Forum
Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
London Singh · 22 Oct 2005
SIKHS IN THE SQUARE
...THE RALLY for SIKH AWARENESS, REMEMBERANCE OF NOV 1984 and the VIGIL FOR JUSTICE...
Organised by the Sikh youth for te whole community and supported by Gurdwaras, Sikh organisations and the Sadh Sangat.
Takes place SUNDAY NOV 6th 1.30-4.30pm AT TRAFALGAR SQUARE..
A benti to ALL Sikhs in and around the UK, a humble request is made for you to attend this rally in your numbers. Make your impact and come and share this day with other likeminded Sikhs who wish to remember the events of NOV 1984...
Pass the word on to other youth
AN EVENT NOT TO MISS!!!
Front and back of postcard:
Poster:
Posters in full size and further details can be found at:
[url=http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=14272&st=40]http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=14272&st=40[/url]
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
DS · 23 Oct 2005
What will you be doing on Sunday 6 November?
YOUNG SIKHS (UK) PRESENT SIKHS IN THE SQUARE
Thousands of Sikhs are expected to gather on Sunday 6 November in London to commemorate the November 1984 ant-Sikh pogroms and share with non-Sikhs the continued suffering and lack of justice for the tens of thousands of innocent Sikh victims.
For those of you that may be in two minds on whether or not to take part in the Sikhs in the Square event in Trafalgar Square between 1:30-4:30pm please read the testimony of Gurdip Kaur taken from 'We Share Their Agony-Sikh Women Victims of November 1984'
[On November 1, Gurdip Kaur, her three sons and her husband were at home. At about noon a mob of young boys attacked her home. Here is how she described the attack]
'Three of the men ran out and were set on fire. My youngest son stayed in the house with me. But they came into the house. Those young boys, 14 and 16 year olds, began to drag my son out even though he was hiding behind me. They tore my clothes and stripped me naked in front of my son. They raped me right there, in front of my son, in my own house. They were young boys, maybe eight of them.
After they had taken my honour, they left. I took my son to sit among the women but they came and dragged him away. They took him to the street corner, hit him with lathis, sprinkled kerosene over him, and burnt him alive. I tried to save him but they struck me with knives and broke my arm. At that time I was completely naked. I had managed to get a hold of an old sheet which I had wrapped around myself. If I had even one piece of clothing on my body, I would have gone and thrown myself over my son and tried to save him. I would have done anything to save at least one young man of my family. Not one of the four is left.'
It is the heart-wrenching experience of thousands of mothers like Gurdip Kaur that place a duty on us to NEVER LET THE WORLD FORGET 1984.
Please share the experiences of Gurdip Kaur with friends, family and the Sangat. This will help those who can spare a few hours on Sunday 6 November to highlight the continued lack of justice for the November 1984 ant-Sikh pogroms to the thousands of non-Sikhs that will be in Trafalgar Square and the millions that are likely to learn through media coverage.
Where possible share the personal testimony of Gurdip Kaur with the Sangat from the stage at Gurdwaras. Some may then feel a greater desire to take part in the Sikhs in the Square event and Gurdwaras themselves may feel obliged to arrange transport.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
JS · 23 Oct 2005
More information is available on.
http://www.youngsikhs.org/6thnov
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
singh · 23 Oct 2005
Please make every effort to attend. Many communities such as the Kurds, Black South Africans, Northern Irish and Eastern Europeans obtained justice because they made their voice heard.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
confused · 24 Oct 2005
With all due respect....
What will be achieved by gathering in large numbers and protesting?
By no means am I trying to say we shouldnt do anything nor am I saying we shouldn't educate ourselves and wider community about the above. But I have to ask after frequently going to the 84 March, what does this type of demonstration actually achieve.
How will the above event get any closer to the goal of justice? Theres got to be a more pro-active step we can take when we are collectivly here - I just dont see how protesting in such a way will do this
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
London Singh · 24 Oct 2005
India has failed to provide any sort of justice for what took place in 1984 so no matter what external pressure needs to br brought to bear on them. Demonstrations and protests raise awareness that yes these atrocities did occur and the more people know the more pressure the media and national government will apply on India. This isnt only a protest- Sikhs in the Square is organised by Sikh youth and will feature a candlelit procession in rememberance of our brothers and sisters that lost their lives in the Anti-Sikh pogroms of 1984, many iimportant speakers on stage discussing the events of 1984 and what the implications could be for the community and how other communities have also endured such atrocities and the steps they took, there will be many stalls and videos about 1984 on large screens to raise awareness. Oh yeah and free refreshments will be provided at the event for the congregation.
TS
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
amorphous_singh · 24 Oct 2005
confused wrote:
> With all due respect....
Ok - in that case .... I will respond to this oft raised point.
> What will be achieved by gathering in large numbers and
> protesting?
Well firstly it hightlight s the cause. It seems to have slipped out of peoples consciousness lately and one way to raise the profile and gather support is to create more awareness.
You agree that awareness raising is a good thing - right?
There is a whole generation who are unaware of such matters. I know many youngsters who are now more aware as a result of such events and they in turn bring others along with them.
To get any sort of action requires numbers and to get numbers requires awareness and rememberance. And lets not forget we should never forget these events.
So see you there and bring along others and get involved. Campaigns involve much hard work behind the scenes and these big events are just one focal point of ongoing campaigns. Please do join in - there is no time to feel "dejected" or "demoralized".
Chardi kala!
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Jagjit Singh · 24 Oct 2005
waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, I could not disagree more. There is alot of benefit in doing programmes like this.
- people will know more about Sikhs in general
- awareness of 1984 delhi riots which is essential
- more Spirit in Youth who are increasingly beginning to believe they can positively influence change through collective action.
- Media controls public opinion. Every community uses media to its benefit except Sikhs. For example, USA is now spending billions on media to create a passive version of Islam using Islamic media outlets including Al jazeera. Media has been used against Sikhs for decades, that why we have phrases like "Sikh extremists". Yet the genocide and terrorism happened against Sikhs.
- Media will only be interested in large events like this which engage the media. I hope the organisers select youth sevadaars who can effectively communicate with the media, especially have dastaar wearing youth Sikh bibians. We as Sikhs should have bibian spokespersons, they are much more media friendly, and you will not get allegations like we had at Behzti protests of middle aged men dominating Sikh affairs.
Leeds and Bradford Sikhs have already booked a coach for this event, and hopefully will attending en mass. I would encourage everyone to attend. Plus everyone should attend in Gurskhi bana, and also wear Kesri Dastaars!
Lastlly knowing the weather in London during November, I would encourage the organisers to make arrangements in case of bad weather.
waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
concerned · 24 Oct 2005
jus hope no-one starts burning India flags and burning effigies of Indira Gandhi.
1/ Burning flags or any objects makes Sikhs look like Palestinians and Radical Extremist Muslims - so you will lose sympathy from gore and non-Sikhs. No-one was to be associated to people who portray a negative impression to society.
2/ Burning an effigy of Indira Gandhi makes NO SENSE. Firstly, she IS DEAD. So why pretend she is alive and burn her. Secondly, if we wish to do this, then why don't we make effigies of Massar Rangar, Aurangzeb who did so much Tyranny and cruelty, Zakhriya Khan and General Dyre etc...
3/ Aggression used in an unproductive i.e. shouting slogans which don't use decent language (i.e. swear words or "not nice words") doesnt help the Sikh cause in any way. Again we want MPs, gore, and non-Sikhs to feel our pain, feel our needs, and then respond positively. By shouting Panjabi slogans you will not get much benefit, then shouting "Indira Kuthi" and "Badal Kutha" - is is necessary? "Nanak Fikaa Boleeya, Tan Man Fikaa Hoye".
Someone may argue that Sikhs are feeling the pain of the tyranny india has caused and hence the aggressive responses such as burning things or using bad language etc. However, Guru Gobind Singh ji's father, four sons, and family were made Shaheed by the Mughals. He lost his home, material wealth and slept in harsh weather conditions in the Jungle of Machiwara. What got to ask ourselves - How did Guru Ji respond to Tyranny?
Answer is ZAFARNAMAH. The letter of Victory. Despite the terrible loss and hurt, Guru Ji kept in Chardikala and wrote a positve letter. Not with swear words, not with bad language, but with the TRUTH - worded in an articulate and marvellous way. Reading the TRUTH Aurangzeb was shaken! Look at the power of Guru Gobind Singh Ji's pen! Guru Ji used the sword, and pen to respond tyranny.
We need to think how we are going to respond - and for this we need awareness of ourselves, awareness of surroundings and the situation.
I think the Candle-light vigil is a great idea. ANd wisht the UK Sikhs all the best in this event. Perhaps more of us should do this in our local Cities and where we live. Get members of parliament, and local politicians involved. Furthermore, the wider public will show solidarity through such an event and hopefully increase it's understanding on the plight and condition of the Sikh nation in India.
sorry if i've offended anyone.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
singh · 24 Oct 2005
'I think the Candle-light vigil is a great idea. ANd wisht the UK Sikhs all the best in this event. Perhaps more of us should do this in our local Cities and where we live. Get members of parliament, and local politicians involved. Furthermore, the wider public will show solidarity through such an event and hopefully increase it's understanding on the plight and condition of the Sikh nation in India.'
Lets turn this into an international event, it is bound to raise awarness worldwide. Come on Canadians, Americans, Australians and others let the world know what happened. Contact MP's, media and Human Rights organisations.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
* · 24 Oct 2005
i agree with everything 'concerned' said :-)
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
amorphous_singh · 25 Oct 2005
Dear concerned and *,
Come along and show us all how it should be done. Show us the positive side as opposed to the 'negative' side you mentioned; your presence would be most welcome and desirable.
