Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

Curious · 11 Oct 2005

Does anyone know if Prime Minister Manmohan Singh is amritdhari? I really hope that he is as guidance from the Guruji would be the best thing for India. The simple fact that a sikh is prime minister speaks to the power of panth. WJKK WJKF [%sig%]

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

asdfasd · 11 Oct 2005

Prime Minister Manmohan Chand is not amritdhari nor does he have any sympathy for the Sikh panth.

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

harminder singh khalistan · 12 Oct 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh there is no way that manmohan singh is amritdhardi,as you can tell he really doesnt even have a beard.its trimmed the closest it can be it,which makes him look like a skeleton,likes half dead or something.also there is many pictures out there where manmohan is matha teykan to the fake hindu holy men,which no true singh would ever do,and also look at which party he belongs to,the congress party,which no self respecting khalsa would ever join.so there is no way that he is amritdhardi,maybe if he was then he could be summoned to akal takht,to beg for forgiveness for what his party has done to sikhs,and he could be labeled apostate,because this guy has no sikhi in him. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

jss · 12 Oct 2005

his beard isn't trimmed....it's called tied tightly....

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

LionKing · 12 Oct 2005

Agreed with JSS. Stop making Assumptions - I know several people who have tied their beard tightly, and it looks exactly like that - it is clearly not trimmed . Let's stop doing Nindya i.e not talking truth about them..

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

harminder singh khalistan · 12 Oct 2005

dear jss have u seen manmohan singh,cuz u must be thinkin off someone else,because president of india manmohan singh has a trimmred beard believe me.

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

SinghJi · 12 Oct 2005

I agree, there's no way Manmohan Singh is amritdhari. If he had half a brain he would realize that the only way to truly be a Sikh is to not help the Hindu majority oppress Sikhs. It's amazing that a whole country can exist just to oppress Sikhs--I mean come on get a life. Anyway, Manmohan Singh is worse that a Hindu. Please, Manmohan Singh a Sikh? More likely that Indira Gandhi is an Indian.

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

ekta · 12 Oct 2005

manmohan chand i like that has ntn 2 do with the panth.

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

harminder singh khalistan · 12 Oct 2005

can someone please post some pictures of manmohan singh,cuz i guess some people dont know what manmohan singh looks like,since they think he has an untrimmed dhardi,and they think its just tied,which it is not,i dont know how people think hes amritdhardi,or maybe their just government if india informers.

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

KHALSA SINGH · 12 Oct 2005

hey i agree,manmohan singh is no singh,he is not amritdhari

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

Curious · 12 Oct 2005

Thank you for your replies. This is disturbing as i thought he was amritdhari...Anybody who believes that he is not helping the panth, are there any examples out there of this oppression? This would be very helpful as i am trying to convince my friends and family that he is not as great as they say he is.... WJKK WJKF

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

dsingh · 12 Oct 2005

well for one thing,he is called a sikh,but what sort of sikh,would join the congress party,its like a jew joining the nazi's,manmohan singh is the president for people who tried to kill us,he's another zail singh,a puppet for the congress party.if you were a sikh president would you not apoligize to your sikh panth,for your party going in and destroying the akal takht sahib,like they brought in 9 battle tanks to blow up the whole darbar sahib complex.they want us dead.maybe the congress party thought that if they give manmohan singh the presidency of india that the people would assasinate him and get it out of they way,so that the congress party doenst have to get its hands dirty.like if you were a true sikh,why wouldnt you bring the criminals in the govenment of india to justice for all the massacre of sikhs in 1984.hes in the same party with the people who gave the call for the genocide of sikhs.to the person who started this post,you should no better than to start conterversial topics on this site,i think the admin.sahibs should shut down this topic,because its gonna get ugly,just think manmohan singh a amritdhari,its kinda funny

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

singhji · 12 Oct 2005

this converstation is retarded. if manmohan singh was a sikh why isn't he amritdhari. we all know that sikhs must take amrit and obey rehit drale in order to become ghaksikhi. the truth of the matter is only sikhilrahin jamis are true Sikhs. But even if pans japi were true Sikhs then why would Manmohan Singh run away like he's a chumchar dhami?

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

singhji · 13 Oct 2005

dude, come on now. we also no charkan sahib must be taken before amritvalle in order to be even considered gursikhi. if we did not have to become raanjalle then what would be the point of even being sikhlival? I swear some people don't even understand Sikhi!

