Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

! · 28 Oct 2005

In response to the Kirpan, here's what the Canadian public has to say. What a Multicultural and accepting place! The fact that Balpreet Singh is born and raised in Canada makes no difference and newspapers like the Ottawa Citizen allow comments like this to appear: Name: Citizen A Email: ashamed to be Canadian Occupation: Accountant Location: Canada (World's dumping ground) For God's sake. When are we going to put an end to this and start putting these people in their place? If we went to there country, we would have to follow the rules and customs of their nation, so why is it that when they come here they are not expect to give us the same common curtise? They don't like it here than leave. In this country, accurding to our laws and custums, carring a wepon is a crime and something that is considered intollerable. Yes there are Canadain custums and traditions, but we know little about them, because we allow immagrents and refugees to come here and do as they please. When in Rome do as the Romans do. Every other nation protects their customs, traditions and laws exept Canada. If Shikes are allowed to carry weapons, then I should be allowed to carry a weapon as well. As matter of fact we should be allowed or not allowed to carry weapons. One nation = one set of laws. If I got into fight with one of them, I would use a weapon, because they have one, period Name: Jon Citizen Email: n/a Occupation: Observer Location: North America If you move to a different country that is mostly Judeo-Christian and you come from the Middle East or India you must accept that our culture and beliefs do not support transporting a sabre or sword on our person (i.e. body). While Canada has been spared terrorist activities (so far) most travelers on a train or plane live in places where terrorism is a constant threat. I am always amazed that the first thing that many of these people from radically different cultures from ours learn is how to scream discrimination and how to file a lawsuit. Name: Modeno Occupation: Retired Location: St-Laurent Why oh why does it have to be us Canadians who have to kneel when faced with some kind religion? Now as far as I know, Via rail is Canadian, so why should they try to do something regarding someone getting on the train with a dagger strung around the belt? My God! when are we going to wake up and put our pants on and tell these people that if they want to live in Canada, they will have to abide by the laws of the land. Religion was invented by men, so don't tell me that God Almighty told them to wear a dagger at all time! I really wonder what would happen if we tried to do the same things in their country? We would most probably get shot on the spot! Name: Sean P. Hogan Occupation: public servant Location: Ottawa Just another example of how the immigrants in this country are trying to shove their beliefs down our throats. If you have to wear a dagger as part of your religion, it doesn't say much for the religion. At the same time, they don't care about the safety of passengers, just themselves, so selfish and so uncaring. Name: Andy Occupation: tech Location: montreal When are these people going to learn that we have laws in this country that they have to abide by if they wish to live here. We do not allow citizens to carry weapons, religious or not, end of story. Whether or not you worship God, Allah, Vishnu or Casper the Friendly Ghost, you will have to do it without a knife, M16 or ground to air missile launcher. If you cannot abide by these rules, there are plenty of medieval middle east countries who can accomodate you. For more enlightened comments go to: http://www.canada.com/ottawa/ottawacitizen/soundoff/story.html?id=59fa9091-8dd3-4b95-8521-b35a9a21aa50

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

singh · 28 Oct 2005

I love how these gore think that Canada is somehow 'their' country. I could understand their mentality if Canada was England or France or something, but their grandfathers and forefathers all came here just like ours did. They came here as immigrants just like anyone else. If the British can go and live in India for 200 years and steal all the wealth, why does it hurt them so much if immigrants come into their home country and earn their living?

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

singh · 28 Oct 2005

first guy doesn't how to spell..typical canadian

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

S Singh · 28 Oct 2005

Typical. It doesnt matter if Balpeet Singh born and raised in Canada. Just because he looks different, he is still considered an outsider, a non-Canadian. Cant they get this through their thick heads that Balpreet Singh is Canadian, his home country IS Canada!

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

P walla!!! · 28 Oct 2005

Come to the uk....and open a tapoban here....!!!! Nah on serious terms TAPOBAN SHOULD COME TO THE UK!!!!

