Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Kes Keski compromise

Kes Keski compromise

Kulbir Singh · 24 Oct 2005

Sometime ago, we had an opportunity to visit an inter-religion meeting organized by a local education board. We were asked to verify information on Sikh faith that the board had collected. There was one more Sikh organization representing Sikhs there. Both Sikh organizations (us and the other one) sat on one table. We wanted Keski to be one of the 5 kakaars but the other organization was insistent on Kes. We kept doing vichaar and soon enough they did not have any answer to the valid and logical questions raised by us but they vichaar continued without any solution in sight. Then a compromise was suggested. It was suggested that the fifth kakaar would be called not kes and not keski but "Kes with Keski". The other organization readily accepted this and so did we. Can this be the possible solution to this issue. Let there be one less divisional issue in Panth. Kulbir Singh

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Seaside Kaur · 24 Oct 2005

This moorakh that thinks Kesh is a Kakkar likes the suggestion a lot.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

DDT · 24 Oct 2005

it seems weird but it may work. i personally beleive kes is the kakkar but i also try my best to wear a keski at all times(starting to wear it when i sleep 2). i think the comprmise should work. and those that dont beleive that keski is the kakkar like me should try to wear keski at all times aswell, because it makes u a tru tyaar bar tyaar sikh.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

SS Singh · 24 Oct 2005

Good one. This way both parties can be satisfied.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

ssingh · 24 Oct 2005

wala!

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Iron Man · 24 Oct 2005

its a good compromise and I have heard it before, but doesnt that mean theres 6 kakkars?

Re: Kes Keski compromise

dsingh · 24 Oct 2005

perfect solution,there's way too much fighting in the panth.brothers and sisters we need panthik ekta.we need a strong sikh nation,not one that fights over things.i know some people will say that rehit is something of the upmost importance,i agree 100%.but is there really any amritdhari sikhs(atleast men)who dont wear keski,even though they believe that kes is a kakkar.so they may believe kes is a kakkar,but they still wear keski,so their not breaking any sort of rehit.so i hope everyone will agree to the kes keski compromise.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

NS · 24 Oct 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh Kulbir Singh Jeeo,don't you think this is the wrong place to ask that question , ask the autuhority AKAL TAKHT.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

J singh · 25 Oct 2005

The only reason why the koum pressured kes as one of the five kakaars, is because by that command, it allows one to be called a "practicing to be sikh" without the need of keeping hair. But must we lovers of Gurmat be fooled by this claim. Without keeping your hair no spirtual gain can come. This is the first thing any "practicing to be sikh" should already have. Now consider this, my "kes as kakaar" brothers and sisters. If a man or woman who shaves there body completely everyday, and at the same time considers themselves a sikh, comes to an amrit sachaar to get amrit. The panj must be able to supply all the kakaars to the abhilaake. Do you now see the bigger issue here. without the 5 kakaars one cannot take amrit. Hair must be grown. Guru sahib gives you the 5 kakaars as a gift when becoming khalsa, can one honestly say they are 1/5th khalsa already, by simply saying they keep their hair? By keeping your hair it proves that you have now accepted akal purkh's hukam of being a human, a manukh, that he formed. In no way or fashion does that make you a sikh. It only makes you more human then anything else. Im not even an akj and i believe that Keski is the only 5th kakaar, please i do benti to all, Lets stop promoting this false maryada.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

gabroo · 25 Oct 2005

when Guru's Sikh sit together, look how well an agreement forms.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Zorawar Singh · 25 Oct 2005

The simple things in life are the best things...

