Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Radhasoamis and Namdharis

HS · 04 Nov 2005

As much as I agree with many Singhs and Sinhness about the implications of the Radhasoami Satsang Beas being non Sikh, I just wanted to ask, i hear alot about it being a goverment organisation. Is there any proof about this? What about Namdharis, are they the same too?

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

manjh payara guru ko · 05 Nov 2005

both are guru de chor [%sig%]

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Khalsa_Force · 07 Nov 2005

SIkhi de naam te Dukan Chalaun waale ..........

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Sewadar · 07 Nov 2005

Surely Naamdharis are worse because they claim the jyot of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji is in their 15th Guru who they term "SATGURU Jagjit Singh Ji Mahraj". They re-write history and make up silly stories abour Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji faking his death and hiding as "Ajaipal Singh" until he secretly passed the Gur Gaddi on to Balak Singh of Hazora who then passed it on to "SATGURU RAM SINGH". They do a dodgy Ardas with an extra 5 Gurus and they say "RAM SINGH CHARDI KALA, TERE BHANA SARBAT DA BHALA" at then end of the Ardas. But hey, we all still think they are OK them becaused "they do kirtan on Raag"!!!! When will we learn!!!!! I suppose next we will have Radhaosoamis teaching us Santhia!!

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

LionKing (LK) · 08 Nov 2005

No naamdharis are nothing compared to the manmat of Radha Suamis. Namdharis have more respect for Guru Sahib than most of oru Singhs - More respect for Guru Ji - Bani Guru - they way the Guru Sahib wanted Bani to be recited - RAAG KIRTAN. THey spend YEARS AND YEARS on learning kirtan on Puratan Saaj, whereis we're (atleast me) are to Tillay to spentd eyars and years on learnign Raag Kirtan on Puratan Saaj.. Perhaps this is sometihng we can learn from them? AGain I don't agree with thier havans and their baba etc.. but Raag Kirtan is soemthing tha makes me have some respect for them. Regards

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Khalsa_Force · 08 Nov 2005

namdharis claim to be sikhs solely on RAAGs.skintight pajami clad people

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

HAHAHAHAHAHHA · 08 Nov 2005

"They do a dodgy Ardas with an extra 5 Gurus and they say "RAM SINGH CHARDI KALA, TERE BHANA SARBAT DA BHALA" at then end of the Ardas." HAHAHAHAHAHAHHA - OMG - that just kills it - "RAM SINGH CHARDI KALA, TERE BHANA SARBAT DA BHALA" - how messed up can u get!!!! hahahaha!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

BirRaas Singh · 08 Nov 2005

The authenticity of the Naamdharis style of Raag Kirtan is not as traditional as people believe. Sure they have learnt the system of Raag, but it is very different to the style of raag that was unique to the Gurus. The Naamdharis have learnt a the broad aspect of a system, but it isnt the raag of our Gurus, they have done dalliya (mixing) of different styles, vocals from the likes of Pandit Jasraj and learning of saaz from various Hindu and Muslim schools. A good comparison would be if someone went to a Philipino martial artist, learnt stick and knife work, and then claimed it was the vidiya of the Gurus. They would have learnt effective skills through a different school, but it wouldnt be authentic to the Sikh Gurus.

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

LK · 09 Nov 2005

true Biraas Singh, but it is a lot closer to the way the Kirtan was in the Guru Ji's time than we find in our local Gurdwara :)

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Khalsa_Force · 09 Nov 2005

i hvnt seen any "Pajami Clad" reply in here ......

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Sehajvir singh · 09 Nov 2005

Khalsa force wrote: "namdharis claim to be sikhs solely on RAAGs.skintight pajami clad people" The second part was waay to funny.

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Baldeep Singh · 10 Nov 2005

Vaheguroooo Jeee Kaaaa Khalsaaah, Vahegurooo Jee Kaaa Fateeeh, HS, asked "Is there any proof about this?" What proof? Proof that the Radhaswamis or Naamdharis are agents of the GOI? PLEASE read HS's original post! HS, didn't ask who could provide the best nindiya for the above mentioned organisations. I, for one would like some proof as WELL. [%sig%]

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Taus Premee · 11 Nov 2005

Khalsa force wrote: "namdharis claim to be sikhs solely on RAAGs.skintight pajami clad people" --And then others are encouraging him... The second part was waay to funny. I agree everyone has a right to an opinion, but why make blanket statements (GOI agents) and make fun of their dress? You may say yah people don't say anything to the Namdharis because of their kirtan, everything aside that is a HUGE thing, kirtan is at the core of Sikhi and Gurmat and good on them for continuing with the maryada..

