Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Kirpan - Can a Kara be one?

Kirpan - Can a Kara be one?

LionKing · 14 Oct 2005

If I'm not mistaken Kirpan is a Shastar worn for protection for yourself and others... soo my question is does it have to be a Pesh Kabz or a Kattar (above), just because traditionally Singhs have been wearing one of the above Shastars and calling it a Kirpan (it is as it's for Kirpa, Rakhya) but My question is, can you keep i.e two karas, one normal one (out of Sarbloh) and one MASSIVE ONE (whcih too, is out of Sarbloh) and the massive one fufilling the funciton of a Kirpan (Rakhya) instead of having any of the above? Would the Panj of tapoban accept that if a Singh came with two KaRe, one extra massive, say tha I want to use this as a Shastar /Kirpan please don't attack me, as I do not know and that is why I'm askin´g thanks bhull chukk di Khima Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Kirpan - Can a Kara be one?

... · 14 Oct 2005

A kirpan is a kirpan. A kirpan is not a khanda and I don't think it' s a kataar. A Kirpan has a defined shape. It is not just any shastar. A kara can be a shastar as well, but it cannot be a kirpan.

Re: Kirpan - Can a Kara be one?

G Singh · 14 Oct 2005

no it cant, it cant even be a kattaar, it must be a kirpan

Re: Kirpan - Can a Kara be one?

seeker of the truth · 14 Oct 2005

Kirpan is one of the FIVE K's Kara is one of the FIVE K's Therefore a KARA and a KIRPAN are 2 seperate Kakkars! Yeh by all means carry a shastar kara and ur small what we call lol, tabla kara!! but keep your kirpan too. If you have to like a small 7inch one which can b used for CLOSE quarter but nothing excessive and keep your kara as a shastar.

Re: Kirpan - Can a Kara be one?

he is a lion among men · 14 Oct 2005

I disagree. A kirpan does not have a defined shape. That is why even amongst manufacted kirpans, you see ones which have thick spines, thin spines, aggressive curves, modest curves. Moreover, the kirpans worn by Sikhs today, the cheaper manufactured ones, the more expensive Taksali ones etc. are not the kirpans you find in puratan shastars. The closest thing to a defined shastar called kirpan is the tulwar, and it is my strong belief that when Guru ji said wear kirpan, he meant the full-sized Indian sabre, NOT a 6 inch knife. So.........given the above, today's "kirpans" are a mere representation (at best) of the kirpans meant to be worn. As such, wearing a curved blade of most any shape is sufficient to be considered a kirpan. I do not believe when Guru ji said kirpan, he said that in an abstract fashion. All of the other kakkars are concrete objects so the kirpan also is a concrete, defined object - in this case, a sword. ... wrote: > A kirpan is a kirpan. A kirpan is not a khanda and I don't > think it' s a kataar. A Kirpan has a defined shape. It is not > just any shastar. A kara can be a shastar as well, but it > cannot be a kirpan.

Re: Kirpan - Can a Kara be one?

LionKing · 14 Oct 2005

Had a look in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Kosh (Bhai Vir Singh Ji) and this is how it defines "Kirpan" - [Sanskrit, Kerpa] 'N' 'Ni' = Parapt karan to. Kirpa Vala. Kerpaloo. 'Yatha' - [gurbani]hir hoho ikrpwn[/gurbani] So he basically refers to the above mentioned Shabad - http://www.srigranth.org/servlet/gurbani.gurbani?Action=Page&Param=1297&punjabi=t&id=55455 [gurbani]hir ho ho ikrpwn ]1] rhwau ] [/gurbani] The Lord shall be Merciful to you. ||1||Pause|| har ho ho kirpaan. ||1|| rahaa-o. (interesting Side note - Bhai Vir Singh wrote "hoho" together, whilst the STTM has it as two separate words....) So "..." what is a "Kirpan" and where can it's defined shape be refered to? Which Rehitnama says it's gotta be like the modern ones? thanks

Re: Kirpan - Can a Kara be one?

LionKing · 14 Oct 2005

When I think about it, most Puaratan Rehitname mention "Karad" rather than "Kirpan" :S

Re: Kirpan - Can a Kara be one?

... · 14 Oct 2005

LionKing, Bhai Kahn Singh defines Kard as Kirpan. So a Kirpan is clearly not a kaRa. A singh is to always keep his kirpan with him. So how would he do that with a 3' sri sahib? I have seen the smaller kirpans of Guru Gobind Singh and Baba Deep Singh. I think even in puratan times there were smaller Sri Sahibs along with the big ones.

Re: Kirpan - Can a Kara be one?

LionKing · 14 Oct 2005

Could a Kirpan be any other Shaster, like Chakkar or somethnig.... or does it ABSOLUTLY AHVE TO BE like the modern Taksali Kirpan?

Re: Kirpan - Can a Kara be one?

... · 14 Oct 2005

a kirpan is a kirpan! A kard! It is not a chakar. It is not a teer and it is not a gun. I'm not sure where you're getting this idea from. It doesn't have to be like the taksali kirpan. It can be of a different shape and size but it is by defintion a sarbloh weapon that is like a "knife".

Re: Kirpan - Can a Kara be one?

LionKing · 15 Oct 2005

"..." where did you get this definition that is has to be like a "knife" and can't be a circle, or a terr, if it fulfills the function of a Kirpan I'm not getting any idea or something, I was just spectating, what limts a"kirpan" to be "knife-shaped", as if an extra KaRa can fulfill the funciton Kirpan, it would solve the airport problem, where you would have to take off your "knife-like" Kirpan (i.e Taksali or whatever type of Kirpan) and you could replace it by a massive KaRa, until you reach where you want to go, and technically if the extra KaRa can be a Kirpan - you havn't removed the 5th kakkar on the flight.... But yeah where does the defintion fo Kirpan say it has to be "knife-shaped"?

Re: Kirpan - Can a Kara be one?

t_singh · 15 Oct 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fathe i was thinking of getting a kirpan custom made here in Canada by an Italian knife maker, is this okay? .. Are their any specifics on how a Kirpan should look , or how it is made, or what kind of metal should be used?.. Im just curious .. im not intending to offend anyone. I have read many posts saying how the Puratan Singhs had alot of pride in the design of their Kirpans.Kirpans in Ajaib Ghar's in India are very elegently designed. I just want to know if it is aright to get a Kirpan made? waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fathe

Re: Kirpan - Can a Kara be one?

agyani · 15 Oct 2005

how the heck you suppose to do kirpa with a MASSIVE kaRa? When guru ji made the Panj he done kirpa with a kirpan! He didnt bash the 5P with a kaRa...think about it!

Re: Kirpan - Can a Kara be one?

close · 15 Oct 2005

There is no problem - go right ahead and have it made because if the bladesmith knows what he is doing, you will end up with a kirpan that is many, many times better quality than any of the top manufactured kirpans you see on the market ie. the taksali kirpan and others like it. What I would recommend: carbon steel blade (sarbloh). While it is true that stainless steel in knives doesn't pose the same structural weakness problems it does in longer lengths, carbon steel has a certain beauty of its own. Moreover, some would argue that even in shorter lengths, carbon steel is the more resilient material to use in a fighting blade. For artistic measure - consider using mechanical damascus for the blade. Since modern steels are much better quality than the steels of yesteryear, a monosteel (one type of steel) blade will be as strong as a damascus. However, a damascus blade with any number of different patterns is very beautiful to look upon. From a functional standpoint, its a good idea to have a crossguard (small, big - your choice) to prevent the hand from slipping forward on a thrust.