Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

do plants have souls?

do plants have souls?

JB · 20 Oct 2005

do plants have souls? are they included in the "charasi lahk joonah"? is it possible for a human being to die and be re-born as a plant? if you look at it from a boilogical point of view, plants are alive. so what does sikhi say? thnx :D

Re: do plants have souls?

in love with Guru Ji · 20 Oct 2005

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA;WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH YES, PLANTS DO HAVE A SOUL ACCORDING TO GURBANI

Re: do plants have souls?

g · 20 Oct 2005

no.

Re: do plants have souls?

blah blah blah · 20 Oct 2005

On a side note, where do we stand regarding cloned animals etc? Where would the soul of that animal come from etc? Any views?

Re: do plants have souls?

Sehajvir Singh · 20 Oct 2005

I remember in one of my classes my prof talked about something very interesting that is related to this topic. There was an experiment done by scientest to see if plants could think or react. What happened was they hooked up i believe a lie dectector or something of this sort to detect any frequencies. Sure enough the needle started moving back and forth slightly showing that somethign was going on with the plant. To take it a step further someone cut the plant leaf with scissors and the activity jumped rapidly for a few minuted indicating that perhaps the plant felt some sort of pain. To take it even a step further they made the person with the scissiors walk out the room which made the frequency normal again. However as soon as this person walked into the room holding the scissors the the needle jumped again. I believe this shows that yes plants may indeed have a soul. They according to this experiment can feel pain. I wish i could give u details on a medical journal or somethign that this was printed in but it was so long ago i can't remember. However my prof was discussing it in class so i highly doubt it was made up. So that brings up another question. Me being a vegetarian i would like to know how would i answer a question like " if plants do have a soul whats the difference in eating them and a chicken?" I mean they both live and grow and die and eating one or the other would effect its life cycle. I am not trying to advocate meat. I am an amritdhari and a strict vegetarian. This is just a question that i came across in my head and i would like the sangat to help me answer it. Especially Veer Kulbir Singh

Re: do plants have souls?

Iron Man · 20 Oct 2005

a cloned animal would be born just like any other

Re: do plants have souls?

JB · 20 Oct 2005

ok, one person answered yes, another answered no. so which is it?

Re: do plants have souls?

.... · 20 Oct 2005

if plants have a soul.....then .... if its wrong to eat meat...it should also be wrong to eat vegetation.... i was asked this & i had NO answer..

Re: do plants have souls?

Singh · 20 Oct 2005

Plants may have souls, but fruits do not. They are the products of plants.

Re: do plants have souls?

JB · 20 Oct 2005

to Singh: ok, say fruits dont have souls. but they are the "seeds" of the plants, just like eggs are the "seeds" of the chickens....

Re: do plants have souls?

~ · 20 Oct 2005

When you kill a plant does it scream or beg or try to run? No. When you kill a cow or a pig, does it scream and beg or try to run? Yes. It shows no ruthlessness or lack of mercy to uproot a carrot or slice an apple. It takes a butcher to kill an animal. I tell you this. I saw last year a couple of the Al Qaeda beheadings. I was so disturbed. I'm not easily disturbed mind you. I remember the screaming as they pin the hostage down and slice his throat and the gurggling he makes as his head is being sawed off and all the blood. Recently I saw a video of a slaughterhouse. I saw the butcher stab the cow in the throat and slice. I felt the same sensations as I saw the cow, hanging from one leg, thrash about, oozing blood. It was totally the same emotion as seeing the beheading. If you can kill an animal without any feeling, you I'm quite sure can do it to a human. Why can the Al Qaeda terrorists do it ? It's because they've done the same procedure of halal to countless goats and lambs. It's not a big jump. Taking the life is not the biggest problem in eating meat. When we breath or walk, we kill countless beings every day. The problem is that only a BUTCHER can slaughter an animal and eat it because of the lack of mercy it takes. Eating plants is not even close to the same thing.

Re: do plants have souls?

DDT · 20 Oct 2005

plants have souls but they do not have the capacity to feel pain.

Re: do plants have souls?

g · 20 Oct 2005

Plants do not have souls! a plant has as much of a soul as the fungus growing between your toes... they have no souls why in the world would you think they have souls... please post me a line in Gurbani where it says plants have souls

Re: do plants have souls?

JB · 21 Oct 2005

ok, this has confused me even more. btw, if i eat a chicken (which i do), do get its karmic load or something? also, if i only eat the chicken thighs, and somebody else eats the chickens breasts, who gets the charmic load? is it split or something? its all v confusing man...

