Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

really LOUD simran

really LOUD simran

duck · 19 Oct 2005

what does sangat think of this shabad? saahib sadhaa hadhoor hai kiaa ouchee karehi pukaar || Our Lord and Master is always present; why do you cry out to Him in such a loud voice? why do some people SCREAM really loudly whilst doing simran. please sangat i would like to know thankyou.no offense inteneded.

Re: really LOUD simran

Abhiyaas.Blogspot.Com · 19 Oct 2005

Daas limited understanding of ths Shabad is that Why do you shout out to Vahiguru as if he is far away - not realising that he is closer to you than your hand. Some Gursikhs 'scream' loudly whilst doing Simran because the Prem Ras (love) that they are feeling over comes them and it is very hard to control.

Re: really LOUD simran

A Singh · 19 Oct 2005

<> With due respect, Abhyas Ji, how does 'prem ras (love)' lead anyone to begin "shouting". Let's look at even worldly love, say with one's spouse, children, family, friends, teachers, pets etc - when overcome with feelings of "prem" for them, one would hardly 'shout' at them? The only time, again in worldly life, we witness people shouting 'out of love' (in their opinion) is perhaps when we see a famous film star, pop star, personality etc and crowds of people turn up for a glimpse of them and scream at the top of their lungs as a result in what they would describe as ecstasy. These are of course worldly things, perhaps I am unable to fully appreciate the same for spiritual qualities and may hold the cliche image of 'shant' meditation / prayer which doesn't allow me to understand the 'scream' - please could you expand a little further. Thanks, A Singh.

Re: really LOUD simran

Kulbir Singh · 19 Oct 2005

I have noticed that such questions are asked by individuals who themselves don't have Simran jeevan. They are not regular abhyaasis of Amrit Naam. Doing simran loudly is not shouting at Vaheguru. It is the vidhi of Naam Abhyaas and is not peculiar to Jatha. Sant Attar Singh Mastuanawalay used to suggest loud simran and very loud paath. It is done so that our surtee gets attuned to Naam. The shabad in question is for people who only shout out to Vaheguru to show other people but inside they are not longing Vaheguru. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: really LOUD simran

....... · 20 Oct 2005

Kulbir Singh, there is a difference between shouting your lungs out and this vidhi sant baba attar singh ji is talking about. There is a huge diffference. Vidhi taught by sant ji is not shouting or screaming your lungs out but reciting it to an volume where your ears can hear it. That's helps later on to focus on the naam dhuni.

Re: really LOUD simran

A Singh · 20 Oct 2005

Veer Kulbir Singh, Many Mahapursh have recommended doing paath and simran aloud, of even loudly as you mention, however do you not feel there to be a difference between this (i.e. reciting bani aloud) and “screaming” as described by the first two posters, particularly if this leads to mispronunciation of the paath/gurmantra (I recall a post not too long ago about this point with a link to a live recording where the shabad had become significantly distorted as a result of the effective “shouting”). Most samagams I personally have attended, be it the Jatha or another institution, they will have the simran ‘loud’ however even at higher volumes or tempos, it is quite distinct from shouting and screaming – the latter I first witnessed during a kuka Namdhari divan, where Namdhari Singhs and Singhnees would get so mast in the kirtan that they would literally 'scream' and enter into a 'sootar' (mast) – I have since witnessing this read about this in Gyani Gyan Singh’s writings which indicate that this has long been the custom within the Kukas and specifically reprimands them for going so mast that their dastaars fall off. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: really LOUD simran

rambo · 20 Oct 2005

lol. i recently attended a program at amritvela in which EVERYONE was screaming very loudly and i weas very surprised that noones datsars came off with all the "headbanging" as bhai a singh mentioned above. yes the word "vaheguru" was very distored.here are some of the ways: 1.Vahgrooooooooo(missing out the "U") 2. gurr gurr...sometimes groo groo(missing out the VAH) 3. sometimes guruuaaaa or vaheguroooaaa(addition of "aa") 4. sometimes just vah vah vah vah 5.an unrecgonisable form which often consisted of-grrrrrrrrovahooogroavhvahgrooooogurr gurr gurr to name but a few often i heard unusual screams....and the rolling of the tongue at very high pitches produced an extremely interesting affect. having said this.i suppose we should all just cocnentrate on the way we do simran individually.in fact i rather enjoyed this simran, becuase it focuses the mind. i especially enjoy the really slow- in and out vahe gurooo vahe gurooo

Re: really LOUD simran

Iron Man · 20 Oct 2005

oiy rambo, what are you there for, listening to others, or doing amritvela? heres a number of answers to these questions which really sound funny to those who actually do naam simran lol (not to sound egotistical)... first off.. anyone heard of a play called streetcar named desire.. remember the line "STEEEEELLLLLLLLLAAAAAAAAAAA" I can name so many times when i have seen in western love dramas where people are literaly screaming the name of someone they love.. yes that can mean other thigns as well, lets not get into it.. but that shows that there is a certain intimacy with waheguroo, does it not? Regarding, starting going off on tangents like GUROOOAAAA now and then, when was the last time you heard of someone not giving someone they love some kind of nickname, at least now and tehn? IF one is truly intimate with akal purakh as gursikhi teaches, such things are not only normal, but really just great. I mean gursikhs that scream the name of their beloved and have nicknames for guru sahib shows a real intimacy, but yes they are japping "Waheguroo" 99% of the time, they can still have some degree of latitude, esp when u are just getting really spiritually excited... Hope all that makes sense..