Re: Kes Keski compromise

..... · 25 Oct 2005

excallent suggestion Kulbir Singh

Re: Kes Keski compromise

||||| · 25 Oct 2005

Will not work, stick with Kes why should we change it for AKJ.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

..... · 25 Oct 2005

Vah Vah 'seaside kaur'.. wot a responce... forget ekta..we truly need more 'mooraks' like yourself... Who needs the RSS when we got 'seaside kaur'..to divide the panth

Re: Kes Keski compromise

#'][}[=-)("!¬``?/>,,..,< · 25 Oct 2005

it seems weird but it may work. i personally beleive kes is the kakkar but i also try my best to wear a keski at all times(starting to wear it when i sleep 2). i think the comprmise should work. and those that dont beleive that keski is the kakkar like me should try to wear keski at all times aswell, because it makes u a tru tyaar bar tyaar sikh. tru say i still fink it kes tho kes the 5th and moctimportant kakar without which the other four are useless and how does tht make ne1 a "moorakh" so r u sayin every1 tht sez kes the kakkar is a "moorakh" coz great gursikhs lyk Sant Jarnail Singh Jee Bhindrawalae and Sant Kartar Singh Jee Bhindrawalae and Sant Gurbachan Singh Jee Bhindrawalae said kes is the kakkar.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

..... · 25 Oct 2005

can i just appologise to 'seaside kaur'... i re-read ur post & ACTUALLY understand what you've said.... Sorry bhenji please forgive this moorakh

Re: Kes Keski compromise

agyani · 25 Oct 2005

can some1 please show me a pic of a keski :) thx

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 25 Oct 2005

Fantastic a WIN-WIN situation for BOTH sides. jarnail Singh

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Great! · 25 Oct 2005

Wicked way to do it!! I believe in both! But i have keski rehit! i treat them both as kakkar coz to em they are!! Just as important as the other!! Ie, kesh is your hair, a gift from birth! and keski covers it! which we are meant to do anyway!! and is practical as protects your kesh!! the same as the other kakkar, practical!! therefore in a way, i jst treat them both the same!! to me though, you should wear a keski, even if you dont see as kakkar, my non keski rehitwale wear a keski neway!! the only time it leaves the body tho is when they comb their kesh in effect ne other time, its on their head or around their waist (when washing kesh) but i think the solution is wicked!!

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Singh · 25 Oct 2005

Any compromise which reduces the rehit should not be entered into. However this one does not, so it should be considered, but carefully. Do the Kes supporters realise that this means they will have to encourage everyone who takes Amrit from their various jathas to wear a keski? Will even taksal accept that? The youth may, but elders will never. Many years ago, Birmingham Council of Gurdwaras ceated a guidelines for schools about Sikhi bana. It this booklet they wrote the 5th kakkar as Kes/keski with a picture of a bibi with a keski. I think this was a very positive move, because everyone should be promoting Dastaar. But this was before Rode federation took over, who have never done anything positive for anyone. One point with compromises is that all Gursikhs should remember the last time a compromise was done was Raagmala. At that time, most of the Panth was against it, and it was not allowed according to the SRM. But then pro-raagmala people said it should be in the Guru Granth Sahib ji, and no one should print one without. Everyone agreed with this because if someone wanted to read it, then can, and if they do not, then fine aswell. But now they have taken this compromise so far that they say those who do not read raagmala are not sikhs. AKJ is the last jatha who still has this Gurmat rehit. Without AKJ it could have been lost forever. This is why Jatha should never compromise the rehit. Kulbir Singh suggestion is a good way of stopping argument in favour of positive parchaar. But Keski is always a must for every Gursikh.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

vivek · 25 Oct 2005

i dont agree 5th kakkar is either kes or keski there cant be 6th kakkars if for a medical condition you dont have hair, then what? 5th kakkar is keski full stop. truth is always the truth, thres no need to bend it, or compromise the truth. why even sujjest you must have kes with keski, isnt it obvious? if you CUT kes, this is a kurehit. if for a medical condition you have hair loss, this isnt a kurehit, because youre not removing youre hair, its falling out on it own accord. i only offer the truth, those who want to accept keski as 5th kakkar, accept it, if you dont you dont. i dont like the truth twisting/ compromising.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

BirRaas Singh · 25 Oct 2005

I dont really see where the comprimise is, apart from the words "kesh with keski" being put together. Its just the same as stating that keski is the kakar. A mere play on words. Everyone in the panth agrees that all Khalsa must keep their kesh, i have yet to come accross someone who believes that kesh isnt kept but a keski is lol.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 25 Oct 2005

vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!! hanjee i totally agree with this. when you say "kes-keski" as the fifth kakaar, it means that you must keep kes, with keski. you must keep kes. you must keep keski. they are mutually inclusive. they are symbiotic. they are interdependent. the punj kakaars - were not explicitly written as "panj kakaar" in any bani by guru gobind singh ji. so this will have to be a decision of the panth. replying to "NS" above: this is not a question for akal takhat. akal takhat is the seat of authority but it is not the authority. the authority is the khalsa panth. khalsa panth must decide it, and proclaim it from akal takhat. vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!!

