 2005
there is actually a wrong approach to this.
A lot of kids have been bought up to feel this caste pride. This will clash big time with religion.
This is a knock on thing from sikhnet.com which became a battleground between sikhs and what turned into jatt sikhs.
Lets not get judgemental on right or wrong, because this has heavily divided the youth into jatt websites creating a further problem. Thus we are pushing our own brothers and sisters away by telling them too harshly.
Maybe its time we take a different approach, bring these brothers in slowly to sikhi through example, show them nimrata and love while making it clear caste has no place for you or for the panth but they can believe in whatever they want.
Re: Caste or Class?
Kulwinder Singh · 07 Nov 2005
Dear bagga Ji
there is actually a wrong approach to this ?
Could you please clear the above point for me.
Your point “This will clash big time with religion.” It is not a matter that it will but it is a big clash with religion right now,
you are right to say “A lot of kids have been bought up to feel this caste pride “.
Problems is our parents and grandparents generally older generation who teach this evil to their children and promote this Anti Sikhi thought to youngsters and corrupt their minds, and cloud their judgments, Same people who teach and emphasise this evil will be more happy if their children go off religion then if their children marry out of caste, very shameful for us to have this serious racism evil within Sikhs.
You are also saying “show them nimrata and love while making it clear caste has no place for you or for the panth “ I don’t think anybody object to that.
Then remarkably you also saying “ but they can believe in whatever they want. “
I do not know what to make of it, May be you are saying that we should point out what Sikhi Says and they can do what ever they want, I am sorry but this is something fundamental in Sikhi, There is no comparison of this evil, How would we feel if in the west, Governments starting saying that equal opportunities policies are wrong and racism is fine ?
I sense that you want to see some kind of third way in dealing with this but I am not sure how you can talk of equality then divide people on basis of something which most of the world regard as evil.
Strangle even people who fall into the traps of caste system admit it is an evil, so how long do we need to carry on admitting this is an evil and how long will it take for us to abandon something that evil.
Bagga Ji I am not taking a shot at you but you need to be clear in your view and most of the caste system from sikhi can disappear over night if people who at least admit it is an evil start to abandon and it openly and start talking it as a shameful part of our culture which need to be wiped out completely.
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
ggg · 29 Jun 2006
The jatt sikhs do not make the best soldiers, Any one who studies history would know that the back bone of sikhism has been the Mazbhi (Chura Sikh). Lets look at history! Bhai Jetha(later baptized and became Bhai Jiwan Singh) his younger brother Bhai Sangaat Singh, they were Mazbhis, Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Ji was a Mazbhi Mai Bhago, she was also a Mazbhi! The 40 sikhs that deserted guru gobind singh were all Jatts lead by Mann Singh! Akali Phula Singh was a Mazbhi, the great sardar Hari singh Nalua was a Mazbhi. In fact the akali nihang order was mostly all Mazbhi! Nower Days They are being replaced by Jatts. Botha & Garjha Singh were both Mazbhis! The Mazbhi time and time again has proved that they are the best soldiers, Fearless Brave, highly renowned for their dauntless courage. Guru Gobind Singh himself said "Rangtetta Guru Ka Betta"
Banda Singh Bahadur followers were mostly Mazbhi. Maharaja Ranjit Singh highly regarded the Mazbhi as Soldiers. The mazbhi was the back bone of the Khalsa forces, Thats a Fact. The British also recognised the Mazbhi as the back bone of the Khalsa Forces during the two anglo sikh wars. The British were greatly impressed by the stubborn resistance and prowness of those men at arms. The Britsih Raised sikh regiments from Mazbhi sikhs first.1857 was the year. The fist sikhs to get into the british army were Mazbhi sikhs....not jatts. The First World war saw the rise of the famous trio of Sikh pioneers, 23rd, 32nd and the 34rth with three battalions each! All sikh pioneers drawing man power from the mazbhi element of sikhism. They never lost a single inch of land. the 34th performed so outstandingly they won the title of "royal" from King George the V. i dont see jatt sikhs winning royal titles. World war two was the same. the british highly regarded the Mazbhi sikh! and assembled them quickly for wwII , they also started to recruit ravidassia sikhs as well. They called the new regiment "the Mazbhi and Ravidassia sikhs" the name was changed in 1944 to the Sikh Light infantry. The sikh LI did the commando work during the second world war in Burma unlike the jatt sikh regiment that worked as a regular mechanized army unit! The british did not consider the Jatt as good as the mazbhi, definatly when it came to soldiering. Jatt Vs Mazbhi who would win i wonder? "Jatts make the best soldiers" what a joke. Jatt sikhs are famous for deserting Guru Gobind Singh ji and a Mazbun insulted them and went to battle her self. Even today if a jatt fights with a chura the jatt gets smashed. But then again i know of cases were churas and Jatts are friends. The fact is mazbhis have been the back bone of sikhism for a very long time. It is only now Mazbhi numbers are falling. Jatts are not a seperate race, Jatts are 4rth class Shudras that do hard labour on farms. There used to be atime where jatts would share one wife amoungst 4 brothers because they were so poor. Hindus used to treat jatts badly by taking unfair profit of a jatt's produce or they would not hesitate to put the jatt under debt as they were also an illiterate caste back in the very old days. The Jatts economical rise in status has seen the Jatt Caste accepted by hindus. This is the reason why jatts have also become socialy higher than they once were.
Re: Caste or Class?
singhnum1 · 30 Jun 2006
nam gurbani gurmat rehat makes a person both mentally physically strong and instills inner strentgh. controlling your 5 vices aids your progress further.
This is why puratan sikhs whether you choose to label them mazbhi jatt tirkaan were all pretty strong people. hari singh nalwa banda singh nawab kapur singh virk and co.
Re: Caste or Class?
Non-Sikh by Choice · 30 Jun 2006
Jatt is not a caste. It's an tribe! Some of you people need to do a little research of what a Jatt is before making such comments in this thread.
Re: Caste or Class?
safe dude · 04 Jul 2006
jatts certainly are not a homogenous tribe non sikh.
uppals used to be khattris believe it or not. show me the background history of grewals rajput or not? can you proove to me beyond doubt grewals have this mythical middle eastern history or moved from rajistan to malwa?
bagris rajput or not? whats the history of maans and sihotas?
down to reality,we even got a lifelong irish friend who came into sikhi and speaks perfect punjabi married to a punjabi girl who was the daughter of a jatt sikh from punjab. tribalness?
Define what you mean? Whatever tribalness was around is not so big anymore. In gravesend a once strong jatt base most of the munde are marrying gurjrati girls creating mixed children.
the traits of punjabis are varieing some dark some light some tall some small. meaning we cannot be an ethnic group either. So what are we?
