Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

morden times

morden times

kitan singh · 16 Oct 2005

why cannot sikhi change with the times. we dont need long hair. as it was protection from ax blow to head. we dont have to wear same under wear all the time. we dont need the sword as it want help with fast automatic gun.

Re: morden times

.. · 16 Oct 2005

Sikhi doesn't need to change with the times because it's perfect. How would long hair protect against an axe blow? I'm pretty sure if it's going to crack open your skull, an inch of hair isn't going to do much to slow it down. How are short hair better than long hair? Why do people cut hair? Why should someone cut their hair every couple of weeks and pay someone to do it each time? Long hair have been a feature of Sikhs since the time of Guru Nanak, when there were very few people trying to put axes into Sikh heads. The same underwear: actually, it's changed every day or ever time you bathe. A kacherra is in my eyes a better piece of clothing than any bandar-kachhee or shorts. It's comfortable and functional. Sword: there were guns around when Guru Sahib gave us the kirpan. He could have told us to keep any shastar, but picked the kirpan. Most armies in the world are still given a knife. Guru Sahib was perfect. He could see the past present and future. What he gave us will be perfect and unchanging for eternity.

Re: morden times

ekta · 16 Oct 2005

simple answer! DO U THINK KITAN SINGH, THAT YOU ARE AT THE LEVEL OF GURU SAHIB MAHARAAJ 2 QUESTION IS AUTHORITY, AND MAKE CHANGES?

Re: morden times

rajinder singh · 16 Oct 2005

Dear Kitan Singh ! Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh The answer to your question in few words is that " Poorey Gur ke poori deekheya ." (Blessings/teachings) & "Saach Purana Theevai Nahin." What ever Poorey (complete in all respects) Guru ji has said and done is also Complete and Perfect. You only fix or change things that have some blemish/mistakes and not something that is perfect. Hope this helps and you can also view more shabads about Poorey Guru ji from www.sikhitothemax.com Hope this helps. Rajinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: morden times

DDT · 19 Oct 2005

i think kirten singh is not a singh at all, but who am i too say. y change sikhi its perfect. ppl have said that if there was a cold war and we had to build society again sikhi would be the best route to follow. even athiests think sikhi is amazing. y would u want to cut ure hair. wats wrong with wearing a kashera. hair is a gift from God. kirpan signifies being able to help those in need and being able to fight tyranny. and a kirpan can be quicker then an automatic gun, i dont no if uve realised but most ppl wont even shoot with there guns, its used to scare and intimidate. further more i would suggest that u refrain from including singh in ure name because u are oviously not a singh. Bhulll Chuk mauf

Re: morden times

A Singh · 20 Oct 2005

Gur Fateh! Kirtan Singh, what exactly does "change with the times" mean? For a discussion similar to this concerning keeping kesh and "moving with the times" see the following link: http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=14122&hl= where someone had asked a similar question – clearly the ‘times have changed’ needs to be carefully considered. As per the rest of your items, such as the wearing of Kacheras and keeping the Kirpan, here are a couple of points for you to consider: In England, UK – where despite there being many Sikhs, plenty of non-Sikhs consider Singhs to be ‘backward’ people, keeping kesh and in the 21st century wearing breeches (a reference to kachera) and a sword or sabre (reference to the Kirpan). This is a view shared also by many people outside of the UK and even in India by non-Sikhs and some Sikhs (like yourself) as well. One ironic thing that always strikes me about these people is that they are also the very same people to come and visit Buckingham Palace, Kesington Palace and other Royal Estates to see the Regalia of the Queen. Interestingly, this invariably includes a fascination with the Queen’s Guards who also in the 21st century, in the modern city of London wear swords and large ‘pom-pom’ black hats and a peculiar uniform. Moreover, when the Queen knights anyone a Sir, to this day, she will use a sword for the purpose. When these latter events occur, none of these people make the same hoo-haa about modernity, instead they flock around their TV screens to view the spectacle or travel far and wide to come to London to see the Queen’s guard. Continuing with the above theme, clearly the use of breeches, swords, turbans (and Kesh) have long across all cultures been signifiers of Royalty and Nobility – some thing that we as Sikhs were granted not by some worldly figurehead but the true Monarch, Sache Patshah, Shen Shah e Shen Shen Shah Guru Gobind Singh, yet today we consider this blessing from the Fort of Permanent Bliss (Anandpur Sahib) to be BACKWARDS, yet find the pompous customs of the British Monarchy a fascination. Next time you are in London, visit Kesington Palace, its worth the tour inside to see the customs prevailing when a ‘presentation’ to the Queen was one of the highest honours within Britain – have a look at the dress codes, mannerism, protocol of both the men and the women and then ask yourself this question again. On another note, the Kachera, although today considered an underwear, as stated on the post concerning the Kirpan and Kachera, this is not actually the case, particularly when we look back at older times. The Kachera is in fact a complete dress in its own right and as key component of the treh mudra, one of the predominant signifiers of the Khalsa (alongside the Kesh and Kirpan) and its sovereignty. The argument against the Kirpan using the case of a gun is again futile, we do not carry the Kirpan simply as a weapon (although this is certainly a function which should not be overlooked, as increasingly it is today by those seeking to make it symbolic only) it also carries with it all the signifiers of soverignity and nobility. The point on firearms is irrelevant for two reasons, the sword is the emblem across the world for righteousness and courage (not the gun) and in any event, accounts such as Sri Guru Sobha also indicate that during war times, Singhs were instructed to carry alongside their Kirpan (which was mandatory as part of the Treh Mudra / Punj Kakkar) Punj Shastar, which invariably included a firearm within it (usually a musket). So in short, Sikhi has no need to alter its fundamentals (i.e. lifestyle, rehit of Punj Kakkars/Punj Banis) with time, these are universal in application – nonetheless, Sikhs in India and throughout the Diaspora have demonstrated that they are in fact more than flexible in adapting to whatever environment they may be placed in, given the numerous examples we have of Keshdhari and Amritdhari Sikhs living successful lives in Business, Politics, Science, Humanitarian Work, Military Service, Construction and various other disciplines. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: morden times

