Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Shahbaaz khalsa · 31 Oct 2005

Open letter from Shahbaaz Khalsa to Amarinder Singh and Parkash Badal From panhic weekely - Recently after the debate at the Punjab Vidhan Sabha on the root causes of terrorism in Punjab, officials of the Shahbaaz Khalsa wrote an open letter to the current and previous Punjab Chief Ministers – Amarinder Singh and Parkash Badal. Where both these personalities held Sikh freedom fighters responsible for being the root cause of terrorism in Punjab, Shahbaaz Khalsa had another story to tell. In this publication of Panthic Weekly, we present to you the main points of the open letter by Shahbaaz Khalsa along with the original letter addressed to Amarinder Singh and Parkash Badal. A Link to the original letter can be found at the bottom of this page. Both parties – the Congress and the Akali Dal took the blame for promoting terrorism off themselves by pointing their fingers at a third party–the Sikh Militants-saying they were responsible for terrorizing the state. But how can this accusation be considered correct when the stance of the third party is not even considered in the debate? The Sikh Nation still respects those Sikh militants as their freedom fighters. When talking about terrorism, India’s ancient history should also be considered. The root causes could easily be found within the history of the 'country'. Just as how Bibi Rajinder Bhathal opened the debate by mentioning the history of AryaVarat, we too will begin our letter here. The actual cause of the trouble actually lies within the history itself. Why don’t we shed some light on the heroes of Indian history so you too can also identify the actual terrorists? 1. Raam Chander Ji: - Historical scriptures refer to this personality as the Maryada Purushottam (ideal man), but in reality Ram Chandra Ji could also be considered a very barbaric terrorist. Just by reading the Ramayan, the evil deeds of this person can be identified. The whole fight of Ramayan took place because of Raam Chander. At one time when Ravan’s sister Saroop Nakha approached Raam with a marriage proposal, Raam refused while telling her that he is already married, sendin g her to Lachman. He lied to her about him being unmarried when he was already married. When she met Isn’t cutting the nose of a woman who comes with a marriage proposal an act of terrorism? Why is it that both of you never cared to label this ideal man a terrorist? Would you consider the act of killing the Shudhar saint who worshipped God as an act of friendliness? He forced his wife into ‘Agni Prikhiya’ and yet disowned her when she was pregnant. Would this be considered an act of love? It would take a long time to mention all the acts of Raja Raam Chander Ji. More can easily be found by reading the ‘terrorist’ scripture Tulsi Ramayan. 2. Hanumaan: - This person is known for committing many sadistic crimes at a young age. In his youth, he abducted the ‘Suraj Devta’! He was also responsible for destroying the Lanka. It is agreed that Ravan was responsible for abducting Sita, but was the destruction of the whole Lanka as revenge reasonable? Here, its about mass killing. 3. Krishan Ji: - Just like Raam, this person is also considered an incarnation of Vishnu. Wasn’t he responsible for having an affair with his aunt Radha? What was the reason behind his acts towards Rukamani and Chandrawal? He was also responsible for starting the battle of the Mahabharat by deceiving Arjun. This battle would have stopped if he wished but he instead decided to get brothers to fight amongst themselves. He also got Arjun to kill his teacher Dronacharya by getting Yudhister to lie about Asvatthama’s death. To find more on these ‘terrorist’ acts, please refer to the Mahabharat, Sukh Sagar and Gita. 4. Inder and Brahma Ji: - I feel ashamed to write about the acts of these fellows. Bibi Rajinder Bhathal referred to the Rig Vedh during the debate. When any person joins in the worship of God, the throne of these personalities gets waved and they send elegant looking women such as Menka and Urvashi to put obstacles in the way of these Bhagats. These are the daring acts of these people. To write the story of Ahilya’s rape is impossible for me. You can read it in the Rig Vedh yourself. On this incident Gurbani states: To read about Brahma Ji, you can refer to the history of Kopal Mochan. It’s your wish where you want to place these two fellows in the list of terrorists. For more examples refer to Shiv Puran Brahm Puran, Rig Vedh and Inder Puran. Respected Raja Sahib and Badal Sahib, we know very well that it’s not possible for both of you to consider the above mentioned persons as terrorists. But we hope that you aren’t tired yet of hearing the stories of terrorists. Please forgive us, but in our small thinking we have a huge list of those who terrorized India. To mention all of them would not be possible. But before leaving this topic we would like to touch the subject of the terrifying scriptures: 1. Manu Simriti: - This great scripture was penned by Brahma Ji’s great son Manu. All of the saloks from this scripture deal with keeping the low caste and women away from their worldly needs. It talks of dishonoring low caste women and how the low caste men and women are impure. 2. Chanakya Niti: - Not only does this scripture talk about ruling through separation, it also teaching the theory of ‘Sham, Daam, Dandh, Bhed’. Sham which means to make others agree by using cunning means, dham means to buy support of people, dhandh means that if they still don’t agree, punish them (just like false police encounters). These are the terror filled teachings of these scripture. But I doubt that any of you will agree to consider these scriptures as being the cause of terrorism. This is because both of you are believers of Indian politics which arose from the teachings of these scriptures. But let’s move on. Let me remind you that our subject is to discuss “who is the actual terrorist”. We have only shown you the advertisement so far, the whole film is yet to follow. Historical Terrorism: - After discussing these scriptures, let us look at Hindu terrorism during the time of Buddhism. Where Buddhism teaches equality among humans, love for humanity, non-violence and enlightenment, the Hindus promote worship of 33 million deities, separation of human kind, Sati tradition, degradation of women and other such things. This religion of Buddhism which was becoming widely accepted all throughout the country at the time of Ashok started to look dangerous in the eyes of the Brahmin terrorists. After the death of Ashok, Buddhism was wiped from India by these Brahmins. Not thousands, but hundreds of thousands of Buddhist temples were demolished. Those Buddhists who were left alive after these massacres went to places such as China, Burma, Thailand, Cambodia and Japan to save this great religion. This religion again grew successfully in these countries. If these acts of Brahmins aren’t acts of terrorism, then what are they? Would your Sadan be interesting in opening a debate on the black acts of these terrorists? If such a time ever comes, we will surely attend the debate along with historical scriptures, Buddhist scholars, pro-terrorism Hindu scriptures, and the writings of respected Dr. Bhim Rao Ambedkar and Dalit literature. Respected leader sahibs, both of you took birth in eminent Sikh families. You must be knowledgeable in Sikh history. We are mentioning some names from it. Our small thinking considers these names terrorists, but what would you consider them as? 1. Chandu: - This dirty terrorist became the reason of Guru Arjan Dev Ji’s martyrdom. 2. Gangu Brahmin: - This person’s seed is still present in the Congress Government’s leadership. Where he should have been thankful to the Gurughar, he instead got Guru Gobind Singh Ji’s younger sons bricked alive. 3. Hill Kings (Pahari Rajae): - These kings always envied Guru Gobind Singh Ji for putting a stop to the caste system by administering Amrit. Those like Bhim Chand and Fateh Shah are included in these kings who uselessly carried out battles with Singhs. These people took oaths in front of cows made out of flour but later went against all the promises that they made. Where would you line these Brahmin backstabbers in the outfit of terrorists? At the time of Maharaja Ranjit Singh: - These terrorists are responsible for destroying the rule of Maharaja Ranjit Singh. After gaining high ranks in the kingdom of gracious King Dhian Singh, they later backstabbed the Sikhs by getting Kanvar Naunihal Singh, Maharaja Kharak Singh, S. Shaam Singh Ataari, Maharani Jind Kaur, S. Ajit Singh Sandhavlea, S. Lehna Singh and other Sikh Sardars killed. Wouldn’t you consider these people terrorists? Time of English rule: - Nathu Ram Godse has been recognized as a terrorist for killing the ‘peace-loving’ Congress leader Mohandas Ghandi, but when would you consider this person a terrorist? RSS and companion terrorist groups: - Both of you should know that the group which declared ‘Hindu Hindi Hindustan’ came into existence in 1920. Badal is very close with its political wing – the Bhajpa. This organization’s main goal is to preach “If you wish to live in Hindustan, you must speak in favor of Hinduism.” This group is responsible for creating more than 70 riots in different places from 1947 to 1992. More than 50,000 Muslims have also been killed by this organization. Along with other like minded groups, the RSS demolished the Babri Masjid. In 2002 alone, thousands of Muslims were killed and their daughters were dishonored under the guidance of the RSS leadership. Would you consider organizations such as the RSS, Shiv Sena, Bajrang Dal, and VHP as terrorist organizations? Would you consider their leaders such as Uma Bharti, Sadhvi Retambra, Govindachariya as terrorists? Isn’t the act of distributing Tirshuls in public and threatening minorities a terrorist act? Let’s turn towards Punjab now: - Respected Raja Sahib and Badal Sahib, you have both looked at Sikh militants with the wrong point of view. To help you both gain more knowledge of the Sikh freedom struggle, it’s important that we identify the terrorists of that time as well. Because the Indian Government is responsible for carrying out several massacres of Punjabis and Sikhs after 1947, it is not possible to discuss all of them here. But let’s look at some of the incidents. Respected Raja Sahib, the party of which you are a leader, the same party’s Chanakya-minded leader Nehru agreed to the separation of the nation for the sake of his leadership. For Gandhi to disagree with the promises that he made at the time of partition, and for Valab Bhai Patel to issue degrading remarks towards the Sikh community, isn’t that considered intellectual terrorism? Illegal separation of Punjab’s land and water, and creation of Chandigarh as a Union Territory is terrifying. And respected Badal Sahib, history is a witness to the mass killings of Communists in Punjab which started to take place during your regime. These people were killed in fake encounters. Can you please tell me if this isn’t a terrorist act? Let us now look at the events of 1978. During this time you were in power in Punjab and the Central Government was under the control of the BJP. During this time 13 innocent Sikhs were killed by the Nirankaris. What is most absurd is that you gave them permission to carry out their parade on the day of Vaisakhi. After the killing of Sikhs took place, the Nirankari leader Gurbhachan was safely transported out of Punjab and the cases of killing Singhs were sent out of Punjab to be dealt with; where the case file of Gurbhachan was closed, isn’t this considered a terrorist act against the Sikh community? The Nirankaris had their own army and kept weapons openly, isn’t this considered a terrorist act? It was because of your shortcomings that the Sikh youth and Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale had to take up arms to ask for their rights. Anti-Sikh slogans can still be found written on the walls of many towns of Amritsar. Why isn’t it that your Government doesn’t call people like Lakshami Kant Chawla, Baldev Raj Chawla and those like Manchanda terrorists? The result of all the practices that you carried out to make your leadership stable resulted in Operation Blue Star. In the eyes of both your parties, Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindrawale and Bhai Sukhdev Singh Babbar are considered the most dangerous terrorists, but have your ever thought of why these two are still the most respected in the eyes of the Sikh youth? Captain Sahib, can you give the reasoning behind why Indira Gandhi, your party leader, chose Guru Arjan Dev Ji’s Shaheedi Divas as the day of Operation Blue Star? Wasn’t this act barbaric? Wouldn’t you consider the killings of innocent pilgrims, dishonor of Sikh women as terrorist acts? Before Operation Blue Star was carried out, during the regime of Darbara Sinh, Singhs such as Bhai Kulwant Singh Nagoke, Bhai Gurmeet Singh Dhoorkot, and many other Sikh youth were killed in most horrifying ways. Wouldn’t you consider these acts of the Government terrorist acts? After the assassination of Indira Gandhi, wouldn’t you consider the decision to hang the innocent Kehar Singh a terrorist act? Whatever happened after the assassination of Indira Gandhi is not hidden from any of you. What are your thoughts about leaders such as Bhagat, Tytler and Lalit Maakam who were responsible for the Delhi riots? Wouldn’t you consider Rajiv Gandhi’s statement in which he said that “after a big tree falls, the Earth shakes” as terror provoking? What about the deaths of thousands of innocent Sikhs in Delhi which followed after this statement was released? What are your thoughts about those like Ray, Rubero, KPS Gill and others who were responsible for the deaths of Sikhs afterwards? Many pages could be blacked by writing about what happened during the rule of Beant Sinh. Human rights advocate S. Jaswant Singh Khalra was picked up from his house during the day and later killed by KP Gill and Ajit Sandhu. Isn’t this the limit of Governmental torture? S. Khalra had gathered proofs of 25,000 wrongful killings of Sikhs during the time of Beant Sinh’s Government in Punjab. These proofs were later accepted by the Supreme Court of India. Who knows how many bodies of Sikh Youth were disposed of by throwing them into the rivers of Punjab? Is this the peaceful approach of India? Today we declare that if all these injustices were carried out against the Sikhs to keep the peace and unity in India, then the land of Five Rivers faces immense danger from the peacekeeping ways of India and for that reason India must be considered a terrorist country. Let us also look at other states in India. Whatever the Indian forces have done in the states of Kashmir, Nagaland, Assam and Mizoram, isn’t that terrorism? You might have forgotten the signs of teeth bites on the faces of women which were given by your forces, but what happened in Manipur in the Manorma Kaand is fairly recent. Aren’t the Indian forces responsible for carrying out these acts of terrorism? Oh! We still haven’t mentioned one kind of terrorism. While only a handful of the elite leaders in India are misusing the countries funds, 80% of the population is kept away from their basic needs of life. What kind of patriotism is this? Where so many people in India die because of starvation, leaders of the country live a royal life. Conclusion: - Raja Sahib and Badal Sahib, we do not feel hesitant to say that not only are Indian leaders, Hindu terrorist organizations, political parties, cruel police officers and other forces responsible for terrorism, but also they are the terrorists themselves. So please think again as to who is responsible for terrorism? We give you an open invitation for a debate on who the actual terrorist is. We are ready to conduct any such debate in front of a peace loving organization such as Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, U.N.O. and peace loving governments anytime. ---- Recently after this letter was published by the officials of Shahbaaz Khalsa, India-based media issued stories labelling the Shahbaaz Khalsa a terrorist organization. How anyone who is willing to have public debate on this issue can be considered a terrorist organization without any basis is absolutely incredible.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Siddharth · 31 Oct 2005

<> No - This is not incredible. Any organization that writes about another religion in this derogatory a manner, deserves to be condemned by all and sundry. If you think otherwise, imagine someone writing about some of your Gurus and attaching a label of terrorist to them. If you can't even bear to think about that then what right do the officials of Shahbaz Khalsa have to criticize our Gods? This is nothing but hate-spewing against Hindus and if you think it is within your"rights" to say all these things then good luck to you. Just don't expect people to stand by you when you say foolish things like these. Regards, Sid.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Iron Man · 31 Oct 2005

[url]http://www.panthic.org/news/131/ARTICLE/1938/2005-10-30.html[/url] [%sig%]

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

The Khalsa Fauj · 31 Oct 2005

Listen to Prof. Inder Singh JI Ghagga on ram chander, kaan, etc.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Straight Arrow · 31 Oct 2005

Sat Sri Akal and Namastey, All I can say to this pathetic post is that if Ram and Krishn were terrorists then why does Gurbani praise them? Please take their names out of Gurbani whether its Ram or Krishn or Murari etc., if you think they are terrorists, otherwise when someone says: Ram Nam ki gat nahin jaani, kaise utras paara According to the officials of Shahbazkhalsa, Kabir is praising a terrorist and what's more, this is incorporated in Guru Granth Sahib. Ridiculous. Thank you.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

JEEVAN SINGH · 31 Oct 2005

ANYWHERE IN GURBANI THAT STATES ''RAM'' DOES NOT MEAN HINDU LORD RAM !!!!!!!!!!! IT MEANS GOD !!!!! IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH HINDUS OR SINDUS ! [%sig%]

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Straight Arrow · 31 Oct 2005

Author: JEEVAN SINGH Date: 10-31-05 16:36 ANYWHERE IN GURBANI THAT STATES ''RAM'' DOES NOT MEAN HINDU LORD RAM !!!!!!!!!!! IT MEANS GOD !!!!! IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH HINDUS OR SINDUS ! ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ First of all,who is a Sindu? Secondly, if it does not mean the Hindu Lord Ram, then which Ram does it mean? Do Sikhs have a separate Ram? And please respond with supporting quotes from Gurbani. Anyway, I quoted Kabir, who wasn't a Sikh to begin with. Thank you.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Iron Man · 31 Oct 2005

Straight arrow, your post shows ignorance of Sikhi.. Bhagat Kabir Jee who wrote bani was a gursikh of Guru Sahib and depending on the context, names such as raam, krishan etc refer to GOD, the ONE god, akal purakh. nobody else. in other contexts, it refers to the hindu dieties in order to tell a story.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Saffajang Singh · 31 Oct 2005

"Ik Shiv Bhaey, Ik Gaae, Raam Chandra Krishan Ki Avtaar Bhee Anaik Hai"

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Niranjan Singh · 31 Oct 2005

Siddharth, Straight Arrow : Like it or not what Shahbaaz Khalsa has written about Ram, Krishan, etc. IS what is contained in your own Hindoo scriptures. Nothing more nothing less. Read them and weep. [%sig%]