Guru Gobind singh ji spoke of rangretta guru ka bhetta what does this mean?
punjab was the bridge between india and the rest of the world for thousands of years and what does that mean? hm
how comes you find sohals in ghumars? and sodhis in both jatts and khattris? tribalism? im lost.
But for some reason i do like and see jatt culture as the cradle of what we once were. But there are bits that just do not make sense and other bits that are plain ancient especially this izat and honour thing can be taken to the extreme. My grandparents cannot even reason right and wrong when their honour is concerned. So to me a western raised kid some parts of culture is dead in the pan where it belongs. Most of us would swap tribal identity and fulfil our spiritual needs of the day and learn to cope in kal yug and create a perfect equilibrium with sikhi. In some ways jatt culture can promote very strong familiy bonds but i feel we need to seperate the goodness from the bad.
each to their own views, just speaking from my own experiences and those around me.
Re: Caste or Class?
kaleji junction · 04 Jul 2006
thats interesting point apparently a very beautiful muslim female tried to seduce hari singh nalwa and he just did not budge in his sikhi. Was hari singh ji married? The warrior who tamed afghanistan brua.
Now if these singhs went out to jhang they obviously would not have the time to do what we corrupted people have more time to do in our lives. And yet they were victorious or fought against such odds leaving a lasting impression. But you just do not see that today. If a man and woman control their kam level at the same pace and cut down would they not aid their own spirituality? and progress further with more energy in the right direction so if the need came sikhs could once again stand up for themselves in such a way where they win.
This also defeats the caste and tribe thing.
Why would someone look at the caste or tribe of shaheed sikhs or those who fought?
I think people need to analyse their minds a bit. When i grew up people associated themselves with sikhism because it gave the name. Then jassi b and others took up the work of mirasis (muslim singers) and added in caste or tribe lyrics and now we have this new era of split identities. Still to me i would rather have sikhs in my mind who fought without remembering their caste or tribe
than remember jazzi b and surinder shindas songs anyday.
Re: Caste or Class?
tip top jatt · 04 Jul 2006
The Jat-Mughals and other Jat admixtures.
p.g.368
the Hir claims to be descendants of Qutab-ud-din
Jat descent is admitted by the Bhullar,Her and Man;by the sirpa(Gils by origin),the Bhangu,who say they came from nepal by the Waraich and apparently the Nol.Rajput origin is vaguely alleged by the Bal,Chhandbar Dhindsa(Saroha),Ghatwal(Saroha),mahal and Sumra.
Thus solar Rajput origin is claimed by the Aulak,Bains,Janjus,Bhutta,Bhuttar,Chahil(Tunwar),Lunar Rajput by the Dhillon(Saroha),Ghumman,Goraya(Saroha),Kahlon.
And in many cases the Jat tribe can point to the Rajput tribe from which it sprang.For example,Bhatti Rajput descent is claimed by the Dhariwal ,Sara,and Sidhu
wirk:Punwar Rajput descent by the Kharral,Harral and Sarai
Rajput ancestry i.e. a last status Rajput--are claimed by Janjua Jats,Chauhan Jats,Dhul,Sohial,Kalial,Goraya,Langarbal,Maral,and Mangat;Janjua rajput origin is claimed by the Kotharmal;Bhatti Rajput origins is claimed by the
Bhatti ,Dhariwal,Paroi,tora,dhamal,Dhali,Randawa,Sahota,Soya,Surai,Kalwal,Kaher,Korantana,Guhlo,Gudho,Gujral,Liddar,Mehar,Mahota,Multani,Nijjra,Hunjar and Hatian;Punnu(Surajbansi) origin is claimed by the Dudhrai,Poti,Gil,Thuthal,Mathi,Nat;Raghbansi by the Rahang Chauhan;Rajput origin is claimed by the Thanel,Gohi and Kaler;Tur Rajput descent is claimed by the Takkar;Langah Rajputs gave birth to the chach,and Manhas to the Raihsi,Katwar,Lohdra,Mahe,Mair,Nangial and wirk;gondal Jat extraction is admitted by the Tola,Jaspal,Sandrana and Ghug;Waraich by the Suggar;Dhariwal by the Sidh,and Ranjha by the Khamb,Gudgor
Re: Caste or Class?
barsha · 06 Jul 2006
after a little research here is your preffered history non sikh by choice
of your own forefathers who were undoubtedly rajputs neither having origins in punjab nor being subjects within maharaja ranjit singhs panjab. I know i would prefer to relate my history to the start of sikhism than to be linked to indian rajputs.
Take the sikhism out of your tribal pride conciousness whats left? nothing! its sikhism that gave you the mark to be invincible sava lakh.
take a peed up bacardi whizzing teenage grewal in surrey, whats he gonna do against 50 thugs alone? Now take an amritdhari singh reading bani and japping naam he has prooved beyond reasonable doubt to challenge 125 000. chamkaur gali shaheeds guru gobind singh ji. hari singh nalwa taming afghanistanis who the british are having a hard time with now.
Why are punjabis imitating rajputs? excessive pride, earings, gold, royalties, dhoom dhaam shaan, trying to be something out of the ordinary when guru sahib made all men one. we can wear the simple kara like every other sikh and be the dust of the ground with each other so we may unite
Without sikhi we are lost sheep in todays world.
Every ordinary man is out there to make a name, what will we do with name and fame when we enter our last breathe? its all in your head you are exposed to the waves of changing maya, the only thing that wil lremain eternal is the name of God. Culture and tribalisms have come and gone, the only thing that will ever save you from maya is sikhi.
GREWAL.
They share their family tree with Chandel Rajputs. Chandels are one of the 36 roral castes of Rajputs. Parimal Chandel had enmity both with Prithviraj Chauhan as well as Jai Chand. At the time of Mohd Gauri’s invasion, Parimal did not support either of them. It was his turn now and Kalinjar was captured by Moslems in 1203 AD. Later on Moslems also captured the forts of Lalitpur and Chandoli as well. Chandel Rajputs had lost their power and glory. They moved towards Haryana, Himachal and Punjab. Grewal of Punjab have descended from Chandels of Lalitpur. They came into Punjab in around 1469 AD. It is said that one of the Chandel kings, named Bairsi (who was born in the cover of a large sand-mound- Griha) was brought up at his mother’s village and later on called Griah Wala. In later usage, it became Grewal. Gujjar was seventh generation progeny of Bairsi who founded Gujjarwal in 1469.
Only on the asking of Grewals of Gujjarwal and Dadu Gill of Moga had Mehar Mittha Dhaliwal agreed to marry his granddaughter to Akbar. Akbar conferred large estates on Dhariwals, Grewals and Gills to appease them. By the virtue of his marriage , Akbar had greatly improved his relations with them.
Most of the Grewals are settled in the district of Ludhiana. Some of the Grewal are also settled in Ferozepur, Bathinda, Mansa, Sangrur and Patiala districts.