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Singh · 11 Nov 2005

Sad, They have distorted our Religion. I heard from someone that Namdharis were promoted to counter Sikhs in Punjab for the first time by Sardar Patel in 1950ies. He used them to counter Akali party and cause a divide in Sikhs.

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Khalsa_Force · 11 Nov 2005

In reply to TAUS PREMI's post ====================================================== Author: BirRaas Singh Date: 11-08-05 15:23 The authenticity of the Naamdharis style of Raag Kirtan is not as traditional as people believe. Sure they have learnt the system of Raag, but it is very different to the style of raag that was unique to the Gurus. The Naamdharis have learnt a the broad aspect of a system, but it isnt the raag of our Gurus, they have done dalliya (mixing) of different styles, vocals from the likes of Pandit Jasraj and learning of saaz from various Hindu and Muslim schools. A good comparison would be if someone went to a Philipino martial artist, learnt stick and knife work, and then claimed it was the vidiya of the Gurus. They would have learnt effective skills through a different school, but it wouldnt be authentic to the Sikh Gurus. ====================================================

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

LionKing (LK) · 12 Nov 2005

Taus Preeme I'm a preemee of Taus toooo - Do you have any recordings of Kirtan with the Taus..... Thanks :D Sooo want to learn Raag Kirtan. Atleast Namdharis are lucky they know it unlike me :(

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Khalsa_Force · 13 Nov 2005

Author: LionKing (LK) Date: 11-12-05 08:15 Taus Preeme I'm a preemee of Taus toooo - Do you have any recordings of Kirtan with the Taus..... Thanks :D Sooo want to learn Raag Kirtan. Atleast Namdharis are lucky they know it unlike me :( ==================================================== want to be lucky like namdharis? go "matha tek" to their SATGURU and get "NIHAAAAAAAAAAL" no other way to get lucky like them....