Afterwards please write a long post like you did above about the positive elements, the awarness raising, about the 1000's of Sikhs who came together to neverforget and to continue the fight for justice and all the rest. It will be more accurate presentation of the vast majority of those present than the above post.
See you there ..... hook up with me there ..... I'll take your pic for free as well :-)
GurFateh
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Gurcharan Singh · 26 Oct 2005
Concerend if only other think constructively intead of being defensive ,Sikhs could better.I certainly agree with you.sikhs seem to be stuck at the 1984, point and do not seem to move on to make the community stronger, like in Zaffernamah.That Zafaafernamah caused AURANGZEB MORE PAIN THAN ANYTHING ELSE.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
... · 26 Oct 2005
i agree with 'concerned' as well ... the point he/she is making is that we must all actively ensure that there is no swearing and flag burning
even if there are many positive things happening in the event, a few people swearing or burning flags may steal the limelight, and end up reflecting very badly on the whole
the media will not be interested in the vast majority or the many positives - they'll only concentrate on the controversial few things
so let's all work actively to ensure that no swear word "naarae" are used, or flag burning
just my opinion - pls forgive if i offended any1
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
JS · 26 Oct 2005
LOCAL RADIO
Time to start publicising the event with your local radio station. Try and get them to do a discussion programme if possible.
AKASH RADIO
Sukhwinder Singh has agreed to provide FREE adverts starting in a couple of days time leading up to the Sikhs in the Square event. He has also agreed to provide FREE live coverage on Sunday 6 November between 2-4pm. This should allow Sikhs throughout Europe to listen on satellite and throughout the world on the Internet.
CANDLES
Please bring candles (big and small) for the Candlelight vigil. Birmingham youngsters have agreed to bring at least 1,000 candles - mainly for the use of non-Sikhs. Estimates of the number of innocent Sikhs killed in November 1984 range from 3,000 to 20,000. Our aim should be to at least light ONE candle for each innocent Sikh life lost in November 1984.
Other towns/cities sending coaches may also want to make a similar commitment as the Birmingham youngsters.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Singh · 26 Oct 2005
Why don't people realise that in the near future there is no hope for Khalistan or justice. Wake up and realise that the time to get justice was the years just after the tragedy. It has now been 21 years - the western world does not care. Concentrate on spiritual things because slogans of "Khalistan Zindabad" are now almost comical.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
simple singhani · 26 Oct 2005
i agree with concerned....good points..
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
#* · 26 Oct 2005
"the media will not be interested in the vast majority or the many positives - they'll only concentrate on the controversial few things"
assuming the media has been informed... or more importantly if they are going to even bother to allow it to air
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
??????? · 26 Oct 2005
I think that it is really good that you are doing this.... keep up the gud work...... as many sikhs need 2 come 2 trafalgur square and support eachother...... so dont be lazy and lets do something..... show everyone what sikhs are!!!
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
..... · 26 Oct 2005
i gonna be there :-)
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
extra concerned · 26 Oct 2005
agree with concerned... wait one min... isnt nagar kirtan on at same time in west london..
yes we see ekta once again with 2 events at same time.. how nice to see everyone working for ekta... NOT!!
media.. AKASH radio.. hahaha wow same radio station whos gyani did bedbi of guru granth sahib ji and whos owners are sell outs to GOI.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
TS · 26 Oct 2005
It amazes me how when anybody tries to do something contructive for the Panth- a few rather than support them or do something else constructive themselves would rather just sit at home and do nindiya. Before doing so let's not forget the event is in the memory of the 20,000 innocent Sikhs that were brutally massacred on the streets of Delhi.
I say shabash to the organisers and let's promote the event and encourage as many others to attend as possible.
It is only when our Panth stays in chardhi kalaa and organises such positive events to raise awareness that we ourselves can say that our conscience is not dead.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
JEEVAN SINGH · 26 Oct 2005
STOP MAKING STUPID COMMENTS !!
EVERY ONE JUST TURN UP IN THE MASSES !
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Jagtar Singh · 27 Oct 2005
Confused
Could you make some suggestions as to what we should do?
And if possible make it happen.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Jagtar Singh · 27 Oct 2005
Just for those thinking of burning any flags etc.
No activities are allowed in Trafalgar Square that will damage the Square (stone work) - this includes flag burning - this was confirmed after the June protest when the Trafalgar Square idea was discussed with the police.
Even lighting thousands of candles may cause difficulties, but we are working with the GLA to make this happen.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Jagtar Singh · 27 Oct 2005
Author: Singh wrote:
Why don't people realise that in the near future there is no hope for Khalistan or justice. Wake up and realise that the time to get justice was the years just after the tragedy. It has now been 21 years - the western world does not care. Concentrate on spiritual things because slogans of "Khalistan Zindabad" are now almost comical.
Guru Ji taught us to fight for the truth and for justice. If the the only purpose of Sikhi is to meditate and accept the will of God then what was the point of Guru Hargobind Ji building Akaal Takht?
The whole point is to fight for the truth while doing Naam Simran and following Sikhi.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
JS · 27 Oct 2005
As expected the people who have stayed silent or even supported the human rights violations against Sikhs suddenly find a voice to attack Sikhs.
All those doing Nindiya look at yourselves and say what have I done to help the victims.
All the anti Sikh types have been stunned at the thousands that have been turning up to demonstrationsin recent years. I bet that has got their paymasters worried.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Randeep Singh · 27 Oct 2005
good Work, see you there! :)
The Candle thing will be reallllyyy good, cos the public will be wondering WHY they doing candles... peaceful Brown Skinned people... instead of shoutin slogans here n ther!
good stuff
Wish the sevadars all the best!
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Concerned · 27 Oct 2005
My suggestions for preventing the possibility of hooligan behaviour, flag burning or burning effigies etc is:
1/ Write an article in Sikh Times, Des Pardes, Panjab Times etc highlighted the advantages and disadvantages of protesting. The benefits of protesting in a proper manner and how it can win hearts and raise awarness, on the other hand it can make the public turn their backs on us if they see us as a group of aggressive uncontrolled people (though it may be one or two youngsters causing the disruption).
2/ Ask Panjab Radio, Akash Radio, Raaj Radio etc to have discussion programmes raising awareness on the advantages & disadvantages of burning flags and letting emotions get the better of us. Also discuss positive ways of protesting, making a point to society and achieving Panthic goals.
3/ Ask Gurdwaras or go to Gurdwaras and do talks to the Sangat asking parents to take responsibility of their youngsters. If a teenager burns a flag or effigy, the parent should take responsbility for the child's behaviour. Parents must ensure to talk to their youngsters and discuss methods of protesting and what are the consequences of doing childish acts and the damage it can cause the Sikh community who are trying to achieve awareness and hopefully action on Panthic causes.
4/ Communicate with Sikh Societies in universities and colleges. Ask Sikh Societies to pass the message on students.
It should hopefully be a great sucess, and I hope the media does coverage of the event, unlike the London June protest in 2004.
Keep up the good work to all the organisers and helpers.
And to everyone else, please come along and show solidarity to the victims and to the Sikh Kaum.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
JS · 27 Oct 2005
This how the BBC covered the 2004 demo
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/3780105.stm
BBC Online
Last Updated: Sunday, 6 June, 2004, 16:19 GMT 17:19 UK
UK Sikhs remember Amritsar attack
Sikhs from across the UK have gathered to mark the 20th anniversary of the storming of their holiest shrine.
Communities and temples congregations met in central London to remember the Indian Army's storming of the Golden Temple of Amritsar.
The temple, which lies at the centre of the faith, was the scene of fierce fighting in 1984 as India's government sought to destroy Sikh militants.
British Sikhs say they still want the government to pressure India and the United Nations for a full investigation into the events.
Operation Bluestar
In June 1984, India's late former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi gave personal approval to Operation Bluestar.
All we say is let the truth come out - let people in the community judge what happened
Jagtar Singh, Sikh Federation
The objective was to flush out militant Sikhs who were fighting for an independent homeland in Punjab.
Bluestar achieved its military objectives - but its costs were enormous. Although there has never been any agreement on the numbers killed, Sikhs say thousands were massacred by Indian troops, many of them innocent bystanders.
The military action led to Mrs Gandhi's assassination later that year by her Sikh bodyguards. That in turn triggered a wave of anti-Sikh rioting which left nearly 3,000 dead.
Jagtar Singh of the UK Sikh Federation, said the arrival of a new Indian government, now led by a Sikh prime minister, had given hope to the Diaspora that the truth could eventually come out.
Sunday's march and rally in central London, which was expected to be attended by a number of MPs and London mayoral candidates, included demands on the British government to pressure Delhi to open up the episode to full international scrutiny.
"This temple is the holiest of holies," Mr Singh told the BBC. "And while trying to flush out a small number of militants, the Indian army killed enormous numbers of innocent pilgrims.
"During the operation there was a complete media blackout in Punjab. But 20 years later and the blood still cannot be washed from the marble floors."
Mr Singh said that while the attack had shocked Sikh communities around the world, it had also led to a reawakening of identity.
"People [in the UK] who had drifted away from their faith start practising it again," he said. "India actually laid the foundation stones for an independence movement and a more aware Sikh community."
Hopes on new PM
He said British Sikhs were hoping that the new Indian prime minister Manmohan Singh would open up the past to "put the record straight".
He was already recognised as a "straight politician" - but the community wanted to see him act as an "honest man".
This could be done by allowing Amnesty International, the United Nations and other organisations fully investigate the events of 1984.
Sikhs campaigning over the Golden Temple attack have long enjoyed the support of many MPs and they want more pressure put on the Foreign Secretary to speak out over what happened.
Mr Singh said: "All we say is let the truth come out. Let people in the international community judge what happened."