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Mehtab Singh · 31 Oct 2005

QUOTE Raam Chander Ji: - Historical scriptures refer to this personality as the Maryada Purushottam (ideal man), but in reality Ram Chandra Ji could also be considered a very barbaric terrorist. Just by reading the Ramayan, the evil deeds of this person can be identified. The whole fight of Ramayan took place because of Raam Chander. At one time when Ravan’s sister Saroop Nakha approached Raam with a marriage proposal, Raam refused while telling her that he is already married, sendin g her to Lachman. He lied to her about him being unmarried when he was already married. When she met Isn’t cutting the nose of a woman who comes with a marriage proposal an act of terrorism? Why is it that both of you never cared to label this ideal man a terrorist? Would you consider the act of killing the Shudhar saint who worshipped God as an act of friendliness? He forced his wife into ‘Agni Prikhiya’ and yet disowned her when she was pregnant. Would this be considered an act of love? It would take a long time to mention all the acts of Raja Raam Chander Ji. More can easily be found by reading the ‘terrorist’ scripture Tulsi Ramayan. QUOTE This Shabad is by Bhai Gurdaas Ji in Vaars Bhai Gurdaas on Pannaa 1 siqjug siqgur vwsdyv vwvw ivSnw nwm jpwvY] sathijug sathigur vaasadhaev vaavaa vishanaa naam japaavai|| In Satyug, Visnu in the form of Vasudev is said to have incarnated and ‘V’ Of Vahiguru reminds of Visnu. duAwpr siqgur hrIikRSn hwhw hir hir nwm iDAwvY] dhuaapar sathigur hareekrishan haahaa har har naam dhhiaavai|| The true Guru of dvapar is said to be Harikrsna and ‘H’ of Vahiguru reminds of Hari. qRyqy siqgur rwm jI rwrw rwm jpy suK pwvY] thraethae sathigur raam jee raaraa raam japae sukh paavai|| In the the treta was Ram and ‘R’ of Vahiguru tells that rembering Ram will produce joy and happiness. kiljug nwnk gur goibMd ggw goivMd nwm jpwvY] kalijug naanak gur gobi(n)dh gagaa govi(n)dh naam japaavai|| In kalijug, Gobind is in the form of Nanak and ‘G’ of Vahiguru gets Govind recited. cwry jwgy chu jugI pMcwiex ivc jwie smwvY] chaarae jaagae chahu jugee pa(n)chaaein vich jaae samaavai|| The recitations o f all the four ages subsume in Panchayan i.e. in the soul of the common man. cwroN ACr iek kr vwihgurU jp mMqR jpwvY] chaaro(n) ashhar eik kar vaahiguroo jap ma(n)thr japaavai|| When joining four letters Vahiguru is remembered, jhW qy aupijAw iPr qhW smwvY ]ôù]ñ] jehaa(n) thae oupajiaa fir thehaa(n) samaavai ||aa||a|| The jiv merges again in its origin. Bhatt Gayandh in Svaiyay Mehl 5 on Pannaa 1401 rGubMis iqlku suMdru dsrQ Gir muin bMCih jw kI srxM ] raghuba(n)s thilak su(n)dhar dhasarathh ghar mun ba(n)shhehi jaa kee sarana(n) || He is certified, like the handsome Ram Chander in the house of Dasrath of the Raghwa dynasty. Even the silent sages seek His Sanctuary. Guru Nanak Dev Ji in Raag Raamkalee on Pannaa 942 lµkw lUtI dYq sMqwpY ] la(n)kaa loottee dhaith sa(n)thaapai || The demons of passion which plundered Sri Lanka - the body - have been conquered. rwmcMid mwirE Aih rwvxu ] raamacha(n)dh maariou ahi raavan || Ram Chand - the mind - has slaughtered Raawan - pride; Guru Nanak Dev Ji in Raag Maaroo on Pannaa 1040 gurmiq ik®sin govrDn Dwry ] guramath kirasan govaradhhan dhhaarae || Through the Guru's Teachings, Krishna lifted up the mountain of Govardhan. gurmiq swieir pwhx qwry ] guramath saaeir paahan thaarae || Through the Guru's Teachings, Rama floated stones across the ocean. This Shabad is by Bhai Gurdaas Ji in Vaars Bhai Gurdaas on Pannaa 10 goqm nwr AihilAw iqsnoN dyK ieMdR loBwxw] gotham naar ahiliaa thisano(n) dhaekh ei(n)dhr lobhaanaa|| Ahalya was wife of Gautam. But when she set eyes Indhar, the king of gods, lust overpowered her. pr gr jwie srwp lY hoie shs Bg pCoqwxw] par gar jaae saraap lai hoe sehas bhag pashhothaanaa|| He entered their house, got curse of being with thousands of pudendums and repented. suM\w hoAw ieMdRlok luikAw srvr mn Srmwxw] su(n)n(j)aa hoaa ei(n)dhralok lukiaa saravar man sharamaanaa|| The Indralok (abode of Indr) became desolate and getting ashamed of himself he hid in a pond. shs Bghu loiex shs lYNdoeI ieMdRpurI isDwxw] sehas bhagahu loein sehas lai(n)adhoee ei(n)dhrapuree sidhhaanaa|| On revocation of the curse when all those holes became eyes, only then he returned to his habitat. sqI sqhuM tl islw hoie ndI iknwry bwJ prwxw] sathee sathahu(n) ttal silaa hoe nadhee kinaarae baajh paraanaa|| Ahalya who could not remain steadfast in her chastity became stone and remained lying on the river bank rGupiq crx CuhMidAw clI surgpur bxy ibbwxw] raghupath charan shhuha(n)dhiaa chalee suragapur banae bibaanaa|| Touching the (holy) feet of Ram she was lifted to the heavens. Bgq vCl BlÎweIAhuM piqq auDwrx pwp kmwxw] bhagath vashhal bhalaaeeahu(n) pathith oudhhaaran paap kamaanaa|| Because of His benevolence He is mother-like to the devotees and being forgiver of the sinners He is called redeemer of the fallen ones. guxnoN gux sBko krY Aaugx kIqy gux iqs jwxw] gunano(n) gun sabhako karai aougan keethae gun this jaanaa|| Doing good is returned by good gestures always, but he who does good to the evil is known as virtuous. Aivgq giq ikAw AwK vKwxw ]ñø] avigath gath kiaa aakh vakhaanaa ||aa|| How can I explain the greatness of that unmanifest (Lord). Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Raag Bhairao on Pannaa 1162 bwvn koit jw kY romwvlI ] rwvn sYnw jh qy ClI ] baavan kott jaa kai romaavalee || raavan sainaa jeh thae shhalee || Rama, with millions of monkeys, conquered Raawan's army. shs koit bhu khq purwn ] sehas kott bahu kehath puraan || Billions of Puraanas greatly praise Him; durjoDn kw miQAw mwnu ]7] dhurajodhhan kaa mathhiaa maan ||7|| He humbled the pride of Duyodhan. ||7|| kMdRp koit jw kY lvY n Drih ] ka(n)dhrap kott jaa kai lavai n dhharehi || Millions of gods of love cannot compete with Him. QUOTE Krishan Ji: - Just like Raam, this person is also considered an incarnation of Vishnu. Wasn’t he responsible for having an affair with his aunt Radha? What was the reason behind his acts towards Rukamani and Chandrawal? He was also responsible for starting the battle of the Mahabharat by deceiving Arjun. This battle would have stopped if he wished but he instead decided to get brothers to fight amongst themselves. He also got Arjun to kill his teacher Dronacharya by getting Yudhister to lie about Asvatthama’s death. To find more on these ‘terrorist’ acts, please refer to the Mahabharat, Sukh Sagar and Gita. QUOTE gopI nY goAwlIAw ] gopee nai goaaleeaa || You are the Gopis, the milk-maids of Krishna; You are the sacred river Jamunaa; You are Krishna, the herdsman. Guru Nanak Dev Ji Siree Raag 73 hQo hiQ ncweIAY vxjwirAw imqRw ijau jsudw Gir kwnu ] hathho hathh nachaaeeai vanajaariaa mithraa jio jasudhaa ghar kaan || From hand to hand, you are passed around, O my merchant friend, like Krishna in the house of Yashoda. Guru Nanak Dev Ji Siree Raag 75 gurmuiK sMgI ik®sn murwry ] guramukh sa(n)gee kirasan muraarae || The Lord Krishna becomes the Gurmukh's Companion. Guru Arjan Dev Ji Raag Maajh 98 ik®snu blBdRü gur pg lig iDAwvY ] kirasan balabhadhra gur pag lag dhhiaavai || Even Krishna and Balbhadar meditated on the Lord, falling at the Guru's Feet. Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Gauree 165 hir Awpy kwn@ü aupwiedw myry goivdw hir Awpy gopI KojI jIau ] har aapae kaanha oupaaeidhaa maerae govidhaa har aapae gopee khojee jeeo || The Lord Himself created Krishna, O my Lord of the Universe; the Lord Himself is the milkmaids who seek Him. Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Gauree 174 Bgiq hyiq Avqwru lIE hY Bwgu bfo bpurw ko ry ]1] bhagath haeth avathaar leeou hai bhaag baddo bapuraa ko rae ||1|| Because of his devotion, Krishna was incarnated in his home; how great was the good fortune of this poor man! ||1|| Bhagat Kabeer Ji Raag Gauree 338 crn biDk jn qyaU mukiq Bey ] charan badhhik jan thaeoo mukath bheae || The hunter who shot Krishna in the foot - even he was liberated. Bhagat Naam Dev Ji Raag Gauree 345 eyk ik®snµ srb dyvw dyv dyvw q Awqmw ] eaek kirasana(n) sarab dhaevaa dhaev dhaevaa th aathamaa || The One Lord Krishna is the Divine Lord of all; He is the Divinity of the individual soul. Guru Angad Dev Ji Raag Aasaa 469 Awpy gopI kwnu hY ipAwrw bin Awpy gaU crwhw ] aapae gopee kaan hai piaaraa ban aapae goo charaahaa || The Beloved Himself is the milk-maid and Krishna; He Himself herds the cows in the woods. Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Sorath 606 ik®s~w qy jwnaU hir hir nwcMqI nwcnw ]1] kirasaa thae jaanoo har har naacha(n)thee naachanaa ||1|| Know that, through Krishna, the Lord, Har, Har, the dance of creation dances. ||1|| Bhagat Naam Dev Ji Raag Dhanaasree 693 hku scu Kwlku Klk imAwny isAwm mUriq nwih ]2] hak sach khaalak khalak miaanae siaam moorath naahi ||2|| The True Creator Lord is diffused into His creation; He is not just the dark-skinned Krishna of legends. ||2|| Bhagat Kabeer Ji Raag Tilang 727 hm icnI pwiqswh sWvly brnW ]3] ham chinee paathisaah saa(n)valae baranaa(n) ||3|| You are my Lord King, like the dark-skinned Krishna. ||3|| Bhagat Naam Dev Ji Raag Tilang 727 Din Din ik®sn EFY kWblI ]1] dhhan dhhan kirasan oudtai kaa(n)balee ||1|| blessed, blessed is the blanket worn by Krishna. ||1|| Bhagat Naam Dev Ji Raag Maalee Gauraa 988 mohn mwDv ik®s~ murwry ] mohan maadhhav kirasa muraarae || The Enticer of Hearts, the Lord of wealth, Krishna, the Enemy of ego. Guru Arjan Dev Ji Raag Maaroo 1082 suAwn sqRü Ajwqu sB qy ik®s~ lwvY hyqu ] suaan sathra ajaath sabh thae kirasa laavai haeth || The killer of dogs, the lowest of all, was lovingly embraced by Krishna. Bhagat Ravi Daas Ji Raag Kaydaaraa 1124 dInw dIn dieAwl Bey hY ijau ik®snu ibdr Gir AwieAw ] dheenaa dheen dhaeiaal bheae hai jio kirasan bidhar ghar aaeiaa || God is Merciful to the meekest of the meek; Krishna came to the house of Bidar, a devotee of low social status. Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Basant 1191 ibdr dwsI suqu Cok Cohrw ik®snu AMik gil lwvYgo ]2] bidhar dhaasee suth shhok shhoharaa kirasan a(n)k gal laavaigo ||2|| Bidur, the son of a slave-girl, was an untouchable, but Krishna hugged him close in His Embrace. ||2|| Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Kaanraa 1309 duAwpuir ik®sn murwir kMsu ikrqwrQu kIE ] dhuaapur kirasan muraar ka(n)s kirathaarathh keeou || In the Brass Age of Dwaapur Yuga, You were Krishna; You killed Mur the demon and saved Kans. Bhatt Kal Svaiyay Mehl 5 1390 kvl nYn mDur bYn koit sYn sMg soB khq mw jsod ijsih dhI Bwqu Kwih jIau ] kaval nain madhhur bain kott sain sa(n)g sobh kehath maa jasodh jisehi dhehee bhaath khaahi jeeo || You are lotus-eyed, with sweet speech, exalted and embellished with millions of companions. Mother Yashoda invited You as Krishna to eat the sweet rice. Bhatt Gayandh Svaiyay Mehl 5 1402 pIq bsn kuMd dsn ipRA sihq kMT mwl muktu sIis mor pMK cwih jIau ] peeth basan ku(n)dh dhasan pria sehith ka(n)t(h) maal mukatt sees mor pa(n)kh chaahi jeeo || As Krishna, You wear yellow robes, with teeth like jasmine flowers; You dwell with Your lovers, with Your mala around Your neck, and You joyfully adorn Your head with the crow of peacock feathers. Bhatt Gayandh Svaiyay Mehl 5 1402 I have listed out my source : DHANN SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE. What is their source? No wait. Don't work too hard on responding. I will type out your response for you, but how will you explain the quotes I just enlisted? Anyways here is YOUR response: QUOTE Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Raag Dhanaasree on Pannaa 691 hnUmwn sir gruV smwnW ] surpiq nrpiq nhI gun jwnW ]2] hanoomaan sar garurr samaanaa(n) || surapath narapath nehee gun jaanaa(n) ||2|| Beings like Hanumaan, Garura, Indra the King of the gods and the rulers of humans - none of them know Your Glories, Lord. ||2|| cwir byd Aru isMimRiq purwnW ] kmlwpiq kvlw nhI jwnW ]3] chaar baedh ar si(n)mrith puraanaa(n) || kamalaapath kavalaa nehee jaanaa(n) ||3|| The four Vedas, the Simritees and the Puraanas, Vishnu the Lord of Lakshmi and Lakshmi herself - none of them know the Lord. ||3|| This Shabad is by Bhai Gurdaas Ji in Vaars Bhai Gurdaas on Pannaa 12 ibSn ley Avqwr ds vYr ivroD ivroD joD sMGwry] bishan leae avathaar dhas vair virodhh virodhh jodhh sa(n)ghaarae|| Visnu incarnated ten times and decimated his opposing warriors. mC kC vYrwh rUp nr isMG hoie bwvn bMDwry] mashh kashh vairaah roop nar si(n)gh hoe baavan ba(n)dhhaarae|| The incarnations in the forms of fish, tortoise, swine, man-lion, dwarf and Buddha etc. have happened. prsrwm rwm ikRSn ho iklik klµkI Aiq AhMkwry] parasaraam raam krishan ho kilak kala(n)kee ath aha(n)kaarae|| Parsu Ram, Ram, Kisan and very much proud incarnation of Kalki have flourished. KqRI mwr iekIh vwr rwmwiex kir BwrQ Bwry] khathree maar eikeeh vaar raamaaein kar bhaarathh bhaarae|| Ram was hero of Ramayan, and kisan was all in the mahabharat. kwm kRoD n swiDE loB moh AhMkwr n mwry] kaam krodhh n saadhhiou lobh moh aha(n)kaar n maarae|| But the lust and anger were not sublimited and greed, infatuation and ego were not eschewed. siqgur purK n ByitAw swD sMgiq shlµGn swry] sathigur purakh n bhaettiaa saadhh sa(n)gath sehala(n)ghan saarae|| None remembered the true Guru (God) and nobody benefited himself in the holy congregation. haumYN AMdr kwr ivkwry ]ø] houmai(n) a(n)dhar kaar vikaarae ||a|| All acted arrogantly being full of evil propensities. Guru Nanak Dev Ji in Raag Raamkalee on Pannaa 953 rovY rwmu inkwlw BieAw ] rovai raam nikaalaa bhaeiaa || Rama wept when he was sent into exile, sIqw lKmxu ivCuiV gieAw ] seethaa lakhaman vishhurr gaeiaa || and separated from Sita and Lakhshman. Fair enough? cool, now what about the quotes before YOUR presumed and expected response? How you gonna explain those? I understand how you use Gurbani to condemn other faiths and their personalities, but what about the tuks where Gurujee does NOT do the same and actually recognizes the light of Waheguru in all of them? ps: the YOU doesn't refer to any single person, it refers to anyone who wants to read this long post. Please just make sure your responses don't contradict each other. Thanks in advance for "enlightening" me whenever you do. I really wanna learn how to hate (note the sarcasm).

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

singh · 31 Oct 2005

if im not mistaken, shabaaz khalsa wasnt refering to ram and krishna as terriost, but they were saying if one considers our shaheed singhs terriosts, then they must consider ran and krishna terriosts, and seeing hoe shabaaz khalsa holds shaheed singhs in high honour, they hold ram and krishna in high honour, its people like badal and cpt amarinder that would consider ram and krishna terriosts, seeing how they see our singhs as terriosts, because they did no wrong, as did ram and krishna

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

ekta · 01 Nov 2005

besides the ponit and irrelevent discussion above. even for shabaaz khalsa, a heavily panthic group, to diss Cpt. Amrinder Singh, who pretty much openly is Panthak, but does not flaunt it, is wrong. Cpt. does alott of work, and even called Bhai Hawara ji, a gentlemen 2 who'm he looks up to. Cpt. works on the water and energy situations for punjab, and also gave a stern warning to the Police in the treatment of the 60 or so babbars this past year so please.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Baldeep Singh · 01 Nov 2005

Vahegurooo Jeee Kaaa Khalsaaaah, Vaheguroooo Jeeee Keee Fateeeeh! One word comes to mind after reading the post by Shahbaaz Khalsa "AMAZING!". May Guru Sahib bless you with the sewa you are providing. It shows in clear light how oppressive the indian government in its true light and shown through its very own history. As Sir Max Arthur MacAuliffe said "Hinduism is like a Boa constrictor, it wraps it self around its victum and chokes the life out of it ...." .... "Hindu, Hindi and Hindustan" Two things that weakens an individual and that is "Physical and Mental slavery" and thus by applying these one cannot gain spiritual nor political prowess. [%sig%]

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

khalsa_force · 01 Nov 2005

><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>< Author: Siddharth Date: 10-31-05 11:57 << Recently after this letter was published by the officials of Shahbaaz Khalsa, India-based media issued stories labelling the Shahbaaz Khalsa a terrorist organization. How anyone who is willing to have public debate on this issue can be considered a terrorist organization without any basis is absolutely incredible.>> No - This is not incredible. Any organization that writes about another religion in this derogatory a manner, deserves to be condemned by all and sundry. If you think otherwise, imagine someone writing about some of your Gurus and attaching a label of terrorist to them. If you can't even bear to think about that then what right do the officials of Shahbaz Khalsa have to criticize our Gods? This is nothing but hate-spewing against Hindus and if you think it is within your"rights" to say all these things then good luck to you. Just don't expect people to stand by you when you say foolish things like these. Regards, Sid. ><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>< May U please copy paste the whole atricle to ur system and Give Counter arguements for each n every made in there.Prove Them wrong if u hv gutts for it. I challenge ANY1 out there to prove it wrong with propr facts n figures. Otherwise keep ur mouth shut. Jaspal

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

LionKing · 01 Nov 2005

Jaspal Singh Although I agree with what you said - You have NO RIGHT TO tell anyone else to keep their mouth shut. If you believe in freedom of Speahc, and are for Sikhs to have it in Panjabm then stop trying to silence everyone else. Sid. If you don't agree with the post, could you please refute the post, as they have clearly backed-up their stuff with the scriptures thanks. Regards LK

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Straight Arrow · 01 Nov 2005

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Author: Iron Man Date: 10-31-05 17:57 Straight arrow, your post shows ignorance of Sikhi.. Bhagat Kabir Jee who wrote bani was a gursikh of Guru Sahib and depending on the context, names such as raam, krishan etc refer to GOD, the ONE god, akal purakh. nobody else. in other contexts, it refers to the hindu dieties in order to tell a story. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ That is correct. I am ignorant about Sikhi but not of Hinduism. Since when is Kabir a Sikh? Of which Guru? You have yourself said that depending upon the context, Ram and krishn refer to the Akal Purakh, which is what I have been saying all along that Ram and Krishn mean the Akal Purakh to Hindus. I don't see what the fuss is about. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Author: Niranjan Singh Date: 10-31-05 21:32 Siddharth, Straight Arrow : Like it or not what Shahbaaz Khalsa has written about Ram, Krishan, etc. IS what is contained in your own Hindoo scriptures. Nothing more nothing less. Read them and weep. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ What Shahbaazkhalsa has written about Ram and Krishn is one-dimensional, to incite hatred and judging by some of the posts here, they have done a good job of it. Sikhs like you have jumped on to their bandwagon without knowing even an iota of truth about the Hindu scriptures. Anyway, please read Mehtab Singh's post above and see how Gurbani praises these "terrorists". Now, I think it is your turn to weep. Thank you.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Mehtab Singh · 01 Nov 2005

Many years ago in university I saw 2 books in my university library. One written by a Hindu author, and another by a Muslim. In both these books, these writers posted distorted version about our Gurus. I wrote in dark and bold letters "PLEASE DON'T BELIEVE ALL THIS. THIS WRITER IS ANTI-SIKH", so that no matter who reads the matter, he/she thinks loads before believing whats written. Even during the times of Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale, a Hindu author from Meerut wrote distorted events about Gurujee. Till today we have such people. Only last month a book was banned in India which presented incorrect historic facts about Dasmesh Pita Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee Maharaj. We guys draw out our swords when a single word is uttered against Gurujee, yet we totally fail to give similar respect to religious figures of other faiths. WHY! Do Hindus regard their deities any less than we regard Gurujee? We can't stand the fact that a Sikh converts to Islam ([i]even if he/she was a jigyasu and converted for purely spiritual reasons[/i]), yet we rejoice when a non-Sikh takes Amrit ([i]without knowing anything else as to what brought them there[/i]). If Shahbaaz Khalsa are that bent on proving who is a terrorist, I think ([i]and this is purely my personal opinion[/i]) it would have been better if they could have outlined the misdeeds of those Hindutva freak parties like VHP, Shiv Sena, Bajrang Dal, RSS and their likes. Perhaps even the common Hindus of India would have been informed and enlightened about the truth behind the people they regard as their religious and communal leaders/masters. Instead, they have attacked the religion thereby widening the "already wide" gap between Hindus and Sikhs. You think thats going to help their case any better? I mean come on you think about it! If I want to explain to you that you have a problem, do I do it in a friendly way or come straight upto your face and tell you that you are a retarded freak who needs psychiatric treatment? If I do the latter, what should I expect from you then? To listen to me or ask me to shut the hell up and get lost? Maybe their purpose is right, but I am sorry, this technique of "enlightening" your opponents by degrading their religion is never going to work. Sorry! Enough of my bakwaas. Not like any of you are going to change. Mai kehda kisi di soch badlan da thekka leya hoya! [i]whole fight of Ramayan took place because of Raam Chander.[/i] No. It took place because Ram went to rescue his wife Sita who was kidnapped by force by Ravan. [i]At one time when Ravan’s sister Saroop Nakha approached Raam with a marriage proposal, Raam refused while telling her that he is already married, sending her to Lachman. He lied to her about him being unmarried when he was already married.[/i] Wrong. As far as I know there is nothing like that stated in the Ramayan. Shri Ram refused to marry her as he was already married and she then went on to Lachman. [i]Wasn’t he responsible for having an affair with his aunt Radha? [/i] Since when was she his aunt? This is something new, and sorry, its hilarious! Plus this comment has been made as a question, so probably these guys themselves don't know what they on about. [i]He was also responsible for starting the battle of the Mahabharat by deceiving Arjun.[/i] It was Duryodhan who said "I wont give the Pandavas a land worth the tip of a needle unless they fight a war". So how is Lord Krishna responsible for the war? [i]This battle would have stopped if he wished but he instead decided to get brothers to fight amongst themselves.[/i] Both Duryodhan and Arjun came to Lord Krishna to ask for help in the war. Arjun got Krishna ji, and Duryodhan got Krishna Ji's army. So again : how did Shri Krishna make the brothers fight among themselves? [i]To find more on these ‘terrorist’ acts, please refer to the Mahabharat, Sukh Sagar and Gita.[/i] Have these guys read even a single page of the Gita? Before jumping on me, let me admit that there IS some stuff I don't have the answer to. If someone does then bring it out and enlighten us all. My hating skills need improvement (lol...sarcasm).

