Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Baldeep Singh · 20 Oct 2005

Vahegurooo Jeee Kaaa Khalsaaaah, Vahegurooo Jeee Keee Fateeeeeeh! Recently, a pyara gursikh told me how evil Jawarlal Nehru (Gangu) was and power hungry he was. During the Indo-china wars, Nehru got a lot of Gursikh who wore the bana and huge dumallay to fight in the wars. These Gursikhs as I was told were from a Maharaja’s court (Patiala?), they were all very tall and well built Singhs. During this war, four Singhs performed their service outstandingly and they were welcomed by the people of Hindustan as Hero’s, however these Singhs were about to retire from their service to their country and they only had one avenue to go and this was politics. Gangu Nehru became anxious about the Singhs entering the politics arena and that their popularity might lower undermine his. Due to this, his invidious mind plotted a plan to get rid of the Singhs. From what I was told was that Nehru invited the four Singhs to board a plane and mysteriously the plane crashed and thus ended the lives of these glorious and patriotic Singhs. __________________________________________________________________________________________________ Does anyone have the names, dates, articles, etc of this event or anything that shows the callous character of Gangu Nehru or any threads on this MB about him __________________________________________________________________________________________________ Baldeep Singh. [%sig%]

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Kulbir Singh · 20 Oct 2005

I think you are referring to General Bikram Singh who along with four of his companions died mysteriously. Sardar Bikram Singh was very frustrated with the way Nehru was doing things. He was one of the most daring military leaders ever and his honesty was unmatched. Once, his wife took his official jeep for shopping. When he found out, he immediately went to the market she had gone shopping and brought back the jeep. He told his wife to come back walking and told her never to use the official jeep again. Another time, he was accosted by an old lady who complained that she had not seen her son for a long time. She complained that he was not granting him chhuttee to come home. Sardar jee immediately sanctioned vacation for her son. The respect that he commanded in the hearts of Indian soldiers is without rival. There was a rumour that he wanted to take over India and establish his rule there. They wanted to eradicate corruption from India. I think he also wanted to take back Nanakana Sahib by attacking Pakistan. Pakistan was very fearful of him because they had seen what Bikram Singh was capable of during the first war for Kashmir. Nehru felt very threatened by him and it is said that they were assassinated, though outwardly it seemed that they died of a plane crash. Kulbir Singh

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

messageboard fan · 20 Oct 2005

I have seen a pinting of all four of these heros with a picture of the plane in Harmander Sahib painting gallery. I will try and find if there is an internet link to it.

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

S Singh · 20 Oct 2005

Nehru and all his coetrie were a bunch of corrput idiots. After independence Nehru appointed his buddy Krishna Menon as High commissioner to the UK. This bloke spent most of his budget buying a Rolls Royce . Later he was given a few million pounds to buy Jeeps for the Indian army. A few decades have passed but to date the jeeps have not been delivered and the money not returned.