In Haryana, Grewals are Hindu Jaats. Guru Hargobind visited Gujjarwal in 1631 AD. Grewals embraced Sikhism at this time.
There are 40 Grewal villages in the Shekhavati region of Rajasthan. Some of the Grewals are also settled in Delhi and Haryana. They are all Hindu Jaats.
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
Non-Sikh by Choice · 06 Jul 2006
LOL @ THIS UK KID
<<>>
Not being subjects within Maharaja Ranjit Singh’s Punjab? Are you saying that Grewal’s didn’t live in Ranjit Singh’s Punjab? My family came from Pakistan before the partition.
<<>>
Umm okay!
“GREWAL is one of the many last names of early Rajput and Jat tribes that played an important historical role in Sikh history who later adopted sikhism while other rajput tribes fought against it.”
So you can’t take my tribe history away from Sikhi because our history is part of Sikhi if you like it or not.
<<>>
You got to be kidding me? I doubt an Amritdhari kid from Surrey or Brampton can fight against 50 thugs alone. Grewal’s here in Canada (like every other Jatts) are crazy people. Throw in an Amritdhari to fight against 50 thugs alone and let’s see what he/she capable of doing. In fact, if wasn’t for Jatts like us Grewal Jatts, a lot of Amritdharis will get bullied around a lot here in Canada. Most people here in Canada don’t mess with Sikhs because of us Jatts NOT because you Amrithdaris. THAT’S A FACT!
On a side note, it's funny how people are attacking me because my last name. It shows how low some people can go to make themselves look like saints.
Re: Caste or Class?
Non-Sikh by Choice · 06 Jul 2006
<<>>
Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Ji was a Jatt. He belongs to the Sandhu tribe.
Mai Bhago was a Jatti. She belongs to the Warriach tribe.
Re: Caste or Class?
Non-Sikh by Choice · 06 Jul 2006
<<< Define what you mean? Whatever tribalness was around is not so big anymore. In gravesend a once strong jatt base most of the munde are marrying gurjrati girls creating mixed children.>>>
I don’t know what part of the world you are from, but here in Canada, it very uncommon for a Jatt to marry a non-Jatt.
<<< how comes you find sohals in ghumars? and sodhis in both jatts and khattris? tribalism? im lost.>>>
Khattris is a caste! But you got to remember that there Hindu Jatts as well. Their follow the caste system since all Jatts share same tribe names. Since Hindu jatts kept their last names/tribe names, people started associating their last names with their caste. That’s why you can find Sohals in castes like khattris, but reality is that originally these names are not caste names at all. Also people got remember that caste system is based on profession, not last names.
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
Non-Sikh by Choice · 06 Jul 2006
Jatt is NOT a Caste but is an Ethnic Tribe
http://www.jattworld.com/portal/modules/mysections/article.php?lid=10
Re: Caste or Class?
barsha · 07 Jul 2006
if its the jattness that ensured the protective layer of sikhism then why have the hindu jatts not produced a single hari singh nalwa or two sahibzadey and chamkaur gail singhs or a banda bahadur singh who were not jatts fighting alongside their sikh brothers and did fight sava lakh?
how comes the muslim jatts neither have the prowess shared amongst punjabi sikhs whatever caste the earlier sikhs came from?
therefore it was the sikhi that made you your dear grewals and all you other dear punjabi fellows. The proof lies in sikh history. Before that as per grewal history you were chandel rajputs in india. This is grewal history just before sikhism
"Only on the asking of Grewals of Gujjarwal and Dadu Gill of Moga had Mehar Mittha Dhaliwal agreed to marry his granddaughter to Akbar. Akbar conferred large estates on Dhariwals, Grewals and Gills to appease them."
teach a kid to fight, and he will, teach a kid to sit there and he will. Sikhi has been lost for a long time, this is why jathebandis arose to bring back the lost heritage of sikhs. If amritdhari sikhs anywhere are taught bhagti from the start with ghatka martial arts they would be kicking it. perhaps the only reason canadian kids like you can large it is because you can congregate on one two key spots, this is the same mentality of muslims in bradford who feel their supreme with a number in an area like 80 000. Thats human nature. And then we have our chaar sahibzadey who were neither jatt and fought entire empires on 4 sides.
Its surprising to note that earlier day sikhs sprang from various parts of india and whatever caste, yet are recorded to win heroic battles, to sava lakh. If this was down to jattness then please tell me why this is not evident in the british empire? and in punjab after 1984? and even now where punjab is still dominated by jatt sikhs? Surely punjab would have been a sikh homeland a sikh paradise with no problems if all we needed were a few jatts to handle it.
and where arethese mega jatts fighting for sikhism on the racist attacks along the west coast of both america and canada?
how can jatt be an ethnic tribe when grewals only migrated to punjab from india while other surnames came from other parts of india pakistan what we call today peshawar rajistan bikaner uttar pradesh. tell me the history of bal jatts if they have not derived from bhagat prahlads grandson? and where did that take place? so how an earth can jatts be " a tribe"? thats like saying the khans came from peshwar and the patels came from gujrat and are "a tribe".
Re: Caste or Class?
barsha · 07 Jul 2006
by attaching jaat paat to shaheed singhs and singhanis
your trying to proove a point that does not exist. Can you really picture shaheed sikhs passionatly believein in sikhi singing their putt jatta de?
shaheed baba deep singh ji was a singh, mai bhago was a kaur.
be real!
you feel attacked because grewal history is linked to rajputs who did not originate in punjab?
Re: Caste or Class?
Khalsa Jatha · 07 Jul 2006
Some people get so exicited over their surnames. LOL! Keep living in cuckoo land!
Re: Caste or Class?
barsha · 07 Jul 2006
the hir (heer) clan descended from quatab din. So how an earth are the hir any tribal or ethnic relation to grewals who descended from rajistan?
How can jatts be an ethnic tribe when some are tall some are small? some are dark brown some are white as milk? some have flat facial features some have pointy features?
the same can be said of all other punjabis.
how can any punjabis be an ethnic tribe when punjab was used as an entry point by every other nationality coming to india ie the moghuls arabs turks ?
define ethnicity to me first.
Re: Caste or Class?
Non-Sikh · 07 Jul 2006
I don’t know too much about Muslim Jatt history but I do know that Rammat Khan Warriach was a Jatt though.
As for Hindu Jatt warriors, well here are some Hindu Jatt warriors I know of: Jatwan Jat, Raja Churaman and Raja Suraj Mal. Go to Jatland.com if you want to know more about Hindu Jats and their history.