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

DDT · 28 Oct 2005

some of these goray need some jutheyan

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

Gandalf · 28 Oct 2005

Some of the comments made on this thread (i.e. typical gorey, gorey can't spell etc) are just as bad as the comments made on the Citizen web site. What makes you think that it is just gorey posting. Hypocritical. And you should consider the source of the comments. Canada.com is owned by CanWest Global (which owns the National Post). This is a right wing/conservative/neo-conservative paper, that is known for its anti-immigrant views. What else do you expect from Canada.com

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

Jagjit Singh · 28 Oct 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I think you should not see these opinions as reflective of canadian public opinion. Similarly in UK alot was being said after the Behzti. Often only people with pre-concieved opinions usually respond to these events. Canadian sikhs rather than accept it, should respond in a positive intellectual manner. Point out things, like since when has Canada become a country which judges someone religion. Point out he is a Canadian citizen, who is law abiding, civil, intelligent. He is not an immigrant, but a Canada born Sikh youth. Canada is mosiac of cultures, it is not USA, and definately not a country who should be forced to accept Christianity. In UK after Behzti, if you went on any messageboards like Channel 4, The Birmingham Rep, SKy news, etc, even The Times newspaper, Sikhs debated there views very well. So must Canadians. They need to write to Canada.com, Ottawa Citizen, in an intelligent manner. In UK, Sikhs are seen as the acceptable Asians. Hardworking, affluent, law abiding, intelligent, and accepting as the most succesful minority group. In Canada, Sikhs seem to have yet to find a coherent voice which only educated youth can bring. You cannot wait for Jathas, or Gurdwaras to sort themselves out and represent you. Youth must start organising themselves and speaking on behalf of Sikhi in a articulate manner. Canada Youth need to spring into action. List on the public information messageboards and main newspaper sites. Put them on Tapoban, sikhsangat, WIN, and other sites, so Sikhs youth worldwide can aslo respond. Flood them with emails supporting Balpreet Singh. Where there is debate like in Ottawa Citizen, respond in a mature articulate manner, in concise mails with clear point. You need to influence opinion with debate, not accept it. - Mention, you are proud to be a canadian, and also proud of being Sikh. - You cannot see why people should be offended by a kirpan, when in other countries like UK, Sikhs are freely open to wear them without incident. - Mention only orthodox Sikh who do not drink, take intoxicants and live to a strict code onf conduct beased upon mediation and service to humanity are allowed to wear them. If anyone has good sample emails then they should share them. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

singh · 28 Oct 2005

I find it interesting how almost each comment refers to Sikhs as "these people".