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

faulty · 13 Oct 2005

So what? Captain Amarinder Singh is also a member of the Congress but look at the voice he is giving Punjab. In another thread, Kulbir Singh ji and others have given him praise for his actions yet he belongs to the Congress party. So the fault is not the Congress party. Think now - do you really believe the Akali Dal has been a great supporter of Sikhi and Sikhs? Do you think the cowardly Badals of Punjab haven't had anything to do with atrocities in Punjab? PM Manmohan is the first Sikh (sahajdhari albeit) to become PM of India. Yes, he was not elected but I think the positive image of a Sikh as the leader of a nation is huge on the international stage. Not to mention the guy is a brilliant economist and acknowledged as such. No one is saying he is a pooran Gursikh and he doesn't make that claim either. Is he a puppet? Is he his own man? I don't know. I do know that as Prime Minister of India, in his role as PM and not on his own time, he apologized for what happened to the Sikhs. Even if it was lip-service (which I don't think it was - Manmohan Singh is more an economist than a savvy politician) it's more than any previous head of state has done. Is it enough? Not by a long shot. But don't knock the man solely for being a Sikh PM in the Congress. dsingh wrote: > well for one thing,he is called a sikh,but what sort of > sikh,would join the congress party,its like a jew joining the > nazi's,manmohan singh is the president for people who tried to > kill us,he's another zail singh,a puppet for the congress > [%sig%]

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

Curious · 13 Oct 2005

Faulty, Although you are right that we should not jump to conclusions and attack Manmohan Singh, the question is, is he doing anything to help the cause of Sikhism. What has he done (or is doing) for Sikhism? Just because he is a sikh doesnt mean he's promoting true Sikhi.

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

close · 13 Oct 2005

Thats just it. In his role as PM, it is ideal for him to maintain a secular stance, like all leaders of democratic nations should. He should not be pushing or promoting Sikhi in his role as PM. Imagine the Canadian PM advocating on behalf of the Anglican faith? Does the Canadian PM have a right to do this when, in his office as PM, he represents a secular nation? No, and the same holds true for Manmohan Singh. However, I believe his role as PM gives him a status to raise secular questions affecting Sikh issues? For example - property rights pertaining to water in Punjab. Reparation for the widows and children of 1984 victims, etc. Curious wrote: > Faulty, > Although you are right that we should not jump to conclusions > and attack Manmohan Singh, the question is, is he doing > anything to help the cause of Sikhism. What has he done (or is > doing) for Sikhism? Just because he is a sikh doesnt mean he's > promoting true Sikhi.

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

ddasd · 14 Oct 2005

Curious, You really are thick aren't you. Manmohan Singh is the prime minister of India - which consists of Hindus, Sikhs, Muslims, Christians, Buddhists, Jains, Parsis and Jews. He has to maintain a secular stance and not favour a particular creed. I know it is difficult for Sikhs to comprehend this, but this is how it is [%sig%]

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

EkSingh · 14 Oct 2005

also the fact that sikhs only form 2% of india's population yeh - maybe he doesnt want to rush things yet - but may take it slowly in the future - jus give him more time - its not like we can do anything else like chuck him out and bring a Gursikh on the stage lol

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

Harpreet singh · 14 Oct 2005

Manmohan Singh is not out to 'opress' sikhs with the hindu majority bla bla bla. He is a politician who ties a distaar and has become PM, take it for whats worth. He is Prime Minister of India not Punjab. And also the congress party has become secular over the last years, ( no excuse for what they did before) But yea some people have such high expectations, if their was a sikh amritidar prime minister of India we would have khalistan. Just aint gona happen so take it for what its worth.

Re: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

Curious · 14 Oct 2005

Thank you for your replies. I now have a fairly balanced I feel of the Prime Minister. Here is what i have taken from these posts: Although Manmohan Singh does not promote true Sikhi, it is not possible for him to do so as he must look to the best interests of India. However, he does not seem to emphasize that he is a sikh and attempt to raise sikhs to an even higher level. He may not need drastic measures, but it seems like he does not even try....Is that a fair assesment?.... I guess in my heart of hearts, I just wish Sikhism could become a such a prominent religion in India and also cause Sikhism to grow around the world. Forgive me for this idealism WJKK WJKF