Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Delhi Text Book Insults Guru Gobind Singh

Delhi Text Book Insults Guru Gobind Singh

... · 16 Oct 2005

Book banned 'for offending Sikhs' By Asit Jolly BBC News, Chandigarh A school textbook has been banned in the northern Indian state of Haryana for references offensive to Sikhs. Authorities banned the book after complaints of "derogatory" material about the 10th religious head of the Sikh community, Guru Gobind Singh. Chief Minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda said all available copies of the book had been seized. The book was issued to students at the Delhi Public School in the town of Hisar in western Haryana. 'Communal tension' The chief minister said he had directed the deputy commissioner of Hisar to conduct a thorough inquiry into how the text was permitted in a school book. The ban was imposed following a complaint from the president of Punjab's main Sikh political party, the Shiromani Akali Dal. Its leader, Prakash Singh Badal, said a chapter of the textbook bore derogatory and fictitious narratives, stating that Guru Gobind Singh killed a Pathan trader who sold him horses. It also, in one section, depicted the guru as an old man repenting his "sins". Mr Badal demanded "stern action against all persons responsible for publishing and prescribing the book as a school text". Describing the book as "highly objectionable and hurtful of religious sentiment", he warned it could provoke communal tension. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/4345478.stm

Re: Delhi Text Book Insults Guru Gobind Singh

Singh · 16 Oct 2005

its good action has been taken, but when will Bada repent his sins

Re: Delhi Text Book Insults Guru Gobind Singh

LSingh · 16 Oct 2005

It is good that the book has been banned, but justice must be done. I hope mr. badal will hold to his word and severely punish those involved

Re: Delhi Text Book Insults Guru Gobind Singh

S Singh · 17 Oct 2005

Badal will do nothing to punish those involved. He did nothing to punish those responsible for the 84 genocide when he was part of the BJP government despite claims he would bring justice for the victims.

Re: Delhi Text Book Insults Guru Gobind Singh

Tribune India · 17 Oct 2005

SSF alleges blasphemy by Hindi text book Tribune News Service Ludhiana, October 17 The Sikh Students' Federation (SSF) has demanded strict action against the publishers of the Basha Manjri, a Hindi textbook carrying blasphemous remarks about Guru Gobind Singh. Addressing a press conference here today, the SSF president, Mr Gurcharan Singh Grewal, and other leaders alleged that it was a deliberate conspiracy to fan communalism. Mr Grewal announced a statewide agitation programme. He said protest demonstrations would be staged at the district headquarters. He said although the book had been banned by the Haryana Government, but that was not enough. Strong action needed to be taken against the author and the publishers for carrying derogatory remarks about the Guru, he added. The SSF leader said there was widespread anger and resentment among the members of the Sikh community about such remarks. He hoped that action would be taken against the culprits.

Re: Delhi Text Book Insults Guru Gobind Singh

Baldeep Singh · 18 Oct 2005

Great News. Is there any previews available of the book containing the salnderous material

Re: Delhi Text Book Insults Guru Gobind Singh

LiongKing · 20 Oct 2005

A question that rises: Why isn't Badal doing anythign when his buddies (RSS) are publishing tons and tons of offensive material? Good action, but wouldn't be surprised if was for a selfish mean...