Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sehjdhari Khalsa, Please READ

Sehjdhari Khalsa, Please READ

Singh · 29 Oct 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Nearly 3 years after Baisakhi of 1699 Guru ji wrote letters (hukamnamas to some sahejdhari Sikhs - non amritdhari) on 6 February 1702 signed (characteristic authentic Nissan of tenth Guruji) by Guruji. The following is the text of one of these written to Sikhs presumably in Patna as the letter is preserved there. "Ek Oankar Satguru ji. Siri Guru ji di agaya hai Bhai Mihar Chand Karam Chand, Guru rakhega. Guru Guru japna janam saurega. Tusi mera Khalsa ho. Ik sau ik 101) rupiah haathi di phurmais hukam dekhde he sitabee hundee karai bhejni. Ar hor jo kichh Guru ke namit ka hovai so apai lai avna. Hathiar banh ke avgu so nihal hogu. Us di ghaal thai pavagu Guru naal rahgu. Guru ke navit ka hovai so horus kise no nahee dena ar masand, masandiay naal naahee milna, nahee mannanna, Jo sikh mile so mail laina. Vadheek dikkat naahee karni. Mera hukam hai sangat. Sammat 1758 miti Fago 10, satran Ath 8." This is its translation. Ek Oankar Satguru ji. This is the command of Siri Guru ji (for) Bhai Mihar Chand and Karam Chand Guru shall protect you. Remember and recite Guru your life shall become worthwhile. YOU ARE MY KHALSA. Your name has been proposed for arranging 101 Rupees for (procuring) an elephant. On seeing this command immediately send a draft, and anything else offered in the name of the Guru, you should bring with you. Those of you who will come adorning weapons shall be blessed, their efforts shall bear fruit and their loyalty to Guru shall be upheld. Anything offered in the name of Guru is not to be handed over to anyone else. And you should not socialise with a Masand or a Masand follower nor honour them. Any sikh who intends to join (sangat) should be admitted, you should not create too much hinderance. This is my command to the Sangat. Sammat(the Indian Bikrami calendar) 1758 Date Fago(Faggan the last month of the Indian year) 10 (Western calendar 6 February 1702) Lines eight 8. This letter is in the Harimandar Sahib Patna (Hukamname edited by Ganda Singh, Hukamnama No. 55, published by Punjabi University Patiala, 1967) Very important points that emerge from this Hukamnama are: 1. This is an actual document signed by tenth Guru ji nearly 3 years after the Baisakhi 1699 rather than some doubtful Rahitnama hence reflecting the actual view or attitude towards the sikhs to whom letter was wirtten. 2. The letter was written to two persons who from their name are obviously not Singhs but with 'Chand' surname hence not amritdhari. 3. The most odd thing is that Guru ji clearly says "Tusi Mera Khalsa Ho" ie You are my Khalsa". This is unusual in the sense that it means Guruji was not reserving the term Khalsa only for Amritdharis but for some Sahejdhari Sikhs as well. 4. Guru ji appears to be more concerned about by-passing the Masands for remitting the offerings directly to Guru ji rather than anything such as urge them to get baptised. 5. In terms of physical appearance (such as kakkaars etc) again Guruji is more particular about the Sikhs arriving with weapons on their person rather than fomally being baptised and bearing "Singh" surname. 6. In order to secure against any forgery Guru ji put his characteristic Nissan (usually brief Mool Mantar in his own hand) on the letter and even gave the number of lines of text in the letter as 8 at the end of the letter. This was the usual security arrangement. Comparison with numerous other such letters by Guru ji confirms that this is an authentic letter. 7. The rigid definition of a Khalsa that we are now given to accept does not seem to apply here. The main criteria for a Khalsa Guru ji appears to be emphasising is not to use the Masand channel to approach Guruji but to have direct connection with Guru ji. Indeed this is what the word "Khalisah" meant in the then existing usage of this term in the Mughal revenue administration of that time. Similarly there is another letter written to the Sangat in Dhaka (Bangladesh) addressed to Bhai Brindaban and Gulal Chand (ibid. Hukamnama 57) with almost identical text such as "Tusi mera khalsa ho" and commanding again 101 rupees to be arranged and coming with weapons on and not socialising with Masands.