<<< how can jatt be an ethnic tribe when grewals only migrated to punjab from india while other surnames came from other parts of india pakistan what we call today peshawar rajistan bikaner uttar pradesh. tell me the history of bal jatts if they have not derived from bhagat prahlads grandson? and where did that take place? so how an earth can jatts be " a tribe"? thats like saying the khans came from peshwar and the patels came from gujrat and are "a tribe".>>>
Genetics of Jatts:
“A recent study of the people of Indian Punjab, where about 40% or more of the population are Jats, suggest that the Jats are similar to other populations of the Indus Valley.The study involved a genealogical DNA test which examined single nucleotide polymorphisms (mutations in a single DNA "letter") on the Y chromosome (which occurs only in males). (See Human Y-chromosome DNA haplogroups for a listing and explanation.)
Jats seem to share many common haplotypes with German, Slavic, Baltic, Iranian and Central Asian groups.Unusually, Jat groups share only two haplotypes, one of which is also shared with the population of present-day Turkey, and have few matches with neighbouring Pakistani populations. This haplotype shared between the two Jat groups may be part of the Indo-Aryan (or Indo-European) genetic contribution to these populations, where as the haplotypes shared with other Eurasian populations may be due to the contribution of Indo-European Scythians (Saka, Massagetae) or White Huns. (These groups may of course all be branches of a larger ethnic complex.)
As for mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA), Jats contain haplogroups typical of North India, Pakistan, and West Asia. This suggests that, at least for mtDNA, there is very little connection with Central Asian or northwest European populations, even though Jats share many male Y-SNP markers with these populations. Hence this suggests that there has been male migration in or out of the Jat population in historical times. Alternatively, the formation of the Jat population may have occurred in West Asia or North India. Hence Jats are very similar to other North Indian and Pakistani groups.”
<<< teach a kid to fight, and he will, teach a kid to sit there and he will. Sikhi has been lost for a long time, this is why jathebandis arose to bring back the lost heritage of sikhs. If amritdhari sikhs anywhere are taught bhagti from the start with ghatka martial arts they would be kicking it. perhaps the only reason canadian kids like you can large it is because you can congregate on one two key spots, this is the same mentality of muslims in bradford who feel their supreme with a number in an area like 80 000. Thats human nature. And then we have our chaar sahibzadey who were neither jatt and fought entire empires on 4 sides.>>>
Wow! At first you said Amritdharis can fight, but now you are making excuses why they can’t fight. How sad! Whites, Blacks, Hispanics, Orientals, Hindu, Muslim etc. outnumber Jatts, but yet, they will not dare to start a fight against Jatts here in Canada. In fact, they’ll be scared to fight a Sikh because us Jatts. In Brampton, Majority of people living there are white but they will never dare to start a fight against a Jatt. How come? In Surrey, Sikhs only make up 16% of total population in Surrey. But no one there will dare to fight against Jatts. How come?
<<< If this was down to jattness then please tell me why this is not evident in the british empire? and in punjab after 1984? and even now where punjab is still dominated by jatt sikhs? Surely punjab would have been a sikh homeland a sikh paradise with no problems if all we needed were a few jatts to handle it.>>>
"They (Jat Sikhs) are manly without false pride, ---. No one could be associated with them for any time without conceiving both respect and liking for them". He went on to say, "the Jat Sikhs sent a very high percentage of their eligible men to the army". In fact the Jat Sikhs attach extremely high regard to the military and police services. The people who give their lives in battles or otherwise for a good cause in their eyes are regarded as the most honourable heroes. The modern Jats have up held the tradition of their forefathers.” - Major Barstow
"Just as quiet and peaceful men find pleasure in rest, so the Halani or Alani (Massagetae) delight in danger and warfare. There the man is judged happy who has sacrificed his life in battle,---". Lt. Gen. Sir MacMunn [9] said, "The opinions of experienced officers and the experience of the World War (I) have placed them (Jats) among the best of the Indian martial classes". He went on to write "---enthusiatic support of the British Government, and devoted and distinguished service in the World War (I) has been the reply of the modern Jat, whether Sikh, Hindu or Moslem in religion, to such suggestions".
Furthermore, the general said, "How the Jats have kept up their war-like proclivities through the ages, how the Jat who is Sikh has been so prominent and faithful a soldier of the Crown, or how the Hindu Jat came to such great fame in the World War (I), for one their battalions (i.e., 6th Jat Regiment) to receive the title of "Royal", will be told in the course of this book". Specifically, with respect to the Sikhs, Captain Bingley [22] wrote in 1899, "Whenever fighting is going on, be it in China, the straits, Burma, or East Africa, there the Sikh to be found. Offer him good pay, and there is no service, however difficult or dangerous, for which he will not gladly come forward". - Ammianus Marcellinus
In 1984, Jatts were running Punjab and they still are. People today who are fighting for Khalistan in Punjab are Jatts.
<<< and where arethese mega jatts fighting for sikhism on the racist attacks along the west coast of both america and canada?>>>
What are you talking about? It’s very rare to hear about racist attacks against Sikhs here in Canada.
<<< by attaching jaat paat to shaheed singhs and singhanis
your trying to proove a point that does not exist. Can you really picture shaheed sikhs passionatly believein in sikhi singing their putt jatta de?
shaheed baba deep singh ji was a singh, mai bhago was a kaur.
be real!>>>
Umm okay! Someone said those two were Mazbhi which was completely wrong. They were Jatts! How about you keep it real! Yes, some of the popular Sikhs took pride of being a Jatt. Jatt is a Jatt no matter what.
<<< you feel attacked because grewal history is linked to rajputs who did not originate in punjab?>>>
Umm no. Fact you people are using my last name to diss Jatts is totally uncalled for. Just you know, Singh is originally a Rajput last name, not a Sikh last name.
Re: Caste or Class?
Non-Sikh · 07 Jul 2006
<<>>
The Grewal community are the descendants of the Chandel Rajputs of Bilaspur in Himachal Pradesh which was part of Punjab long time ago until Indian government break it up.
<<>>
You can say same thing about every ethnic group in this world. There isn’t one community that looks exactly same from each other.
Re: Caste or Class?
SikhFacts · 10 Jul 2006
Let us analyse some of the comments here. There have been some quite hysterical comments.
Firstly Landowning Classes - There are many in Punjab, including Jatts, Mazbhai, Tarkhann, Rajpoot, Khatri, Bramin, Arora etc.
Were these always Landowning Classes? - According to Professor Grewal pn;y the Khatri's (Kshatriya's) and Rajpoot's have been land owning classes. The rest including Jatts have been known as "Kamins" (see poetry of Waris Shah).
The Jatt Question - Jatts were not in any significant numbers during the lifetime of the Guru's. The Paanth during that time was mostly Khatri's, Service Classes, Artisan's (Labana, Siklighar, Lohar, Tarkhan), and Untouchables. There were a few noticable Jatt like Baba Buddha and Bala.
Warriors in Sikhs - Most of the warrioirs during the ttime of the Sikh Guru's were not of Jatt background. Jatts came into the Sikh fold in large numbers in the 1700's.
see www.globalsikhstudies.net.