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Harcharan Singh · 27 Nov 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I have to say I am disgusted at the level of ignorence and disrespect on this site. People are going on about Namdharis and silly conspiracy theories without mentioning any historical knowledge. Before anything else, some of you should get off your high horse and learn how to act like Sikhs. Sikhs do not do nindah about anyone, good or bad, it is fair to state facts and let people make up their own mind. Joking about things you know nothing about shows a lack of maturity. Baba Ram Singh Namdhari was a general in the Khalsa army of Maharaja Ranjit Singh. He fought many wars alongside the famous Hari Singh Nalwa. Just before the 1st Anglo-Sikh war in 1845, Baba Ram Singh deserted the army due to the infighting after Ranjit Singhs death and the back stabbing of Brahmin Maharaj Gulab Singh. He foresaw the end of the Khalsa raj (at that time). Baba Ram Singh then devoted his life to Sikhi, during the first 30 years of hte British Raj, many atrocities took place in Punjab, deceptive conversion, killing Akalis (feared by the British), dividing and destroying Sikhi (by forcing the Harmonium as it resembled Christian music, clearing out Amritsar - it used to be the cultural capital of Asia, many languages, script writing, music, faiths etc were taught there), putting masands back in power of Gur ghar, banning Sikhs from carrying kirpaans, introduced ethnic division and recording of Sikhs - i.e. reintrocued the caste system... The Sikhs were in a dire circumstances and the faith was disappearing. Baba Ram Singh revived Sikhi, he can be somewhat compared to Baba Jarnail Singh. Baba Ram Singh went from village to village doing kathaa, giving amrit through panj pyare to thousands, forcing people to carry a laathi instead of a kirpaan (never be withot weapon), he lay the foundations of the Anand Karaj, and stopped the use of Brahmins at Sikh weddings, he encouraged female education and baptism (which wasn't common at this point in time). The list goes on, but most famously, he was the 1st person to stand up against the unfair British. He invented the movement of non-coperation (to break the British economy) which Ghandi now has the credit for). 1. Boycott of Government service. 2. Boycott of educational institution opened by British. 3. Boycott of Law-courts started by British. 4. Boycott of foreign made Goods. 5. Boycott of obey and resist the Laws & orders which owns conscience abhors. The British had pretty much wiped out the Akalis, the Namdharis were now public enemy no 1. Many Namdharis were famously shaheed, but the most famous story is of the Namdharis who sought to break the disrespect of the British (who had introduced abitoires and butchery into the Punjab). Some Namdharis put a stop to British backed Muslim butchers who at the time were killing cows. Although a cow is not a religious/sacred animal per se to Sikhs, Sikhs do have respect for all life especially cows as we drink their milk. More to the point, the cow is sacred to Hindus and this was just part of the British divide and conquer ploy, all faiths should be respected and Sikhs ensure that. Namdharis were caught and made shaheed by tying them to the mouth of long range cannons and blowing them up point blank. Namdharis also eleminated the dowry system (which is clearly evident today). Namdhari weddings are very sanatan. There is no cost invloved in either the boy or girls side, no party no alchohol no meat. The boy and girl can only be married if they are wearing the 5ks. Compared to your "mainstream" Sikh wedding which has absolutely no resemblence to how our Guru's ordained marriages - dowry, party, sharaab, meat (Guru Ji's besti as this happens after having Guru Jis darshan), cameraman dictating everything...boy and girl don't even have to be khalsa, forget Khalsa most don't even understand the vows (lavaan). That aside, the Namdhair wear their sanatan dress, which shouldn't be mocked, it shows simplicity and humilty, in accordance with Gurbani, their dastaar are also sanatan, not 20th century inventions. Now for the controversy. Yes at some point in time Namdhari version of Sikh history was changed, yes they do have a Satgur (kind of dalai lama, but I don't see anyone having a problem with him). Yes they do take their lavaan around a fire (to represent the begging and end of life). So they they are different, but why can we as humans, and more so as Sikhs not see the good in people and try and win them over to change thje bad? No, this would be to much to ask for Punjabis, this is the reason why we haven't got our own state, why we our youth have lost the plot (they know more about hip hop and fashion than Sikhi). If we could all unite we could conquer and revive Sikhi in it's true form. The same problem exists for Nihangs. They hold true to Guru Gobind Singhs roop and hukum 90%. They know the Shaster Vidya (science of war) as opposed to sport stick fighting (gatka) which is known to mainstream Sikhs). They have invaluble ancient oral history, we have scholars who have distorted history i.e. Guru Hargobind and Gobind Singh Ji having 3 wives. Even Bhai Randhir Singh Ji held the upmost respect for baba Ram Singh and Akalis, this website is somewhat dedicated to him, should we not be following in Bhai Sahibs footsteps and not be so incorrectly fanatical? The aim of this post is not to cause a further slandering match, Iam just hoping to reach those few individuals who have recieved Wahegurus kirpa and are interested in learning, uniting and correcting. All Jathas/sect hold somehting of Guru: Nihangs - Shaster Vidya/history Namdhari - Raag Kirtan (using Guru's raags and saaj) Guru Nanakl Nishkaam Sevak Jathaa - Correct seva jeevan principles AKJ - To follow Gurus maryada strictly Taksaal - correct Kathaa and prononciation of Gurbani etc etc No one party is 100% correct. If all united we would be closer to the true Guru. Through love and unity the 10% deviations could be eliminated. As for Radha Swami that is a different story, they have been proven to be fake and are a modern movement. They give a naam (baptism) and require you not tell anyone otherwise your family will perish. That is obviously not gurmat. Hope to have inspired a little. Sat Sri Akaal - Only the revered truth is Immortal Harcharan Singh

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 27 Nov 2005

1 thing "right" and 10 things "WRONG" doesnt make it with me... The MOST IMPORTANT THING is not kirtan/raag/dress /rehit/whatever.....etc BUT UNDIVIDED FAITH in GURU GRANTH JI as the One and ONLY LIVING GURU..This CHHATREE like the SKY covers EVERYTHING...and is the Very FOUNDATION of SIKHEE. Namdharees and Radhasoamis BOTH FAIL in this. They have a RIVAL GURU..and regard GURU GRANTH JI as a BOOK. Bhai mardana Ji was a "MUSLIM"....but he had UNDIVIDED FAITH in GURU NANAK JI.....He is a SIKH much more than any Namdharree. as for "proof"...what does the poster want ?? What types of proofs can ordinary posters like us have ?? Can anyone here really "prove" anything ? How about the Namdharees prooving that Guru Gobind Singh Ji faked his death and didnt give gurgadhi to GURU GRANTH JI ?? Can anyone really "prove" that KPS Gill murdered thousands of Sikh Youths in false encounters ?? but we all know dont we ?? ACTIONS speak louder than PROOF.