Re: Sehjdhari Khalsa, Please READ

... · 29 Oct 2005

That's not much of a find. Even Gurus before Guru Gobind Singh were using the term "Khalsa" to refer to certain sangats. Khalsa means that land which is governed directly by the King, without an intermediatary. There being no masand, that sangat would be a "Khalsa" sangat. Khalsa in that context is different than the Khalsa we refer to as being amritdhari. It was a hukam of Guru Gobind Singh that all Sikhs receive Khanday Kee Paahul. No ifs ands or buts.

Re: Sehjdhari Khalsa, Please READ

Singh · 29 Oct 2005

I have also found the below: Available Hukamnamas of some Gurus and important personalities edited by Shamsher Singh Ashok were published by the Shiromani Gurdwara Prabandhak Committee, Amritsar in 1967. Original spadework was done by the great historian of Sikhism, Dr. Ganda Singh, who had got his compilation by the Punjabi University, Patiala. Most Hukamnamas are common to both the publications. Translations of a few of the Hukamnamas published by the SGPC are presented here below for the appreciation of the Sikhnet Sangat. HUKNAMAS OF GURU GOBIND SINGH JI: The one at Sr. No.83: Ek-Onkar Satiguru jio By the directions of Sri Guru jio Bhai Mehar Chand Jatt you have the blessings of the Guru You must meditate upon the Guru to redeem your birth You are my Khalsa One tola (about 10 grams) gold is desired Send it by hundi (a sort of bill of exchange) urgently upon seeing this hukam Guru will bless you You must not deal with Masands or their agents You must not feel it a trouble and must welcome any Sikh you come across Any Sikh who comes to see me carrying arms would be blessed it is my order All ablations, offerings and tithe etc. whatever is due to the Guru must be brought personally and may not be entrusted to anybody else It shall earn appreciation and pleasure (of the Guru) Dated Phagun 10 Samvat 1758 Lines 10? The one at Sr. No.84: Ek-Onkar Satiguru jio By the directions of Sri Guru jio Bhai Mehar Chand Peshkar of Khufiye Navees you are my Khalsa and have Guru?s blessings Meditate on Guru to redeem your birth Twenty five rupees are desired Send it by hundi urgently upon seeing this hukam You will earn the pleasure and blessings of the Guru You must not deal with Masands or their agents Whatever is due to the Guru may be brought to the Guru personally to earn his blessings Welcome any Sikh you come across without feeling any trouble to earn my pleasure Effort of those who come armed for darshan shall bear fruit Dated Phagun 10 Samvat 1758 Lines 9? The one at Sr. No.86: Ek-Onkar Satguru ji By the directions of Sri Guru ji Bhai Mehar Chand Dharam Chand Karam Chand you are blessed by the Guru Meditate upon the Guru to redeem your birth You are my Khalsa Rupees one hundred are desired for elephant Send urgently by hundi upon seeing hukam Whatever is due to the Guru be brought personally Whosoever comes armed for darshan shall be blessed His efforts shall bear fruit and he shall bear with the Guru Whatever is due to the Guru may not be given to anyone else You must not deal with the Masands or their agents Welcome any Sikh you come across without feeling any trouble It is my order for the sangat Samvat 1758 dated Phagun 10 Lines 8? The one at Sr. No.90: Ek-Onkar Sri Satguru jio By the directions of the Guru It is my order for the whole sangat that Gani Khan and Nabi Khan are my children They have obliged me Those Sikhs who feel pleasure in serving them shall have my blessings They are my people The Sikhs who serve them shall thus serve me Samvat 1762? HUKAMNAMA OF MATA SAHIB DEVI, at Sr. No.106: Ek-Onkar Sri Waheguru ji Ki Fateh Khalsa of Sri Akal Purakh It is with the directions of Sri Mata Sahib Devi Bhai Thakur Das Bhai Sobhai Mal Chopra Bhai Simbhu Nath Bhai Sahib Rai sarbat Khalsa of Benaras is blessed by Guru Meditate upon the Guru to redeem your birth I am pleased by you You are my sons my children May Guru fulfill your desires It is desired that you send rupees fifty for the langar by hundi urgently upon seeing this request through Bhai Sidhu Singh Mewarha to kothi of Sri Waheguru ji in Benaras. This sewa be done keenly Whosoever serves the langar keenly his labours shall receive the Guru?s bounties Samvat 1786 Chet Sudi 11 Lines 14?” Hence the question, why is Guru Sahib calling monai "khalsa", does this mean the term is not just for Amridhari's, and Monai's can also be "Khalsa"?