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Niranjan Singh · 01 Nov 2005

Straight Arrow, You and the 'Sikh' apologists fail to understand the message in Shahbaaz Khalsa's post. Read the original format in Gurmukhi (pasted below), it might enlighten you minds. The bottom line is that if you put our Shaheeds (Baba Jarnail Singh Bhinderanwale, Sukhdev Singh Babbar, Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochal (whom they call ATWADEE, WAKHWADEE, ATANKWADEE, etc) side-by-side to Hindoo Devi Devtaas, there is NO comparison. In Gurbani GurSikhs are respected at the highest level. The charan-dhoor and seva of GurSikhs is considered a great blessing in Sikhi. Is there even a single tuk that asks Sikhs to worship, serve, or yearn for the charndhoor of these fake devis devtaas ? No ! Therefore one can conclude that Brahma/Vishan/Mahesh are not even equal to the status of a true GurSikhs charandhoor. If India was to apply the same standard on its devi devtas, that it had applied on Sikhs when more than quarter million of them were eliminated from 1978 - 1993, it would also come to the same conclusion : That it is NOT our dear GurSikh Jajharroos but your own devis devtaas who are the real ATWADEES, WAKHWADEES, ATANKWADEES. This is part fo your history and your scriptures, please don't mis-use Guru Granth Sahib Ji's Bannee to falsely prop them up. If India isn't ready to change its stance on our Shaheeds, then WE need to apply the same litmus test and expose the terror, carnage, and destruction your devi devtas and Hinduvata have brought to that "sacred land". In the end remember : [gurbani]kbIr bwmnu gurU hY jgq kw Bgqn kw guru nwih ][/gurbani] Kabeer, the Brahmin may be the guru of the world, but he is not the Guru of the devotees. [gurbani]AriJ auriJ kY pic mUAw cwrau bydhu mwih ]237][/gurbani] He rots and dies in the perplexities of the four Vedas. ||237|| ORIGINAL LETTER IN GURMUKHI : [gurbani] AiqvwdI kox? Sihbwz Kwlsw vloN Ku`lw K`q mOjUdw Aqy swbkw mu`KmMqrI sihbwn jIE, vwihgurU jI kw Kwlsw ] vwihgurU jI kI Pqih ] A`j imqI 18 AkqUbr 2005 dy idn Awp dohW iDrW (s`qwDwrI iDr Aqy ivroDI iDr) v`loN pMjwb dy ivDwn sBw sdn ivc kIqI geI bihs suxI[ ijs dw ivSw pMjwb ivc “A`qvwd leI izMmyvwr kOx?” sI[ siqkwr Xog lIfr swihbwn swrI bihs suxn qoN bwAd mihsUs hoieAw ik qusI dovyN iDrW jW qW bhuq Axjwx ho jW iPr AiqAMq clwk jo byloVI bihs muhwsby bwzI krky pMjwb dy lokW ƒ byvkU& bxw ky AwpxIAW isAwsI rotIAW sykxw cwhuMdy ho ? Asl ivc Awp dohW iDrW v`loN cuixAw igAw bihs dw m`udw hI glq hY[ qusIN dohW iDrW ny iek dUsry ƒ A`qvwd leI izMmyvwr TihrwauNdy hoey qIjI iDr (isK KwVkU lihr) ƒ ibnW ivcwr kIqy A`qvwdI grdwn id`qw hY[ jd ik nYiqk qOr qy ieh g`l ikvyN vI TIk nhIN TihrweI jw skdI, ijnW icr ies bihs ivc qIjI iDr dw p`K nhIN ilAw jWdw[ isK kOm A`j vI isK KwVkU lihr ƒ A`qvwdI nhIN sgoN isKW dI AwzwdI leI lVI lVweI dy juJwrU, Bwv PrIfm PweItr vjoN mwnqw idMdI hY[ vYsy QoVI bhuq isAwsI sUJ r`Kx vwlw Awm ivAkqI vI ies g`l ƒ cMgI qrHW jwxdw hY ik KwVkU iDrW ƒ A`qvwdI kihx vwly lok ikMny ku s`qvwdI hn ? ijvyN AsIN pihlW vI bynqI kIqI hY Awp dohW iDrW dw Asl mudw ieh hoxw cwhIdw hY ik shI mwieinAW ivc A`qvwdI hn kOx ? BwrqI AKOqI jW lokqMqrI isstm qy kwbz quhwfy vrgy isAwsI srmweydwr lok ? jnwby Awlw hwlq ieh hn “hm Awh BI Brqy hY qo ho jwqy hY bdnwm, voh kql kr jwqy hY AOr crcw nhIN hoqw[ swfy iKAwl muqwbk quhwƒ dohW iDrW nMU A`qvwd dy kwrnW Aqy AslI A`qvwdIAW bwry d`sxw qW boly A`gy BYrv jW gwauVI rwg gwaux qoN v`D hor kuJ nhIN ho skdw[ smJdy qusIN dovyN iDrW vI cMgI qrHW nwl ho pr iPr vI quhwƒ Bwrq dyS dy Asl A`qvwd dy Asl ieiqhws qoN jwxUM krvw hI id`qw jwvy[ siqkwrXog lIfr swihbwn jI Bwrq khy jWdy dyS ivc A`qvwd dw ieiqhws bhuq sdIAW purwxw ikhw jw skdw hY[ ijvyN Awp jI dy siqkwrXog sdn ivc bIbI rijMdr kOr B`Tl ny g`l AwrIAw vrq dy irSIAW munIAW qoN SurU kIqI sI [ AsIN vI g`l auQoN hI SurU krnI cwhuMdy hW[ Asl isAwpy dI jVH ieho A`qvwdI gRMQ hn[ siqkwrXog bIbI jI ny Awpxy BwSn ivc purwqn gRMQW rmwiex qy irgvyd dIAW audwhrxW id`qIAW[ so AwE ienHW gMRQW dy mhwn nwiekW dy AslI cir`qr dw ivvycn kr ilAw jwvy qW ik Awp jI (dohW iDrW) ƒ AslI A`qvwdIAW dI pihcwx ho jwvy[ 1. rwm cMdr jI :- BwvyN ik purwqn gMRQW ivc ienHW ƒ mirXwdw purSoqm dw drjw id`qw igAw hY, pr Asl ivc ieh bVI iBAwnk iksm dy purwqn A`qvwdI khy jw skdy hn[ purwqn gMRQ rmwiex ƒ ghu nwl vwicAW Awp jI ƒ BlIBWq pqw l`g jwvygw ik ies mhwn purS ny ikhVw-ikhVw A`qvwdI kMm kIqw[ pr iPr vI ienHW dy cMd ku krqvW v`l Awp jI dw iDAwn idvwauxw cwhuMdy hW[ rmwiex dI lVweI ivc Asl puAwVy dI jV ienHW duAwrw isMmxI CyVx krky hI hoeI[ lMkw pqI rwvx dI BYx srUp nKW bnvws dy idnW ivc jdoN ienHW pws SwdI dw pRsqwv lY ky AweI qW ienHW Awpxy Awp ƒ ivAwihAw d`isAw qy srUp nKW ƒ Awpxy Brw lCmx kol Byj id`qw qy aus dy Ax ivAwhy hox dw JUT vI boilAw jd ik lCmx pihlW hI ivAwihAw hoieAw sI[ lCmx ny ienHW dy kihx ’qy srUp nKW (suMdr n`k dI mwilk) dI suMdrqw dI inSwnI ausdw n`k hI v`F id`qw[ ijs dy bdly ivc rwvx ny sIqw jI ƒ cuikAw Aqy iBAwnk lVweI hoeI bhuq mnu`KI jwnW geIAW[ SwdI dw pRsqwv lY ky AweI iek suMdr iesqrI dw n`k v`F dyxw A`qvwd nhIN hY? pr Awp dohW iDrW ny kdy vI ienHW mhwn purSW ƒ A`qvwdI ikauN nhIN ikhw ? mslw vot dw jo hoieAw ? idl Qwm bYTxw rwjw jno ABI qo kQw bwkI hY[ Ablw iesqrI dw n`k v`F dyxw, DoKy nwl kyly dy dr`Kq dy auhly KVy bwlI ƒ mwr dyxw, r`b dI BgqI krn bdly SMBUk SUdr irSI ƒ mwr dyxw qW s`qvwd hI ikhw jw skdw hY ? AwpxI sqvMqI pqnI ƒ AgnI pRIiKAw dyx leI mzbUr krnw, AgnI pRIiKAw ivcoN pws hox qy vI grBvqI hwlq ivc Gro k`F dyxw qW mhwn puMn krm hY? A`qvwd qW hrigz nhIN ho skdw? clo ieh qW hoey Bwrq dy pihly mhwn A`qvwdI rwjw rwm cMdr, k`lI-k`lI g`l ilKidAW sOdw lMmw ltk jwx dI sMBwvnw hY so hvwilAW leI A`qvwdI gRMQ qulsI rmwiex dyK lYxw jI[ 2. hnMUmwn :- hux do nMbr qy g`l krdy hW rwm cMdr jI dy ifptI kmWfr (muK sYnwpqI) sRI hMnUmwn jI dI.... vYsy qW ieh sRI mwn jI Awpxy bcpn qoN hI A`qvwdI kwrvweIAW krdy rhy hn[ ienHW ny bcpn ivc hI sUrj dyvqw Agvw kWf ƒ AMzwm dy id`qw sI[ purwqn gRMQW ivc izkr hY ik ienHW mhwn purSW ny sUrj hI ingl ilAw sI Aqy jdoN jgq ivc AMDkwr p`sr igAw qW irSIAW munIAW dy kurlwht krn qy ivcwry ƒ Azwd kIqw[ auh vI Atpty ijhy drvwzy QWxI bwhr k`iFAw ijs dI inSwnI (piv`qr gRMQW muqwbk) A`j q`k ienHW dI nsl dy ‘ihps’ qy kwiem hY[ iek hor kQw muqwbk jdoN rwm cMdr jI dy ieh mhwn SUtr sIqw jI dI Bwl ivc lMkw gey qW rwjy rwvx dI ASok vwitkw dI AYsI qYsI A`Dy GMty ivc Pyr id`qI[ clo jy ies mhwn rwm Bgq dy ienHW kwrnwimAW ƒ “s`qvwdI” vI mMn ilAw jwvy qW lMkw dihn bwry Awp jI dy kI ivcwr hn? sIqw Agvw kWf leI rwvx doSI mMinAw jw skdw hY pr pUC ƒ logV lpyt ky swrI lMkw ƒ suAwh kr dyxw ikQoN dI isAwxp hY ? kI lMkw dihn smyN mhwn AgnI kWf ivc Awm lok nhIN sVy hoxgy ? lIfr swihbwn muAwmlw isDw ‘mws ikilMg’ dw hY, ikhVI Dwrw l`gygI ivcwr kr lYxw[ mYƒ mihsUs huMdw hY ik jykr aus smyN A`j dw kƒn huMdw qW ieh sRI mwn jI iPdwienW dI ilst ivc pihly nMbr qy Awauxy sn[ 3. ikRSn jI :- siqkwr Xog lIfr swihbwn (rwjw jI qy bwdl swihb) ies mhwn ivAkqI bwry kOx nhIN jwxdw? ieh vI rwm jI vWg ivSƒ dy Avqwr mMny jWdy hn ijs ny rwKS jlMDr dI iesqrI dw sq BMg krn dw mhwn s`qvwdI kwrnwmw kIqw sI[ so ienHW ƒ ipCly jnmW dw boD kudrqI hovygw hI[ ienHW dy kwrnwmy ilKx leI iek v`KrI ikqwb dI zrUrq hY[ rwjw rukmWd dI BYx rukmxI ƒ k`F ky ilAwauxw, AwpxI skI mwmI rwDw nwl ieSk pycw Pswauxw, 365 gopIAW hox dy bwvzUd cMdrwvl vrgI swaU gvwlx dI p`q nwl auhdy shury Gr jw ky Kyfxw (juj mih jor ClI cMdRwvl) kubzW bu`FI mwlx ƒ inhwl krnw, ndI ivc ieSnwn krdIAW SrIP AOrqW dy k`pVy cuk ky dr`Kq qy cV jwxw, mhWBwrq dI twlI jw skx vwlI lVweI ƒ Arjn ƒ PUk dy ky, vrglwA ky BweIAW h`QoN BweIAW dIAW ATwrW KUhxIAW kql krvw dyxIAW, KWfv bn ƒ A`g lgvw ky inh`Qy BIlW ƒ sVvw dyxw, mhWBwrq dy Xu`D ivc XuiDStr koloN “AsvQwmW mr igAw hY” dw JUT bulvw ky Arjx kolo aus dy ausqwd doRxwcwrIAw dw kql krvwauxw, BIm jrwsMD XuD ivc BIm ƒ f`kw ivcwilE pwV ky jugq d`s ky jrwsMD dw kql krvwauxw, ieh sB s`qvwdI kwrvweIAW iesy mhwn ivAkqI dy ih`sy AweIAW hn[ so ies mhwn (s`qvwdI) s`jx dy jIvn ieiqhws ƒ dyKx leI Aqy auprokq g`lW (kQwvW) ƒ ivsQwr sihq pVx leI mhWBwrq, suKswgru Aqy gIqw vrgy gRMQ vyKy jw skdy hn[ 4. ieMdr qy bRhmw jI :- ienHW mhwn s`qvwdI s`jxw bwry ilKidAW Srm Aw rhI hY[ pr iPr vI ienHW dy s`qvwdI kwrnwmy Awp jI dy iDAwn ivc ilAwauxy Aiq zrUrI hn[ “ieMdr” jI ƒ piv`qr pOrwixk gRMQW, ijnHW ivcoN iek dw izkr Awp jI dy sdn ivc siqkwrXog bIbI rijMdr kOr B`Tl ny vI kIqw hY myrI murwd “irg vyd” qoN hY, ivc svrg dw rwjw qy vrKw Byjx vwlw mMinAw jWdw hY[ ienHW mhwn purSW dIAW rMgIlIAW AwdqW qoN qW hr Bwrq vwsI jwxUM hI hY[ jdoN ikqy koeI Blw purS r`b dI bMdgI krdw hY qW J`tp`t ienHW dw isMGwsx sWJI srkwr dy pRDwn mMqrI dy isMGwsx vWg foldw hY Aqy ieh Awpxy rwj Bwg ivcoN rMBw, mynkw, aurvSI Awidk suMdrIAW dI vrqoN krky ivcwry r`b dy ipAwirAW dI BgqI ƒ KMfn krn dw s`qvwdI kwrnwmw srMzwm krdy hn[ ienHW dI nIqI dw rgiVAw ivSvw im`qr hly q`k qwb nhIN AwieAw[ hux Ah`ilAw blwqkwr dI khwxI ieQy ilKxI myry leI AsMBv hY[ irg vyd Awpy hI pV lYxw[ vYsy gurbwxI dw hvwlw zrUr dyvWgw, “goqmu qpw AihilAw iesqRI iqsu dyiK ieMdRü luBwieAw ]shs srIr ichn Bg hUey qw min pCoqwieAw ]”bRhmw jI dy kXw kihxy, AwpxI DI srsvqI dw rUp dyK hI fol gey...... h`d eI krqI? ivcwrI ijDr jwvy mgry mgr dOVy iPrn...... hwr ky iSv jI ƒ gwtw v`Fxw ipAw[ kpwl mocn dw ieiqhws pV lYxw[ ienHW dovW s`jxW ƒ A`qvwdI jW s`qvwdI jW iksy hor kYtwgrI ivc ijQy mrzI r`K lYxw[ (hvwilAW leI iSv purwx bRhm purwx, irg vyd Aqy ieMdr purwx pVy jw skdy hn) siqkwrXog rwjw swihb Aqy bwdl swihb swƒ pqw hY ienHW auprokq mhwn sKSIAqW ƒ AqvwdI AwKxw quhwfy v`s dw rog nhIN hY[ lokqMqrI mzbUrI ijauN hoeI[ Aws krdy hW A`qvwd dI khwxI sux dy Q`ky nhIN hovogy[ muAw& krnw rjvwVy srdwro swfI inkI ijhI idRStI ivc Bwrq vrS dy A`qvwdIAW dI ilst bhuq lMmI hY[ swirAW dw izkr sMBv vI nhIN hY[ pr iPr vI pOrwixk kwl qoN A`gy jwx qoN pihlW A`qvwdI gRMQW ivcoN do dI g`l zrUr krnI cwhWgy[ auh A`qvwdI gRMQ ies pRkwr hn, 1. mnUM ismRqI :- ieh bRhmw jI dy AlOikk puqr mhwn irSI mnUM jI dI mhwn ikrq hY[ ijs dy swry slokW ivc AOrq SUdr Aqy gYr bRhwmx jwqW ƒ jIvn dIAW mUl loVW qoN s`Kxy krn, SUdr AOrqW nwl blwqkwr krn, sUdrW dy Bjn suxn qy kMnW qy muK ivc is`kw Fwl ky pwaux, sUdrW dy Dwn ƒ Apiv`qr Aqy SUdr AOrq dI XonI ƒ piv`qr d`isAw igAw hY[ siqkwrXog lIfr swihbwn Bwrq ivc jwq-pwq Aqy vrx vMf vrgy isAwpy dI jV ieho mhwn gRMQ hY[ hux qusIN ies ƒ dunIAW dw pihlw A`qvwdI mYnIPYsto mMno BwvyN nw mMno ieh quhwfI mrzI auqy inrBr hY[ 2. cwnikXw nIqI :- ies gRMQ dy rcYqw pMfq ivSƒ gupq dy jwhr rwjnIqk SUqr ivc swm,dwm, dMf, Byd dI nIqI dw vrxn hY[ ijs auqy A`j q`k dw swrw BwrqI qMqr KVw hY[ so ies mhwn rcnw ijs ivc pwVo qy rwj kro dI nIqI hI nhIN sgoN swm (smJwE, Bwv cqurweI nwl Awpxy v`l kr lvo), dwm (ijsdw ArQ hY, KRIdo), dMf (jy nhIN mMndw qW mwr dyvo, Bwv JUTw puils mukwblw bxw lvo) dw A`qvwdI sMdyS id`qw hoieAw hY[ ies gRMQ ƒ A`qvwdI smJx dI Aws Awp dohW rwjnIqk iDrW qoN krnI qW JoitAW dy GroN l`sI Bwlx vwlI g`l hY[ ikauNik Awp dohyN iDrW BwrqI ihMdUSwhI dI ienHW mhwn gRMQW ivcoN aupjI hoeI pivqr rwjnIqk pRxwlI (igxqMqr) auqy AMnI SrDw r`Kdy ho[ c`lo hux A`gy c`ilAw jwvy[ siqkwrXog lIfr swihbwn gusqwKI muAw& AsIN dubwrw Xwd idvw deIey Awpxw ivSw “A`qvwdI kOx ?’ hY[ ijs ivc hly qW nMbirMg hI c`lI hY pUrI i&lm qW bwkI peI hY[ ieiqhwsk A`qvwd :- gRMQW qoN bwAd Awau hux buD kwl smyN dI ihMdU A`qvwd qy vI mwVI ijhI nzr mwrdy c`lIey.... ieDr sy guzrw Qw socw slwm krqw clUM, buD Drm qy ihMdU A`qvwdI Drm ivcly PrkW dw Awp ƒ BlI BWq pqw hI hovygw[ ijQy buD Drm vrgw mhwn PlsPw mnu`KI brwbrI ienswnI ipAwr, sihnSIlqw, AihMsw prmo Drm qy mnuKI mukqI dI g`l krdw hY, auQy ihMdU A`qvwdI drSn 33 kroV dyvI dyvqy, vrx vMf, jwq pwq sqI pRQw, iesqrI nrk dw duAwr, Awidk kuqrkW dw hwmI hY[ cwnikXw dy pihly cyly cMdr gupq mOrIAw dy vMS ivcoN A`gy jw ky mhwrwjw ASok dy bu`D Drm Dwrn krn qoN bwAd buD PlsPw pUry Bwrq ivc pUrI qrHW Cw igAw[ “rwj ibnw nih Drm cly hY dy mhwn gurvwkW Anuswr rwj hIx lokW dy Drm vI smwpq ho jwieAw krdy hn[ so ASok kwl ivc pRPulq hoieAw buD Drm Blw bRwhmxvwdI A`qvwdIAW dIAW nzrW qy ihMdU A`qvwdI rwijAW dIAW nzrW ivc kokV vWg ikauN nw rVkdw ? so mhwn ASok dI mOq qoN bwAd ibprW dy kihx qy mhwn buD Drm dw ihMdU A`qvwdIAW v`loN srvnwS kr id`qw igAw[ hzwrW nhIN l`KW boDI mMdrW ƒ imtI ivc imlw id`qw igAw[ boD kMinAwvW SMkrwcwrIAw dy cyilAW dy blwqkwr dw iSkwr hoeIAW[ pr AwpxI hoNd ƒ bcwaux leI ivcwry boDI iBkSUAW ƒ cIn, brmw, QweIlYNf, kMbofIAw Aqy jpwn Awidk dySW ivc jwxw ipAw ijQy bwAd ivc ieh Drm AwpxIAW jVW lwaux ivc kwmXwb hoieAw[ bRwhmxvwdIAW, ihMdU rwijAW, SMkrwcwrIAw Aqy ies dy cyilAW v`loN buD Drm dy AnuAweIAW auqy Fwhy zulm ieiqhwsk A`qvwd nhIN qW hor kI hn? kI Awp jI dw sdn kdy ieiqhwsk A`qvwd dy ies kwly dOr bwry koeI swrQk bihs krvwaux leI iqAwr ho skdw hY? jykr kdy Aijhw mOkw AwauNdw hY ik ies ivSy qy Ku`lI bihs ho sky qW AsIN ieiqhwsk gRMQW, boDI ivdvwnW, ihMdU A`qvwdI gRMQW Aqy siqkwr Xog fw. BIm rwE AMbydkr jI dI smu`cI rcnw Aqy dilq swihq dy hvwilAW smyq hwzr hox leI iqAwr hW[ siqkwrXog lIfr swihbwn vYsy Awp dono sulJy hoey B`dr purS isK kOm ivcoN hI ho jW ieauN kih ilAw jwvy ik kwdr dI kudrq ny quhwƒ isKW dy isrmOr GrwixAW ivc jnm id`qw hY so isK ieiqhws dI vwkPIAq qW BlI pRkwr (dohW iDrW ƒ) hovygI hI? pr iPr AsIN svwl krnw cwhMudy hW ik isK ieiqhws dy aunHW pwqrW ijnHW ƒ swfI kulCxI ijhI soc qW A`qvwdI hI smJdI hY Awp kI smJdy ho ? ieiqhwsk bRwhmxvwdI A`qvwdIAW dw sMKyp izkr krn l`gy hW[ 1. cMdU :- ijs ny gurU Gr nIvW idKwaux leI cubwry dI ie`t bwrI ƒ lwaux dw myhxw mwirAw[ ieh gMdw A`qvwdI kIVw sRI gurU Arjn dyv jI dI Shwdq dw muK kwrn bixAw[ siqgurU dy sIs ivc Awpxy swhmxy q`qI ryq pvwauNdw Aqy siqguru jI dI ShIdI dw iek kwrn bixAw[ 2. gMgU bRwhmx :- ieh gdwr ijs dw quKm A`j q`k quhwfI kWgrsI srkwr dy lIfrW dy Gry pl irhw hY[ ijs ny gurU Gr dw lUx Kwky hrwm kIqw Aqy siqgurU dy SIr Kor swihbjwidAW ƒ nINhW ivc icxvwaux leI izMmyvwr bixAw[ 3. phwVI rwjy :- gurU swihb jI dy jwq-pwq nwiSnI KMfy-bwty dy AMimRq qoN eIrKw krn vwly ihMdU phwVI rwjy, ijnW ivc gurU Gr nwl ibnW mqlb pMgw shyVx vwly BIm cMd, Pqy Swh vrgy AwauNdy hn[ ijhVy gurU Gr qy cVH-cVH AwauNdy rhy[ Awty dIAW gaUAW bxw ky gIqw qy h`Q r`K ky ijnW ny ksmW KwDIAW pr qoV nw inBweIAW[ ieh auprokq ibprvwdI Kymy dy gdwrW ƒ ikhVy Kymy ivc r`Kdy ho d`sx dI ikRpwlqw krnI jI ? mhwrwjw rxjIq isMG kwl :- Syry pMjwb mhwrwjw rxjIq isMG dI cVHq smyN AwpxI skI BYx dw folw (mhwrwxI phwVx) mhwrwjw swihb ƒ dy