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

LionKing (LK) · 28 Nov 2005

as for "proof"...what does the poster want ?? What types of proofs can ordinary posters like us have ?? Can anyone here really "prove" anything ? How about the Namdharees prooving that Guru Gobind Singh Ji faked his death and didnt give gurgadhi to GURU GRANTH JI ?? ************* Singho, he's asking for proof that Namdhari's are Gov agents. We all know tha KPS Gill is agent - how - I didn't kow it long ago, and yes it is WRITTEN in books about it. There is NO proof that Naamdhari's are Gov agents - and unless there is any evidence we shouldn't just though around accusations, just like you wouldn't throw comments about Bhia Ram Singh (the person Naamdhari's consider their 11 Guru) - or would you? Would you throw comments about Bhai Kanaiya Ji? (consider Seva panthi) Again all bhaji is asking for is - evidence that they are gov people.. ********** 1 thing "right" and 10 things "WRONG" doesnt make it with me... The MOST IMPORTANT THING is not kirtan/raag/dress /rehit/whatever.....etc BUT UNDIVIDED FAITH in GURU GRANTH JI as the One and ONLY LIVING GURU..This CHHATREE like the SKY covers EVERYTHING...and is the Very FOUNDATION of SIKHEE. ***************** is Guru ji not telling us to take good things from everyone? You yourself a while ago said that if someone has good thing in him/her - take the good things - leave the bad thing out - let them be on the wrong path - but they shoud be acknowledged for lerning Raag Kirtan, the way the Gurus wanted us to do Kirtan I have undivided faith in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji as my only Guru , and my Guru tells me to take good things from other, and leave the bad things - if tha makes me wrong then I don't know what I should do about it. Again, as mentioend in abvoe posts, they do manmats, they do havans, they do dogy things - they do Raag Kirtan - take the good thing from them, as that is NOT a small thing - koi choti cheej ni haigi 15-20 saal Purtan Saaj ate Raag Sikhne - they need to be acknowledged for it, whether we liek it or not , as that is MASSIVE towards Guru Ji - spending SOOO LONG learning kirtanthe way he wanted us to do Kirtan, on the otherhand most of us are too lazy to take a year or two out learning Shudh Paath (Santheya) [or tha goes for me atleast] they use 15-20 years of their life for it - that should be ackowledged.... If we had respect for our Guru we woudl leran Rag Kirtan, we would take Santheya etc and not just talk and talk about respect and not actually follow what Guru Ji wants. Bhull Chukk Maaf Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

....... · 28 Nov 2005

harcharan singh, despite your detailed response. You still have not accepted the fact that these naamdharis actually stabbed the very Ram singh in the back. He worte them letters saying he is not the Guru. They ignored him. It is nothing but a dera business. You all talk about raag kertan. But how can they respect the guru when they do not even accept it as the Guru? They think Guru Granth sahib has no vioce and power. That is why the need a human Guru. The history is such a lie, and they basically say Guru Gobind singh was a coward, who ran away. How much more disrepect can you take! Shame on you all. Respect for Guru comes before everything else!

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Sikh Sangat · 28 Nov 2005

Todays Naamdharis are NOT a sect of Sikhism. Stop comparing them to AKJ or Taksaal. They may have a place in our history, but they would have been following a more Sikh Maryada during the time of Baba Ram Singh. After his death his brother proclaimed that Ram Singh was the 12 incarnation of Guru Nanak Dev Ji and he (Hari Singh) was the 13th Guru Nanak. Then his son Partap Singh becamed the 14th Guru Nanak and finally we have the present "satguru" Jagjit Singh who is the son of Partap Singh. Now compare this to any "sect" or jatha within Sikh Dharm today. Does ANYONE proclaim to be part of the lineage of Guru Nanak Dev Ji? We may have our differences within these jathas but all unite under the banner "GURU MANYO GRANTH". This is no ignorance. I was born into a family who were Naamdharis back in the 1970s.

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Dr.Sukhpreet Singh Udhoke · 28 Nov 2005

respected Gursikhs, waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh!! plz. read the article from the given link, http://www.panthic.org/news/131/ARTICLE/2020/2005-11-27.html guru fateh Dr.Sukhpreet Singh Udhoke GURSIKH FEATURES AND SHAHBAAZ MEDIA SERVICES [%sig%]

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

reference · 28 Nov 2005

Refer to the movement created by Baba Ram Singh as Kooka. People who refer to it as Namdhari Movement are misrepresenting history & trying relate modern day farce a great rebelious movement.