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Not confused · 27 Oct 2005
Totally agree with the positive comments made-
Instead of listening to the negative slander of the congressia that would prefer to forget what happened let's focus on what actually happened-
Thousands of our own Sikh brothers, sisters, mothers, fathers, daughters, sons, grandparents and defenceless babies were beaten, killed, raped and burned with tyres around their necks and their corpses were left to be eaten by dogs in the street...
At least OUR consciences will be clear and we can sleep ok at night.
Together if we stay positive we can make a difference!
So let's attend in massive numbers and raise awareness of what happened in the Anti-Sikh Pogroms of 1984
SL
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
singh · 29 Oct 2005
Only on week left until Sunday 6th Nov, please make all arrangements to attend.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
mmm · 29 Oct 2005
This is one of the many disadvantages of living in Scotland....London is too far!!
And although the youth are willing to organise programmes here, the older gursikhs have pointed out that personal rehit must be a priority over and above any other programmes.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Jagtar Singh · 30 Oct 2005
Author: mmm wrote
This is one of the many disadvantages of living in Scotland....London is too far!!
And although the youth are willing to organise programmes here, the older gursikhs have pointed out that personal rehit must be a priority over and above any other programmes.
Please organise events at the Sottish Parliament (lobby) or candlelight vigil in Edinburgh - Young Sikhs (UK) and Sikh Ferderation (UK) have UK in their title and will do what they can to support you.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
British Singh · 30 Oct 2005
It took around 100 years after Guru Gobind SIngh to break free from the Mughals, and get real justice. The Panth went through all sorts but never gave up, and eventually established raj. That was the undying attitude of the SIkh's then which was fruitful. However sad little people today seem to loose hope simply after twenty one years, says allot about how chardikela they are, ie not very.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Jagtar Singh · 30 Oct 2005
Sikhs in the Square - Publicity on the radio
Panjab Radio
Tonight (Sunday 30 October) the Sweet Sikhi programme in English between 7-8pm will highlight the Sikhs in the Square event on Sunday 6 November. The Panjabi programme between 8-10pm will also feature the Sikhs in the Square event. They may play the sound from the 13-minute preview of The Widow Colony, which will have its first UK public showing in Trafalgar Square next Sunday.
Sky Digital - Channel 880
Internet: NOT SURE as now on DAB Radio
Raaj Radio
Gurjit Singh will also be covering the Sikhs in the Square event on his programme tonight (Sunday 30 October) between 7-8pm.
Sky Digital - Channel - 891
Internet: www.raajradio.co.uk
You may want to ring in urging both radio stations to be official sponsors of the Sikhs in the Square event and demonstrate their support for the Sikh youth.
We need to get across to all concerned that
'Our youth is our future'
Akash Radio
The discussion programme on Wednesday 2 November between 8-10pm will highlight the Sikhs in the Square event. Akash Radio may also play the sound from the 13-minute preview of The Widow Colony to be shown in Trafalgar Square.
Akash Radio has agreed to provide adverts free of charge for this event by the Sikh youth. The adverts are expected to start on Monday (tomorrow). They are also providing 2 hours free live coverage between 2-4pm from Trafalgar Square on Sunday 6 November.
Sky Digital - Channel - 918
Internet: www.akashradio.com
Please send text messages to your friends regarding the programmes on Panjab and Raaj Radio.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
singh · 01 Nov 2005
November 1, 1984: An eyewitness account
There was a glint of madness in their eyes and murder etched across their faces. Ominous shouts and cries of "Koi Sardar hai? Goli se maar dalenge" (Is there any Sikh? We will shoot him) followed. We were all shocked into a state of stunned numbness.
I was a journalist working with a leading magazine, The Illustrated Weekly of India. A Sikh myself, I was travelling with a group of 20 Sikh friends and family members to Delhi for a wedding. When we boarded the train from Calcutta at 10 am on October 31, 1984 we had never imagined that death and destruction were in store for us.
It was at 12.30 pm that we first heard that Prime Minister Indira Gandhi had been shot by her bodyguards and was in hospital. Our instant reaction was one of disbelief. The confirmed news of Mrs Gandhi's assassination reached us over the radio at about 6.30 pm. And it was only then that we learnt that the two assailants were Sikhs.
Every passenger, irrespective of his or her religion, was in a state of shocked silence. But not one anticipated the disaster that awaited us at Ghaziabad. The train reached Ghaziabad (two hours from Delhi) at 11 am the next day.
That was the beginning of two harrowing hours for us, when we were suspended between life and death. A bloodthirsty mob, almost like a pack of hungry wolves hunting for prey, went from coach to coach in search of Sikhs. In a frenzy of madness the mob, armed with iron rods and knives, brutally dragged out Sikhs, burnt their turbans, hacked them to death and threw them across the tracks.
Even the old and feeble were not spared. However, the mob, devoid of rationality, declared that women would be spared. But in what sense were they spared? After all, what could be more torturous for women than seeing male members of their family hacked to death in front of their eyes?
The only Sikhs who were spared were the six with us. And all because of the concern and cooperation of the passengers in our coach. Before the train even halted at Ghaziabad, the hysterical mob had caught a glimpse of the six Sikh men with us.
A fusillade of stones followed and the glass windows were smashed to bits. Shutters were hastily put down for protection. The police, we were told, could not control the wild mob and so they just turned their backs and walked away. We had a ladies' compartment and the other passengers in our coach, realising there was more trouble ahead, suggested that the Sikh men in our group occupy it.
At first, they were reluctant but we literally forced them to stay inside. It was ironic. Sikhs, who were historically known for their valour, now had to protect themselves by hiding in a ladies' compartment. Two ladies were sent into the ladies' compartment so they could answer if any questions were asked. The main doors of the coach were locked from inside and we waited with bated breath. The mob was not to be deterred. Then it began.
They pounded on the heavy metal door for over 15 minutes. The incessant pounding was accompanied by threats to set the train on fire. One non-Sikh passenger shifted uncomfortably in his seat and felt that all of them would lose their lives, but he was sternly reprimanded by the others who declared that under no circumstances would the door be opened.
But the mob finally broke open the door. Their violent mutilation of the train had only whetted their appetite for more destruction. The mob stormed into our coach and walked past the ladies' compartment. But before we could even sigh with relief, they turned around and demanded that the door of the ladies' compartment be opened, so they could check it.
By now, our nerves had reached breaking point. We tried to convince them but the mob was adamant and began to bang on the door. They seemed to grow suspicious at the sight of a number of women outside the ladies' compartment and pointing towards us asked the other passengers, "Are these women travelling alone?"
"No, they are with us," came the quick reply. The other passengers couldn't have been more cooperative. The petrified screams of the two ladies from inside, our pleas and the persuasion of the other passengers finally seemed to convince the mob that there were no Sikhs inside. The mob retreated.
We hoped that conditions in Delhi would be better. But no security arrangements had been made at the station. As a result there were more than 500 Sikh men stranded in the waiting room, while the women left the station to make arrangements for them.
I left the station at 3 pm with the women in our group, while the Sikh men with us -- who were the only ones on the train to survive the disaster -- waited at the station. They removed dead bodies from the train and assisted the injured. By 8 pm we had been successful in making arrangements for them to be taken out of the station.
In a state of stupefied silence, I saw bodies of Sikhs, with rivulets of blood streaming down their faces, being unloaded from the train in which I had travelled. Brutally battered bodies of Sikhs reached Delhi from other incoming trains as well. Innocent people who had done nothing wrong except for being Sikhs and travelling towards Delhi on that fateful day.
That was 21 years ago.
Please take part in the SIKHS IN THE SQUARE event on Sunday 6 November 2005 between 1.30-4.30pm in Trafalgar Square.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
KS · 02 Nov 2005
Coaches have been booked from all over the country, check with your local Gurdwara/organiser for details. Not long left until Sunday, weather is going to be good.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
JS · 02 Nov 2005
After ’84 riots they are now fighting drugs
New Delhi, November 2
Widows walk down the narrow steps to a gurdwara basement gallery where walls are crammed with pictures of their loved ones lynched 21 years ago as young men wander outside in clusters with zombie, glassy looks.
Blazes of colour flashed into the sky as neighbourhoods marked Divali but it was a day of mourning for women at Tilak Vihar as they remembered the dead in the 1984 anti-Sikh riots.
At Gurdwara Shahidan, they prayed not just for the lost ones but for many of the second-generation survivors driven to drugs and crime.
Narcotics, they say, have swamped the rehabilitation colony, home to thousands of young unschooled, jobless men.
“We lost people from our generation in 1984, and are losing our children to drugs,” said Bhagi Kaur as she knelt down at Gurdwara Shahidan during a special service to mark the 21st anniversary of the carnage.
On November, 2, 1984, mobs burnt Bhagi’s husband Lachchman Singh alive a day after they lynched her three brothers in their Tirlokpuri home.
Her son Balwant Singh committed suicide last year because of depression from being jobless.
Colony elders say they are struggling with a second battle — drugs — after a “failed” legal quest for justice.
“For these young drug addicts, supply is not an issue. You can find them all time popping red and blue pills or sniffing smack outside Gurdwara Shahidan,” Gurdwara vice-president Hakam Singh said.
One of the addicts, who requested not to be named, said most of the fellow addicts would buy large quantities of painkillers from local pharmacies. “It’s just an overdose for a kick,” he said.
Residents say many young addicts have also taken to petty crimes to make up for drug costs.