ky ijnHW ny isK rwj ivc GuspYT kIqI Aqy rwjw iDAwn isMG vrgy mhwrwjw swihb dI audwrvwdI nIqI dw nzwiez &wiedw auTwauNdy hoey pRDwn mMqrI q`k dy Ahudy q`k phuMc gey[ bwAd ivc ieho nmk hrwmI, kMvr nOinhwl isMG, mhwrwjw KVk isMG, s. Swm isMG AtwrI, mhwrwxI ijMd kOr, s. AjIq isMG sMDwvwlIAw, s. lihxw isMG Awidk isK srdwrW dI mOq dw kwrn bxy[ ienHW pwpIAW ny hI is`K &OjW ƒ sMq srUp BweI bIr isMG vrgy mhwpurS dy ivruD BVkwieAw Aqy AMq isK rwj dy pqn dw kwrn bxy kI qusIN donoN iDrW ienHW ƒ dyS dy gdwr qy A`qvwdI nhIN mMndy ? pMjW pwxIAW dI DrqI auqy AMgRyzW nwl cVHky AwieAw ihMdU mulKeIAw ijs bwry Swh muhMmd ƒ vI ilKxw ipAw “jMg ihMd pMjwb dw hox l`gw.....” Aqy “isMGW mwr ky ktk mukwey v`fy ihMdosqwnI pUrbI d`KxI jI......” ienHW ƒ ieiqhwsk A`qvwdI Aqy pMjwb dyS dy gdwr kdoN AYlwn krogy ? AMgryz kwl :-AMgryz kwl smyN, krqwr isMG srwBy vrgy XoiDAW ƒ &WsI cVvwaux qoN bwAd prmw nMd, vIr swvrkr Awidk gdwr Aqy kWgrs dy SWqI psMd lIfr gWDI dw mMzw Tokx vwly n`QU rwm gOfsy jo ik iek ivSv pRis`D A`qvwdI sI, aus ƒ quhwfI isAwxI sBw kdoN A`qvwdI khygI ? swƒ smyN dw ieMqzwr rhygw[ jykr auprokq ijkr kIqy B`dr purSW ivcoN iksy dy A`qvwdI hox bwry koeI S`k hovy qW swƒ AwKxw AsIN ieiqhwsk dsqwvyjW smyq hwzr hovWgy[ Awr.AY~s.AY~s. Aqy ies dy swQI A`qvwdI sMgTn:-siqkwrXog kYptn swihb Aqy bwdl jI Swied Awp jI ƒ pqw hI hovygw ik 1920 ivc iek ihMdU ihMdI ihMdosqwn dw hwmI sMgTn Awr.AY~s.AY~s. hoNd ivc AwieAw[ ijs dy isAwsI ivMg Bwjpw nwl bwdl swihb dy DVy dI gUhVI XwrI hY[ ies sMgTn dw inSwnW kMinAW kumwrI qoN lY ky ihMdUkuS dIAW phwVIAW q`k ihMdU dyS hoNd ivc ilAwaux dw hY[ Agr ihMdusqwn my rihnw hogw qo ihMdU ihqmy kihnw hogw dy nwAry lwauxw ienHW dw prm krq`v hY[ 1947 qoN lY ky 1992 q`k myrT, BivMfI, bMbeI, Aihmdwbwd Aqy dyS dy hornW QWvW qy ies sMgTn ny 70 qoN vI v`D vwr iPrkU dMgy BVkwey Aqy 50 hzwr qoN v`D muslmwnW dw kql kIqw[ iesy sMgTn qy ies dy sihXogI sMgTnW ny 1992 ivc bwbrI msizd qoVI[ 2002 ivc gujrwq ivc hzwrW muslmwnW ƒ ijMdw jlw id`qw hzwrW nMnz nwl blwqkwr kIqy[ kI quhwƒ ienHW dy iPrkU lIfr, AfvwnI, vwjpweI, isMGl, qogVIAw, bwl Twkry, modI, bwbrI msijd ƒ fygx leI izMmyvwr aumw BwrqI, swDvI irqMbrw, goivMdAcwrIAw, ienHW dy A`qvwdI gu`t, iSv sYnw, bzrMg dl, ivSv ihMdU pRISd Awidk kdy A`qvwdI idKweI dyxgy ? SryHAwm iqRSUl vMfxw, G`t igxqIAW ƒ Dmkwauxw A`qvwd nhIN qW hor kI hY ? AwE hux pMjwb v`l ƒ muiVAw jwvy :-siqkwrXog rwjw swihb Aqy bwdl jI bihs ivc Awp dohW iDrW isK KwVkU vrg ƒ glq nzrIey nwl dyKdy rhy ho[ hYrwnI dI g`l hY ik bwdl swihb aunHW ƒ A`qvwdI Aqy Awp jI “lVky jW b`cy” kih ky sMboDn krdy rhy ho[ siqkwrXog rwjw jno BwvyN ik AsIN jwxdy hW quhwfy v`loN aunHW (is`K KwVkU iDrW) ƒ A`qvwdI kihxw srwsr glq hY pr iPr vI Awp jI dI jwxkwrI ivc vwDy leI is`K sMGrS vyly dy AslI A`qvwdIAW dI g`l krnI zrUrI smJdy hW[ BwvyN ik BwrqI A`qvwdI qMqr ny sMn 1947 qoN hI AnykW vwr pMjwb Aqy is`K kOm nwl DoRh krky rwjnIiqk Aqy bOiDk A`qvwd kmwieAw hY, ijs dw izkr pUry qrW nwl kr skxw sMBv nhIN, pr iPr vI cMd ku GtnwvW v`l iDAwn dvwauxw jrUrI smJdy hW[ siqkwrXog rwjw swihb ijhVI kWgrs pwrtI dy qusI mYbr Aqy lIfr ho ausy kWgrs dy mhwn cwxikAwvwdI lIfr nihrU v`loN AwpxI kursI Kwqr dyS dI vMf pRvwn kr lYxw, nihrU, gWDI v`loN AzwdI qoN pihlW is`KW nwl kIqy vwAidAW qoN mukrnW, v`lB BweI ptyl v`loN bqOr hom minstr srkwrI AwrfInYNs zwrI kr dyS dI AzwdI leI 86% kurbwnIAW krn vwlI is`K kOm nMU zrwiem pySw dw lkb dyxw, kI isAwsI Aqy bOiDk A`qvwd nhI hY? pMjwb dy h`kI msly ijvyN pwxI, rwjDwnI (cMfIgVH), pMjwbI boldy ielwky ieiqAwidk hor h`kI mMgW nMU AxgOly krnW is`Dm is`Dw isAwsI A`qvwd nhIN qW hor kI hY? ikRpw hux qusI dovyN iDrW sqrkqw sihq iDAwn dyxw:- A`qvwdI kOx? dy iCVy mu`dy AMdr jykr sMn 1978 dy GtnwkRm dI g`l nW kIqI geI qW bihs ADUrI rih jwvygI[ swƒ sd A&sos huMdw hY jdoN srdwr bwdl swihb Awp jI v`loN is`K g`BrUAW ƒ A`qvwdI ivSySx nwl invwijAw jWdw hY[ srmweydwr srdwrVw swihb jI ieiqhws gvwh hY 1968-70 ivc c`lI nkslbwVI lihr dy jwJrU KwVkUAW ƒ Bwrq ivc sB qoN pihlW quhwfy rwj-kwj ivc JUTy puils mukwbly bxw ky mwirAw igAw[ hux qusIN hI d`so 80 dy krIb pMjwb dy pu`qrW ƒ JUTy mukwbilAW ivc kql krn qy Bwrq ivc ies rwh ƒ Kohlx dw ishrw Awp jI dy isr bJdw hY ik nhIN[ kI qusIN s`qvwdI hox dw dwAvw krdy ho? hux sMn 1978 dy GtnW kRm auqy nzr mwrIey, jdoN pMjwb ivc quhwfI srkwr sI Aqy sYNtr ivc quhwfy isAwsI BweIvwlW Bwv bI.jy.pI. dI srkwr kMm krdI sI[ srdwrVw swihb quhwfy isAwsI BweIvwlW dI vot isAwsq dI pYdwieS nrkDwrI bwbw gurbcnW quhwƒ A`j q`k kdy A`qvwdI idKweI ikauN nhIN id`qw ? BUqry A`qvwdI swnW (nrkDwrIAW) v`loN gurU sihbwn pRqI ApSbd bolxy, quhwfI srkwr v`loN ivswKI dy Aiq nwzk idn aus ƒ jlUs k`Fxy qy jlsw krn dI AwigAw dyxw, nrkDwrIAW v`loN 13 msUm inh`Qy isKW ƒ kql kr dyxw, quhwƒ A`qvwd ikauN idKweI nhIN idMdw ? l`gdy h`Q Awp jI dI kwrguzwrI dI g`l vI kr leI jwvy nrkDwrI ƒ bw ihPwzq pMjwb ivcoN bwhr k`F dyxw, isMGW dy kys ƒ pMjwb qoN bwhr iNBjvw dyxw, nrkDwrI A`qvwdI bwby gurbcny ƒ quhwfy AKOqI lokqMqrI inzwm dI BirSt inAwpwlkw v`loN sw& brI kr dyxw, quhwfy v`loN ShId isMG dy kys dI PweIl bMd kr dyxw kI quhwfy smyN dw srkwrI A`qvwd nhIN sI ? nrkDwrI bwbw gurbcnw sI.bI.AweI. duAwrw pyS kIqI hweI post mwrtm irport muqwbk Srwb dw AwdI hox krky gurdy Aqy izgr PylH hox dw mrIz pwieAw igAw[ aus v`loN AMny AgnI sSqr r`Kxw, AwpxI &Oj bxwauxw, ivBcwr dy A`fy kwiem krnw quhwƒ (dohW iDrW nUM) kdy A`qvwd ikauN nhIN idKweI id`qw ? quhwfy dohW iDrW dI auc p`DrI isAwsI lIfriSp vloN bwby ƒ h`lwSyrI dyx auhdy fyry (ieMdrw gWDI, igAwnI jYl ishuM, morwrjI fysweI, vwjpweI, aumrw nMgl Awidk) auqy jwxw kI iPrkU isAwsI qy srkwrI A`qvwd nhIN sI? mwVy Bwg pMjwb dy quhwfIAW (dohW iDrW dIAW) isAwsI nIqIAW dw A`qvwd lokW dy gl pY igAw[ quhwfIAW glq nIqIAW Aqy iensw& nw imlx krky isK nOzuAwnW Aqy sMq jrnYl isMG jI iBMfrWvwilAW ƒ mzbUrn iensw& Kohx leI hiQAwrbMd hoxw ipAw Aqy A`j hYrwnI dI g`l hY ik qusIN iPr ies AiqAMq nwzuk m`udy ƒ sOVI isAwsI nzr nwl qoldy nzr Aw rhy ho? 1978 qoN bwAd 1984 q`k jo kuJ vwpirAw aus ivc “k`C, kVw, ikRpwn Byj idAWgy pwiksqwn” “isgrt bIVI pIeyNgy Swn sy jIeyNgy” dy nwAry mwrn vwly lkSmI kWqw cwvlw, bldyv rwj cwvlw, mncMdw vrgy lok ijnW ny AMimRqsr dI piv`qr DrqI ƒ iPrkU ibAwnW qy nwAirAW dy A`qvwd nwl plIq kIqw, rylvy stySn ’qy sRI drbwr swihb dw mwfl qoiVAw Aqy A`j q`k ijnW dI soc A`qvwdI Aqy iPrkU hY ijnHW ny Ajy vI AMimRqsr dIAW kMDW ‘Agr ihMdosqwn myN rihnw hogw qo ihMdUihq my kihnw hogw’ vrgy iPrkU nwAry ilK ky kwlIAW kIqIAW peIAW hn, quhwfI isAwxI sBw ƒ A`qvwdI ikauN nhIN idKweI id`qy? siqkwrXog lIfr swihbwn qusIN audoN gOr nhIN kIqw isr& AwpxI isAwsI iKcVI bxwaux ivc hI ivAsQ rhy Aqy nqIjw swkw nIlw qwrw dy rUp ivc inkilAw[ quhwfIAW dohW iDrW dIAW nzrW ivc sB qoN Kqrnwk A`qvwdI sMq jrnYl isMG jI iBMfrWvwly, BweI suKdyv isMG b`br, A`j vI is`K nOzuAwn mnW auqy rwj ikauN kr rhy hn? ikRpw krky s`cy mn nwl kwrn Kojx dI koiSS zrUr krnw jI[ mhwrwjw swihb ijhVI pwrtI nwl Awp jI sbMDq ho, du`D DoqI auh vI nhIN[ mMn ilAw jwvy ik sMq iBMfrWvwly Aqy aunHW dy jwnSIl srkwrI nzrW ivc doSI sn pr sRImqI ieMdrw gWDI vloN hmlw krn leI sRI gurU Arjn dyv jI dw ShIdI idhwVw hI ikauN cuixAw igAw? kI sMq iBMfrWvwly Aqy aunHW dy jwnSIn iksy hor qrIky nwl igR&qwr nhIN krvwey jw skdy sn? quhwfI rwxI dIAW &OjW v`loN XwqrUAW aupr qS`dd krnw, kIrqnI isMGW ƒ mSIn gMnW nwl BuMn su`txw, bzurgW b`icAW ƒ ipAwsy mwrnw, sMgqW ƒ jUn mhIny dI kVkdI grmI ivc nMgy krky PrS qy iltw dyxw, nOzuAwn bIbIAW dI bypqI krnw, kI srkwrI A`qvwd nhIN ikhw jw skdw? aunHW idnW ivc Awp jI ny swkw nIlw qwrw dy hmly dy ros vjoN AsqI&w id`qw, Swied Awp jI dI soc aus smyN ies swry vrqwry ƒ A`qvwd smJdI hovygI[ pr A`j qusIN Awpxy piv`qr AKvwauNdy sdn ivc iek`ly sMq iBMfrWvwilAW qy isK g`BrUAW ƒ ikhVy mUMh nwl A`qvwdI khI jw rhy ho? sRImqI ieMdrw gWDI, BwrqI &Oj, jnrl vYidAw, suMdrjI, brwV, idAwl vrgy BwrqI kirMidAW ƒ A`qvwdIAW dI ikhVI kYtwgrI ivc r`Kdy ho? d`sx dI Kycl krnI jI[ swkw nIlw qwrw qoN pihlW drbwrw ishuM srkwr smyN BweI kulvMq isMG nwgoky, BweI gurmIq isMG DUrkot qy AnykW is`K nOzuAwnW ƒ koh-koh ky kql krn vwly srkwrI qwnwSwhW Aqy srkwrI puils ƒ, ijs ny ipMf cupkIqI dI isK lVkI (ilKidAW Srm Aw rhI hY) aupr aus dy ipqw ƒ inrvsqr krky iltwieAw dyS BgqW dI s`qvwdIAW dI nvIN kYtwgrI ivc r`K lYxw sI[ 1984 qoN bwAd smyN dy c`kr ny rwxI ƒ kIqy dI sjw id`qI[ aus ƒ mwrn ivc jykr (quhwfy muqwbk) BweI byAMq isMG qy sqvMq isMG ƒ doSI vI smJ ilAw jwvy qW BweI kyhr isMG ƒ inrdoS hI &wsI lwaux vwlIAW quhwfIAW AdwlqW ƒ kƒnI A`qvwdI dI ifgrI kdoN dyvogy? sRI mqI gWDI dI mOq bwAd jo kuJ id`lI qy hor SihrW ivc vwpirAw auh quhwfy kolo gu`Jw nhIN ho skdw[ id`lI kqlyAwm leI izMmyvwr quhwfy pwrtI mYNbrW Bgq, tweItlr, lilq mwkn vrgy A`qvwdIAW bwry kI iKAwl hY? ies swry iBAwnk Gtnw kRm dw muK izMmyvwr quhwfI pwrtI pRDwn dw mhrUm pqI pwielt rwjIv gWDI ijsny “jb koeI bVw pyV igrqw hY qo QoVI sI zmIn qo srkqI hI hY” vrgw A`q A`qvwd BrpUr ibAwn id`qw ijs dI srpRsqI hyT hzwrW isKW ƒ glW ivc twier pw ky izMdw sVvw id`qw igAw, isK b`cIAW nwl blwqkwr hoey ies mrhUm A`qvwdI s`jx bwry Ku`lyH mn nwl vIcwr kr lYxw[ kI ieh izMmyvwr ivAkqI ƒ A`qvwdIAW dI ilst ivc r`iKAw jw skdw hY? jW iPr iesdy A`qvwd ƒ klmb`D krn leI “A`qvwd” dI QWvyN koeI hor Sbd GVvw pvygw? id`lI kqlyAwm dy pRmuK doSIAW ƒ quhwfy AKOqI lokqMqr ny A`j q`k koeI sjw ikauN nhIN id`qI? ies swry vrqwry dIAW izMmyvwr swrIAW iDrW (isAwsI pwrtIAW, inAwpwlkw, votqMqr) ikhVy pwsy qoN s`qvwdI hn? 1984 dy GlUGwry ivcoN aupjy roh ny isK nOzuAwnW (quhwfy muqwbk A`qvwdI jW lVky b`cy) ƒ AKOqI Bwrq dyS ivc Asur`iKAw dw Aihsws krvwieAw jo iek muK kwrn bixAw isK jvwnI dy ivdrohI hox dw[ l`KW nOzuAwnW ƒ kql krn vwly ryA, rIbYro, ky.pI.AY~s. igl vrgy srkwrI A`qvwdIAW bwry kI iKAwl hY? rwjw swihb ies qoN pihlW quhwfI pwrtI dI byAMq ishuM dI srkwr smyN isKW qy hoey zulmW dI khwxI ilKx leI mxW mUMhI vrky kwly kIqy jw skdy hn[ sMqW dy Brwqw BweI jgjIq isMG rofy ƒ kql krky rylvyN lwien auqy sut dyxw, ibml kOr ^wlsw ƒ auhdy bwQrUm ivc krMt lgvw ky Kqm krvw dyxw, jgivMdr isMG AYfvokyt kpUrQlw ƒ 1988 ivc quhwfy lokqMqr dI A`qvwdI puils ny Kqm kIqw[ AYfvokyt klvMq isMG sYxI ƒ aus dI pqnI Aqy ds swl dy msUm b`cy smyq mwr ky nihr ivc roV dyxw, jQydwr KufIAw dw kql, sMgrUr dy bfbr ipMf qoN vkIl s. B`tI, sRI Bgq isMG dw Bwxjw kuljIq isMG quhwfI nwdrSwhI puils dy kihr dw iSkwr ho ky dunIAW qoN c`l vsy kI ieh sB A`qvwdI vrqwrw nhIN? mnu`KI AiDkwrW dy AlMbdwr s. jsvMq isMG KwlVw ƒ idn idhwVy aus dy GroN Agvw krky Awp jI dy AKOqI lokqMqr dy rwiKAW ky.pI.AY~s. igl qy AjIq isMG sMDU v`loN koh-koh ky Kqm kr id`qw igAw[ kI ieh srkwrI A`qvwd dw isKr nhIN hY? ropV izlyH dy KwVkU nOzuAwn BweI blivMdr isMG jtwxw dy pirvwr ijs ivc aus dI pMj swl dI msUm BwxjI qy A`sI swl dI bzurg dwdI q`k ƒ hor pirvwr mYNbrW smyq quhwfy sumyD sYxI dy pwlqUAW v`loN izMdw jlw dyxw qW A`qvwd nhIN dyS BgqI hovygI? ipMf iklI bodlw ivKy iek pirvwr ( ijs dw ksUr isr& ienHW sI ik aunHW dy GroN kuJ KwVkU pRSwdw Ck gey sn) ’qy quhwfI puils vloN kIqw igAw AMnw qS`dd ijs dI imswl nyVly ieiqhws ivc imlxI AsMBv hY, swry pirvwr ƒ dr`KqW nwl nUV ky inrvsqr kr id`qw igAw, aunHW dy srIrW ƒ k`dUkS kIqw igAw qy swry srIr iC`ly jwx qoN bwAd grm fIzl pwieAw igAw[ Swied ieh vI quhwfIAW nzrW ivc s`qvwd hI hovygw[ byAMq isMG srkwr smyN iek`ly AMimRqsr izlyH ivc hI p`cI hzwr isKW ƒ lwSW ivc qbdIl krn dy sbUq s. KwlVw v`loN id`qy gey[ ijnW ƒ bwAd ivc suprIm kort ny kbUl kIqw hY[ ies qoN ielwvw AnykW nOzuAwnW ƒ nihrW Aqy dirAwvW dI ByNt kr id`qw igAw ijnW dI igxqI dy AWkVy hzwrW nhIN l`KW ivc jw phuMcdy hn, kI ies swry vrqwry ƒ BwrqI lokqMqr dw s`qvwd ikhw jwvy? quhwfI pwrtI dI srkwr (byAMq isMG) smyN aus smyN dy puils muKI ny pMjwb ivc puils v`loN pYdw kIqy nklI KwVkUAW (kwlIAW ib`lIAW) ƒ puls dI zrUrI loV kbUl kIqw hY[ puils v`loN iqAwr kIqIAW kwlIAW ib`lIAW dy kwly kwrnwimAW ny ijQy KwVkU &orsW ƒ Kqm krn ivc pRSwSn dI shwieqw kIqI auQy Awm lokW dI iezq AwbrU Aqy izMdgI dw Gwx kIqw[ kI ies ƒ srkwrI A`qvwd nhIN ikhw jwvygw? kursI leI r`sw-kSI kr rhy rwjw jno ikqy s`cy mn nwl AwpxI AMdrlI Awqmw ivc bwkI bcdI mwVI motI zmIr dy ikxikAW ƒ iek`iTAW krky nihrW, dirAwvW dy pulW, iknwirAW, SmSwn GwtW dy buJ cu`ky isivAW dI rwK dw dOrw krky dyKo iek A`D nhIN hzwrW srkwrI A`qvwd khwxIAW A`KW A`gy bl auTxgIAW Aqy quhwfIAW nzrW ivcly AKOqI mhwnwiek plW ivc KlnwiekW ivc qbdIl ho jwxgy[ AsIN kUk-kUk ky ieh kihxw cwhuMdy hW ik jykr ieh sB kqlogwrq BwrqI Amn jW dyS dI eykqw AKMfqw ƒ kwiem r`Kx leI hoeI hY qW muAw& krnw pMjW pwxIAW dI DrqI ƒ Bwrq dI bMdy KwxI SWqI qoN Kqrw hY ies leI ies ƒ A`qvwdI grdwinAw jwvy[ hux jWdy-jWdy bwkI sUibAW v`l vI nzr mwr leI jwvy ijhVw kuJ BwrqI &OjW kSmIr, nwgwlYNf, Aswm, mIjorm qy nkslbwVI lihr pRBwivq A`T rwjW ivc kr rhI hY[ kI auh A`qvwd nhIN hY? isAwsI pRBUE ho skdY ik bRhmpurw ipMf ivc isK bIbIAW dy mUMhW auqy quhwfIAW lokqMqrI &orsW v`loN v`FIAW dMdIAW qW quhwƒ Xwd nw rhIAW hox pr mnIpur dI DrqI auqy hoieAw mnormw kWf qW hwly k`l dI g`l hY Aqy BwrqI qMqr dI hlkI hoeI mwniskqw dw pRqIk hY[ pqw nhIN hor ivcwrIAW ikMnIAW ku mnormW BwrqI &orsW h`QoN hr roz kohIAW jWdIAW hoxgIAW? kI BwrqI &OjW (&orsW) A`qvwdI nhIN hn? pr kOx khy rwxIeyN A`gw F`k? skqy dw s`qI vIhIN sO[ s`c! A`qvwd dI iek iksm ibAwn krnI qW bwkI hI rih geI[ Bwrq dI B`uKI mrdI sO kroV jnqw dw swrw srmwieAw isr& quhwfy vrgy cMd ku srmweydwr GrwixAW kol bYA ipAw hY[ ijMnW dI kul igxqI 110 ku qoN v`D nhIN hY[ iek pwsy ijs dyS ivc lokweI dw 80% ih`sw jIvn ijaUx dIAW muFlIAW loVW qoN vI hIxw hY[ auQy cMd ku srmweydwr, isAwsI qy rwj GrwixAW dw dyS dy srmwey auqy s`p vWg kuMflI mwr ky bYTy rihxw ikhVw s`qvwd hY? swfy muqwbk qW ies ƒ srmweydwr A`qvwd AwKxw auicq hovygw? quhwfy iKAwl dI aufIk rhygI[ AMiqkw :- siqkwrXog rwjw swihb Aqy bwdl swihb AMq ivc AsIN ieh ilKx ivc Borw vI ihckcwht mihsUs nhIN krdy ik BwrqI qMqr ivc mOzUd lokqMqrI (AKOqI) qwxwbwxw, ihMdU A`qvwdI sMgTn, swrIAW vot vtorU rwjsI pwrtIAW, BirSt A&srSwhI, zwlm puils Aqy hor &orsW, A`qvwd leI izMmyvwr hI nhIN sgoN Kud A`qvwdI hn[ so AsIN quhwfI A`qvwd leI izMmyvwr kOx? dI byloVI bihs krn dI bjwey, A`qvwdI kOx hY? dy mudy qy Ku`lI bihs dw s`dw idMdy hW[ ieh bihs dunIAW Br dIAW Amn psMd qwkqW AYmnstI ieMtrnYSnl, ihaUmYn rweIts vwc, XU.AYn.E. Aqy Amn psMd srkwrW, smwjvwdI dySW Aqy sgMTnW Aqy pUrI dunIAW dy inrp`K mIfIey Aqy ivdvwnW swhmxy kdoN vI ikQy mrzI kr leI jwvy[ AsIN ies Ku`lHI bihs leI iqAwr hW[ hly kI ey swfw pMKyrUAW dw pqw l`gygw jdoN AsIN tihlggy AsIN g`BrU qUq dI CtI vrgy ijMnW CwgoNgy Enw hI PYlrWgy Awp dohW iDrW dy pRqIkrm dI aufIk ivc Sihbwz Kwlsw [/gurbani]

