Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Women Gurus? or 5piyare?

Women Gurus? or 5piyare?

Singh · 04 Nov 2005

Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa Vahiguru ji ki fateh Basicly, why is that in the era of the past ten Gurus no women Guru was selected to be the next Guru, why are men always dominant? If we look into Sikh history we can see that the main things were about men except for Singhnis like Mai Bhago etc. But why is it that even in the first panj piyare it was only men and not women.. Isn't this against what Gurus Nanaks message about equality between men and women? I would be grateful if someone could answer this question as I couldn't answer this question to my moneh friend. Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa Vahiguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Women Gurus? or 5piyare?

HS · 04 Nov 2005

Good question, but i don't think there is a right or wrong answer to this. My personal view is that this was Wahguru Ji's hukam and He knew that if women Gurus were used for His mission then the arrogant male population of india would not accept their parchaar.

Re: Women Gurus? or 5piyare?

.. · 04 Nov 2005

singh -"Isn't this against what Gurus Nanaks message about equality between men and women?" you cant really say sikhi is unequal because all 10 gurus were male because i dont think women are disadvantaged, by not being one of the guru's poeple usually say situations are inequal because one group has an advantage. eg in islam women are disadvantaged because they cant go mosque, and they have to wear parda. same with panj, women can still take amrit, does it really matter if they cant be in panj?

Re: Women Gurus? or 5piyare?

Iron Man · 04 Nov 2005

The best answer to the question "why were there no women gurus" that I have ever heard is: There were no women gurus because during that time, if guru nanak dev jee had come into the body of a woman, most likely nobody would have even listened. Guru sahib came here to do parchar and the body of a man at that time and in that place was needed in order to spread the message the most effectively.

Re: Women Gurus? or 5piyare?

.. · 04 Nov 2005

I think the main aspects of Sikh history cover men because it's men who are doing the studying and writing. There are lots of Sikh women in Sikh history from the first Sikh, Bibi Nanaki jee, to Mata Khivi jee who is even referred to in Bani because of her seva, Bibi Bhani jee who is the mother, daughter and wife of three different Gurus, Mata Gujri jee, Mata Sundari jee, Mata Sahib Kaur jee. All these women played huge roles in Sikh history. The fact that they dont' get covered much is a different story. Women like Mata Bhagbhari and others who were heads of Sangats all could be considered major players in Sikh history. But the question why there were no women Gurus is answered only in one way: because there weren't any. Vahiguru chose which body to put the Guru-jot in and no woman was selected. Only Vahiguru knows the reason and why second guess?

Re: Women Gurus? or 5piyare?

me · 04 Nov 2005

Sikh Gurus were not male or female. It was the Shabad that was the Guru the whole time, and still is, and forever will be.

Re: Women Gurus? or 5piyare?

Prabhjoyt singh · 05 Nov 2005

The names are Mata Gujar KAUR Ji and Mata Sundar KAUR Ji

Re: Women Gurus? or 5piyare?

Jasjeet Singh · 05 Nov 2005

well true but lets go to the indian census and see if what is the situation of women in sikh community and well the ratio of women to men is alramingly low and killing of girl child is now quite comman in punjab where people want just boys well to say we are goin against guru Nanak jis teachings well there is nothin new we always have been doing that... if there was no women guru it was because guru is not a body but the word the shabad... the body was only a mean to pass thw shabad to us... and then panj payaare is just the Male Ego case i belive we have the worst case for men full with thier ego of being MEN and looking down upon women ..i mean how often do u see women engaged in local gurudawars else then preparing langars.. Sad but ture women are just not treated qually even by thoes who follow the rahat maryda to the core.... not all but many .... only thing that can save us is more education

Re: Women Gurus? or 5piyare?

erm · 05 Nov 2005

"Sikh Gurus were not male or female. It was the Shabad that was the Guru the whole time, and still is, and forever will be." first ten gurus were in male form

Re: Women Gurus? or 5piyare?

Singh · 07 Nov 2005

actually...think about it...didn't Guru Ji say that the body is not Guru, it is the Shabad that is the Guru? So, what does it matter if the body was that of a male? All that matters is the Shabad that was given to us. Guru Ji is beyond gender.