Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

kachee bani

kachee bani

singh · 05 Nov 2005

i went to the gurdwara the other day, hoping to listen to some kirtan in sadh sangh when i got there there were 3 girls singing a song about khalistan inside i felt it was wrong, that siri guru granth sahib was there on the thakt, and all these girls could sing is a song about there desire to have a country why not sing gurbani? whats the point of singing a song about a country that doesnt exist? listening to kachee bani is against gurmat, i dont understand why sanghat remained seated in darbar sahib.

Re: kachee bani

,,, · 06 Nov 2005

does this song count as kachee bani as well, or is it only kachee when someone with "sant" in front of their name sings it? where's the uproar now?

Re: kachee bani

now you're just boring · 06 Nov 2005

Where and when was this? Was it a (dhadi) vaar or something? Aren't vaars etc allowed in Guru Ji's hajoori? (If not then a lot of Dhadi Jatha's have to find somewhere new to do their thing!)

Re: kachee bani

moorakh · 06 Nov 2005

why didn't you get some beer russ soldier spirit inside of you from this dhadhi vaar and go and do some gatka stop whining

Re: kachee bani

akj_4eva_and_eva_amen · 06 Nov 2005

"Author: moorakh Date: 11-06-05 04:50 why didn't you get some beer russ soldier spirit inside of you from this dhadhi vaar and go and do some gatka stop whining" beer ras from kachi bani???? do gatka??? wats that gonna do if someone is singin kachi bani in presence of guru ji tht is manmat and we shud stop it. wa u mean stop whining. he has a perfectly good point, do you support the singing of kachi banee. paapi [gurbani]siqgurU ibnw hor kcI hY bwxI ][/gurbani] Without the True Guru, other songs are false. [gurbani]bwxI q kcI siqgurU bwJhu hor kcI bwxI ][/gurbani] The songs are false without the True Guru; all other songs are false. [gurbani]khdy kcy suxdy kcy kc^ØI AwiK vKwxI ][/gurbani] The speakers are false, and the listeners are false; those who speak and recite are false. [gurbani]hir hir inq krih rsnw kihAw kCU n jwxI ][/gurbani] They may continually chant, 'Har, Har' with their tongues, but they do not know what they are saying. [gurbani]icqu ijn kw ihir lieAw mwieAw bolin pey rvwxI ][/gurbani] Their consciousness is lured by Maya; they are just reciting mechanically. [gurbani]khY nwnku siqgurU bwJhu hor kcI bwxI ]24][/gurbani] Says Nanak, without the True Guru, other songs are false. ||24|| [%sig%]

Re: kachee bani

khalistani · 06 Nov 2005

how the hell is tha wron it was guru harobind sahib who STARTED dhahdees they sang in guru jes darbar, y wud the same guru have a problem with it now wat the hell hapened to miri AND PIRI wat happened to sant SIPAHI i think people are confused on wat KACHEE banee is, or maybe i am haha in my opinion, kachee banee is anything without satguru je, somethin not to do with sikhi to people who think that only gurbanee shud be sang in darbar, thas the stupidest thing ive ever heard then wat boutkatha, which guru je started dhadee which guru je started most people ot problrm with dharna thas same thin like dhadee and katha mixed people these days are hypocrits everyones turnin into me :( bhula chuka maf

Re: kachee bani

BirRaas Singh · 06 Nov 2005

Someone needs to understand the context that the Guru wrote the shabad in. The shabad in question was uchaared when the the Prithi Chandiyas were writing "Gurbani" in the name of Guru Nanak to bring people to their Sangats. Kachi Bani is "Bani" which isnt really of the pen of the Guru, but it is made out to be. A Dhadhi Vaar isnt kachi bani because it isnt made out to be the words of the Guru.

Re: kachee bani

yo · 06 Nov 2005

akj_4eva_and_eva_amen, that bani you quoting clearly states that songs WITHOUT the true guru are false, but dhadi jathaas still sing about the true guru, so they are not false, you say its kuchi bani, but its not even bani, saying kuchi bani makes no sense because bani cant be kuchi, bani is gurus word, dhadi and dharna are NOT bani, they are GURU'S GEETS which involve the true guru so are not false

Re: kachee bani

Bundha · 07 Nov 2005

Singh, You say that how could the sangat remain seated, did you remain seated ? You went to the gurdwara to listen to kirtan, were these girls the only people on stage on the day? We should be proud that our youngsters felt inspired to pen a vaar about Khalistan or at least to sing about it. Kachi Bani is a composition that is trying to pass-off as Gurbani but is not. This to me sounds like a vaar and there is nothing wrong in that.