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

HISTORY · 20 Oct 2005

This thread is really small self talk.First and foremost there was NO such thing as INDO CHINA WAR. I think you fellows are referring to the 1962 Sino Indian war. Secondly, Lt General Bikram Singh and Lt General Daulat Singh were among five other senior generals whose helicopter went down in bad weather in kashmir, Ladakh near sian chen glacier.Hindu generals were also killed in this crash. They indeed said to be very able generals.The talk of deliberate killing came out after 1984-when khalistani propogandists were trying to find every excuse to blame the indian government. There were sikh soldiers sent after the start of the sino indian war to stand up to the chinese offensive. The poorer armed sikhs with inappropariate winter clothing did put a great fight, but were still pushed back by the chinese. Nehru wass VERY proud of the Sikhs, and thought they will stop the attacks by the chinese just because they were sikhs. The beleive was that the mere presence of sikhs will put a stop to the chinese advance, as the madrasi soldiers left their positons and ran .. I tremeber seeing him on telly saying ...now I have ordered a brigade of my legendary Sikhs warriors..let us see what the chinese are going to do "...ab hamare desh bhagat sher bahader Sikh sipahion ki ek brigade NEFA ko ja rahi hai ..dekhenge eh chini kaise bhaagten hai ab" Sadly as said, the Sikhs did fight heroically ....but with outdated weopons and summer uniforms in the cold of the himalayas they soon had to retreat ..but they retreated giving the chinese a bloody fightof their life ...As chinese were cut down by the Sikhs, the chinese sent wave after wave of soldiers until the Sikh troops had to retreat....my cousin was there and captured fighting with his boynet after he ran out of bullets.He was under the famous Lt general Joginder Singh who led the attacks upon the chinese in this war, and it only his sector that stood up to the chinese. It was nehru's fault, the army was not modernised, and was not useless defence minister.General Kaul was the commander incharge who brought this debacle upon the indian army.he was said to be related to nehru and later removed. It was recognised world wide that if it was not for the Sikhs and Gurkha troops, the defeat would have been far greater for India.In fact the sino chinese war changed the Indian army ...and it began to modernise..and was able to repeulse the pakistani attack in 1965 , again thanks to the Sikh and Gurkha soldiers.

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Sikhi · 22 Oct 2005

And its quiet ironic that the same "modernised" army attacked the Golden Temple by using chemical weapons. See how history can change in a moment.

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

manjh payara guru ko · 22 Oct 2005

gangu chor chor [%sig%]

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Gurcharan Singh · 23 Oct 2005

And its quiet ironic that the same "modernised" army attacked the Golden Temple by using chemical weapons. See how history can change in a moment. Yes, it was ironic as well government SIKH soldiers saw the fortified harmander occupied by terrorirsts , parts of this modernised army also consisted many Sikhs who saw their duty to attack. As for using" chemical weapons ..."is going over the top of exagerrating is it not ??

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

DS · 23 Oct 2005

Didn't Nehru put his cousin in charge of the war with China who subsequently left his forward position and fled to Delhi leaving the poor Sikhs to fight. In the recent KGB disclosure Krishnan Menon was shown to have taken bribes from the Soviets to buy their military hardware. What great patriots!! In 1984 this army did mass killing of Sikhs at many Gurdwaras in Punjab, is this bravery?

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

10th regiment · 23 Oct 2005

i also remeber nehru and patel calling sikhs are a criminal tribe

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

DS · 23 Oct 2005

Look Gurcharan Singh everybody including even Sonia Gandhi have apologised for the attack in Amritsar stating that it was a mistake. Sunderji the General in charge in 84 said that the attack haunted him, his wife said he never laughed again until his death. So why do a handfull of people try to defend the attack?

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Ranjha Ranjha · 23 Oct 2005

The attack on sikhs will never be forgiven. Thousands of innocent jatt sikhs were mercilessly killed. We share your pain and aguish and one day revenge will be due. History repeats brothers. Now the entire sikh religion knows how cunning the brahmins are. The rest of indian has a jelous hatred towards punjabis. Revenge will be taken on the brahmins for their cowardly attack. Ranjha Ranjha Lozells Krew

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Baldeep Singh · 24 Oct 2005

>>Thousands of innocent jatt sikhs were mercilessly killed. lol! So only Jatts "Sikhs" are allowed into Darbar sahib hey. From this statement, one must assume that before entry into darbar sahib complex, one must fill in a questionaire based upon which caste one belongs too. Preach one thing and practice another. A true inspiration to all Humans. keep it up! >> Sonia Gandhi have apologised Hmmmmm???? This topic is not about the the attack on Sri Darbar Sahib, please familiarise yourselves to the topic in hand. Greatly appreciate the individuals who have posted relevant responses. >> To DS Please eloborate on the information the details you have provided regarding the KGB AND Krishnan Menon. Who is Mr Menon and where have you got your sources from. Vahegurooo Jee Kee Khalsaaaah, Vahegurooo Jeee Keee Fateeeeh! [%sig%]

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Singh · 24 Oct 2005

Nice post ranjha, but there were not jatt Sikhs. Most were Amritdharis, and caste is not apart of Sikhi.

