Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Navdeep Singh Bains Stands Up for Kirpan

Navdeep Singh Bains Stands Up for Kirpan

News · 26 Oct 2005

CITY Liberal MP calls VIA's banning of ceremonial sword 'unacceptable' PM's parliamentary secretary to take up issue with transport minister Mohammed Adam The Ottawa Citizen October 26, 2005 CREDIT: Bruno Schlumberger, The Ottawa Citizen MP Navdeep Bains Prime Minister Paul Martin's parliamentary secretary has condemned VIA Rail for ordering a Sikh student off a train for wearing a ceremonial sword, or kirpan, saying he intends to take the matter up with Transport Minister Jean Lapierre. Navdeep Bains, an Ontario Sikh and MP for Mississauga-Brampton South, said yesterday he also plans to raise the incident with VIA Rail executives and the board of directors. Mr. Bains noted that he wears the kirpan in the House of Commons without any problem and is disappointed that a Crown corporation, such as VIA, would order a man out of a train for wearing an article of religious significance. "It is unfortunate and it is unacceptable. It is disappointing to see an institution like VIA Rail taking a position like this, because you expect better from them," Mr. Bains said. "I want to make sure that the appropriate authorities that I am aware of -- ultimately the transport minister -- are brought up to speed on this. The management of VIA Rail and the board of directors have accountability on this particular issue and I'll probably communicate in an appropriate fashion with them." Controversy over kirpans, long a subject of debate and litigation in the courts, erupted once again after University of Ottawa law student Balpreet Singh was taken off a train twice in a month after someone complained that he had a weapon. His explanation that the kirpan is a religious symbol worn by baptized Sikhs wasn't acceptable to VIA officials, who took him off a train once in Toronto and last Friday in Ottawa. A VIA spokeswoman said the company prohibits all kinds of weapons from its trains and the kirpan falls under a ban on weapons that includes "collectibles, antiques and those of a ceremonial nature." VIA said the ban is in the larger interest of public safety and security. Mr. Bains acknowledged that public safety is of paramount importance to Canadians, but said people ought to know the difference between a weapon and the Sikh religious artifact. In a democracy, every effort should be made to strike a balance between public safety and religious freedom to make sure people's rights under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms are respected. After more than 100 years in Canada, Mr. Bains said the incident shows that Sikhs still have a major task of educating Canadians and the likes of VIA Rail about their religion. "Public safety is always an important part of sound public policy, but I think it has been demonstrated, through various cases, that there should be a balance with respect to articles of faith," he said. "At the end of the day, the issue is very clear -- Balpreet poses no threat. He is simply practising his beliefs and it is important for VIA Rail to understand that, and enforce a policy that is mindful of that." About 15 per cent of Canada's estimated 300,000 Sikhs wear a sheathed kirpan strapped to their chests as a sign of their readiness to defend the weak and fight for justice. While Sikhs say the daggers have never been used in violence or cited in any such action in North America, they have been the subject of furious debate and controversy in Canada. The blades are allowed in most Canadian schools, but in the wake of the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks in the U.S., Transport Canada banned the carrying of knives and "knife-like objects," which includes kirpans, from airplanes. Sikh leaders say the 2001 attacks were such a searing event that "there was no way anyone could have made a stand or fuss" about the prohibition, said Manjit Singh, a spokesman for the Canadian Sikh Council. The community had to strike a balance between its religious beliefs and public security, and accepted the ban. "That was an exceptional circumstance," Mr. Singh said. Even then, Sikhs had to make an atonement for not wearing the dagger, he said. At the end of their journey, they had to say a special prayer of atonement and perform other rites and then don the kirpan. VIA Rail's action, however, is viewed as a form of harassment that threatens the religion. "You've got to look at the next step. Can people carry kirpans anywhere?" Mr. Singh said. What They Said The Citizen's Vito Pilieci spoke to several shoppers last night and asked them: 'Would you object to having a person wear a kirpan on public transit and what are your thoughts with regard to Mr. Singh's ordeal?' Here is what they said. Sanjein Lee, 28 It is part of their religion, so they should allow it. But, for safety reasons, maybe then there should be some kind of limitations. Pierre St. Cyr, 39 I think it's a good thing not to allow him on the train with that. They wouldn't allow me to come on with a knife, even if it was for my religion. Matt Martin, 21 I know it's ceremonious for them to wear it (the kirpan). Personally, I don't feel uncomfortable with it. But there are a lot of people who would feel uncomfortable with it and so I would say, don't allow them on the train. Roberta Dupont, 70 We have had so many problems. This fellow may be fine. But if you are going to have a rule and break it, where does it end? I find it a difficult thing, because we have had so many problems with high school kids carrying blades. Rules have to apply to everyone. Richard Whitelock, 48 This is a free society. We are very open. If he is boarding the train, then he should not be hassled. The way he was dressed ... he might be going somewhere. If he wanted to do anything (terrorist related), it would not have been possible. He is not a terrorist. They should have asked him where he was going, dressed like that. They may have learned something. Ran with fact box "What they said", which has been appended to the story. © The Ottawa Citizen 2005