Re: kachee bani

uksingh · 07 Nov 2005

ban = language / words gur bani = gurus words kachee banee = words from source other then gurbani

Re: kachee bani

Prabhjoyt Singh · 11 Nov 2005

'Singh' are you from coventry?

Re: kachee bani

LionKing (LK) · 11 Nov 2005

ukSingh Would this include Bhai Gurdas Ji Diya Vaara. the Rehitnamey, Dhadhi Vaara (n)?

Re: kachee bani

?? · 11 Nov 2005

!

Re: kachee bani

. · 11 Nov 2005

no it isnt read the Gurbani extract above and you'll see what kachi bani is.

Re: kachee bani

agyani · 12 Nov 2005

Author: BirRaas Singh Date: 11-06-05 15:00 Someone needs to understand the context that the Guru wrote the shabad in. The shabad in question was uchaared when the the Prithi Chandiyas were writing "Gurbani" in the name of Guru Nanak to bring people to their Sangats. Kachi Bani is "Bani" which isnt really of the pen of the Guru, but it is made out to be. A Dhadhi Vaar isnt kachi bani because it isnt made out to be the words of the Guru. ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ VERY well said veer ji, i think you are one of the first people who ACTUALLY know what kachi bani REALLY means...well on the internet that is.

Re: kachee bani

LionKing (LK) · 12 Nov 2005

Was just questioning the the definition of "kachi Bani" by "Uksingh" veer ji :)

Re: kachee bani

singh · 13 Nov 2005

no im not but it was at cross rds and i cant believe ppl are supporting singing songs in darbar sahib GURbani should be done in a GURDwara the song definatly didnt get my nam going, actually it had a negative affect. i dont need to be told what kachee bani is, you can tell whats right and wrong by the effect it has on youre surtee

Re: kachee bani

reply to singh · 14 Nov 2005

Singh, talking about effect to surtee. no one disputes that Guru's Bani is best and we should read, understand and contemplate on it BUT ... you can not criticise what you call "kachi bani" firstly - some people are very inspired them - parchaar by dhaarna/dhadhi vaars has made them gursikhs - there many sikhs in UK that are still proper GurSikhs due to Parchaar done by Sant Isher Singh in UK, or back in the day by dhaarna of Sant Attar Singh - there jeevan completely changed - are those ppl fake sikhs cos they were inspired by kachi bani? secondly - dhadhi vaars/dhaarnas are not even bani. if your definition of kachi bani extends to anything that is not Gurbani, then what about katha, secretary announcements, bhai gurdas vaars, etc etc in gurdvaaras. BirRass Singh gave the true definition of Kachi Bani - It's where someone holds out their own words as the word of Guru. Only Bani came to Guru. Only that is the True Bani. Anyone else who says their work is Bani is mistaken - their work is Kachi Bani

Re: kachee bani

Jagjit Singh · 14 Nov 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, bani is from Sahib Siri Guru Granth Sahib ji, Sahib Siri Guru Gobind Singh ji Bani, Bhai Gurdas di varaan, and Bhai Nand lal jis rehitnamas. Dhadi vaars as part of Gurmat as started by Sahib Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib ji. They bring debate and discussion on history and Gurmat. My belief is that they are essential, otherwise there is a dangar that a Gursikh can become far too passive. Many people who listen to keertan, find it difficult to listen to dhadhis, because you do not get the same Rass. But it is wrong to criticize Dhadhis vaars. kacchee bani is a manipulation of Gurbani with an individuals thoughts to create new compositions. This is against Gurmat. By dropping names of Great gursikhs does not make it acceptable. Rather it would be better if Gursikhs are encouraged to do Parchaar like Sant Singh Maskeen, or Bhai Jasvir Singh Khannewale, whether Gurbani is explained to inspire the sangat. If everybody did it in this manner, then there would be no issues. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: kachee bani

vivek · 14 Nov 2005

kachee bani = falsa bani ban means words/language yes a song about khalistan is kachee bani, sorry to dissapoint you all ppl need to stop twisting things to fit their own mat ie, manmat dont bring preaching into the equation, theres numerous discussion in which it has been proven that preaching is gurmat. gurmukhs dont need to speak to inspire, they inspire by example, actions speak more then words.