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Iron Man · 01 Nov 2005

Straight arrow, kulbir singh has posted many times on this forum about bhagat kabir jee being a sikh of guru sahib, you can read his posts through a simple search, or he might even post here again. regarding the new hindu one god philophy i dont buy it and i know plenty of hindus that would disagree with you.. the problem is, hinduism isnt one religion but many sets of beleifs lumped into one, theres some that beleive in many gods and the reality of them (we beleive such beings exist but that they are nothign special as they cannot even meditate on akal purakh) and then theres some hindus that think theres one god (no doubt an influence of bhagats and of guru nanak dev jee and others). also, the point of shabaaz khalsas letter isnt to insult hinduism but to say why is there a double standard? if our sikh heroes, the singhs who were butchered by the indian government are so called terrorists, what does that make these indian heroes? its to make people think.. not to incite hatred.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Siddharth · 01 Nov 2005

Jaspal - I DARE YOU to shut me up. Neo-Sikhs like you would be most pleased if Hindus bellied up and swallowed the utter lies of groups like Shahbaz Khalsa. Sorry, ain't gonna happen. My reponses in capital letters (doesn't mean I'm shouting but my responses will be easier to make out. 1. Raam Chander Ji: - Historical scriptures refer to this personality as the Maryada Purushottam (ideal man), but in reality Ram Chandra Ji could also be considered a very barbaric terrorist. Just by reading the Ramayan, the evil deeds of this person can be identified. IF ANY SARDAR READS THE RAMAYAN THOROUGHLY, HIS EVIL DEEDS WOULD VANISH JUST BY SAYIN RAM NAAM. The whole fight of Ramayan took place because of Raam Chander. INCORRECT. IT WAS BECAUSE OF RAVAN. At one time when Ravan’s sister Saroop Nakha approached Raam with a marriage proposal, Raam refused while telling her that he is already married, sendin g her to Lachman. He lied to her about him being unmarried when he was already married. When she met Isn’t cutting the nose of a woman who comes with a marriage proposal an act of terrorism? IF YOU WERE MARRIED AND SOME LOOSE WOMAN THREW HERSELF AT YOU AND YOU TOLD HER SEVERAL TIMES THAT YOU WERE MARRIED BUT SHE ASKS YOU TO KILL YOUR WIFE AND MARRY HER INSTEAD, WHAT WOULD YOU DO? WOULD YOU MARRY HER? ANYWAY, WHAT HAPPENS NEXT, IS VERY CONVENIENTLY IGNORED BY THE GREAT MINDS OF SHAHBAZ KHALSA. SOORP NAKHA GETS VERY UPSET AT RAM AND LAXMAN AND TRIES TO KILL THE BROTHERS. IT IS ONLY THEN THAT LAXMAN CUTS OFF HER NOSE AND EARS. BUT LISTENING TO THE SK OFFICIALS, THEY WOULD IMMEDIATELY MARRY ANOTHER WOMAN IN CASE SHE PROPOSED TO THEM EVEN IF THEY WERE MARRIED. Why is it that both of you never cared to label this ideal man a terrorist? Would you consider the act of killing the Shudhar saint who worshipped God as an act of friendliness? WHAT IS THIS ALL ABOUT? DEFINITELY DOES NOT APPEAR IN TULSI RAMAYAN. He forced his wife into ‘Agni Prikhiya’ and yet disowned her when she was pregnant. Would this be considered an act of love? THIS WOULD BE CONSIDERED RAM RAJYA. A PERSON CONSIDERS HIS PRAJA TO BE MUCH MORE THAN HIS OWN FAMILY AND IS READY TO SACRIFICE ANYTHING FOR THE PRAJA. CAN YOU NAME ONE PERSON WHO CAN DO IT TODAY? It would take a long time to mention all the acts of Raja Raam Chander Ji. More can easily be found by reading the ‘terrorist’ scripture Tulsi Ramayan. OF COURSE, AS STRAIGHT ARROW POINTED OUT, HE IS VERY MUCH ADMIRED BY THE SAINTS IN GURBANI. 2. Hanumaan: - This person is known for committing many sadistic crimes at a young age. In his youth, he abducted the ‘Suraj Devta’! He was also responsible for destroying the Lanka. It is agreed that Ravan was responsible for abducting Sita, but was the destruction of the whole Lanka as revenge reasonable? Here, its about mass killing. THIS IS LAUGHABLE. I JUST LOVE IT WHEN THE NEO-SIKHS PRETEND TO HAVE GREAT KNOWLEDGE OF HINDU SCRIPTURES. THERE WAS NO MASS KILLING. HANUMAN JI JUST BURNT LANKA. AGAIN THE GREAT MINDS OF SK FORGET WHAT LEAD TO THIS EVENT. HANUMAN JI HAD GONE TO LANKA TO PERSUADE RAVAN TO GIVE UP DEVI SITA BY PEACEFUL MEANS BUT HE TRIED TO BURN HANUMAN INSTEAD WHOM HE THOUGHT WAS A NOTHING ENEMY. HOWEVER, VIBHISHAN'S HOUSE WAS SAVED AS HE HAD GREAT FAITH IN GOD. YOU CAN LEARN TWO LESSONS HERE: 1. NEVER CONSIDER YOUR ENEMY TO BE WEAK 2. WHOEVER HAS GREAT FAITH IN GOD WILL SURVIVE EVEN THE TOUGHEST OF TIMES 3. Krishan Ji: - Just like Raam, this person is also considered an incarnation of Vishnu. Wasn’t he responsible for having an affair with his aunt Radha? AGAIN, LAUGHABLE. KRISHNA IS CONSIDERED TO BE PREMAVTAR. RADHA WAS NOT KRISHNA'S AUNT AND RADHA-KRISHNA IS SUCH A PURE AND DIVINE RELATIONSHIP THAT SMALL SMINDS SUCH AS THOSE OF THE SK CAN'T FATHOM EVEN ONE DROP OF IT. What was the reason behind his acts towards Rukamani and Chandrawal? He was also responsible for starting the battle of the Mahabharat by deceiving Arjun. DECEIVING ARJUN??? NOW, NOW, NOW, SK, WHERE DID THIS COME FROM? ARJUN'S CHARIOTEER WAS LORD KRISHNA AND SYMBOLICALLY, THIS IS SO GREAT THAT MINDS LIKE THOSE OF THE SK CAN ONLY DEGRADE THIS. This battle would have stopped if he wished but he instead decided to get brothers to fight amongst themselves. HOW COULD HE HAVE STOPPED THE BATTLE? INSIGHTS PLEASE. He also got Arjun to kill his teacher Dronacharya by getting Yudhister to lie about Asvatthama’s death. AGAIN, THIS IS HALF-BAKED INFORMATION. DRONA WAS AN ACHARYA-A TEACHER. HIS PLACE WAS NOT ON THE BATTLEFIELD BUT HE GOT INTO IT FOR THE GLORY AND ARJUN COULD NOT BRING FORTH ENOUGH COURAGE TO KILL HIS TEACHER. THEN BHIM KILLED AN ELEPHANT BY THE NAME OF ASHWATTHAMA WHICH IS WHEN YUDHISHTHIR TOLD DRONA. To find more on these ‘terrorist’ acts, please refer to the Mahabharat, Sukh Sagar and Gita. IF YOU REFER TO THE GITA, AND READ IT COMPLETELY AND FAITHFULLY, I PROMISE YOU WILL SEE THIS IN A COMPLETELY DIFFERENT LIGHT. JO BHAANA MAHARAJ KA, BAAT BANEGI SOI WHO KNOWS WHAT GOD'S WILL IS. IF THE KAURAVAS HAD TO DIE, THEY HAD TO. GURU GOVIND SINGH IS CONSIDERED ALMOST GOD. HE COULD'VE STOPPED HIS CHILDREN FROM BEING KILLED BUT HE DID NOT. HOW CAN YOU QUESTION GOD? 4. Inder and Brahma Ji: - I feel ashamed to write about the acts of these fellows. Bibi Rajinder Bhathal referred to the Rig Vedh during the debate. When any person joins in the worship of God, the throne of these personalities gets waved and they send elegant looking women such as Menka and Urvashi to put obstacles in the way of these Bhagats. These are the daring acts of these people. MOST OF IT IS SYMBOLIC. EVEN TODAY, WHEN SOMEONE STARTS ON THE PATH OF PURITY AND RELIGION, THERE ARE HUNDREDS OF OBSTACLES AND ONLY WHEN ONE PASSES THE TESTS CAN ONE ATTAIN THE LORD. SO IF THEY PUT OBSTACLES IN THE PATH OF THE BHAGATS, GOOD FOR THE BHAGATS. THAT SEPARATED THE REAL BHAGATS FROM THE ONES WHO JUST PRETENDED TO BE BHAGATS. HAANSI KHELI HARI MILE, TO KAUN SAHE SIRSAAN KAAM KRODH TRISHNA TAJO, TAHI MILE BHAGWAN (IF ONE COULD GET THE LORD BY LAUGHING, THEN WHO WOULD TAKE PAINS TO REACH HIM? ONLY WHEN ONE GETS AWAY FROM KAAM, KRODH AND TRISHNA, DOES ONE ACHIEVE THE LORD) To write the story of Ahilya’s rape is impossible for me. You can read it in the Rig Vedh yourself. I'M NOT AWARE OF THIS BUT I WILL READ IT AND COME BACK TO YOU. ANYWAY, WHY SHOULD THIS BE IMPOSSIBLE? ARE THE SK OFFICALS SAYING THAT THIS DOES NOT HAPPEN? On this incident Gurbani states: To read about Brahma Ji, you can refer to the history of Kopal Mochan. It’s your wish where you want to place these two fellows in the list of terrorists. For more examples refer to Shiv Puran Brahm Puran, Rig Vedh and Inder Puran. Respected Raja Sahib and Badal Sahib, we know very well that it’s not possible for both of you to consider the above mentioned persons as terrorists. But we hope that you aren’t tired yet of hearing the stories of terrorists. Please forgive us, but in our small thinking we have a huge list of those who terrorized India. To mention all of them would not be possible. But before leaving this topic we would like to touch the subject of the terrifying scriptures: 1. Manu Simriti: - This great scripture was penned by Brahma Ji’s great son Manu. All of the saloks from this scripture deal with keeping the low caste and women away from their worldly needs. It talks of dishonoring low caste women and how the low caste men and women are impure. HAVE THE GREAT MINDS OF SK EVEN OPENED THIS SCRIPTURE? I HAVE READ BITS AND PIECES OF IT AND THEY ARE CORRECT IN MENTIONING THAT THEY TALK ABOUT CASTE SYSTEM, THE REST OF IT IS VERY ENLIGHTENING. JASPAL, I URGE YOU TO READ THIS. I THINK BHAI KULBIR SINGH MENTIONED THAT HE HAS READ THIS, MAY BE HE CAN SHED SOME LIGHT ON THIS. 2. Chanakya Niti: - Not only does this scripture talk about ruling through separation, it also teaching the theory of ‘Sham, Daam, Dandh, Bhed’. Sham which means to make others agree by using cunning means, dham means to buy support of people, dhandh means that if they still don’t agree, punish them (just like false police encounters). FIRST OF ALL, THIS IS NOT A SCRIPTURE, THIS IS A BOOK OF POLITICS. MACHIAVELLI WROTE A SIMILAR BOOK IN THE ROMAN TIMES AND THE PEOPLE REFER TO THIS EVEN TODAY. I HAVE TO SAY, THOUGH, THAT I HAVEN'T READ THIS BOOK SO CAN'T COMMENT ON IT. CHANAKYA'S OTHER BOOK, ARTHASHASTRA IS A FANTASTIC BOOK ON ECONOMICS. EVEN TODAY,PEOPLE IN THE US AND GERMAN UNIVERSITIES HAVE THEIR Phd THESES ON THIS BOOK. These are the terror filled teachings of these scripture. But I doubt that any of you will agree to consider these scriptures as being the cause of terrorism. This is because both of you are believers of Indian politics which arose from the teachings of these scriptures. But let’s move on. Let me remind you that our subject is to discuss “who is the actual terrorist”. We have only shown you the advertisement so far, the whole film is yet to follow. Historical Terrorism: - After discussing these scriptures, let us look at Hindu terrorism during the time of Buddhism. Where Buddhism teaches equality among humans, love for humanity, non-violence and enlightenment, the Hindus promote worship of 33 million deities, separation of human kind, Sati tradition, degradation of women and other such things. AGAIN, YOU CAN'T HELP BUT FEEL SORRY FOR THE SMALL MINDS OF SK. I SUGGEST THEY LEARN ABOUT HINDUISM FIRST BEFORE ACTUALLY COMMENTING ON THIS. DEGRADATION OF WOMEN APPLIES MORE TO THE SGPC THESE DAYS WHO WILL NOT ALLOW WOMEN TO PERFORM KIRTAN AT THE GOLDEN TEMPLE This religion of Buddhism which was becoming widely accepted all throughout the country at the time of Ashok started to look dangerous in the eyes of the Brahmin terrorists. After the death of Ashok, Buddhism was wiped from India by these Brahmins. CAN THESE MINDS TELL ME OF A WAR IN WHICH BRAHMINS FOUGHT AGAINST BUDDHISTS? Not thousands, but hundreds of thousands of Buddhist temples were demolished. INDIA HAS SOME OF THE OLDEST BUDDHIST TEMPLES, CAN THESE GREAT MINDS NAME EVEN 5 BUDDHIST TEMPLES THAT WERE DESTROYED? Those Buddhists who were left alive after these massacres went to places such as China, Burma, Thailand, Cambodia (CAMBODIA???? HAVE THEY NEVER HEARD OF ANGKOR WAT? HAVE THE GREAT INTERNET WARRIORS SUCH AS JASPAL NEVER HEARD OF ANGKOR WAT?) and Japan (ACTUALLY, THE BUDDHISTS DESTROYED THE ORIGINAL RELIGION OF JAPAN-SHINTOISM) to save this great religion. This religion again grew successfully in these countries. If these acts of Brahmins aren’t acts of terrorism, then what are they? Would your Sadan be interesting in opening a debate on the black acts of these terrorists? If such a time ever comes, we will surely attend the debate along with historical scriptures, Buddhist scholars, pro-terrorism Hindu scriptures, and the writings of respected Dr. Bhim Rao Ambedkar and Dalit literature. ALL IN ALL - I HAVE SPENT ENOUGH TIME IN RESPONDING TO THE CHILDISH ACCUSATIONS OF SK. I HOPE THAT ENOUGH SIKHS HAVE READ THIS AND AT LEAST TRIED TO UNDERSTAND THE POINT OF VIEW OF THE OTHER SIDE. NO RELIGION IS BAD, SOME PEOPLE MAKE IT SO. INSTEAD OF BADMOUTHING HINDUISM, SK SHOULD FOCUS ITS ENERGIES ON WRITING THE WRONGS OF THE SIKH COMMUNITY AND FIGHT THE RSS, IF NECESSARY. I AM SURE, IF THERE WAS A TEAM OF 100 RESEARCHERS THAT I HAD, I COULD FIND AT LEAST 100 ACTS OF TERRORISM, COMMITTED IN THE NAME OF RELIGION BY FOLLOWERS OF EACH AND EVERY RELIGION OF THIS EARTH AND HINDUISM IS NO EXCEPTION. MY FINAL POINT - JIYO AUR JEENE DO. STOP DISSING HINDUISM. THE GOVERNMENT, SURE. THE MEDIA, SURE. RSS, SURE. THE POLICE, SURE. BUT HINDUISM, NO.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Swaran Singh Panesar · 01 Nov 2005

