Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

WHo killed Hindus 1984

WHo killed Hindus 1984

LionKing · 11 Oct 2005

Some Say that , black cats, som say, kale kachevale, Red Bridgade, Panthic Tiger Force etc etc - dressed up as Sikhs and killed Hindus on streets, high-jacked buses to give SIkhs a Bad name - But who was is in reality- and what proof is there? I'm writing an Essay about 1984, so I need some info about who it was that killed/abused Hindus.. Please response and let me know... Please provide reference, proof such as Books like A.R Darshi, Cynthia Mahmood etc, (Reliable sources like independant Journalists etc) Thanks =) Really appreciate it...

Re: WHo killed Hindus 1984

A Singh · 11 Oct 2005

I recommend looking at Chand Joshi's accounts for the happenings in 1984 - he equally grills the Right-wing Hindu parties and government and also the Sikhs who played a role in the ensuing human rights abuses. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: WHo killed Hindus 1984

LionKing · 12 Oct 2005

A Singh, had a quick run on Amazon after Chand Joshi, is this the book you're talking about? - http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0706926943/qid=1129109981/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/104-9391479-8462318?v=glance&s=books Availability: Out of Print--Limited Availability :( Do you knwo fo any retailers of the book? Even fi you find any in panjab, let me know as I might be going there soon. Also... I've seen quite a lot of anti- Baba Jarnail Singh ji sites quoting him, but they've also quoted Cynthia Mahmoods book (probably out of context) - but which Sikhs and parties does he blame for it? thanks a lot =) Stay in Chardikala Please keep posting Sangat jeeeee! Vaheguru Ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: WHo killed Hindus 1984

ekta · 12 Oct 2005

of one reeds Bibi Mahmoods book, u will see that she is PRO- SANT JI. if not pro very neutral on the subject, but not once does she bash sant ji

Re: WHo killed Hindus 1984

RoopKaur · 12 Oct 2005

You can also try reading Joyce Pettigrew's work. Although she does not speak postitively about the Akhand Keertani Jatha, but generally, her writing is similar to Cynthia Mahmood's.

Re: WHo killed Hindus 1984

Babbar Jujharoo · 12 Oct 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Jocye Pettigrews books is garbage. She gets most of her information from intervies with Wassan Zaffarwal who was head of a Khalistan Commandos Force faction. In the book Zaffarwal practically calls every Jathedar of Jujharoo Jathebandis gadhars(traitors). He makes up so much garbage about them, how they were killing other jujharoos and how they were actually working with the Indian government. Singhs suspected Zaffarwal of being an agent and couple of years back he has proven this suspicion by the Singhs to be true. He went back to India after so many years and nothing happened to him all the cases against him were dropped. Also the way he entered India is suspicous as he came through the airport and no red alerts were sounded by the Indian intelligence agencies when a so called jathedar of a jujharoo jathebandi was entering India. Now he walks around freely. Everything that Zaffarwal was saying about the Singhs seems to be all the stuff that he did himself. Zaffarwal is a gaddar and gave a bunch of false trashy information to Pettigrew which she wrote in her book as she thought he was a genuine jujharoo. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: WHo killed Hindus 1984

LionKing · 13 Oct 2005

I've order Bibi Mahmood's book but does that book cover this subject, about who was the one killing the innocent people?

Re: WHo killed Hindus 1984

Sikhi · 13 Oct 2005

AR Darshi tried to explain who killed the Hindus in '84. This book is called The Gallant Defender. He is blaying the goverment for the killings.

Re: WHo killed Hindus 1984

Singh · 13 Oct 2005

Its hard to get any reliable sources due to the simple fact that the Indian Goverment did not allow any independant inquiries into the killings, although this was requested by Longowal on many occasions. Even people like Cynthia Mahmood who themselves tried to research what happened were attacked by Indian Goverment goons and threated to stop her work. She told me and others this when we met her a few years ago. The fact is that the Indian Goverment had everything to gain from the killings (propoghanda value), did not allow any inquiries, used its media to blame Sikh's across the World and has a history of using such dirty tricks. Whilst the Sikhs had absolutly nothing to really gain from it, think for yourself.

Re: WHo killed Hindus 1984

Ravinder Singh · 14 Oct 2005

Gurfateh Joyce Pettigrews book is definately garbage I thought it would be a truthful account of the jujaroos of panjab, like Mamoods, but it reeked of a negative attitude. The Scottish bibi makes herself out to be an expert on panjab terrorism but all she does is cuss Babbar khalsa, G S Manochahal and most jathebandia (except for KCF). She talks about many jujaroos being traitors, but Zaffarwal(KCF).. her source, is probably behind all this. Don't waste your money and your time on this book. Its nothing but a disappointment.

Re: WHo killed Hindus 1984

A Singh · 14 Oct 2005

Lion King, There is of course no black and white answer for this, naturally many of the 'encounters' were staged, but to argue that this accounts for all the events would be simply naive. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: WHo killed Hindus 1984

LionKing · 14 Oct 2005

Author: Sikhi Date: 10-13-05 07:18 AR Darshi tried to explain who killed the Hindus in '84. This book is called The Gallant Defender. He is blaying the goverment for the killings. _______________________ I'm reading hsi book, but where woudl this be though? could you please look up the page, as I've read it but probably missed it.. ******* Ravinder Singh, I thought so too, bt after havin read the reviews, i found out it wasn't way to reliable.. ********* "Singh" Ji, I myself understand this, but to convince other people from my assignment, it is important I have sources, and that is why I'm asking. Assuming Bibi Cynthia Mahmood has written about it, I shall surely have a look at it thanks a lot Sangat jee and let me know if you canr ecomend any more books =)