Re: Sehjdhari Khalsa, Please READ

Singh · 29 Oct 2005

"It was a hukam of Guru Gobind Singh that all Sikhs receive Khanday Kee Paahul. No ifs ands or buts." Where is the above hukam, I have never seen it anywhere apart from the Kabul Hukamnamah and Eh Nishani Panj from Dhasm Granth both of which people on this site would argue are fake as they do not mention Keski.

Re: Sehjdhari Khalsa, Please READ

Singh · 29 Oct 2005

Forgot to ask where is proof of "Even Gurus before Guru Gobind Singh were using the term "Khalsa" to refer to certain sangats."

Re: Sehjdhari Khalsa, Please READ

singh2 · 29 Oct 2005

REad 'bhai Gurdass Ji's Vaarn, wherin He states that those who have not undergone the initation (Pahul) do not have a Guru. I agree, that Khalsa is more than just Amritdhaaree. A Muslim who is pure could be 'Khalsa. Still, it does not refer to everyday ordinary peopel who try to follow Sikhi but cut their hair. If you have faith in the Guru, you should start moving towards Amrit, ji.

Re: Sehjdhari Khalsa, Please READ

... · 29 Oct 2005

Proof that Gurus before Guru Gobind Singh used the term "Khalsa" for sangats they directly adminstered without an intermediatery: Hukumnama of Guru Hargobind Sahib in Dr. Ganda Singh's book "Hukumnamey" pg. 67, "Poorab dee sangat Guru da Khalsa hai, uprant Guru dee aagyaa hai...." and makes the order for the service required. Guru Gobind Singh jee's desire that all Sikhs receive Khanday Kee Paahul comes from a lot of sources, " The Rehitnamas clearly say a number of times that all Sikhs should receive Khanday Kee Pahul and the famous quote "pritham rehit ye jaan, Khanday kee pahul chhakay...." from the Bhai Desa Singh rehitnama comes to mind first. Sainapati, the writer of Gursobha in 1711, declared that “it was the wish of Gobind Singh that all Sikhs turn Khalsa .” Similarly in the Amarnamah by Nathmal, a document appended to a copy of the Gursobha and dated October 8, 1708 the Guru “commanded the Sikhs to be courageous and to come to him for taking amrit ”. It thus seems that Khalsa identity was indeed intended for all Sikhs But was the Sahajdhari identity considered an acceptable form of Sikh identity? The Bhagatratnavalee helps answer this question. The Bhagatratnavalee is a text attributed to Bhai Mani Singh but due to textual references to the Bhai in the third person is likely not by him. “The work may be dated between AD 1706....and AD 1737.” The Bhagatratnavalee includes a conversation between the Sahajdharis and Guru Gobind Singh in which the Sahajdharis seem to differentiate between themselves and “Sikhs” or the Khalsa. The Sahajdharis allow that they are indeed not fully Sikhs and the Guru also encourages them to adopt Khalsa practices while acknowledging that they are not yet ready to abandon many Hindu customs. There are clear directions that the Sahajdharis should eventually embrace the Khalsa identity. When the Sahajdharis wonder what ceremonies to perform for their young sons who used to undergo the ritual shaving or Bhadun, Guru Gobind Singh orders “give Paahul to the sons of the Sahajdharis”. The Sahajdharis are even told “those of you who are Sahajdhari Sikhs, if you can keep your form complete like the keshdharis, it is good” The Sahajdharis complain “At the time of weddings, we would call the Brahmins to read the Vedas and the hymns of marriage. Now the Sikhs say ‘you should marry by reading the Anand, do not call the Brahmins.” The Guru advises them to first do Ardas and the Anand, followed by whatever practices they followed previously. Subsequently the Sahajdharis say that the “Sikhs say now that the Vahiguru has revealed the Khalsa, you must not perform the ceremonies of the rest of the world”. Discussions with the Guru address different issues including death rituals, the practice of Sharadh, bathing at the Ganges etc. Overall, the Sahajdharis complain that the “Sikhs” are telling them to abandon Hindu life rituals and the Guru in response attempts to slowly wean them away from the Hindus and towards the Khalsa. This account of the tension between the Khalsa and the Sahajdharis is also cited by Sainapati who writes that the “Khatris in particular were opposed to the injunction regarding keeping the hair uncut because ceremonially cutting of the hair was a part of their ceremonial practices” and that they largely opposed the Khalsa. Nonetheless, what is made clear in the Bhagatratnavalee is that the Sahajdharis were not considered to have a legitimate Sikh identity but “Sahajdhari” was a halfway house between Hindu and Sikh.