Dear Sid, Whether or not you are a Hindu, it does not concern me in the least but from the style of your writing it would appear to me that you are a completely ignorant person, who has very little knowledge about the shameful acts of your very own so-called Hindu gods and godesses as mentioned in the Hindu vedas. It would be very interesting to learn from the 'clever dicks' like you the definition of a 'Hindu', Hindu beliefs and practices, and 'Hindu' worship. Surely, a person of your calebre would not or would not like to know what the RSS/VHP sponsored Hindu fundamentalists have already written about the Sikh Gurus, Great Sikh Martyres, and the Great Sikh warriors alike. Have you any idea why the Hindu writers are so interested in distorting/destroying the Sikh History since the times of Guru Nanak? And why do the so-called Hindu writers categorically avoid mentioning the shamefull acts of your gods and godesses in the text books for school children? In any case the Sikhs do not expect the pro-Hindu media to be honest and independant. Unlike the Hindus, Sikhs have a unique history full of unparalled sacrifices and persons of high character throughout the last 540 years. Unlike the Hindus, Sikhs do not worship the stone statues and the like. Unlike the Hindus, the Sikhs do not believe in mass killings of the innocent men, raping women and children. Unlike the Hindus, Sikhs do not interfere in other religions; they respect all the world religions. What is your opinion? Be advised, study the history of the Hindus which is based on nothing but lies and betrayals throughout the ages and when you have done that, I bet you would neither have the strength nor any sanity left to look straight into the eyes of a Sikh nor would you open your careless mouth to criticise the Sikhs in any way. Only the inhumans like you might feel happy to justify the massacre of 40,000 plus Sikh men, women and children at the hands of those criminal minded Hindus in 1984? You have raised the issue of [our]'rights'. Please tell us what 'rights' do your Hindu brothers have to interfere with the Sikh religion and malign the name of the Sikh nation without which the people like you would not have survived forcible convertions into Islam. So, why don't you people mind your own business and learn to live and let others live peacefully? Let mealso remind you that Shahbaaz Khalsa is one of the many and the most courageous establishments that stand for the righteous cause of the Sikhs. Whether you like it or not, they have every right to produce series of Truthful literature, articles, books and important documents for the benefit of the Sikh nation. Sikhs have openly challenged the Hindu fundamentalist leaders to hold discussions in the past, they are being challeged now and they will continue to be challenged for ever. Truth is the weapon that defeats falsehood. For that very reason the Hindus have always failed to accept any challenges offered by the Sikh scholars. It is a well-known fact that Truth is the bitterest pill for anyone to swallow, especially for the highly ignorant people like you. Ulimately, it is only the Truth that shall prevail. Hopefully this brief note would suffice to shut your mouth for now. I have no intention of hurting your feelings but should you wish to continue with this topic on the basis of your unfounded arguments on this forum, I am prepared to setlle the scores with you without hesitation. Furthermore, my sincere advice to you is to listen carefully and accept the Truth with patience and kill that ugly monster that disturbes the peace of your mind and the peace of mind of other culprits like you. Shahbaaz Khalsa Zindabaad. Swaran Singh Panesar.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Straight Arrow · 01 Nov 2005

Dear Swaran Singh Panesar ji, Sat Sri Akal and Namastey. I am so glad that you have no intention of hurting the feelings of Hindus. You sure have a funny way of showing it. In any event, what is your point? That Sikhs are superior than Hindus? That Hindus are cowards, that our Gods and Godesses lower than the Sikh God? OK, accepted. Now what next? Just answer one simple question? If Ram and Krishn are no good, then why are they mentioned in Gurbani? You MUST take out each and every reference to Ram, Krishn, Gopal, Murari and then, I will accept that the Sikhs are the greatest thing to have happened to this world. Thank you.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Niranjan Singh · 01 Nov 2005

Siddharth stated : >>>CAN THESE GREAT MINDS NAME EVEN 5 BUDDHIST TEMPLES THAT WERE DESTROYED? How about 84,000 ? http://www.reference.com/browse/wiki/Pusyamitra_Sunga Pusyamitra Sunga (also Pushyamitra Shunga) was the founder of the Indian Sunga dynasty (185-78 BCE). He reigned from 185 BCE to 151 BCE. Originally a general and commander-in-chief on the armies of the Mauryan empire, he assassinated the last Mauryan emperor Brhadrata in 185 BCE, and subsequently founded the Sunga dynasty. Pusyamitra Sunga was a Hindu monarch, deeply established in the tradition of orthodox Brahminism. He allegedly became very active in persecuting the Buddhist faith, which the Mauryan empire had been promoting since Ashoka around 250 BCE. He seems to have destroyed Buddhist monasteries and exterminated monks, offering to pay 100 gold coins for the head of each one (Indian Historical Quarterly Vol. XXII, p.81 ff cited in Hars.407, also Divyavadana, p.429-434). [u]He is said to have destroyed 84,000 buddhist stupas which had been built by the Mauryan king Ashoka (R. Thaper). A large number of Buddhist monasteries (viharas) were converted to Hindu temples, in such places as Nalanda, Bodhgaya, Sarnath or Mathura.[/u] ca. 200 BC - 100 BC Late Buddhist Golden Age Realising that they could not defeat Buddhism from the outside, the Brahmins resorted to destroying it from within. The Brahmins slowly infiltrate Buddhism, with the aim of undermining it from within. Brahmin `converts' to Buddhism start to attack each other, thereby splitting Buddhism into several warring factions. Foremost of these Brahmin conspirators is Nagarjuna, who succeeded in sounding the death-knell of Buddhism by expending all his energy in vitriolic attacks against other Buddhist sects. Buddhism splits into innumerable perpetually warring sects; the confused population is left bewildered, and the world's greatest anti-Brahmin movement is soon destroyed from within. After the rise of the fanatic Brahminic Guptas, all traces of Buddhism are destroyed in India. [%sig%]

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

ps · 01 Nov 2005

And how do they hope to obtain their goal by going against gurbani. Even Sant Jarnail Singh used to say for sikh to be true sikh, hindu to be true hindu, muslim to be true muslim. The terrorists don't follow any religion for they are communists. For if they followed religion then it would have shown in their behavior. Dukh and Sukh are two sides of the coin of life. This is teaching of sikhism. If we follow the three bhabba then we have no worry - bhabba bhana, bhabba bhalla, bhabba bhuli. Religious is to look at bad qualities in yourself, look at good in other. wjkk wjkf

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Sukhmander Singh · 02 Nov 2005

vahiguroo ji ka khalssa, vahiguroo ji ki fateh i m very thank ful to Bahi Mehtab Singh and bhai Swaran Singh Panesar jo nad other guriskhs. who supprort to Shahbaaz khalsa's truth about Who is Attwadi matter. bahman is very clever . he beated us from last 3000 years but now we r awaked with blessing of Guroo Sahib JI. so now i want to see...................................................... him with hard hands. vahiguroo ji ka khalssa, vahiguroo ji ki fateh Sukhmander Singh Meet Jathedar, SHAHBAAZ KHALSA

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Mehtab Singh · 02 Nov 2005

My only request to the Singhs of the Shahbaaz Khalsa is as follows : You guys have taken a really bold step in standing up for Sikhi in India. Now please use your energy to educate non-Sikhs about Sikh scriptures, history and all that the Sikhs have had to face at the hands of the Mughals as well as after 1947. Let the people be aware that the people whom they mock are not clowns but lions. A mere reading of your article by any non-Sikh will give him/her the impression that its full of hate ([i]I know you'll disagree with me but for once look at it from their viewpoint[/i]). I wish you guys all the very best in educating the Indian masses about what the Sikhs have suffered before and after 1984, but please don't pull religion into this. Since you ([i]as you say[/i]) have nothing against Hinduism or Hindus, it would be best if you could enlighten them on the futility of their political masters rather than insult their scriptures and deities. Tomorrow they will bring up historic facts against our Gurus and Puratan Shaheeds, and may even slap us on the face with [u]seemingly[/u] reliable evidence. What will we do then? This inter-religious disharmony will never end. I mean I seriously don't understand. Gurujee never hated or condemned any of these avtars, in fact He saw the light of Waheguru in all. So who are we to malign their name? And for what purpose? Plus its not possible to educate someone if all you can do is insult them. In the end, I am not against these guys or their Panthic mission. I just don't seem to support the way they are doing their stuff, atleast for now. Yeah I know nobody gives 2 cents about my opinion or support ([i]after all who the heck am I to comment[/i]), but I would really want to know how other Sikhs and non-Sikhs in India would react to this write up by Shahbaaz Khalsa. [%sig%]

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Kulbir Singh · 02 Nov 2005

The following is my personal opinion. Many Singhs may differ in opinion: Surya Vanshee Raam Chander, the eldest son of King Dashratha and Kaushaliya, was a good man of great probity. I don’t understand what is the purpose of slandering him unnecessarily. Being a Singh of Siri Dasmesh jee, I don’t worship Krishna or Rama even in my dreams but this does not mean that I can’t appreciate their many good doings. Gurbani is very fair to these two personalities (Krishna and Rama). Where they deserve praise, they have been praised for their good deeds or their divine powers and where they made mistakes, Gurbani has clearly and vocally stated them. Just because they made mistakes does not mean that everything they did is bad and that we should unnecessarily slander them. Here are some of the comments on issues raised in the original post: Cutting off Saroopnakha’s nose: This vile woman – Saroopnakha – approached Rama with sexual intentions. It’s written in the Hindu scriptures that she was a very beautiful woman. Rama was alone, in a secluded area in the forest when he was approached by Saroopnakha. Raam jee rejected all her advances and kept his character high. Saroopnakha refused to take rejection. Finally to get rid of her, he sent her to his brother Lakshman, telling her that since he (Rama) is married and is with his wife in the forest, he would be unable to take her (Saroopnakha). He asked her to try Lakshmana and see if he agrees to marry her. He knew how high Lakshman's character was. She went to Lakshaman who was an embodiment of high character and probity. He too refused to lose his character. Saroopnakha got very vulgar and promiscuous with him. When he could take it no longer, he slapped her and cut off her nose. While one can argue that he should not have cut off her nose but we should not ignore the fact that Lakshman had a great character. When Sita was taken away by Ravan and Lakshman was asked to explain how she looked like, Lakshman innocently replied that all his life he had only seen her feet and had never looked at her face. He said that he could only describe her feet. This tells a lot about his great character. Rama and Lakshman were such great kings but yet they did not marry more than once. Though polygamy was allowed and acceptable in those days, these two men kept themselves to one wife only. As for who started Mahabharat, Krishna cannot be blamed for this war. The following persons were most responsible: 1) Dhiritrashtra: He was the king of the Kuru dynasty and ultimately it is his responsibility that Duryodhan went out of control and did all those atrocities to his cousins Pandavas. He was a victim of Puttar-moh (attachment to his son) and though his wife Gandhari kept advising him not to let Duryodhan do all this, he failed to restrain his son. He holds the primary responsibilty for this war. 2) Bhishma: He was the great grandfather of Pandavs and also was the most mature fugure there. He blindly sided with the Kauravs knowing very well that Kauravs were wrong. He misinterpreted his pledge that he would always side with the king of Kurus. His personal pledge was not greater than the virtues that were taught to him by his religion of Vedas. He should have kept Dharma above his personal pledges. 3) Duryodhana: He is directly responsible for Mahabharata. He was totally evil and Gurbani confirms this too. His dead body was left out in the open and vultures ate his dead body. He did not even get a funeral. He is responsible for the destruction of civilization of that time. 4) Shakuni: He was the uncle of Duryodhana and he misled his nephew. He was a very vile person. 5) Panchali: You will be surprised to see this name here. I think Panchali (Durpadi) was partially responsible for this war. When Kauravs came to the kingdom of Pandavas in Indraprastha, Duryodhan accidently fell in a pool. She made fun of him and said that a son of a blind is a blind after all. Duryodhana never forgot this comment and pledged to teach her a lesson. He overdid the revenge and tried to strip her naked in front of everybody. Bheem pledged that he would drink Dushasan’s blood in battlefield. All this resulted in Mahabharata. Krishna was not responsible for Mahabharata. Please explain how he was responsible. And Radha was not his aunt and nor he had sexual relationship with her. He was only 9-10 years old when he used to play with Radha the milkmaid who was married at that time. Once he left Brindaban and came to Dwarka, he never met Radha, Chandravali and other Gopis again. We should not forget that Rama and Krishna were great men but still they were humans only. They had great powers but they were not mistake-proof. They made mistakes too. But they did good things too. Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee makes it clear in one of his shabads that Raam cried when he was separated from his wife Sita. Pandavs suffered so much, even though Krishna who was supposed to be an Avatar was on their side. One of the mistakes Krishna made was the way he killed Ashavdhama, the son of Dronacharya. He used trickery to do so. Same way, he should not have asked Arjun too shoot Karan when he was changing the tire of his Chariot. That was wrong. Also, according to Gurbani, Rama and Krishna did not connect people to the bhagti of Vaheguru. Instead, people started worshipping them. That was wrong. Kulbir Singh

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Mehtab Singh · 03 Nov 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh i dont have words to appreciate bhai kulbir singh ji's response...veerjee, i should have known that only u can respond intellectually...it was stupid of me to have tried...but anyways, total respect to ur post waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Kulbir Singh · 03 Nov 2005

------- One of the mistakes Krishna made was the way he killed Ashavdhama, the son of Dronacharya. He used trickery to do so. --------- I just want to retract this statement in my previous post. Ashavdhama was the son of Dronacharya and there also was an elephant by the same name. Dronacharya was invincible and was destroying the Pandav army and even Arjun was unable to counter him and stop his onslaught. Finally, Krishna came up with an idea. He knew that Dronacharya was very attached to his son. He asked Bheem to kill Ashavdhama the elephant. Then they spread the rumour that Ashavdhama was killed. As soon as Dronacharya heard this, he got depressed. He thought that his son had been killed. He lost all interest in fighting. Then when Arjun faced his Guru (Dronacharya), he easily defeated him and killed him. Later on, Ashavdhama who had survived the Mahabharata Yudh, killed all sons of Panchali. Many others were burned alive. So one could conclude that though Pandavs technically won the war but in reality no one won it. Everybody suffered heavy losses. There was no celebration of the victory. Krishna died soon after. Kaljug started soon after. Prikshat the grandson of Arjun and son of Abhimanyu was the first king of Kaljug. Prikshat died of snake bite and Janmeja his son committed massive atrocities as written in Gurbani. Kulbir Singh

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

JEEVAN SINGH · 03 Nov 2005

TO SHAHBAAZ KHALSA WE SUPPORT SHAHBAAZ KHALSA VERY MUCH AND HOPE YOU WILL BRING CHANGE IN PANJAB ! I REQUEST TO YOU TO HOLD REGULAR CONFERENCES AND CONVENTIONS WITH OTHER PANTHIC GROUPS, WE FEEL PANTHIC GROUPS NEED TO WORK MORE CLOSELY WITH EACH OTHER. PLEASE MAKE GOOD REALTIONS WITH DAL KHALSA | AKALI DAL (MANN) KHALSA PANCHYAT | AKALI DAL INTERNATIONAL SHIROMANI KHALSA DAL | KHALSA CONFERENCE SIKH STUDENTS FEDERATION (BITTU) | HUMAN RIGHTS ORGS KHALSA RAJJ PARTY | KHALSA MISSION COMMITIEE PLEASE REPLY TO ME !! [%sig%]

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

hs singh · 03 Nov 2005

i read total matter......... now i want to ask about Sahahbaaz khalsa which located this organisation;s head office? who operated this org.? is this org like other sikh organisatios like babbar khalsa, khalistan kommando force, dal khalsa etc. plzz tell me who is writer of this matter "WHO IS TERRORIST"

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Dr.Sukhpreet Singh Udhoke · 04 Nov 2005

guru piyare jio, wahe guru jika khalsa wahe guru ji ki fateh. SHAHBAAZ KHALSA is a public wing of GURSIKH(global united research and service institute of knowledge for humanity) the office of the org. is in sri amritsar .the mode of working of this org. is not like other orgs. which you have above mentioned. our mission is try to stop the missinterpretation of sikh scripture,and counter the fascist organizations like RSS which are always trying to proof that sikhs are not a separate nation and they are a part and parcel of hindu society.this letter was written by SHAHBAAZ khalsa officials under the exelent command of thier jathedaar S.Amardeep singh amar and released to prees by me as the media sevadaar. Dr.Sukhpreet singh Udhoke SHAHBAAZ MEDIA and GURSIKH FEATURES NOTE-WE ARE VERY THANKS FULL TO THAT SINGHS AND OTHERS WHICH ARE ACTIVE IN ABOVE DEBATE,AND AFTER ALL WE WILL ALSO POST OUR REPLY TO ALL WITHIN FEW DAYS.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Swaran Singh Panesar · 05 Nov 2005

Dear Sid, ‘The illiterate of the 21st Century, are not those who cannot read and write, but those who cannot learn, unlearn and relearn [AlvinTofler] Please read my post carefully, try to understand it thoroughly, and then respond to it [if possible] in a formal and appropriate manner. I am a learner, always willing to unlearn and reIearn. So please help me by having a healthy discussion. By the way, the 'Ram', 'Krishan', 'Gopal', and 'Murari' that people like you have in mind were never included in the Gurbani. Looking forward to receiving a better response to my post this time. Thanks Swaran Singh Panesar. [%sig%]

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Sukhmander Singh · 05 Nov 2005

Respected Bhai Sahib Bhai Kulbir Singh ji Vahiguroo ji ka khalsaa, vahiguru ji ki fateh with high regards I hope that u have read all books of bhai sahib bhai randhir singh ji So plzz before giving ur opnion next time read Gurmat Gorvita very very carefully. In December 04/ jan05 when u visited in India while going to Hazoor Sahib u with all sangat and stayed that Bhai Ratinder Singh’s house (indore). And u have carried set of 13 books naming “SARITA MUKTA REPRINT”. These 13 books containing more than 400 article of 4-5 pages each. All the article were deadly against Hindu mythology all the authors of these books were hindus and were from differents facets, each and every article contained more than sufficient examples from all Hindu granths, according to Hindu granth it self Rama and Krishna were characterless and terrorist person. Plzz read all those different books very very carefully. Before making opinion abt Krishna plzz read Krishna avtar bani in Dasham Granth Sahib completely and care fully. According to Krishna avtar itself Krishan was having sexual relation with many young women including Radha. It is very clear the Krishana avtar that Krishan was drug addict, he was addict of Bhang, afeem, dhatoora, and many more drugs. Do u think that Guru Sahib has written wrong in Krishna avatar? Maharshi Balmiki have written in Balmiki Ramayan that Rama was an alcoholic drinker and he used to watch mujra(dance of prostitute). He used to beat Sita many times and forced her to drink and join him in watching mujra. All such details of Balmik Ramayan was published in an aritcal written by Sardar Balwant Singh Bahoru in may 2000 issue of GURMAT PARKASH( A monthly magzin of S.G.P.C.). The orginal Balmiki or Bhudhist ramayan are available in our library. Many other Hindu granths for reference are also available with us. The letter head contained many names of Hindu terrorist, but why u replied only to defend Rama and Krishna. Do you agree all other contains in the letter completely. Why u have stop discussion only on the First paragraph about Rama and Krishna. And also answer me CHANDAWAL named woman (wife of a milkman) who kidnapped and raped by lord Krishna ( plzz read care fully 12th pourri of Assa Ki Var) So plzz read carefully Gurmat Gorvita, Sarita Mukta reprint and Krishna Avtar (Dasham Granth) then start the fresh discussion on the subject. High Regards From All of us. Sukhmander Singh Karmu wala Meet Jathedar Shahbaaz Khalsa

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

, . · 05 Nov 2005

7.1 RAMA'S RUTHLESS PERSECUTION OF WOMEN Rama treated women with all the severity of the Vedas. As per standard versions of the Ramayana, Rama was 16 years old when she married Sita, and Sita was only 14 years old [ Ram.wh 69 ]. However, these are later, forged versions where the Brahmins have deliberately deleted incriminating passages proving that Rama married Sita when she was 6 years old. As per the oldest extant versions of the Ramayana, namely the Buddhist Ramayana, the marriage was performed as per Manu-Smrti, and Sita was only 6 years old when the lecherous bastard Rama raped her. Marrying a 6 year old baby clearly shows that Ram was not only a rapist and scoundrel to boot but also a child molester. " These items were deleted by the Vaishnava Brahmans in yet another attempt to perpetrate historical fraud. However, the truth has finally been dug out since the Buddhist Ramayana is older than the extant Vaishnava versions, and preserve the facts which were later suppressed by the Aryan Vaishnava fundamentalists. Rama's dirty laundry has been exposed for all to see. So Rama was, besides being guilty of the mass murder of Sudra Blacks, introducing apartheid and supporting fascism, guilty of incest and child-marriage. " -- [ Babu ] Many of the real-life passages of Rama's life are also preserved in the Ravayana, an oral history of the Dalits. This version also accredits Rama with killing his own father. This epitome of a god was nothing but a coward who cut off womens' noses and murdered his enemies by striking from the back. After he brutally murdered Ravana this traitor burnt the city of Lanka, killing all the thousands of innocent women and children in it. These are only a few of the sadistic crimes against humanity committed by this butcher. 7.2 KRISHNA'S WONDROUS TREATMENT OF WOMEN The main reasons for forming the insidious religion of Brahmanic Hinduism was so that the white male Aryan followers of this religion could satisfy their desires with their own as well as the enslaved black Sudra women. Later the lecherous Brahmin men transformed Vedism into Vaishnavism (which represents 75 % of all `Hindus') and abrogated to themselves the right to sexual enjouyment of all races, while other men were forbidden access to Brahmin women. One of the main examples of this wonderful treatment of aboriginal women is the `great' God Krishna himself. He raped the Black Sudra women, namely the low-caste cowherdesses or gopis on a massive scale. These ghastly deeds were later distorted into a benign love story by the fraud Brahmins in order to whitewash Krishna's crimes. 7.3 BRAHMA'S KINDNESS TOWARDS WOMEN As I have already proved in the previous chapters the Vedas justity treating a women as nothing but an object for forced labour, child-rearing and fuel for fire or money-making (through Vedic dowry). The creator God's interactions with women, his insatiable lust for lascivious ladies, his lecherous behaviour with his wives and concubines are components that form the model of a true Brahmin. In fact, every Brahmin is said to be a manifestation of Brahma [ cite ] hence they have to follow him in every respect ! The legend of Brahma and Sarasvati is given in the following Vedic texts ( Spellman, p.28 ): Aitareya Brahmana.III.33 Satapatha Brahmana.I.7.4.1ff; XIV, 4.2.1ff; Matsya Purana.III.32 ff; Bhagavata Purana.III.12.28ff. Kovoor has amply summed up the acts of this vile `God' Brahma, the model for all Hindus : " Brahma is one of the 3 main gods - Trimurti - of the Hindu pantheon. He is the creator of the universe. Sarasvati, who became the wife of her own father, was the daughter of Brahma. There are 2 stories about her genesis in the `Saraswati Purana'. One is that Brahma created his beautiful daughter Saraswati direct from his `vital strength' or seminal fluid. The other is that Brahma used to collect his semen in a pot whenever he masturbated fixing his carnal eyes on the celestial beauty Urvasi. Brahma's semen in the pot gave birth to the sage Agastya, and Agastya in turn gave birth to Saraswati. Thus, Saraswati had no mother. This daughter or grand-daughter of Brahma is the Hindu goddess of learning. When Brahma saw the beauty of Saraswati he became amorous. To escape from her father's passionate approach Saraswati ran to the lands in all four directions, but she could not escape from her father. She succumbed to Brahma's wish. Brahma and his daughter Saraswati lived as husband and wife indulging in incest for 100 years. They had a son Swayambhumaru and a daughter Satarupa. THrough the incest of Brahma's son and daughter Brahma got two grandsons and two grand-daughters." [ Kovoor, p.76 ] This shows that Brahma considered women merely as objects for sensual fulfullment. Read on about the `greatness' of these Hindu gods. His constant affairs with women throws light upon his insatiable appetite. The Vedas enjoin incest as a kind of marriage. This fact was utilised by Brahma when convincing Sarasvati (also known as Padma) to succumb to his unlimited lust : " 8. On seeing his beautiful daughter Padma, Brahma was sexually excited. He wooed his daughter and wanted to copulate with her. How could a daughter give consent to her own father? Padma refused. Brahma could not give up his desire. He began to quote the Vedas to convince her that there was nothing wrong in having sex with anyone, anytime, anywhere for the sake of giving birth to a child. " -- ( Puran ) This is the Vedic verse Brahma quoted to justify incest : Mathara Mupathya, susara Mupatithe, Puthrartheetha. Sagamarthi, Napathra loka, nasthee thath. Saravam paravo vindu ha, dasmath Puthrar tham. Matharam suransathee Rehathee - ( Vedas, cited in Puran ) Translated this verse means " This is the sanskrit sloka Brahma quoted to his daughter. The sacred verse enjoins, that for the sake of a child one can enjoy her own sister or daughter, without any sin attached to it. ( Puran )" Yet, the Brahmins give some strage `justifications' for this act, in order to fool the non-Brahmins into practicing incest and destroying their race forever : " Brahma followed Savitri [ Sarasvati ], married her, and they lived together in a lotus for one hundred years. The Purana [ Matsya ] then points out that no question arises regarding prohibited acts of the gods since they do not reap the fruits of their karma (actions) as do mortals. A further justification of Brahma's action is given by noting that Brahma is the lord of the Vedas and Savitri is the goddess of the Vedas. They therefore are inseparable, and to unite the Vedas with the sacred prayer can surely be no evil." ( Spellman, p.30 ) Brahma was not satisfied by visiting the many prostitutes and had to marry his own daughter. Incest being sanctioned in the `Holy' Vedas, she was more than happy to marry her father. What a great father Brahma was, a model for all Brahmin fathers ! Indeed, Brahma served as the model and justification for the terrible Devadasis system. This was the instutionalised mass rape of Black Sudra women by lecherous Brahmin men. The huge Vishnu temples served as massive brothels in which thousands of Sudra women were forced into prostitution. Not only that, the money they earned was all eaten by the Brahmins ! The Vishnu temples of Brahmanism served as an open sex market with the Brahmin men as pimps and Sudra women as the merchandise. What a fantastic religion indeed ! And in this, Brahma merely served as the role model of the mad, raping Brahmin whose lecherous sexual appetite knew no bounds. >>>>>>>>>>>>> Excerpt of Krishna/Chandravali story: Debauchee Womanizer Seeing the situation, the beautiful Lalita consoled Vinodini Radha, and went out to search for Madhava. She looked for Vanamali Krishna in every gopi’s kunja. At last, she came to Chandravali’s kunja. There she found Banamali, maddened after the love of Chandravali. Seeing Him there, Lalita became very surprised. She took a ketaki flower leaf from the decoration on her hair, wrote a letter on that leaf and threw it on the road in the place where Shyam would depart from the kunja. With much anger, Lalita sakhi then came to Radhika and said, “O my dear friend! What shall I tell You? Chandravali has bound up Muralidhara, that lampata nagara, debauchee womanizer. The poet Sri Chandan says, “Oh Kishori, Lord Hari has rejected You.” Restless Krishna At dawn, Shyam woke up and found the ketaki leaf letter. He picked it up and immediately knew that it was Lalita’s handwriting. His chest trembled. He thought, “Giving up the love of Kamalini, lotus-like Radha, I am here with Chandravali.” Breathing heavily, His mind disturbed, Krishna thought, “How did They know I was here? Oh what I will do now?” The poet Sri Chandan says, “Kanu, Krishna, became restless and apprehensive.” Radhika’s Anger Like a thief, Shyam then went to meet Kishori. With folded hands, a cloth around His neck, and straw in His teeth, He came before Kishori and began to plead, “O merciful Radhe! Please forgive Me for My offenses.” Humbly offering His obeisances again and again to Her, Shyam said, “O life of My heart, please show Me Your moon-like face. I am dina-jana, a fallen person, but You are dina-bandhu, the friend of the fallen. Please be merciful to Me. O karuna-sindhu, ocean of mercy. Please excuse this offender.” Hearing Shyam’s humble prayer, Kishori became even angrier. Radharani was keeping Her back to Shyam, Her moonlike face looking down at the ground. She began drawing lines on the earth with Her fingernail. At that time, Lalita held a mirror in front of Radhika’s face. Seeing Shyam’s reflection, Radha became even angrier and began to chastise Lalita. But lotus-like Radha noticed that Krishna was wearing a piece of Chandravali’s cloth. She said, “What kind of cloth are you wearing? There is kajjala and vermilion on Your lips. Go back to Your dearmost Chandravali and try to console her.” Seeing bite marks on Krishna’s cheek, and seeing that His peacock feather was bent and the hair on His head completely disheveled, Radhika said, “Go present Yourself to Chandravali! You have no shame! Even though the Yamuna River is nearby, You have not washed Your face. O Braja-bandhu, Krishna, friend of the Vrajabasis, now Your name ‘Radha-bandhu’ no longer applies. Before You were mugdha-natha, lord of bewildered persons. Now You have become Chandravali-nath, the Lord of Chandravali.” Krishna said, “O affectionate Radha! You are most forgiving! Please forgive Me. O foremost of young girls, I became bewildered and mistakenly touched a lily, thinking that it was a lotus. “O ksama-nidhi, ocean of forgiveness, Sri Kishori! Please excuse Me for all of My offenses. Unable to bear Your harsh insulting words, I must jump into the Yamuna river and end My life. I am like the body and You are the life. Without You, everything is empty. Radhika angrily responded, “Don’t touch me. Get out of here! I don’t want to see You. I don’t even want to see Your shadow. O shameless one, go! Take bath in the Yamuna, feed the brahmanas, and became free from sin.” All of the sakhis then spoke to Radhika on behalf of Krishna. They said, “O crest jewel of young women! Why are You so angry with Giridhari? Not getting a taste of nectar, You are throwing it away. This will only bring You lamentation. You know how He danced on the heads of Kaliya and how He lifted Govardhan Hill. What kind of love do You have? Sukadeva Goswami, Sanaka Kumar, Janaka Maharaja — all of the sages and all of the three worlds are meditating on His name. That same Krishna is now standing before You with folded hands. Please don’t make Him more miserable and depressed. Show Him Your face and relieve Shyam of His sorrow.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Dr.Sukhpreet Singh Udhoke · 05 Nov 2005

respected, Wahe guru ji ka khalsa Wahe guru ji ki fateh i m sending some qoutes from the writtings of Dr.B.R.Ambedkar with the refernces of hindu mythological graths.i think that will be enough who claims that rama was god,and the ram word used in gurbani is for lord rama. so, we are in this qouting only some hindu historians,so plz accept this first reply,post u next again. THE HINDU RELIGION EXPOSED Brahmins always criticize, condemn and mock at other religions Their criticism and mocking is unreasonable and unacceptable. In his autobiography, Dr Charles , an American scholar says that it is very simple to define a Hindu. He says a Hindu means "one who believes in anything and everything if said in the name of god and shall never question its authenticity". The Brahmins claim that Lord Rama is incarnated (came in human form) to study and understand the difficulties of mankind. Is it really necessary for a god to incarnate Himself?? CAn he not understand the creation? Why should God become a donkey or a cockroach in order to understand the sufferings of these creatures? LORD RAMA Lord Rama is the central character to the Epic RAMAYAN (whose author was Valmiki) Rama is the son of Dasharath, the king of Banaras. Dasharath had three wives, kaushalya, kaikeyi and Smitra besides several hundreds concubines. According to the Ramayana, Rama spent most of his life trying to save his wife, Sita from the clutches of Ravan At the same time Rama was enjoying life to the full at every opportunity. HOW RAMA WAS FOOLED BY SUKRIEVAN When god Rama was exiled to the forest together with his wife, sukrievan appeared as deer and fooled god Rama. Although Rama was a "god", he was not able to see through Sukreivan's disguise! 12 YEARS FOR RAMA, BUT ONE DAY TO RAVAN To retrieve his wife from Devil Ravan, god Rama sought the help of Hanuman, a monkey god. Hanuman agreed to help Rama bring his wife back on condition that god Rama in turn help him (Hanuman) to kill his twin brother prior to undertaking the mission. I took more than twelve years for Hanuman to build a bridge and accomplish the task while Ravan just took Sita and flew to Sri lanka in just one day's time Where is the bridge that Rama built?? Who is more powerful - God Rama or Devil Ravan ? Would a god seek the help of another god to murder a third god? · If Hanuman could fly carrying big mountains, he should have in the first instance carried and flown god Rama to Sri Lanka, which would have resulted in early rescue of Sita. · Who knows what Ravan might have done to Sita during this period of twelve years? Definitely a devil would have done only "devilish" things! Before helping god Rama, Hanuman made Rama shoot his own twin brother in the back and only then did Hanuman help god Rama How can a "god" indulge in such a criminal act for personal gain? BEEF EATING RAMA When God Rama was told to go to forest, he mournfully revealed to is mother: "if has been ordained that I have to lose the kingdom, forego the princely comforts and the tasty, MEAT DISHES. (Ayodha Kandam, 20, 26, 94th Chapters). RAMA'S MANY WIVES Mr. C.R. Sreenivasa lyengar's translation of Valmiki Ramayana says: " Though Rama had married Sita to be the queen, he married many other wives for sexual pleasure in accordance with the royal customs. (Ayodha Kandam 8th Chapter, page 28). (The term "Rama's wives" as been used in many places in Ramayan). RAMA'S DISRESPECT FOR HIS FATHER Rama called his father " A FOOL, AN IDIOT" (Ayodhya Kandam, 53rd Chapter). RAMA'S CONTEMPT FOR WOMEN & LOW CASTES Rama disfigured and mutilated many women by cutting off her noses, breasts, ears etc., and tortured them (Soorpanaki, Ayomuki). Rama said, "Women should not be trusted" and that "Secrets should not be confided to the wife" (Ayodhya kandam, Chapter 100). Sambuka was slain (by Rama) because he was making penance which was forbidden to hime by Vedas as he was a "Shudra" (Uttara kanadam, Chapter 76). Looking at is hand Rama said the Sanskirt slogan "O right hand, you kill this Asche Shudra unhesitatingly as killing this Shudra is the only way to get back the life of the deceased Brahmin boy." Are you not one of the limbs of Rama? (Valmiki Ramayana) Note: This Rama, who mercilessly took away the life of Sambuka for no other fault than that of making penance, is held as the Avatar (incarnation) of Vishnu (God)! If there were kings like Rama alive now, alas! what would be the plight of those who are called "Shudras?". RAMA'S DEATH Rama , like an ordinary man, fell down into the river and was DROWNED. (Uttara Kandam, Chapter 106). How can a "god die? Who will then look after the affairs of the world? LUSTFUL SITA VS THE "IMPOTENT" RAMA Sita told Rama "You are no better than a woman-monger who lets his wife for hire and makes is livelihood. You want to be profited by my prostitution". Sita also told Rama "You lack in POTENCE, manners and charm" & "She called her husband a simpleton". As soon as Sita stepped into Ravan's palace her love towards Ravan grew more. (Aranya Kandam, Chapter 54). When at length Rama asked Sita to swear about her chastity, she declined and died. (Uttara kandam, Chapter 97). Kukuvavathy, sister-in-law of Rama, said to him - "Oh Elder! How you love Sita more than you love yourself! come with me and see what really is in your lovely wife's heart. Still she could not forget that fellow Ravan. Drawing a picture of Ravan on hand-fan and pressing it closed to her bosom She is lying on your bed with eyes closed thinking on and rejoicing at Ravan's glories. Rama sighed and went out to Sita's house. There she was found sleeping pressing to her breast the hand-fan on which Ravan's picture was drawn (This is found in pages 199, 200 of the Bengali Ramayana written by Mrs. Chandravathi). If Rama loved Sita so much and Sita is held as an ideal Hindu wife, can Hindu women tolerate their husbands leaving them in forest for the years? Rama left Sita in forest after se became pregnant and she delivered er two kids in forest. (DR. B. R. Ambedkar : Riddles in Hinduism Maharashtra Govt. Publication, 1987). WHAT LEADERS SAY ABOUT GOD RAMA? · "My Rama (god Rama) is not the Rama of Ramayana". Mahatma Gandhi · "The Ramayana and Mahabaratha are nothing but another Arabian Nights Story" Jawaharlal Nehru · "Rama is not a god; but he is a hero" Rajagopalachari, First Governor-General of India and a great Brahmin leader. · "Ramayan is not a divine story; it is only a literature" (Kaliyuga Kamban, T.K. Chidambaranatha Mudaliar). Babri Masjid was demolished by Rama Bhatkas claiming that it was his birth place. LORD KRISHNA Lord krishna was very fond of looking at naked young girls. Once upon a time Krishna, in order to get a full view of some bathing virgin girls, went to the extent of hiding their clothes on the tree top just to get a panoramic view. Does he have divine immunity from looking at naked women? The Gita, a Holy book of the Hindus, quotes that when these bathing low caste girls begged for the return of their clothes, Lord Krishna demanded that they come out of the water with their hands raised instead of covering their bodies. Oh my innocent Hindu brethren! Can this action be attributed to god? Is this God capable of indulging in such ungodly acts? Will Hindu mothers tolerate their son imitating god Krishna?? THE RIDDLE OF RAMA AND KRISHNA The "Times of India" reported on 12-11-87 that the Education Department, Government of Maharashtra, had published a book called "The Riddles of Hinduism" by Dr. Ambedkar. The report said that various statements contained in the book aroused the ire of some Brahmins, particularly the author's observation on Rama & Dasharth's many wives and also Krishna's moral character. (The Riddles of Rama and Krishna is available from Dalit Saithya Academy, Bangalore-3). GOD SHIVA, LORD GANESH & GODDESS PARVATHI According to Hinduism, god Shiva's head is the source of the river Ganges and his head is also the place where the moon is located (if this was really a fact then why should America send astronaut Neil Armstrong 240,000 miles away to the moon) According to Puranas, goddess Parvathi, wife of God Shiva, sought Shivas's permission to have a baby When Shiva refused, Paravathi took dirt from her body and created Lord Ganesh. (The late E.V.R. Preiyar used to call this god a "bundle fo dirt"). Later God Shiva mistakenly chopped off his own son's head. How could a god make such a foolish mistake? Would such a god solve your problems or make them more complicated? To rectify his error God Shiva severed the head of baby elephant and transplanted in onto his son who then become known as the Elephant headed god. His statues are usually found near river-sides where he is said to be looking for a bride resembling his mother! (There is a different version to this story which, for decency's sake, cannot be printed here). PORNOGRAPHY IN RAMAYANA Dr. Charles claims that Ramayana contains much pornographic materials and cannot be read in public. He gives the following examples. Rama's description of Sita's beauty which is lewdly detailed (refer to C.R Srinivasa lyengar's translation of Aranya Kandam - Chapter 46). In Kiskind Kandam, Rama explains to Lakshmana of his sexual experience with Sita. BRAHMINS AS BEEF-EATER According to the Ramayana, the Aryans (Brahmins) used to drink liquor (nine different kinds), eat beef, marry many wives and prostitution was an accepted way of life amongst the priests and gods. "Sura" means alcoholic drink. All the Aryan gods drink "sura" and hence they are called suras as against a suras wo don't drink. Ravana was an asura. Periyar E.V.Ramaswamy, a great Hindu leader of Tamil Nadu, was a worshipper of Ravan because Ravana was a Dravidian. Ramanaya also recounts the story of king Dasaratha who, in order to have a baby son, made a big sacrifice (yagam) of sheep, cattle, horses, birds and snakes. He then delivered his three wives Kaushaliya, Sumatirai and Kaikeyi to three priests. These holy men, having fully satisfied their carnal desire, returned the ladies to the king. By this means, the king was able to have three sons-Ram, Lakshman and Bharat (Bala Kandam, Chapter 14. For more details on yagam, refer to the book "Gnana Surian", published by the kudi Arasu Press.) Does it mean Rama was born to a Brahmin? The Ramayana tells us much about the unlawful relationship of incest but we do not feel it appropriate or decent for ut to go in details (Please refer to Aranya Kandam, chapter 45 verses 122, 123, 124, & 125). The following Aryan practices will reveal how immorality and indecency are sanctified in the name of Hinduism. LINGAM & YOUNI Lingam and Yoni in Sanskrit means the male and female sexual organs respectively. Hindus are allowed to worship anything - including sexual organs. It is not unknown for them to name their children as Shiva Lingam (God Shiva's sexual organ) or Rama Lingam (God Rama's sexual organ), (in some places in Karnataka, the gods demand both male and females to pray naked together). DEVADASI (RELIGIOUS PROSTITUTION) The Devadasi system was set up, according to a Times of India report (10-11-87), as a result of conspiracy between the feudal class and the priests (Brahmins). The latter, with their ideological and religious hold over the peasants and craftsmen, devised a means that gave prostitution their religious sanction. Poor low-caste Hindu girls, initially sold at private auctions, were later "dedicated" to the temples. They were then initiated in to prostitution Even to this day this religious prostitution blessed by Hindu religion is still alive in Karnataka and Maharashtra. BHARAT NATYAM & THE BRAHMINS The Bharat Natyam is a dance performance which, because of the Brahmin media, has gained much recognition as a form of art. The celebrated Bharat Natya expert, Rukmini Devi, admits in National Geographic video program, that the Barahta Natayam was really the art of Devadasis (temple prostitutes) to please their audience and admirers. This is the reason why you might have seen various Baratha Natyam postures in Hindu temples. May be like the art of KARATE of the Japanese, the BHARAT NATYAM is a national art to the Brahmins and very much part of their culture. THE KAMASUTRA Brahmins has also created Kamasutra - a set of instructions on how to have sexual intercourse. Some of the postures detailed in Kamasutra are so complex that they can only be performed with the help of one or more ASSISTANTS! Some Hindu temples have stone carvings of Kamasutra sexual poses and Hindus worship them. THE DEVADASI SYSTEM THRIVES UNI. - TIMES OF INDIA - 10th Nov 1987: confirms that the practice of dedication young Harijan (Hindu) girls (Mahars, Mangs, Dowris and Chambhar) at childhood to a goddess, and their initiation into prostitution when they attain puberty continues to thrive in Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh and other parts of South India. This is largely due to social backwardness, poverty and illiteracy, according to a study by two doctors of the India Health Organization. The report clearly indicates that the Devadasi system was the result of a conspiracy between the feudal class and the priests (Brahmins) who with their ideological and religious hold over the peasants and craftsmen, devised a practice which acquired religious sanctions. They noted in their study on - "Devadasis" - "the link between religious culture and child prostitution". The study revealed that girls from poor Hindu families were sold after puberty at private auctions to a master who initially paid a sum of money to the families ranging from 500 to Rs. 5,000. The study, made during health camps organized by the World Health Organization (WHO) in the Devadasi populated areas, revealed that the dedicated girls formed 15 percent of the total women involved in prostitution in the country, and as much as 70 percent of the prostitutes in the border districts of Karnataka and Maharashtra Shahbaaz media services and gursikh features [%sig%]