JB · 20 Oct 2005

interesting questions. i think ppl need to stop being so defensive and actually consider the questions being asked, instead of feeling threatned by them. personally, i think a sikh could question things, coz when ppl dont question things, they end up getting sucked into cults etc, n following this baba or that baba. obviously hukam is hukam, but there is nothing wrong with asking questions to make sure ur on the right path, as long as you are still respectful... i got a few questions of my own: why do singhs wear jeans etc on top of their kacheray? if singhs are so adament on wearing kasheray, why not wear them how they are ment to be worn? also, singhs n singhnia that carry kirpan. do you know how to use it? some1 said a kirpan is faster than an automatic gun! lol. i dnt think so... ppl are saying sikhi shouldnt change with the times. fair enough. so where do u draw the line? some ppl say, eat out of iron dishes, plastic didnt exist then so dnt eat out of it, rah rah rah. so should we ditch cars n go around on horse back? hang on a second! what am i doing using a PC and the net. they never had PC's back then, why use them now?! pleaseeeeeee. (this will prob get deleted my admin just like alot of my other posts, so much for freedom of speech... )

Re: morden times

g · 20 Oct 2005

haha good one kitan singh good one... ill laugh for a long time over that pure retardedness, I supposed we should start drinking and going out to clubs and dancing and sleeping with random people also... thats the thing to do in these times keertan is so outdated lets go to clubs =P Im being sarcastic if you cant tell

Re: morden times

A Singh · 20 Oct 2005

JB Veer/Bhain, Gur Fateh! You asked: <> I quite agree, as this is the type of questioning that we will all face at some time and need to be secure and sensible enough to address them appropriately. <> I agree, Faith is paramount (for a Sikh in Vaheguru / Guru Sahib), however it has to be noted that questioning and discussion (veechar) is what gets you an education (and as you rightly point out keep the ‘cult’ factors at bay). <> The idea that the Kachera must not be covered with a pyjama (or as you mentioned jeans/trousers) is one advocated strongly today by the Nihangs and other groups who seek to emulate them. There is nothing wrong with this assertion, equally however there is nothing adverse to having a garment on top of one’s kachera – no rehit is breeched. <> This is something I’ll agree with, however how does this challenge the worth of a Kirpan? Surely, as I often say, it is best to get to the root of the matter – here, it would be far better to actually insist say during Amrit Sachar (similar to the account given in Pracheen Panth Parkash) that newly initiated Khalsa seek to ‘maintain the traditions of Shastar Vidiya in whatever way possible” – i.e. learn martial arts and practice them (whichever one is available to you, the point is that you have some proficiency in the use of the shaster and are not a walking liability to yourself and others around you). <> This is now a rather puerile argument – matters such as plastic, horseback, use of pc etc are not tantamount to reducing the maryada of Sikhs, which concerns the Punj Kakkar and Punj Bani rehit – Gurbani and Sikhi are not rigid time specific concept specific and limited rules, they are free of such restrictions and elevate our minds to ensure we practice Gurmat in whatever situation/circumstance we may find ourselves. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: morden times

Sehajvir Singh · 20 Oct 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh I would like to commend A singh on his very informative post. It was beautifuly articulated. I don't want to offend anyone but i think when we respond to these kinds of questions we have to be careful of what words we use. What i mean is this person can be two types. one is someone trying to stir up stuff and disrespect sikhi. Or he can be someone who generally has questions about sikhi that he really wants answers too. Sadh sangat ji we are not all blessed with sangat of gursikhs or an atmoshphere where sikhi can flourish within us. Most likely if this person is the second type he doesn't have the sangat that a lot of us have been blessed with. And for him to even bring this question up is something beautiful. Because it shows that he wants to learn. But how will he ever be inspired to delve into the pavitre naam amrit if we the people who are supposed to be the most humble treat him with hankaar and scorn. I mean it doesn't matter in my opinion what type of person he is, if he really has the willingness to learn or he's just a trouble maker. We are going to be judged by our actions. So please refrain from putting this person down and treating him like he is beneath you. He just might not understand the great concepts of sikhi. But for us to treat him like he is lower then us shows everyone we don't understand these concepts either. As for JB'S comments "some ppl say, eat out of iron dishes, plastic didnt exist then so dnt eat out of it, rah rah rah. so should we ditch cars n go around on horse back?" I believe that people keep sarbloh bibek not because their wasn't plastic back then but because there are spiritual and physical benefits to eating out of sarbloh. (please correct me if i'm wrong sangat ji). So to comment on your statement about horse back. Sikhi is not about discriminating (bibek) against technology it is about discriminating against elements that bring your spirituality down. LIKE 99% of T.V. shows out there. So you might think i'm a fundmentalist because I view T.V. as wrong, however you shouldn't look at what i view as wrong or right instead you should look at WHY i view these things wrong or right. And if you were to look at why people do bibek then i don't think you have an argument. However i am not bibeki. i do have respect for ppl who keep it because it comes from the inside however people must be careful not to fall into dikhava, and pandit style rituals of just doing bibek to apear spiritual.