Re: Kes Keski compromise

jss · 25 Oct 2005

this is the funniest thing ever.... it's not even a compromise...you all are being duped....hahaha....

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Guru ki Fauj · 25 Oct 2005

There is no compromise in sach khand where Guru Sahib sits on the throne. Kulbir Singh veer would you ask Guru Sahib to compromise on a Kakar. I think just thinking about compromise is kuljug and maha pap. What do you think Guru Sahib would do to you if you asked him to Compromise on Rehat. Rehat pyaree mujh ko Sikh pyara nahi? Did Sahibzade compromise to mughals? Who are you trying to make happy? Guru or Malech Khalsa?

Re: Kes Keski compromise

International Akaali · 25 Oct 2005

KULBIR SINGH, Who are you to have the authority to change kes to kes with keski LOL..... go to akal takht cuz akj isnt AKAL TAKHT..... who are you to have the right to change something that think it is suitable for you... please dont tlk here between a few people who dont know anythigng...

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Gurpreet Singh · 25 Oct 2005

how is kes with keski a compromise? there is no difference with saying keski is a kakkar, or saying kes with keski is a kakaar.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

raj karega khalsa · 25 Oct 2005

international akaali u sed veerjee was ASKIN wut the sangat thought about this....if u red his post he sed, CAN, he was askin, no need to attack him.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

khalistani · 25 Oct 2005

yo does rode federation mean isyf? cause if it does u r rely lost isyf has helped mad shaheed singhs daughters get married, and isyf has cntrubited many shaheeds t the panth, and sent hundreds of thousands of dollars overseas in order to support the kharkoos during the khalstaan movemnet after 84 bhula chuka maf

Re: Kes Keski compromise

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 26 Oct 2005

actually there is no compromise dastaar is necessary for both genders, without question, without compromise, without negotiation there is *NO DIFFERENCE* between the rehit a woman should keep and the rehit a man should keep except motherhood and fatherhood as those are different roles. but other than that, nitnem, 5 k's, dastaar, are all rehit for both genders. the reason i thought it was a good idea is that it would standardize the dastaar as requirement for all people. however i have now realized that there is no such thing as compromise. it is NOT a good idea to call it a compromise, and what bhai kulbir singh ji has posted above was not a real compromise. and for that matter guru sahib's rehit CANNOT BE COMPROMISED ANYWAY. the bottom line is this 1. kes is a requirement for all people in sikhi 2. dastaar is a requirement for all people in sikhi deciding the legal language for that is a secondary thing. no matter how we put it the above two facts are definately true.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

... · 26 Oct 2005

rode federation has done a lot for the panth don't cuss it

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Bundha · 26 Oct 2005

There should be no compromise. Kesh is Karkaar, only AKJ believe in Keski as kakaar and produce contrived arguments for it. Why should we the Khalsa bend for a Jathabundi? We are Sikhs of Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Ji and will not dilute His maryadha.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Prabhjoyt singh · 26 Oct 2005

ISYF didnt contribute any shaheeds you mean SSF, ISYF was set up in the western countries by Khalistanis living there

Re: Kes Keski compromise

agyani · 26 Oct 2005

maybe we should stick to the rehit given by the panj? As everyone know kes is kakaar :)

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Bhopinder Singh · 26 Oct 2005

: khalistani Where has rode fedration sent the money,to jasbir singh rode who according to ms dhar was always working for them .He is still shouting sant is not shaeed.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Fact · 26 Oct 2005