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

JEEVAN SINGH · 05 Nov 2005

TO SHAHBAAZ KHALSA !!!!!!!! PLEASE REPLY TO MY ABOVE POST ! [%sig%]

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Straight Arrow · 05 Nov 2005

<<>> Swaran Singh Panesar Bha Ji - This was my question. I am also willing to learn. I am the smallest of small men but my question remains unanswered. If these words are not Hindu Gods, then what are they? Why were these names used in Gurbani? I'm not trying to offend anybody, just looking for an answer. <<>> <<>> Dr. Sukhpreet Singh Udhoke Ji. First of all, the very first line of your post is incorrect. Dashrath was the King of Ayodhya and not Banaras. Secondly, again, I am willing to accept that Sikhs are great but you have again avoided answering my basic question. If the word used in Gurbani is that of some other Ram, who is this Ram? Who is this Krishn whose name is used in Gurbani? Also, since when did Ambedkar become an authority on Hinduism? He converted to Buddhism, didn't he? Please do respond. Mine is a simple question. Thanks you.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Mehtab Singh · 05 Nov 2005

Actually there are a number of other things that have confused me always. Like Krishan ji breaking his promise of not raising a weapon in the war, of getting Duryodhan killed by unfair means, and a number of others in the war were also killed unfairly by the Pandavs. Then we have Ram ji killing Ravan only after Vibheeshan told him that Ravan's navel had amrit and so he should be shot there, otherwise how would have Ram ji killed him? And as mentioned above Bali was killed treacherously as well. Even in the Hindi movie Lajja, the question was raised as to why only Sita had to pass through Agni Pariksha to justify her purity and not Ram ji. These are just some incidents I remembered at the back of my head which I have not fully understood. Probably there are many more which need to be explained. Don't worry I am not changing sides. I wasn't against anyone to begin with and here I am just pointing out other things behind which I don't know the reasoning. So anyone care to explain? [%sig%]

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Dr.Sukhpreet Singh Udhoke · 06 Nov 2005

Respected Sardaar jeewan singh jio, Wahe guru ji ka khalsa, Wahe guru ji ki fateh we are in high spirits and hope u same.Veer jio ,our aim and objects are different from that other organizations ,they have their own field, but we respect all organizations which are active for the chardi kalla of panth.We have good relations with all panth dardi organizations except pro-RSS .Veer jio when all other factions will break their own structure and will accept the leadership of Sardaar Simranjit singh Maan,we promise u that we will think about ur suggestion.Actually now Khalistaan is not in our aims and objects,and we want to work for chardi kalla of panth within bounderies of indian law.we suppprt all panthic groups but do,nt want to take part in indian election system because we blieve in selection i mean Guntantra not in Gintantra. For more details u can call and contact SHAHBAAZ KHALSA S.Amardeep singh Amar-093566 11106 S.Jagdeep Singh-098554 25774 S.Sukhmander Singh-093177 77911 S.Avtaar Singh-093509 22366 S.Kulwinder jeet Singh******** Shahbaaz Khalsa is a public wing of GURSIKH(Global United Research and Service Institute of Knowledge for Humanity) so, u can also contact to Gursikh high command official, S.Ratinder Singh Indore President GURSIKH-07313948933 Guru Panth de daas Dr.Sukhpreet Singh Udhoke 93160 88579,9316199795 GURSIKH FEATURES AND SHAHBAAZ MEDIA SERVICES Sri Amritsar

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

JEEVAN SINGH · 06 Nov 2005

DR SUKHPREET SINGH UDHOKE ! Thank you very much for your reply, i was delighted with your thoughts. I feel more friendship between panthic groups needs to be formed although all groups are working within their own fields, in older times reqular panthic gathering were held to discuss present day issues, and for the chardikala of the panth, we would be very happy if you could hold a big panthic ekat a few times a year to strenghten the panthic forces in panjab !! In sant jarnail singh ji khalsa bhindrawala's time all groups were on one platform and the whole quam woke up holding arm in arm! we need to start making more interaction with each other. If you look at are enemies rss,vhp,bajrang dal,shiv sena,congress,bjp, they all have one cause and the same mission which they are working very closely hand in hand to achive, but we panthic groups silightly lack in that direction so more needs to be done to defeat are oppersors !! I prey to waheguru to grant you fateh in every thing that you do and for the chardikala of the the panth !! wahe guru ji ka khalsa wahaguru ji ki fateh ! please reply to me if you can! [%sig%]

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Kaur, Simran · 07 Nov 2005

Deg Teg Fateh Ji…….. This is all for who have contradiction on who is terrorist and who is not. Why all of these persons are backing Ram and Krishan? What about other persons named in letter they admitted that they all are terrorist except these two, but I think these two were the big terrorists. You all say Ram is god? he was very good man? give me any strong reason for that, if u want to know how good Ram was u better ask Shamboke family, Ram killed that rishi just because he was meditating, ask Bali family whom he killed with corrupt ways. You talk of Ram character, he insulted Bali’s wife and forced her to marry Sugrive not only this he also forced Ravaana’s wife’s to marry Vibhishan also Ram father was married three times. Also there famous scholars Osho Rajnish and many other say they( ram and lakshman) raped Sroopnakha. They insulted the rajkumari of such a rich country whose mahals were made of gold and such limelight how can one stop himself from taking revenge. Ravaana kidnapped Sita because Ram and Lakhsman insulted Sroopnakha. But Ravaana is a high character man he kidnapped her but kept her in separate place and never touched her and u all say ravaana was a bad man of low character, what u will say for the character of Ram and Others? In Tamil Nadu, Burma, Cambodia, Sri Lanka, Thailand and many more places Ravaana is worshipped and Ram’s Effigy’s are burned down. Where were these people who are having problem, when blood was shedding in Punjab, our sisters mothers were being insulted, Sri Harmindar Sahib Ji was insulted which no one can tolerate, tanks were taken inside such a highly worshipped place, army personals were entering its premises with boots, where were you when Guru Granth Sahib Ji’s Pavitar Saroops were burnt insulted, you never opened your mouth that time. Where were you when young blood was being killed in Punjab and all over just with key to finish SIKHI. Where were u when innocent people were brutally killed in Delhi and around when indira Gandhi was assassinated? Have these people ever opened there voice against what is happening have they ever come hands in hands to fight for sikhi? I ask these people where were u when all this was happening? Did u ever tried to help any innocent’s family members who were left after all this holocaust?

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Khalsa_Force · 07 Nov 2005

Jey Sach Bolna Paap Hai (as some ppl in here blame Shahbaaz khalsa for) taan Saade Guru Sahibaan Ton Wadda Paapi Kaun c fer? Sach bolan naal ihna lokaan de dhid peer kio hundi hai? Asi ohna hinduaan nu SHEESHA vikha rahe haan jo apne aap nu Rabb samajhde, palle nai dhela te kardi mela mela. Hindu MYTHOLOGY <<<<<<<<<<<

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Swaran Singh Panesar · 08 Nov 2005

Veer Siddharth Ji, Sat Sri Akaal and Nimastay. In one of your posts you have accepted, "I am ignorant about Sikhi but not of Hinduism." I must admitt I am most ignorant about 'Hinduism' and I am keen to learn from you the definition of a 'Hindu', Hindu beliefs and practices, the 'Hindu' worship and perhaps the age Hinduism. I am sure you have the knowledge and the intellegence to response to my original post in detail and in a much more satisfactory manner without deviating from the subject matter. Thank you. Swaran Singh Panesar.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Kulbir Singh · 08 Nov 2005

Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh! Veer Sukhmandar Singh jee, ------- I hope that u have read all books of bhai sahib bhai randhir singh ji So plzz before giving ur opnion next time read Gurmat Gorvita very very carefully. --------- I have read Gurmat Gauravta carefully and in this book Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has proved that the ultimate spiritual state is possible only and only through Gurmat Naam and by adopting Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee as our Guru. Also, Bhai Sahib has written that by doing other karams and not doing Gurmat Naam Karam, one cannot get anywhere. But why are you referring me to this book? I have never said that we should worship Rama and Krishna. All I had written in my previous article was that we have nothing to gain by slandering Rama and Krishna. ----------- In December 04/ jan05 when u visited in India while going to Hazoor Sahib u with all sangat and stayed that Bhai Ratinder Singh’s house (indore). And u have carried set of 13 books naming “SARITA MUKTA REPRINT”. These 13 books containing more than 400 article of 4-5 pages each. All the article were deadly against Hindu mythology all the authors of these books were hindus and were from differents facets, each and every article contained more than sufficient examples from all Hindu granths, according to Hindu granth it self Rama and Krishna were characterless and terrorist person. Plzz read all those different books very very carefully. Before making opinion abt Krishna plzz read Krishna avtar bani in Dasham Granth Sahib completely and care fully. ------------- Since you have mentioned our visit to Hazoor Sahib, I want to draw your attention to the debates we used to have. We used to have similar debates over there too and I used to ask you why you ignore the Muslim atrocities? You have mentioned bad acts of Rama and Krishna but what about the bad acts of Mohammad? And I don’t believe this Dalit Propaganda. They have become Buddhist and are now condemning their old religion Hinduism. Let them do what they are doing but I don’t understand why we Sikhs need to get indulged in such slandering. Our aim is to bring Chardi Kala to Khalsa Panth but this Chardi Kala will come by obeying hukams of Guru Sahib and not by slandering Rama and Krishna. ------------- According to Krishna avtar itself Krishan was having sexual relation with many young women including Radha. It is very clear the Krishana avtar that Krishan was drug addict, he was addict of Bhang, afeem, dhatoora, and many more drugs. Do u think that Guru Sahib has written wrong in Krishna avatar? ------------ I will read Krishna Avtaar before I comment on this section. Please bear with me for a week or so. ---------- Maharshi Balmiki have written in Balmiki Ramayan that Rama was an alcoholic drinker and he used to watch mujra(dance of prostitute). He used to beat Sita many times and forced her to drink and join him in watching mujra. All such details of Balmik Ramayan was published in an aritcal written by Sardar Balwant Singh Bahoru in may 2000 issue of GURMAT PARKASH( A monthly magzin of S.G.P.C.). ----------- I have read Balmiki Ramayan and I did not find all this anywhere. There are many versions of Ramayan and some of the versions written by South Indians contain such things about Rama. And Dalits are doing propaganda of exploiting such books. I don’t think Dalits are any friends of Sikhs either. And I don't believe the Dalit Propaganda. ------------- The letter head contained many names of Hindu terrorist, but why u replied only to defend Rama and Krishna. Do you agree all other contains in the letter completely. Why u have stop discussion only on the First paragraph about Rama and Krishna. ----------- I am not a defender of Hindu Dharam. What I saw wrong, I responded to. Also, I don’t have time for countering everything wrong. I did what I could. ------------ And also answer me CHANDAWAL named woman (wife of a milkman) who kidnapped and raped by lord Krishna ( plzz read care fully 12th pourri of Assa Ki Var) --------- Chandrawali was a Gopi of Krishna and if he did wrong to her then he made a mistake. As written before, Krishna was a child when he met Chandrawali and I don’t think his relation to her was of sexual nature. Siri Mad Bhagwat Puraan has many versions and some of the stories written there seem to have been fabricated. I already wrote before that Krishna did make mistakes but he did some good things too e.g. killing Kansa and supporting Pandavs in war against evil Kauravs. In any case, I am not here to defend other religions. My benti to you is that we should not waste our energy in slandering others. We don’t believe in them and we only worship one almighty God through the true Guru – Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. It was a pleasure to hear from you. Daas, Kulbir Singh Tapoban.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Khalsa_Force · 08 Nov 2005

====================================================================== Author: Straight Arrow Date: 11-05-05 23:12 <<>> Swaran Singh Panesar Bha Ji - This was my question. I am also willing to learn. I am the smallest of small men but my question remains unanswered. If these words are not Hindu Gods, then what are they? Why were these names used in Gurbani? I'm not trying to offend anybody, just looking for an answer. ======================================================================= The Ram, Krishan may be the characters of Ramayan but Gosai, Allah r characters of which epic? anyways, lets get back to ur question. The Ram, Krishan, Gopal and Gosai are not the CHARACTERS or dieties of Hindus but NAMES of GODS. Only those names were included in Gurbani which fulfilled the portrait of AKAL PURKH as per Gurbani. RAM = RAMMIA HOI (not the Ram Chandar) GOPAL = GO (earth) PAL (nourisherer) GOSAI = GO (earth) SAI ( owner) BEETHAL = BISTHAL (asthir) stable KRISHAN = on whom KASHISH doesnt work all are names of Akal Purkh.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Swaran Singh Panesar · 09 Nov 2005

Dear Dr. Sukhpreet Singh Ji Udhoke and the members of Shabaaz Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji KI Fateh. My observations dictate that majority of the Sikhs across the world still appear to be unaware of the most deceitful and dangerous activities of the evil forces like the RSS/VHP/ BAJRANG DAL etc., whose main aims and objectives are to determinedly destroy, distort, debase the Sikh History and to uproot Sikhism in order to gradually take it into Hindu fold. I think there is a much greater need to raise the level of such awreness within the worldwide Sikh community. I believe you have a long list of books that the fundamentalist Hindu writers have been publishing for many decades. I would like to see that such list of books published on this forum as soon as possible. Aap da bauhat, bauhat dhanvaad karda hoyia, Panth da sevadaar Swaran Singh Panesar.

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Dr.Sukhpreet Singh Udhoke · 13 Nov 2005

Respected panesar sahib, Waheguru ji ka khalsa! Waheguru jiki fateh!! With grace of Akal purakh i m in high spirits and hope same for u. veer jio i m preparing list and mail u on ur persinal mail within few days. With regards Dr.sukhpreet Singh Udhoke SHAHBAAZ MEDIA AND GURSIKH FEATURES

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Bikram Singh · 02 Dec 2005

To Mr Siddarth (sid) I was going through forum, and I come across the heading "who is the terrorist in india". And I like it very much, written by Shehbaaz Khalsa. I am sending you one link which hopefully, you will read and increase you knowledge about waht hinduism is and how they work collected from centuries. http://dalitstan.org/books/awake/ [address removed]-- THis is my email address, and I am eager to talk to you regarding hinduism according to humanity. [%sig%]

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

sInGh 13 · 03 Dec 2005

Siddarth bro, i think u totally missunderstood the point of 'Shabaaz Khalsa's" letter, the word 'terrorist' used in the letter for 'Sri Ram, Krishan etcc" is just to tell they did good deeds to protect others, would you guys call them terrorists ! thats what they are trying to say in the letter. As we all know that people call sant jarnail singh ji a terrorist, infact they did a lot for sikhs. thats what they are trying to convince them. Think about it from Different Angles !! Thanks

Re: guru gobind

diana · 26 Feb 2006

was guru gobind singh right to ask people to die for thier religion? [%sig%]

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

Balwant Rao · 26 Feb 2006

what a disgusting post I note that some of the Sikhs on this site see it fir to cast the most pathetic slander on Hinduism They say that Sikhs and Hindus are seperate - Good ! I dont have the slightest issue with that Then they claim to to be experts on the Hindu religion ! The pathetic attempts to justify the moronic politcally motivated babbling are not from a single Hindu source. Surely we as Hindus know more about our own religion than non Hindus. If you want to learn about Hinduism then ask a Hindu instead of a Hindu hater! The lies that Hindus destroyed Buddhist temples are not proven at all I resent the snide comments that no Hindu fought for freedom. Read about 1857 and all the other risings from then until 1942 in which thousands died. Prof KS Lal estimated that between 10 to 50 million people died in the milleia precedding this one in wars. We of Maharasthra fought three wars with the British. We marched to the farthest reaches of Punjab in 1757-1759 and planted the saffron banner on the fort of Attock We defeated them in the Battle of Wadgaon - when the Brit commander signed a surrender document. The Mughal emperor danced to the tune of the Peshwas. The first person to pick up a gun after 1857 was Vasant Rao Phadke who was sentnced to life in prison in Aden followed by the Chapekar brothers and then the Savarkar brothers So read some history before making such bold statements about glory and valour. Brave hearts also beat in people who are not of white complexion or wear turbans. I can respect the acheivements of some Sikhs without becoming a hater. I can see Hindus and Sikhs being seperate but I dont need to slander the Sikh religion to do this Is this the dharma of 'recognise the human race as one' being practiced ? Jai Bhawani

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

...singh... · 27 Feb 2006

arguing over this is useless can any of u even follow a strict rehat in sikhism or hinduism?? can u wake up at amritvela and do naam bhagti??? can u control your sins??? untill u can be truthfull to ur own religions dont argue about each others religions

Re: Who is terrorist in India? A letter to BADAL & CAIPTAN

**- · 27 Feb 2006

This post is the most disgusting post that I have seen from a Sikh. I never knew Sikhs could fall to such depths. It seems Sikhs never seem to be able to make an intelligent arguement without resorting to insult Hinduism. We [hindus] respect you Sikhs so much and yet you spit in our faces