Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Is wearing leather wrong? How about using animal skin for tablay skins??

Is wearing leather wrong? How about using animal skin for tablay skins??

SenghSational · 21 Oct 2005

WJKK WJKF I think Sikhi is a very unique religion as it is very...umm how do i put it; environmentally friendly lol. But,,, Is wearing leather wrong...eg; boots? By the way; "85% of black.....shiny leather [looking] boots are [actually] leather...." [source:Mintel Reports 1998: Page 17 'The Decline of Britain's Black Shoe Industry and Increase of Import Shoes'] At the end of the day.. by wearing boots and other leather materials we are increasing the demand for cattle skin,,, Althought some may argue; that it is dead animal skin;; one Sikh made a statement on the "eating dead meat" post... "How many dead sheep are you going to find? Will you stop their?" Similarly can be applied to Cows. Also I guess Tabla skin = cattle skin... hmmm... WJKK WJKF! [%sig%]

Re: Is wearing leather wrong? How about using animal skin for tablay skins??

London Vala Singh.... · 22 Oct 2005

lolll okk lets get one thing straight. most of pratan sikh instruments use chamra (skin) therefor personally dont see nothing wrong..

Re: Is wearing leather wrong? How about using animal skin for tablay skins??

Manvir Singh Khalsa · 22 Oct 2005

[gurbani]"nrU mrY nru kwim n AwvY ] psU mrY ds kwj svwrY ]1]"[/gurbani] "When a man dies, his body is of no use to anyone. But when an animal dies, it is used in ten ways. ||1||" [gurbani](mYƒ kdy soc hI nhIN PurdI ik mYN iks srIr qy mwx kr ky mMdy kMm krdw rihMdw hW, myrw Aslw qW iehI hY nw ik) jdoN mnu`K mr jWdw hY qW mnu`K (dw srIr) iksy kMm nhIN AwauNdw, pr pSU mrdw hY qW (iPr BI aus dw srIr mnu`K dy) keI kMMm svwrdw hY [1[[/gurbani] In India when an animal dies, the body of the animal goes to the "Chamaar" (leather-worker). The Chamaar (who works with "Chamraa" - leather/skin) deskins the dead body and takes it apart. He would use the skin for making instruments, shoes etc. The bones would be used for something else etc etc. The skin of cows is also used. Cows are considered sacred by Hindus, yet they use their skin. Is there something wrong then? No. Because the cow is not killed for its leather or skin, it dies and man utilizes it's body. So Hindus dont have a problem with using leather etc. It is a different issue if we are breeding animals and then killing them for merely using its skin for leather etc etc, which leads to other forms of abuse when the people who are incharge start compromising care and treatment of animals for making quick pounds or bucks. Hence many factory farms in UK and America have a bad record of over-crowing, cramp conditions and animals being crowded into cages. Hope that helps.

Re: Is wearing leather wrong? How about using animal skin for tablay skins??

Manjit kaur · 22 Oct 2005

this is a bottomless pit !! How to JUSTIFY Tabla skin..but DENY leather belt ?? NO LOGIC at all. Tablas have ben used all along..and we CANNOT LIVE without that....so we sheepishly say..thats ok..lah..lols..blah blah..but leather wallet ?/no..leather belt ? No ..leather shoes NO ?? The reality is even TABLAS do lead to DEMAND for dead cows ?? so what IF the cows are fewer ?? they are still dead ?? How about the MIaan of swords..dhaals of puratan sikhs ?? these were amde of LEATHER !!! such uselss types of arguments lead to schisms and hypocracy !! Either ALL NO - 100% or ALL YES 100%..no middle way about it is my motto. So if the GYANI/RAGI is OK with beating a dead cow skin for Kirtan..why cant I carry a leather handbag to Gurdwara ??...and the Ragi/Granthi is also going to distribute DEGH to everyone but i am NOT ?? so ?? mk

Re: Is wearing leather wrong? How about using animal skin for tablay skins??

singh · 22 Oct 2005

in olden days i think skin was taken from animals which died of old age, i dnt think sikhs killed animals for skin. killing an animal is bad, but isnt a kurehit, eating its meat is. meat is jhoot, its spiritually filthy if an animal died from natural causes, you canNOT EAT it.

Re: Is wearing leather wrong? How about using animal skin for tablay skins??

Manjit kaur · 22 Oct 2005

Author: Manvir Singh Khalsa Date: 10-22-05 02:54 [gurbani]"nrU mrY nru kwim n AwvY ] psU mrY ds kwj svwrY ]1]"[/gurbani] "When a man dies, his body is of no use to anyone. But when an animal dies, it is used in ten ways. ||1||" <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< I just sent in a NEW THREAD on this Tuk in Gurbani. It relates to a SINGH JI who DONATED his ORGANS, bones, Joints etc to Living recipients and SCIENCE. So He is USEFUL in DEATH..just like the Animals mentioned by gurbani above. Does this "negate" that " a Human is USELESS to anyone...??? Please discuss in new thread. MK

Re: Is wearing leather wrong? How about using animal skin for tablay skins??

Truth · 22 Oct 2005

Manjit Kaur==> it's a bad trait of a Sikh to doubt Gurbani.....eventhough you're only asking a question, the manner in which you are going about it is very disrespectful. about leather issue and tabla skins....well most tablas are made in india where it's more likely that the animal was not killed, but died naturally (again, i'm saying more likely, not so in every case ofcourse). factory farming leather is quite different from the leather used from animals having died a natural death....so there is a middle ground!!!!! the leather purse you love is most likely coming from an animal killed for it's hide..... the tabla the raagi uses has a good chance of coming from an animal which died a natural death.