The Jatts have servered as honourable and loyal servants to the Sikh Paanth, but they were not there from the begining in large numbers.
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
Canadian (Non-Sikh by Choice) · 10 Jul 2006
<<>>
You got to be kidding me? All major Jatt clans converted to Sikhi during Sikh guru’s time. For an example, Grewal Jatts converted to Sikhi during Guru Hargobind Ji’s time. Another example is Brar Jatts. Check this quote out:
“If only you were gracious enough to come to the village of Kangar,
We could then see each other face to face. (58)
On the way, there will be no danger to your life,
for, the whole tribe of Brars accepts my command." - Guru Gobind Singh Ji (Zafarnama)
<<>>
Is there a stat/link for this where can I look into your statement with more depth? Some of most popular Sikh warriors are Jatt themselves.
Anyway, now some of you people need to stop hating on Jatts and try to change history to make Jatts look like nothing. Like it or not, Jatts have done a lot of good things for the Sikh community and they will continue to do great things for Sikhs. Now I think some of you people need to relax and focus on your “Sikhi” more than focusing on your hate for Jatts. This is going to be my last post in this thread unless if there is anything new to add/say in this thread.
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
humans are not different · 11 Jul 2006
Wherever people are loosing their spirituality they begin looking at each other and noticing differences.
The larger body of sikhs has from its half and half position given way and has its back broken until a time may come when they wake up to what the ten guru sahibs taught.
Some sikh groups believing in caste were either getting nowhere or end up dividing further, and producing very little chardi kala sikhs or the ones that were are not holding on much and end up going back to their old ways or what we call maya. Then in our wisdom we blame external elements failing to understand amrit is amrit and its strentgh and the flow of khalsas concepts if followed correctly one would never sway just like those old sikhs of yesterday.
I have no idea what akj or any of its associated groups are like but what i can say is where parchar on jaat paat is emphasised alongside gurbani and gurmat with other things those stay strong, develop much further in spirituality rapidly.
I have attended bhai ajit singhs sangat in swindon twice, there are two points i do not agree with, but overall majority i have to admit the guy speaks sense. We say ik oankar satnam karta purkh nirbau nirvair akal murat ajuni saibung gur prasad then we still believe in these castes races and tribes? with no sharam at all!
You should hear bhai sahib speak about how jaat paat (caste tribe or race affiliation) affects your bhagti ( the whole point of becoming a sikh).
Bhai sahib goes on to say how he did not get anywhere for 18 years of his life, and how he progressed rapidly within a short space of time. These things are not shared to make numbers but to ensure the youth actually stay on track and do not sway from sikhi and develop further to different stages
nam is recited with no other disturbance so mental focus is pushed towards it. bhai sahib talks about how we sikhs split each other up into groups castes sects and how we then become frustrated that we are not getting anywhere.
I cannot remember much more on the jaat paat issues but what i can say is within a very short space of time 60 youth are on rom rom level.
When those sikhs are in simran they are united into one force, by the end my own battreries were recharged just from 2 hours. Each sikh is humble and serves the other. Such punjabis are transformed into sikhs. This is not bhai ajit singhs efforts this is following gurmat and applying gurbani to ones life without irka.
there are other successful groups out there who stick to sikhi matt and do not have punjabi hang ups like we do.
Tell me how far have we got with our punjabinness? what was the point in taking amrit in the first place? This is the most casteless religion on earth, the most unifieing faith ever around. I am not saying that because i have a crusade because i may be some low form, i too come from these high title names attached to warriors and royalty. But it is they that are what cause us problems in our sikhi. Just look at your mind horoscope and analyse if with that thinking we will ever devlop.
Remmber the word haumai and how it can kill your credits and how it can creep on you and drag you down.
Sikhi is far beyond anything, it taps into a vaste ocean where everything is fulfilled. This plane is multidimensional, the current of naam lifts your soul higher your genetics background are meaningless, anything physical upon this realm is only driven by spirit.
Re: Caste or Class?
. · 12 Jul 2006
canadian jatt say
"You got to be kidding me? All major Jatt clans converted to Sikhi during Sikh guru’s time. For an example, Grewal Jatts converted to Sikhi during Guru Hargobind Ji’s time. Another example is Brar Jatts."
then how comes theres 80 million pakistani muslim jatts and only 16 million sikh jatts and a number of hindus who claim to be jatt? meaning all major jatt clans did not convert to sikhism. There are probably more muslim sandhus, ghumans bajweh cheemas than sikhs.
Some grewals became sikhs the ones that stayed hindus are found in hariana and delhi.
your emotions seem strong why do you feel hated for being jatt? What is wrong with logically questioning? that shows your argument is weak and you very quickly resort to the hating game when your stuck.
these x y chromosomes study does not really mean much. Punjab was a border area where turks moghuls arabs afghans came in large numbers at a time when islam was run by the sword. How comes hindu dhillons, grewals, and others do not have these "germanic or nearlike pakistani features"?
And how comes other sikh castes or tribes whatever you may call them have similar features to what you claim from the study?
jatts bexcame something when they followed sikhi. It is sikhism that enabled the jatt to become a soorma maha jodha. This spirit has now departed from punjab as sikhs loose their sikh heritage. ironically this is also a time in punjab where jatt culture is somehwta promoted, and yet there is no group nobody no entity to stand up for the sikh khalsa panth.
We can no longer even challenge these cults, fake sadhus, and rss until we have bakshish from the path that has been laid before us.
By following tribalism, castes you are defieing Akhal Takhats divine hukam ( the Throne of God on earth), srimoni parbandak rehat, gurbani which roars against all forms of divisions men make, and the khalsa set up laid by Guru Gobind Singh built on the foundation of panj piare who came from 5 diverse backgrounds from 5 different lands.
defieing sikhi at its root structure is not a good thing. When one takes amrit they are no longer a jatt sikh a tirkan sikh or a rajput sikh . They are a sikh of the guru with path that stretches skywards back to their original home.
This explains why those like you are becoming more distant from sikhi, what you followed was back in the day. Singh the day has changed! we are subject to Kaal we and our traditions are not akaal. Sikhi will outlive kal yug and its temporary spaces times and situations until every man is equal in every way. This is not orwells perfect world, but sikhi is built and will ensure one day every human will become one.
rajputs came in glory and went. jatts came into sikhi and the glory stood when sikhi was followed. Common brother let us not loose what we are what makes us stand against an army of 125000, let us stay strong with each other, and never forget where we came from as spirit souls and where we must finally go. let nothing break our mission for khalsa raj.
there is no such thing as a caste or tribal sikh, please do not distort the sacred definition of a sikh. A sikh is a learner on the path of spirituality. In the world of spirituality where avenues opens there is no division between beings. Therefore jatt sikh is contradiction ramgharia sikh is a contradiction rajput sikh is a contradiction. To become a sikh as per guru granth sahib is not an easy task. Its easy to call oneself a sikh.