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

singh · 28 Oct 2005

The kirpan is not offensive Re: No-weapons rule applies to everyone, OCT. 27. It’s saddening to see intolerance towards the kirpan, one of the items of the Sikh faith. In 1699, Guru Gobind Singh Ji made it mandatory for the kirpan to be worn at all times by male members of the Sikh faith. He told them to treat the kirpan as a part of their bodies, and never be separated from it. The kirpan is not a “sword,” it’s more of a “shield.” It is never to be used in aggression, never to oppress or make someone afraid. It is meant for upholding justice and protecting the weak. Sikhs are not allowed to unsheath their kirpans except to protect themselves or others in life-or-death situations. The police wear their guns and no one is intimidated or afraid because they know the guns are there to protect them. The same thing applies to the kirpan; people just need to be made aware of this. For example, if a Sikh sees someone being mugged by five people, the Sikh has a duty to ignore his personal safety and help the person being mugged. A Sikh will sacrifice himself or herself to protect and help those in need. This has been a pillar of the Sikh faith since its inception. Has a Sikh ever used a kirpan to initiate violence? In the 100 years Sikhs have been in Canada, has there ever been a reported case of a kirpan being used in a negative way? Balpreet Singh went to board a train wearing a kirpan that he was not hiding from anyone, but he was not allowed into the car. If his kirpan is visible and attracts attention, do you think he’s really there to cause trouble? There are so many other ways to get a weapon on board without drawing attention to yourself. It just makes no sense. Sikhs are honest law-abiding citizens, and should be treated as such. TEJDEEP S. CHATTHA, Ottawa Not ordinary weapon The kirpan that is part of a Sikh’s identity is no ordinary weapon. It carries with it the divine responsibility to be compassionate and respect human dignity. Every Sikh is drilled in the responsibility to challenge evil even when life is at risk. History bears witness that Sikhs used the kirpan successfully to stop the repeated attacks on India by invading hordes that would not only loot but also carry away thousands of men and women as slaves. History is also replete with examples of Sikhs’ extreme tolerance and peacefulness. The Guru Granth Sahib teaches: “Even if someone strikes you in anger, abide in utter humility and love.” The kirpan is only a last resort in defence of the oppressed and exploited. I appeal to the Canadian government and its agencies to respect this “article of faith” duly and not treat it at par with weapons carried by the evil-minded. Please realize that wearing a kirpan is not a matter of choice but a mandatory commandment of the Guru. To enable law-abiding Sikhs to stay true to their faith will go a long way toward earning the gratitude and goodwill of the Sikhs. JASPINDER SINGH, Kanata Misuse of power It’s unacceptable for Navdeep Bains, parliamentary secretary to the prime minister, to use his position of power to interfere with the safety of VIA Rail passengers. When there was controversy over RCMP officers wearing turbans, I supported the officers. I didn’t support them because of the religious value of the turban but because I value their personal freedom to choose. However, I do not support the wearing of a sword by a VIA Rail passenger because personal freedom is overtaken in this case by safety concerns. The safety concern is not limited to the wearer of the sword. There is also a concern about potential actions by other passengers. Like the wearing of a sword in schools, this matter should be examined purely on the basis of safety. If we allow this sword to be worn everywhere because of its religious value to one group, what other weapons are we also willing to allow? What if other religious groups feel it is their right to carry guns or hand grenades? VIA Rail employees or even governments should not have to make judgments on the validity of one religion or another. They should decide simply on the basis of public safety. I believe that this is what VIA Rail did in this case. Mr. Bains should thank them for it. FRED MAROUN, Ottawa Simple solution Since the kirpan is symbolic only, wouldn’t the simple solution be to make it out of a harmless material such as plastic? Surely that would satisfy both the people who want to wear it and the others who would no longer fear it any more than a child’s toy sword. SYLVIANE DUVAL, Ingleside Should be grateful Re: Liberal MP calls VIA’s banning of ceremonial sword ‘unacceptable,’ OCT. 26. Navdeep Bains, MP for Mississauga-Brampton South, believes that VIA Rail’s banning of the kirpan ceremonial sword is unacceptable, and he intends to pursue the matter with VIA executives, the board of directors, and the minister of Transport. Does Mr. Bains also believe that swords of religious significance should be allowed on Air Canada flights? The right of all Canadians to personal safety on any form of public transportation must supercede the right of religious expression. VIA Rail, Air Canada and other carriers have a duty to refuse boarding to anyone carrying a weapon, regardless of its spiritual significance to the owner. As a passenger, I would insist on it. VIA Rail employees did the right thing, and they should not be blamed or otherwise criticized by Mr. Bains for exercising good judgment. JEFF SHAVER, Orléans Seek understanding I am very aware of and respectful of the Sikhs in Canada with whom I have come in close contact through the Ottawa branch of the interfaith organization World Conference of Religions and Peace. Like all religions, Sikhism has some traditions and practices that are not always understood. In the recent incident on VIA Rail where the Sikh was stopped from carrying the religious kirpan on board, one can appreciate both the Sikh’s and the railway’s perspectives. The Sikhs traditionally wear the kirpan as a symbol of their faith that has never been used in violent acts. VIA Rail takes all precautions to ensure that no weapons or sharp instruments are carried on board to protect to all passengers. In the present climate of fear of terrorism or attacks on a train, one can come to a Canadian compromise solution that respects the Sikhs and ensures the psychological safety of passengers: properly store the sacred kirpans during voyages and return it to the passenger on arrival. Most important, all parties must realize that the kirpan is sacred and not a weapon. The key is to come up with a peaceful resolution of the diversity we face. ROMAN MUKERJEE, Ottawa

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

* · 28 Oct 2005

A lot of people think the solution is to wear plastic kirpans. This is why it is so important for Sikhs to realize that a kirpan must be of sarbloh. When people suggest that we trade our real kirpans for plastic ones in the name of safety, what can steel-kirpan wearing Sikhs say? Steel is better than plastic, we must stick with steel?? A kirpan must be of sarbloh in order to be considered a kakaar. Plastic, steel, etc won't suffice. Our kirpans must be of sarbloh and only sarbloh. A plastic kirpan is not a compromise Sikhs can make. A plastic kirpan is not the solution to this issue.

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

J singh · 28 Oct 2005

"Guru Gobind Singh Ji made it mandatory for the kirpan to be worn at all times by male members of the Sikh faith." ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- AND WOMEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

... · 28 Oct 2005

Tejdeep Singh had written "worn at all times by members of the Sikh faith" and the paper themselves changed it to "male" members Tejdeep Singh wrote the following in response: >>>>>>>>>> just got off the phone with the editor, after some debate he has agreed to run this in tommorows paper... "There was an editting mistake in Tejdeeps letter, Kirpans aren't for males of the sikh faith. Kirpans are actaully for Males and Females of the Sikh Faith" in my discussion with the editor, he was pretty much shocked to know that females also wear a kirpan.. hes like 'this is a male issue', im like 'no its a Sikh issue, Sikhs have full equality kirpans are for females and males', hes like 'no one knows that', im like 'yea tahts why im asking you to correct the mistake you made in editting the letter, so people will know'... i guess this conversation shows that ppl think we are a backward religion that is male dominated. We have to make a greater effort to bring Singhnia to the forefront when dealing with the media... Knowing females where kirpans will go along way in changing peoples perception