I think let people believe what they want to believe. Most the people who are very pro-Kesh are also deluded into thinking they follow some type of "Puratan" lineage from Guru Sahib's time. People with these types of mindsets will never change no matter what facts are presented.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

G Singh · 26 Oct 2005

If a woman was given amrit by the Panj without a keski (i.e. only covered her head with a chunni during sanchaar), would her amrit then become invalid after this compromise is implemented? Also, since many women wear keskis of similar length as chunnis, where's the difference aside from the 'wrapping', considering they both serve the same functions and are of similar length. Please note that I do keep a keski and respect those who consider it a kakaar. I'm just curious. Wjkk Wjkf! [%sig%]

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Gupt Singh · 26 Oct 2005

If you think about it, there is no actual proof on kesh being a kakkar. Before the British were in rule, akal takhat amrit sanchar’s use to say keski is kakkar. When British came into power they had the influence to change it to kesh. Kesh comes into the 4-bujjer kurehit(Removing kesh, alcohol, adultery and intoxicants) and if you remove it, you have committed a big sin. Kesh is also a natural gift guru jee has given us. We put a kangha on our head to keep the cleanliness of the kesh, so obviously this proves that kesh isn’t a kakkar because it’s much higher. The Punj kakkars are all material. The keski is there to cover our head at all times and to keep our hair neat. Even Bhai Rama Singh when he was a Hindu, had a dream of Guru Gobind Singh stating that keski is the 5 kakkar. Phul chuck maaf Dass Vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa, Vaaheguroojeekefaateh!!

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Sehajvir Singh · 26 Oct 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh I am not familiar about the details of the kes keski issue. I know the basics of why each side believes in what they do. I believe for no reason then because my rehit is taksaali that kes is the kakar. However it is important to treat keski as one as well. Maybe it is the kakar i don't know i don't have the soji to know. But I agree with Kulbir Singh Veer on this one. Why not compromise to bring the panth together so that we will have one less wall between us. Compromise and focus on naam simran. This moorakh needs to do that anyway. If i have offended anyone forgive me. [%sig%]

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Seaside Kaur · 26 Oct 2005

May I please offer a reply to "....." ji You are forgiven either way. It is a difficult topic to talk about. It's my blessing from Waheguruji to have a veer/bhen like you with so much pyar for Sikhi. Your Moorakh Sister. ..... wrote: > can i just appologise to 'seaside kaur'... > > i re-read ur post & ACTUALLY understand what you've said.... > > Sorry bhenji please forgive this moorakh

Re: Kes Keski compromise

r singh · 26 Oct 2005

kesh is the kakkar that guru ji gave us although everyone shud where keski, but it is not a kakkar

Re: Kes Keski compromise

RoopKaur · 26 Oct 2005

> kesh is the kakkar that guru ji gave us although everyone shud where keski, but it is not a kakkar < It should be noted that there are no records from Guru Ji's times that say Kes is kakaar. However, there ARE records that mention keski as kakaar. Ex, Bhatt Vehis, Bhai Chaupa SInghs rehitnaamaa, etc...

Re: Kes Keski compromise

agyani · 26 Oct 2005

is keski just well a "round" dastaar? lol..i still dont know what the heck it looks like!

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 26 Oct 2005

good suggestion but I don't think it will work that much. I have come to recognize that most people that do not support keski being a kakaar are those who do n't want to wear dastars at all time or don't want their wives, daughters to wear them. So with these kind of people, there can be no platform on which anything could be achieved for unity. The conpromise that Kulbir Singh wrote about will only work if other side also promotes Keski as a general requirement.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