Re: Sehjdhari Khalsa, Please READ

Gurpartap Singh · 29 Oct 2005

in reply to 1st comment, by ... khalsa is not a meaning of an amritdhari, but Khalsa means pure as Khalas[pure] as we say Khalas Ghee, desi ghee, pure ghee. and this purity is refered for an amritdhari singh. also, khalistan is called the land of pure, where khalis=pure and tan=land.

Re: Sehjdhari Khalsa, Please READ

A Singh · 01 Nov 2005

It is true that Guru Sahib had a recorded conversation with the Sahejdhari Khalsa in the form of 10 questions. I suggest that all Amritdharis and non-Amritdharis kindly read this with an open mind. It is a great piece of work since its implications would lead to a much greater unification in the Panth with little room for people to have splits in Jathabandis or face threats from the RSS, Tat Khalsa, Kala Afghanites, Sanatanists or whoever. The record is quite clear in this hukamnama, Guru Sahib is fully appreciative of the fact that not everyone is necessarily ready to become a full Amritdhari Khalsa and makes provisions for this - HOWEVER, those who use this as an excuse to deny the necessity of Amrit, READ CAREFULLY the last question and answer concerning death ceremonies- Guru Sahib clearly states that the Sehajdhari will need to become Amritdhari at some stage, be that in this life or the next. I personally feel if we as a Panth were able to put into practice these directives, Amritdharis and Non-Amritdharis should have no problem in co-existing in a more cohesive fashion in a unified Panth. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Sehjdhari Khalsa, Please READ

Singh · 02 Nov 2005

"It is true that Guru Sahib had a recorded conversation with the Sahejdhari Khalsa in the form of 10 questions." Is the above disputed or authentic?

Re: Sehjdhari Khalsa, Please READ

Gurcharan Singh · 02 Nov 2005

Gurpartap Singh Date: 10-29-05 16:40 in reply to 1st comment, by ... khalsa is not a meaning of an amritdhari, but Khalsa means pure as Khalas[pure] as we say Khalas Ghee, desi ghee, pure ghee. and this purity is refered for an amritdhari singh. also, khalistan is called the land of pure, where khalis=pure and tan=land. --------------------------------------------------------------------- The last is WRONG and wrongly interpreted. Khalistan means "the land of the pure" The word is made of two parts-khali--stan Khali- mean empty Stan means -land .....in farsee and arabic. "taan"- as Gurpartap singh ji says DOES NOT Mean LAND.Taan is altogether a different word and meaning. It is 'stan' that means land.