Re: kachee bani

khalistani · 14 Nov 2005

anything to do wiith satguru je ands vaheguru je is sachee banee anything without satguru je is kachee banee vaheguru if a person there whole life goes dhan hai dhan hai guru naanak dev je dhan hai that person will become mukht even if tha saying doesnt fit in to the sachee banee category with some people bhula chuka maf

Re: kachee bani

vivek · 15 Nov 2005

"if a person there whole life goes dhan hai dhan hai guru naanak dev je dhan hai that person will become mukht" lol what absolute nonsense only continuos repetition of nam and gurbani will gain you mukhti - according to gurmat lets all make up songs about how great god and guru is..............we will be saved in the end actually theres one problem, gurbani says words cannot descrice the greatness of guru, anyone who tries will ultimatly repent only GURbani can describe greatness of true SATGURU any other words will just belittle satguru, this is paap. GURBANI is the ultimate and only way to praise satguru, because only gurbani is true everything else is false.

Re: kachee bani

khalistani · 17 Nov 2005

HAHAHAH ya riye ok if y say soeone saying dhan guru nanak dev e or dhan vaheguru willnot get mukht nice;) well ill try it ot il let u kno wat happens:) bhula chuka maf

Re: kachee bani

Manjot Kaur · 17 Nov 2005

Pure Bani is that written by the Gurus' hands. Tharnas/Kavita(Kaftha/Kavitha) is used to EXPLAIN bani and help to understand it. Kachi Bani- Trying to pass of something that you wrote as Pure Bani. There are some people that pretend to be the guru. They wrote their own version of the Guru Granth Sahib. That is an example of Kachi Bani. Bhul Chook Maff That might not be the right way to describe it but I tried my best.

Re: kachee bani

. · 17 Nov 2005

The Gurus never stopped people writing their own songs/shabads by your logic then Bhai Gurdas' vaars are false too. as far as you saying what the khalistani said is nonsense: 'Ek shabad mere praan vast hai, bahur janam na aava' singing with pure love to Guru Sahib will never belittle the Guru. 'Jin prem kio tin hee prach paio' Bhull Chhuk maaf

Re: kachee bani

uksingh · 18 Nov 2005

by your logic then Bhai Gurdas' vaars are false too. - no, bani descended on bhai gurdas from above "singing with pure love to Guru Sahib will never belittle the Guru" the only pure way of praise is gurbani

Re: kachee bani

uksingh · 18 Nov 2005

jae ho jaanaa aakhaa naahee kehanaa kathhan n jaaee || Even knowing God, I cannot describe Him; He cannot be described in words.

Re: kachee bani

uksingh · 18 Nov 2005

kudharath kavan kehaa veechaar || How can I describe Your Creative Power? vaariaa n jaavaa eaek vaar || I cannot even once be a sacrifice to You.

Re: kachee bani

uksingh · 18 Nov 2005

jae ko aakhai boluvigaarr || If anyone presumes to describe God, thaa likheeai sir gaavaaraa gaavaar ||26|| he shall be known as the greatest fool of fools!

Re: kachee bani

vivek · 18 Nov 2005

bhanath naamadhaeo eik naam nisathaarai || Naam Dayv prays, only the Naam, the Name of the Lord, can save us.

Re: kachee bani

. · 18 Nov 2005

so you imply that it cant desend on anyone else...