DDT · 26 Oct 2005

y cant ppl belive in kes as a kakkar and still wear keski at all times and make it mandatory anyways.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

uk singh · 27 Oct 2005

Well said DDT.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

khalistani · 27 Oct 2005

wat the hell ru guys talkin bout do u guys even KNO anythin on frekin isyf ya isyf was set up in western countries do u kno how many bhujangees went from west to fight for khalstaan do u kno how much money was sent to khalstaan efforts in punjaab do u kno how many shaheed singhs daughters have been married due to efforts of bhai jasbir singh je,a nd members of isyf y the hell do u think mad isyf members are blacklisted for fun? man my baba personally went down mad investigations for somethings and obviosly i woudnt tell people wa he did, cause u just dont go around tellin people stuff like tha but isyf did mad things for panth thas y its labbleed as a terrorist orginazation and thas y its banned i cant belive now ANOTHER lie like this has come out and yo if u have so much beef with people tha say sant je is alive u shud go talk to there face ive said it befoe and ill say it again everyone shud keep there opinons to themselves and just wait if santje come they will come, if not then no time will show but in tha time no need to stir up another contrversie in te panth just chill and im guessin u mean rodes fed. is isyf if not, ma bad then i dunt kno wat rode fed is, if not isyf bhula chuka maf

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Prabhjoyt singh · 09 Nov 2005

the keski issue was only brought up when the akj came about

Re: Kes Keski compromise

bl · 09 Nov 2005

i think its a good suggestion. i think someone with lower understanding wouldnt realize that its a good idea. whoever doesnt agree does so out of pride.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Bundha · 09 Nov 2005

Don't paint those who disagree with you as being lower interlectually. <<<< whoever doesnt agree does so out of pride. >>>> Sorry, this is nonsense. This keski issue has only come about because of AKJ, and of all the great things that AKJ has done and continue to do , THIS is a big DIS-SERVICE it has done to the panth. [%sig%]

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Singh · 09 Nov 2005

For all the non-scholars above who say only AKJ brought about keski. How do you explain all the Prataan texts that mention keski? Next time think before you write!

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 09 Nov 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh Firstly, Keeping Kes is common sense thats why its not one of the Kakaars. We should be keeping our Kes anyway since Vaheguru Jee's light abides within each and every hair on the human body. Secondly, all that occurred in the past due to the change of the kakaar Keski to Kes was because the Gora at that time new that religion was the key to the Sikhs strength but couldn't figure out how to weaken the religion. Gora wanted to do all this because they wanted British Raj in india. Finally Gora had found a solution, all they had to do and did was go to india and blend with the Sikhs there by becoming friends with them. As time went by Gora relised that all they had to do was slowly erase the Ki from Kes on wherever Guru Gobind Singh Jee had wrote the Panj Kakaars so that the turban isn't worn all the time and the head is left bareheaded as well as due to the carelessness of wearing a turban slowly the Sikhs would begin to cut their hair too. So it seems like their plan worked. But then Guru Gobind Singh Jee came on to earth spiritually and showed himself to the valiant Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee and explained to him that Keski is the true Kakaar. Guru Jee could only show the truth to that pure servant that begs for Guru Jee’s Naam every day and has a deep strong piercing love for Vaheguru Jee. Sikhs have weakened from then on and aren’t that strong as they used to be then. Realize that the life we have now is just a dream, we really wake up when we pass away. At the end death takes hold of whosoever falls in the trap of Kalyug it wins and they always regret and cry out for forgiveness. The most powerful fighters in the world right now and were in the past are the five demons and whosoever is strong enough to defeat these demons step up and give your head to Guru Jee and play the game of love. Only through the Guru can Vaheguru Jee be found and shall you then be free from all entanglements of Maya. The mind of human beings is confused and lost in a pitch of white fog counseled with doubts and influenced by evil, which has been dressed up in an illusion of pleasure, the mind has become corrupt. Love Vaheguru Jee for all he has done for you. Vaheguru Jee is your only friend, brother, sister, Mother and Father. Become strong in this age of time, become a BharamGyani and gain spiritual wisdom as then and only then will truth and justice be brought to this sinful world. Some of the Gursikhs that are here on earth is the only reason why the earth is still standing. Become humble and destroy your ego and laziness. To conclude FEAR GURU JEE!! VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Prabhjoyt Singh · 09 Nov 2005

which puratan texts mention eski as a kaakaar?