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

DS · 24 Oct 2005

>> To DS Please eloborate on the information the details you have provided regarding the KGB AND Krishnan Menon. Who is Mr Menon and where have you got your sources from. We demand statement from Congress, says BJP's Naqvi; New book claims KGB bribed India govt under Indira Gandhi NEW DELHI (Agencies): India's main opposition party Sunday called for an investigation into claims made in a new book that the former Soviet Union bribed senior figures of the Indira Gandhi government during the Cold War. Former KGB senior archivist Vasili Mitrokhin wrote in "The Mitrokhin Archive II: The KGB and the World" that the spy agency had bought secrets from Indian cabinet ministers and paid them retainers. "It seemed like the entire country was for sale," Mitrokhin quotes then KGB general Olef Kalugnin as saying, describing India as a model for the infiltration of a third world government. Excerpts were published on the front pages of major Indian newspapers Sunday. The claims were likely to embarrass the ruling coalition headed by the Congress party and supported from the outside by the Communist Party of India ر the two alleged recipients of KGB largesse. "On at least one occasion a secret gift of two million rupees (then about $250,000) from Moscow to the Congress was personally delivered after midnight," Mitrokhin wrote. "Another million rupees was given on the same occasion to a newspaper which supported Mrs Gandhi." Gandhi ruled India from 1966 to 1984, when she was assassinated by her Sikh bodyguards in revenge for ordering a raid on the religion's holiest shrine. The book also alleged that the KGB arranged Gandhi's welcome to the Soviet Union during a personal visit in 1953 and "surrounded her with handsome, attentive male admirers". The KGB also had subsidised the election campaigns of 21 politicians, including four cabinet ministers, in national polls, according to the excerpts. One beneficiary was former defence minister V.K. Krishna Menon, who was persuaded to buy Soviet MiGs fighter jets instead of British planes and who had received KGB funding for election expenses in 1962 and 1967, the book alleged. India's opposition Hindu nationalist Bhartiya Janata Party was quick to demand an explanation from the 120-year-old Congress party on Sunday. "We demand a statement from the Congress," said BJP leader Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi. "These are serious allegations." But the Congress Party and the communists dismissed the claims. "This is the version of one person," said Congress spokesman Abhishek Singhvi. "There is no way of checking the facts as some of the people mentioned are no longer alive. "Such statements are meant for sensationalism and cannot be dignified with a reaction unless there is something specific to comment on." Communist party spokesman D. Raja called the claims in the book "baseless" and said, "I dismiss it with the contempt that it deserves". The book suggests the KGB was more successful than the American Central Intelligence Agency in India as it was more adept at exploiting corruption that had become "endemic under Indira's regime". Mitrokhin defected to Britain from the Soviet Union in 1992 with classified material, the Indian Express reported. His first book, written with Christopher Andrew, a historian at Corpus Christi College, Cambridge, dealt with the KGB network in the West while the sequel deals with the network in the developing world. "The openness of Indias democracy ... combined with a streak of corruption through its media and political system provided numerous opportunities for Soviet intelligence," said one excerpt in the Indian Express newspaper. India was Russia's Cold War ally, and 70 per cent of its military supplies come from Moscow. Despite the 1992 breakup of the Soviet Union, Moscow remains New Delhi's closest military ally. The book named Lalit Narayan Mishra, the Congress party's principal fund raiser, as a direct recipient of KGB money. It said the KGB successfully convinced Gandhi that Mishra's death in a bomb blast in 1974 was a "CIA hit-job." Gandhi lost power in the 1977 polls. The book is based on files from the KGB's archives which Mitokhin brought to British intelligence in 1992, said co-author Andrew, a professor of modern history at Cambridge University in Britain. The Congress party dismissed the claims. "One can't even comment on them," said Abhishek Manu Singhvi, a congress party spokesman. However, Singhvi said the Soviet Union was a source of strength for India in the Cold War era. "We are proud of it," he said. The KGB documents also accused the US Central Intelligence Agency of fomenting an Insurgency in India's remote northeast and a Sikh separatist movement in the northern state of Punjab, the book said.