Re: Is wearing leather wrong? How about using animal skin for tablay skins??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 24 Oct 2005

I DOUBT THAT many animals are DYING NATURALLY in India fro it to ber able to make Tabals/mirdungams/drums etc.... BTW many such drums also coem from other countries... INDIA is the WORLD LEADER in EXPORT of BEEF....90% of BEEF sold in malaysia is INDIAN.... and Muslims WONT eat flesh of DEAD ANIMALS>>>NO WAY LOL.... What do you think they Do with the SKINS ??

Re: Is wearing leather wrong? How about using animal skin for tablay skins??

Seaside Kaur · 24 Oct 2005

Due to news reports appeared in foreign media in Europe, America and Asia conceming the cruel slaughtering of dogs and cats in Thailand for domestic consumption, and the animals' skin are being exported. Moreover, some United States members of the House of Representatives initiated a draft bill " The dog and Cat Protection Act" to the House of Representatives and the senate. Should this draft bill become law, it may affect the export of Thai leather products to the United States. http://www.magma.ca/~thaiott/aniproblems.htm Chicken Leather. Ostrich Leather. Fish leather. Stingray leather. http://www.exoticleather.biz/ Leather Types When you look for leather types, you will hear two main terms, “Leather Hide” and “Leather Skin”. The difference is that hide comes from large animals and skin comes from small animals, generally weighing 15 pounds or less. Listed below are the various leather types you can buy. Types Of Animals Leather Comes From * Buckskin - This leather type is from deer and elk. The leather is soft, pliable, and naturally resistant to water. Although this type of leather is known to have blemishes, it is ideal for outdoor wear such as gloves and moccasins. * Buffalo - You'll find this leather type to be soft yet heavy. It is stronger than cowhide and features a nice grain pattern. Much of the newer motorcycle apparel is now being made from water buffalo as it is less expensive than cowhide. * Calfskin - This leather type comes from young cattle and is smooth and lightweight. The grain is fine, it wears a long time, and is available in a number of colors. Calfskin has a natural luster, making it perfect for jackets, pants, vests, and so on. * Cowhide - This also comes from cattle but is heavier and the most commonly used. Cowhide is very durable and strong. Additionally, many people like this leather since it can breathe, making it ideal for shoes, purses, and other accessories. * Goatskin - Many leather shoes and boots have goatskin for the uppers and linings. You will also find goatskin used for wallets, belts, and bookbindings. This leather type is available in numerous colors and is a nice leather. * Kangaroo - Yes, there is a Kangaroo leather that is softer than cowhide and one of the strongest lightweight leathers available. The texture is fine, making this a prestigious option, used often in the fashion industry. In fact, international soccer players typically wear soccer boots made from Kangaroo leather. * Lambskin - This leather type naturally comes in a number of finishes since the skins from different origins look different. Very lightweight with a nice, tight grain makes this a favorite of many people. * Ostrich - This leather type is the most commonly used of all bird skins. You can tell ostrich leather easily by the unique bumps on the skin. When buying genuine ostrich, expect to pay a hefty price. * Pigskin - This type of leather is very inexpensive yet tougher than cowhide. The dotted markings make the leather unique and is primarily used for purses, luggage, gloves, and other small personal items. * Reptile - This includes leather that comes from snakes, alligators, crocodiles, and turtles. This leather type has the scales, which gives its look and texture its characteristics. Depending on where you live, you will find that some reptile leathers are protected by law as endangered species. * Sharkskin - This leather type is made from a specific species of shark and primarily used for making belts, luggage, shoes, and fine leather goods. In most cases, you'll have a choice of brown and white or black and white and will find many of the pieces with small scales. * Sheepskin - This leather type is from an older lamb and heavier than lambskin although it is still soft and supple. The only drawback is that while beautiful, it does not hold up as well as cowhide and therefore used only for items not used every day. http://www.leathersecrets.com/index.php?page_id=4&article_id=18

Re: Is wearing leather wrong? How about using animal skin for tablay skins??

american singh sahib · 24 Oct 2005

Ironic to see "strict vegetarian gursikhs" such as those particularly of the akj who are so anti-meat to be especially using animal skin. How do YOU know if the tablas we play on are from dead animals. Puratan times, tablas were custom made, many times people would or the builder would go out themselves and find dead animals. Honestly, do you really think a place like Raj Musicals, or Jas Musicals when they have a demand for tablas go out to the jangla and find dead deer. YEAAA RIgHTTTT... B.S Leather shoes, belts, tablas, pakhawajs, mridangs, rabab, siranda, taus, dilruba...etc...etc... INSTRUMENTS USED DURING THE GURUS TIME! Puratan Times were different. You cant even attempt to say its all from already dead animals. I say, if your going to wear it or play it, you might as well be eating it and getting healthier too.

Re: Is wearing leather wrong? How about using animal skin for tablay skins??

Jasmin · 24 Oct 2005

Healthier is questionable. WjkkWjkf

Re: Is wearing leather wrong? How about using animal skin for tablay skins??

Iron Man · 24 Oct 2005

>>>How do YOU know if the tablas we play on are from dead animals. <<< I certainly hope they are dead, otherwise we would be hearing BAAAAAHHHH or MOOOO during keertan... not very good....