Re: do plants have souls?

khalistani · 21 Oct 2005

plants DO HAVE SOULS to say sikhi says plants are jus tplants is wrong ive read in gurbanee before to guru je saying tha plants have life in them a athma but to survive man must eat plants are not ba dfor re bhagthee, like they wont make ure mind wander and stuff, wont incite kaam, and panj dooths meat is BAD for bhagthee and animals have children and families, which even in jungles rely on each other to an extent no need to kill animals for food but to survive we must eat plants we arnt gonna go overboard and say we dont eat meat because we dont kill animals to say that wud be hypocrisy, like the jains didnt guru jes singh use LEATHER? ya they did we all breathe and kill millions of microoganisms its just we dont need to consume a food such as meat its not good for bhagthee this is y gurbanee is so agaisnt meat and the fact, u dont need it, u have plants to eat, and animals have FAMILIES but plants do have souls read the shabad by guru nanak dev je

Re: do plants have souls?

LionKing · 22 Oct 2005

This Shabad came to mind. Note before you attack me hahaha : I'm a veggie - First Mehl: The fools argue about flesh and meat, but they know nothing about meditation and spiritual wisdom. What is called meat, and what is called green vegetables? What leads to sin? It was the habit of the gods to kill the rhinoceros, and make a feast of the burnt offering. Those who renounce meat, and hold their noses when sitting near it, devour men at night. They practice hypocrisy, and make a show before other people, but they do not understand anything about meditation or spiritual wisdom. O Nanak, what can be said to the blind people? They cannot answer, or even understand what is said. [gurbani]kauxu mwsu kauxu swgu khwvY iksu mih pwp smwxy ][/gurbani] http://www.sikhitothemax.com/Page.asp?SourceID=G&PageNo=&ShabadID=4678&Format=2 Can some Gurmukh please explain the relevance of the Shabad in this context

Re: do plants have souls?

!! · 25 Oct 2005

Author: in love with Guru Ji Date: 10-20-05 09:50 WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA;WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH YES, PLANTS DO HAVE A SOUL ACCORDING TO GURBANI """"Please give reference to page and Tuk fromSGGS ji."""" Or just don't makeit up. Singh Date: 10-20-05 14:23 Plants may have souls, but fruits do not. They are the products of plants. """""""fruit contains the seed to start a new plant. """""""""" egg before the chicken or chicken before the egg situation [%sig%]

Re: do plants have souls?

PERSON · 25 Oct 2005

OmG.. i was gna ask about this q... cos m8 always says how he thinks eatin vegtables of a plant is like meat too.. obviousli not then

Re: do plants have souls?

panth Ka Daas · 26 Oct 2005

Dear brother and sisters Below is an article I found on the internet. I hope it is of some use in your understanding between meat and plant issues. Sikh Meat Issue. Now, to get to the heart of the matter, we are talking about killing another living being , cutting its flesh and muscles which that animal relied upon for its existence and consuming it, primarily for the taste. It has been said that we are designed to eat meat and that we evolved to eat meat. There are many things that we can do but that does not make them right, we as gursikhs need to overcome these primal urges, we need to rise above them. We can exist quite happily without meat so why do many people feel the urge to consume it, taste plays a large part of it. Can we in our hearts believe that the Gurus advocated this? Question : Are beings born on this earth and have living bodies just to be a convenience food ? Or are beings born into a life with a body so that they can develop and eventually evolve away from karma and into Dharma ? In the beginnings of SGGS , Guru Ji says : This human body has been given to you. This is your chance to meet the Lord of the Universe. Nothing else will work. Join the SaadhSangat, the company of the holy. Vibrate and meditate on the Jewel on the Naam. Make every effort to cross over this terrifying world-ocean. Your are squandering this life uselessly in the love of Maya I have not practiced meditation, self discipline, Self restraint or righteous living. I have not served the holy; I have not acknowledged the Lord, my king. Says Nanak, my actions are contemptible! O Lord, I seek Your Sanctuary, please preserve my honour. This 'body' is given to all in order to meet Akal Purkh and the Guru says that there is no other way to meet him. We are so fortunate that in Gods wisdom he has blessed us with a human body, for it is only a human who can meditate upon His Name and gain salvation, no other animal has this ability. By killing a healthy animal for consumption interrupts its life experience and its evolution towards meeting God. Animals can sense impending doom especially if they can hear the death throws of their colleagues. This can evoke a very powerful glandular response in the animal, pumping hormones around its body. When you eat that flesh you take on those hormones, and you take on its karma. This has a great effect on your Atma (soul) , for the Atma feels pain. Why do you think we are always restless and only catch brief moments of inner peace ? This is beacuse the atma is seperated from its maker, it longs to be reunited with it, but adding the karma of another soul to yours you are 'weighing' yourself down even more with paap, you are also interfering with your own desire to meet Akal Pukh. If you have not cleared away your own karma why would you want to create the karma of killing and consuming the flesh of another being ? Sikhs do not eat or take into their bodies anything which is harmful or have an ill effect upon the body or mind. Meat is a stimulant of the gross passions of the mind and body. Meat is harmful on a physical, mental and spiritual level. You are killing a soul who is in the process of evolving towards God this is not going to help you in any way on your journey towards God. Meat stimulates your 'lower nature' making it impossible to achieve a meditative spiritual mind set, try sitting down and clearing your mind to meditate after comsuming meat, it cannot be done. If you want constant confusion and irritation then chew on a piece of flesh, if you want to feed your lower passions then carry on as you are. Make no mistake, when the noose of death is around your neck and the jaal (net) of maya (illusion) is finally lifted then all will become clear, but my friend, it will all be too late. If on the other hand you want to evolve spiritually , open up the capacity for meditative comprehension of higher truths, gain inner peace of which you have never known before, then the karmic and polluting nature of meat cannot be ignored. It is said by many that plants also have life so why do we not abstain from eating plants ? It is very true that plants do have life, Guru Nanak dev Ji has said "patti toray maalni, patti patti geeo" (The gardner plucks leaves from the plant, (but she does not know that) there is life in each leaf) but the karmic energy and consequences of eating plants do not compare to those of an animal which has feeling, possible thoughts, parental instincts towards its offspring, also plants (lentils, maize , spinach etc) are not harmful on a mental, spiritual level but are in fact good for the digestion. Much has been made of the Nihang Singh sect eating Maha Parshad, but the Nihangs also drink a concoction of Marihuana and opium called Suckha, are we all to start taking drugs because of this? They (the truest of the true) burn away the bonds of the world, And eat a simple diet of grain and water. (SGGS p467) Kabir, those mortals who consume marijuana, fish and wine - no matter what pilgrimages, fasts and rituals they follow, they will all go to hell. (SGGS p1337) You kill living beings and worship lifeless things, at your very last moment, You will suffer terrible pain. (SGGS p332) Do not say that the Vedas are false, false are those who do not reflect. If in all is one god, then why does one kill the hen ? (SGGS p1350) Sayeth Kabir, that the best food is eating kichree (daal/lentils) where nectar sweet is the salt. You eat hunted meat, but which animal is willing to have their head cut ? (SGGS p1378) In this dark age of Kali Yuga, people have faces like dogs; They eat rotting dead bodies for food. (SGGS p1242) Sayeth Kabir, sayeth thou by "forcefully" killing living beings, Halaal. When in God's house, your accounts be taken, what will then there happen to you! (SGGS p1375) Kabeer bhang mashalee suraapaan, jo jo pranee khaan-he teerath barat neym kee-ey, te sabh rasaatal jaan-he (1377) suraapaan=alcohol rasaatal=below hell, underground. Those people who drink bhang, eat fish, drink alcohol, and do ritual bathing, keep fast, all shall be burried underground. The Vars of Bhai Gurdas Ji are known as the 'kunji' (key) to Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji. Var 31 pauree 9 : "Just because the Guru has saved the butcher,That does not mean that we can kill animals and eat them." The only hymn in the whole of Sri Guru Granth Sahib that is specifically cited in support of eating meat is the hymn of Sahib Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji in the Var of Raag Malhar on pages 1289-90 beginning with the couplet: Maas Maas Kar Moorakh Jhaghrrey. Gian dhian Nahin Jaaney. Kaun Maas Kaun Saag Kahaavey Kis Mah Paap Samaaney. (pg. 1289-1290) Only the fool quarrels over the question of eating or not eating of the meat. He does not have the True Wisdom. Without True Wisdom or Meditation, he harps on which is flesh and which is not flesh and which food is sinful and which is not. A deeper study of the whole hymn brings out: Herein, Guru Sahib is addressing a Vaishnav Pandit who believes that he can achieve his spiritual goal only by avoiding meat as food and not trying to obtain the true wisdom through meditation. Guru Ji has stressed that only avoiding meat will not lead one to the achievement of Spiritual Bliss if one does not do Naam-Simran. This equally applies to all, including non-meat-eating Sikhs. It relates to the flesh or meat in general and not to any particular type of flesh - whether prepared by Halaal or Jhatka method. The Sikh supporters of flesh eating do not accept at all the intake of all types of meat, but according to them, only Jhatka meat is permissible and Halaal is totally prohibited. In other words, what does the term "Kuthha" denote? The flesh of the mother's womb wherein the human body is born, the flesh of the mother's breasts which feed the infant, the flesh of the tongue, ears, mouth, etc., used for perception of various senses of the body, the flesh in the form of wife and off-springs referred to in the Shabad, is flesh no doubt and one cannot escape it, but is it the flesh to be eaten as food by the humans? Does the love for this type of flesh involve any cruelty or slaughter of living bodies? Obviously, the Shabad has a deeper meaning telling Vaishnav pandits that merely escaping from the flesh does not take one anywhere. Nor can anyone get rid of the flesh (i.e., attainment of salvation from the cycle of birth and death) by his own futile efforts without the Grace of the True Guru. A final thought, the Sants and Mahapursh of the present day all warn us of the evils of eating meat. They all urge us to take Paol/Amrit and to give up maas, shraab and birri. Not one Sant has ever said otherwise. As a young lad I can just remember the times when Sant Baba Puran Singh Ji (Krichowali) used to administer Amrit to hundreds to people up and down the country and they never ever condoned meat eating. In recent times I have also been blessed by darshans of Sant Baba Bhagwan Singh Ji (Southall), not once have they ever even entertained the notion of meat and Sikism. Surely, being spiritually on a higher plain then all of us if there was any ambiguity in the 'meat - no meat' argument Baba ji would have stated it. But instead they are fiercely against meat. So who are we going to believe, Sant Mahapurshs or some academic manmukh ? Do we eat to live, or do we live to eat ?

Re: do plants have souls?

Singhni Miri Piri · 26 Oct 2005

WaheguruJiKaKhalsaWaheguruJiKiFateh Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh said the only reason why we can’t eat meat is because animals feel pain, whereas plants do not feel pain. If one eats meat then in their after life they have to be recarniated as a wolf. This will then make them suffer for their victim’s grief. WaheguruJiKaKhalsaWaheguruJiKiFateh

Re: do plants have souls?

.......?? · 26 Oct 2005

but everyone eats meat and there aint even that many wolves in the world

Re: do plants have souls?

Singhni Miri Piri · 26 Oct 2005

WaheguruJiKaKhalsaWaheguruJiKiFateh .......?? , Sorry, my mistake. If one eats meat they are committing a sin so they have to get punished for in hell for their misdeeds. But if one eats meat and their last dying thought is of that then they have to get recarniated as a wolf. WaheguruJiKaKhalsaWaheguruJiKiFateh

Re: do plants have souls?

khalistani · 27 Oct 2005

reincarnated as a wolf? who told u tha veer je ? bhula chuka maf

Re: do plants have souls?

cyber singh · 27 Oct 2005

Guru ji says: Kaetai RUKH BIRKH HUM CHEENAI

Re: do plants have souls?

g · 28 Oct 2005

ugh! of course plants are alive but they do not have mind body or soul... They have no soul! they are not a beign... geez if you really think plants have a soul you are truely lost, this shouldnt even be a question of course not! they have no soul! PLANTS ARE LIVING but it does not mean they have a soul understand? probally not =P

Re: do plants have souls?

cyber singh · 28 Oct 2005

g, plants have souls as per gurbani we have been through countless jeevans including plants and trees "KATAI RUKH BIRKH HUM CHEENAI..."

Re: do plants have souls?

g · 28 Oct 2005

So I guess fungus have souls too and mold and viruses and bacteria... so all this can have souls? but a soul doesnt enter the fetus until 6 months? gosh contradictions up the wazoo

Re: do plants have souls?

Singhni Miri Piri · 29 Oct 2005

khalistani, >>>reincarnated as a wolf?<<< This is said within Bhai Rama Singh’s Book; ‘In search of the true Guru’.

Re: do plants have souls?

agyani · 29 Oct 2005

But if one eats meat and their last dying thought is of that then they have to get recarniated as a wolf. ___________________________________________________________ not eat but think of, there is a sakhi frm guru nanak maharajis time about this.

Re: do plants have souls?

DDT · 29 Oct 2005

plants have souls and i would also assume that they are part of chalase lakh joon. bhull chuk mauff

Re: do plants have souls?

Gurpartap Singh · 29 Oct 2005

LionKing wrote: > This Shabad came to mind. > Note before you attack me hahaha : I'm a veggie - > well i am not a veggie, but u r write. even brahmins in older time ate non-veg. and guru nanak dev ji have clarification on that topic. they explained them, that if u dont want to eat a goat or cock, then why u dont think while rolling ur finger over an ant. why dont u see that whether an ant is below ur feet and then move

Re: do plants have souls?

khalsa_force · 01 Nov 2005

yes plants do hv souls. ><><><>><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><> Quote: Author: DDT Date: 10-20-05 15:57 plants have souls but they do not have the capacity to feel pain. ><><><>><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><> They do hv capacity to feel pain but not to express it. How abt tht?

Re: do plants have souls?

LionKing · 01 Nov 2005

They do express it - in their own way. an animal notices when an animal is sad, that's why you'd see a human hug a sad animal or something. How do you know the case isn't the samefor plant - where they understand each other?

Re: do plants have souls?

khalsa_force · 02 Nov 2005

thts human's weekness, old rish muni's who discovered AYURVED neva testes those plants by years of reasearch, they simply communicated not like we do, with plants.