Re: kachee bani

uksingh · 19 Nov 2005

you imply that it descends on everyone

Re: kachee bani

vivek · 19 Nov 2005

thoo(n) akathh kio kathhiaa jaahi || You are Indescribable; how can I describe You? gur sabadh maaran man maahi samaahi || Those who subdue their minds, through the Word of the Guru's Shabad, are absorbed in You. thaerae gun anaek keemath neh paahi ||1|| Your Glorious Virtues are countless; their value cannot be estimated. ||1|| jis kee baanee this maahi samaanee || The Word of His Bani belongs to Him; in Him, it is diffused. thaeree akathh kathhaa gur sabadh vakhaanee ||1|| rehaao || Your Speech cannot be spoken; through the Word of the Guru's Shabad, it is chanted. ||1||Pause|| jeh sathigur theh sathasa(n)gath banaaee || Where the True Guru is - there is the Sat Sangat, the True Congregation. jeh sathigur sehajae har gun gaaee || Where the True Guru is - there, the Glorious Praises of the Lord are intuitively sung. jeh sathigur thehaa houmai sabadh jalaaee ||2|| Where the True Guru is - there egotism is burnt away, through the Word of the Shabad. ||2|| guramukh saevaa mehalee thhaao paaeae || The Gurmukhs serve Him; they obtain a place in the Mansion of His Presence. guramukh a(n)thar har naam vasaaeae || The Gurmukhs enshrine the Naam within the mind. guramukh bhagath har naam samaaeae ||3|| The Gurmukhs worship the Lord, and are absorbed in the Naam. ||3|| aapae dhaath karae dhaathaar || The Giver Himself gives His Gifts, poorae sathigur sio lagai piaar || as we enshrine love for the True Guru. naanak naam rathae thin ko jaikaar ||4||8||28|| Nanak celebrates those who are attuned to the Naam, the Name of the Lord.

Re: kachee bani

LionKing (LK) · 19 Nov 2005

Bani ta Kachi Stagur Bajho hor Kachi Bani. Bhai Gurdas Ji's Vaara were accepted by the Gurus, just like Bhai Nand Lal Ji's, and Dhadi Vaara....(although personally I would care more about what Bhai Gurdas Ji said than what a Dhadhi said, but thats a completly different topic) Khalistani if saying "Dhan Guru Nanak Dev jee" over and over will merge you one with Vaheguru, Akaal Purakh, Kartar, what was the point of - jaisee mai aavai khasam kee baanee thaisarraa karee giaan vae laalo || As the Word of the Forgiving Lord comes to me, so do I express it, O Lalo. or - dhhur kee baanee aaee || The Bani of His Word emanated from the Primal Lord. thin sagalee chi(n)th mittaaee || It eradicates all anxiety. They could have summarized everything in one verse- ********* This human body has been given to you. This is your chance to meet the Lord of the Universe. Nothing else will work. Join the Saadh Sangat, the Company of the Holy; vibrate and meditate on the Jewel of the Naam. ||1|| Make every effort to cross over this terrifying world-ocean. You are squandering this life uselessly in the love of Maya. ||1||Pause|| I have not practiced meditation, self-discipline, self-restraint or righteous living. I have not served the Holy; I have not acknowledged the Lord, my King. Says Nanak, my actions are contemptible! O Lord, I seek Your Sanctuary; please, preserve my honor! ||2||4|| http://www.sikhitothemax.com/Page.asp?SourceID=G&PageNo=&ShabadID=48&Format=2 ****** "Apey Japi jao jo japna je" - they could have said - they didn't They could have simply left it there. They decided to write 5894 in 31 Raags, If simply repeating the man-made mantar, what was the point of Kartar, Akal Puarakh to send us such a treasure of diamonds, if simply something home-made is going to enable us to merge with Kartar? [gurbani]gur ibnu Goru AMDwru gurU ibnu smJ n AwvY ] gur ibnu suriq n isiD gurU ibnu mukiq n pwvY ] guru kru scu bIcwru gurU kru ry mn myry ] guru kru sbd spuMn AGn ktih sB qyry ] guru nXix bXix guru guru krhu gurU siq kiv nl´ kih ] ijin gurU n dyiKAau nhu kIAau qy AkXQ sMswr mih ]4]8] [/gurbani] Without the Guru, there is utter darkness; without the Guru, understanding does not come. Without the Guru, there is no intuitive awareness or success; without the Guru, there is no liberation. So make Him your Guru, and contemplate the Truth; make Him your Guru, O my mind. Make Him your Guru, who is embellished and exalted in the Word of the Shabad; all your sins shall be washed away. So speaks NALL the poet: with your eyes, make Him your Guru; with the words you speak, make Him your Guru, your True Guru. Those who have not seen the Guru, who have not made Him their Guru, are useless in this world. ||4||8|| [gurbani]mhlw 2 ] jy sau cMdw augvih sUrj cVih hjwr ] eyqy cwnx hoidAW gur ibnu Gor AMDwr ]2][/gurbani] Second Mehl: If a hundred moons were to rise, and a thousand suns appeared, even with such light, there would still be pitch darkness without the Guru. ||2||