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Bhagwant Singh · 28 Nov 2005

WJK, WJF Though I am not a Namdhari myself I have respect for Baba Ram Singh as a true Gursikh and great fighter. I believe there is much that can be learn't from his jeevan . I think the majority of the Sikh nation view Baba Ram Singh in that light and Namdhari's infact do him a disservice by calling him Guru. As for todays Namdhari Guru - I have to respect the fact that he is a great Ustad in terms of Gurmat sangeet and the fact that Gurmat Sangeet tradition has been maintained by the Namdhari is to there credit. Again I believe they do themselves a disservice by calling Jagjit Singh a guru. A guru he is not. A fountain of knowledge (Ustad) in Gurmat Sangeet he certainly is. I believe the Sikh nation would be more ammenable to the Namdhari's if they joined the mainstream and acknowledge that Guru Granth is the last Guru and acknowledge Baba Ram Singh as a true Gursikh and Jagjit Singh as a great resource in Gurmat sangeet I hope I have not offended anybody but these are my thoughts WJK,WJF [%sig%]

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Nov 2005

Its a huge mistake to decide on today's Namdharees based on what Baba Raam Singh Ji was.....today the namdharees have left Baba ji far behind and deviated from whatever he was. He was NOT a GURU, he was a devout SIKH of the Guru Granth Ji Sahib. He was also a Freedom Fighter...the ORIGINATOR of the SWADESHI MOVEMENT which gandhi HIJACKED as his own...and under Baaba ji the Kookas were among the first to fight for freedom of India. They were such a huge danger to the British that baaba Ji was EXILED to kalla Paanee for life. YES..IF the Namdharees give up their GURUDOM and accept GURU GRANTH JI as the One and ONLY GURU....they are acceptable to Sikhs....otherwise NO.....as SIKHS can NEVER accept a human dehdharee "guru" no matter how great a ustaad in gurmat sangeet he is....Remember how SATTA and BALWAND were REJECTED by the Sangat ( they were the TOP Ragees of Guru Arjun JI).....and the duo were accepted back only when they realised their mistake.

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Sikh · 29 Nov 2005

Harcharan Singh Its very simple. They don't recognise Guru Granth Sahib as Guru and hence we should have nothing to do with them. To advocate anything else is just weakness to accept the truth. Jarnail Singh has made the point perfectly,

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Scam · 29 Nov 2005

I think you are mistaken about Jagjit being a great ustad of Gurmat Sangeet. Yes it is true that Namdharis have created good relationships with the well known classical artists of India from whom they get their training. The likes of Ranjan Sanjan (who like tabbacco paans and I have seen Namdharis in shops buying these paans while the duo sit in the car) and others. Its incorrect to say Jagjit is worthy of being a Guru because he is a great ustad. I have hear some of his recordings and I am no expert of Raag but it was not melodious at all. For a Jatha/Samprada to be accepted in Sikhi they have to believe that Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the living Guru, simple. One interesting point to note is that we "respect" Namdharis for their Kirtan in Raag but dislike their belief of the Living Guru. So again it shows that they are only surviving in this world with the blessings of Gurbani, without Gurbani their Guru doesnt have anything to offer the world.

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

LionKing (LK) · 29 Nov 2005

I agree 100% With Bhagwant Singh =)

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

I am too scared · 29 Nov 2005

I just went online to read about Namdhari's and it scared me to think that a human being can call themselves a SatGuru let alone claim to be descendents from Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji. Whilst I was reading I felt a shiver and as though I was committing a sin! Q: In one of the earlier posts, a comment was posted saying that Radhasoamis give the person a name and if they tell anyone then the family pershises. What does the name given signify?

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Sikh Sangat · 29 Nov 2005

Good pointers by the authour "Scam". It is the classical non-Sikh ustads of India who are training the Naamdharis in classical music. The Naamdharis have put a alot of input in developing relationships with these Ustads and have groomed a number of their youngsters into the classical music environment. It's a good sneaky investment into the future as they use the Raag Kirtan platform for their parchar. A prime example of this is the "Raj Academy" of UK which recruits young Sikhs and is mixing the Naamdhari Sangat with the Sikh Sangat. References to Naamdhari Guru Jagjit Singh as HIS HOLINESS SAT GURU JAGJIT SINGH JI MAHRAJ can be seen on their websites, yet they proclaim to be a Sikh organisation. Raag Kirtan may be slowly declining in the Sikh environment, but the focus on the eternal Guru SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI still remains. Shabad still remains Guru whether we sing in Raag or Not. We don't need to associate with any Naamdhari/Nirankari group. THINK ABOUT YOUR GURU FIRST.