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Singh · 09 Nov 2005

Do a search these things have been discussed so many times. Guru Kian Sakhian, Bhatt Vehis, Chaupa Singh Rehatnama (a little more controversial but the first two are explicit and clear)

Re: Kes Keski compromise

BirRaas Singh · 09 Nov 2005

There are more Rehitnameh which mention Kesh as the Kakar, along with the other Trai Mudras. The most authentic would be Khalsa Mehima by guess who? Guru Gobind Singh :D, if this bani wasnt authentic, then people should stop singing the shabad "Khalsa Mero Roop Hai Khaas" I can understand the "logic" that is applied to the Keski being a Kakar, but the fact remains that the Guru set the Khalsas Nishani as Kach Kesh and Kirpan. When you challenge the logic of all Kakars being external, you challenge the wisdom of Guru Gobind Singh, is your mat higher then the Gurus? I personally wear a Keski all the time, along with a Kamarkasa, but I dont see them as Kakars. Im not against Keski for everyone, im against false parchar which is being done.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

sewak · 09 Nov 2005

Waheguru Waheguru Waheguru Jio. Please all on this forum. Please understand before we venture into this rehat of whether kes or keski is the actual way forward. We need to understand that every Guru Ka Tyaar par Tyaar Sikh need to have his Kes uncut. Now, to maintain this long uncut hair, he need to tie a knot on his top head i.e dasam duar location. This also applies to our Benji's as well. Where is your dasam duar located, right on the top of your head. Your hair knot should be placed as where Gursikhs males have. Now, going forward, if the above statement makes sense, then lets go another step. To cover your head. We need a dastar i'e a piece of cloth would round your head covering this hair knot. A chunni for the benji's, if it looks appropriate, then carry on covering your head with the hair knot on your dasam duar. But surely, this will not stay on. So, the best is like our Singh's, tie a appropriate dastar. In this matter, let the benji's say and make the call, not the Singhs as you all are already followng the described rehat accordingly. The rest, please do not attack anyone aswe are all in the learning curve, as a sikh means learning.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Singh · 10 Nov 2005

BirRaas Singh, The whole point that has been discussed, possibly 100s of times, is that Trai Mudra isn't the same as Panj Kakkars. Are you sure the Trai Mudra is mentioned in Khalsa Mero Roop Hai Khas Shabad? Could you give a reference? I have always thought it was in a seperate part of Sarbloh Granth, some sections' authenticities being dubious at best? And there are no Rehatnameh which mention Kesh as one of the Panj Kakkar. Check Daya Singh, Desa Singh, Prehlad Rai, Chaupa Singh, Nand Lal (3 different Rehatnameh); none mention Kesh as a Kakkar. Scholars who research this issue but stick by "Kesh", often have had to concede that Guru Sahib never made the Panj Kakkars formally but this was made up later by someone else. Other highly respected scholars such as Pyara Singh Padam have indeed agreed that the Kakkar is Keski.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

BirRaas Singh · 10 Nov 2005

"Singh" The Shaabad which mentions Trai Mudra is part of Khalsa Mehima, the second stanza. Prior to the publication of "Twarik Guru Khalsa" in 1880, there was no written mention of "Panj Kakar", and after that history was re-written with all mentions of Trai Mudra being changed to Panj Kakar with the addition of Kara and Kanga. If there are no mentions in original texts of Panj Kakar, then it has to be acknowledged that Panj Kakar is an evolution of the Trai Mudra, there is no difference. Why would the Guru establish Trai Mudra and Panj Kakar paralell to each other? Here comes the logic (what everyones using to allocate Keski as a Kakar) If Panj Kakar is an evolution of the Trai Mudra, and the original Trai Mudra are Kach Kesh and Kirpan, then where does the Keski fit in? If you look at the Trai Mudra, the 2 external nishaniya are Kach and Kirpan, with the Kesh being non external (ie bodypart). Someones "logic" (manmat), has changed the Gurus ordained nishaniya because they feel it doesnt make sense. I will reply in a day or two with the correct refferences.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Singh · 10 Nov 2005

A repeat of what I previously said: "Scholars who research this issue but stick by "Kesh", often have had to concede that Guru Sahib never made the Panj Kakkars formally but this was made up later by someone else." You have indeed fitted yourself into this group, as many Sanatanists do, as you see no other Puratan Kesh-Kakkar references. Perhaps you could remove your Kangha and Kara if you believe these were not given to you by Guru Sahib but are infact a later Manmat addition? For others who believe the Kakkars were made by Guru Sahib, as I have mentioned, there are sources like Guru Ki Sakhian, Bhatt Vahis which back up their beliefs. And they mention Keski. Whether or not Trai Mudra is mentioned in Puratan Granths I do not worry; I don't see the Trai Mudra and Panj Kakkar as mutually exclusive. There are plenty of Rehatnameh that list one or two of the Kakkars, of different combinations, this doesn't make the Panj Kakkar any less valid. The concept of "threes" can be traced back to Hindu Kings having 3 signs (the whisk, throne and club) signifying their power and regality. It is quite possible that if the Trai Mudra has been mentioned by Guru Sahib he is drawing a parallel between the worldly symbols of the Kings vs the spiritual symbols of the Khalsa. It does not decrease the significance of the Kangha, Kara or Keski in any way.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Singh · 10 Nov 2005

The term Treh-Mudra is not puratan. It does not appear in any of the puratan rehtinamas. It appears in Sarbloh Granth but this Granth has been put as a work from the late 19th century by Bhai Vir Singh, Pandit Tara Singh Narotam, Bhai Kanh Singh and others. Find me a puraatan reference to it. You can't. The most puratan source for rehit is the Bhat Vehis which clearly list keski as a kakaar.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

BirRaas Singh · 10 Nov 2005

Your view is fairly skewed, just because something doesnt fit into the Trai Mudras, mean that we cant wear anything else? Your putting words into my mouth by making your own conclusions about what I believe. No one has ever said that just because Trai Mudra dont mention Kara and Kanga that they are not to be carried. In Gurbilas Paatshahi 6, the Kara is termed as a "Beeni Ka Shastar", so its worn as a matter of defence, and a Kanga is carried because when you comb your Kesh twice a day, its handy to carry on your person. Like i mentioned earlier i will provide you with the refferences, but it seems as if you have already made up your mind. Whether me going through the hassle of finding and typing these up is going to be in vain i dont know. Im not posting to change anyones views, merely to provide the other side of the coin. I dont it funny how you see 3rd hand Rehitnamas are authentic, and you believe the words of someone who doubts Bhagat Bani.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Singh · 10 Nov 2005

BirRaas Singh - here is a shocker for you - the majority of people here already have an opinion/view! So, why don't you present your beliefs too with evidence so we can learn a little more. If you can't be bothered to back up your views because you dont want to go "through the hassle of finding and typing", please don't expect people to take your points seriously. I'm not sure what you mean by 3rd hand Rehatnamas; a text written near to contemporary and a text written in the latter half of the 18th century is more than good enough for me; as I have stated, the authenticity of Sarbloh Granth is certainly much more suspect (having magically appeared out of nowhere after many years for all the Panth to see! Whilst many people have come to defend Sri Dasam Granth Sahib, there is deafening silence against the points risen against Sarbloh Granth) PS Don't even get me started on Gurbilas Patshahi 6! You are basing your reason to wear a Kara on Gurbilas P:6?!!? And you wear your Kangha because "it is handy" to have it on your person? It is a pity how this Sanatanist mindset is reducing what most Gursikhs consider as Angs to "handy items".