“They steal cables, car stereos and even outdoor water pumps. Many of them are pickpockets,” Surjit Singh, a Tilak Vihar resident, said.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
TS · 02 Nov 2005
To Forget Is Fatal
A few committed men keep the fight alive to bring the culprits to book
SHEELA REDDY
Gurcharan Kaur's trophies are displayed on a high shelf in her two-roomed home in East Delhi's Trilokpuri: four daughters in their bridal finery with their grooms. But for the 55-year-old widow who has single-handedly raised seven children with a measly pension of Rs 375 and the earnings from a teashop she opened in her verandah, supplemented now and then by free rations from the gurudwara, the best trophy so far is her youngest daughter. Ravinder, 20, is working her way through college and will soon be the family's first graduate. Gurcharan waits for the smiling young girl to leave the room before recounting the events of November 1, 1984, when her husband, Naik Teja Singh, was butchered and torched by a mob outside their newly-built home. "It's OK for me to remember," she says stoically, pulling out her husband's photograph from behind a curtained enclosure, "but I don't want my children to be affected."
This motherly urge to shield her children from the horrors of the 1984 anti-Sikh pogroms sometimes has the spokesmen for the Sikh community fretting. "The younger generation of Sikhs scarcely know (or want to know) the events that culminated in 1984," says an editorial in The Sikh Review, a community journal. "It's spineless to forget what happened," agrees Patwant Singh, best-selling author of The Sikhs. "The Jews haven't forgotten till now, why should we? Even some gurudwara functionaries ask the victims to lay off (filing complaints against the killers)."
But it's simply not fair, as advocate Harinder Singh Phoolka points out, to shift the entire burden of bringing the guilty to book onto the widows and children of the riot victims. "How can you expect a poor widow from a small colony to give evidence against the culprits? She has enough on her hands trying to earn a living for herself and her children without having to pursue court cases and face intimidation by policemen and politicians. There is a difference between forgetting and helplessness. If they are helpless, it is not their failure but society's."
Twenty years later, the collective 'forgetfulness' is leading to new inequities: while the Sikhs have risen to be India's richest community, the families of the estimated 2,733 pogrom victims in Delhi are almost all below the poverty line. The reason: most of the Sikhs butchered during the pogroms were the only bread-winners in the family, leaving behind widows and children who fell—are still falling—through the cracks. Phoolka's 25-year-old employee, his driver Gurpal Singh, is one example. At five, Gurpal watched his father and two uncles being slaughtered by mobs. With his mother receiving only Rs 10,000 from the government in compensation, Gurpal couldn't afford to go to school. Even the gurudwara committees, which used to give scholarships and rations to the victims' families, stopped helping after a few years, forcing Gurpal to take a job as soon as he was able. "Delhi's gurudwara committee employs a staff of some 2,000 but even they prefer to give jobs to relatives rather than the children of the pogrom victims," says Phoolka, who is fighting a case for a pogrom orphan who has been refused a job in the gurudwara committee's many institutions.
Phoolka is among the few who refuse to forget. As secretary of the now-disbanded umbrella organisation of human rights activists, Citizens Justice Committee, the senior advocate in the Supreme Court has been fighting ceaselessly to nail the culprits of the 1984 pogroms. "At that time," he recalls, "I thought it would take no more than four or five years. The kind of material we were getting I had no doubt that the killers would be brought to justice." Phoolka has still not lost faith—relentlessly pursuing cases, encouraging the demoralised, and reassuring the intimidated.
"I am not doing it for the Sikhs—our turn is over and won't come again for at least another 50 years. I am doing it to uphold the rule of law, to make sure that there won't be another Gujarat or Jhajjar."
In November 1984 youngsters like us watched Singhs and Singhnia, Gurughar, businesses, homes, etc. all burned to the ground- so everyone let's attend the events organised across the world in remembrance.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
JS · 03 Nov 2005
Please bring candles for the No84 vigil
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
!!!!1984!!!!! · 03 Nov 2005
I know it's mentioned already but please do not make this in to a event in to another "Bhezti play" , ot typical 1984 demo where you have hot heads jumping up and down on effigy of indran ghandi , or a burning turanga . That is not good the impression we wanna be givien to the rest of the world, are we a bunch of "hot heads" ??? If any one is coming to this event withthe intention of doing any of the above your better off staying at home. We should raise awarenss by distributing litreture, and using the media, cadle light vigils appeal to peopel in the west .
**thugs and jokers plese do not attend**
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
TS · 03 Nov 2005
has been discussed already- this is not a protest demonstration it is a candlelight vigil and awareness-creating event. The point is you can only affect change in the world by taking part in such positive events and encouraging others instead of doing negative things to do likewise. If you read the previous posts you can see there will be candlelit procession in rememberance of our brothers and sisters that lost their lives in the Anti-Sikh pogroms of 1984, many iimportant speakers on stage discussing the events of 1984 and what the implications could be for the community and how other communities have also endured such atrocities and the steps they took, there will be many stalls and videos about 1984 on large screens to raise awareness. Oh yeah and free refreshments will be provided at the event for the congregation. So attend in your thousands and remember the tragic events that occurred in November '84
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
anon · 03 Nov 2005
i think this demonstarion is gna bring nothing to us. like last year it happnd bunch of sikhs gathered up and personally i think they done our besti. burning stuffd dolls of indihra ghandi acting like hooligans. sure fine we should make aware of our presence but at what consequince. plz gurmukh piyiario if u go protest peacefully act like a tru gur sikh not like badmashs
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
nindo nindo... · 03 Nov 2005
Nindiya is easy for anonymous haters but i have the utmost respect for those who put the hard work into organising such events. Not sure if anon bothered to read the previous posts but as stated previously this is the FIRST event of its kind and i hope we see more and more of such events!
Actions speak louder than words
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
dsingh · 03 Nov 2005
WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH
PLEASE RECORD THE MARCH FOR INTERNATIONAL SANGAT TO WATCH THANK YOU
WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
NS · 04 Nov 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh
Very surprised at some of the comments from people on this forum and thread. Just think for a minute Adolf Hitler in his hay days when he was so powerful but did he ever attack the vatican!!?? No...
But In India anything can happen and the world woudn;t even know about it this is pure brahminical thought process. Chandar Shekkar has been quoted as saying we could kill 500000 and the world wouldn't even notice.
Now it's up to the us to turn up and show the wider world of who we are and what has happened to us and why.Because if we don't then how would you look at your self in the mirror and call your self Sikh /Khalsa of Guru JI.
I work in London and yesterday at Lunch one of the Amensty International reps approached me.I gave him the run down on how Amensty International is banned in India...the reasons why..told him of the Sikh event. He assured me he would be down with a few more on the event. It took me about 20 mins in a nutshell to explain to this guy who we are, why we are and what has happened to us. His response was postiive and he even took down my mobile number case he gets lost. What surprises me most that educated Sikh youth that mention on this forum to keep quiet, it's not worth it what 's the point, how ignorant can one be , shows no brotherhood in us at all.. like it does in Muslims.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
singhni London · 04 Nov 2005
India is nark on earth
i found out today my cousin sis from a pind in jullander has been kidnapped taken to delhi and maybe sold, the family are devasted, my mamaji is searching everywhere for her.Shes been missing for a month and a half. i just cant believe how things are there. makes me weep inside.
vaheguru
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
SL · 05 Nov 2005
The event takes place tommorow
NOBODY should be sat at home so let's ALL across the world attend such events that have been organised in HUGE numbers.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
KS · 06 Nov 2005
The day has arrived see you in Trafalgar square at 1.30pm, this event will bring the Nov 84 massacre of Sikhs to peoples attention
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Confused Khalsa · 06 Nov 2005
Event was brilliant, especially Roop Singhs talk. Its a shame about the weather though, apart from that brilliant day.
Well organised and planned.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
a singh...! · 06 Nov 2005
PHOTOS : http://www.ektaone.com/PHOTOS/2005/sikhsinthesquare/
VIDEO OF ROOP SINGH SPEECH : http://www.ektaone.com/video/sikhsinthesquare/BhaiRoopSingh.wmv
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Interested Singh · 06 Nov 2005
Hey,
I heard that the rally was great! If anyone can give specifics about what happened, what was talked about, and who was there, i would be very appreciative! I just wished there would have been something like this in every country!
Thx
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
NS · 06 Nov 2005
A Singh Jeeo.
Many thanks for putting up the links now that is sharp.....may this event give other Sikhs around the world to wake up and orgnise such events in their host countries too.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
amorphous_singh · 07 Nov 2005
The whole event was recorded - professional camera crew who were fully hooked up with the control room.
It is hoped to produce a DVD of the event.
Some pictures up at
http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=14272
(go to pages 13/14 of the thread if you want to see just the pics).
The event was a great success - thank you to everyone who made the effort to turn up.
The weather might have been awful - but the Sikh Spirit was sky high!
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
jsr · 07 Nov 2005
Just checked the pictures, looked OK, not many people, and the weather was rough.
Maybe the weather was a sign to not do the function on Sunday, who knows, my view is that it should'nt have took place, its OK and everything but what would we acheive from shouting and standing in the rain, what should have been done is an akhand part or raensbai. No one will every forget about 1984, especially me, a lot of our people died, but that is history, we should leave it alone now.
bhul chuk marf.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
cant belive ittttttt · 07 Nov 2005
I would b more impressed seeing Panj tyar by tyar singhneea.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
A Singh · 07 Nov 2005
Gur Fateh!
The event was indeed excellent and well delivered, credit goes to Amporheous Singh for being the driving force and all the Sevadars and Sangat on the day.
The opening speech by Roop Singh set it sailing and the those that followed by the Canadian Bibian were well scripted and well presented.
Glad to see the focus remained largely raising sikh awareness and the issue of Human Rights and predominantly that too from the youth.
Gur Bar Akaaaaallllll!!!
A Singh.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Young Sikhs!!! · 07 Nov 2005
Pic 191 is my Favourite LOL!!!!
Hope the rally was a success despite the typical british weather.
Well Done!!