Re: Caste or Class?
? · 12 Jul 2006
i have a question for any knowledgable sikh like bhai kulbir singh, bhai jarnail singh ji. Is it ok to attach ourselvs to racial definitions as sikhs? or should that be done away as we do with castes?
Re: Caste or Class?
Canadian (Non-Sikh by Choice) · 12 Jul 2006
Canadian Jatt???? My username is Canadian (Non-Sikh by choice)
<<>>
LOL what are you talking about? 80 Million Muslim Jatts? LMAO!
There’s hardly any Muslim Jatts in Pakistan. Last time I checked the figures, Muslim Jatts made up 1/3 of the Jatt population.
<<>>
Grewal = Jatt Punjabis
Garewal = Hindu Jats.
All Grewal jatts converted to Sikhi. That’s a fact.
<<>>
Buddy, I have been posting quotes from people like Guru Gobind Singh Ji to back up my claims. None of y’all haven’t backup any your claims. You people are simply talking a lot of crap.
<<>>
Wow! Jatts are Indo-Scythian according to Sir Alexander Cunnigham. Just read “History of Sikhs” by Sir Alexander Cunnigham if you don’t believe me.
Anyway, have you seen or met a Hindu Jat before? Mallika Sherawat is a Hindu Jat.
But you got to remember that interracial (not sure this is the right term) have occurred in the Jatt community before. I doubt you will find a Hindu Jat that would rather marry a Sikh Jatt (or Muslim Jatt) than non-Jatt Hindu. Also remember that Indian states like Haryana & Himachal Pradesh were always part of Punjab before the Indian government break up Punjab.
<<>>
Not really. Jatts have a long history. Maybe doing a little research on Jatt History wouldn’t hurt you at all.
<<>>
Who should get the blame for all this mess? Let me guess, Jatts, right? LMAO! Funny part about this is that it’s usually non-Jatt Sikhs that are doing negative stuff in the Sikh community. In fact, you can find a lot of non-Jatt gurdwaras in the world while there’s barely any Jatt gurdwaras....and a lot of non-Jatt Sikhs in India follow and worship Hindu gods unlike Jatt Sikhs who just stick with Sikhi. But yet, you people will ALWAYS put the blame on Jatts for no real reason while you people wouldn’t blame non-Jatt Sikhs for anything they do.
<<< By following tribalism, castes you are defieing Akhal Takhats divine hukam ( the Throne of God on earth), srimoni parbandak rehat, gurbani which roars against all forms of divisions men make, and the khalsa set up laid by Guru Gobind Singh built on the foundation of panj piare who came from 5 diverse backgrounds from 5 different lands.
defieing sikhi at its root structure is not a good thing. When one takes amrit they are no longer a jatt sikh a tirkan sikh or a rajput sikh . They are a sikh of the guru with path that stretches skywards back to their original home.>>>
Buddy, by using your logic, then this means that there is no such thing as a Punjabi Sikh or Canadian Sikh. And I personally don’t care about those corrupt Sikh political parties (like Akal Takht) that are controlled by the Indian government. They don’t have authority over me! They mean nothing to me! So I don’t care what these Sikh parties think and say about this issue and people like me.
<<< Common brother let us not loose what we are what makes us stand against an army of 125000, let us stay strong with each other, and never forget where we came from as spirit souls and where we must finally go. let nothing break our mission for khalsa raj.>>>
I understand what you are saying here, but according to people on this website, Sikh = Amritdhari. If you are not an Amritdhari, then you are NOT a Sikh. Since I am not an Amritdhari, I don’t qualify as a Sikh. So all this stuff you are mentioning about means nothing to me because I am NOT a Sikh.
<<< there is no such thing as a caste or tribal sikh, please do not distort the sacred definition of a sikh. A sikh is a learner on the path of spirituality. In the world of spirituality where avenues opens there is no division between beings. Therefore jatt sikh is contradiction ramgharia sikh is a contradiction rajput sikh is a contradiction. To become a sikh as per guru granth sahib is not an easy task. Its easy to call oneself a sikh.>>>
If there is no such thing as a tribal Sikh, then how come this class/caste issue is a problem to you people? How come this is a big issue for the Sikh community if there is no such thing as a tribal Sikh? Like I said before, I am NOT a Sikh nor do I classify myself as a Sikh. I never call myself a Sikh.
[%sig%]
Re: Caste or Class?
pagh banlah · 14 Jul 2006
canada non sikh say
"
If there is no such thing as a tribal Sikh, then how come this class/caste issue is a problem to you people? How come this is a big issue for the Sikh community if there is no such thing as a tribal Sikh? Like I said before, I am NOT a Sikh nor do I classify myself as a Sikh. I never call myself a Sikh."
the people with a problem are those who believe in caste not those who are trying to get rid of this evil shyte. And it will go, there will be no jatt v the rest. It will be jatts lohars sainis lubaney in advanced countries in the next generations ahead who will move ahead away from this stupid illogical system that is forced onto us. I say this as a jatt sikh myself i am sick of castes we are not living in the 12th century here. To most of us we see and accept a person as they are and that includes yourself as a non sikh while we are sikh.
a person with some knolwedge and experience is not stupid to fall into a caste trap. The internet can be a great tool to educate sikh masses and we arenow educated enough to see past divides.
Re: Caste or Class?
proud of da punjab as u r · 16 Jul 2006
non sikh says
"Who should get the blame for all this mess? Let me guess, Jatts, right? LMAO! Funny part about this is that it’s usually non-Jatt Sikhs that are doing negative stuff in the Sikh community. In fact, you can find a lot of non-Jatt gurdwaras in the world while there’s barely any Jatt gurdwaras....and a lot of non-Jatt Sikhs in India follow and worship Hindu gods unlike Jatt Sikhs who just stick with Sikhi. But yet, you people will ALWAYS put the blame on Jatts for no real reason while you people wouldn’t blame non-Jatt Sikhs for anything they do. "
you have taken the post in complete paranioa, the original post illustrates that until sikhs unite we cannot fight cults. We are divided into amritdharis, non amritdharis, castes, jatts tirkans rajputs sainis cheembeh dish washers and so forth, then we are divided into singhs cut haired, then into sub amritdhari groups. Now there is so much confusion false cults spring up, and sikhs fall victim for sadhu sants. I am from the same background as yourself, what nbeed do i have to bash jatts? half of my own relatives are now taken in by sadhus sants and radaswamis. therefore by your own logic if your looking out for your own punjabi prahvah, your own community, you have to address we have a problem we have issues that need discussing. Look at this way, a lot of radaswamis in uk are actually apney lok now, whether we like it or not, i do not need to tell you who gurinder dhillon is or who his private army is.