Re: Kes Keski compromise

BirRaas Singh · 10 Nov 2005

I was talking about the practicality of the Kanga and their uses, not in any way was i reducing their significance, again your putting words into my mouth, I must admit, thats a talent.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Singh · 11 Nov 2005

My apologies for putting words into your mouth; this may be due to the fact that you have not adequately clarified either your position on the Panj Kakkars or the evidence you claim for Trai Mudra. The reasons behind this, either fall into the catagory of you genuinely not wanting "the hassle" of doing so (which would bring into question of why you are still replying on this thread?) or you have come to a personal realization that your personal beliefs are not quite as well backed up as you thought they were. Please do enlighten us on your stance re. Kangha/Kara. Do you consider these Angs of yourself even if Guru Sahib has never mentioned them (according to you)? Do you wear your Kangha and Kara all the time or occasionally take them off when you feel like it? If you follow Kara rehat due to Gurbilas P:6 do you believe in everything else in Gurbilas P:6 equally? How can you place this Kara rehat on the same level as the Kirpan/Kachera rehat if one is formally Guru made and the other is not? Would you agree it is Manmat on the Sikh Kaum to have changed the Guru-made Trai Mudra to the man-made formalised Panj Kakkar and just added 2 Kakkars on the end? Does this not call into question the authenticity of the many so called "Puratan" Maryadas (whether they be Taksal, Nihang, etc) as they have not mantained the original Maryada and made their own concepts?

Re: Kes Keski compromise

moorakh · 11 Nov 2005

a question .. doesnt it say KES in dasam bani .. why not keski anywhere ???? i only seen KES over and over again in dasam bani .. AND DONT SAY that is not written by guru gobind singh cuz there is no anti-gurmat in those lines aside from the kes/keski argument.. so isnt that enough to declare that the kakkar is KES not KESKI !?!?!

Re: Kes Keski compromise

Singh · 11 Nov 2005

"Moorakh" you have not seen Kesh is Kakkar written anywhere in Dasam Bani, never mind over and over. The Nishani Sikhi Shabad, if you are referring to this, has only been promoted as so called Dasam Bani recently. Previously it was called Bhai Nand Lal's, and even then most scholars have dismissed it as a 19th century composition. That particular issue has already been discussed on this site multiple times also. If you are not clear on facts you should not try to enter a discussion or put forward vague/ambigious comments.

Re: Kes Keski compromise

}{/\RPR33T · 13 Nov 2005

< sRI vwihgurU jI kI Pqih ] sRi muKvwk pwiqswhI 10 ] inswin isKI eIN pMj hriP Asq kwP ] hrigj nw bwsd eIN pMj muAwP ] 1] kVw kwrdo k`C kMGy ibdW ] iblw kys hyc Asq jumly insW ] 2] hrP hkwieq Asq AjI pMj kwP] ibdw nMd bwvr n goXm iKlwP ] 3] hu`kw hjwmq hlwlo hrwm ] bwrIsy ihnw krd rU isXw Pwm ] 4] 1] (AsPokt sÍYXy, sRI dsm gRMQ) The following five K’s are the mark of Sikhi.These five can never be parted from the body. Kara, Kirpan, Kashera, Kangha, recognise these as four of them.The fifth is Kesh, without which the other four are useless. There are also four H’s which must be avoided. Understand this without any doubt, no lies have been told. Hukka, taking tobacco (including any other type of intoxicants). Hajamat, removing of hair. Halalo, eating meat. Haram, adultery (sexual relationships outside of marriage). These are the four H’s. Dyeing of beards (including any other body hair), and the wearing of mehndi (including other types of make up) are strictly forbidden. (Sri Dasam Granth)

Re: Kes Keski compromise

soorma · 14 Nov 2005

MANY PEOPLE BELIEVE KESH IS GIVEN AT BIRTH SO THEIR FOR KESKI IS A KAKKAR BUT WAT ABOUT THE PEOPLE HU HVE HAD TO DISCOVER KESH THEMSHELES AS IN THEY USED 2 CUT KESH ETC... N WHY ALL THIS JATHABANDI STUFF? IF SUM1 NEW WANTS 2 GET TOWARDS SIKHI AKJ WILL BE PULLING HIM BY ONE ARM N TAKSAL BY THE OTHER N THE POOR SOUL WID BE CONFUSED N NOT NO WHICH WAY TO GO Y CANT THEY JUST BE ONE REHAT 4 EVERY 1 AINT THEIR A FIXED REHAT THAT GURU JI HAD GIVEN ???

Re: Kes Keski compromise

........ · 15 Nov 2005

would this then mean that non akjs would be allowed in akj amrit veli?