terrorism victims’ kin still suffering
AS · 26 Oct 2005
Study shows terrorism victims’ kin still suffering Tribune News Service Chandigarh, October 26 A study by two internationally renowned organisations-the Physicians for Human Rights (PHR) and the Bellevue/New York University School of Medicine Program for Survivors of Torture, Bellevue, - has brought out startling facts concerning family members of those who were allegedly killed and illegally cremated by the Punjab Police between 1984 and 1995. The report is now part of proceedings of an ongoing case -the Committee for Information and Initiative on Punjab (CIIP) versus the State of Punjab - before the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC). The study found that a majority of family members suffered "a variety of abuses, including harassment (75 per cent threat and/or surveillance (54 per cent), and physical assault (47 per cent). In addition, 63 per cent of those interviewed reported having been arrested by law enforcement officials and 48 per cent others reported having been tortured. The six-member PHR/Bellevue investigative team, which conducted the study in Amritsar in May-June 2005, came across a "pattern of intentional abuse by law enforcement officials among multiple family members". It has concluded that the NHRC should investigate and adjudicate the fundamental rights violations committed by the police, beyond the illegal cremation of the family member. "As a result of the death and illegal cremation of a close family member, most of the individuals interviewed demonstrated severe psychological disorders, including depression and post-traumatic stress disorder, with nearly half of those interviewed continuing to describe these symptoms more than 10 years after the traumas occurred," the reports quotes Dr Allen Keller and Dr Barry Rosenfeld as saying. Mr Ram Narayan-Kumar of the CIIP, who has been spearheading the movement to get justice for the vast number of innocent persons allegedly killed and cremated by the police during terrorism in Punjab, said, "The study followed a systematic probability sample of 189 cases out of 756 identified cases before the NHRC, taking every fourth individual in the database of all the identified cases on a random basis. The study reveals the existence of startling rates of current and past psychological and physical suffering," he stated. He also added that the report clearly concluded that compensation to family members should include not only the specific violations resulting in the destruction of the right to life and illegal cremations, but also the emotional and financial impact of such violations and the extraordinary context within which these losses occurred. "The PHR/Bellevue report should compel the NHRC to investigate the physical and psychological trauma suffered by victim families, in addition to the murder and illegal cremation of their relative(s). The right to justice means that the victims of atrocities are able to bring their complaints before the forum that is acting as an extension and the instrument of the Supreme Court under Article 32 jurisdiction and to have their complaints heard and adjudicated. This the commission has not done so far," he pointed out. Mr Ram Narayan-Kumar demanded since it was not possible for the NHRC to restore the lives that have been lost, it is doubly important for it to force the state to repair the remaining consequences of the violations through comprehensive measures of reparation directed at the survivors. "They must receive compensation for physical and mental injury, including lost opportunities, defamation and legal costs, emotional and moral harm and the measures of reparation must include medical care, including psychological treatment, education of the orphaned and work opportunities for those who remain physically capable. Reparation must also include guarantees of non-recurrence," he said. Ms Jatinder Kaur of CIIP also addressed the media persons.