This is why bhai ajit singhs vichara are good on this topic. the whole point is for guys like yourself, for sikh youth and any panthic wellwishers come to programmes sit down with sangat, and experience rapid spiritual progress where you develop love for sikhi, where other sikhs sit down on the same platform, do bhangti together. You have the chance to talk to interact with gurmukhs, with other seekers on various levels. Amrit is vital, but it is not a status or a stop point. beyond amrit is a long journey, and before that is a journery. You may wish to be at the start of the journey but why deny happiness to your soul? you may love it so much you may wish to experience it everyday and if you wish to go further it is your hearts wish. Please do not use this website as an excuse to not resreach sikhi. Just like you would like us to resreach jatt history then be open minded to practical sikhi too. let your soul and heart experience gurbani, naam and with single focus gain diamonds and keep them hidden inside you brother.
bhai sahib does excellent vichar that we must first unite get rid of tribalism casteism and irkha from our hearts, do more bhagti and then unite to take on the cults.
wish you well and please do not take anything to heart, we are one we come from one place and from the same place we will go. Punjab will one day blossom, and we have to do our bit for ourself first before we can help our home flourish.
Re: Caste or Class?
no caste dude · 16 Jul 2006
canadian non sikh says
""You got to be kidding me? All major Jatt clans converted to Sikhi during Sikh guru’s time."
below is a table that tells us a large number of jatt clans well outside punjab This only concentrated on some rajhistani haraiana and up branches missing out pakistan. I strongly doubt each of these clans are sikh with the exception of some in hariana. If they were sikh there would be a clear numerical sikh strentgh in rajistan and hariana in numbers. Clearly sikhs number a small minority.
Aulakh or Olak or Olakh is a gotra of Jats found in Rajasthan, Punjab, Haryana and Uttar PradeshSikar district
basdi, chaindas ki dhani, dinarpura, katlathal, kudli, netarwas, olakh ki dhani, olakh ki dhani sangalia, piprali, rulyani, sawaipura sihot chhoti, sikar
Bhati is clan name found in Rajputs, Jats and Muslims in India. when the influence of Buddhism came down and Hindu religion was spreading, Bhatis got divided into two categories namely 1. Rajput Bhati and 2. Jat Bhati. Third category came into existence, Muslim Bhati, under the influence of Islam.
Batar is gotra of Jats found in Distt Sikar and Jodhpur in Rajasthan. Bataranau is village of Batars in Sikar district,Rajasthan.
[edit]
Villages inhabited by this Gotra in sikar district
bataranau, sikar, shivsinghpura
Cheema is a clan found in Jats of India and Pakistan.People belonging to this gotra are found in large numbers as Hindus and Sikhs in the Punjab and as Muslim in Pakistan. They are found in Gwalior in Madhya Pradesh also
Deol is gotra of Jats found in Punjab, Distt Saharanpur in UP and Ambala in Haryana.
Dhariwal is gotra of Jats found in Distt Gurgaon, Jhajjar, and Mahendergarh in Haryana. Dhariwal or Dharan gotra is found in Jats and Brahmans also in India. One branch of the Mudgals was called Dharan. At present there are Dharan Jats as well as Brahmins. Later on, These people were known as Dhariwals. The daughter of Chandra Gupta II who was married to King Rudra Sen has given her gotra as Dharan.
Sardar Jai Singh Dhariwal was included in twelve misls of the Sikhs.
Delhi, the capital of India was founded by Dhillon gotra jats.
Dhillon / Dehlan / Dhall have same origin and are considered brothers and sisters. Dhillons are mainly found among Jatt Sikhs but Hindu jats also exist in Hissar & Kurukshetra districts. Muslim Dhillon jats also exist in West Punjab (now Pakistan).
Garewal or Gre-wal or Gaharwal is a gotra of Jats and Rajputs found in Punjab and Rajasthan in India. This gotra is from the Chandela dynasty. Some writers have associated them with the Rathores, but other historians have proved that Rathore gotra is from Gaherwal gotra, and is also called Grewal.
Sikhs of this gotra are called Grewals. They have 52 villages in district Ludhiana. In Dholpur they are called Ghurwal
The people of Sipra Sub-Clan of Gill clan had mostly migrated towards Jhang. Most of them converted to Islam. Gills in Kabul are Moslems.
In Sandal Baar, Kakkar Gill was the only prominent village of Gills. The Gills settled in Jhang, Montegomery and Shahpur in the West Punjab had converted to Islam.
Shahi are also from the Clan of Gills. Some of Gills had settled in Assam in 1505 during the times of Guru Nanak. Many gypsies in France are Gills (also a very common French name,probably derived from the name Jill)
Gills were numbered at 124172 in the 1881 Census.
Khokhar or Khokar is a gotra of Jats found in Punjab, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh in India. Khokhar is a derivative of Kukar. The Khokhars are found in Rajputs also. They are found in the Punjab state. There are about 52 villages of the Khokhar Jats in Mathura and Aligarh districts.
Bhai Roop chand ji Was also Khokhar who was devout sikh of Guru Hargobind Ji.There is village on his name Bhai Roopa in Bathinda distt. Punjab, India. Haral, Ajra, Bhalu and Bhala are the sub gotras of the Khokhar Jats.
Khokhar is a term or tribe as equal to barbarian in europe.
Khokhars origin is from Central Asia. They were centeral Asian Huns who repeadly attack and influence north india.
They are same as for north india's empires as barbarians or huns were for roman empire.
They have very deep and myterious history and need to be researched. Khokhar Jats constructed fort at Kanwat village in Sikar district of Rajasthan. It was their capital.
In Pakistan Khokhars are followers of Islam. A former high commissioner of Pakistan in India was Riaz Khokhar.
[edit]
Villages in Sikar district
raipura, mordunga
Saran or Saharan is a gotra of jats in Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, Haryana and Madhya Pradesh in IndiaVillages in Sikar district
Hudera,Mirjwas,Ghirania Bada
[edit]
Villages in Churu district
Lalgarh
[edit]
Distribution in Madhya Pradesh
atarsama harda, bhopal, harda, intkheri raisen,
Birk gotra Jats are found in Sikar district of Rajasthan. Birk and Virk gotras seem to be of same origin. Only due to linguistic differences pronunciation is different.
[edit]
Villages inhabited by this gotra in Sikar district
hardayalpura, sikar, birk ki dhani, katlathal
Daara or Dara gotra Jats are found in Sikar district of Rajasthan.
[edit]
Villages in Sikar district
garinda
Dadarwal gotra Jats are found in Sikar district of Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh.
[edit]
Villages in Sikar district
Badusar,
[edit]
Distribution of gotra in Madhya Pradesh
Haliakhedi sehore,
Dehru is gotra of Jats found in Distt Nagaur and Jhunjhunu in Rajasthan.