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Bhopinder Singh · 24 Oct 2005

The story of assasination of generals has some logic as Yahya Khan took over in Pakistan Nehru got nervous that the Indian counterpart may follow through.

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

!! · 25 Oct 2005

"The talk of deliberate killing came out after 1984-when khalistani propogandists were trying to find every excuse to blame the indian government." This is not true. This was on everybodies tongue even the hindus of Punjab were saying the same thing that these punjabi generals are killed deliberately. It was not an accident . In those days most punjabi hindus were loyal to punjab and these sikh generals were their heros as well. This is not post 1984 propoganda. [%sig%]

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Gurcharan Singh · 26 Oct 2005

"In those days most punjabi hindus were loyal to punjab and these sikh generals were their heros as well. This is not post 1984 propoganda." This is NOT true at all.Facts show it was because of the dislaoyalty of the Punjabi hindus the problem of Punjab got escalated and worse. Since Bhim Sen sachar went off as the Punjab CM the hindu block vote started going against the issues of the punjab .... Any way it does NOT matter what people say, as long as there are not facts recorded.I was around when the air crash happend.I read about in overseas papers.The weather was said to be pretty bad in Ladakh that day.Now if it was state triggered , it is unlikely that they are going to get it so perfect to time the accident even with Gods weather helping them. The whole country went into shock at the loss.NO BODY challenged it for years to be an assination attempt...until after the 1984, some one from Khalistani elements started listing about Sikh generals bypassed for promotion , gave the accident the name of "state triggered" killing of Punjabi generals. This mere misrepresented propoganda.Just dont based on what others say, study the whole and see the circumstances...understand the facts...it is amusing how people twist the truth and make their own facts ..and Sikhs seem to be doing it effectually!

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Bhopinder Singh · 26 Oct 2005

Gurcharan Singh Sikhs always twist things even the ordinance of sikhs are all criminals is made up. even though India did a Kargill type operation in 1984 and took gilgit and siachin from Pakistan but still barely armed ( according to Gen. Sinha of Indian army the disparity in arms was such that the sikhs were virtually unarmed ) in plain terrain were a threat to India.

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

ACCURATE HISTORY · 26 Oct 2005

HISTORY said: "Nehru wass VERY proud of the Sikhs, and thought they will stop the attacks by the chinese just because they were sikhs." Here's a speach made by the former indian prime minister, Thankless Sleazy Pandit Nehru: "The sikhs are a lawless people and a menace to the law abiding hindus...the government should take strict measures agaisnt them"

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Gurcharan Singh · 27 Oct 2005

See again HOW this "true histroy "changes history and tells TRUE lies!! Nehru NEVER SAID that at all!It was his home minister...S patel who said that. If you rememeber it was alo Indidra who got upset when her Sikh body guards were removed and asked them to be re-instated at once! Bhoppinder Singh it is a bare fact that the Indian army did come in very heavy,may be it was the fear of the Sikhs that made them do that !!! But whatever, there is no doubt the attack was bad and evil, but that does not change the facts that it was both the sikh political party's continual loggerheads with the centre made the centre harder and also confrontative ...and when it came down it came using excessive force..and that force initself was wrong and un warranted when essepcially thousands of innocents were caught into it. By the way ....dont twist facts ...

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Baldeep Singh · 27 Oct 2005

Gurcharan are you from Bradford

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Bhopinder Singh · 27 Oct 2005

Gurcharan Singh Did i name Nehro?Please check your facts first or let mehta ji from RAW do it. Army came in heavy are you stupid or a bloody agent. A professional army that fought 4 wars and was routed in one of them (1962) and behaved very true to their ancestors with Goc running like a rat in that war. It was a deliberate move to show sikhs their place in India as they participated in emegency imposed by Indira for political purposes .They thought they were equal Indians and theirfore can peacefully oppose the dictatorship of Indira , not only Indira took revenge but even the opposition the very party at the recieving end of the Indiras beating ,kept silent and made sikhs remember who they are for they foolishly thought of themselves as Indians. sant sipahi Jarnail singh rightly understood the situation that the minority bashing is being done deliberately and intentionally to apease the hindu majority and get 3/4 mojority in parliament. The last battle of world war fought by 600 Germans in mountains of Italy aginst the way superior forces without any air cover or for that reason even a central command for 6 months and untill the last of them fell stands as monument of german defiance to this day.SO ARE THE BATTLE OF CHAMKOUR, KHATRANE DE DHAB IN MUKTSAR IN THE PRESENCE OF 10 TH MASTER AS THE LIGHTHOUSES FOR US IN PAST So is the battle of headless Baba Deep singh and the battle of 1984 in Drabar sahib. never after that should we even debate Khalistan for that we will face the rath of guru in this world and the world after.

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Gurcharan Singh · 27 Oct 2005

""Here's a speach made by the former indian prime minister, Thankless Sleazy Pandit Nehru: "The sikhs are a lawless people and a menace to the law abiding hindus...the government should take strict measures agaisnt them" THE ABOVE IS WHAT YOU SAID. Patel was NOT the PM either.The PM did not say that either. Bhai sahib,today Sikhs are not that calibre of Baba Deep singh.let us not get personal.This is a free world to discuss the pros and cons. Why dont you think spreading sikhism and increasing its numbers will NOT make a Khalisatn of an area far bigger then the mini Punjab you have today.BBhindrawala did not say he wanted khalstan either...the Gurus did not confine to the punjab either ,so why confine a khalistan to mini punjab ?what is the problem of sprading sikhism to more in India, and making the khalistan bigger?? or is this representing the Dr ambedkaar times mentality of constricting the Sikhs? Dont woprry about Hitler and the italians,they are NOT sikhs, and they dont have the problems of the Sikhs.Seeing others does not make our issues easier.Worry about our own. You have not naswered to how do we unite in khalistan when we cant unite ...in a dream khalsitan is BEAUTIFUL.We all know our fore ftahers made the bIGGEST blunder...we are today feeling it ...but by killing half the kaum aimlessly will not get us the khalistan we awant. Think strategically, the game can be won in numbers far easily ..so why not use that instead of killing off the few we have ?have you any problem with the rest of india even half converting to sikhi ?? becomming emotional and throwing emotional arguments would not win us anything.

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Bhopinder Singh · 27 Oct 2005

Gurcharan singh I never said anything about Nehru.So please dont write that in yor response or show me the post. nothing comes free for even 5 th master ,9 th master and 10 th master had to give their blood. If Iraq can fight the single superpower that to in plain terrain very similar to Punjab.This is a fact leave aside emotionalism. Either get you rights or try getting them.We dont want conversion by covert methods.Let their be a nation and then the facts of faith itself will do the conversion.We cannot even protect our faith in punjab forget about India. The moment Indian govt sees your conversion even in one village you are done with ask people doing that in up. Entire power if GOI is behind radhes ,nirankaris, kukas,ashutosh to name a few.

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Singh · 27 Oct 2005

Gurcharan Singh JI Go to the thread "FWD: Why we want a Sikh nation ?" and read the writeup of BS Goraya and Beant Singh to know why Sikhs deserves and need an independent nation in Punjab. I think B.S.Goraya answered your question and cleared your confusion in very first lines Read ..." Sikhism has a dynamic approach and has the potential to be spread to whole world. But the Sikhs of Punjab are fully entitled to be a nation. They have sacrificed enough and thus can't forego their claim. Our fathers sacrificed for India before 1947 and to that extent our credit is much heavier. The total fighters who were sent to gallows for freedom of India, 86% were Sikhs. But after winning freedom the brahmin turned his back to the Sikhs. So much so when Nehru was reminded of the promises the Congressites made to Sikhs he plainly and unashamedly said, "Now the circumstances have changed." We would have tolerated the excesses until the Congress launched secret programme to absorb Sikhs in the Hinduism. Every effort is being made to liquidate our culture. We will thus continue to raise voices for Khalistan (within India) until the Brahminic programmes are withdrawn and justice is meted out to us. ..................................... ...................... " So veer Gurcharan Singh, if you are not a Punjabi Sikh and have not realized the need and legitimate right to have a Sikh nation in Punjab, I can understand your position but if try to understand the situation from the other point of view then you will definitely find why the Sikhs in Punjab deserve to have a Sikh nation at its birth place from a long time and it will in fact help the Sikhs around the world flourish more and better. [%sig%]

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Gurcharan Singh · 27 Oct 2005

aahh...author singh ..you have hit the nail on the head..." we deserve to have ..."" yes we deserve ..no body and neither have I said we dont deserve ...we deserve far more ...than a small land locked khalistan ...but tell me what are you going to do with the rest of the 8-9 million Sikhs that live in the rest of the country ?Where will they go ?into the indian ocean ? is there sufficeint land for these popel to live and run agriculture in the mini khalistan? I know BS Goraya and his last declartaion of the kartar pur corridor!!which when I challend on another net turned out to be a hoax som emonths back.Then he said we deserve to have ..too. Bhai sahib, the Sikh nation desrves far more...far more than you can ever think. but merely deserving and facing the reallity to have that deserve is unrealistic andtwo different things! Bhai sahib, no one can country will stand by the Sikhs to break the mini punjab and declare khalistan.The sikh leadership under master tara singh did not have hindsight at all.they took upon press declarations and vote rigging speeches to beleive the congress party ..and we are payng the price now. They sealed our fate with declaration of india in 1947, while they did not seal with agreemnt the fate of sikhs freedom .....legally PUNJAB belongs to india.It does not matter what ...no country will want to be the culpprit to break away another country ..as no part of anyone country apart from tahiland is historically ALL original part of those countries.Even britain is in the same position,.but will not let Northern Ireland go. I can understand the aspirations , and many years back long before 1984, I used to wonder why did sikhs not have their own country...but bhai sahib ...killing off half our community to gain a small land locked area will not be much of a gain. why can the Sikhs NOT preach sikhism properly and bring in converts in the rest of India?Why can we not expose sikhi to others and increase our numbers to 300,000,000 millions?then there will be no need for khailsitan we can sit equally with the majooriyty and say this is also our rights and our nation.Why are we trying to close sikhi into a small khalistan. Comming back to no country will allow the break up of another these days ...se what the american have done to the kurds ...who were hoping theuy will get a nation of their own in Northern iraq...after all the help they gave ...what happens ...america stays short of that ...promise ...kurds still are part of Iraq. Bhai sahib , try to change the tactics...I can gurantee you sikhs will go far with spreading the message of gurbani ,,,and khalistan will be on their laps. I know BS goraya 's emotional write ups.Emotions dont gain anything.

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

Bhopinder Singh · 27 Oct 2005

What happened to jews living in different parts of the world when Israel was created?Were they all thrown in sea WHAT A FOOLISH STATEMENT

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

true facts · 28 Oct 2005

Jews got their homeland before they shouted,The british helped them, the country was being split by the british ...so they jumped up the bandwagon , and asked for their share ..but when the british split India sikhs unlike the jews ,gave their share away , now later they changed their mind, but the foolish do not realise this and sitting behind the computers they are churning khalistan after khalistan ...out ..what a foolish dream and dreaming on ...

Re: Nehru - Sikhs and Indo-China War

unknown · 28 Oct 2005

answer my question were the jews from different countries thrown in the sea. as of Israel it was forced o n Palisine by 3 powers who refused to except them as per their own agreement and looked for a place 3000 years ago left by jews. for your Khurdish statement Iraq is going to be split into 3 parts is just a statement like yours ,just wait and see.