Re: really LOUD simran

rambo · 20 Oct 2005

i'm so sorry i'm a paapi. i dnt rele agree with what u said bt i understand that we should concentrate on ourselves. it thought the post was a bad idea but i couldnt stop my Mun from interfering. sorry jeeo.

Re: really LOUD simran

MOW · 20 Oct 2005

so dont cuss gursikhs doing saas giraas please, cussing saas giraas is one of the panj po's which should be avoided at all costs, i thought when doing saas giraas it doesnt matter what sound comes out your mouth, it is the dhunni in your mind you are meant to concentrate on, linking it with the vidhi the panj teach ju

Re: really LOUD simran

Dass · 20 Oct 2005

I think it is absolutly disrespectful for people to judge how others do simran. I know this took me away from sangat for quite some time. I'm still not fully involved with the "regular" Gurdwara sangat because of all the judging that happens. I used to DO simran in sangat and i was one of the people who moved my body alot and i did it loud because thats just how i felt to do it. I had to do it loud and in a way that my extremely mahapaapi mann would concentrate. Everytime my mann would slip i would start doing it loud or i would get josh from others loud simran and without knowing it being doing it really really loud. I would have such a blissful feeling afterwords. But then i started hearing rumours about me and the few who did it loud about how we were pakhandis and trying to impress ppl..or how we looked posessed. It broke my heart when i realized this was coming from so "called" Gursikhs. I know i'm a pakhandi but it hurts when you are just doing simran the best way u know how and people come and do nothing but judge you. It hurts to see what state we are in today. We can't even escape kaljug at amritvela in the middle of simran. Forgive me for any mistakes.

Re: really LOUD simran

Kulbir Singh · 20 Oct 2005

What does it mean by the word "Kookna"? Keso keso kookiye, naa soyeeye asaar|| Kookna means to cry out in very loud voice. Here in the above pankiti Gurbani is clearly instructing us to cry out to Keshaw Vaheguru. Doing "Kook Pukaar" to Vaheguru is perfectly according to Gurmat. The only thing required is that one is not doing pakhand and one has love inside too. When the Christian Paadri (priest) in Nagpur jail asked Bhai Sahib how he had managed to be in jail alone for so many years. Bhai Sahib replied back saying that he was not alone. At this the jail ward accused Bhai Sahib of lying. The priest looked at Bhai Sahib and it did not seem to him that Bhai Sahib was lying. He asked him who was with, if he was not alone. Hearing this question, Bhai Sahib's surtee at once reached Dasam Duaar and an unrestrained, very sharp kirtan dhunee came out of Bhai Sahib. He sang - "Gur mere Sang Sada hai naalay||" in full ecstasy. The whole jail was echoing with Bhai Sahib Bairaagi voice. Bhagats are kamlay. Unless they become kamlay, they cannot reach Vaheguru. In jail, once Bhai Sahib was moved to that section of jail, that Bhai Sahib found full of natural beauty. The natural beauty of that place was striking. Immediately, Bhai Sahib's surtee reached the highest spiritual planes. In ecstasy he sang a shabad in voice extremely loud that the whole jail could hear it and the voice was so mesmerizing that who ever heard Bhai Sahib's voice dropped all that they were doing. The whole jail came to a standstill. Later, the superitendant came to Bhai Sahib and complained to him. Bhai Sahib told him that he did not mean to disturb anyone but he had no control over what happened that day. There is nothing wrong in saying Naam as loud as possible. When Bhai Sahib and their companions used to to Naam Abhyaas (Swaas Swaas) on the Dhaab between Gujjarwal and Narangwal, their voice used to be audible in many villages around. So Pyaray Veero, lagay raho. Don't worry about what people say. People have to say something. We are here to please our beloved Vaheguru. We will do whatever it takes to please him. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: really LOUD simran

singh... · 20 Oct 2005

Bhagats are kamlay. Unless they become kamlay, they cannot reach Vaheguru. In jail, once Bhai Sahib was moved to that section of jail, that Bhai Sahib found full of natural beauty. The natural beauty of that place was striking. Immediately, Bhai Sahib's surtee reached the highest spiritual planes. In ecstasy he sang a shabad in voice extremely loud that the whole jail could hear it and the voice was so mesmerizing that who ever heard Bhai Sahib's voice dropped all that they were doing. The whole jail came to a standstill. Later, the superitendant came to Bhai Sahib and complained to him. Bhai Sahib told him that he did not mean to disturb anyone but he had no control over what happened that day. >>>> great post kulbir singh. however, don't you always pick on other sant mahapurh picking on their techniques, mock them by saying this is not gurmat blah blah... it's time that you follow your own advise.

Re: really LOUD simran

Dass 2 · 20 Oct 2005

By the way the above DASS post is my post.. i just saw another dass posting here so i don't want sangat to get confused