Re: Navdeep Singh Bains Stands Up for Kirpan

News · 26 Oct 2005

Sikh student banned from train for wearing kirpan Last Updated Wed, 26 Oct 2005 10:52:41 EDT CBC News A Sikh man is considering taking Via Rail to the Ontario Human Rights Commission because the Crown corporation won't let him wear his ceremonial dagger on its trains. RELATED: Kirpan Controversy in the Classroom On Friday, Balpreet Singh was ordered off a Via train as he was about to travel home to Toronto. Another passenger had complained about his kirpan. "To be led off a train that's filled ... [is] absolutely humiliating," said the first-year law student at the University of Ottawa. Singh, 24, says he wears the kirpan for religious reasons. He says he is never without it, even while attending class. "This is essentially one of the signs of the Sikh faith," he said. "It's absolutely required. I'm never apart from this, whether I'm sleeping or whatever. It's basically considered part of my body. "I consider that one of my fundamental freedoms ... [and my] freedom of religion is being infringed." Via has a policy of not allowing anything that could be considered a weapon on its trains, even if that weapon is only used for ceremonial purposes. MP promises to pursue issue News of Singh's situation dismayed the prime minister's parliamentary secretary, Navdeep Bains. The Toronto-area member of Parliament, who is also a Sikh, says he's never had a problem wearing a kirpan in the House of Commons. He says he's disappointed that a Crown corporation would try to ban them. Bains said he plans to take the issue up with the federal transport minister and with Via's board of directors. In Canada, the debate over whether to allow Sikhs to wear kirpans in public places has been going on for more than a decade. As well as Via trains, the daggers are banned from airplanes, Greyhound buses and some schools.

Re: Navdeep Singh Bains Stands Up for Kirpan

me · 26 Oct 2005

>>>>>As well as Via trains, the daggers are banned from airplanes, Greyhound buses and some schools.<<<<< Greyhound buses?? I personally know many Sikhs who wear their kirpans on the Greyhound buses without any problems in Toronto.

Re: Navdeep Singh Bains Stands Up for Kirpan

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 26 Oct 2005

technically they say you cannot take sharp objects like knives onto greyhound buses in 2003 i was pulled off a bus for wearing a kirpan and transfered to another bus this happened in winnipeg

Re: Navdeep Singh Bains Stands Up for Kirpan

Pradeep Singh · 26 Oct 2005

-- I was pulled off a bus for wearing a kirpan-- Brother, listen to me, this happened to me too on a train in the U.S.. I refused to take off my kirpan and they did not let me on the train. However, they were willing to keep my kirpan in a safe place in the front of the train so i finally allowed them to do so. Is this okay for Sikhi? Im trying to be a gursikh, but how could i have kept my kirpan on? I had to make it to the Gurdwara in my hometown which was holding a special function in my honor.

Re: Navdeep Singh Bains Stands Up for Kirpan

? · 26 Oct 2005

>>>>>in 2003 i was pulled off a bus for wearing a kirpan and transfered to another bus<<<<< What difference would that have made? Weren't there people on that bus as well, or was that bus special and specially made for people with "sharp objects" on hand? Sorry for the sarcasm...but people are so ignorant...

Re: Navdeep Singh Bains Stands Up for Kirpan

Sher Khalsa · 26 Oct 2005

By doing that you may not realize it , but you made it way way way harder for future Sikhs who take the train. Next time a Singh says I cant remove my kirpan and let you hold it in a box for me, they will say Pradeep Singh did it why can't you. We all have to take a common stand, if someone compromises, it makes it harder for those who are not willing to part with their kirpan. It makes no sense to part with kirpan on a train anyways, no one has access to the conductor. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Author: Pradeep Singh Date: 10-26-05 17:29 -- I was pulled off a bus for wearing a kirpan-- Brother, listen to me, this happened to me too on a train in the U.S.. I refused to take off my kirpan and they did not let me on the train. However, they were willing to keep my kirpan in a safe place in the front of the train so i finally allowed them to do so. Is this okay for Sikhi? Im trying to be a gursikh, but how could i have kept my kirpan on? I had to make it to the Gurdwara in my hometown which was holding a special function in my honor.

Re: Navdeep Singh Bains Stands Up for Kirpan

observer · 26 Oct 2005

The incident should be reported to http://www.sikhcoalition.org/

Re: Navdeep Singh Bains Stands Up for Kirpan

A Singh · 28 Oct 2005

The same issue prevails on the Eurostar trains, however I've never had a problem explaining it well in advance of boarding to actually board with my Kirpan onto the Train - coming back the other way from France is not always so easy though! Gur Fateh! A "SINGH"

Re: Navdeep Singh Bains Stands Up for Kirpan

nARINDER pAUL sINGH · 28 Oct 2005

he is doing awonderful job may the all mighty Waheguru bless our yougest M P in Canada with wisdom & strength so that he can serve for panth the way he is serving. Thanks NARINDER PAUL SINGH