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
JS · 07 Nov 2005
A very successful event, the impressive stage , the films , the speaches just excellent. This is the way people will find out about the Sikhs, can't wait until the next one.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
M S Nijjar · 07 Nov 2005
Yes Pic 191 on EktaOne lol - Bhai Amrik Singh Ji Gill!!!! - I thought their speech towards the end was very good and encouraging, the way he encouraged the youth was quite powerful!!!
The event was a proper success and I think the organisers behind the scene deserve a big thankyou from everyone!!!
Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!!
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
amorphous_singh · 07 Nov 2005
> The event was indeed excellent and well delivered, credit goes
> to Amporheous Singh for being the driving force and all the
> Sevadars and Sangat on the day.
A SIngh - thanks you for the kind words - but I am not worthy of such a comment.
There was a core group of organisers who all worked very hard to pull this off and that is where all credit should go.
It was a team effort and everyone worked amazingly hard to get everything organised.
But as always at the end of the day it was all down to Mararaj's Kirpa.
So please credit where credit is due - one day I hope to worthy of the amazing SIkhs I see all around me today in the UK and further afield and the great Sikhs of our yesterdays and if I can even live up to be 0.01% of what they are and were then I will be a most fortunate person.
Gurfateh
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
,,, · 07 Nov 2005
JSR - u just made the most stupid comments. By what you've written, you obviously weren't there!!!!!! The pictures don't do full justice to the turn out.
The lower section of the Square was almost full. And there were Sikhs all along the side. There definitely were hundreds and hundreds of people, perhaps even a couple of thoussand. Yes the weather was very bad - but the whole Sangat stood resolutely to remember the thousands that died.
There was absolutely no shouting and empty standing. The organisers did a grand job in organising this. All credit to them.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
amorphous_singh · 07 Nov 2005
jsr wrote:
> Maybe the weather was a sign to not do the function on Sunday,
> who knows, my view is that it should'nt have took place, its OK
Good job we didnt listen to you.
> and everything but what would we acheive from shouting and
> standing in the rain, what should have been done is an akhand
> part or raensbai. No one will every forget about 1984,
> especially me, a lot of our people died, but that is history,
> we should leave it alone now.
Leaving it alone (your words) is forgetting it. We shall not do that.
No one, none of us is ever going to say don't do Akhand Path's, hold Raeinsbhai's etc; we all get behind and attend and join in.
This event was a complement to these; it raised a hell of a lot of awareness and captured whole sections of society that might not have been made aware.
It's always those who don't attend, don't join in who stand around moaning.
I'm going to quote from the final speech of the day:
"We all hope you have learnt something and that you have felt the Sikh Spirit present here today; knowing that it will not go out; that it can not be extinguished.
It also means that you should leave here today knowing that more needs to
be done; that it will require concerted efforts by all of us to work
together to bring the guilty to justice."
So join in and please do don't forget to organise plenty of programmes and to publise them and to invite everyone along. I will not belittle your efforts or make inaccurate posts about it. Go for it - nothing is stopping you.
It rained - we went on.
It rained - the sangat still turned up.
It rained - the rain stopped in time for the vigil and we went ahead with it.
Looks like someone wanted us to carry on with the event and to complete it.
No one can extinguish the Sikh Spirit. Especially not those who can only carp from the sidelines.
Gurfateh
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Jaskaran Kaur · 07 Nov 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
The whole event wasss justt awesome. Loved it into bits. It was justtt too fine to define. On top of that Ardaas killed it. It got me into tears. Enough respect for everyone andd Waheguru aswell who blessed his sikhs with high spirit even tho it was really bad weather. Waheguru...
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
MSB · 07 Nov 2005
WGKK WGKF
I agree to an extent.
Erm,... what did the event acheive? I think your wrong about the whole "shouting in the rain"... no one was really shouting.
If Maharaj wanted the event to go well with weather prevailing etc, the weather would have been wicked. Like someone pointed out to me -- on Vaisakhi days, even when its raining to start off with, the weather improves so much towards the end.
not being funny, but the Young Sikhs "lot" have spent months trying to organise this event. . . but where was the proof?
Heres a few factors to consider.
1. A massive screen on display, truck stage, pro camera crew... all outsourced to a company using money which was raised "behind the scenes".
2. T-shirts were standard. Black n white. Nothing different. Sant Jarnail Singh jee bhindrawale on t-shirt as usual.
3. Banners and pickets. Seen them before. No new material made.
4. Candle lighting... some material on the floor... with candles.. bought from a shop. most likely contained animal fat and whatever other stuff they use in these things.
5. There werent really any non-sikhs around who stopped to take notice of the event. Looking at the photos and that, you will see that too.
6. A well organised event would have had rain in mind and had some sort of covering or tent on standy which would have MUCH improved the event.
7. No leaflets.. no information on Sikhi or even the whole Operation Bluestar before n beyond was distributed. i got a calmness in the rush cd one and a keep on walking music album leaflet, but that was about it.
8. They ran out of langar and asked coaches to help. This should have been in a tent anyway - where sangat could have sat down to enjoy Guru Ka Langar.
9. They could have chosen one of the GurSikhs to lead the ardaas.
10. Could have done some simran with everyone - would have been totally amazing and uplifting.
11. Expected to see some more WELL KNOWN politicians.
--
Ok heres the positives
1. Most speakers were good. I agree - Roop Singh was great and had everyone gripped to the stage.
2. The lighting on stage was good - probably by camera crew.
3. Most videos and powerpoint presentations were professionally done.
Apologies if anything i said causes offence to anyone. Just something maybe the "Young Sikhs" could consider in future before organising such an event.
ALSO: May i ask... there was BBC logo on the poster... but where were they? Its not a "dig", a serious question. Also, i dont think it was covered by any news channel? Also, will this be shown on BBC then??
Forgive my mistakes.
Gr Br Akaal
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Ravinder Kaur · 07 Nov 2005
MSB wrote:
> WGKK WGKF
>
> I agree to an extent.
>
> Erm,... what did the event acheive? I think your wrong about
> the whole "shouting in the rain"... no one was really shouting.
>
> If Maharaj wanted the event to go well with weather prevailing
> etc, the weather would have been wicked. Like someone pointed
> out to me -- on Vaisakhi days, even when its raining to start
> off with, the weather improves so much towards the end.
>
> not being funny, but the Young Sikhs "lot" have spent months
> trying to organise this event. . . but where was the proof?
Not being funny... bur did you not see the huge trailer/screen/videos/set up/speeches/tents/leaflets//…etc? Just SOME proof of the work was in that, did you not see the amount of Singhs and Singhnia in Maharaaj's Sikhi roop fill the centre of London… Guru Saahib themselves in the form of the Panj standing TALL in TRAFALGER SQUARE? Not being funny, but did you not see images of our Guru's projected on the Big screen for all to see?! Proof was there Jee.. all you needed to do was have the eyes to see it.
>
> Heres a few factors to consider.
>
> 1. A massive screen on display, truck stage, pro camera crew...
> all outsourced to a company using money which was raised
> "behind the scenes".
>
I suppose you were in the thick of it behind the scenes, knowing who was controlling what etc? I also suppose you stayed at the end, and helped clear up? I suppose, you've also had a good look at the costs and accounts and seen how the money was raised and was needed for the event.
> 2. T-shirts were standard. Black n white. Nothing different.
> Sant Jarnail Singh jee bhindrawale on t-shirt as usual.
Funny thing is... YS seem to have sold a HECK of a lot of these "nothing different" T-Shirts... I suppose those fools that bought them knew nothing... why on earth would I want a "nothing different" T-shirt with the image of the greatest Sant Sipahi of the 20th/21st Century on it? Why would they want to wear their wounds across their chests in stating "WE JUST WANT TO LIVE FREE LIKE THE REST OF THE WORLD".. Silly people.
>
> 3. Banners and pickets. Seen them before. No new material made.
>
Message was simple Jee, NEVER FORGET 84 - why need new banners EVERY TIME? I suppose you were the one who had the BIG HUGE BANNER to show the world of your wounds of 1984? Arh yes, must have cost a lot to have made? Or was it a home made job? Either way, good job that you thought of it, cos you know, you had a message to display and you did it? Oh Sorry no, that wasn’t YOU, that was someone who had a little more passion?! I suppose YOU played your part by making this post?!
> 4. Candle lighting... some material on the floor... with
> candles.. bought from a shop. most likely contained animal fat
> and whatever other stuff they use in these things.
And let me guess? You know of the shop which sells "kosher" candles, or you make them???! You also helped by bringing some with you? You know, cos the wounds of 1984 are so deep in your heart that you wanted to share that pain with others, and walk, with a candle in your hand, begging Guru Saahib, for this light lit only by a candle to pervade throughout us all.. and help us all see the jot that will ultimately bring freedom and justice to the brothers and sisters of 1984?
>
> 5. There werent really any non-sikhs around who stopped to take
> notice of the event. Looking at the photos and that, you will
> see that too.
Yes... and I suppose the 3000 leaflets distributed to non sikhs within the 1st 2 hours was nothing also... funny thing is, non were found on the floor, or in the bins. I suppose if only 100 of those 3000 were to stand up and take notice... well it's just not good enough, is it? Cos I am sure you spoke with the non Sikhs at the event and told them of your woes, and the injustices against your people. I'm sure you made our plight topic number one? You actively sought out non Sikhs and said, “Excuse me….”
>
> 6. A well organised event would have had rain in mind and had
> some sort of covering or tent on standy which would have MUCH
> improved the event.
Of course the organisers were mindful of the weather... but it was A, the first event, from which they will learn and secondly, showed immense Sikh Spirit in that Sikhs stood tall, come rain or shine, they stood there, and remembered our Shaheeds... hold on, a little rain is not going to stop us - thousands of our family were killed in 1984, we're not going to begrudge a little rain, and we’re certainly not going to moan about it on a message board!
>
> 7. No leaflets.. no information on Sikhi or even the whole
> Operation Bluestar before n beyond was distributed. i got a
> calmness in the rush cd one and a keep on walking music album
> leaflet, but that was about it.
Yep. Again, you paid great attention... funny thing is, I collected a whole host of leaflets on the day - would you like me to send you some, I could make you some copies?!
>
> 8. They ran out of langar and asked coaches to help. This
> should have been in a tent anyway - where sangat could have sat
> down to enjoy Guru Ka Langar.
Errr... maybe Mr MSB you should contact the GLA about Langar.. something that sadly was out of the hands of the organisers... still, I didn't see it run out, in fact I remember my father having some at the end, I seemed to remember a few patila fulls of sholay - very nice they were too.. again, don't think you looked hard enough.
>
> 9. They could have chosen one of the GurSikhs to lead the ardaas.
Well, Guess next time they should ask you Mahapurukh Jee. One thing, Guru Jee CHOSES who they want in their Five... not us... Didn't see you there?!
>
> 10. Could have done some simran with everyone - would have been totally amazing and uplifting.
Indeed, if you were standing by the vigil, when Singhs and Singhnia were doing Simran, you may have heard it... or do you not have the ears to hear either?
>
> 11. Expected to see some more WELL KNOWN politicians.
>
Join the organising committee, and next year you can invite them along? Eh? Good idea methinks!!
> --
>
> Ok heres the positives
>
> 1. Most speakers were good. I agree - Roop Singh was great and
> had everyone gripped to the stage.
>
ALL speakers did a FANTASTIC job, and credit goes to each of them for having the courage to stand up in front of the sangat and show that the wounds of 1984 are as painful today as they were then. You all did SIKHI proud.
> 2. The lighting on stage was good - probably by camera crew.
Credit goes to those Gursikhs who turned up early to set up stage!
>
> 3. Most videos and powerpoint presentations were professionally
> done.
The YS sevadhaar behind this knows who they are - what a great seva Guru Maharaaj bestowed upon you, may his grace continue.
>
>
>
> Apologies if anything i said causes offence to anyone. Just
> something maybe the "Young Sikhs" could consider in future
> before organising such an event.
Like I said, next year we'll invite YOU along. Seeing as you know so much about negativities, maybe we can avoid them.
>
> ALSO: May i ask... there was BBC logo on the poster... but
> where were they? Its not a "dig", a serious question. Also, i
> dont think it was covered by any news channel? Also, will this
> be shown on BBC then??
Watch This Space?!
>
> Forgive my mistakes.
>
> Gr Br Akaal
Mr MSB, please take a moment and think about the event, with eyes of love, and ears no longer wanting to hear the pain of our shaheeds.... think of the effort that must have gone into an event like this, and thank Guru Saahib that their Grace was upon those Gursikhs who felt it their duty to put forward this event.
Lastly, I ask you... if you think you can do better, DO IT! Don't just post on a message board, SHOW YOUNG SIKHS HOW IT IS DONE!
You're obviously SUCH A KNOWER.. Then please, show how affected YOU are by the wounds of 1984, and TELL US what YOU are doing to make a difference... posting under a pseudonym does not do you justice.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Jathedar Gurgian Singh · 07 Nov 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
MSB your comments are totally out of order and show no respect nor do they show any appreciation for the effort that had been put in!
I am not a member of Young Sikhs UK, however, I realise to plan an event in 4 weeks is VERY HARD and CANNOT be knocked, especially when it was done with PYAAR and HUMILITY, something that you are obviously lacking in!
You Said:
>1. A massive screen on display, truck stage, pro camera crew... all outsourced to a company using money which was raised "behind the scenes".
Whats the point of this comment? Has no relevance WHATSOEVER and is completely absurd.
>2. T-shirts were standard. Black n white. Nothing different. Sant Jarnail Singh jee bhindrawale on t-shirt as usual.
The t shirts WERE effective and because of them, they raised awareness. I know that a few non-sikhs were asking about them and the man that was on them (Sant Bhindranwale)
>3. Banners and pickets. Seen them before. No new material made.
There was plenty of NEW material, LARGE SCREEN, TRAILER, STAGE, ringing any bells? Open your eyes GURSIKHO!
>4. Candle lighting... some material on the floor... with candles.. bought from a shop. most likely contained animal fat and whatever other stuff they use in these things.
Yet again, what was the point of this inconsistent comment? How else would it have been viable, other than to lay down FIREPROOF Material REQUIRED BY GLA (Greater London Authorities) ????
>5. There werent really any non-sikhs around who stopped to take notice of the event. Looking at the photos and that, you will see that too.
Before the event there were ALOT of Non-Sikhs that were asking questions and that were VERY interested. During the event there were ALOT of non-Sikhs asking questions and AFTER the event there were ALOT of non-Sikhs paying their respects and also giving their condolences. Why not LOOK around FIRST and then make a statement!?!
>6. A well organised event would have had rain in mind and had some sort of covering or tent on standy which would have MUCH improved the event.
No one can know Maharaj's khel and the weather is just that, Maharaj's khel. His Beauty! However, someone made the implication that the weather was a down fall and that even when there is a Nagar Keertan at Vasakhi the sun comes out. Do not forget that the day was about Shaheeds, if we cant stand in the rain for a few hours. If we're going to complain about the rain and that is going to deter us from remembering our Panths Soormay then SHAME ON YOU! OH "GREAT GURSIKHS OF THE GURU"
Well Done, I Salute You and your mentality!
[Please note the above was said with SARCASAM!]
>7. No leaflets.. no information on Sikhi or even the whole Operation Bluestar before n beyond was distributed. i got a calmness in the rush cd one and a keep on walking music album leaflet, but that was about it.
Once again, you did not do thorough research before mouthing off. Leaflets were handed out and were VERY SUCCESSFUL and raised ALOT of awareness for the NON-SIKHS!
>8. They ran out of langar and asked coaches to help. This should have been in a tent anyway - where sangat could have sat down to enjoy Guru Ka Langar.
The GLA required a food certificate from the providers of the food to certify that food can be distributed, as it was GURU KA LANGAR and was provided from the Gurdwara they were unable to distribute Langar in the Tents set up at the sides! Please Note, Gurdwaray are NOT required to have these certificates!
>9. They could have chosen one of the GurSikhs to lead the ardaas.
The ardaas was done with much love and was done by Guru Sahib through HIS PANJ SINGHS! If you cant see that then you must BLIND! The Panj were there the to represent the first Panj of 1699 and did the seva with Guru Sahibs Kirpa, I have a feeling you werent giving the opportunity to Serve Guru Sahib, chalo, some people just don't have the Kirpa! Well done to the two Pehredar Singhs too, they did well for being of such young ages!
>10. Could have done some simran with everyone - would have been totally amazing and uplifting.
I heard some simran during the vigil... if you wanted to do some simran then you should have either: gone to the organisers and requested or started it yourself as a "GURU KA SIKH"
>11. Expected to see me more WELL KNOWN politicians.
If you actually took an interest in Sikh Polictics then you would have known the politicians to speak were of a very high calibre and took time out of their busy schedules to represent and give their postive input!
MSB, what you have said shows no love, no unity and ALOT of arrogance. You have not caused offence because the TRUE GURU KA SIKHS are above that! They are TRUE and follow TRUTH and SEE TRUTH! Unfortunaltly YOU are NOT one of these! Before you hide behind computers posting on forums, think with humility in your heart, with love in your eyes and naam in your mind....and you will see that whatever was done yesterday was done out of humility, with love and with Guru Sahibs Shaheeds and the Naam of Akaal in Mind!
Wake up dude...
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
"Jathedar" Gurgian Singh
ps. its GUR BAR Akaal not Gr Br.... Learn Santhia!
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Sikh Int in the Fed of Youth!! · 07 Nov 2005
'Yes Pic 191 on EktaOne lol - Bhai Amrik Singh Ji Gill!!!! - I thought their speech towards the end was very good and encouraging, the way he encouraged the youth was quite powerful!!!'
Hope he didn't encourage the youth to join the I Sikh Y Federation, because they are the biggest numpty's in th UK. I have heard him speaking loads of times and the words Very good and encouraging and quite powerful, umm how can I put it DUHH!!!!!
I just hope the youth actually wake up and realise that they do not need these people in thier midst because if they do want them then alot of Gursikh youth will not join them period!!!
But top marks on the organisation, Well done again and MSB made some good points, please take them in mind when organising another event. Some good literature, not too political and about Sikhi can do loads of parchar.
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
amorphous_singh · 07 Nov 2005
MSB wrote:
> If Maharaj wanted the event to go well with weather prevailing
> etc, the weather would have been wicked. Like someone pointed
> out to me -- on Vaisakhi days, even when its raining to start
> off with, the weather improves so much towards the end.
Actually it did improve toward the end. It stopped in time to start the vigil.
I'm told it rained during the Southall Nagar Kirtan as well. Glad they carried on!
No wonder it's always a case of one step forward and two steps back. It is never possible to please some people;
we can't control the rain,
I'm sorry if the T-shirts with Sant Ji on them are just too "standard" for you;
I'm sorry we couldnt get a giant tarpaulin and have 4 helicopters are each corner holding it over the Sq to keep the rain at bay, maybe we could suggest that idea to the cricket authorities the next time a test match is rained off,
I'm sorry that the lighting was good - even if it might have been a camera crew,
I'm sorry that we were not able to build out own giant screen with out own hand and using light bulbs purchased from the local DIY shop, but had to hire one,
I'm sorry that there was a camera man, we did try to polish our own lens and to stick some film in a metal can and call it a camera but we just weren't very good at the whole DIY camera thing,
I'm sorry that young, fit, healthy Sikhs are "turned off" by the rain.
And above all I'm sorry that we couldnt please you. I'm sure we'll try really hard time next time; and I'm sure someone will tell us of all the things that were "wrong" before they do anything else.
And I'm sorry that I had to write this reply. Really really sorry.
This event was probably the first of it's kind in the UK, it's the first time I can remember a giant screen in Traf. Sq with images of Sikhs and their struggles being projected on to it. None of us claim to be experts in organising and implementing this kind of event and we were all learning as we went along.
We were just trying to do our best by doing some seva, I'm sorry that it was not good enough for some of you.
If any mistakes were made on the day then we ask for forgiveness and that we learn from our mistakes and take things forward positively.
Bhul chuk marf karni
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
MSB · 07 Nov 2005
LOL
criticism - brothers, sisters... learn how to take it.
Ravinder Kaur Rai, please dont take my comments to heart. For they are speaking personal opinions. I do not force them on neone. You have tried to reply back to these and i respect that, however, lower the tone.
Not everyone sees things the same way. I saw the event in a different light from others. I dont think you should be givin' it large like you are doing to someone who is offering you constructive criticism. And we are all sangat here - there shouldnt be any secrets or anything. Its easy to say "you should talk to us directly" however, i find that forums and public discussions have more of an impact rather than just e-mailing these thoughts.
You do your events, rKr, expecting rave reviews like you and your crew do a lot on other forums. You expect glory, praise... and you can easily say on here "nahi, Guru jee is everything, and we are not worthy" speech like you give but thats not really the case (IMHO).
Its always good to have someone there who can offer you criticism. You expect too much dhan dhan. You ALL should be coming on the forums and having a go at those who big you up so much for they are providing you with ego. They are fuelling your ego. They are doing you more bad than good, in the short and long runs. My opinion has seemed to ruffle your feathers, so to speak, and thats actually a good sign. It means next time you will think about them things to prove me wrong. You will have that drive to prove the critics wrong. If everyone began to say how fantastico the event was - the next time, its more likely for you to lay back, and just keep it the same. But you need a drive. You need criticism. You need a passion to make each event not only different... but better.
If we were in Satjug, yes... all posts on all forums would be bigging you up. You would not have any haters. But you're not. This is a dark age.
Once again... forgive my mistakes.
Thank you to the Singh who taught us that little bit of santhiyaa. We have taken santhiyaa though. If you want to go more into it, you should say its "Gur Bur Ukaal" - it is more closer to the correct pronunciation. You are the jathaedhaar though... we are just saevaks of the True Guroo. I also apologise for any spelling mistakes appearing in this post.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
niiiiiiiiiice · 07 Nov 2005
The event was awesome- it was fab to see Sant ji as well as the events of '84 on the big screen as it really opened our eyes to our history- forget the haters that wish every1 was like them- sat at home, not bothering to do anything about the Pogroms of 1984 and whinging when anyone else does.
W e l l D o n e
:)
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
jsr · 07 Nov 2005
there will never be khalistan, or a sikh country, we have punjab, this is our homeland and heritage, we should be proud,
a lot of work must have gone into this event, well done
bhul chuk marf --- so overall, what REALLY have we acheived????? apart from ---- ""it raised a hell of a lot of awareness and captured whole sections of society that might not have been made aware""", this is not really a 'concrete' acheivment.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Ravinder Kaur · 08 Nov 2005
MSB Jee...
There is a lot that didn't work with the event, and we realise that, however, there was A LOT that DID work. And like I said earlier, how about YOU do something positive instead of posting on this board and show us HOW IT IS DONE?!
Constructive critcism is good, and like I said, organisers will take it all on board, but you're wrong in thinking they will lay back next time, cos you see, there will BE A NEXT time. And I have NO DOUBT that you will be the first one NEXT TIME to point out all the negatives.
Like I said, look with the eyes of Love and you would have seen a lot more than you did. Chalo...
If you think people's praise bumps my ego, I can only apologise and do ardaas to Maharaaj Dhan Sri Guru Granth Saahib Jee and beg them to make me the dust of the feet of his Gursikhs like you.
I don't wish there to be secrets, I am saying, it's easy to sit behind a computer screen with donning your BKI jackets etc, but it's actually harder to go to Maharaaj and ask them, BEG THEM to give you the kind of seva it takes to try and remember our shaheeds... A bit of contructive critcism from your sister here - Get out from behind your PC and SHOW US HOW IT IS DONE?!
> You do your events, rKr, expecting rave reviews like you and
> your crew do a lot on other forums. You expect glory, praise...
> and you can easily say on here "nahi, Guru jee is everything,
> and we are not worthy" speech like you give but thats not
> really the case (IMHO).
The only glory we expect is for Guru Saahib... for people to say Guru Saahib's meher was upon us, their grace was prevelant, there Gursikhs were one. IMHO Jee, you don't know anything about me to know if it is easy to say "Nahee Guru Saahib does everything!"
>You need a passion to make each event not only different... but better.
Like I said, next year, your seva of this event will be paramount in making it better, do you dare to walk the walk? You so clearly like to talk the talk?!
> You would not have any haters. But you're not.This is a dark age.
Funny thing is, I thought the post was about SIKHS IN THE SQUARE, not about hating someone personally... I see it all clearly now. Thank you JEe.
If any of the sangat feels that either myself personally, or the sevadhaars behind SITS have ego's and did all wrong, then we can only ask for forgiveness. I accept that I personally have a LOT wrong with me, and not out of humility but again out of ego beg for your forgiveness. You are our sadhsangat and our Guru's roop and we can only do as our Guru Saahib sets us to do. When we truely believe that "MERAE HAR JEEO SABH KO THAERAE VASS" then we would realise that all in the event was down to one, AKAAL.
I apologise for my many, many mistakes.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Taus Premee · 08 Nov 2005
People seem to think Akal Purakh is some sort of weather-man, what bizaree views we have of our formless, all loving, all knowning creator of the World. Uncle Gill Ji's speech spoke of solidarity, he was proud that in the dark, cold, rain we all stuck together and had a wonderful time. So now we equate 20cel. weather, blue skies, and not a cloud in sight to 'good' and dark, rains to bad? I didn't realise sikhs thought in black and white situations, I think of it as even if it rained on the day who cared? It didn't stop us or the hundreds of people from coming down and showing their support, whatever the weather, whatever the situation it is never in redemption..we are taught to live in this natural world..and as per that silly point about the Nagar Kirtan weather, well bhai sahib there was a Nagar Kirtan in Southall that same day and it was reported to me that the rain cut half of their usual crowds..Where I used to live every time it was Guru Nanak Dev Ji's Gurpurab the weather was so foul, sometimes it would even snow and it would shock people that snow in November and that too in such a hot place, we always thought it was amazing..rain or shine we sikhs stick it through, hot or cold we keep going..these things are nothing, it's about 'MORAL COURAGE' as one speaker said..
A Gursikh should have done the ardas eh? That is below the belt, didn't realise you were Maharaj and can judge people..that young Gursikh Singh touched the whole sangat with this powerful ardas, may Guru Ji continue to bless him..and to all those amazing Singhs who if you were backstage could hear them doing vaheguroo jap the entire time they were standing on stage (!!) it was so touching and uplifting..
The entire programme was done so professional, it was on time and organised, a rarity for most Sikh programmes. Also, it was said that there were not enough BIG POLITICIANS. Is it our fault that you don't read the papers? SIMON HUGHES is the Liberal-Democrat party PRESIDENT (!), I'm sorry we couldn't get Mr. Blair & President Bush for you..
It is fine to be critical but to say you're doing it to push the organisers for a better one next year, again I must ask are you on some Sant level? The problem with the world these days is that they don't complete the 'learning cycle', after an event, an achievement/pursuit..there must be recognitiona nd appreciation..the critiques were pointed out by some of the organisers already; the sound failed for a few seconds and so on..but to go as far to say a Gursikh should have led the ardas or essentially the event shouldn't have happened due to the weather is outrageous..anyone can see the hard workd put into this and the amazing result at the end of it..Also, we too had langar near the end of the event and it was in abundant, perhaps you don't know the full story and don't know what we went through to even have langar(!) so please stop making assumptions..
It is sad that there are debates actually happening about this, perhaps it is indeed annoying people to see that Sikhs of all groups (jatahs, ages, sexes) CAME TOGETHER on stage, in the crowd and stuck it through and made the event a success, perhaps it scares people to see solidarity..well it's coming so watch out!
Moral courage is certainly so rare in the world..
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
,,, · 08 Nov 2005
JSR - you just displaying your ignorance again and proving that by making ridiculous claims
Khalistan wasnt even mentioned - it was only to remember the shaheeds, and that's what it was all about
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Daas · 08 Nov 2005
Ummm i hear a lot about these events and see the pics etc, but for me its amazing that many weren't even born when this all happened, I was in my teens and remember a much darker period of our history, yes we can remember the shaeeds as we do in our ardass, but we must also remember that this period was one of despair and heartbreak for many including hindus/muslims/sikhs - HUMANS.
Its amazing to see all this youth in bana etc and wearing the old Sant Ji t-shirts but how much do you really know about that period, personally I feel a lot of the bad things that happened within our own panth have been covered up and hid under the carpet. These leaders that come to these events are the biggest joke that the panth have, the have destroyed grass root sikhi for my generation by making the guru ghars nothing but pawns in their political power struggles. Where there should have been parchar of Gurbani, simran, kirtan all we had was gymns in the gurudwara being used my monea to pump themselves up for the day of election so that they could punch innocent sevadars.
If we continue to paint a picture of greatness on an era that was far from it, we are nothing buy hypocrites, shouldn't the events of that era be pointed out good or bad, I remember when a train was stopped and all the innocents massacred, what was their sin ??? what was their paap ??? nothing other than there religion, we sons of Dhan Guru Tegh Bahadur ji who sacrificed his life for the protection of the another dharam carried out the same badmashis the indian government did, we can argue war is war but we cannot change sikhi to suit us.
Lets be realistic, what is needed now is parchar for youth around the world and foremost in punjab. Sikhi has to be from the inside, we can all put on a bana and dress up but the bana is nothing if there is nothing but an empty vessel behind it. The only way the pandea will be cleansed and filled with Naam is through gyan, paath, sangat and least but not least nimarata. We must learn to accept criticism, our critic is our best friend. There intentions maybe selfish but there words are a reminder to us that our egos love the inflation and must be bought down to a puncuterd ballon if they are to be eradicated.
Again continue these events but don't live in blind faith, Sant Ji was not perfect, others of that period were not perfect, no one is perfect other than Guru Ji, please forgive my ramblings but I felt that I had to write this if only to remind myself of where we should be going.
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa, Vaheguru ji ki fateh.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Harpartap Singh · 08 Nov 2005
Its the spirit with which criticism is given which is important - seems like many of those making negative points did not intend it to be constructive.
As with so many things - its easy to be a ''sher' on a forum and slag off others. The downside is you don't realise how mmany oother peoples minds you poison....
I think the commemoration was an excellent attempt considered it was put together in only 4 weeks. For those with all the sarky comments - you should either put up or shut up!
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
gabroo · 08 Nov 2005
the few negative comments that have appeared above really do reflect the negativity in the hearts of the writers as the comments are derogative, discouraging to the effort makers and generally typical of the 'panjabi mentality' of saying nothing but exaggerating any perceived 'badness' they could possibly squeeze out of something.
typical.
no doubt organisers will ignore the destructive criticism. criticism is not helpful unless it's constructive. perhaps the posters above should take THAT as some constructive criticism of their posts.
_________
I suggest that sewadars in question should also launch a random event of a similar structure, to mark the spirit of sewa and love. your skills and experience now should allow you to run a similar event to further share these qualities. automatic parchar will be done during this too. no doubt the self-proclaimed critiques will find fault with this too though hehe.
but aside from parchar, what a wonderful sewa this would be.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
True facts · 08 Nov 2005
I think this shows that Sikhs truly have not matured ....any criticism should be taken at it face value.
It does NOT matter if it is constructive or negative, it should matter that the response be still postive even in the face of negative criticism.
I beleive it is called ....PR.....if anyone has not heard.
I see someone made a negative critcism , every one of the "organisers"I beleive jumps upon the band wagon and gives a defensive response.This is NOT PR.
A negative criticism should be seen as strong enough for ssomeone to take an interest and write ,therefore the response should be responded in a way,that should note the concerns and point out the GOOD effects and strengths of the event.
Instead , very sensitive peopl are responding point by point irrespective of the severity and maturity of the complainant .....talk psotively, reassure the complainant that next time it will better as their critical analysis will help to make better.JUST END IT THERE INSTEAD OF GIVING IT MORE AMMUNITION, and bad publicty.
I suppose this will now be respinded by the same sensitivities.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
amorphous_singh · 08 Nov 2005
True facts wrote:
> I think this shows that Sikhs truly have not matured ....any
> criticism should be taken at it face value.
>
> It does NOT matter if it is constructive or negative, it should
> matter that the response be still postive even in the face of
> negative criticism.
If the facts as presented are inaccurate, then should they just be accepted at face value?
> I see someone made a negative critcism , every one of the
> "organisers"I beleive jumps upon the band wagon and gives a
Well you see - as far as I am aware only myself and RK Bhenji - who were both involved with the organising have responding. Others who were involved have not responded. So how you can claim that "every one of the organisers" is "jumping on the band wagon" is beyond me,
Should this inaccurate comment of yours be taken at face value?
> A negative criticism should be seen as strong enough for
> ssomeone to take an interest and write ,therefore the response
Or it can not be taken in that way; especially when it is inaccurate.
> should be responded in a way,that should note the concerns and
> point out the GOOD effects and strengths of the event.
The latter have been pointed out.
> Instead , very sensitive peopl are responding point by point
It's not about sensitivities, it's about accuracy,
> irrespective of the severity and maturity of the complainant
> .....talk psotively, reassure the complainant that next time it
> will better as their critical analysis will help to make
I believe this has also been done. Maybe you didnt read my earlier post. If not I apologize once more for mistakes.
> better.JUST END IT THERE INSTEAD OF GIVING IT MORE AMMUNITION,
> and bad publicty.
But you couldnt even follow your own advise.
> I suppose this will now be respinded by the same sensitivities.
I decided to respond instead of respinding; as I wasnt sure if the latter was permissible or even possible.
I'm told that good PR is about presentation. That might even include using words that actually exist. Oh it was a simple typing mistake? Please do accept my apologies in that case.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
amorphous_singh · 08 Nov 2005
I would just like to apologize for the tone of my previous reply. Digs about typing esp. from a moorakh such as me are unacceptable.
I don't know what came over me.
If there are genuine points to respond to I will; otherwise I'll keep mum.
For any mistakes made bhul chuk marf.
GurFateh
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
manjit kaur · 08 Nov 2005
FANTASTIC!!! enjoyed all the whole of the programme so did my family encluding our 72 yr old gran! ROOP SINGH was brill as ever!!
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Stay Positive!!! · 09 Nov 2005
I just want to say that the program was FANTASTIC. Don't be disheartened by a few negative posters on here. The tone in which they criticise is very vindictive - they cannot claim they are trying to offer constructive criticism or feedback.
All the organisers - stay Chardikala - I'm the vast vast majority of the sangat is very appreciative of your efforts. :)
The only thing I would like to offer feedback on is that there were hints in the final speaker that there would be another such programme in the Square next year. Personally, I think a program in the Square should only be a one-off event held every few years - otherwise there is the danger that such an event could lose its uniqueness. But that's only a personal view.
Please forgive my mistakes.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
NS · 09 Nov 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh
Just read all of the above and it I can only summarize in quotes below:
" If you don't like something, change it. If you can't change it, change your attitude. Don't complain."
"All change is not growth, as all movement is not forward. "
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
sL · 09 Nov 2005
lets see MORE similair events EVERYWHERE-
let the world NEVER forget the holocaust committed on Sikhs
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Jagjit Singh · 10 Nov 2005
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, I am a bit surprised at coments above so I will give an example of something that happened that day.
We had two coaches and one mini-bus from leeds and bradford. They left about 7.30am with many families and even young children. They got caught in traffic and reached Trafalgar Square at 2pm. As you can see a very long journey, especailly for young children to sit in the coach.
I met them in London, as I came down one day before, because of work. The event was a good start, I thought. Yes, we can improve and it rained. But it does rain in Uk, and for a first effort I think the organers did really well. Each year it will get better and better.
Then we left at 5pm on the coach. The mini-bus left about 20mins before us. On the way to the M1, there was an accident in front of us. As a result we were stuck in a standstill just outside London for 3 hours. The minibus was in front of accident so reached Leeds about 9pm.
We were stuck and rapidly running out of food. Rajvinder kaur, myself and another young lad, at one point even had to run from our coach to local shops to get bread for langar. Eventually the Police turned all the traffic around, and we went on another route.
We reached Leeds at 12.15 am. To the sangat credit, not one sangat member complained, no kids were crying. After reading this, and thinking these kids were in that coach from 7.30am and got home at 12.15 after midnight. Yet not one person complained, so why are Gursikhs here complaining about rain, organisers, etc.
We do have to get in the habit of being constructive. rather than complaining or taking digs, practically do seva to make events better.
Just my view... I hope new groups like Young Sikhs stay in Chardi kala!
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
a.s.b · 14 Nov 2005
it should,nt have happens, and the proof why guru ji did'nt want it to happen is that it started raining, if the almighty wanted us to have the programme, there would have been sunshine. lets not protest like this again, and do an akhand part or kirtan to remember victims who died, and what happend in 1984. sikhism is a peacfull religion.
also, there will never be khalistan, we have got the punjab
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Jagjit Singh · 14 Nov 2005
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare a.s.b jio, If you stayed inside everytime it rained, then you might aswell just become a hermit. To make a judgement on the will of God, based on whether it rains, it is nothing more than superstition, the very thing Sikhs should be free of.
Why are Sikhs so afraid of creating awareness of Sikh issues? I think we need more events like these.
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
JS · 15 Nov 2005
Staying inside your house will do nothing. Did the Gurus stay at home? Did they say do nothing when you see injustice? Of course not, so why asb do you keep saying the same thing?
So the Punjab in which 250,000 Sikhs have been killed is something to be proud of?
Wake up!
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
simple singhani · 18 Nov 2005
i totally agree with JS and.. jagit singh! stay chardikala! we deffo need more events like this!! we need to raise awareness. people dont even know who sikhs are! if u wanna sit at home and b called muslim.. then thats up to u..but i dont think thats the right attitude.
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
AVTAR · 21 Nov 2005
Payre a.s.b,
Khalisatan will be . you can forget or do not want to remember what happen to sikh, what about our guru granth shaib? our guru was murdered.
and yet people like you say you do not want khalistan.? Shabas to the organizer to such program. Guru kripa kereh. Khalistan Zindabad.London Singh wrote:
Re: Sikhs in the Square, 6th November, Trafalgar Square
Gupt · 30 Nov 2005
The vids for Sikhs in the square can be found on www.ektaone.com (roop singhs speech) and the remaining videos on www.neverforget84.com