Garewal or Gre-wal or Gaharwal is a gotra of Jats and Rajputs found in Punjab and Rajasthan in India. This gotra is from the Chandela dynasty. Some writers have associated them with the Rathores, but other historians have proved that Rathore gotra is from Gaherwal gotra, and is also called Grewal.
Sikhs of this gotra are called Grewals. They have 52 villages in district Ludhiana. In Dholpur they are called Ghurwal
Kaler gotra Jats are found in Sikar district of Rajasthan.
[edit]
Villages in Sikar district
alakhpura godaran, kaler ki dhani, laxmangarh, nethwa, sikar
Kalhar/Kalher/Kaler is gotra of Jats found in: Distt Meerut in UP and in Rajasthan. Kalher gotra found in haryana also in village Balkara Tehsil Charkhi Dadri District Bhiwani Haryana.
Kulhar gotra Jats are found in Sikar district of Rajasthan.
[edit]
Villages in Sikar district
madhopur, kudli
Mali gotra Jats are found in Sikar district of Rajasthan and in Madhya Pradesh.
[edit]
Villages in Sikar district
fakirpura, ringas, rulyanamali, sangalia, sewad badi, sikar
[edit]
Distribution in Madhya Pradesh
chapdagrahan seonimalwa
Bohra gotra Jats are found in Madhya Pradesh.
[edit]
Distribution of gotra in Madhya Pradesh
intkheri raisen
Additional info provided by Dr AK Boora: The kheda (origin) of Boora gotra is village Kharkri Distt Hisar, from where it spread (directly and indirectly) to districts Jind, Kaithal, Kurukshetra, Rohtak (Meham tehsil), Sonepat, and Bhiwani in Haryana. In UP and some part of Haryana the gotra Boora known as Sirohi/Saroya/Siroha.
Chahal gotra Jats are found in Madhya Pradesh.
[edit]
Distribution of gotra in Madhya Pradesh
Bhopal
Chattha is gotra of Jats found in Distt Ghaziabad in UP.
Kadiyan gotra Jats are found in Madhya Pradesh.
[edit]
Distribution in Madhya Pradesh
Bhopal
Kandhol/Kandhola is gotra of Jats found in Distt Karnal in Haryana
Malik are Jats mostly found in Distt. Muzaffarnagar in Western U.P., In Muzaffarnagar Area there are 52 villages of MALIK's Gotra. This area is well known as GATHWALA-KHAP. They are found in Haryana. Malik gotra Jats are also found in Madhya Pradesh.
Pannu Jat gotra is found in Gwalior region of Madhya Pradesh
Rana is a gotra of Jats in Delhi, Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh in India. This gotra used as surname is based on title Rana. Rana is the ruling clan of Jat rulers of Gohad in Madhya Pradesh and Dholpur in Rajasthan. They were originally Bamraulias from Bamrauli village near Agra.
In District Bagpat in UP, there are four huge villages, famous as Chaugama, where Jat of Gotra Rana, live.
1. Bhadal
2. Daha
3. Nirpuda
4. Gaid Bara
"Rana" is also used as a surname by Jatrana and Chaudaranasaroha
[edit]
Distribution in Madhya Pradesh
Bhind, Birlanagar Gwalior Gohad, Gwalior, Lashkar, Murar, Shivpuri
[edit]
Reference
• Thakur Deshraj: Jat Itihas (Hindi), Maharaja Suraj Mal Smarak Shiksha Sansthan, Delhi, 1934.
The randhawa
The Saran gotra is a branch of Bhatti gotra and the Saran Jats are associated with the royal dynasty of Jaisalmer. Their capital was in Bikaner State, which was later occupied by the Rathors. The Sarans live in this area even today.
In the history of Saran gotra there have been two famous men named Kajal Singh and his son Randhir Singh. Kajal Singh is the forefather of the Kajla gotra of the Jats who mostly live in Bikaner and Haryana.
Randhir Singh founded the village of Jhandiala in 1580 in the Punjab and his descendants are called Randhawa.
Sumal is gotra of Jats found in Distt Amroha in UP.
Toor gotra Jats are found in Madhya Pradesh.
there are 95,000 jats in himachal,mainly hindu jats.they are 1%(approx) tothe total population of the states.recently jats in himachal got OBC status with the efforts of Mr. Harnam Singh Gill,State president of JAT KALYAN PARISHAD.you can also contact him at 01892-232283 for more information.Mostly jats are in army or migrated to others states for work.jats are no poltical back like mla/minister in himachal cabinet.jats in himachal are economical poors than jats in punjab/haryana/delhi.
generly himachali jats are same gotra/caste like in punjab & haryana
few of them are-gill , randhawa , sandhu ,sidhu,sahota , badal chawala ,bhakal ,
kahalon , nanda , bains , rilach ,bagga etc...
Distt.-una has 20,000 jats(approx)
distt- kangra has 10-12000 jats
i got this information from himachal jat kalyan parished.it may be differ.if u want more information u can contact Mr. Gill/association at 01892-232283
bholi- pharhi
Re: Caste or Class?
Canadian (Non-Sikh by Choice) · 16 Jul 2006
"proud of da punjab as u r",
Interesting....all the Jatts you have mention (I just skim through your post) are from the UK....Interesting that's all I have to say about them. But they're not bigger threat to some non-Jatt who goes around and buliding caste based gurdwaras.....
Re: Caste or Class?
Canadian (Non-Sikh by Choice) · 16 Jul 2006
“no caste dude”,
<<>>
Umm actually, Haraiana are Punjabis before the Indian government divided Punjab state. Anyway, “no caste dude”, you didn’t even state any numbers on Jatt clans (expect for end of your post well give some numbers). But you got to remember that Punjab was a big state back in the days. Indian states like Haryana were part of Punjab back in the days.
By the way, I said, "Interesting that's all I have to say about them. But they're not bigger threat to some non-Jatt who goes around and buliding caste based gurdwaras....." in my last post.
I meant to say was, "Interesting that's all I have to say about them. But they're not biggest threat to Sikhi compare to some non-Jatt who goes around and buliding caste based gurdwaras....."
Re: Caste or Class?
jasvir singh · 24 Jul 2006
we have many threats to sikhi grewal sahib. If the youth keep their kes, work towards amrit and read gurbani and naam with their heart they have no worries.
do you have any reason to not be a sikh?
i am a jatt like yourself we have programmes everywhere, the sangat of sikhs mostly jatts attend smaagam annually and one of our venues is ramgharia gurdwara slough and another singh sabha. This jatha is very successful in atracting the youth towards sikhi matt. Instead of a threat both the gurdwaras and the jatha transcend caste differences through gurmat rehat in the tone of nam and gurbani shabad kirtan. singhs and singhnia in bana. no caste on anyons forehead.
ignorance lies in alienation.