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

Singh · 28 Oct 2005

i guess even the newspaper editors hate us

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

Singh · 29 Oct 2005

I live in Vancouver, and used to take the skytrain daily. Only once in my life did police approach me for wearing a Kirpan. They came upto me and said, "Excuse me sir, but a passenger complained that you have a knife on you". I said to them, "I am wearing a Kirpan", and they responded by saying, "Can we please see it?" I showed them the Kirpan, and they said, "Yup, okay. Its a Kirpan. Thank you sir, have a nice day". They just wanted to see it, and when they saw that it was a traditional Kirpan (Taksali), they just said okay and left. I hope that the whole world could be this way. Also once, a guy i know was wearing Kirpan in a mall, and a security officer saw it and told him to leave, but the Singh refused and the police were called. The police made the security guard apologize to the Singh and also told the manager of the security company to teach his security guards about what a Kirpan is, and that they should never ask anyone to leave the mall for wearing a Kirpan.

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

singh · 29 Oct 2005

Sikhs all over the world must realise that they need to educate the media, Governments and the general public. Nobody says Orthodox Jews are strange because that have formed powerful lobbies. Young educated Sikhs(There plenty of doctors,accountants and IT staff out there) should educate non Sikhs

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

Kulwinder Singh · 30 Oct 2005

Sikh are in successful in Canadian politics, Business, Police and other services, Education , Music and so on so …….. , If every body in Canada hate Sikhs they would not have done so well, Don’t label the whole of Canada as bigot, because it is not. 1. You must see improve your positive points and abandon bad ones. 2. then see things clearly 3. improve your PR 4. Show your loyalty to Canada 5. Show your true love for humanity 6. Show the humbleness of our Guru’s in your daily life 7. and so on………. Then judge for yourself what Canadian think about Sikhs.

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

yo · 30 Oct 2005

is there gonig to be some sort of a rally or protest for this situation, i say we get singhs together and protest outside the VIA offices, whereever they are, and carry signs like the singhs in France about the head covering's ban

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

Canadian Singh · 30 Oct 2005

Kulwinder Singh, so are you trying to imply that it is the fault of the Sikhs that Balpreet Singh had to face this humiliation? -------------------------------- 1. You must see improve your positive points and abandon bad ones. -------------------------------- I dont understand is what 'bad points' are you refering to because of which balpreet singh had to face this? -------------------------------- 4. Show your loyalty to Canada -------------------------------- How are Sikhs not showing there loyalty to Canada? I wasn't aware that Sikhs were 'disloyal' to Canada to begin with. ------------------------------- 5. Show your true love for humanity 6. Show the humbleness of our Guru’s in your daily life ------------------------------- Sikhs do that all the time. We make donations, ask for "sarbat dha bhala" in our ardaas everyday. Kulvinder Singh, it seems like are blaiming Sikhs for this. Dont you understand? we can do all the things you have stated(most of which we already do) and still it will not make a difference to some ignorant people. For them it doesnt not matter that Canadian Sikhs like Balpreet Singh was born and raised in Canada. The only thing they see is the fact that he looks different.

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

Gurpartap Singh · 31 Oct 2005

another>> by a singh :( Name: Singh Occupation: Student Location: Ottawa The editorial comparison of trains and planes isn't correct. If the visible kirpan should not be allowed because it is a danger on the train, then there should also be precautions for the invisible danger that could be in baggage or hidden on the person. That would require baggage checks and metal detectors. The threat posed by the kirpan is insubstantial compared to the threat posed by giving passengers knives and forks with their meals. Or the threat posed by those who might bring real weapons with them in their baggage. Those threats aren't addressed by VIA policy, but a Sikh wearing his kirpan over his clothes is a focus?

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

name change · 31 Oct 2005

those aint the views of most canadians i live in bc and most people here dont say nothing to us. i've seen singhs walk around with 3 ft sri sahibs no one says anything. its just the views of a few people. there was stuff written in papers here and everyone was understand dont base your judgements on a few people. to be honest with u canada is one of the best places to live in. and have freedoms compared to other countries.

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

uk singh · 31 Oct 2005

Please read http://www.worldsikh.org/sikhism/articles_of_faith/5_k_background.pdf

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

Iron Man · 31 Oct 2005

Panthic weekly has two awesome articles on this in this weeks issue: http://www.panthic.org/news/123/ARTICLE/1931/2005-10-30.html http://www.panthic.org/news/131/ARTICLE/1930/2005-10-30.html

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

Kulwinder Singh · 31 Oct 2005

Dear Canadian Singh Ji, You have completely taken my points from the worst point of view, I have said above comments in response to the heading of the debate that. What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs And it is full of negative comments from people, who are obviously bigots, My Main point is “Don’t label the whole of Canada as bigot, because it is not.” The point you have highlighted +++++++++++++++my writing and your comments+++++++++++++++++ 1. You must see improve your positive points and abandon bad ones. I don’t understand is what 'bad points' are you referring to because of which balpreet singh had to face this? ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ======== my reply===== When I said bad points is that we need root out the racism elements within our community, Some non Asian people do claim that they feel the treatment some Asian (Sikhs included) give to others is less then deserved, ======================== +++++++++++++++your comments+++++++++++++++ so are you trying to imply that it is the fault of the Sikhs that Balpreet Singh had to face this humiliation? ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ==== my reply===== I am not imply anything to put the blame on the Sikhs, I am suggesting a way forward. =========================== +++++++++++++++my writing and your comments+++++++++++++++++ Show your loyalty to Canada How are Sikhs not showing there loyalty to Canada? I wasn't aware that Sikhs were 'disloyal' to Canada to begin with. +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ===========my reply============ The point here is not of being disloyal, the point here is to show how Sikhs have contributed to Canada’s betterment and Over the 100 Years, Sikhs have maintained their religion in harmony with the rest of Canadian population in most fantastic ways, ( Sikhs may have been in trouble with one and another but not with anybody else).Many non Sikhs think Sikhism is a just another typical religion which have it’s own political aims which compromise or intend to compromise the political configuration of the country, Which is not the case in Sikhism. A Sikh can be loyal to any country they live in without in conflict with their religion. ============================================= +++++++++++++++my writing and your comments+++++++++++++++++ 5. Show your true love for humanity 6. Show the humbleness of our Guru’s in your daily life Sikhs do that all the time. We make donations, ask for "sarbat dha bhala" in our ardaas everyday. +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ========My Reply======== Fantastic ! But make sure you tell at least 5 people who are not aware of this fact and encourage other Sikhs to do so as well. ========================================= +++++++++++++++my writing and your comments+++++++++++++++++ Kulvinder Singh, it seems like are blaming Sikhs for this. Don’t you understand? we can do all the things you have stated(most of which we already do) and still it will not make a difference to some ignorant people. For them it doesn’t not matter that Canadian Sikhs like Balpreet Singh was born and raised in Canada. The only thing they see is the fact that he looks different. +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ==============my reply================ My Dear I am not blaming Sikhs at all, and I do understand that some people’s attitude towards something different is less then desirable, I am also glad that you are saying the similar thing as me that “some Ignorant people“ will not change, Yes you are right my friend, Even when some people saw Guru Nanak Dev Ji himself they were not able to grasp the simple truth Guru Ji was telling , they called him names and were abusive some time. So That is how some people are, but we all should make positive and more positive change in ourselves so it may have effect on others in long term. In a nutshell, All I am saying is don’t think that few letters and some editorials should be taken as the voice of whole nation, Canada have fantastic reputation for being very progressive society , don’t let anybody tarnish it. If you think positive, act positive and promote positive the outcome will be positive! ===================================================== I do apologies if I hurt anybody’s sentiments in the comments I made that was not my intention. I hope I have cleared my point of view, Please feel free to criticise me if required. Best Regards Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: What Canadians Really Think of Sikhs

Gurcharan Singh · 01 Nov 2005

Kulwinder Singh ji , dont worry the Sikhs are the worst enemies of themselves.There is atendency among Sikhs to twist anything good written by any Sikh. Not long ago, I asked Sikhs to show their loyalty to the cocntries they live in , and stand with the government shoulder to shoulder...many many in fact most here responded with accusations of asking Sikhs to lick the A off the whites!!That is how pathethic their mentality is. I now see the same ones asking how are they NOt loyal to the cocuntry !!! it is thanks to such and those mindless thinkers taht Sikhs still continue to get bad image many times. Whta you have said is very said. We are generally a successful community, but the black sheep among us will continue to give the publicity not wanted. Just watch the space and observe this debate turns into an argument and then goes off the point altogther. Well what do we expect of Sikhs who still think in terms of jat, khatri, Zhiver or Kummiar , then they say they are SIKHS!!!