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Bhagwant Singh · 29 Nov 2005

Khalsa Ji I agree with many of the points made and I know that Namdhari's do mix with the Indian Classical types and indeed some have become professional Indian Classical artisits in there own right - Gurdev Singh on the sarood and of course Pinky Namdhari on the tabla is two I can think of the top of my head However they do have foremost knowledge of Gurmat Sangeet - if you listen to Ustad Harbhajan Singh and his recordings they are pure Gurmat Sangeet especially some of the Dhrupads. In actual fact ustad Harbhajan Singh has taught most of the younger namdhari students. Also Bhai Baljeet Singh Bhai Gurmeet Singh recordings are very worthy Again I would point out that if the Namdhari community along with Jagjit Singh recognised Guru Granth Sahib as the last Guru and respected Baba Ram Singh as jeevan wale Gursikh then I see no reason why they would not only be welcomed but also be respected in the Sikh Panth WJK,WJF [%sig%]

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

ThaiDhari · 29 Nov 2005

Harcharan Singh wrote: > > Namdharis also eleminated the dowry system (which is clearly > evident today). Namdhari weddings are very sanatan. There is > no cost invloved in either the boy or girls side, no party no > alchohol no meat. > The boy and girl can only be married if they are wearing the > 5ks. > Sorry to highlight your inconsistances but Namdharis dont wear 5ks. The Kirpan has been replaced by mala because the current Guru has the power to change things. Dowry system exists behind closed doors with Namdharis, the lenn denn as per Punjabi Culture still exists before & after the weddings By the way I came back from a holiday in Bangkok recently and I saw loads of Namdharis in the hotel I stayed in eating meat & drinking alcohol!! I hear from locals that they have mistresses aswell. I spoke to my Uncle and he says that the Main Man allows the Thai Namdharis to run riot because they own loads of Property and a Bank in Thailand.... I guess the main man turns a blind eye to the richer Namdharis. Or his power doesnt reach Thailand??? [%sig%]

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Bhopinder Singh · 29 Nov 2005

It needs no proove if you are a Sikh. Rest let them believe what they want, they are free to do that , yes they should never call themselves sikhs but then that is what all intelligence oppossing sikhs want them to do and they have and are doining it promtly.

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Gurdial Singh · 29 Nov 2005

The Naamdhari President of UK (Rajinder Channa) was exposed on Channel 4 Dispatches 2 years ago for heading a people smuggling racket. He was refered to as a Sikh Spiritual Leader in the documentary and was caught by hidden camera arranging the travel & passport of an illegal immigrant for £6000. The funny thing is that he is still one of the most senior Naamdharis in the UK and the satguru's close PR advisor. He is also a much loved member of the "Ramgharia" Sikh Community. But then again you dress in white and sing kirtan in raag, everyone loves you!!!

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Dr.Sukhpreet Singh Udhoke · 29 Nov 2005

respected gurdial singh veer jio, Wahe guru ji ka khalsa!! Wahe guru ji ki fateh!! veer jio, can u mail me the pictures of that namdhaari,coz, i m making slide show on Dehdhari Gurudom,so plz. mail me on my below given E-mail. with regards Dr.Sukhpreet Singh Udhoke [address removed] 93161 99795 GURSIKH FEATURES AND SHAHBAAZ MEDIA SERVICES

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Bundha · 30 Nov 2005

One thing that makes my blood boil is that they have paintings that have the ten Gurus sitting in a circle and their Namdhari "guru" is depicted sitting in the middle !!! [%sig%]

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

cyberkhalsa · 30 Nov 2005

Read This: http://www.panthic.org/news/126/ARTICLE/1977/2005-11-13.html and now tell me who has respect for Guru Ji's saroop?..........

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Singh · 30 Nov 2005

Dr.Sukhpreet Singh Udhoke, For Pictures go here http://www.kukasikhs.com/kukasikhs/mainframe.htm Do a full search on the above page some good pictures of the so called Guru Go to this site http://www.namdhari-world.com/new%20nw/frame1.htm Click history then "Sikh Gurus" to read they rubbish

Re: Radhasoamis and Namdharis

Surf · 30 Nov 2005

Nihangs - Believe in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Namdhari - Dont believe in Sri Guru GRanth Sahib Ji Guru Nanak Nishkaam Sevak Jathaa - Believe in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji AKJ - Believe in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Taksaal - Believe in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji